USF Libraries
USF Digital Collections

Minimally innate ideas

MISSING IMAGE

Material Information

Title:
Minimally innate ideas
Physical Description:
Book
Language:
English
Creator:
Merritt, Michele
Publisher:
University of South Florida
Place of Publication:
Tampa, Fla.
Publication Date:

Subjects

Subjects / Keywords:
Language acquisition
Representational nativism
Usage-based linguistics
Emergentism
Interactivism
Connectionism
Dissertations, Academic -- Philosophy -- Masters -- USF   ( lcsh )
Genre:
bibliography   ( marcgt )
theses   ( marcgt )
non-fiction   ( marcgt )

Notes

Summary:
ABSTRACT: This project provides a detailed examination and critique of current philosophical, linguistic, and cognitive accounts of first language acquisition. In particular, I focus on the concept of "innate" and how it is embraced, marginally utilized, or abandoned altogether in efforts to describe the way that a child comes to be a competent user of a language. A central question that naturally falls out of this general inquiry is therefore what exactly is supposed to be "innate," according to various theories? Philosophically, the theory of innate ideas put forth to explain human learning has existed for centuries and hence, this thesis as it relates to language is discussed. The revival of nativism by linguists like Chomsky is thus a central theme of the first chapter. Universal Grammar and the various arguments for it are closely scrutinized, and I close this chapter with what I take to be the commitments of linguistic nativism, how its proponents conceive of "innate," andseveral possible objections to the arguments they put forth. Just as the theory of innate ideas has had its contesters throughout the history of philosophy, so too have linguists and cognitive scientists rejected Universal Grammar and other forms of linguistic nativism. Thus, the second chapter presents several of these alternative explanations of language acquisition. Namely, I divide the chapter into three sections, Usage-Based Linguistics, Emergentism, and Sociolinguistic Acquisition, as it is my suggestion that most of the anti-UG attacks are levied from one of these three fields. In discussing the details of each, two distinctions become of particular concern: first, a large part of the differing conceptions of "innate" seem to hinge on what is meant by "learning" and "acquiring," and therefore second, a fine line between UBL and Emergentism can be drawn, a relationship that is otherwise conflated in the literature. Because chapter two involves a brief account of the way in whichconnectionist simulations are often utilized to model or represent language acquisition, particularly from an Emergentist perspective, chapter three begins by examining this feature of Emergentism in more detail. Due to its explanatory power, ability to be effectively modeled, and the evidentiary support found in neuroscience, Emergentism would appear to be the most tenable position to maintain regarding language acquisition. This possibility seems further strengthened when we take into account the neuroscientific data often used to bolster anti-nativist claims. Nevertheless, reflecting on the overarching concern of the project, regarding what is really meant by "innate," it is shown that this attack on nativism might stand on shakier ground than was originally assumed. Finally, based on these considerations, a case is made for an intermediary position, a theory of "Minimally Innate Ideas."
Thesis:
Thesis (M.A.)--University of South Florida, 2007.
Bibliography:
Includes bibliographical references.
System Details:
System requirements: World Wide Web browser and PDF reader.
System Details:
Mode of access: World Wide Web.
Statement of Responsibility:
by Michele Merritt.
General Note:
Title from PDF of title page.
General Note:
Document formatted into pages; contains 105 pages.

Record Information

Source Institution:
University of South Florida Library
Holding Location:
University of South Florida
Rights Management:
All applicable rights reserved by the source institution and holding location.
Resource Identifier:
aleph - 001914881
oclc - 179673909
usfldc doi - E14-SFE0001993
usfldc handle - e14.1993
System ID:
SFS0026311:00001


This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text

PAGE 1

nr nn nrrrnnnn nnrn rnrnr nnr nrr rnn rr!"r#$%% n&$%% '($%% n! )*$+**, -.r!rn$rnn nr$r/rrnr$ nr$nnr$nr 0n+**,$nn

PAGE 2

n r

PAGE 3

#.nr! rn#nn$n$ n$%"r#$ nnr$%(%& %&# rnr$'nr$r$r$ nr% &#rnnrrrrnn rnnn%n nnnnnn#nr nrn rr$nrnrnrrnr % nr!rn rn nnrrn%"nnn $rnn rrnnnnnrnnr% n.nn%

PAGE 4

&nnr rnnnn)n)!1nrr23)%)45rnrn3)%+nr2)*)%+%)rn)))%+%+rnrr( )+ )%+%6nnnr)6)%+%7rnnnrrr n r)7 )%+%3(rnrr)3)%+%8n)8)%+%,(nnr)9)%6::2$:: n2); )%7r+7)%3r!23,+%7%7Dnnn!""A3 ; n6!:nr$nr1 nr 6%)nn8)6%+1r$1r$1n.#r8+6%6n'!:n(rn 88 6%6%)r886%6%+">8;

PAGE 5

6%6%6('nr,)6%6%7rnnrn,76%6%3nnrnnr,86%7nr:nr!&..rr nrnA,,6%3"n..nnrrA9*6%3%)nnrrnrn 9+ 6%3%+rn=Dn936%3%6">nnnr996%8r!=nrC( rnE 1nr;7=r;8

PAGE 6

nr nn 4&=& &r nrn'n nnr$ rn$nnrrn rn%n$r nn?n@.nr$ nD$ nnnrnrn.nn rnnnr %nrnnnnr nnrrn 'nrrrn?n$@n rnrAr$ nnnrnnn' r'rnnr $nrnrrrnnrnr rrr%&nr rnr#r#rnrnnn rnn%r2 nrnrnrrn D$rnrn.n.n n#nnnnrrnnr $.nrnr ?n$@rrr nrnn nrnnn% Frnrnnnrrnr nrnrnnnrn r$rnrnrnr nrnr nr2 nrrnnr%&r$nr nrnrrnr nn'nrrn%1 $nnnn rnr$r/4r(rnr$:nr$ rnrn$rnr rrnnnrnnn/2nn#r nrnr% rrrnnr$n.rnnr n!rn$ nnnr?n@ rn.nrn ?@?$@nr$ n.4( :nr.$nrnnrn .rnnnn%

PAGE 7

4rnn.rnn ..nrn rnrnnDnr nrn$n :nrnrn$nn r'nrn :nrn%nnr'n .$nnn $nnrn r$:nr. nnrnnrnnn rn%&r rrnrrnrnn..n# nnnrnn nrnrnn/nrnr%1n rr$nn n n$.nr n?n$@nrr.nnnr nn#nrnrnr#n .rrr%$ rnrrnr$rr nrn$n ?nr%@

PAGE 8

) nn &n?n@nn r#r rnrn$nn%n '$.nnnn rnnnB <.n.r#. r%) 1nrn
PAGE 9

+ .nnrrrrnr rnn%&rn nnnr./nrnrnnnr rnnnn.nn rnrnnnn$ .$nrnnn #.$rnrn rn$n'rnn'% nr$nnnnnnr% &rrn?nrr@.r n.nn 'rn%$nrnr#nr nrnnnn .nn.rnr%nrn nrnrnn rnn nn#%4rn rnrnnr$ r#nrnnrnrn nn%&rnnnn rnr$rn.rnrnnn rnrnnn n$nrrnrrr$nr nnnrn$nrr nr.rrnn.nn $nrn. nn%$n.n n.% n$rnr$nG?&=nrnr@ !&nn rnnrrrn (!! $nrrnnn'rn rn'r$# ..nnrn rn$rnn$' % (#n:rnr! &r $rn #.rn'%"n nrrnr nrnn'rnn'$#. n$ $rn (!! r% 1/1nrnr! nrnnrnrr nr n%nr ?.@nn nnnrnn$n n%:' ?rnr.nr@nr % &?1."@:rnr! 1rrnrnnn 'rn?nr@n nnr

PAGE 10

6 r%4rrrnr. nnn '$nrnn rnrnnrn rrnrrnnn% rrrrnn ?n$@...nnn nn/r$ ..#$nnnnr nrn .nnn% &rrn.rn nr$ n.$nrrr .n$rrn.rn# nnr rnrnr.%rn$nn 'nnnn.nnr nnnrrnn .rnrn nrnrn#$r%r.r $rnnn/ nrnrn..rnr$n'rn nnnrnnnrn/ nrnnr%&r$nrn. !" ) n.r$ nrnnr I1J1K$rnrrn nn$rnD n$r.rnnrD nn$nn $rnn

PAGE 11

7 rnnnr $nrnrnrrnn$n n rrn nr ''rA$r nrrnrr nnnrnn nn nrnrArn nnr rnr$rr.nnn rnrnn 'rrrnn$n rnrnrn$ .nnrrnrnnr rnrnr$r n% nrnrnrr$.# nrnr.nn r.nrnnrr .r%rnn nr..$n' nnr 'nnLn/nn%n. rnnn .nrnr.#nr2 $rnnr$ nr$.nn)K(r n$+K(rn$ 6K(rnn$rn%" nrrnnnrnnn$ nrnnn#$n%.n .r$.n#nn .nnrnrn.B
PAGE 12

3 n)!1nrr2 +,+-!&#!. !(! 4.$n.nnr.r nnrnn Br#%<5rnr$nrnn $#%nr nnrr$nr nnr rnr#nr rrnrrnr r.$$nn'n#n 2rn?rnn$ .rnnnnrn rnrnr .rn%@7"nrnnr2 rnn ?rnr@n$nn r.nnnrr r.nn#%$nn nr?n@ nrrn#.rr nnr rrn$rrr rrr% rnnnrr#<2nI+**3K% (1!"!! $%)))%3);3,

PAGE 13

8 #$n%&rrr nr$n rn.n?nr@ rnn rn$nnnn%nrnn.n nnnnnn$ rnr/rrnnr$n nnr %8 r2.rnnn# r$nnn rrrrn.n.%n$n rrnnnn ?@r$nr?@nr nrrnn.nn ( rnrnn #.$n'n rnnr2r.% r#$nrrnn#$n rnn !&& r$nnn !!!! nrn r%rrrnnnr$ r r $, rnnnn rrrnGnnr $n rrnBn
PAGE 14

, rnKnn$9r#rnnnnrnr &22rrnnn'nrGnr nnrrr %&$ nrn&22. nnnnrnr rn#nrrnnn&22 nr.nrrrr% =n$r#r$rrrnr nnrnr%; &rnnnn.nr# nrrn&22rnrn rr#
PAGE 15

9 r#
PAGE 16

; rrn$n.r$ nn$ nrn%"nnrnn nnr2$ .#rn nn?n@r%rn$r nnn.nr$nrnn nrr2 nnrnnnrnnn rnn$ rnnn$nn nn%)+ &r n$.nrn?n n@rnrrrr rnr'nn#. $nrnnnrrnn nrnrnrn# rrnnnr%=n$n nnrrn.n rrn nn$nrnnr%&r rr.nrnnn r2rnrrnn n.rnr$ nnrnrn #.nr$ nnn$nrnrr % nrnnrnBr.nr< nn'rnnrn nrnnrnrn$# Dn$nn nrn#nr$n nB$n.n nnrnrn'r n%

PAGE 17

)* 2$n.rrnn n'n.nnrr nrnn % +,6"&$ &n$rnn nr.r nnr nn2
PAGE 18

)) $$rr$.r#n .nr#. %rr$rn$?rr nn$n nr'n$.nn nnr nrnnQ@)8 nnrrn n$n?.'r$@), rrnrnr#r#
PAGE 19

)+ ()%rnrnB 2<)9rnnr$nr nnnrrnrn 'rnn nnnrnI(Kr nnrn n%nrnn.()(+rr %n$n nn#r$nr? @.rr. .nn%&rrnrnnn ..n()r?@ n%rnr#2
PAGE 20

)6 +,6,94&r! rnrnnnrn 2rnrnnnnn n.n.nnrn.#r r%&?nn nr@I>Knnnr! )%K&nrnnn nrnnrnrr rrnnn'n rnnr% +%KRn$nnnrn nrrr$ nr.nnnn n# 6%K&r$nr?rnn.n nnn'rrrn (rnnnnr# nn nnrr.rrnn r%@); &$nnrnn..n nrrrn rrrn%I4r.nnn $nrrr$nr. rrrn.n%K &.nr>nr.nn %rn$.nn'n rnnrnr.n'rn ! ( rnnnr n$nrnnnn r$rnn nnr#$rr 'rnnr% nr.$rrr ( $nn$n nn$nrrrnnr r)9/nr$ .nnnnrnrnnr nn..r%+* $nn & : nnr.%Rr nnrnn $.nrrr$nnrn nnnrnn rn%+)rn$ nnn ": $nnnrnnrrnnnnn ); 1""! $)*+/66%+*n.rnnrn nr%+)%&rI+**+K%

PAGE 21

)7 ; :, 5.$nnrnnnn DnnP.n'n nr#B$nnnrrnr n#r.r nnrrrn.nrn rr%&r ++r$+;

PAGE 22

)3 .$nnnrrn r$n nnr..#.% nrr#
PAGE 23

)8 DrnnrPrnnr$ rnr# ." nnn%:r#nrn & nnr rnr$nn nr$nnnrn$ nr#rnn% "r#Dn rrrnn.$n nrrnnn nrnr%rn $#rnrn# rrnnrnnn n (! $r nnr$ (! $nn.nrn .nnrn$ rnnn.$S nrrrrnnnn nnrnn .n.Gn $nn$n rn$%+,6,="&">r2$rr# rnrn%4r$ nnr!&nnnrr $nr$rnn ?nn@.nnr Gnnr nnnnn$nn n$rn%$n? @.#rrn nrnnnn$n rnnn nnnrn%>r$ nrnrrrn rnnrnnrnr $$nnnr? %@nnn2nrnnnr rn $nnr.r nn.rrr

PAGE 24

), nr$nr#nr$n rnn 'rnr%&rrnrr nnnn nn2%rrnrn$ r#.rrr nn.$.nrn% :nr?@ 'nrnnr#4n 2$rn );3*r$?r#rnr.Dr.n .r%@+8 :r rrnr $nrnrnnn rn/%nr. nnr#nr n'rnnrn' n2%$ rnnn.rnnr$r rr$n n$n..n.nnr %+,1nrr$. rrnrr .nnrrrn$n nnnnrrnn n%n rnrr$ nr2r$nnr nr.nnrn n.n%+,6,>1"" r#$ 1""! 6?n#nrn rrrnrn/nrn nrn.r#% nrnrnn n.nnrr$nrn +8r$67+, 88(!+77+9);;7

PAGE 25

)9 rrnn#n $.$r.nn$rn rnrnrnnrn rnrnr rn$.rnnrnnn nn$ nnn.nrnrn .nrn% &rn.rn2# );;*$+;n #,6)r$);;;

PAGE 26

); rnn$. rrn %r.$rnn$B. n$<# nnr$rrnn r.nrnr n.nnr#r$nrn nnnrn .%r r.nn$n$r #r$rn n% +,9(!! &$(!! &$ &nrr2n rrnn rn$nrnnnn%>n $'nrn nnrrnrr% n$nrnnnn >n2rr%' $'nn (D$"'$I("Kn#rrr.nn .nnrrnr rnn'nrn nr%rn$nnnn rnnnnn n$ nn)9/nnr nrnnB< rrnrnnnrnnrnnrn % nrn$nr.rnn nrr. nnrnn%nD nr$r n.rr. nnrnnnnnnr rnr%&rnnr. $'$ A1:B;-, nnrn r$nrn#'nnnn. rnr n $nrrnnn Dnn$nnn

PAGE 27

+* %I&r.nn$. rnn$rnK &.n.nr.nnnrnr$ n%4n r.'rnnnr'n nrnrnr%& nn.rrr rB ':, ) &rn n#$B ':, .) <(#nr.nrr. nn nnnnnr.n #nnnnrn rnrnr%6+ &rnr.r.r!nn n.rn .r$nrn#nn Inrr$nnnK% nnrnr$.$.nnnnn B$
PAGE 28

+) rrn$nnrDnn1rr rnnrn rnnn%66 nn.n n.rrr nr$n nrr rnnrrnn rrn%&rI+**7K$'$ rnn r D.?nrrn.n nnrrn 'rrr%@5r#nrr. r.n#$.n rnn$rnn $nrn rr$ # %nrr$ n n rnnnr$nr nnrn'$nn$ rnnnn'nnrn n% (D"'n7T66n,;+rr$( D"'$)3;%

PAGE 29

++ nnrrnn.n nnrnr %n&r$nnn r.nrn r nrnn'nn r $n nr.rnnr%n(D$nr n$.$?nr rnnnDn #nrnr nnnrn%@63 &rr(D"'nn nnnrn nnnrnnn rn#.nn r nnrnr.nn n#nrnr n% (D$2n$2nI+**6$n(22 Kr 'nnr.nn .rnrrn'rn rnnrrn$ -$'$n rrnrr$ r$.n r#nnnn%68&rnn?rr rrrrr.nn%@6,&.rnr'nr. n$nr$nn nr%4nnnn 1rnI);;+Kn.##n rrrnr. rnnnr%"1r.nr .nnn#.r? $@n'nr#. rnrrrn'$r .nrr$(22 nnn -rnrnrr rrn' nrr% nr.rn.n r 63(D"'$)8*68r#$);9)%6,(D$2n$2n$)37%

PAGE 30

+6 InKn'nrnr#nnn .nnrnr% nrnnrnnrnn rnn-$(22. nnrnrr.r nr. r#nnnnrn nn'n%n/n rnn$-r#rr rn'rnrn$ nnn1r% n'nr.$(22nnr nr n rrnnnrn $.nr nnnnnrrn. r'n .$rr/rn% rrn(22$:%2I+**7K rnnnr 5nrrrrG #nr#:.$ .rnn.nrn: r$.rnrn.n 1 n$($..rrrn nrrnnnrn nnr'rrnn .rn.1r%69r$rnr nn.rnrrn nnn$nrrn %?&nr$.nr. n !! r nr$nr n "!! In nnnrnrnrn K!rnnr nnn%@6;2nrnnnrn. rn' rnrrn$rn rGr$r 'nrnrn$nrn nr2n (22% 692$,9%n.r#$);;3$:rr #I+**3K%6;$9+

PAGE 31

+7 1n$(D2nI+**7$(2Krn 2n$rnrrnn nDrnnrn nr%&rrn#r> nrrnnn rn$nrrrn nnrnrn$r n/nIK$n r#Bnrr$
PAGE 32

+3 r.nnnr.r$n .rr rn%nnrnnnnnn nrr$7+r rnrrn r'n rnn%5rrr#
PAGE 33

+8 nrnrrrnnnrn nr$nnrnrn nnnr#r
PAGE 34

+, nn.rnn n%1n$ 'n..nnn rnrr$n nnrrrnnnr n'nnrI/rrnn r#rnrnnr. nBrn% 73rnnnnrr nrrnrn$n rnrrn n rrrI2$'K%n rr.nrr.$n r nr.n#nrrrnr nnrnrnn%

PAGE 35

+9 n$>.rnnnnrn 'rnnr r.n'rnnn n%$rr#n '$nnnnr'rn rn.r.n rrnrnnn nr$nn.rnnn 'nrrnrnn>.rr nnrn nnn%nrrr$r
PAGE 36

+; #rnnn.n n ( rn$rrn nrr.nn%$ nrnnnrr rnnnrnr. rrnnn%"nn nrn'$n$rnn /.rrn%n r#$nnrnnnr nnn$nr $nnrrnnnnr .nrnnF1:: nr%rn$rr rr$nnr rnnrnnnrr nn$$n rr%&nr$.n nr$nrnn nn.nnrnnn#r %&r$nrnnnnn/ nrnrnrrnn nnnrnrn$r rnnrnnrrr nnrrn%>r$r nr$.rn'rn nr nrnn.nn .nnn$r' rrrnn$ n.rrnrnn r rn.n.r#. nr.nn/ nr#nnrn n%1nrr$nn/nrnnrr#n rnnrrr rn.r#rnnnrn rnnrn%4n$n nB
PAGE 37

6* nr'nn.rrn rr$nrn nrn.nrn/nrn nnr% >n.r..n n?n@rr nrnrnr.rnn rnrrn%&nn nnrnnnrrnn nrnnn?n$@rnr n/nrnr$rn r! )%rnrnnn$$r nnn nnnrnrnnnr# % +%nrrn%nr r$nrn nnn nrrnnrr n'nnn$.#nn nnrrn$ nrnr$nr n?n@rn rnnrr$nn nrnr./$ nrnrnnr?n @nr%

PAGE 38

6) n+!nn&r(r n 6,+ !rnnn.2(Dnr rrnrnn rrnr$nrnn rnnnrnnrr$ n$nr2%&r n rn'nrn n2n278nnn#2rnnr$r rn rnnnnnrnn n.n.nn r%'$r4r(rnr #&rI);;+Kn# rr.nrnrnnr2 rnnr$rr nnrnr%rn$n$ nrrrr nnrnnrrnrrn nr n#rnrnr%nrnrn'r $.n rr'nn$. .rnn ?rnn@r'r%>nr rnnrrDn nrnrn
PAGE 39

6+ n$.nnrnn? n@r$nn ?n@#.$nr2r rnn ( %n$nr) %K.nrnrnr .nr?@?$@+%K n.n'nn#. rn?n@$6%Kn.n rnnrn 2Arnnrrnrn$ r#nnn nnrnn2n $nrnnr rrnn%6,6 %!!! !0F rnrnnnn#2rn nnnrn ?@nn$rn n'n nnrnnr$rr rrnnr$n 'rrr$n'nrr%r/r r$&rr$ n$nrnnnnn nI);9;K$2 I);;,K$nI+**)K$r#r rnnr%3)&rrr r/4rrrn
PAGE 40

66 n.nr'r$.n Dnrn nnrnnr %@3+ nnr/4r(rnrI4(Krn nnrnnrn r%=nn.nrnn$r nn$rnn rnnr$4(.rnnrr. nnrr$.n rnDnrrnrn nnrnn%"n nnrrn *!: $nrrnnnr rnnrrD$ nnrnn ?r$@nn%r& rnrn! r/rr$nnrrr$ rnr$rnnr$ nr$rnnr rrrnrGnr n'rnnrnr#rn %N+**6$)**O "rn#4(rrrn nn 2n(rnr$nnnn..n ( rn% nr#rrnnnnr rrrr$nr rrn2n(rnr$n.2 rnnn$rr rnr rr$.nr.nrnn rr$r.nn.r n%r$4( rnnnr'rnn rnnnrn Drnnn Dnnr$.n .r?/#@rnnr%&r nnrDnrn nnnnr'rrnnn r$nnrr rnnrr%nrnn$4(.r rnr !, 3+$;9%

PAGE 41

67 (#.r$.rnn.2rnnn rn ( nn : nnn$4($ nrrrrr%&r.n?n rnrrnr ( n#r$@36nn'r$n$ nnnrn rnnnr%&nnDn4( rnn.n rnrrn%4r4( rn.nnn nr $nnrnrnnnnnr n Dr'r$nrr rnrnr. nnr$r%nn n$.$r n$n$rn' nr%&r$rrn nn(n:' rnI5(:K$37rn rnrnrnr$rnrn r$nrr$nr rn%5(:r.rn.# rr$rn rrnrnrrn rn$rrnr &r
PAGE 42

63 rnn?@n n$nrrnnrnn n.nr.'nn n.r4(.n #n.'nrn n$nnnrr nrrrr#.rn r% 6,6,+$-13 %!!!1!")nnrn$nnr?rn@? @r nrn4(%r nrnnn.n n.nn.nrn4(n n%.'r! ?n2nrnnnr #r rnnnrn Dnrnn nrnnrrn@N(#$ +**+O%38 ?Hnnrnnnr /r$ nrn1&H:(R@Nn$ +**)O% ?&rrnnrnD nnrnnnr$ nrnnnrnnn rnnnrn @Nn$+**)O%3, ?&rn.. rn#.rnn nn/nnrrn nrnrn rnnrnrnnn@N&r$+**6O%39 $nrnnnnrr nrrr$r nrrrnnr?rn@? @nrnn nr4(%r#.$n nn$. nnn.nrrnnrr rr$n#r 384.$n%I+**+K$6%3,4n39$nn
PAGE 43

68 %:r.rnrnn $(#$.rr 4( !!!5 nn/rrnnr$ nn./ rnr$ rA!!! !") .rn n rnnr.nr$nn#.rnr #rnrnrnn nrnn%$r#n nnnn.rnnr .nnrnrrn n#nnnr% 1nrr$r:rr$4($?n r.r$r rn'rn$nn n$@3;.rn nn.rn/rn% nnnnnnrn $.nrn. .nnrr$.nrn $4(nr nr$.'.n. nrn%r rrr$nrrnnn# n.nrnnrn rrnn %(#nr.nn nrnnr$nrnrnn $nrn nr ?r@rnrnnnr%> r$nrrnrn &r
PAGE 44

6, rnrrr%n nn$.n rr.4(nDr nr?((n%@ .n:rnrnn$.rnn4( rnn?r$@ .nn#?=rnnrnr$@ #n$../ rrnnr%nrrnnrr r.nn$nrr4( .rnr.rn% 6,6,6A1!"1! %!!!& nnn n$n 4($rnn.'r% 5.$n'rnrrn rnnr#rnnn ''rrr#n $rr nrnn:r $9*TnH>
PAGE 45

69 4rrr.nrnrrn rn4($.nnnn nnnnnnr$4(rnr?rnnr$ @rrnn ?rnnrnrn( rn%@86nr rn$rn#n4(n nrrn$rr n%>nnnrrnrn r.n4(/nnrr "! %&r$$rrn#% 8+nrnrrnnB
PAGE 46

6; & nnrnrnn rrn Gnnnnn %r.r nrnnr rrn $nnnrn rnrnr rrr%>rr# nnn nr$87.r.nnn.rn. r rnn%$nrn r
PAGE 47

7* nn$nrn nr$nnn'nr n%'$nrnnr nrrnrn$88 rnrn n$nr?n%@ :nnnnr rnrI:K8,nrr rnnnnrnn.nBrn nrnnnrn<89rn nn nrnn%>n .$?nrrn rnn$n %nrnnnnr n.nrnr rrr.rnnr.nn r%@8;&r$.nrnn rrnnr nn$r#n nrrnrrn$.$ rn2 nn rnnnrn$rrnn nnrn%nrn .n.nn 'rrnr:% 4rnnnn:nrn nnnr$ nrrnnr$rr .$n#nrnnr n.nnnrn4(% nnnn:nrrn nnr n.n/n?n @n/n.n .r%1r rrrnnn nnn'$.$r:nr n$rrnrnnrDnn 88%nWnnDI+**+K>I+***K8,F#I+**)K89&rrn>$nI+**)Kn nrrnrn$nr.' n.rn$n#?rnnr@ ?nnr@rnnnn r .nrnrnL %8;>$nI+**)K$7%

PAGE 48

7) nrr#nnrn nnrn%,* :nrnrnn$nnn nnnDnn GnrrrnnnnrDn r?n@nnnn n%n$nnnn ?n@n rr..rr# r=I);;7K. r.nnnr"#
PAGE 49

7+ 6,9,+"!<$"*-1!"! G'!") &nnrnnrrrn n:nrrn nr4(%n$n rBr/
PAGE 50

76 rnrnn$nnnn .$.nrn rrrrnnD'rnn r%:nrnrn. rBn .:r$rrnrnn ?'nrnrnnn r% n'nn nnrrnnn rnrn%@,7$4#&I);;3Krn .nnrI:nrKrn rnn%?&nr$nrnrn 'nrnn IrnK$nnnDn rnn %@,3 6%K 1!"!! $!3 "nrnn.n rnrn4($nrnrn rrnnnr n?r$@nn 4(nn%,8$n rnrr#( :.nnr nnnrr $r nnnrnrn r%nrrrn.n n:nrnrnnnr nrrG.$r rnrn'rn$:nrrn $rnrrnnr nrnrrr%rn $:nrnr'. rrrnnG rnrr$ ,7:r$87+%,33,$nrr%rH2#I);9+K$. rnnrrrnn nrnrnrrn .rnnnrrnnn%,8%%rI+**3K$2I);;3K$n

PAGE 51

77 rnrnrnnrnr %,,&rrnr nr$nn$n nnrrr$n r$nn$nrnnr n% &rD$:nrrnnn nrrr.n nnr$rnrrr$ nnnn.% 4($nn$rrrrn n 'rn' rrrI"$);;9$: n$);;8K$nn ,,I);96K

PAGE 52

73 n .rnrnI$);;*K$ nrI:r$);;9K% nr$nnrnn n (! n. nn#r%&'rrn $nr nnnrnr$nnn r#rnnr nnr%&n' n$nnrnn% 4rnnrnn %2(.nI);,;K nnrn nnr%&# '$n?rrn%#nr/nrn nrr:rI);;9K$. rnnn?r@?r@.. nrr.n n%rnrrnnn.n. rnnn n.%rnrrrnn r$r$nn rn n%&r.rrn nr.nn nrrrn$nn rrnrnrn 5.r%?rn$nB
PAGE 53

78 rrnrnrnnrn rrrr$ nr$r$n%@,9 nnrrnnr :nrnr< nr$n.rnnr rrrrn .$n$nrnnn n.:nrnrr% #rn:nrnrnr nrnrnr$.. rrrnnnnn$nn nnnnnr :nr.nn%>rn.n n?nrr$@nn rrnrrnnr$rn nn$ rrnr% 6,9,91!""!"3'!!r!1 :!") :nrnrrnrnnnr nn $n.rnnnn rrr?n@ #..'rnrnrnnr% n.r$nrn nnDnrn$ nn:nrnr. nrn$nrr rr%>r$r r/4r(rnr$rnrnnnr $rnr n.nn.nr$nn. nnn#.r rn$r$.n##.nn % r.rn$:nrnrr .r rrnnn#nn .nnr n%n#$ 8!:!" $:nrrrn ,9:r$876%

PAGE 54

7, n$.nr$n :
PAGE 55

79 nnrrnnrnr rnr nr%nrn.$rr nrnn:nrrn nrnn%$nnn #$:nrnn$?& rnnn nn rr%@9+&r$nrnn.rnnrnr :nrnrrnnnnn nrrnG n$nrnr.nr$nr rrnrrr !: n$.nnrr $nn%:nrnrnn. nnrnrnrr.nn#rn nnnnnr .rn$rn $nrnr.n ?rnn$@rrnnnnrn rn?n@n rnn%r:nnn$n .nnrnrn./ $nn.nn .rn$n .nrrnn%96Frnr.nr nnrnnrrr r#nn n%n$rnrnr rnnnr rnrnn%& nnnrrnnr r'rnrnnr nnnrr.rnr nrrr#nrr n%&rnn rnrrnn: nrnn2Gnnnr rnrrnnnrrn 'n'r%97 9+$63,%96:$+)%97:r$866

PAGE 56

7; :nnrnn ?n$@n FrnI);;)K$.rn /rnrnnn nnr2r%4r$? nn rr$nr.rrn n.rn%@93 &rrnr.$rnr ..nrnDn nrn2%n.n nrr?n@ ?nn@rn% nn nrrrnnr n$ nnrn$rnrrn n%(#.r$nr r2rnFrn
PAGE 57

3* 8(!3!&:(( !&!! "!! (!?= 3!!! (( !&!: ! (! 3!&!!"&!(!!(! (!":! (! !! "!!" !:H !I &!"!& &" 6,7r !J !J!1"" %!!!n:nrr#rnnnn rnnnr$ .rnnnn rr$nn rrrnnrnn nrr%&rrnnr nnnrrnnn :nrnrG$r :$n:rrrn$nrrn n nnrnnnnnnnnnr nnn%9,rnnr n$rrnrrrnn rnrrn /r/rI(Kn%&r nn4($nr nnnnrD rrnrnrnn rrnnnrrrrn'n%& r$nrn#r nrn$nn rr%nrn$nrrn nDn
PAGE 58

3) nr ( nr#r$nnrr# $rnnr nnr%rn$4(nr .n ( r#r rr !( nnnrnD$ D$ ?%@nr n#nrrnrnn rrn.nnrnn.n nr. %rDnrnn rnr$. r.r!)K5.n.n'nnrr n$.nnnr rnnrrnnA$+K 5.r
PAGE 59

3+ nrnr%rnr.n nrn $nrrrn nnrrrnrn r#n.nnnrn n% nr1.nn
PAGE 60

36 &#n$nnrn/rn% %rnnn rr?rnnr@nn n.nnr% $rI);;*Knrn$n1.2.n r?n#%@&n nrrrn ?$@nr#n rr%;)rnrr rnr$rnnn% 1nrr$nn&#nnr# rnr .rrrrrr .nnr nr%"2nr#nnr# nnn-$nrn nnnnrnn.n rnn$nrn nnnnnrr%( I);;7Knrnnnnr rrnr$.r/ 'rnn$rD nnn.r%n -nr$ nnrnnr$.'n nnnr%;+nrr nnnn'nDn #nrrnnr$. /n/r%( nr! &rnnrrn rnrnnn .nn#n .n#r rr.rrnn.n rnGnn$ nn#. nnrn nrrnnn%&rrQn rnn r#rnnnrnnnr# nn#%nrrrn rrnn.r.nrnn.n .nr. rLrrn.r.#nn %N);;7$,6O ;),)*/));+($I);;7K ( !1"" %!!! 2.$n$:r%

PAGE 61

37 rrr$nnnnnr nnnrn nnnnrr?n#@ $n n$rrrnnn rn.n r n%&nnnnn$ nrnrn.nr n$.rrnr$r rnnr r% 6,7,6 !$ 8 nnnnnnrnr rn.nnnn #$r.n rnnr n%rrrn' nn#.n #rn#r%&rn$nr /n$rrD nn.rrnn %nnrnr ." $..rr#nn
PAGE 62

33 nnnnr nrn'n nrr.%1n nrnrn nn%rnrnn n# rnr%4rnn r#I+***K$)7*%

PAGE 63

38 rnnr
PAGE 64

3, 6,7,9'*1!"!! 2r# #!1!"& 4I+***Kn rnn! (.rrn%" nnnrnnr$n rnnn'n.$ n.nnn rnnr$nn nrn r#r$n/. n%" n.$n/.nn #.nn/ rnnnnnrn%N+*** $33O nnrnrrnn /nrrr./n/ n rnr$n#4nI+**)K$nn rnrrn$r rnrn%& r /rnn..nnr%&$ nn nrDnrr%&nn nnrnr#r nrnnn rnnnnrnnrnrr #r$.n.r $rn nr&I&>K%&> rnrrrn nrnrnr .$nrnrnrrn rnrrn nnn%4rrnn&>$n/ rnr'rn. nnnn%nD $rn$rnnrn nr$nr.n.n n#r
PAGE 65

39 n%;9rnrn$D. rnn rrrnn %&nr. rrnnnnnnD.$ nrnrnnn .rnDrnnrnr nrn.n Drn%n$nn nn.n#
PAGE 66

3; 6,7,7r !!5!&&3) &nrrrn(.rn./% rn$nrr.n rrnrnnrnnr rn%&r$r.r$nr nnn#2n22%nr n.$n nr4(:nrrnnrr% n$4(nr :nrnr#.nnnrn nr%"nnnr r.'n&$nn (nr nrnr'n nnn nnr%n ( nnrnrnr% rn./#. rnrn$Hnr#$nnn nr#rrnrn n.rnnnr Dnn rnnnnrrnrr$n rrn?/Hnr#@ rnnr%Frnrrrr$ #r$nrnn n.rr.$nrr nrnnn nrr.nnr%(r rnn /n$nn$r/ nrrnrn nr$nn$ rn%)*) &rrnn(r rnnn nnr n%=$$ nnr?n@?rr@r nrnnn%rnnrn$ n.nrrnn rnrnrr n(%&rn rr.r?@nr .#n$n )*)(nI+***K$,9/97%

PAGE 67

8* nrnrnn(nrnrrrn nnrrnrn nrnr%&r.rn nrrnnrr$ .nrn%&nnn nnn nrnrn$rr$. rnrrnn r%&$nn.n .rrnrrr%$ .':nrnnr$rn nrnr$n n.nnrnnr nnrnr%> nrnn'..n nrnnr$$r rnnrA

PAGE 68

8) n6!:nr$nr$ 1nr 9,+ !nnrn$n.rrnr#n n. n rnnr$n nrrnnr.#rrr $nnn%1n rr$rnrn nrrnr$nnnr nr rrnn.r n:nrnrn$nrr%rn$ :nrn#rnrn nnnnnnrnn nrr$ #2$.rrnrnnrn# .r.nnr.nn nD$#rrnnn#%" nrrrnnn n:nr$nrn nrnn #.$n$rn rnnr nnr#.nr%$nr rrnrnn:nrn nrnrnr$ n$rnrnrnn%r: I);;8K$=n I);9,K$nrnn$.nrr nr.n rrnnnnn$n rrrrnr .%(rnrnnn$ nnn'.n rnnn?n@rnn Dnnnrr :nrrnnrnrrnn rn.nrnnn nDn?n%@5.$r rrrnnnn

PAGE 69

8+ nrnrn r$r.r rnnr?n@nn rrrr$n nrrrnn$nn. n..nn?n@r rnnnnn$nnrn .#rn%n.r$ .rrnnr$rrn r'$n n$n.nrDBr
PAGE 70

86 rrn.nr$rrr$ rn%)*+nrr rnn.n nnr$r nrnrnnr.$rn nrnn nn%:rn nnnnrrn nnrnrG $nrr.' $n rn$ rnrnr$ rnr$r$r .nrnrnrn#% &r/#nnnrr n$.$rr rr%nnrn.n nnrnrrn 1nr$:nr$rnr nrn$n.n nrrrnrrr.n rnr %nrnr$.n n$/.$rn 'nn$nrnrnr r.nr%&$ rrnr# r$rrnr% r#r$rnrr rnrn nr$nnn nnr.$rn$n nrnnn.%nn .#$rn$n.$ nnrnr#r%&.rn. nr.nnrn nnn !! !!!! nrnrn.r rr$..nr% "nrnn )*+:n$.rrnnnn$r rrnr/n/.n rn.nrrn#rr rn.r%5.$nr r$n.nnnn?n r%@n$:nrr#nnr r n.nrrrnr%

PAGE 71

87 n$rnnn ( rr%'$ rnn*%7nnn. Yr.n)%*$nY .rrnn*%7$n nnn$ nrnn$n n$nnrnn n$'nnrrr .n%nrrr$nn n rnrnnn% nn.#r$.nn?r@rn rrnnnr nr%'$nnn)%* nnn'r nrZ.n*%*n nrr%>nnr.n rn)%**%*' r/#$. nnrrn*%3rnrrn r. r%)*6 4rnnrn.r nrnnrnnn #.$)*7nnr#n.n #. #.n.#%rn./ n.#rrnnn )*6:$3+%n:$n$nr rrr.n.nn.#rn# rnrnnrnr$nn n//nnrrr nnr%)*7n.nrrnrnn.nr rn#.$nrrnnnnn rr nnnrnrnrnn rnn.nnr%

PAGE 72

83 n.nrrnn 1$'$n nr)%*$?%@n.##n r$r/$.nrrnr nrnn.n$rnn nInr 'nnK$nnn.?%@nr .nnnnrr nnnrnnn nnn%&r n.#n$.$nn:'r>= IZ>=Kn%n :n$n.n.#nr nrn.n r?nr$@. nnnrnnr%)*3 &r$nrn.#rn rn'n rnnrn%&rnrn.#r nrnr rrr%nrrn $nrnn nrnn%" n$rn$/. nnrnrrn 'rrnr nrnnnnrnrrn nrnnr%&nn .rnrnn$n rn $nn'rrnr nnrnrrnr $rrrnnrn $nn.n$ $nrnnnrrnrr n% )*3$87$n=rI);;7Krr.nn rnrrrnnr%

PAGE 73

88 9,9Jr!((3"1!"!! 4 9,9,+4"! r% n.rnnnn.n.# nnnZ>= n$rrnnr n#nnr#n rr%&rrrnn.#n nnnnnn rnnr$rr))***)))**)$nrn nnnnrn n.#=n.n .rnrnrrnn nnnn nrn$.nnrrnn rrrnnrn%n :I);;*K$.nrrnnrnnZ>=r .nrnnnr %"nn$nnr nnnnGn$. nnnn$nn.#r nn$. rnnrrnrn nn'nnn%&n.# rnrn.nrnnrnrn n.nnrnn nnnnn%n.r$nn.# nrnn.n'%( nrrrrn$.$'$rn r rnnnnn.#=rn$: I);;*Kn $nrn.n8nr$+* r$8nnr$+*n'n r%nrr$nnr.nr $rnr

PAGE 74

8, rr%)*8"nn.rnrrnnr nr. n$n.rrnrrn .rnn.rnr. %rnn.#.rnn $nrnnn nn.r...% n.rn.n+**rnr n.rnn $nnrr. rnnnrnnnnnn rn%'nrnn r! ""!!" "!n &nr#nn.#.rnnn'nn nnr$# nZ>=rnnn'$n .r'nnnnr$n. rrnnr$rnnn&+$ nr.n n&+r.rnrnrrr n&)nn'nr% :rrrnnn.nn.#n nnnn'n nnnnr.nr$n $.nnn$nn n ( nn%>nrrnnnn .rnn$ r.$rnn.#rrrnn nnr.n. .rr.%nn.r $.$r$r nn.#nn.nn nrnn.%&r$nr $nn.#rnrnnn rnnrn n.rn.n$ rnr#%)*,1nrr$ rnnrnrr r'nrn$ )*8n$n.nr$ rnnr'rr nnnnr%)*,:I);;*K$)9;%

PAGE 75

89 'nnnnr.rrr nnrn%"n n.#n#..nnn.rn .r$n#. rn.r%nnrr rnrnrr rnnnr$rr?rn$@?. $@?$@r% 5.$nrrnrnnr.n .nn nnnn.#%&rr n#%: rnrnnnrn.nnZ>=n $nrr $nn'n$8/ nnn)/nnr%rn$ nrnr#rnn.#$)*9rn'nnrn rn nrrn%4n$r :nrn$?&nnnnr nrInnn nnrKrnn.#n#n nr$rr.n nrnrr%@)*; 9,9,62 :r'rnrnnr. rnr%nr nn.nn $$rr#nr n$nrn?rnn@r rnn..rr )*9rr$$nnrn nnnrr '$nnnnr#.rn%5. $rrnn#rrnn nnnrn%r:r$n .rrnnr.r nnn .$n.rnnn. n ( I.rnK.$ ..rnrnnrrn%)*;$);)%

PAGE 76

8; rnnrrnnDn%))*1nrr$nrnn 'rnnrnn$nnrr rrnrrnr% &rnnrnrr rnnn%)))&r$ nrnnnrnnrnn nr$n.rnn nnn#.r$ rr#.nn 'nrnnrn rnr%5.$ n.#nrnnrnn$ nrnnrnn. nnI/nn.#rrn nrrK$nnrnn rrnnrn%:nnn.#rnr. rrnn$ .n./n/.rnr nn$rrn+; 'nr)6rrr1rHr%> nr.rr +,$6376)/nnr$..rn nn%&rn Dnn.#
PAGE 77

,* n%rnn nn %rnrnn.nnnn#. :rnn#n.$rn I);;7K))6rrn$r rnnn rn%rn rn:#r$% $4.$2%%%$I);;7K '! 4 ",

PAGE 78

,) .nnnn#$.n'rn /.rnInn.#r rnr$nK$.r nnn.rn nnnn%nnn rnrnn'rn B.nnnr
PAGE 79

,+ nnn+*/rrr .n.7*$***)**$*** .r$n$,/)3.rrn %4n.nn r$nrrn$nnrrn)*/)3 ..r%))3 &(rrn( rr?rn nn/n%nr( ).nIn nK$(6n'n..In' nrKn$ r(+r$nn nn.(r)+ n.(r+6%@))8n.rnnrn :(I &"!J!"1"" K$. rrr%&$n&>:(rn .n6*/7* rnr$n6*Tnrrrn r$nrnrn. ))3++)))8$+),)),);;7))9HrnnnDnnrr (%rn$nrrnrrn nrnrrnnnn rrn.rnr%nrr$ Hr rnrrrnnnr n.nr.rn'$n rn.r$nnrnnn 'nr.nr.r%I+)9 (rK

PAGE 80

,6 nnrn$.n+*Tnrn rnn%&r$ )3/),rnrn&>:(..n rr%&r 87%7Tnrrnrn%4r$n rr/ n:rr#nrn%%r r87%3T$.rrrn rr%4rnrrnr$n rnrn nn/:rr% "nrr n.nrnn(nrrnnr?r n'nrr.rn rnn.rrB.r:(/D nnr$r$.nrrr$n /nr$nrrnrnr rnnr#%"nrnn nnrnnn :(rnnrn9*nrn )+*I88%8,TKnn.# rnnrn$n. nrrnnnn n.#rrn:rrnnr nn.r rnrrrrr nn&>:(%'n/r'nrr rnr. nr/$r#$rn$.n /nrn6%3% ));$++*)+*:r$);;9$83)%

PAGE 81

,7 'n/r'nrrnrrn nrrrr rr%9,9,7( %!!! =nI);98K.nrnnr nnrn n.rrnr n.rn $nnrrnrr n%rnn rnrnnnrr rrrnrrr$r rr$.nrnr nn.rrI/$/$/ r$nKnnrnnr$r$ nr$rn%r nrnrnrnr rnrn .nnD$rrn rrP#n rnnr $r$rnrnn rrr ", &rnn=n .r rn?nnrrn@)+).rrnnrn n$.nr#.rn/r %)++n.rr nnnnrnr nnr r%4I);9+Kn nnr rnnrG'$& r$.nrn r.nrInLn$nLnK$ rr&Hrrr $.rrnnr r.n )+));98$++8/6*rnn%)+++7*/+7)

PAGE 82

,3 r%&r$=n$n nr#.rnrnr rn-D rrnrrrnn nn$+n nnrnnr%&r$nr nrrnn nrrnn nnnnr rr%&rrnrrnnnn nnr .nnnn:rrnn nnrnn.n rrrnr.r r%N);98$+86O >r$n.nrrrrr $rr % n %: $nn (G rnr%& rnnnnr#r r$nnnnnnr nrnr%)+61nrr$n.nn/n/ 'n$nnnrn rn.r .nr% )+6+83

PAGE 83

,8 =n$r "nrn$.r# n?rn@nn.n.n$n.n n#?rn@nr )+7#$);99%)+3:rI);;9K$83+

PAGE 84

,, nn?@nnrrnr$ n n$nr n nrnnr%)+8rrrnr$rnnrn$r rn nnnrnnrn' r$rnnrn rr#.nn%nrnrnrrrrnrn nnn. rnnrnnr%"I); ;,Kn.#nn rnnrnnnrrr r%"rn.n rnrr "!(( nrr$rrnn nr$.nnr
PAGE 85

,9 rnnnr nnnrnrr rnnr%r2I);;3Knr nnrn$.nnr n(rnrrI(Knn rI(K%" r#r.r.rr r? @nnrrn.nn rrnr rn$:nrnrrrnnn' rnnrBnrnn$< nnrnnn$r rnrn%"$ rrn:nrn$nnnn'. nnr r%&nrnnr.n rn'r nrrnr nnrnnn nnnnrrrnn.#r :nr%rnrrnr rnrnn$nrrr. nrnrrnr $nnnn rn$'/rnn rn$rnnrn%&r rnnrnnrr. nnrnn nnr%Yn $2nrnn nnrrr$nn .#.%&.$n.nrn nn#rnn nrnrnnrr% rn$nrnnn $nn'n/n/n r$rrn$nn rrnrnrn.# $nrrnnn

PAGE 86

,; 'nnrn rnnr#%)+, $nrnrnrnnn Gn$nrn rrnrnrr rnnnn%)+9 Frnrnrnrnr$n rnnrnrrrn nr?@nr rrnr.nnnn rrnn#.% &$r..n nrnrnnn :nrnrn.rr %rr$. nrnnnrn nrr rn$nnnr.r rnnrrn $nrn.nn rnrnr %>r$nnn rnrnnn rn#nnr% (#.r$nnrnn n rnr$# rI);99K.nn nrnrrnrrrn nr$YnDI);;6K$. rrnrnnnr?nrnrnr r%@&r nrnnn nnn rnn n:nrnr rrnrn rnGnrrn nrn.nnn# nr?n@ rn%nn nnrnrnrnr nnrrnnBrnnrn$< nnrrnnn/' )+,nrrrn(rrn nn$nrnn $nnBn
PAGE 87

9* nrr$nnn rr.rnr% n#nrrrnrnrnnr/ (! (! /nrnr%r:nr rnnn?n@r nnrrnnr$nnrrnn nnrnrnrnr nnnrnnrr n$.:nrnnnnr ..nnrnnnrnnr% n$ (! rnnrnnnrnnrn$rn .:n :nrnr%r.rr.n.r. $nrrnn .n=rnn 1nr%&r$.'nr rnnrn$r# n.'n ?n@rrr'n.n.nn rrnnrn.# nnrnr%9,0!) nrrnrn$nnnn. nnr nrnrnnrnrr/n rnnrrn% "nr$nnnr .n nrnrrn rn$r$ n.$nrnrn nrnn$nn nnrnDn %rnnn$nn ?n@r'nrn$ nnrn$r nrnrn%&n nrn?nrr@r#n

PAGE 88

9) nr$.rnrnn /nrnr/rnr$r nn..!n1nrnrIr#$#$nK! nrnn rnrrnrn% nr ?.@nnn nnrnn$ nn%:' ?rnr.nr@n r% &?1."@:rnrI:$nK! &nrrn rnr.%&rnn rnnr$nn rnnr$nrnnr%4r r nrn$nrrn nnnr rnnrrnnI/n. .n.#r $nnn$K5 .$nnnr rIrKr.nrI rnnrKrnrnn n rnnn% n$nrnrnr rnrrnnn.n nnrnnrrn nrnnr$ nnrnrnn rrr% 4rnrnn.nDnr$ .nn $nrnnn?n @.rrn$ .nrn: rnrrr(#%& nnrnnrn nr%nr. nnnrnnnn $nrn ?rn/@I/.nnrn $.nnr n/.$nK$rnrn ?r@nn rn%nnnrn nrnrr:nrnr nnnrBn< nn%4nnr nDnrnnr.n rnrnnn.nr

PAGE 89

9+ rn%&r!nnrn $nrnnn r$rnn (! $nn/nrn$nn :nrn.nDrnrnrnr rnrn$ rnnrnnrn #nn#% n$rn:nrnLnrnI n:K$n rn$#$nn n=rnn1nr I=1K%&r$.nnrnn ?n@n n.nnnn:r rrn=1$nr nnrn.nn#$r rrn% 9,0,+r( !&! !!! &nrn=1nn:nnn rr rnr.nr r.nn nn%'$r.r nrn$n nnrrrnrnnnr nn$ nnnrnnrr.nn# n.rr nr%&rrnrrrrnnnn rnnnrnnrr rn$n$nn%5.$r=rI);;9Knrn$n rrn=1n !( !&! nrnnrr.n !!! nr%)+; rnrn$?nr@rnn nrnnnr rnnnnrrnr rnnr%$ nrnrr.n.nr# $#$nr )+;rI);;9K$333%

PAGE 90

96 .nnDnrr ?n%@n. rnnrr$nrnn1nrnr nnnnrnnr nnnrnnr%: nnDnr ?n@nrrnnnr nr$)6*n1nrnrrrn nnnrrrnrn rnnrnnn ?nrnr$@nn nnr$?nr@n rnnr%&rnnnn rrnr$nrn$r#n 'nnrnn$.rr nrnnr$n.r nn n?r.nrn%@ &r$?n$@rnr:n$ rnnn .n1nrnr.rnn%rrnrrnnnnnn rnrrnn=1$ ?nrrnrrnnnr nnnr !! %@)6)nr'nrn nnn rrnnn nr nnnrnrnnrnnn nrnr%rn$nr nr#nnnrr r#nrrn%&rn ?nnr@rn/nn nnr#rn rr#nrrn nrn/nr$nr'nr%&rr nn r$.$nn.nnnnrn rr#nnnn nrrr#nrrn%n$nr rnr$nrn nnr'$nnnrrnnr 'nrnr#% rrnn=1rnnrnnr !!! $n$nrrn. )6*:I);;8K$++%)6)rI);;9K$333$rr%

PAGE 91

97 r1nrr#rnnnn=1 rnrrnn.nn n:n%r rr! .n:n1K !!! %I&1Krn#rnnn rnnnnrnrnnr rnrrnr$ nnrrnnnrnnn rnnrrnnrr nrnrrrr%)66>rnr$nn$rnn .rrrrrrnrn rnnr%r$. rnnnrnnrn nnnrrrn nrrnnr$4:(:>(>=' $rnnrr rnrrrrn#rnrnr%)67"nrrnnn rnnrnnrr n&1$nrnrnnn. rnr n>1% &rrn:nrJ&1n J=1$n $nrrnrnnn=1% = n&1r.n nrn%n$n>1rnn (( nrnrr$ )6+rnnrnn:nn n.n.nnn#n rnnrr !! !( rnnr%)66$33;)67nnnr$33;%1nn n.nr=:rnr ( $nrn>(>=$rrnnrr nnn=:rrnr rnnn%

PAGE 92

93 rrrrnrnr%)63&rrr$n nrnrnnn>1n$ &1rn% "nnnrnn#rn:n. r rnn%n nrrnn>1n .&1rr !& n nnrnrnnr !(!5 I=K$$?n#rnrn rnnDn# rnnNrO%@)68> nrrnnn);8,$rr .r=n rnrnnn/nnnn.r rnnrrnnr%"n nnnrnn ( !&! nn'rn$r$ 4:(:$nnnrnn rnnrnrnn%&r$ nnDn$4:(:n n1) $n1+&%rrrnrnnn Dnr? rrnnnr$@ nnnnn$rnn (*( nnr?.@n?r%@)6,nrnnrrrnnn.n% 9,0,6!!"!(8!5!! n$ !(8!5!!8!! $)694nrrn nnnrrnnnnr rnnrnDrnr nnrrr rrnn% r$nrrn.n.nr nrnn nrrn=%&$rr rrnrrn )63%$);9)%)68r$);;9$38*%4n$nnr r=r5n$);8,%)6,$38*$38+)69);;;%

PAGE 93

98 rnnrr?nr@rrrrr $.rrn nnrnnr%5.$r4n n$.#n rrnnnnrn rrnr$nr= rnr.%n rrn.. nnnrnnrr .nnr n%(#.r$nDnrrn Dn$nrrnr. nrn rr%nrrn rnnnrnrn nnnn rnrnnr$rr rn nrnD nrnnr%)6;nnnrD.$ rnn'n .nrr% (#n'n$4n$rn rnn=rr .rrn%nnnn(r nnrnrn rnnr$Dnrnnr$ '$nn nrrrrn.nr/r #%5.$ nnr$rr.nrrn$.n rrn$.nnr$ n$nn/r#nrr nrnnn%r 4nnnn$r#.n n.nrnr n#rrr.nrnnrn n%.rnBn nr$
PAGE 94

9, r$nnr nDnrrn rn%)7* =rr.n..nnnnrr rn=$)7)nn rnn=rnr.nr rrrr%&'r rn%(.$rn $#rrn$ rrnn#n4#
PAGE 95

99 nrn.r.$rn#n n.nn.rnr r#$$n. rnr n%&r$n.rn. '
PAGE 96

9; n%nrrnr nrnnnrrrr ?%@&rnrnnrr nn.$rrrr .rnnnnrnrnr n$?$@.n.n nDn%nrr $r4n nn$..n#nnr n#nrn?%@ &rrrnrr$r nrn%rn$. rrnnrrn .nrrnnr$ nrnnr.nrnrnnr % 4nnnrnnrnn rn'%nn nn?@rnrnnn$n r rnrrnn$rn nnrn%&r$r nr$nrrn n=rnn1nr%n$ ?@rnnrn%: nrn/nrnrnnnrn n?@rn$rr .nnnrnrnn%& nrrrn$. rnnnnrnnrrr n% n
PAGE 97

;* rrn.nrnnrA r&n rrrnnrInn #nnnnK$ nnnnn nrnn=nrnn% >r$r$nDnrn.nn nrr$rnr nnn%$.nrnr nrrnnr n=rnnnrn$rn rnnnnr#rnr rn/rr.n%&n =nrrrnnnrnnr BD
PAGE 98

;) nn.nrDnn.$n rr%: DDr.rrn#nrrn nnnDn.r rnnnr%&nnn rnnrn rnnrn (!!! nnnrrnnrn rnr%.nn nnr$.rnn nnnrrnnrn$nnnn nrnrrrn% 4rrrrr$n.r .!n nn/rrrrnnnr$ nnn' .rnnrnr#n=n rnn rnrnnr$n# nnDnnnr nrnn.nn$.n rrnnr%>nn$r nrrn %&nrrnr nnn/rrn Dnn'r$nr $nrrrn%4n .nn/rr.n nrnnrnDAn#r nrnrr$nr.nr nrnr$r.r .nrnnnr%rn$ 4!! &rrrrnrn Dn?.n.n$@nnnrnrnr nrrrn%)77&r .r!)%K"#/=!nrnrnrnnn 'n#rnr rnrr +%K:&/=)73!nrnnrnn rn rrnrr 6%Kn/=!rnrnIr nKr )77+**+$)78/,%)73&.rnr:'n/& rnn n%

PAGE 99

;+ rnrrr 7%K=/=!:Drrn$rr nrrrn$ rr n$nn/=rnr nr#=/=$ nnrr$n/=.rn =/=%)78 rnrrn .nrr.rnnr r$nr.$.n nrr%.n"#/=.$nrn rn.r$ nnrrnrrnnn/ rrn%rnrn! ?&nrn.nrnnr# rnnnnr .nrnnnrnrnrn n#Q"#/=rn nnnnn&$nr rnrnr nnrrrrnnr$rrn rrr nr.nr@N+**+$)3*O% n.r$.#n&$n n.nrn'n# nrrn$nnnn r$nnrr$n nrnrnrnnrnrn rnnrrnnn rnnr%&#nnr.!&n rnn=nrnn%
PAGE 100

;6 nrn.n/nn"#/ =nrrrrn nnrnnn'r n%"
PAGE 101

;7 rnnr%& rnrrnn ?n@n.n.?rnn %@.n#=$'K%.n $nrrrnn rnn.nr#nr .nrrnnnn nr.n#%>r$n rnrr2. rnnnr'rn nnn.n .n#%n$n #nnnrn r$rr$r/rn%1n rr$nn nnr .n%n#rn.nnn. rrn. nnrnrrn$ .nn.rnr%

PAGE 102

;3 rn$nrrr:$nrr $/nrnr nrnr$rnrr.n rn?n%@.nr nnrnnrnnrn%& !nr.n:n nnrrnn nnr$r .nnnrnrnnnn rnnrnD$ .r$rrrrnr$nnn D$rnrrnnn rnnrn%nnrnnnn rnrrn$rr. nnrnnnr$n rr% $rnn rnnnrnrn rnrr$r. rrn nnr$r.rr$nn nrrnnrn rn.%"nrn nnnn#.n rrnnrnrnnr$nr nn'nrn nn2$4($:nr%&rrn nrnnn n.rrnnn rn$nr$ nnnnrn nrrnn r%4r$nrnnn nnn .r.rn#%

PAGE 103

;8 =r #5%W5n$%I+***K%&nn nnr rr% L&'!"!! +9 $;3/))8% #$%-%I);;3K%&rnrnn r:.% "!!1!"!! = $ )6;/)9)%4.$%W-$%$r%I+**+K% $"-&1"" %1.R#! rnrr%4nr$:%$W:$F%(%I+***K%&n n.#rn%%#$F%($W% -$I:r%K$ -!" !!3!& ( I%9;/)6*K%n !=rrr% 4nr$:%$:$F%$Fr$%$-/n$ %$r$%$W#nn$-%I);;9K% nrr:nr%"%4nW2%2 I:r%K$ (! "!!r I%3;*/8*)K%>'!4r4#.% 4n$"%W2$2%$:r%I);;9K% (!"!!r >'! 4r4#.% 4n$"%$F%I);;;K%nD nrn!#n rnnr% 4!(&r ! == $),3/+*,% 4#$%W&$(%I);;3K% J!!!&! !!" "!!r 3(r! %1.R#!:r% 4#$1%$F%%I);,+K%"nr rnnrn% 4!(! 8! ?+ $)3;/)9)% 4$%I+***K #!1!"& %!& rr% 4nn.n$2%I);;)K%&n nrnnn%% "nnI:%K$ "!!.(&1"", 1.R#!"% n$"%WnnD$-%I+**+K% -!(!""&.( r !!, !rnrr% /#$&%$($:%$W&r$%I +**6K%rnnr rrnr% "!!r +, 976/9,6%

PAGE 104

;, $%&%I);;*K%(rDn$. .rn$n rnnnnrn %2$2%$:% &$I:r%K$&rn:n-. %5r$1F!:% $%#$:%I);;7K%/r# .n% (%5r%2IrK$ ((!"! %rn rr%n$1%W#$%I);;7K%rr .nnn.#r% 2%%%4.W%>#rI:r%K$ '! 4 I%+8;/ +;7K%(rr% r#$1%I);83K% ( &&r %!&&rr% r#$1%I);83K% !1!"!! %1.R#!5=.% r#$1%.n$%&%I+***K%&r#/ r);;6/);;7% !&/-! ),I+***K!,/69% r#$1%I);;6K%(&n%"#$ =!4% r#$1%I);9,K% 1""4&" %&(nr% $(!&&rr%r#$1%I);;3K% !!!4" %$!&&rr% r#$1%I+***K% '#!5r&1""!, $ !rnrr%r#$1%I);3;K=.#
PAGE 105

;9 #$H%$W$%I);;3K%n nrnnnnr%% W%I:r%K$ L!!32!"!8!.( 5r$1F!:%n$"%I+**)K% 8! !3r ! ("! 4( !, >'!>'rnrr% nrr$%I);,,K% !34 !"!! &A! !, 1. R#!rr%n$%$WH$:%I);;9K%n r%%nWF% "rI:r%K$ J &! "" %!! I% ))7/)69K%!rnrr% :$2%%I);99K% (!"3 1. R#!4r4#r%:$F%(%$4nr$:%%$Fr$%5%$/n$%$r$%$W#nn$ -%I);;8K 8!:!"3 !!4( .(, !&rr% :r$1%I);;9K%:nr$nr$ % 1"" 1!" !79$86)/887% :r$1%%$Wn$=%I);;,K% /rnr! (nrnn(% r!!r 1"" %!!! $ +@ )73P),)% :$F%(%I);;*K%rnnn% "!!r +7 $),;P+))% :$F%(%$4nr$:%%$Fr$%5%$/n$%$r$%$W#nn$ -%I);;8K% 8!:!"!3 !!(( (, $!&rr% :rr$F%W#$%I+**3K%D r!nn/$H/ nA 4 !"&96& &! 1!"!! $ rn$4#% $%F%I);9;K%2nrnnn nnr% =%nW%%2$r% 1""( !"! % rn!1n/5L:r%I),/69K% $%$Wn$1%I);;7K%(rnn nr!rnnrn% %>#rW2%%%4.I:r%K$ '! 4 I%+;3P 6+)K%(!rr%

PAGE 106

;; $F%I);,3K% 1""&" %1.R#!.% $F%%I);9)K%&rnrnnrnn rrnr% 8(!, $!&rr% $F%I);,;K 8(!3J!&"! !r $!&rr% $F%Wr$\%I);;,K%nr nnn!n rr%NnO5$F%I:K%I);;,K% !!"634!( 4 "!&! !!" I%6*;/63*K%$!&rr% $F%%W.n$%I+**+K%rnr nrnnr 1!"!! 8! );I)/+KG)*3/)73% 2.$%W=r$4%$r%I);;7K% ( !!1"" %!!! % $!rnrr% 2$=%%W2$4%&%I);8;K%&r nD% r +=0 $887/8,+% 2n$(%=%$1.n$:%(%$W2n$5%I); 97K%&nrnnrn nrnrr% L&!1"" $ ++ $76P,;% 2$%:%I+**7K%4n.r An(Dn% "!! ;7$,,/9% 2$%:%I);;,Krnn2% :%-%4.F%:%$r% (!&r ! %1.R#!:r (n% 2#$%I);;,K% &, >'!>' rnrr%2#$%W$%I);;)K%n n r% "!! 6;I)KG)/3*% 2$%F%W(.n$=%%I);,;K%&rr nrr !nnnrn% 4 !"&8 r !&16F0 +9)/99% 2$2%$W&$:%$:r%I);;*K% !&!&!", 5r$1F!:2$2%%$nr%I);9*K%n
PAGE 107

)** 5n$%4%I);96K% !31""1!&:! !! !rnrr% 5$&%W&r$F%I);;)K% !!(!(&! % n!-.%5$&%W&r$F%I);;7K%rr .#nr% r $ +F+ $6*3/73% 5rn$(%W(nn$%$r%I);9)K% (!!1!"!! (! (%F#$:%I+**)K%&rrnrn% %>$%:%2nr$W=%% 2I:rK &!" 3.(r !, $!&rr%Fr$%5%Wn$F%I);;)K% -!""!!.(3& J 8 "!!, >'!4#.% Fr$%$n$H%$W$%I);;9K%" rD.nr.A& nnD.n./nr % .(r + I+K$ +66/69%-/n$%I+**+K% -!3.(4( "!!r !&rr% -/n$-%$W-/n$%I+**)K% 41""3JJ !5rnrr% -$%$#$&%$-rr#$F%$$5%=%$ W2$%"%I+**+K%n nr!n=r n% "!!-! 8 +9 $+*6/+)+% -D $%%I);,9K%"n DnrrnA L&!1""0 $)8,/,)% ($4%$n$(%$WFr$%I);;+K%nn n'nnrr
PAGE 108

)*) (n$F%%I+***K%r nrr% 1"" !"99 ,;/;8%($%Wr$:%I+**+K%= nnr% "!! $98I)KG+3/33% (D$F%$2n$5%W2n$(%I+**6K% rn.nnnr!H nnnr% "!! 9,$)3)/),9% (D$F%$2n$5%$W2n$(%I+**7K%-D nB!nnnrn nn'% 5$%2"'$%=%$r% I+**7K% !"1! !&rr$8*6/86,% (D$F%W2n$(%I+**7K%Rr$.rn r2% "!! ;7 93/;6% (D$F%W"'$%=%=nn nrnrn!n nr% "!! ;6$)3,/)83% (D$F%$"'$%$W$F%I+**6K%"n nr#.nrn'n
PAGE 109

)*+ $%W5$:%$r%I+**8K% !-!!"! %$-!n nnr% $5%$W&r$%I+**7K%&./)9/ n/nr.Dn rrr% .(r > I)K$)/;%1r$(%=%$.$%$W5$%I);;+K% nrnrnrnn r% "!!.(> 7*6P7+,% 1.n$:%(%I);,,K%nr!&rn rn%1%F% rn$%4%r$W2%=%nnr$r% "!! I%+K%5r$ 1F!(:% 1n$%5%$%I);,3K%5$! %! !"#$!", !>'rnrr% 1n$%W1n$%$r%I+**,K5$! !&#' H%)% >'!rr%><2$"%$$F%$$%$W=r/ $F%I+**3K% ( 1!"!! 4!n%nn$%%I+**)K% r 1"" %!!!4 31!" L(, .$1F!(.:% ><($%n$4%I);9;K%n rnn'A %FrIK -!.("!!38, >'!4r 4#.%>$=%I+***K%rnn #rrr .#% r!!r 1"" %!!!+> 73;/9)% >$%$2nr$%:%$W2$=%%$:r%I+** )K% &!" 3 .(r!, $!&rr% >$%I+***K% !3r/!&-!"* .!!, $1!#rnrr%#$%$($F%$W%-$%$:r%I+*** K% -!"-!-!3 !&#.( %n!=r rr% $F%I);;)K% $!"8(!! %$! rnrr%

PAGE 110

)*6 $F%%I);;7K%& r%%2.W4%F%=r I:r%K$ (! !!"" %!!! %! rnrr% #$%I);;7K% 1""! 1.R#!5r% #$%I);;;K% #!: %!"%"%1nW% #$%$W$%I);99K%> nr!rr rnnrrrn % "!! 6@ $);3P+7,% $&%I+**7K% '!, $!&rr% $&%I+**+Kn%I);8*K% 2< %!&rr% =r$"%Wn$%%I);;*K%nr nrnr% r $ ?6 I+K$),,/+*3% =n$%W$F%I);9,K% 4.!!4 !" IH%)K% !&rr%

PAGE 111

)*7 =n$%W$F%I);98K%> nrnnr:rr% F%W%=n$I:r%K$ 4.!!4 !"3 (!!! &"!!/ 634 "! -!"! $!&rr$+)8/+,)% n$F%$$>%I);9;K%nrnn r%%r$%I);9;K% 8(!, 1.R#!-.% r$2%I);;;K% !"31""! ., (! nnn%r$2%I+**3%K 1""! ., (!nnn% r$=%I);;9K%"nr.[nnrn n!nn nrnrnn nr% !1"" )6I7KG379/3,*% $4%I);;*K% !:&1!&31""r !5!& !! %rnrr$);;*% D$4%%$W$2%-%I+**+K% nrnrnrn nr ,1!"!! 8! );I)/+KG)93/++6% $(%I+***K%nDnr% L&4!( !;,$863/837% $%I);93K%:rnnn'n/ rrn% 1!"!! 4!( 9!666/676% $%I);96K%rr%> #NrrnnO%":=r(n% #$4%%I);69K% -!&2"!3(!! &-!, 1.R#!n/n/nr%#$4%%I);3,K% /-! %1.R#!n/n/nr% .$%:%Wr$%%$r%I);,,K% :!"!31""( !, $%-%!rnrr% #$F%(W.$%:%I);;7K%& nnr n%%2.W4%=%= r$I:r%K$ ( !!1"" %!!!, !rnrr% #$:%%I+***K%1nr$r$n r#.% % W%n$r%I+***K% &(3!!", $ !4#.rr%

PAGE 112

)*3 #$:%%$5rn$%W$Y%I+**)K% n nr8/n/nr% L&"!!.( +I6K%+8)/ +9)%n$-%I);9;K%

xml version 1.0 encoding UTF-8 standalone no
record xmlns http:www.loc.govMARC21slim xmlns:xsi http:www.w3.org2001XMLSchema-instance xsi:schemaLocation http:www.loc.govstandardsmarcxmlschemaMARC21slim.xsd
leader nam Ka
controlfield tag 001 001914881
003 fts
005 20071029145046.0
006 m||||e|||d||||||||
007 cr mnu|||uuuuu
008 071029s2007 flu sbm 000 0 eng d
datafield ind1 8 ind2 024
subfield code a E14-SFE0001993
035
(OCoLC)179673909
040
FHM
c FHM
049
FHMM
090
B72 (ONLINE)
1 100
Merritt, Michele.
0 245
Minimally innate ideas
h [electronic resource] /
by Michele Merritt.
260
[Tampa, Fla.] :
b University of South Florida,
2007.
520
ABSTRACT: This project provides a detailed examination and critique of current philosophical, linguistic, and cognitive accounts of first language acquisition. In particular, I focus on the concept of "innate" and how it is embraced, marginally utilized, or abandoned altogether in efforts to describe the way that a child comes to be a competent user of a language. A central question that naturally falls out of this general inquiry is therefore what exactly is supposed to be "innate," according to various theories? Philosophically, the theory of innate ideas put forth to explain human learning has existed for centuries and hence, this thesis as it relates to language is discussed. The revival of nativism by linguists like Chomsky is thus a central theme of the first chapter. Universal Grammar and the various arguments for it are closely scrutinized, and I close this chapter with what I take to be the commitments of linguistic nativism, how its proponents conceive of "innate," andseveral possible objections to the arguments they put forth. Just as the theory of innate ideas has had its contesters throughout the history of philosophy, so too have linguists and cognitive scientists rejected Universal Grammar and other forms of linguistic nativism. Thus, the second chapter presents several of these alternative explanations of language acquisition. Namely, I divide the chapter into three sections, Usage-Based Linguistics, Emergentism, and Sociolinguistic Acquisition, as it is my suggestion that most of the anti-UG attacks are levied from one of these three fields. In discussing the details of each, two distinctions become of particular concern: first, a large part of the differing conceptions of "innate" seem to hinge on what is meant by "learning" and "acquiring," and therefore second, a fine line between UBL and Emergentism can be drawn, a relationship that is otherwise conflated in the literature. Because chapter two involves a brief account of the way in whichconnectionist simulations are often utilized to model or represent language acquisition, particularly from an Emergentist perspective, chapter three begins by examining this feature of Emergentism in more detail. Due to its explanatory power, ability to be effectively modeled, and the evidentiary support found in neuroscience, Emergentism would appear to be the most tenable position to maintain regarding language acquisition. This possibility seems further strengthened when we take into account the neuroscientific data often used to bolster anti-nativist claims. Nevertheless, reflecting on the overarching concern of the project, regarding what is really meant by "innate," it is shown that this attack on nativism might stand on shakier ground than was originally assumed. Finally, based on these considerations, a case is made for an intermediary position, a theory of "Minimally Innate Ideas."
502
Thesis (M.A.)--University of South Florida, 2007.
504
Includes bibliographical references.
516
Text (Electronic thesis) in PDF format.
538
System requirements: World Wide Web browser and PDF reader.
Mode of access: World Wide Web.
500
Title from PDF of title page.
Document formatted into pages; contains 105 pages.
590
Advisor: Daniel Weiskopf, Ph.D.
653
Language acquisition.
Representational nativism.
Usage-based linguistics.
Emergentism.
Interactivism.
Connectionism.
690
Dissertations, Academic
z USF
x Philosophy
Masters.
773
t USF Electronic Theses and Dissertations.
4 856
u http://digital.lib.usf.edu/?e14.1993