USF Libraries
USF Digital Collections

Kalamata earthquake, 1986

MISSING IMAGE

Material Information

Title:
Kalamata earthquake, 1986 psychological reactions and roles for health care workers
Series Title:
Quick response research report ;
Physical Description:
8 leaves : ; 28 cm.
Language:
English
Creator:
Laube, Jerri
University of Colorado, Boulder -- Natural Hazards Research and Applications Information Center
University of Colorado, Boulder -- Institute of Behavioral Science
Publisher:
Natural Hazards Research and Applications Information Center, University of Colorado
Place of Publication:
Boulder, Colo
Publication Date:

Subjects

Subjects / Keywords:
Earthquakes -- Psychological aspects -- Greece -- Kalamai   ( lcsh )
Health care teams -- Mental health -- Greece -- Kalamai   ( lcsh )
Disaster victims -- Mental health -- Greece -- Kalamai   ( lcsh )
Genre:
government publication (state, provincial, terriorial, dependent)   ( marcgt )
bibliography   ( marcgt )
non-fiction   ( marcgt )

Notes

Bibliography:
Includes bibliographical references (p. 8).
Additional Physical Form:
Also issued online as part of a joint project with the Louis de la Parte Florida Mental Health Institute (FMHI) Research Library's disaster mental health initiative.
Statement of Responsibility:
Jerri Laube.
General Note:
Cover title.
General Note:
"Institute of Behavioral Science #6."

Record Information

Source Institution:
University of South Florida Library
Holding Location:
University of South Florida
Rights Management:
All applicable rights reserved by the source institution and holding location.
Resource Identifier:
aleph - 001985199
oclc - 39083664
usfldc doi - F57-00039
usfldc handle - f57.39
System ID:
SFS0001120:00001


This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text
xml version 1.0 encoding UTF-8 standalone no
record xmlns http:www.loc.govMARC21slim xmlns:xsi http:www.w3.org2001XMLSchema-instance xsi:schemaLocation http:www.loc.govstandardsmarcxmlschemaMARC21slim.xsd
leader cam 2200289Ia 4500
controlfield tag 001 001985199
005 20090312110147.0
008 980507s1987 cou b s000 0 eng d
datafield ind1 8 ind2 024
subfield code a F57-00039
035
(OCoLC)39083664
040
DDB
c DDB
d OCLCQ
043
e-gr---
086
UCB6/57.15/11
2 codocs
1 100
Laube, Jerri.
0 245
Kalamata earthquake, 1986 :
b psychological reactions and roles for health care workers /
Jerri Laube.
260
Boulder, Colo. :
Natural Hazards Research and Applications Information Center, University of Colorado,
1987.
300
[8] leaves ;
28 cm.
440
Quick response research report ;
v #11
500
Cover title.
"Institute of Behavioral Science #6."
504
Includes bibliographical references (p. [8]).
530
Also issued online as part of a joint project with the Louis de la Parte Florida Mental Health Institute (FMHI) Research Library's disaster mental health initiative.
650
Earthquakes
z Greece
Kalamai
x Psychological aspects.
Health care teams
Mental health
Greece
Kalamai.
Disaster victims
Mental health
Greece
Kalamai.
710
University of Colorado, Boulder.
Natural Hazards Research and Applications Information Center.
University of Colorado, Boulder.
Institute of Behavioral Science
773
t Natural Hazards Center Collection
TKR
ARL-FMHI
049
FHIM
994
C0
FHI
4 856
u http://digital.lib.usf.edu/?f57.39



PAGE 1

HAZARDHOUSECOpy ..." X.. J ..../....1'18': I attJ.,....lie. If I.G.;.

PAGE 2

NaturalHazardsResearchandApplicationsInformationCenter.CampusBox482UniversityofColoradoBoulder,Colorado80309-0482KALAMATAEARTHQUAKE,1986:PSYCHOLOGICALREACTIONSANDROLESFORHEALTHCAREWORKERSJerriLaube1987QuickResponseResearch Report#11This pUblication is partofthe Natural Haz d &Applications Information Centa:r'ss ongoing h. esponse Research Report Seriesttp.llwww.colorado. edu/hazards .InstituteofBehavioralScience #6 (303)492-6818

PAGE 3

KALAMATAEARTHQUAKE1986:PSYCHOLOGICAL REACTIONSANDALOOKATHEALTHCAREWORKERSJerriLaube,Ph.D.Purposes1.Toidentifythepsychologicaleffectofdisasteronhealthcareworkers2.Todeterminethesubjectiveimpactondisastervictims,onemonthaftertheevent3.Toconductacross-culturalcomparisonbetweendisastervictimsinGreeceanddisastervictimsinU.S.A.4.TocomparetheresponsesofhealthcaredisasterworkersinGreecewithresponsesofhealthcaredisasterworkersinU.S.A.EventKalamata,Greece(population50,000)andthesurroundingareawasstruckbyanearthquake,measuring6.2ontheRichterScale,at20:00Saturday,13September1986.Asecondearthquake,measuring5.6ontheRichterScaleoccurredat14:30onMonday15September1986.Twenty-fourdeathswerecontributeddirectlytothedisaster.Seventytoninetypercent(reportsvaried)ofthebuildingsweredamagedordestroyed.Aneighboringvillage,Eleohore,wascompletelydestroyed.Followingtheearthquake,thebuildingswereinspectedforseverityofdamage.Thedamagedbuildingswere marRed withredorgreenpaint.Theredpaintindicatedthatthebuildingwasunsafeanddamagedbeyondrepair.Greenpaintindicatedthebuildingcouldberepaired.Familieswhosehomeshadeitheraredoragreenmarkwereprohibitedbythegovernmentfromusingthesepropertiesandhadtoberelocated.Twelvethousandtents,providedbytheRedCrossandtheArmy,shelteredthemajorityofthevictims.Ninehundredpeoplewerehousedonaprivatecruiseship,theMarianna"9",dockedinKalamata.TwohundredfiftypeoplelivedonaNavaltrainingbattleship,theAris.Theremainingvictims,providedtheirowntemporaryhousing,orfoundshelterinthesurroundingvillages.RedCrossunits,fromGermany,Yugoslavia,andSweden,sentlargetentstobeusedforschoolclasssrooms.AlatershipmentfromSwedenof30metalstoragetypebuildings,wastobeusedwheredeemedmostnecessary--suchastheRedCrossHeadquarters'officesandclinics.TheGermanRedCrossunitprovidedagenerator,largerefrigerator,andworkers.Theycookedand served 4,000meals,two

PAGE 4

KalamataEarthquaketimesaday,forthedisastervictims.ThestaffontheArisandMarianna"9"provldedmealsandlinenforthevictimstheyhoused.SubjectsInterviewswereconductedwith87individualswhowerevictimsoftheearthquake.Ofthattotal,10werephysicians,8wereregisterednursesandtheremaining69werestudentnurses.TheImpactofEventScalewasadministeredto83subjects,somefromthehealth-careprovidergroupandothersfromthegeneraldisaster-struckpopulation.InstrumentHorowitz's(Horowitz,WilnerandAlvarez,1979)ImpactofEventScale(IES)wasusedtoassessthevictim'sresponsetotheearthquake.Itisascaleof15currentsubjectivedistressitems,relatedtoaspecificevent.Thescaleisdividedinto2 subscales: intrusion(signsofcognitiveandaffectiveintrusion)andavoidance(blockingorsuppressionofthoughtsandimages).TheIEShasbeenfoundvaluableincollectinglongitudinaldataasitcanbetiedtothesamestressorovertheentirespanofdatacollection.Itisself-administered,short,andeasilyunderstoodandacceptedbypeopleofvariouscultures,educationalandeconomicbackground. Thescoresaredeterminedbyassigningavalueof0,1,3,and5tothefrequencycategoriesforeachitemandthensummingthevaluesforthespecificsubscalesandscaletotal.Reliabilites(Chronbach'salpha)fortheintrusiansubscalewere0.79and,fortheavoidancesubscale,0.82.Test-retestreliabilitywasreportedat0.87forthetotalstressscores,0.89fortheintrusionsubscale,and 0./9 fortheavoidancesubscale.AsthetoolhadtobetranslatedintoGreek,foradministrationintheearthquakearea,itwasimportanttodetermineiftheinternalconsistencywasmaintainedinthesubscales.Thereliabilitycoefficient(Cronbach'salpha)was0.72fortheintrusiansubscaleand0.65fortheavoidancesubscale.Theinternalconsistencyoftheintrusiansubscaleremainedhigh,buttheadvoidancysubscalehaddippedwiththetranslationalthoughnottoolowforuse.InadditiontotheIES,the"healthcareproviderswereinterviewed,withtheassistanceofaninterpretor,todeterminetheirresponsestothestressesofdisasterwork.Astructuredquestionnaireof10items,modifiedfromLaube's(1973),wasused.Duetothelanguagedifficulties,noattemptwasmadetogathertheusualdemographicdata.Theinterviewsweretapedandtranscribed.MethodEntryintothedisasterareawasfacilitatedthroughtheAmericanRedCross,theHellenicRedCross,andtheGovernorofMessiniinGreece.TheHeadoftheHellenicRedCrossdisasterservicesin

PAGE 5

Kalamata Barthquake Kalamatacoordinatedtheinvestigator'sactivitiesinKalamata.ThelanguagedifferencespresentedsomedifficultiesastheinvestigatorcouldspeaknoGreekandalimitednumberof the sUbjectscouldspeakEnglish,namelythephysicians,shopkeepersandsomeofficialsandRedCrossstaff.AUniversityofAustraliastudent,onemergencyleavetobewithhisfamily,servedasan interpreterinmanyofthesessions.Otherwise,communicationtookplacethroughuseofaBerlitzmanual,pre-translatedstatementsandinstructions,andalotofnon-verballanguage.Althoughindividualinterviewswerepreferred,thesUbjectswereinterviewedingroupsbecauseoflimitedaccesstoaninterpreter.Anonymitywasassuredasnonameswererecorded.Onlyageandgenderwererequestedonthepencilandpapertest.Participationintheinterviewsandtestingwasonavoluntarybasis.Alloftheintervieweesdidnottakethetest.Conversely,someofthosethattookthetestwerenotinterviewed.Theinterviewsandtestingtookplaceoverathreeweekspan,beginningfourweeksafterthefirstearthquakeon13Septenber1986.ToincreasethenumberofsubjectsfortheImpactofEventScale,assistancewassecuredfromapsychologist,whowasvolunteeringherserviceinthedisaster,andtheSocialDirectorofthecruiseshipthatwasservingastemporarylivingquartersforthehomeless.Thesetwoindividualsadministeredtheteststotheir"clients"whovolunteeredtoparticipate.Tosecurenormativedata,similiartothatofthemedicalstudentpopulationusedbyHorowitzetal(1979),assistancewassecuredfromthedirectorof'alargeschoolofnursinginAthens,Greece.SheadministeredtheIESto63nursingstudents.Studentsweredirectedonlytorelatetheitemstoasignificanteventintherecentpast.SubjectiveeffectonvictimsasmeasuredbyImpactofEventScaleTherewere9malesinthesamplepopulationof 83: thustherewasnoanalysisforgenderdifferences.Theagerangeforthegroupwas15-60years,themeanwas25.71yearsandthemedianwas20years.Therangefortheintrusiansubscalewas2-41,themeanwas27.26,themedianwas28andthestandarddeviationwas7.52.Therangefortheavoidancesubscalewas5-35,themeanwas21.07,themedianwas21,andthestandarddeviationwas7.67.Therewere8malesinthestudentnursegroupof 63: noanalysiswasneededforgenderdifferences.Theagerangeforthisgroupwas20-51years,themeanwas31yearsandthemedianagewas30years.Therangefortheintrusiansubscalewas0-35,themeanwas12.32,themedianwas12andthestandarddeviationwas8.58.Therangefortheavoidancesubscalewas0-35,themeanwas12.06,themedianwas11,andthestandarddeviationwas8.64.AscanbeseeninTable1,theGreekdisastervictimsscoredhigheronthesubscalesthandidtheAmericanpatientpopulationusedby

PAGE 6

KalamataEarthquakeHorowitz(1979,P215),butthisdifferenceistruealsobetweentheGreekandAmericannon-victimpopulations.TABLE1.MeansandStandardDeviationsOfImpactof EventSubscalesforDisasterVictimsandNursingStudentsinGreeceandPatientsandMedicalStudentsinU.S.A.*PopulationsIntrusianAvoidanceGreeceDisasterVictimsNursingStudentsU.S.A.PatientsMedicalStudentsMen WomenMean27.2712.3221.202.506.10SD7.538.587.903.005.30Mean21.0712.0620.806.9012.70SD7.678.6410.26.8010.80*StatisticstakenfromHorowitz,WilnerandAlvarez,(1979)ImpactofEventScale:Ameasureofsubjectivestress,PsychomaticMedicine4(3),216.UsingthePearsonProduct-Momenttest,correlationsbtweenthesubscalesweredeterminedforthedisastervictimsandforthestudentnurses.Thecorrelationcoefficientwas0.63(p=<.006)forthestudentnursesanditwas0.21(p=<.10)forthedisastervictims.ThisparallelsthefindingsofZilberg,WeissandHorowitz(1982).IntheirstudyonU.S.A.subjects,thesubscalesweresubstantiallycorrelatedintheirfieldsubjectsbuttherewaslittlecorrelationbetweenthesubscalesintheirpatientgroup.Notonlydoesthisindicateacross-culturalpatterning,italsosubstantiatesHorowitz's(1976)theorythatthereisapredictablepatternofresponsefollowingaseverestressevent.Hepostulatedthatintrusivesymptomatologyfollowstheevent,butasthisissopainful,avoidancebehaviorthenoccursasameasureofdefense.ThissuggeststhatcorrelationsontheIESsubscalescouldserveasadiagnostictoolfordetermingthepatient's/victim'spathologyandphaseofrecovery.ComparisonofthetwoculturesispresentedinTable2.Thesignificanceofdifferenceinthesubscalesbetweenthe2groupsinGreeceweredeterminedthroughuseofthet-test.Thefindingsweresignificantforboth,intrusianandadvoidance.(SeeTable3)

PAGE 7

KalamataEarthquakeTable2.PearsonProduct-MomentCorrelationsbetweenIntrusianandAvoidanceSubscalesforPatientsandFieldSubjectsinU.S.A.andbetweenSubscalesforDisasterVictimsandNursingStudentsinGreece* SubjectsGreeceDisasterVictimsNursingStudentsU.S.A.PatientsFieldSUbjectsN836335 37r.21.63.15.70p<.10<.006<.40<.01*U.S.A.statisticsfromZilberg,WeissandHorowitz.(1982)ImpactofEventScale:Across-validationstudyandsomeempiricalevidencesupportingaconceptualmodelofstressresponsesyndromes,JournalofConsultingandClinicalPsychology,50(3),412.Table3.Means,StandardDeviationsandt-testsontheImpactofEventSubscalesforDisasterVictimsandNursingStudentsinGreeceVictimsStudents(N=83 ) (N=63 )SubscalesMM tdfIntrusian27.2712.3211.19144<.006Avoidance21.0712.066.65144<.006HealthCareWorkersReactionsinDisasterSpecificnumberscouldnotbeobtainedduetothelargesizeofthegroupbeinginterviewed,insomeinstances,andthelimitedtimeforworkingwithaninterpreter.Theresultsbelowareasdescribedbythosethatresponded.Themajorityofregisterednursesandphysiciansworked48to60hourswithoutrelief.Asdescribedbyone,wecamebackassoonaswecouldgethereanddidn'tleaveunti11thepatientsweresett1ed--throughdischargeortransfer.Thelongestperiodofworkforthestudentswas10hours.Themajorstressesreported

PAGE 8

KalamataEarthquakeweretheirconcernfortheirfamilies,theaged--"thesadnessontheolderpeople'sfaces"andthechildren--"seeingthechildrenhurtandcrying".Somrtalkedofthecrowded,uncomfortablelivingconditions--tents,noprivacy,nolaundryorbathingfaciliities.Specifictothecareoftheinjuredandthenecessaryevacuationofthehospital,theirmajorconcernsweredisorganization,suppliesandlackofinformation.Table4comparesthemajorstressesof the twocultures.Table 4G MajorStressesofHealthCareWorkersinDisaster:GreeceandU.S.A.ReportedStressesExcessivephysicaldemandsConcernforown/patients'safety IncreasedmedicalresponsibilityConcernforfamilySeeingthepoorsufferInjured/scaredchildrenInjuredolderpersonsSadnessontheolderpeople'sfacesDisorganizationSeeingsomanyinjuredandkilledFeelingsofinadquacytomeetpsychologicalneedsThelivingconditionsLackofinformationKnowingthatlifewillneverbethesameGreecexx.XX X X X X X XXU.S.A.xx xX X X X X X XWhenaskedhowtheymanagedtheirfeelings,manyrepliedthattheydidn'trememberfeelinganything--theyjustworked.Asdescribedbyoneperson,hegot"caughtupintherush"anddidn'tseemtofeelanything.Onlyafewadmittedtocryingasameasureof

PAGE 9

KalamataEarthquaketensionreduction.Onereportedthatshepanicked,feltasifshewere"goingtopieces,veryuncharacteristicfl.Others-reportedhavingsomaticsymptomsofdiarrhea,nauseaandvomiting,butnottooseveretowork.TheresponsesfromthehealthcareworkersinGreecewerenotunlikethosereportedbyLaube(1972)undersimilarconditionsinAmerica. Tothequestionrelatingtothefunniesthappeningduringthedisaster,theimmediateresponsewas"Nothing."Later,onetoldthestoryaboutherunclegettingcaughtunderatable,becausehewastoofat.Notbeingabletogetloose,hejustranoutwiththetablestuckonhisback.Therewereafewsmileswhenthestorywastold, noonelaughed.Truly,evenfourweeksaftertheearthquake,thedevastationwastoogreat.ConclusionsTheearthquakevictimsinKalamata,GreeceexperiencedgreatsUbjectivedistress.Onemonthpostdisaster,bothintrusiveandavoidancesymptomatology,asmeasuredbytheIES,wassignificantlygreaterthannormal.Cross-culturally,intrusivesymptomatologyintheearthquakevictimswasatahigherlevelthanHorowitzetal(1979)reportedforanidentifiedstressedpatientpopulationinAmerica.Theavoidancesymptomatologylevelwassimilarinthetwopopulations.HealthcareworkersinGreeceidentifiedsimilarstressesindisasterashavethoseinAmerica.Inbothpopulations,concernfortheelderly,thechildren,andtheirownfamilywereparamount.Theheavyphysicaldemandsanddisorganizationwerealsoreportedinbothgroups.Emotionalresponsesweresimilarinbothculturalgroups.Therewas,however,onemajordifferenceinhealthcaredeliveryfollowingthe disaster. InGreece,manyofthestaffphysiciansandnursesfromthedisasterareawererelievedbyprofessionalsfromoutsidethearea,somefromasfarawayasAthens(6to7hoursbycar).ThisallowedthosefromKalamatatimetogettheirlivingaccomodationsarranged,takecareoftheirfamiliesandthemselves,asneeded.Underthesocialisttypeofmedicalcare,transferofstaffbetweenhospitalscouldbearranged.ThiscouldnotbeaseasilyimplementedintheprivatesectoroftheU.S.A.

PAGE 10

KalamataEarthquakeREFERENCESHorowitz,M.J.(1976).StressResponseSyndromes.NewYork:Wiley.Horowitz,M.J.,Wilner,N.,&Alvarez,W.(1979).Impactofeventscale:Ameasureofsubjectivestress.PsychomaticMedicine.41,209-218.Laube,J.(1973).Psychologicalreactionsofnursesindisaster.Nursing Researche22 (4),343-347.Zilberg,N.J.,Weiss,D.s.&Horowitz,M.J.(1982).Impactofeventscale:Across-validationstudyandsomeempiricalevidencesupportingaconceptualmodelofstressresponsesyndromes.JournalofConsultingandClinicalPsychology.50,(3),407-417.