USF Libraries
USF Digital Collections

SFRA review


Material Information

SFRA review
Alternate Title:
Science Fiction Research Association review
Physical Description:
Science Fiction Research Association
Science Fiction Research Association
Place of Publication:
Eugene, Ore
Publication Date:


Subjects / Keywords:
Science fiction -- History and criticism -- Periodicals   ( lcsh )
Fantasy fiction -- History and criticism -- Periodicals   ( lcsh )
Science fiction -- Book reviews -- Periodicals   ( lcsh )
Fantasy fiction -- Book reviews -- Periodicals   ( lcsh )
non-fiction   ( marcgt )
serial   ( sobekcm )


General Note:
Place of publication varies.

Record Information

Source Institution:
University of South Florida Library
Holding Location:
University of South Florida
Rights Management:
All applicable rights reserved by the source institution and holding location.
Resource Identifier:
usfldc doi - S67-00017-n252-2001-05_06
usfldc handle - s67.17
System ID:

This item is only available as the following downloads:

Full Text
xml version 1.0 encoding UTF-8 standalone no
mods:mods xmlns:mods http:www.loc.govmodsv3 xmlns:xsi http:www.w3.org2001XMLSchema-instance xsi:schemaLocation http:www.loc.govmodsv3mods-3-1.xsd
mods:relatedItem type host
mods:identifier issn 1068-395Xmods:part
mods:detail issue mods:number 252series Year mods:caption 20012001Month June6Day 11mods:originInfo mods:dateIssued iso8601 2001-06-01


#2S2 Ifay/June 200' Coeditors: Barbara Lucas Shelley Rodrjgo Blanctiard Nonfiction lerie lIeil Barron Fiction Ie riews: Shelley Rodrjgo Blancliard The SFRAReview (ISSN 1068-395X) is published six times a year by the Science Fiction ResearchAssociation (SFRA) and to SFRA mem bers.lndividual issues are not for sale. For information about the SFRA and its benefits, see the description at the back of this issue. For a membership application, contact SFRA Treasurer Dave Mead or get one from the SFRA website: . SUBMISSIONS The SFRAReview editors encourage submissions, including essays, review essays that cover several related texts, and interviews. Please send submis sions or queries to both coeditors. If you would like to review nonfiction or fiction, please contact the respective editor and/or email Barbara Lucas, Coeditor 1352 Fox Run Drive, Suite 206 Willoughby, OH 44094 Shelley Rodrigo Blanchard, Coeditor & Fiction Reviews Editor 6842 S. 40th Place Phoenix, AZ 85040 Neil Barron, Nonfiction Reviews Editor 1149 Lime Place Vista, CA 92083-7428 Visit Us At:


HELP WITH RECRUITMENT NEEDED The SFRA's membership has hov ered around 300 for some years. Peter Brig, the new vice president, intends to increase the number of members by various means. One strategy is sending recruiting ma terials to people likely to be inter ested, most of whom have never been contacted by the SFRA. That's where you could be ex tremely helpful. What he would welcome from you is the book title, year of publication, and name and academic or other affiliation of au thors, editors, and contributors to books about any type of fantastic literature/film/illustration or utopian studies that you have reviewed since January 1998. Check past issues of the SFRA Review to iden tify titles. Send information to or to # I 20 Budgell Terrace, Toronto, Ontario M65 I B4. Most edited collections of essays include contributor notes, which normally show academic af filiation. A photocopy of such notes would suffice, along with the book's title and year, or you can copy and e-mail the information. It you see a name that you know to be a cur rent member, delete it, but Peter will check this and gather the needed additional information for letter mailing recruitment material. Many thanks. Neil Barron CORRECTION Karen McGuire's review of Berthold Schoene-Harwood's Mary Shelley: Frankentstein was indeed in issue #25 IThe table of contents did not reflect this. The review is on page 15. Shelley Rodrigo Blanchard LATEST HEINLEIN JOURNAL The January 200 I semi-annual is sue (# 8) reached me in mid-Feb ruary. Jane Davitt examNONFICTION REVIEW "HE A OFAFE. SUPER.ArUBA .. HORROR L.FEBAFURE Stefan Dziemianowia Lovecraft, H.P. The Annotated Supernatural Horror in Uterature, ed. by S.T. Joshi. Hippocampus Press, Box 641, New York, NY 10156, September 2000. 172 p. $15 + $3.50 postage, trade paper. 0-9673215-0-6. Lovecraft's canonical essay remains a landmark of weird fiction criticism nearly three quarters of a century since it first saw print in the pages of an amateur press journal. Though not every critic has agreed with its assessments and Lovecraft has been taken to task for omissions and imbalance in his analysis, the essay has shaped reading lists and bibliographies of essential horror fiction for decades. Lovecraft was one of the first critical writers to view horror in a context not limited solely to the Gothic tradition, and his essay contains some of the earliest appraisals of Blackwood, Machen, de la Mare, and other writers who set a standard of literary excellence even as horror was curdling into a genre in the pages of the pulp magazines Lovecraft contributed to. Before the appearance of this new edition of the essay-the first offer ing from a new specialty press-there were already two editions long in print: the Dover paperback struck from the Abramson edition of 1945 (106 p., $6.95, intro duced by E.F. Bleiler) and the version included in Dagon and Other Macabre Tales, the third volume in Arkham House's standard edition of Lovecraft, which Lovecraft authority Joshi indexed for the current corrected eighth printing of 1986. What does this new edition offer that these editions don't? For one thing, a comprehensive bibliography of all the texts cited by Lovecraft, including cita tions for further critical study. But even better are Joshi's annotations and his informative introduction on the history of the essay's composition. (Lovecraft's essay occupies fifty-two pages of fairly small type in this edition. Joshi"s contri butions dwarf that: preface and introduction (13 pages), notes (36 pages), bibli ography of authors and works cited by Lovecraft (52 pages), and index (10 pages. Though Lovecraft is generally revered as one of the horror writers of the twentieth century most knowledgeable about the field in which he wrote, at the time he was assigned the essay, he was actually unfamiliar with several writers and works now regarded as seminal to horror literature. As Joshi notes, Lovecraft had read the Gothics piecemeal and cribbed extensively from Edith Birkhead's The Tale of Terror (1921) for his commen tary in the early sections of the survey. An omnivorous reader in a variety of areas, Lovecraft still completely overlooked the fiction of trend-setting ghost story master 1\1. R. J amee until he began researching the essay. The essay went through several revisions between its fust publication in 1927 and Lovecraft's death in 1937, and he took his work on it seriously enough to continue adding writers whose work he picked up on the interim. He pro fessed his admiration for the fiction of William Hope Hodgson in paragraphs added in 1934, and it's arguable that they helped spark the revival of interest in Hodgson's work. Even more interesting are the correspondences Joshi finds between the works Lovecraft read to write the essay and Lovecraft's own fiction. It was in this essay that Lovecraft first began to identify what he called "a sense of the cosmic" in the work of weird fiction writers he respected. Joshi defines cosmicism as "the suggestions of vast gulfs of space and time and the consequent triviality of the human race," and it's hardly surprising that Lovecraft's fiction began increasingly to show this quality after the essay was written, in stories like "The Call ofCthulhu," "The Dtu1\vich Horror," "The Shadow Out of Time" and most of the other tales of "cosmic horror" on which his reputation rests today. Joshi has read the same texts Lovecraft read in preparation to write the essay, and he identifies interest-


ing echoes in Lovecraft's writings of both well-known and obscure works. In Lovecraft's case, this was more than simple mimicry. His research of the essay almost certainly helped him to articulate his own aesthetic for supernatu ral horror, and one suspects his immersion in the work of other writers who made their mark showed him not just what to do, but what not to do, as he created his own body of memorable and weird fiction. [Admirers of Love craft sometimes quote the first sentence of this essay as a dogma: "The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown." This statement has been investigated by psychologists, so I asked Alan Elms, who teaches psychol ogy at UC Davis, what his colleagues have concluded. He replied: As for the 'oldest and strongest emotion of mankind,' Freud voted for pleasure (''Lust'' in German, which can also be translated as "desire''). He saw fear as important too, with fear of castration being most important to mankind (for womankind, of course, it has already happened). Even fear of death, Freud said, is a disguised version of castration anxiety. Karen Horney, Freud's ftrst feminist disciple and critic, more nearly resembled Lovecraft in proposing that the earliest (and for most people the most powerful) element in personality development is basic anxiety-the child's fear of being helpless and alone in a dangerous world. Psychologists have long conducted empirical studies to demonstrate either the presence of certain specific innate fear responses (fear of falling, etc.) or the early learning of fear responses Oohn E. Watson's "Little Albert" study is the most famous of these.) But developmental psychologists today, I think, would generally agree that such positive emotional reactions as pleasure at seeing a familiar face are demonstrably as "old and strong" as fear. Back to Freud. -Neil Barron] NONFICTION REVIEW 0 .. 'l'HE FR'NGE FOR 'rH'R'I'Y YEARS: A H'S'I'ORY OF HORROR .. 'l'HE BR'F'SH SNALL PRESS Dziemianowicz Sutton, David. On the Fringe for Thirty Years: A History of Horror in the British Small Pms. Shadow Publishing, 194 Station Road, Kings Heath, Bir mingham, England B14 7TE, October 2000. 39 p., stapled. /$15 (air mailed), payable to author. 0-9539032-0-6. Devotees of horror know that the current dominance of the field by the small press is the culmination of several decades of incessant specialty publishing activity. Although the British small press has been as industrious as its American counterpart, most readers on this side of the pond are probably familiar with only a handful of representative publishers and publications before the mid-1980's, when horror's fan subculture became solidly entrenched. David Sutton is eminently qualified to give readers the big picture on the UK's small press. He edited Shadow, the ftrst British small press 'zine of note devoted exclusively to the appreciation of horror fiction, and later teamed with Stephen Jones to edit the award-winning FantaD' Tales. He currently co-edits the Dark Terrors continuation of the Pan Book of Horror Stories series, and his career arc mirrors the evolutionary path followed by the horror small press in general. Though this chapbook substantially beefs up the pithy history of the small press, Sutton ftrst wrote for the American small press magazine The S mam Factory in 1996; it is not quite the album of intimate snapshots one might have wished for. Rather, it's more a large group picture, which means some detail has been sacrificed for the sake of inclusiveness. A. publisher as well as an editor, Sutton spends as much (if not more) time talking about the physical design and composition of the scores of magazines he mentions as he does their content or literary objective. Unleavened by the sort of anecdotes and personality profiles ines the differences be tween Heinlein's Red Planet in the 1949 Scribner's edition and the revised 1990 Ballantine edition. Edi tor Patterson studies"Requim," first published in 1940. Robert James investigates "The Age of Reasoning: Starship Troopers and the History of the Franchise in America." The text of a radio play based on Ray Bradbury's'The ManWhoTraveled in Elephants," by Brad Linaweaver, presented at the 1998 Dragon Con, is printed, along with an introduc tion by the producer and brief com ments by Bradbury. Letters and a cumulative index to issue I Uuly 1997) -8 conclude this 52-page, 8Y2 x II inch issue. $7.50/issue, $15/year ($10/$20 outside the US) to Bill Patterson,602West Bennett Avenue, Glendora, CA 91741, que ries to Neil Barron SHOULD YOU JOIN THE POD PEOPLE? POD in this context means "Print on Demand," a rapidly evolving publishing technology that has be come widespread in the past few years. The texts of the books are stored electronically, with copies generated by laser and/or ink jet printers, with paper covers glued to the pages in a standard perfect binding format. Hardcover bind ings are possible, of course, but used mostly for the library market, which has a buckram syndrome--"real books are hardcover only. For short print runs, from a few dozen to a few hundred copies, POD unit costs are less than conventional printing-one hundred copies might cost $150 for setup, plus $500 for the books, or $6.50 each, with a retail of two to three times that. In the fantastic fiction field, the book summary for calendar 2000 in the February 200 I Locus says that they saw 87 POD trade paperbacks, mostly reprints, but admitted that there were many


more they didn't see. Wildside Press in New Jersey has done the most by far, mosdy undistinguished fantastic fiction. In theory, POD would be ideal if a hundred teachers of fantastic literature could agree on out-of-print books they'd like to see in print. Assuming they could negotiate rights relatively cheaply, they'd (col lectively?) negotiate a contract with a POD printer to supply each in structor, say, twenty-five copies of x titles, billed at cost. The instructors would resell the books as course texts for a few more bucks than copy, enough to recover their out-of-pocket costs. The students would pay less, in most cases, than for standard in-print trade paper backs, and the instructor wouldn't be faced with the infuriating and common situation of all books hel she wanted to teach being out of print. For additional details, see the article by Roger McBrideAllen,"D Books [his term for POD books] for theWorkingWriter" in the April 200 I Science Fiction Chronicle ($4.95, probably plus postage, from DNA Publications, Box 2988, Radford,VA 24143-2988; yearly subscriptions are $45 for US, more elsewhere; Neil Barron UMGAWA In apish, that's "Listen up!" Bruce Watson has an enjoyable article in the March 200 I Smithsonian Magazine, ''Tarzan the Eternal:' The essay is not limited to Tarzan books but is a balanced account of Burroughs generally. Most of the black-and-white photos from the Tarzan films come from the huge Edgar Rice Burroughs' collection at the University of Louisville library. He says some dictionaries now list Tarzan as "a strong. agile person of heroic proportions and bearing." Can Xena or Sheena be far behind? Neil Barron GETTING IT PUBthat enliven the histories of SF fandom, like Sam Moskwitz's The Immortal Storm or Harry Warner's All Our Yesterdqys, Sutton's chronicle reads in spots like an annotated bibliography, albeit in accessible narrative form. The British and American horror small presses were very similar, but the 1960's American magazines were orien ted toward pre-World War II films (nota bly Ackerman's Famous Monsters of Fi/m/and), while British fan writers focused on the infamous Hammer horror films showing at their local cinemas. Sutton's Shadow, with its informed and intelligent appraisals of classic, pulp, and contem porary horror fiction, led in the change of emphasis from film to fiction and provided one of the few outlets for non-film horror criticism. He describes his magazine here and in more detail in a recommended companion, Voices from Shadow (1994,64 p., .50/$15 postpaid). The small press shifted again in the 1980's from writing about to publishing fiction, and in the '90's from publishing fiction in magazines to bringing it our in hardcover and trade paperback books. Sutton gives considerable credit to the British Fantasy Society, founded in 1970, as the glue that gave cohesion to the whole British small press scene, and his reminiscences make a fine companion piece to Silver Rhapsocfy (1996), the anec dotal history of the BFS. He profiles all the prominent magazines and their offshoot specialty book publishers as well as scads of obscure magazines we might never have known about. Most interesting is the abandon with which he names names: Clive Barker, Kim Newman, Brian Lumley, Steve Jones, Ramsey Campbell, Mike Ashley, and Richard Dalby, to name but a few, all of whom were (and to some degree are) regular contributors to small press publications, and account in no small part for the British small press's superior quality. Sutton's short but detailed account makes the British horror small press seem live one big house party where attendees flit from room to room, sustaining festivities that are still going on. NONFICTION REVIEW ".CFOR.AH GOFH.C: L.FERACY AH. CU ... FURA ... NAH.FESFAF.OHS .H ... HE ".HEFEEHFH CEH ... URY & GO ... H.C RA CA ..... S .. : L .... ERA ... PH .... OSOPHY AH. PSYCHOAHA ... YS.S 'H FHE ... HE ... EEH ... H CEH ... URY g C. Robinson Robbins, Ruth & Julian Wolfreys, eds. Victorian Gothic: Literary and Cultural Manifestations in the Nineteenth Century. February 2001. xx + 260 p. $69.95. 0-312-231695 (North America), 0-333-74935-9 (outside North America). Smith, Andrew. Gothic Radicalism: Literature, Philosopf?y and PsychoanalYsis in the Nineteenth Century. August 1990. ix + 188 p. $59.95. 0-313-23042-7; 0333-76035-2. Both: Palgrave, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010 Two recent Palgrave publications attest to the pervasive influence of throughout the nineteenth century. Victorian Gothic, an anthology of cnllcal essays, shows Gothic's infiltration of many aspects of Victorian conscious ness. Gothic Radicalism more particularly on the interrelationship between Gotluc notJons of subJectivity and the tradition of idealist thought in the nine teenth century. Edited by a British and an American academic, VictontJn Gothic features twelve original essays of varying lengths and quality by Anglo-American academics. an re:eals how Gothic's influence persists even after it's suppos edly dead : Escapl11g from the tomb and the castle, the Gothic in the Victorian period becomes arguably more potentially terrifying because of its


ability to manifest itself anywhere." Gothic endures not only in Victorian literature, but also in the emerging art of photography, in the revival of hypnotism as a medical treatment, and in the new science of archaeology. In general, the best essays are those that move beyond the borders of literature. 'The Dream' "by Marion Wynne-Davies is a fascinating exploration of the influence of the Gothic on Julia Margaret Cameron's photography. Roger Luckhurst's ''Trance-Gothic, 1882-97" traces how the re-emergence of discredited mesmerism as the more scientific hypnotism correlates with cycles of Gothic influence in literature; and Richard Pearson's ''Archeology and Gothic Desire" rereads H. Rider Haggard's fiction in the light of Victorian Egyptology. Honorable mentions must go to editor Wolfrey's reassessment of the role of the "comic-gothic" in Dickens, and to R.J.c. Watt's article on "Hopkins and the Gothic Body." Wolfrey's essay, in particular, helps to clarify Gothic's enduring appeal: having (temporarily) set aside their fear of Catholics and foreigners, the Victorians "need[ed] to scare themselves, to cut a caper at home [ ... ] There are no bogeymen abroad, so why not pretend t be a little spooky in one's own back yard?" Gothic Radicalism reveals just how much can be done with homegrown Gothic. Smith, a lecturer in English at the University of Glamorgan in Wales, focuses on the nineteenth century Gothic canon-Frankenstein, Poe's stories, Dracula, and Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde-in order to critique previous psychoanalytic interpretations of the literature. Smith's argument is that Victorian Gothic con tinues but transmutes eighteenth century and Romantic notions of the sublime, as articulated by Burke and Kant, thereby preparing the way for Freud. In essence, he claims that Burke's, Kant's, and Freud's metaphysics share problems that can be illuminated by the Gothic of their times, if one begins from the position that "the unconscious is an internalized version of the sublime." In seven chapters, Smith lays out what he admits is "only one particular Gothic history," taking care to place his own arguments in the context of those of other theorists and to position himself more as a complement to their analyses than as a challenger. Perhaps his most interesting (and surprisingly accessible) chapter is the one in which he reads Stoker's Dracula through the lens of Foucault's History of Sexuality. Victorian Gothic offers a wider range of perspectives and takes ill a greater variety of texts than does Gothic Radicalism. However, it's riddled with proofread ing errors (particularly evident in the preface) and includes a serious error in the illustrations (Figure 5.1 is supposed to be a well-known patnttng by William Morris, but reproduced instead is an obscure stained glass \vindow de sign of a similar subject.). The publisher, if not the editors, should have caught these mistakes. Gothic Radicalism is more polished and offers readings of more canonical works, but its dense prose may alienate readers not already thoroughly conversant in the highly specialized debates in which the author engages. Under graduate libraries seeking more generalist studies of the Gothic may be better served by David Punter's recent A Companion in the Gothic (Oxford 2000) or by Glennis Byron and David Punter's Spectral Readings: Towards a Gothic Geograp-'!J (St. Martins, 1999). However, libraries and individuals who already have Gothic col lections may find either of these new works of interest. [Guest reviewer Robinson is assistant professor of Victorian studies at Mary Washington College.-Ed.] NONFICTION REVIEW ." SEARCH OF DR .lEHYLL "R. HYDE A. Langley McNally, Raymond T. & Radu Florescu. In Search Dr. Jekyll and AJr. H)de. Renaissance Books, 5858 \X'ilshire Boulevard, #200, Los Angeles, CA 90036,December2000. 181 p. $24.95.1-58063-157-6. USHED Getting it Published is the tide ofa book by William Germano, vice president and publishing director at Roudedge. Sub-tided A Guide for Scholars and Anyone Else Serious about Serious Books, this I 93-page book (University of Chicago, $15 trade paper, May 200 I, 0-226-28844-7), discusses writing and presenting one's manuscript for both wouldbe academic authors and those who've been through the mill and want to make it easier for them selves the next time around. Neil Barron (based on brief descrip tion in PW) SCIENCE FICfION:A REVIEW OF SPECULATIVE LITERATURE The latest issue of editor Van Ikin's journal (v. IS, no. 2, #42, 2000) reached me in mid-April. The cover photograph is of Tess Williams, whose original short story, "Sea As Mirror" is reprinted, along with an article by her, an interview of her by the editor and Helen Merrick, and a review of her novel based on the story. Bruce Shaw discussed Peter Goldsworthy's 1995 Austra lian novel, Wish: A Biologically Engineered Love Story. Richard Harland investigates the fantasies of Ameri can writer Paula Volsky. Reviews and a poem complete this attrac tively printer 64-page issue. A$9 for this issue,A$16 for two issues (Australia), A$20 (US), payable to Van Ikin, English Department, Uni versity of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, CrawleyWA 6009, Australia; or payable to J.Y. Post, 3225 North Marengo Avenue, Altadena, CA 91 00 I. Neil Barron PILGRIMS AND PIONEERS SLATED JUST RELEASED Hall, Hal W. & Daryl F. Mallett, eds. Pilgrims and Pionners:The History and Speeches of the Science Fiction Research Association Award Winners. Jacob's Ladder Books, clo


Angel Enterprises, 717 Mill Avenue, PMB 87, Tempe, AZ 85281,2001. 292 p. 0-913960-4 hardcover; 0-913960-29-2 trade paper. For price and availability, inquire of SFRA Treasurer Dave Mead, Arts & Humanities, Texas A & M, 6300 Ocean Drive, Corpus Christi, TX 78412, Just as academics founded organi zations devoted to the study of SF, so they began to bestow awards for scholarly distinction. The SFRA was the first to offer such awards, be ginning in 1970 with the Pilgrim, for sustained contribution to the study of SF, continuing with the Pioneer in 1990 for the best article, and most recently with the Clareson award since 1996 for outstanding service to fantastic lit and scholarship, organizing meeting, speaking, etc. This volume assembles the presen tation and acceptance speeches for most winners, supplemented by bio graphical profiles and selected bib liographies (the last prepared by Fiona Kelleghan (mostly) and Rob Reginald). As veteran members know, this book has had a very long gestation. I'd forgotten that, along with a $5,000 grant from the 1986 Atlanta WoridCon that I distributed to the contributors to my 1990 fan tasy and horror gUides, I helped line up funds for this project. It has been at least a dozen years, during which the evolving manuscript bounced between Hall and Mallett, with the Pioneer and Clareson awards added to the lengthening Pilgrim list (The coverage is through the 1999 awards.). Supplemental material includes a short history by Art Lewis of the Pilgrim's first decade and a seven page apercu by Mallett on his links to various Pilgrim winners. The print is a bit small; the occasional On October 1, 1788, at the age of forty-seven, William Dea-con Brodie and one of his henchmen were publicly hanged after being convicted of robbing the General Excise Office of Scotland. During a sensational trial, Brodie was revealed to have lead a double life. He had been a successful cabinetmaker and house furnisher in Edinburgh but, in later years, willingly turned to crime to support high living and gambling losses. What particularly piqued public interest was that he clearly preferred the precarious underground life that included supporting two mistresses to a stable but duller existence and an honest trades man. As a young man, he had wanted to gain fame and fortune by heroic adven ture in the British army or navy, and this frustrated yearning for a life of perilous adventure never left him. Over the years, Brodie's escapes became an embroidered legend that transcended history. Books about his trial were published, and places in Edinburgh named after him. Reports even circulated that he had somehow cheated the hangman and had been seen living prosperously in Paris, New York, and elsewhere. Two generations later, Robert Louis Stevenson (1850-1894) learned all about this from his nurse, Allison Cunningham. He was a sickly child, and she would try alleviate his pain by telling him stories; one of these was suggested by the cabmet (which Brodie's firm had made) facing his bed. It was a story Stevenson never forgot. He recapitulated it in an essay shortly afterward, and life often talk.ed about it to his family and friends. He even wrote a play tltled 'William Brodie, or the Double Life." The theme became seminal in Stevenson's thinking, because he gradually came to live a double life himself. He was brought up a Calvinist but was a freethinker by nature. His father expected him to follow family tradition and become an engineer, while his own inclinations were towards a literary career. "He was fascmated with the companionship of vagabonds, sailors, and smugglers," wnte McNally and Florescu, and "turned off by the monotonous lives of the establishment" to which he had to conform while living at home. The theme of doubles occurs regularly in Stevenson's fiction. He used the judge at Brodie's trial as a model for a character in The Weir at Hermiston; the estranged brothers The MasterofBallantrae harbor exactly opposite personalitles; and ambIValence IS strongly suggested in "The Suicide Club" one of the stories in his New Arabian Nights. The purest and most intimate of course, comes In Dr. Jelgll and Mr. I-fyde, whose fIrst draft he dashed offin three days in September 1885. After receiving a favorable review in America, sales of the rocketed. They not only made rich but placed him among the .ew professlOnal wnters of his day who could live comfortably on royalties alone. The e"!dence Iinking]eky.ll ,,?th Brodie is cumulative rather than singu lar; oral or watten words by partles mvolved precisely connect the two. But the plenutude of suggestive .incidents and the length of time over which they oc curred make It hypothesis, and there is no data to gainsay it. That CIte additlonallnstances of what I've mentioned here, and I agree with theIr concluslOn. /ilong the way, pertinent events in the Stevenson household are summarized, and a helpful appendix furnishes chronologies of Stevenson's life, hIS and parallel world events (the last of which, however, is so puzzlingly eclectlc It often seems irrelevant). The concluding chapter describes adaptations of Jekyll to the various media, and an added filmography and videography bring these up to date. At last count, thirty-five mmnes of Jekyll have been made; the casts, directors, etc. of all are carefully cited. ,\nother.appendix offers a travel guide, with an annotated map, for those mterested In nsltmg the relevant sites in Edinburgh. ;\s IS so often true of collaborations, the level of writing can best be as serVlceable; but if it never rises to the heights of elegance, neither does It even descend into reader's block. Should literary genealogy interest you-and I think most people would find tillS example of It pleasant-your nught seek out its predecessors, the


authors' In Search of Dracula and In Search of Frankenstein, which trace the roots of two other fantasy classics. [Stevenson's novella is elucidated in many works, including Harry M. Geduld, ed., The Definitive Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde Companion (1983), William Veeder & Gordon Hersch, eds., Dr. Jek:JII After One Hundred Yean (1988), and Leonard Wolf's annotated edition, The Essential Dr. Jek:JII and Mr. Hyde (1995). -Ed.] NONFICTION REVIEW NARY F.c'r'o"s: FRO,. FRA .. KE .. S ... E .. ... 0 FAULK .. ER Amelia A. Rutledge Eberle-Sinatra, Michael, ed. Mary Shelley's Fictions: From Frankenstein to Faulkner. Palgrave, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010, November 2000. xxvi + 250 p. $59.95. 0-333-77106-0. The fourteen essays here, grouped in four thematic sections, were pre sented at 1997 conferences in Britain, Canada, and the US on the bicentennial of Mary Wollstonecraft Godwin's death and Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley's birth. There is much high-quality work here to engage the reader. Nora Crook's introduction surveys the history of Shelley scholarship. Her essay acknowledges criticism of the 1831 text of Frankenstein, but she recon siders the commonplace of increased "fatalism" in Victor's career. Three essays focus on stylistics, including "temporal ambiguity" in The Last Man, especially in Shelley's peculiar choice of the "narrative anterior" moment; and an examination of Shelley's styles as sentimental and "styptic" in Lodore. Four essays explore gender relationships in Matilda, Valperga, Frankenstein, The Last Man, and Shelley's short fiction. Two essays in the "contemporary scene" segment deal with time as apocalypse and as past history in The Last Man and The Fortunes of Perkin Warbeck. The other two essays explore differing aspects of Lordore. The final three essays share a focus on rehabilitation of "family" in Frankenstein and Falkner. A useful collection of academic pieces investigating Shelley's significant fiction at all lengths, whose references and notes provide a survey of contemporary Shelley scholarship. For university libraries, faculty, and graduate students. NONFICTION REVIEW SC.E .. CE A .. g F.c'r'o,,: "HE FRA .. KE .. S ... E ...... HER .... A .. CE Amelia A. Rutledge Shaw, De bra Benita. Women, Science and Fiction: The Frankenstein Inheritance. Palgrave, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010, February 2001. ix + 231 p. $59.95.0-312-23605-0 (US), 0-333-74158-7 (UK) In a revision of the author's University of East Anglia doctoral thesis, Shaw studies "how specific scientific theories, current at the time of writing, have motivated women to imagine new female identities and social orders which present a re-evaluation of the place of science in women's lives." She reads inter textually without falling into a "naive reflectionism" that would disparage the writers' engagement with their subjects. Shelley'S Frankestein is not the subject of ex tended analysis; instead, Shaw discusses Gilman's Herland, Swastika Nigh! by Katherine Burdekin (writing as "Murray Constantine"), c.L.I\!oore's "No \'\'oman Born:' Margaret Sinclair's "Short in the Chest," ''Your Haploid Heart" by Tiptree, two lesbian separatist utopias, Sally Gearhart's The lJ7anderground, and Caroline footnotes are positively microscopic This summary is not a review but primarily an announcement of the book's availability. Review copies were sent to the SF news and aca demic magazines, plus library Jour nal, and to libraries with significant SF collections. Copies were exhib ited and sold at the Schenectady conference. Because the appeal of this compilation is likely to be somewhat limited, the print run was small. Dave Mead will know if cop ies remain and their price (roughly $20 for the paperback). Do not write mallet, the publisher. Neil Barron CALLS FOR PAPERS WHAT: Gender Roles and 1970s Popular Culture Call for Contributors to a New Anthology on Gender, Women, and Popular Cul ture. TOPIC:This anthology will include essays that explore the complex relationships between United States women and popular culture in the 70's. How were women's roles influenced and shaped by popular culture in this period? How did popular culture depict theWomen's Movement? How did popular culture offer liberation for women? How did popular culture depict women from different races, classes, and ethnic backgrounds? The range of materials that could be addressed is vast: toys, television shows, mov ies, marital guides, magazines, to name just a few. Essays that adopt an interdiSciplinary approach to their material are welcome, as are essays that discuss race, ethnicity, and socioeconomic class. Essays should be lively, vibrant, and engaging; they should be of broad interest to scholars in many academic disciplines from the humanities, in-cluding history,


women's studies, English,American studies, Chicana Studies, Asian American studies, and African American studies. CONTACT: Dr.SherrieA.lnness, Department of English, 160 I Peck Boulevard, Miami University, Hamilton, Ohio 450 I I ( Early sub missions are encouraged. SEND: Articles should be 8,000 to 10,000 words (this includes notes and references); accompany ing photographs are welcome. Please send completed article and curriculum vita. DEADLINE: September 1,200 I. WHAT:Annual Central New York Conference on Language and lit erature WHO: Cortland College of the State University of New York WHERE: Cortland,NewYork WHEN: October 28-30, 200 I TOPICS: "Film and literature: Imagining the Body." Do we imag ine the corporeal differently in writ ten texts and film? Is there a com mon, foundational idea of "the body" that underpins representa tions, regardless of medium? Or might we use differences in textual mediation to reconsider our theo ries of the body? This year's panel on film and literature seeks papers that comparatively analyze repre sentations of the body in a (broad) consideration of these and other questions. Paper topics may in clude the portrayal of particular kinds of bodies (marked by race, gender, disability, age, sexuality, ath letic pursuits, addictions of one kind or another); evocations of bodily affect (How, for example, might we compare written and filmed por nography? Written and filmed vio lence?); intimations of bodilessness (the spiritual, the supernatural); the imagined/implied bodies of the au-Forbes' "London Fields;" ending with a discussion of Merge Piercy's Body ojG/ass (He, She, and It in the US). According to Shaw, Gilman, who parodies the hypermasculine literary figure "Newbold Man" in the character Terry Nicholson, cannot quite escape the strictures of conventional narrative, but her resistance to the standard narrative of "The Adventures of Him in Pursuit of Her" actively engages the "gynaeococentric" theory of Frank Lester Ward, enthusiastically adopted by Gilman. When Shaw discusses Swastika Night, she must alter her strategy since, as she notes, there is no evidence that Burdekin read the works of Melanie Klein or Karen Homey, but the novel "offers an objective analysis of gender stereotyp ing which resonates suggestively" with their own theories. The Nazi society in Swastika Night is doomed by its own ideological fissures, forced to expend great effort in repressing its own acts of repression. This chapter, dealing with a novel worth more notice, is one of the most valuable. Shaw accurately describes women's struggles to engage critically with SF's dominant constructions of femininity, but her assertion that SF fandom of the 1940's and 1950's constituted an intelligentsia that demanded a high standard of writing is dubious at best, or more applicable to the UK than to the US. More interesting is her focus on the complex influences of nascent behaviorism, the canonization of the American school of Freudian psychology, and the gender anxieties underlying the pressures, post-World War II, embodied in the first Kinsey report, and in a1947 study by Marynia Farham and Ferdinand Lundberg, Modern Woman: The Lost Sex, that proclaimed a "deep illness." The book's more useful discussions are based on less familiar works; the discussions of Moore and Piercy in terms of Donna Haraway's cyborg theory add little to SF criticism. Shaw's reading of Sinclair's story suggests a comic variation of Turing tests: investment in machine authority-the male-gendered machine, in this case a psychiatrist-makes even a malfunction seem normative. The Tiptree chapter recuperates a somewhat neglected story as an example of a feminist critique of science's claims of objectivity. Shaw reads by Gearhart and Forbes' separatist feminist utopias ,vith sensitivity, but her allegiances are clear. She is not in favor of the kind of gendered separatism, shading toward essentialism, that she finds in Gearhart's The Wanderground. Shaw regards Forbes' "perpetual negotiation" as a more flexible approach to utopian goals. In one way, Shaw's choice of tests is problematic: both are grounded in lesbian politics, but Gearhart's novel contains too many elements of the fantastic, as opposed to the sociologically and scientifically grounded "London Fields," to provide many workable contrasts. My cavils are minor, however. This book, overpriced as such publica tions curren tly seem to be, is a worthy addition to SF criticism and is accessible to both students and to scholars. NONFICTION REVIEW SCRAPS OF FHE U .. FA' .. FED SHY: SC'E .. CE .YSFOP'A. Joan Gordon Moylan, Tom. Scraps oj the Untainted Science Fiction, Utopia, D)lStopia. \X'estview Press, 5500 Central ,-\venue, Boulder, CO 80310-2877, December 2000. xLX + 386 p. $30, trade paper. 0-8133-9768-5. 10m Moylan is already an important contributor to utopian scholar ship ",;th his Demand the Impossible: ScieJIce Fiction and the Utopian Imaination (1986) and numerous articles. Scraps from the Untainted should also prove valuable, though it doesn't so much break new ground as go over old ground ,,,ith a new perspective.


The tide refers to the vision at the end of Forester's "The Machine Stops," when the mechanistic dystopia explodes and its dying citizens see the briefest glimpse of a purer, eutopian world. And in that vision is the understanding of Moylan's central term, "critical dystopia:' a phrase that describes a work that depicts a WOl;se world while suggesting the possibility of eutopian change. Also crucial is the importance of distinguishing between dystopia and anti-utopia, the latter a term he reserves, as Lyman Tower Sargent does, for works that criticize eutopian possibility. This is an important distinction for Moylan as he emphasizes political and ethical action in utopian thinking. Scraps of the Untainted Sky meticulously covers the major theoretical works in utopian scholarship, using them as building blocks to construct paradigms for eutopia, dystopia, and anti-utopia, and applies to these theoretical texts Moylan's own Marxist political and ethical analysis of the opposition politics of the 1960's and 1970's and the more conservative retreats of the 1980's and 1990's. Finally, he uses the aggregated theoretical and political framework to analyze several recent dystopian novels. The book's first section offers readings of stories from the 1970's: "When It Changed" by Russ and "Houston, Houston, Do You Read?" by Tiptree. It then surveys major theoretical works in SF and utopian studies of or about that same period by Fredric Jameson, Darko Suvin, Lyman Tower Sargent, and others. Part Two provides a close reading of Forester's famous dystopian story and sur veys the theoretical work in dystopian literature, with particular attention paid to Irving Howe, Peter Fitting, Kingsley Amis, and the necessarily inevitable Jameson and Suvin. It establishes the range of utopian and anti-utpoian positions pos sible in dystopian writing and defines and discusses "critical dystopias," including Pohl and Kornbluth's early The Space Merchants, Dick's "Faith of Our Fathers," and Zoline's "Heat Death of the Universe." Part Three examines three major critical dystopias: Robinson's Gold Coast, Butler's Parable series, and Piercy's He, She, and It. Moylan's clarifying emphasis on the need for differentiating between dystopia and anti-utopia, his introduction of the term "critical dystopia," and his exploration of examples of the type are important contributions to the ongoing critical conversation in utopian studies. His discussion of the protocols of read ing SF and utopian literature is especially fIne. Further, his meticulous survey of the major theoretical works of SF and utopian scholarship provides an excellent ground for any reader ,vishing to be introduced to this rich field of study, either teacher or student. I do have a reservation, however. The book is extremely descriptive, overloaded ,vith plot summary and reiteration of theoretical argu ment, which can be tedious for a reader already familiar with the texts. For less knowledgeable readers, it is so extensive as to sometimes take over the originals. In spite of this problem and, I fear, because of it in some cases, Scraps of the Untainted Sky will become a very useful source in utopian and SF studies. NONFICTION REVIEW LEAR ..... G FRO,. O ... HER WORLDS: ES ... IIIA .. GE,.E ..... COG ....... O .. A .. D 7'HE POL ..... CS OF $C.E .. CE F.c .... o .. A .. D U ... OP.A Jimmy H(Croy Parrinder, Patrick, ed. Learningfrom Other Worlds: Estrangement, Cognition and the Politics of Science Fiction and Utopia. Liverpool University Press, 4 Cam bridge Street, Liverpool, L69 7ZU, England, December 2000. vii + 312 p. 0-85323-574-0, .95, trade paper, 0-85323-5848. Duke Uni versity Press, 905 West Main Street, Durham, NC 27701,Summer 200l. $54.95,0-8223-2773-, $18.95 trade paper, 0-8223-2776-7. (lience (and evocations of audience affect). They are interested in a variety of approaches (comparative studies of adaptations; close read ings of texts; general outlines of theories; pedagogical practices and utility. CONTACT: Submissions should go to Mike Reynolds, 1483 Huron Ave., St. Paul, MN 55108 or SEND: 1-2 page abstracts (for 20minute papers). DEADLINE: July 3, 200 I. WHAT: "Classical Myths in Recent Literature and Film" WHO: Southwest Texas American Culture Association/Popular Cul tureAssociation Conference. WHERE: Albuquerque, New Mexico. WHEN: February 13-17,200 I. TOPICS: Papers on any aspect of classical mythology in modern lit erature and film are eligible for con sideration. Possible topics include (but are not limited to): film ver sions of ancient myths, modern ad aptations of classical material in film or literature, the classical heroic figure in modern film or literature, his torical fiction in modern film, clas sical myth in children's literature or film. CONTACT: Kirsten Day, Foreign Languages Department, 425 Kimpel Hall, UniverSity of Arkan sas, Fayetteville, AR 7270 I or via e-mail to. Please include e-mail address with surface mail abstracts so that we can confirm receipt of your submission. SEND:Abstracts. DEADLINE: October 15,200 I. WHAT: GhostWorks TOPIC: In Spectres of Marx, Derrida claims that 'everyone reads, acts, writes with his or her ghosts, even when one goes after the ghosts of the other' ( I 39}.What


(loes it mean to read, act or write with ghosts if not to suggest that reading. writing. interpretation, 'be ing.' are inexorably linked to haunt inglThis special issue of West Coast UNE, scheduled for Spring 2002, is concerned with 'ghost writing' but seeks submissions from visual art ists as well as scholars, poets and fiction writers whose works take up the issue of haunting, spectrality, revenance and the uncanny in millennial culture. popular or oth erwise. Submissions to this issue might consider that talking with ghosts does not only mean being in conversation with them. It also rheans to use them instrumentally and. in turn, whether one knows it or not, to be used by them. CONTACT: Jodey Castricano. De partment of English.Wilfrid Laurier University, Waterloo. Ontario N2L 3C5 or or SEND: Final submissions. DEADLINE: July 31. 200 I. WHAT:janus Head:journal of/nterdisciplinary Studies in Uterature, Conti nental Philosophy, Phenomenological Psychology and the Arts TOPIC: janus Head is actively seek ing contributions for its tenth issue to be published in March 2002. The topic of this issue is "Magical Real ism." to be guest edited by Bainard Cowan. Professor of Literature, Loui siana State University. What specifically is this movement, "Magical Realism?" From the works of such authors as Garcia Marquez.Allende. Morrison. Italo Calvi no. Pelevin. Chamoiseau. and Rushdie. and films such as Breaking the Waves. Comedie Infantil. Ugetsu. Crouch ing Tiger, Hidden Dragon. there is a motion away from the common lin ear perspective of reality towards a world view that undercuts the tra ditional empirical. rational tenets and embraces not only holistic patterns This festschrift is a diverse collection of insightful elaborations and literary/cultural analyses dedicated to the scholar and theorist Darko Suvin. In dialogue with Suvin's previous writings on SF and utopia, particularly his exploration of "cognitive estrangement" (the notion that imagining alterna tive realities allows for a re-evaluation of one's own socio-political climate), the essays function in several ways. First, they gesture toward a contemporary reassessment of SF as a po tentially progressive genre capable of interrogating dominant cultural ideologies. They also allow for critical (re)evaluations of a myriad of popular literary and cultural texts, including the utopian writings of More and Marx, Robinson's popular Mars trilogy, and the recent journalistic free-for-all following the birth of a sheep named Dolly. Furthermore, because of the multiple visions and theoreti cal approaches, Learning, like a successful academic conference, is by turns cohesive and expansive. Culminating with an inspiring afterward by Suvin, in which the link between fiction and social intervention is made increasingly evident, this book provides an important opportunity to evaluate the political impact of SF and utopia. Among the best essays are Carl Freedman's "Science Fiction alld Utopia," Peter Fitting's "Estranged Invaders: The War of the Wor/ds," and Marleen Barr's" 'We're at the start of a new ball game and that's why we're all real nervous': Or, Cloning-Technological Cognition Reflects Estrangement from Women." Freeman's essay skillfully explores the paradoxes inherent in SF imaginings and cognitive estrangement (one can only possess a "perfect knowledge" of utopia by living within a utopia). He also deftly illustrates the extent to which a "deep theoretical affinity" exists between SF and "scientific socialism." Fitting and Barr's essays represent very different but equally effective applications of "cognitive es trangement." Fitting reads Wells' invasion as a Darwinian critique of colonialist practices that, despite the obvious racism, provides a far more detailed consider ation of alien dynamics than do many of its imitators, such as Frederick brown's (1944). Social critique also informs Barr's ruminations upon media rep resentations of emerging reproductive technologies. Although far less in debt to Suvin, she takes estrangement as a primary concern, revealing how "new cloning cognition yields old misogyny." Scholars working with Suvin's theories of literature and culture will be hard pressed to find a more timely and comprehensive collection. Whether this will satisfy the intellectual curiosity of readers searching for extensive deliberations on SF's oppositional potential in a culture informed by post-Fordist economic structures is open to question. Suvin's eclectic "Afterward: With Sober, Estranged Eyes" lays important groundwork for future projects of that nature. As he eloquently states, progressive utopian discourse, including SF, must enact "a poli tics that can recuperate (make sense of) paradise and-alas especially--hell." NONFICTION REVIEW REWR ....... a rHE WOfltlE .. OF CAfItIELOr: ARrHUR.A .. POPULAR F.c .... o .. A ... FEfItI .... Sfltl Karen HcGuire Howey, ,.\nn r. Rewriting the Women of Camelot: Arthurian Popular Fiction and Femimsm. Greenwood Press, 88 Post Road West, Westport, CT 06881, February 2001. xix + 137 p. $59.95. 0-313-31604-X. This analysis of women characters in recent and popular Arthurian fic tion is effective and engaging. With emphasis on characters in the works of 1\laoon Zimmer Bradley, Gillian Bradshaw, Fay Sampson, and Mary Stewart, Howey examines the images of royal women and magical \voman, women as protagonists, and narrative techniques with emphasis on feminist interpretation. Us-


ing abundant examples, Howey demonstrates the ways these writing strategies "undermine traditional symbols of power, [ ... ] redefine the heroic, and [ .. ] problematize binary oppositions." With careful precision, she defines both popular fiction and feminism as these terms are used throughout the text and provides a medieval context for Arthurian mythology in the opening chapters. However, these sections are the least effective, for they cover familiar ground and could have been condensed, allowing for Howey to include more writers' works. For example, Persia Woolley's Guinevere Trilogy (She mentions Child of the Northern Spring, 1987, first in the series in passing.) would have been a worthy addition to the analysis and is con spicuous in its absence. Howey's analysis of various novels and short stories (One chapter is devoted to several short stories published between 1985 and 1996.) are clearly supported and maintain a focus on Arthurian popular fiction as a vehicle for revisioning the old myth while also examining the feminist themes that Bradley, Bradshaw, and Sampson consistently address and Stewart occasionally considers. Howey's best analysis is devoted to Bradley's best-selling The Mists of Avalon, which she commends for its emphasis on the communities of women; oddly, though, she refers to Raven "as Viviane's servant" and thereby misses Raven's function and significance. Rewriting the Women of Camelot would be a useful addition to anyone interested in women characters of that myth. However, the appendices are redun dant, since a list of character names is unnecessary, but the eight-page bibliography is helpful and points the reader to other i\rthurian texts and analyses of tradition and recent versions of the myth. [Usefully supplementing Howey is Raymond H. Thompson's The Re turn from Avalon: A Stucfy of the Arthurian Legend in Modern Fiction (1985) and, for instructors, Approaches to Teaching the Arthurian Tradition by Maureen Fries and Jeanie Watson (1992). -Ed.] NONFICTION REVIEW Con,c BOOK CIILrllRE: A .. ILLIIS'rRA'rED H'SrORY Darren Harrisfain Goulart, Ron. Comic Book Culture: An Illustrated History. Collectors Press, Box 230986, Portland, OR 97281, May 2000. 204 p. $49.95. 1-888054-38-7. Orders to 800-423-1848. If a picture is worth a thousand words, the ratio in Goulart is seriously skewed, for the publisher claims 400+ color illustrations. Goulart admits this: "While we offer an informative text outlining the birth and development of the modem comic book [ ... ] Comic Book Culture is basically a picture book." Such a book isn't entirely useless for scholars of SF and fantasy. A substantial portion of American comic books has always been part of these genres, and little scholarship has been devoted to questions of genre in a field that's typically received even less respect than prose fantasy or SF. Goulart's book could serve as an introduction to American comic books for the uninitiated, and he does discuss comics that employ the fantastic. The book's scope is limited to American comic books, from the origins of the comic book in America to the late 1940's. Thus, despite its title, Comic Book Culture deals primarily with the 1930's and 1940's, the Golden Age of the Ameri can comic books. The sparse text also limits the scope. Goulart's attempt to provide a lot of information unfortunately results in a breezy pace in which chapters often read like laundry lists of names and dates, with much infonnation packed into very short chapters. Goulart says of artist Alex Schomburg that "the writer who could fit the whole story of a typical Schomburg cover into that f reality, but the chaotic and un expected manifestations of human experience as well. In this vein, questions of faith, salvation, and devotion arise, as well as the iden tity and formation of the individual within the community through meaning and experience. Magical realism also responds to or correlates with the explosion of technology and the birth of cyberworlds, cultural interface and the seeds of planetary culture, quantum effects and black hole cosmology, and textualization and language theory. Themes and mo tifs of magical realism include the otherworldly power of things in the world, storytelling, the sacred, tra dition and the breaking of tradi tion, generation, transformation, metaphor and lyrical language, the alien and other. We are considering essays, poetry and fiction, com mentaries and explorations in film, art, and reviews, but are also seeking multimedia projects, transla tions, transcriptions, interviews and non-traditional contributions. The editors suggest that potential con tributors review past issues of the journal and the criteria stated be low in order to obtain a sense of the journal's spirit, style, and inter est. CONTACT:Any questions should be directed to: CRITERIA FOR ESSAYS: Sub missions should be no longer than 9800-12000 words (may be shorter).Works should, of course, be typed and double-spaced. How ever, there is no format requirement (e.g.,APA, MLA, etc.) due to the HTML conversion of word pre cessing documents. In terms of content, the work should speak to the Janus Head attitude of "respect


and openness to the various mani festations of truth in human expe rience and the fostering of under standing through meditative thinking, narrative structure, and poetic imagination." Special consider ation is given to any work which: a) emphasizes a qualitative, rather than quantitative approach to any research phenomena, b) success fully attempts a cross-disciplinary approach to the research topic, c) either via theory or methodologi cal approach, speaks to the current continental philosophical cri sis, and d) involves a creative and unique approach to the research topic. CRITERIA FOR SHORT FICTION & POETRY: Submissions should be no longer than 9,80012,000 words. Short fiction should be typed and double-spaced. Po etry should be typed in the format in which it would be printed. Special consideration is given to any fiction or poetry that speaks to the human condition in our current cultural and historical milieu. We advise you to browse through works of past contributors on our website before you decide to sub mit your own work. Our selec tions of poetry tend towards those whose language is fully fleshed, but succinct, lyrically poignant, and skillfully rendered. Persons interested in submitting essays and/or short works of fiction should send a SASE, along with a hard diskette (PC format is pre ferred. but not necessary) to: Janus Head. PO Box 7914, Pittsburgh, PA 15216-0914. We do not accept essay submissions via e-mail. Po etry. if 300 words or less, may be sent via e-mail to: Authors should include their elimited space was indeed a master of compression," and one might say the same of Goulart's efforts in his constrained format. Such compression makes it difficult to keep names, publishers, and titles straight, which is compounded by the fact that there is no index, a major deficit given the number of names. His book makes not claims to be an extended history or a work of serious scholarship, although he's certainly well informed, as his earlier books on comics indicate. Readers desiring a more developed treatment of American comic books and their relationship with SF and fantasy should consult the surveys of the secondary literature, such as that by Peter M. Coogan in Anatonry of Wonder (1995) and by Doug Highsmith in Fanta!) and Horror (1999), both edited by Neil Barron. Comic Book Culture could still be useful to scholars in spite of its limita tions. For instance, while many histories of American comics begin with the 1930's, Goulart traces the prototypes of comic books back decades earlier, and the text gives a good idea of what comic books were like prior to 1950. He's also good at establishing relationships between comic books and other contemporary forms of entertainment, such as newspapers, pulp magazines, radio, and films. In addition, a few chapters depart from the chronological approach to focus on such topics as early and little-known superheroes, patriotic superheroes, comic book responses to World War II, and humor comics. All chapters include sample illustrations, all in brilliant color with infor mative captions, but neither are keyed to the text, although this is a minor problem. Who could resist a book with captions like turns back an invasion of green Nazi gorillas"? Only someone who wouldn't be interested in a book like this in the first place. Goulart concludes with a few paragraphs about collecting comic books, followed by a key to the price symbols that accompany each reproduced comic cover. I f for nothing else, this book is valuable for presenting hundreds of pictures of covers that are worth not only a thousand words but also hundreds or thousands of dollars, far more than most scholars could afford. In that light, the book's price doesn't seem to be all that bad. [To be reviewed in a future issue is a Johns Hopkins book, Comic Book Nation: TransJormingAmerican Culture by Bradford W Wright, who provides an insightful political and cultural history of comic books -Ed.] NONFICTION REVIEW 'rRANSREAL'S'r F'CF'ON: 'WR''r'NC .. 'rHE SL'PSFREAN OF SC'E .. CE Donald Gilzinger, Jr. Broderick, Damien. Transrealist Fiction: Writing in the Slipstream of Science. Contri butions to the Study of Science Fiction and Fantasy, No. 90. Westport, CT: Greenwood, 2000. 195 pages, $65.00. ISBN:0-3t3-31121-8. Transreaiist Fiction could serve as a companion to Broderick's earlier Reading lry Starligbt (Routledge, 1995) in which he attempted to construct a theory of postmodern science fiction using Samuel R. Delany as an exemplar. In this study, Broderick continues his examination of postmodernism in science fiction by proposing the evolution of a bifurcated model of science fiction: first, the Star Wars/ Star Trek (and the like) novel tie-in branch aimed at the popular culture market and second, the literary branch, which produces more complex, serious (for w,ult of a better word), and experimental texts. The dismissal of both branches by mainstream scholars has often been based on the perception, frequently inaccu rate, that the genre is plot and setting driven with resulting poor characterization. If this take on contemporary sciene fiction sounds familiar, it is, having been proposed earlier by, among others, Robert Silverberg and Brian Aldiss.


However, Broderick extends the definition of porno science fiction by offering the concept of transrealism originally posited by Rudy Rucker as "writing about your immediate perceptions in a fantastic way ... [with] characters ... based on actual people ... (1). In other words, transrealist employ the apparatus of science fiction and fantasy to describe their immediate reality or their peculiar perception of it, because science fiction is the most valid lens through which they can depict their personal experience. As a result, they are thereby freed to create dynamic, rounded characters. Perhaps this, too, is restating and redefining the obvious. Tbis study's two most substantive and closely argued chapters focus on Philip K. Dick and Rudy Rucker whom Broderick identifies as models for transrealist writers. According to Broderick, Dick continually mined his personal experience, including failed marriages, drug abuse, religious euphoria, and haunt ing childhood incidents, for material in both his early novels like E)'e in the S9 (1957) and The Broken Bubble (c1956) and his later Valis (1981) and The Transmigration of Timotf?y Archer (1982). Dick's characters frequently mirror himself or the dark-haired girls who fascinated him. As Dick admits, he was "making use of what I went through and saw to feed back into my life as a writer, so that it was not wasted in that respect" (129). Most of the biographic information in tills volume is gleaned from Anne Dick's The SearchforPhilipK Dick, 1928-1982 (l\fellen, 1995) and Dick's essays collected in The Shifting Realities of Philip K Dick (Vintage, 1995). Rucker's chapter is deeply informed by autobiographical information provided through what appears to have been a lengthy and frank correspondence between him and Broderick. It includes a table that identifies the character repre senting Rucker in each of his stand-alone works and series as well as the period in his life, from the early 1960s through the late 1990s, that each text portrays. Rucker admits that many of his characters are composites of family members and other people he knows (as in the 1V'are series), but in most of his work "the main character is modeled on me" (157) as in White Light (1980) or Saucer IFi.rdnm (1999). However, the difficulty with claiming the centrality of complex character ization based on personal experience in any fiction is the tendency of readers to commit the biographical mistake. Broderick admits this can be the case and then elides over it. However, I believe that transrealist characterization would be diffi cult to read as such without intimate knowledge of the writer's life, and most writers withhold those details from us for reasons of privacy and even modesty. Furthermore, the danger of reading too much transrealist autobiographic detail into dynamic, rounded fictional characters might force writers to include personal disclaimers in their novels, as does Nicola Griffith at the close of Slow River. Transrealist Fiction is alternately absorbing and frustrating. It also con tains a good number of typos and a high price tag for 176 pages of text. Still, Broderick actively extends the boundaries of science fiction critical theory. It's a risk well worth taking, and Transrealist Fiction should be read by anyone interested in closely reasoned, cutting-edge criticism. FICTION REVIEW A COLLECY"OH OF SHOllY' SY'OIl'ES Hichaellevy Chapman, Stepan. Dossier, A Collection of Short Stories. Creative Arts Book Co., 833 Bancroft Way, Berkeley, CA 94710, 2001. 166 p. $13.95, paper. 088739-280-6. A few years back Chapman's The Troika (1997) became the first small press book ever to win a major SF prize, the Philip K. Dick ,-\ward, an honor it richly deserved. NO\,,; Chapman has brought out his first full-length short ail address and full postal address. Please allow six to eight months for editorial decisions. DEADLINE: The deadline for sub missions is December 1st, 200 I. WHAT: Children's Fantasy Fiction Debates for the Twenty First Century WHO: An Interdisciplinary conference hosted by the Science Fiction Foundation and the Associa tion for Research in Popular Fic tions WHERE: Bulmershe College, Uni versity of Reading UK WHEN: 7th, 8th & 9th January 2002 TOPICS:Advance Call for Papers and Panel Convenors Abstracts for 25 minute presentations should be submitted by I st August 200 I on all areas of research concerning children's fantasy fiction across media or popular cultural forms e.g. books. graphic novels. radio. television. film. games. story telling and toys which will make a contribution to a forum on new approaches and research perspectives for this field of study. CONTACT: Helen Briscoe. Conference Administrator. MCCA. Liverpool John Moores University. Dean Walters Building St James Road. Liverpool L I 7BR UK. E-mail Fax + 44 15 I 23 I 5049. Tel + 44 151 23 I 5052 SEND: Please send proposals. DEADLINE: August 1st 200 I. WHAT: The Superhero Reader:An Introduction to Comic Books and the Superhero Genre TOPIC: Original essays are invited for a collection tentatively entitled The Superhero Reader: An Introduction to Comic Books and the Superhero Genre. The purpose of this book is to explore the cultural sig-


nificance of superhero comic bookS from a variety of approaches and perspectives. Ideally, this collection will be a suitable and comprehen sive introductory text book for the growing field of comic book stud ies. Possible topics may include but are not limited to: Origins and His tory, Characters, Archetypes, Psy chology, Gender, Ethnicity, Sexuali ties, Fandom, Creators. Corporate Structure. Cinema tic/Television Ad aptations.Themes and Trends. Mar keting. Censorship. CONTACT: Jeffrey A Brown. De partment of Popular Culture, Bowl ing Green State University. Bowling Green. Ohio 43403-0226. Tel: (419) 372-2982. Fax: (419) 3722577. E-mail: SEND: Please submit 2-page pro posals or completed manuscripts (MLA style. 15 25 pages in length) to: DEADLINE: The deadline for the submission of completed papers is September 4th. 200 I. WHAT: Technotopias:Texts. Iden tities. and Technological Cultures WHO: The University of Strathclyde WHERE: Glasgow. Scotland WHEN: July 10-12 2002 TOPIC: The University of Strathclyde is a world leader in sci ence and engineering yet, like many similar institutions. it maintains a strong commitment to the humani ties. In societies that seem to place increasing emphasis on the appli cation of technology and scientific knowledge, this kind of commitment is sometimes seen as irrelevant. For humanities departments. this situa tion raises new questions of iden tity. within both university faculties and cultural discourse itself. In the light of this situation. the aims of story collection, and it is also a definite winner. DOJ'sierfeatures seventeen of Chapman's decidedly off-center fantasies. Among the best are "Boots Practice," in which a soldier tries out an experimental military version of the classic fairy tale footwear; '''!be Stairways of Causation," which concerns an Indian healer who goes to truly amazing lengths and heights to cure a little girl's illness; ''Noc turne," the tale of an epic battle between a hate-filled automobile engine and a monstrous seaweed creature; "The Sister City," which concerns a man who meets the spirit of a dead Japanese village in a bar and falls in love with her; and two of the strangest end-of-the-world stories you will ever come across, "When the Moths Came Down" and "Minutes of the Last Meeting." Chapman plays games with reality in an almost obsessive fashion, but his surreal, dream-like and intensely visual tales have more in common with the fiction of Franz Kafka or the paint ings of Salvador Dali than they do with the work of Philip K. Dick. He's perhaps the best of a group of writers-including Steven Aylett, Michael Cisco,Jeffrey Thomas. and Jeff VanderMeer, among others-who are creating outstanding speculative fiction more or less entirely outside the normal genre venues. DOJ'J'ier is a wonderful short story collection, and I heartily recommend it. FICTION REVIEW "'HEYEA .. S DES ... FA ..... ASY A ... Ho .... o .. : ... H ...... EE" ... H A .... "AL COLLEC .... O .. Margaret H(Bride Datlow, Ellen and Windling, Terri. The Years But Fantasy and Horror: Thirteenth Annual Colledion. New York: St. Martin's Griffin, 2000. 514 pages, trade, $17.95. ISBN 0-312-26416-X or hardcover, $29.95. ISBN 0-31226274-4. A quick glance through Datlow's and Windling's anthology for 1999 makes it clear why this series has been a staple in the fiction and horror fields for over a decade. Not only do these editors collect some of the best short stories and poetry from diverse sources, but they also give useful introductory articles on novels and other publishing information. Terri Windling begins with thirty-nine pages summarizing the notable fantasy publications. Ellen Datlow has thirty seven pages of summary for horror, followed by Edward Bryant's twenty-five pages on fantasy and horror in the media, Seth Johnson's seven pages on comics, and eight pages giving information on people of note in the field who died in 1999. The last twelve pages of the book list other short stories that the editors consider notable. I regularly read Locus, Asimovs, Fantasy and Science Fiction, and other re,,;ew sources to compile my "books worth reading" list; nevertheless, I found books I had never read about in the other sources. Windling says that over five hundred books were reviewed for the year. The anthology introductions are particularly useful for librarians and teachers who are asked to recommend books because they list subgenres (such as urban fantasy, mythic fiction, humorous fantasy, etc.), in addition to giving picks for the top twenty books in fantasy and top sixteen in horror. I appreciated the philosophic principles discussed before the listings, including the citation from Interstitial Arts Manifesto describing "art that can't be labeled or defined." The ,vide range of sources (literary and univer sity journals, on-line sites, one-author collections as well as the expected fantasy magazines and anthologies) used for the selection process suggest the editors are willing to cross boundaries, as does the fact that some novels and stories are listed by both editors. If the above doesn't convince you this anthology belongs in all public libraries and your own private collection, a glance through the table of contents should do so. You will find the names you might expect, such as Charles DeLiot, Neil Gaiman, Ursula K. LeGuin, Patricia A. McKillip, Delia Sherman, Gene


Wolfe, and Jane Yolen. You will also find an N. Scott Momaday story revisioning a Kiowan folktale about the Big Dipper, a story by Juan Goytisolo translated from Spanish, a number of poems, and an essay by Douglas E. Winter urging horror writers to ignore publishers' typecasting and remember that the unexpected is the core of horror. Readers of diverse interests will find stories they relished reading during 1999 as well as new ones to pique their interest. A teacher of almost any class dealing with speculative fiction or other literary themes could find a story in this anthology worth sharing with students. One story takes place during Britain's WWII air battles (Ian R. MacLeod "The Chop Girl"); another deals with Irish female laborers in England (Mary Sharratt "The Anatomy of a Mermaid',); yet another refers to Alice in Wonderland in a wonderfully surreal ship setting (Denise Lee "Sailing the Painted Ocean"). Several stories would be appropriate for readers interested in the burgeoning subgenre of retold fairy tales. Wendy Wheeler's "Skin So Green and Fine" transplants ''Beauty and the Beast" to Santa Domingo with voodoo figures, while :Michael Marshall Smith's "\Vhat You Make It" com bines horror and fairy tale in a Disneyfied retirement home-four terms you're unlikely to see combined too often. Elizabeth Birmingham's "Falling Away" could be taught in a class on Native American themes as well as a class based on speculative fiction. I am not generally much of a horror fan, but Paul]. McAuley's "Naming the Dead" with its layers of British reality and long-lived ghosts, as well as its interesting central character, made me want to read more in its milieu. I also liked Neil Gaiman's mixture of sadistic criminals and mythic religion in "Keep sakes and Treasures: A Love Story." Kelly Link's "The Girl Detective" gets my vote for the story I most want to discuss with other readers and \\lill be irresistible to anyone who loved Nancy Drew stories. The last story I will mention for special recognition is Eleanor Arnason's "The Grammarian's Five Daughters." I don't know if the students in a writing class would appreciate its sly wit, poetic lan guage, and use of fairy tale motifs to memorialize the parts of speech, but I think members of SFRA would. The thirteenth edition of The Years Best Fantary and Horror is worth buying for her story alone. FICTION REVIEW ARCNAHGEL IPROFOCOL Hichaellevy Morehouse, Lyda. Archangel Protocol. New York: Roc, 2001. 352 p. paperback, $6.99. ISBN: 0-451-45827-3. Morehouse's first novel combines traditional cyberpunk and hard-boiled detective elements \\lith a bit of romance, a dash of parody, and some truly whacked out theology to create an entertaining science-fiction adventure. The novel reminds me to some extent of Richard Paul Russo's much praised Carlucci series, although it is less grim and horrific. Deirdre McMannus is a disgraced former cop now scratching out a life on the fringes of society as a private eye. She lives in a world where virtually everyone is LINKed, tied into a late twenty-first century equivalent of the World Wide Web, through wetware installed in their skulls. Most of the world's major nations, including the U.S., are theocracies and use of the LINK is limited to people who are members of an established church. This religious revival carne about after angels began to appear on the LINK and proclaim God's message. Sometime later, Daniel Fitzpatrick, Deirdre's partner in the NYPD, for reasons unknown even to himself, goes crazy while on duty and assassinates the Pope, who is visiting New York. Deirdre, caught in the backwash from that crime, soon finds herself both excommunicated from the Catholic Church and exiled from the LINK. Now, she has been recruited by l\.1ichael Angelucci, a strangely charismatic NYPD officer who wants her to help him discredit the LINK-angels. The problem is, though, that much of the evidence implies that the LINK-angels may indeed be the real thing and that Lieu-Technotopias are to: investigate the complex historical and contemporary interplay between the humani ties and technology; address the impact of technologies upon the for mation of physical and cultural iden tities; consider historical and con temporary representations of tech nology, and reflect upon the place of the arts within modern academia. To realize the interdisciplinary nature of this conference we invite papers from all fields of literary and cultural criticism, as well as the sci entific and technological disciplines, at both post-doctoral and postgraduate levels. Suggested topics include: Literatures of technology: historical contexts; Frontiers of the imagination: Science and Fiction; (Post)modern texts I (post)industrial spaces;Technologos: technology and the word; The science of Angellica: gender and technology; Culture, technology, and the body;Technolo gies and the self; New media, old academe; Paradigms of utility in academia. CONTACT: Stephen Jones, Technotopias Organising Commit tee, Department of English Studies, University ofStrathclyde, Uvingstone Tower, 26 Richmond Street, Glasgow, G I I XH. Tel: 0141 548 3529 (Tues-Thurs 10am-4pm). Fax: 0141 552 3493. Further informa tion will shortly be available through the department's online Journal Edoga: SEND: Abstracts of 200 words for a 20 30 minute paper DEADLINE: 31 December 200 I WHAT: "SF" Issue of Reconstruction TOPIC: Reconstruction is seeking formally and intellectually innova tive submissions in anticipation of the Fall 200 I debut of this new peer-


reviewed electronic culture studies journal. Published in a cellular format rather than traditional issues, each cell will be organized around specific themes with a unit editor overseeing production and forging links between existing cells to for mulate ever-changing juxtapositions of new knowledge. In addition to the organic structure made possible by its electronic format, Reconstruction will promote work that is inter active, and will actively solicit reader response to comment on, question, and complement existing works while pushing the journal into new directions. Submissions may be cre ated from a variety of perspectives, including, but not limited to: geog raphy, cultural studies, folklore, ar chitecture, history, sociology, psy chology, communications, music, political science, semiotics, theology, art history, queer theory,literature, criminology, urban planning, women's studies,graphic design,etc. Both theoretical and empirical ap proaches are welcomed. "SF" seeks criticism focusing on sci ence and speculative fiction, as well as fantasy and magic realism, dedi cated to broadening the scope of SF Studies. Articles focusing on SF and its relation to political ideolo gies; sexuality and gender construc tion; the wilderness/civilization di vide; colonial and postcolonial stud ies; race, ethnicity and racism; class; techno-fetishism; and cultural theory, as well as studies of individual authors and their oeuvres, are encouraged. Moreover, articles con cerning SF and its placement and popularity in various media are de sired (which mayor may not be limited to the follOWing: television, cin ema, music, and comic books). Reconstruction is also considering tenant Angelucci may not be entirely human either. Archangel Protocol features a variety oflovely little touches. When McMannus gets really depressed, she reaches into the bottom drawer of her desk, not for the traditional botde of whiskey but for a bent up romance novel. has a series of run-ins with a rather terrifying mafia type named Morningstar and eventually discovers that some of her most valuable allies are Hassidic terrorists. And then there's the rather odd sex scene in the belfry. This is an excellent first novel from a writer who's definitely worth keeping an eye on. FICTION REVIEW "HE OCFAGO .. AL RArE .. Janice H. Bogstad Modesitt,]r. L.E. The Octagonal Raven. New York: TOR Books, Feb. 2001. 432 pages, cloth, $27.95. ISBN 0 312 87720 X A very politically oriented mystery story, this novel requires a commitment of attention and time, both of which are richly rewarded. Like the science fiction of Pat Cadigan or lain Banks, it engages the reader's thought processes at several levels and satisfies a taste for both problem-solving and adventure. In the far future, Daryn Alwyn is embroiled in a mystery that causes him to question the structure of his society, his own wealth and position, and his family members' morality. Daryn is a rebel. When given the opportunity to work for the family media business, UniCorn, he chose first to serve as a pilot in the military, then to create his own media-oriented career, both as a consultant for family competitors and as an artist in this complex medium. The story here revolves around numerous unsuccessful attempts on his life and successful ones against his family and other members of a social elite. He gradually discovers how his social class profit from being able to afford gene-sculpting for their children and how some of his peers are now manipulating government in order to ensure the longevity of their social position. Ivfodesitt executes his multi-level plot through the use of firstperson narrative, involving the reader intimately in Dal)Tn's dilemmas. Thus, the reader is given very little advantage over his protagonist. The fast-paced action of the novel begins in the first chapter, as Daryn is attacked at a social gathering, and becomes more and more complex as the attacks do. But all the threats to Daryn's life allow him to make elaborate attempts at researching how they were executed, satisfying a reader's desire to further understand the technology of his world. His social investigations are no less intriguing. In trying to solve the mystery and protect himself, Daryn uncovers plots and counter plots involving his family members on both sides of a debate about access to education and to the benefits it brings. As he attempts to find his attackers, his quest forces him into parts of his social space from which he was previously insulated and requires him to confront a host of ugly truths. Daryn's quest is hampered by his own ignorance about the social stratification of his society and his confusion about why he, the least powerful and least well known of his siblings, should be under attack. He finds he can trust few people, himself included, until he can become not only more socially and politically aware but also more honest with himself. He can't understand why he is a target until he begins to understand how his family and his class manage their society, and in fact, until his sister, head of another powerful media company, is killed. Her instructions on his inheritance and information about his parents and other sibling help Daryn to unravel threats to both friends and foes in order to chart his own course through a moral minefield. While avoiding standard contemporary political positions (anarchy, capitalism, democracy, oligarchy, socialism), Modesitt explores the personal/political relation ship and emphasizes each individual's complicity in rights and wrongs to create a truly manue story about adults ,vith adult problems. He also extrapolates the sort of society that results from near-future technological and scientific advances, 'v;thout neglecting the human story in the effort to explain the science.


While this book falls outside his several series works (Recluse, Spe/Lrong C;Ycle, Graviry Dreams), it is one of his best to date. FICTION REVIEW "HE CO,. .. ,e Hatthew Wolf-Heyer Haldeman,]oe. The Coming. New York: Ace, 2000. 217 pages, cloth, $21.95. ISBN 0-441-00769-4. While falling into the corpus of science fiction novels that rely on first contact with aliens as a central oxganizing theme, Haldeman's The Coming finds its most direct precedents in Fredrick PoW's The Day the Martians Came (1988) and, strangely, Mack Reynolds's After Utopia (1977); The Coming, like Pohl's novel, is not about aliens, but rather about human beings and their imminent contact, whether confrontational or not, with another species. Unlike Pohl's feeble Mar tians, Haldeman's aliens, who insist they are entirely harmless, prove themselves to be far superior to Earthlings, thereby raising the ire of the US government in its fear of a militaristically superior foe. While not a satire of the American government and its militaristic fetishism, The Coming, interestingly, is primarily a political novel, reminiscent of Stanley Kubrick's Dr. Strange/ove, or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb (1969) and Haldeman's other works. Set in 2055, Haldeman's near-future Gainesville, Florida, superficially mirrors our own times, with the notable exception of the national enforcement of anti-sodomy and anti-oral sex laws. The overt implication in the novel i3 that the government, largely portrayed as conservative, has reinstated historical laws to police homosexuality. This, I find, is the most interesting aspect of the novel, continuing Haldeman's evident interest in human sexuality and cultural norms begun in The Forever War (1974) and compounded in much of his other work. Whereas the government and society (at times) is largely indifferent to homosexuality in The I'orever War (when not fully supportive), The Coming makes an interesting counterpoint, quite possibly in response to the homophobia still evident in a post-Stonewall American culture. Whereas human sexuality in The Forever War is given free reign, The Coming reveals Haldeman's libertarian leanings against the government and its policing of human sexuality, reminiscent of Michel Foucault and his condemnation of government and its control of sexuality most evident in his The History of 5 exua/it)', Part One (1978). This is not to say that The Coming acts as polemic, but rather that Haldeman employs the continuing homophobia in American culture as an axis on which the plot of the novel turns. The relationship between husband and wife, Norman and Aurora Bell, the protagonists of the novel, is predicated on the need for Norman to appear heterosexual. When Aurora learns of the government's preparations to move against the aliens and acts against it, she and Norman are blackmailed through his past homosexual, hence illegal, activities by those sympathetic to the government and its anxieties. There is no mention of AIDS or any other factor for the governmental policing of its citizens' sexualities, so the policies forbidding such acts can only be read as the blatantly homophobic act of a conservative, puritanical government. Haldeman, in his condemnation of American politics and, more broadly, American culture, has never been more astute (although Disney World as mecca in Forever Free worked on similar levels and to similar ends). And yet, Haldeman's utopian impulse is intact throughout the novel. It is clearly utopian, but rather than embracing the after-effort narrative of most utopian fictions, Haldeman reveals what needs to be acted against and offers the reader the option for utopia, but only through the reader's efforts. I mention Reynolds'S After Utopia with some reservations: for readers familiar with the novel, Reynolds' deus ex machina offers a wonderful parallel to Haldeman's; for readers unfamiliar \vith After Utopia, it allows me to hint at the ending without divulging the conclusion to the novel in its entirety. The proposals for additional cells, which should be organized around a gen eral theme with far-reaching appli cations. Proposals for new cells should be clearly labeled, sent with cv and/or resume, and abstract for initial paper to be authored by the cell's editor. CONTACT: Large files, such as Flash movies or essays with many large pictures, should be sent on a zip disk or CDR to: Submissions, Reconstruction, 104 East Hall, Bowling Green State UniverSity, Bowling Green, OH 43402. Since we anticipate a number of innovative submissions, we encourage contributors to contact the editors at with any questions. SEND: Please send textual essays as attachments in Word or HTML to: DEADLINE: Submissions are always accepted for consideration. However. to be considered for Fall 200 I. submissions must be received no later than August 1st, 2001. WHAT: "Creator" M/C: A Journal or Media and Culture. TOPIC: Creators do not just 'cre ate' or 'act' they are privileged agents. points of origin. sources of innovation and transformation. Within religious systems. creators can exist in an extra-discursive real beyond nature and culture. func tioning as the origin of the word and being. They can be supernatu ral. existing outside nature to influence earthly events via strange pow ers. They can also be 'supra' natu ral above nature capable of acts that both break and establish laws to which the created


are subject. Yet, these types of cre ators only seem to exist through the cultural economies that allow their representation.Their roles and personas can differ with the pro duction. combination and utilization of selected characterizations: in other words. creators are created. Cultural history shows their con tinual design. The Romantics in vented the author in the form of the creative artist-come-genius who is the originator of unique artistic impulses conceived in accordance with his/her own laws. Such cre ators seem peculiarly modern they are revered sources of the in novation that continually pushes us beyond tradition. creating new value. And when such value is de bated. we can at least. according to some existentialists and liberals. count on the ability of the authen tic individual to have the power to create him or her self. But creators cannot be confined to the spheres of religion and art. In the world of science. improving upon nature is often the preserve of the (mad?) inventor. Scientific creators are capable of epic acts that command the codes of nature in novel ways. even to the extent of mastery and the creation of new life where we have moved from Fran kenstein as a scientist to Franken stein as an ism. The editors of "Creator" invite cul tural interventions interpreting the creator theme from a wide variety of angles.We welcome theoretical. historical and contemporary per spectives. In particular. we encour age contributions that identify the politiCS of creators and their cre ations. after all, is a detective novel. Not necessarily with respect to the nature of the aliens. their intentions (which they make quite clear), or any other trope that might be construed as linked with the motif of first contact narratives, but in that once read, the novel fails to yield the ultimate answer to Haldeman's mystery: The Coming is clearly a mystery of the most wonderful sort, compelling and engrossing. Each chapter is constructed as one of three months, culminating in January and the arrival of the aliens, and is developed through a passing-of-the torch technique where sections are defined by the main character in them (for example, ''Aurora'' or "Norman") and rely on the meeting of the two characters for the shift in narrative focus to occur. Due to Haldeman's masterful narrative skill, The Coming reads cinematically, as a detective novel of sorts. In the purest, most cliche-ridden, sense of the term, The like all of Haldeman's work, is a page-turner. Weaving political insight into a novel of utopian compassion, Haldeman, again, creates a fiction compelling in its realism, its urgency, and its insight. But like the best of political works, Haldeman calls for revolution but relies on us, as readers and as citizens, to enact our own future history. The burden of utopia is on us. FICTION REVIEW 'rHE QUAHrUN ROSE John A.Wass Asaro, Catherine. The Quantum Rose. New York: Tor Books, 2001. 398 pages, cloth, $24.95. ISBN 0-312-89062-1 This novel, the sixth in the author's Skolian empire saga, is quite a bit more than the standard space opera that takes up so much shelf-space in the science fiction section of most bookstores. It is more than the simple blend of romance and hard science that it seems at first glance, and the interested reader may drill down many layers to get to the ultimate truths. Perhaps a little background is in order. The opening scene finds Kamoj Quanta Argali, the young governor of her impoverished province on the planet Balumil, swimming in a local river under the watchful eye of her bodyguard Lyode. Before the setting is even constructed as a medieval society, we are told that Lyode's name is short for light emitting diode and that no one in that society has the faintest idea just what that means. So by page two the reader is confronted with the hypothesis that what was once a high-tech civilization has, in some way, degraded to the primitive. Quite a few surprises await. On the first two pages we meet not only the heroine but the protagonist as well, in the form of a stranger, Havyrl Lionstar. This is a physically immense and apparently very wealthy individual who rents an old palace that previously belonged to Kamoj's family. I t seems that the socialization/ marriage process in this society is viewed as a business merger, not really a great stretch. To assist her poor state out of its economic plight, Kamoj has established a "merger" with Jax lronbridge, the powerful governor of a far more prosperous neighboring province. As with all of the major male characters, J ax has his good and bad features. He is a strong, intelligent leader given to violent bursts of temper. Lionstar, on the other hand, is a quiet, brooding alcoholic whose problems are driven by deep mental angst stemming from a long stay in a small coffin (read the book). To complicate what might have been a very one-dimensional situation, Lionstar observes Kamoj during the above s\vim and proposes a merger by offering a dowry so large that she cannot refuse and lronbridge cannot hope to match. Naturally, the volatile Jax is incensed at the thought of Kamoj, almost betrothed to him at birth, being snatched away at the last minute by a rich stranger. This sets the conflict that drives the story's visible action and provides not only insight into the planet'S culture and ecology, but also sets the stage for the finer drama that plays out in


the minds of the central characters. As to plot movement, suffice it to say that the young bride finds attraction to, then love for, the stranger. Marriage follows abduction by Ironbridge, annulment of the first marriage, and a "forced" second marriage. Intrigue follows action as we learn more of Lionstar's past, his reasons for coming to Balumil, and his eventual recovery of his bride as the lovers are reunited after the requisite chase and defeat of Ironbridge. 1bis novel first appeared as a serialization in Analog from May to August 1999. Far from being another entry in a "franchise universe" series, this novel is an attempt to put a very new spin on a very old technique. While allegories abound in print and have been around since the onset of the written word, this is the first that bases characters and plot on quantum scattering principles. As such, it is intensely puzzling (to the non-physicist) until the author does a bit of ex plainingin the last few pages. Even then it takes a bit of thought to pull the pieces together. It has been said of the author, that she sometimes forgets to let loose of her day job (as a molecular physicist), and this shows in most of her work. What sets this work apart from her other novels, as well as any other entries in the space opera genre, is an intense interest in illustrating some prin ciples of quantum mechanics through the vagaries of human behavior, brilliantly scripted as a very entertaining tale of love and action. Not quite a futuristic Casablanca em fact containing many elements of the 1965 Charleton Heston movie The Warlord) with tortured hero, exotic setting, and evil protagonists, this story features a fractured hero and an antagonist with several admirable features. As such it evades easy categorization in a nice, compact sub-genre. Devoid of humor, devices such as gender reversal (as in an earlier novel, The Last Hawk) and mega space battles, the book relies on pace, intelligent use of characters, tension, and above all mental pain inflicted over physical discomfort to drive the plot. There are few wasted words and every thought and action places another piece of the puzzle. This work can easily be viewed as a very fresh look at an old idea, with an added twist. While realizing that the romance novel with flawed hero and not-quite evil antagonist is not new, and layering the plot in a science-fiction scenario quite old, the author has achieved a convincing blend. The mixture consists of irony (a technologically backward society with links to advanced science), allegory (hwnans and human interaction viewed as quantum theory), and romance described in a way that is both fascinating to the reader and intriguing to the scholar. The author is adept at not only style and characterization, but plotting as well. The elegance of her style is the very sparseness by which detailed backgrounds are constructed and profound emotions are expressed. The reader is given a base upon which to fill in some details but only those details the story allows within certain bounds. 1bis type of construction lends itself to interpretation on many levels and, therefore, is suitable for the more adventurous analyst. uggested topics include (but are by no means limited to): religion in contemporary culture. New Age Gods within. Creationism vs. evo lutionism. etc; the authority and property rights of creators. includ ing intellectual property in an in formation age. the artist as star and cultural leader or prophet; the eco nomics of creation: the aura of the creator and the construction of brand value (from fashion design ers to star authors). the patenting of inventions and information (in cluding biosciences). the new me dia authors and the creative (gift and commercial) economies of the Internet, freeware. the mp3 saga. code poaching. etc; distinctions be tween the creative artist, perfor mance artist and artisan. creator and producer. originals and copies. authentic and artificial; reconstruc tions of creators (especially Gods. biographies or The Biography of God. making of documentaries); individual creators and communal creation (e.g. directors as creators of films. community art, anonymous art. festivals. carnivals. galleries); myths of self-creation and social construction (from entrepreneurs to criminals. baptism to reborn agains); and minority creators. countercultural creators. gendered creators. CONTACT: Guy Redden or Jason Ensor SEND: Please email enquiries. ab stracts and 1-2.000 word articles in MLA style. DEADLINE: 16 July 200 I.


Scjence Fjdjon Research Assocja.jon www.s' cnmingboolprinl5newsabootSFRAintanal fantasyliterarureandIilrn.Foundedinl970,theSFRAwasOrganizediS0im rove affiUrs,callsforpapers,updaresonwoIksinprogress,andanannuaiindex. dassroom and to evaluare and .. newOOol. Fora membership applicuion, mntIC(theSFRA T rcasurcrorseethewebsite. SFRA Benefits Extrapolation. Four issues per year. The oldest scholarly journal in the field, with critical, historical, and bibliographical articles, book reviews, letters, occasional special topic issues, and an annual index. Science-Fiction Studies. Three issues per year. This scholarly journal includes critical, historical, and bibliographical articles, review articles, reviews, notcs, letters, international coverage, and an annual index. SFRA Annual Directory. One issue per year. Members' names, addresses, phone, e-mail addresses, and special interests. SFRA &view Six issues per year. This newsletter/journal includes extensive book reviews ofboth nonfiaion and fiaion, review anides, listing; of new and furth-The New York Review a/Science Fiction. Discounted subscription rate for SFRA members. Twelve issues per year. Reviews and features. Add to dues: $26 domestic; $35 domestic first class; $28 domestic institutional; $29Caw:1a; $37 = SFRA Listseru The SFRA Lisrserv allows users with e-mail accounts to post e-mails to all subscribers of the listserv, round-robin style. It is used by SFRA members to discuss topics and news of interest to the SF community. To sign on to the listserv or to obtain further information, contact the list manager, Len Hatfield, at> or . He will subscribe you. An e-mail sent automatically to new subscribers gives more information about the list. President SFRA Execu.jve Commj ee Secretary Michael M. Levy Department of English Universiry ofWisconsin-Srout Menomonie, WI 54751> Vice President Wendy Bousfield Peter Brigg Reference Department, Bird Library #120 Budgell Terrace Syracuse Universiry Toronto, Ontario M651 B4, Canada Syracuse NY, 13244-2010 Treasurer David Mead Arts and Humanities Texas A&M Univ.-Corpus Cristi 6300 Ocean Drive Corpus Crist, TX 78412 Immediate Past President Alan Elms Psychology Department U of California-Davis Davis, CA95616-8686 181 PRESORTED STANDARD U.S. POSTAGE PAID TEMPE, ARIZONA PERMIT NO. 45 Shelley Rodrigo Blanchard (,842 S. 40th Place Phoenl.'t, i\Z 85281 2S2

xml version 1.0 encoding UTF-8 standalone no
record xmlns http:www.loc.govMARC21slim xmlns:xsi http:www.w3.org2001XMLSchema-instance xsi:schemaLocation http:www.loc.govstandardsmarcxmlschemaMARC21slim.xsd
leader nam a22 u 4500
controlfield tag 008 c19929999oru 000 0 eng d
datafield ind1 8 ind2 024
subfield code a S67-00017-n252-2001-05_06
0 245
SFRA review.
n No. 252 (May/June, 2001)
1 3 246
Science Fiction Research Association review
Eugene, Ore. :
b Science Fiction Research Association
c May/June, 2001
Place of publication varies.
Science fiction
x History and criticism
v Periodicals.
Fantasy fiction
History and criticism.
Science fiction
Book reviews
Fantasy fiction
Book reviews
2 710
Science Fiction Research Association.
t SFRA Review
4 856