|USFDC Home | USF Electronic Theses and Dissertations||| RSS|
This item is only available as the following downloads:
xml version 1.0 encoding UTF-8 standalone no
record xmlns http:www.loc.govMARC21slim xmlns:xsi http:www.w3.org2001XMLSchema-instance xsi:schemaLocation http:www.loc.govstandardsmarcxmlschemaMARC21slim.xsd
leader nam Ka
controlfield tag 001 002007338
007 cr mnu|||uuuuu
008 090618s2008 flu s 000 0 eng d
datafield ind1 8 ind2 024
subfield code a E14-SFE0002773
Todd, Daniel Elias.
The first Icomde a library for the information age
h [electronic resource] /
by Daniel Elias Todd.
[Tampa, Fla] :
b University of South Florida,
Title from PDF of title page.
Document formatted into pages; contains 240 pages.
Thesis (M.Arch.)--University of South Florida, 2008.
Includes bibliographical references.
Text (Electronic thesis) in PDF format.
ABSTRACT: The library has existed as a repository for knowledge for centuries. However, in spite of the information revolution and its watershed component, the internet, this institution has found itself fundamentally unchanged. Great strides have been taken to adapt the library to this changing world, but these incremental changes are timid and reactionary. Through the internet the floodgates have opened; individuals are creating and sharing information both personal and academic, in the form of not-so-private journals, works of creative fiction, works of journalism, works of scholarship, and every other form of intellectual (and not so intellectual) propagation imaginable. Additionally, advances in computer display and input technology are breaking down the conceptions of what a computer is and how we interact with them.The trend is pointing to a future where computers are no longer objects, but an integrated component of our built environment, capable of responding to practically limitless simultaneous individual users. This thesis will take the lead on these growing trends and create a new type of information age institution to evolve alongside, rather than supplant, the library: Icomde. This new institution will explore the possibilities of these new technologies while embracing the spirit of the information revolution. It will create a unique place where people can experience state of the art means of information creation, interaction, and collaboration. Finally, when the technology present has been fundamentally surpassed, the Icomde will be dismantled and the pieces distributed to dozens of locations throughout the world to found new Icomdes, with the original site becoming host to the next iteration of whatever advanced technologies will follow.This thesis will seek to examine the cultural, social role of the library as it has evolved and has been propagated through the course of human events, using design and history research, so as to employ the 'spirit' of this place as completely as possible in spite of the proposed radical paradigm shift. It will also use logical argumentation to organize trends in web content generation and publication into patterns that can be interpreted and acted upon in a forward-thinking fashion rather than a reactionary one.
Mode of access: World Wide Web.
System requirements: World Wide Web browser and PDF reader.
Advisor: Stanley R. Russell, M.Arch.
Library as Place
t USF Electronic Theses and Dissertations.
The First Icomde A Library for the Information Age by Daniel Elias Todd A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Architecture School of Architecture and Community Design College of Visual and Performing Arts University of South Florida Major Professor: Stanley R. Russell, M.Arch. Ilene Frank, M.L.S., M.F.A. Dmitry B. Goldgof, Ph.D. Date of Approval: November 18th, 2008 Keywords: Architecture, Library, Librarie s, Library as Place, Icomde, Informatio n, Information Revolution, Information Age, Internet, Web 2.0, Multi-touch, OLED Copyright 2008, Da niel Elias Todd
i TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................................... ............... vi LIST OF FIGURES .............................................................................................................................. ............. vii ABSTRACT .............................................................................................................................. ...................... xii INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................................. ................ 1 The Problem ............................................................................................................................... .......................................................... 1 Geoffrey T. Freeman ............................................................................................................................... ................................ 1 Scott Bennet ............................................................................................................................... ............................................ 3 Bernard Frischer ............................................................................................................................... ....................................... 5 Christina A. Peterson ............................................................................................................................... ............................... 6 Web 2.0. ............................................................................................................................... ................................................... 7 Self Publishing. ............................................................................................................................... ......................................... 7 Digital Readers. ............................................................................................................................... ........................................ 8 Research Methods: Interpretive Historical Research ......................................................................................................................... 8 Research Methods: Logical Argumentation ............................................................................................................................... .......... 9 CASE STUDY 1 University of South Florid a Research Library, Habitation and Usage ............................................... 11 Findings ............................................................................................................................... ............................................................... 15 Conclusions ............................................................................................................................... ......................................................... 17
ii CASE STUDY 2 Four Hillsborou gh County Public Libraries ................................................................................... 32 Temple Terrace Public Library ............................................................................................................................... ............................ 33 Jimmie B. Keel Public Library ............................................................................................................................... .............................. 37 John F Germany (Downtown Tampa) Public Library ......................................................................................................................... 40 Port Tampa City Public Library ............................................................................................................................... ............................ 44 Conclusions ............................................................................................................................... ......................................................... 47 CASE STUDY 2 ADDENDUM Cent ral Brevard Public Library ................................................................................. 49 Location....................................................................................................................... ....................................................................... 50 The Building ............................................................................................................................... ........................................................ 50 Floorplan ............................................................................................................................... ............................................................. 51 Addendum Conclusions ............................................................................................................................... ...................................... 57 CASE STUDY 3 Four Major Attempts ............................................................................................................... 58 Sendai Mediatheque (2000) ............................................................................................................................... ............................... 59 Salt Lake City Public Library (2003) ............................................................................................................................... ..................... 64 Seattle Library (2004) ............................................................................................................................... .......................................... 69 Chicago State University Library (2006) ............................................................................................................................... .............. 72 Conclusions ............................................................................................................................... ......................................................... 77 CASE STUDY 4 The Nexus at 5th and 40th ....................................................................................................... 79
iii CASE STUDY 5 The User Generated Revolution ................................................................................................. 99 Social Networking ............................................................................................................................... ............................................. 102 Wikis ............................................................................................................................... .................................................................. 104 Blogs ............................................................................................................................... .................................................................. 106 Folksonomy ............................................................................................................................... ....................................................... 108 Forums ............................................................................................................................... .............................................................. 110 Information as Place ............................................................................................................................... ......................................... 112 Conclusions ............................................................................................................................... ....................................................... 113 CASE STUDY 6 Technologies ........................................................................................................................ 114 Output Computing as Architecture ............................................................................................................................... ................ 115 Input Active ............................................................................................................................... .................................................... 118 Input Passive ............................................................................................................................... ................................................... 123 Input Multiple Devices ............................................................................................................................... ................................... 126 Input and Output as One ............................................................................................................................... .................................. 128 Cloud Computing ............................................................................................................................... .............................................. 130 Noise Cancellation ............................................................................................................................... ............................................ 132 Human to Human Input ............................................................................................................................... .................................... 133
iv SITE ANALYSIS ............................................................................................................................... ............. 134 PROGRAM .............................................................................................................................. ..................... 146 Turning Point ............................................................................................................................... ..................................................... 146 Prototype ............................................................................................................................... .......................................................... 146 Midtown Manhattan, New York City: 2020 ............................................................................................................................... ..... 147 Nexus ............................................................................................................................... ................................................................ 147 Technology ............................................................................................................................... ........................................................ 148 Cascade ............................................................................................................................... ............................................................. 151 Pods ............................................................................................................................... ................................................................... 153 Other Features ............................................................................................................................... .................................................. 154 Organization ............................................................................................................................... ...................................................... 157 Total Square Footage ............................................................................................................................... ........................................ 158 FINAL SCHEMATIC DESIGN IMAGES ............................................................................................................... 161 Plans ............................................................................................................................... .................................................................. 162 Sections ............................................................................................................................... ............................................................. 170 Elevation ............................................................................................................................... ........................................................... 174 Rendered Perspectives ............................................................................................................................... ..................................... 175 Commissioned Perspectives ............................................................................................................................... ............................. 182 Model Photos ............................................................................................................................... .................................................... 184
v REFERENCES .............................................................................................................................. ................. 189 BIBLIOGRAPHY .............................................................................................................................. .............. 191 APPENDIX .............................................................................................................................. ..................... 193 Appendix: Icomde Story ............................................................................................................................... .................................... 194
vi LIST OF TABLES Table 1: Tuesday, May 20th 20 Table 2: Wednesday, May 21st 21 Table 3: Tuesday, May 22nd 22 Table 4: Friday, May 23rd 23 Table 5: Saturday, May 24th 24 Table 6: Total & Average Users 25
vii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: University of South Florida Library, Tampa Campus 11 Figure 2: USF Library Stacks 14 Figure 3: USF Library North Elevation 19 Figure 4: Activity Pattern, Basement Red dots indicate activity. 26 Figure 5: Activity Pattern, 1st Floor 27 Figure 6: Activity Pattern, 2nd Floor 28 Figure 7: Activity Pattern, 3rd Floor 29 Figure 8: Activity Pattern, 4th Floor 30 Figure 9: Activity Pattern, 5th Floor 31 Figure 10: Temple Terrace Public Library Exterior 33 Figure 11: Temple Terrace Public Library Front Desk 34 Figure 12: Temple Terrace Public Library Stacks 35 Figure 13: Temple Terrace Public Library Central Area 36 Figure 14: Jimmie B. Keel Public Library Exterior 37 Figure 15: Jimmie B. Keel Public Library Stacks 38 Figure 16: Jimmie B. Keel Public Library Central Area 39 Figure 17: John F Germany Public Library Exterior 40 Figure 18: John F Germany Public Library First Floor Central 41 Figure 19: John F Germany Public Library First Floor Computer Use 42 Figure 20: John F Germany Public Li brary Second Floor Reading Area 43 Figure 21: Port Tampa City Library Exterior 44 Figure 22: Port Tampa City Library Interior 45 Figure 23: Port Tampa City Library Exterior 46 Figure 24: Central Brevard Public Library Exterior 49 Figure 25: Central Brevard Public Library Reference Area 51 Figure 26: Central Brevard Pu blic Library Reading Room 52 Figure 27: Central Brevard Public Library Garden 53 Figure 28: Central Brevard Public Library Periodicals 54 Figure 29: Central Brevard Public Library Special Needs Collection 55
viii Figure 30: Central Brevard Public Library Current Periodicals 56 Figure 31: Sendai Me diatheque Exterior 59 Figure 32: Sendai Mediatheque Lobby 60 Figure 33: Sendai Mediatheque Stacks 61 Figure 34: Sendai Me diatheque Elevator 62 Figure 35: Sendai Mediat heque Overlooking Street 63 Figure 36: Salt Lake City Library Concourse 64 Figure 37: Salt Lake City Library Exterior 65 Figure 38: Salt Lake City Library View to Plaza 66 Figure 39: Salt Lake City Library View into Concourse 67 Figure 40: Seattle Li brary Fiction Area 69 Figure 41: Seattle Library Exterior 70 Figure 42: Seattle Library Front Lobby 71 Figure 43: Chicago State University Library ROVER 72 Figure 44: Chicago State Univer sity Library Interior Views 73 Figure 45: Chicago State University Library Traditional Stacks 74 Figure 46: Chicago State Un iversity Library Exterior 75 Figure 47: Chicago State Univ ersity Library Front Lobby 75 Figure 48: New York Ci ty Humanities Library 79 Figure 49: Humaniti es Library Plans 80 Figure 50: Humanities Library Sections 81 Figure 51: Humanities Library Reading Room 82 Figure 52: Humanities Library Fountain 84 Figure 53: Humanities Library Reading Room 85 Figure 54: Humaniti es Library Lobby 86 Figure 55: South Court Ceiling 87 Figure 56: South Court Edge 88 Figure 57: South Court Entrance 89 Figure 58: Mid-Manhat tan Library Exterior 90 Figure 59: Mid-Manhat tan Library Stacks 91 Figure 60: Mid-Manhatta n Library Reading Area 92
ix Figure 61: Humanities Li brary 5th Avenue Terrace 93 Figure 62: Mid-Manhatta n Library Proposed Renovation Exterior 94 Figure 63: Mid-Manhatta n Library Proposed Renovation Street Edge 95 Figure 64: Mid-Manhattan Library Proposed Renovati on Section Perspective 96 Figure 65: The Traditiona l System, 1800s to Present 99 Figure 66: The Internet Bypass 100 Figure 67: Concentric Arrangement 101 Figure 68: Social Networking Example Myspace Music 102 Figure 69: Wiki Example Wikipedia 104 Figure 70: Political Blog Example Texas Rainmaker 106 Figure 71: Folksonomy Tag Clou d Artist's Interpretation 108 Figure 72: Community Forum Example Through the Looking Glass (TTLG) 110 Figure 73: Forum Example TTLG Threaded Topic View 111 Figure 74: Organic Li ght-Emitting Diode 115 Figure 75: Flexibility in OLEDs 116 Figure 76: Sony's 11" OLED TV 117 Figure 77: Traditional Input Device: Keyboard 118 Figure 78: Multi-Touch, Multi-User, Microsoft Su rface Table Computer 119 Figure 79: Perceptive Pixel's Wall Computer 120 Figure 80: Object Manipulation, Citywall, Helsinki Finland 121 Figure 81: Citywall, Helsinki Finland 122 Figure 82: Head Tracking 123 Figure 83: Depth Illusion in Head Tracking 124 Figure 84: Body Awareness 125 Figure 85: Wireless Interaction 126 Figure 86: Multi-touch Object Interaction 127 Figure 87: Present Day Double Side d Touch Screen Interface (Otani) 128 Figure 88: Near-Future Multi-touch OLED Interface 129 Figure 89: Off-site Computing Warehouse 130 Figure 90: Cloud Computing Example Google Docs 131 Figure 91: Noise Cancellation Earpiece Jawbone 132
x Figure 92: Science Fiction Translat ion Device Babel Fish from The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy 133 Figure 93: Midtown Manhattan 134 Figure 94: Bryant Park Area Diagram 135 Figure 95: Bryant Park Area Arial 136 Figure 96: Building Heights 136 Figure 97: Figure Ground and Population Density 137 Figure 98: Views 138 Figure 99: Forces Diagram 139 Figure 100: Terrace Organization 140 Figure 101: Pedest rian Movement 141 Figure 102: Stationary Population Density 142 Figure 103: Circulation 143 Figure 104: Solar Angles 144 Figure 105: Shade 145 Figure 106: Icomde Logo 146 Figure 107: Early Concept: Icomde 146 Figure 108: Multi-Touch 148 Figure 109: Organic Li ght-Emitting Diodes 149 Figure 110: Early Concept: Cascade 151 Figure 111: Early Co ncepts: Cascade Workflow & Team Pod 152 Figure 112: Early Conc ept: Cascade Terrace 153 Figure 113: Early Concept: Cascade 154 Figure 114: Early Concept: Cafe 156 Figure 115: Early Conc ept: Organization 157 Figure 116: Cascade Plaza 158 Figure 117: Team Pods 159 Figure 118: Auditorium 160 Figure 119: Plan s Site Plan 162 Figure 120: 1st Floor Plan 163 Figure 121: 2nd Floor Plan 164 Figure 122: 3rd Floor Plan 165
xi Figure 123: 4th Floor Plan 166 Figure 124: 5th Floor Plan 167 Figure 125: 6th Floor Plan 168 Figure 126: Rooftop Plan 169 Figure 127: Street Se ction 5th Avenue 170 Figure 128: Street Se ction 40th Street 171 Figure 129: Section A Through Terrace and Core 172 Figure 130: Section B Through West Wing and Core 173 Figure 131: Elevat ion 5th Avenue 174 Figure 132: Rendered Perspective 1 175 Figure 133: Rendered Perspective 2 176 Figure 134: Rendered Perspective 3 177 Figure 135: Rendered Perspective 4 178 Figure 136: Rendered Perspective 5 179 Figure 137: Rendered Perspective 6 180 Figure 138: Rendered Perspective 7 181 Figure 139: Watercolor and Ink Perspective 1 Commissioned 182 Figure 140: Watercolor and Ink Perspective 2 Commissioned 183 Figure 141: 1':0.1" scale model, acrylic, plastic, and wood 184 Figure 142: 1':0.1" scale model, acrylic, plastic, and wood 185 Figure 143: 1':0.1" scale model, acrylic, plastic, and wood 186 Figure 144: Site Model, 1:400 scale, Icomde piece courtesy of Engineering Dept. Rapid Prototyping 187 Figure 145: 1:400 scale, Icomde piece courtesy of Engineer ing Dept. Rapid Prototyping 188
xii THE FIRST ICOMDE: A LIBRARY FOR THE INFORMATION AGE Daniel Elias Todd ABSTRACT The library has existed as a repository for knowledge for centuries. However, in spite of the information revolution and its watershed component, the internet, this institution has found itself fundamentally unchanged. Great strides have been taken to adapt the library to this changing world, but these incremen tal changes are timid and reactionary. Through the internet the floodgates have opened; individuals are creating and sharing information both personal and academic, in the form of not-so-private journals, works of creative fiction, work s of journalism, works of scholarship, and every other form of intellectual (and not so intellectual) propagation imaginable. Additionally, advances in computer display and input technolo gy are breaking down the conc eptions of what a computer is and how we interact with them. The trend is pointing to a future where computers are no longer objects, but an integrated component of our bu ilt environment, capable of responding to pr actically limitless simultaneous individual users.
xiii This thesis will take the lead on these growing trends and create a new type of information age institution to evolve alongside, rather than supplant, the library: Icomde. This new institution will explore the possibilities of these new technologies while embracing the spirit of the information revolution. It will create a unique place where people can experience state of the art means of information creation, interaction, and collaboration. Finally, when the technology present has been fundamentally surpassed, the Icomde will be dism antled and the piec es distributed to dozens of locations throughout the world to found new Icom des, with the original site becoming host to the next iteration of whatever advanced technologies will follow. This thesis will seek to exam ine the cultural, social role of the library as it has evolved and has been propagated through the course of human events, using design an d history research, so as to employ the s pirit of this place as completely as possible in spite of the proposed radical pa radigm shift. It will al so use logical argumentation to organize trends in web content generation and publicat ion into patterns that can be interpreted an d acted upon in a forw ard-thinking fashion rather than a reactionary one.
1 INTRODUCTION The Problem There is a consensus among thos e who put themselves to the task of discove ring the library of tomorrow no one knows what that is. In my research I have discovered many questions, and many ideas, but few answers. Geoffrey T. Freeman an architect, believes in the traditional role of the library. He also, however, believes they need to evolve. (C.L.I.R.) He asks, and correctly so, why woul d one wish to use the library, when one could theoretically access whatever information or entertainm ent one needed from the comfort of what ever locale they happen to chose to nestle with their laptop computer in? Why is the library, a facility that in the twentieth century became a machine for the storage and organization of printed material, still relevant in the age of wireless digital information access? This is a question that must be answered before we can pr oceed. It could be the most important question. However, Freeman claims that what no one could have expected is that in light of the information revolution, maybe in spite of or maybe because of, library usage in this country in the past five years has actually increased in some places as much as doubling.
2 Freeman believes that it is the synergy, not the dichotomy, of digital media and print media that has made todays libraries so important. The library is a place where new and emerging informat ion technologies and cultures can be combined with traditional knowledge resources in a service rich, commercial free, highly social environment. The internet, for all of its capacity of expr ession for raw thought and knowledge to encircle the globe and spread ideas as never before, still isolates the individual. It is the library that focuses on community. Though much success has been met in the area of nurturing the new library into the future Freeman believes that the answer has not yet been discovered. He believes that careful and continue d focus on how these technologies are evolving is still needed before one can design the model library of the future. It is no longer simply about information gathering, but thanks to the power of th e computer, also about communi cations and publication. It will be the union of information gathering, transfer, and presentation that will define the new library. Freeman charges architects to design libraries that learn. Spaces must be designed to be so flexible, that the designation of areas can be continually evolved based on the attentive examinatio n of the changing patterns of library use already discussed. As the domina nce of independent study steadily lose s precedence to more group oriented projects and communal endeavors, the natu re of the spaces within the library quiet areas versus di scussion areas, will be threatened, and if they do no t bend, they will get broken.
3 He proposes the expansion and addition of laboratory, studio, or development spaces wi thin libraries to present epicenters of production, creativity and progress, rather than simply research. Thanks to technology, the speed at which a library operates has also increased dramatically. Freeman claims that what once took two weeks now takes two hours. Designers of libraries must be critic al and attentive to the speed at which life goes by, and design their spac es accordingly. Flexibility, he stresses, flexibility is the key. Scott Bennet is a library planner by trade, and his insights fall alon g two lines. (C.L.I.R.) The first of which is related to this topic peripherally, but it is like the wake of a passing ocean liner upon our small vessel; rocking of the boat will take place. He speaks of a paradigm shift wi thin higher education away from a cultur e of instruction and towards a culture of learning. While this superficially may seem to be merely ju ggling semantics, it is in a broader scope the juxtaposition between an end and a means. How does this effect library design? The mission of libraries has been the storage, organization, and preservation of books. If th is paradigm shift is to be correctly applied to library de sign, the purpose of libraries becomes a place to enjoy and be nefit from those books. The responsibility of the library designer is clear. While once all of a librarys problems were believed to be solved by simply throwing more square footage to the doma in of clerical and organizational purs uits, the new doctrine has become just the opposite. Space for the experience of using the library is now the premium an d space for the functions of the library
4 are being marginalized. In fact, the sp acing between stacks is being compresse d and even the number of books on the stacks is being increased to allow more floor space to be given over to the user, rather than the material stored. The second issue which Bennet discusses is the domestication of the library. He admits this is a broad, nebulous concept which he does not truly possess the vocabulary to de scribe. But he poses the ques tion, how can the library be made more like the home? First we must understand why this questi on is being posed. He insists that, according to surveys, discussion, debate, and teaching amongst peers, is most likely to occu r in the home. Bennet believes, why the home and not the library? But how would one make the library more like a home? There are two angles to this. The first is the introduction of the caf into the library, already wide spread in bookstores, and eliminate the taboo against food and drin k inside the library. This aspect, the introduction of beverage, or food, into the library setting is in itself a major and fundamental step towards the domestication of the space. The second angle is to loosen, not eliminate the taboo against noise inside a libra ry. Bennet suggests creating three levels of noise zoning; conversational, quiet, and silent. The first of which would be, of course, the domesticated aspect of the library, areas where conversation and social mingling were encouraged. Quiet areas allowe d conversation, but at a much lower volume, and finally, silent areas are the sanctuaries for those who seek the escape to the librarys traditional nature; conversation here is forbidden.
5 Those two angles, Bennet says, are the fi rst steps towards the domestication of the library, and the evolution of the place away from sterile, static stud y, and to more of an open forum fo r discussion, debate, and face to face communication. Bernard Frischer is the director at an institute for advanced te chnology, and he dreams of the technologically empowered library. (C.L.I.R.) First, he stresses that he does not believe that electronic ally presented data can ever replace a physical book. But he does off (Biba)er three points of argument for the introducti on of the high-tech into this low-tech realm. First of all, he dreams of a type of elec tronic data presentation over which libraries could have a monopoly. Stuff, as he puts it, not intended for dissemination over the internet. Fri scher proposes that this could entail large three dimensional theaters where information stored in a private library networ k could be presented, shared, created, and developed. He muses about the day where projects collaborated upon by libra ries across the globe could rebu ild ancient cities and allow visitors to the library the ability to wander about and explore these cities in virtual reality. The technology, he claims, for this already exists. Its simply a matter of making it a reality. Second, and this is a point echoed by others and discussed in-depth previously in this essay, thanks to todays technology the library can be a place as much for the production of material as it is for the digestion of material. He
6 suggests the creation of hybrid workst ations empowered not only to allow st udents to gather information, but collaborate with others on projects that allow for the production and creativity. Third, he feels that the space within the library must be rearranged to take advantage of its primary power over the internet: the community building power of real physical presence. Christina A. Peterson is a librarian, and for her, the future of library design isnt really a matter of technology; its about unity. (C.L.I.R.) In the past, a library was a library. Today however, there are many types of libraries; public libraries, university libraries, research libraries, medical libraries, art libraries (or galleries) and even music libraries. In a unique venture in San Jose, at the library of her employ, the Martin Luther King library the gap between the public library and the university / research libra ry has been erased. In this so called joint-use library, the public as well as students can mingle and interact, learn and read together, in a remarkably successful way. Usage reports and statistics show that the public utilize the academic research port ions of the library almost as much as they do the public sector, an d the same could be said for the students. Strict organization and monitoring is still required, to, for example, keep children in the childrens section and not playing tag in the study areas. The separation and definition of spaces howe ver only seems to empower the unity of them rather than detract. This venture has proven to be a remarkable success, and a model for future library planners.
7 Peterson encourages additional unity between currently sepa rate affairs, bringing the ar t gallery and the music world into the traditionally book-filled realm. Books along with art and music create a circle of cu lture that need not be kept separate; when combined, they bloom. Web 2.0. The term became notable after the fi rst O'Reilly Media Web 2.0 conference in 2004. (O'Reilly) Although the term suggests a new version of the World Wi de Web, it does not refer to an update to any technical specifications, but to changes in the ways software developers and end-users use webs. Web 2.0 embodies collaborative information compendiums, authored creative content, journals or journalism, social obsessi ons, and discussion and debate venues. Self Publishing. Self-publishing is the publishing of books and other media by the authors of those works, rather than by established, third-party publishers. An agent is still employed to print and bind the material, but all other aspects editing, marketing, and so forth, are in the hands of the author. Although it represents a small percentage of the publishing industry in terms of sales, it has been present in one form or anot her since the beginning of publishing and has seen an increase in activity wi th the advancement of publishing tech nology, including xerography, desktop publishing systems, print on de mand, and the World Wide Web.
8 Digital Readers. Rather than looking at di gital, or e-book, readers as an opposi tion to books and the 'right' way of doing things, realize that the digital reader is confirmation of the fundamental nature of the book it is a thing, not a service. It is a thing to be held in one's hands and is a ha ptic experience as much as it is a visual and mental one. Although use of a digital reader means that the form ha s changed, the fundamental ex perience of reading has not changed for most users. Research Methods: Interpretive-Historical Research The only way to anticipate the future is to understand what has come before. If this thesis is to explore a solution which shall span cultural epochs, it must study all of the ch anges, evolutions, and revolutions which have come before. Only then can the next phase of the library come into play. The concept of the library is well over two thousand years old, and it is not a concept which will vanish. The question is not, will the library go away, but what new form will it take, and when? My research will examine the development of the library from a place of exclusion an d privilege; that is, only those of a specific rank, usually within the church, were allowed access to the books, and furthermore a general lack of literacy among the population; through its evolution throughout the ag es into its current form, wh ich embodies a new form of
9 privilege and exclusion; whose b ooks are allowed to be on the shelves, and why? This evolution will of course also be affected directly with the advent and deve lopment of technological printing means. I will also attempt to set aside the pragmatic and objective da ta and examine the ever evolvi ng cultural significance of the library, a thing based on thought and feeling more than actual use or demand as that element will remain key to whatever solution I devise, however distant from the traditional library I go. Finally, I will document the librarys reactive and thus flawed approach to the changing ways in which the world shares information in the current decade and be yond, in an attempt to avoid the pitfalls. Research Methods: Logical Argumentation I choose logic because it is not only a method of research analysis, but a problem solving technique as well. If I am to be venturing into the unknown, into area s where the only consensus is that no-one knows, I will need a logical system which can take what is and extr apolate what can be from that.
10 Using logical argumentation I will identify the pertinent aspects of the discourse; what things are related to current library design and what issues th reaten to supplan t these things? These things include the way information is created and shar ed, the needs for this informat ion, the speed at which the systems operate, how economics, busine ss, and capitalist considerations wo rk into all of th ese systems and, categorically speaking, how all of this falls into the realm of work, recreation, relaxation, or creation. I will deduce associations between these pertinent as pects, and any addi tional peripheral components which may come into play. These associations can be further groupe d and divided into other ca tegorical systems; The trad itional library, Web 2.0, self publishing, digital reader s, mobile computing, emergent input and output computer technologies, constant, instant, perpetual, and immediate access. A hi erarchy can be established from these ca tegorical systems, and from that the beginning of an architectural program.
11 Figure 1: University of South Florida Library, Tampa Campus CASE STUDY 1 University of South Florida Research Library, Habitation and Usage This case study was conducted on a large university research institution library, namely the USF Library located in Tampa, Florida. It was conducted as a silent observational survey in which students were counted and their activity and location, arranged into several loose categories, and recorded. No specific information about the st udents, their business, or their reasons for using the library was obtained. Each of five surveys were conducted on a different co nsecutive day of the week at a different time. These days and times were, Tuesday, May 20th 10:00 11:00 pm Wednesday, May 21st 10:00 11:00 am Thursday, May 22nd 3:00 4:00 pm Friday, May 23rd 8:00 9:00 am Saturday, May 24th 5:00 6:00 pm
12 These times were chosen arbitr arily (though the librarys hours of operation were obviously a factor) and not selected in anticipation of any pattern in the librarys business. However, both Sunday the 25th and Monday the 24th were not recorded due to the Memorial Day holiday which would present anomalous results. Since study was conducted during the summer semester, the library was far less active than it would be during the fall or spring semesters. The student locations we re divided simply by floor, though on the 1st floor the customers in Starbucks were counted separately. At one phase of the survey I counted students in the lobby areas of each floor as well as group study rooms separately, but I soon absorbed these counts into the general count for each floor as I noti ced inconsistencies in the way I was counting them. Grouping them back in with the ge neral floor count erased thes e inconsistencies. The 6th floor of the Library is occupied by Library Admi nistration, Academic Computing, and a st aff area so there is no appreciable student use of the floor. When counting, I would associate each sp ace with a moment in time. Once thos e present in that space were counted, I would move on to the next. That space was then done. If I returned to that space late r, even moments later, and the numbers present had changed, I would not re count or adjust the numbers. Each su rvey took anywhere from an hour to thirty minutes, depending on how busy the library was.
13 The types of activities recorded were as follows. Loiter : Individuals simply standing aro und with no clear objective. Students who seemed to be going somewhere were not counted, here, or in any other total. Relax: Individuals who were seated and occu pied, but not engaged in any type of discernable school-related activity or using a laptop. They could be reading a novel or having a drink, or simply looking out the window. Computer Lab Station: Individuals using the si t-down desktop PCs in the large lab of the 1st floor of the library. Computer Terminal: The e-mail stations designed to be used while standing up. PC Group: The spacious group-pc stations to the back of the co mputer lab. Interestingly, more often than not these were used by individuals and not groups. PC Library: Any of the many PCs throughout the library designed for use with the library website, and not general activity such as in the computer lab. Multimedia PC Terminal: Any of the PCs in the multimedia section of the 1st floor of the library, which is not part of the computer lab but rather the library proper. Study: Any student sitting down with work in front of them.
14 Study with Laptop: The same as above, but with a laptop involved. This laptop may or may not be actively in use, it simply was to be present. I di d not count laptop bags unless the laptop itself was clearly visible. Staff: Any library staff person either at a desk or out in the stacks reshelving. Staff in Office: Any library staff person who seemed to be in a personal office. Stacks: A person actively looking for something in the stacks. A rare beast indeed. Multimedia Stacks: As above, but specifically in the multimedia section of the library on the 1st floor. Micro Stacks: As above, but specifically in the microfiche/microfilm section of the library on the 2nd floor. It smells like ammonia in there. Figure 2: USF Library Stacks
15 Special Collection: Likewise, but specifically in the special collections section of the library on the 4th floor. Starbucks Line / Drink: Anyone in Starbucks who was there simply as a customer. Starbucks Study: Just like studying in the library, but in the Starbucks instead. Starbucks Study with Laptop: As above. Other: Anything that did not fall into any other category, or individuals whose activities simply could not be pinned down by cursory observation. Findings For the data visualization, I grouped the categori es into several broader categories. As follows: Comp Lab: Computer Lab Station, Computer Terminal, PC Group (Numbers from the library computers and multimedia stations were not included, as these are library functions and not part of the computer lab.) Stacks: Stacks, Multimedia Stacks, Microf orms Stacks, Special Collection Study: Both library and Starbucks. Study with Laptop: Both library and Starbucks.
16 Other: Everything else. Numbers for individual days are presented in the charts following this report. I feel that the most important information for this case study is the ratios between the activities, an d not the numbers themselves, nor the day nor time of day. Thus, a chart was created to show the aver ages of all uses across these five days. The use of the computer lab dominated over the entire rest of the library. A total of 260 users were witnessed using the lab across the five days, at an average of 52 students per day. This made up 32 percent of the total library use during the study. (Note: Th e computer lab that is part of the Tampa Librarys Learning Commons is the largest computer lab on campus. Since the building is located near some heavily used classroom buildings, students tend to come to the building as one of the nearest and largest labs.) Those witnessed studying totaled at 226 and those using a laptop totaled at 157 The averages were 45.2 and 31.4 respectively, with 28 percent of accounted individu als using the library as a place of study and 19 percent using it as a location to use their laptop. It is also worth noting that if combined as the distinction between these two may be purely arbitrary, the share becomes 47 percent which allows it to rank higher than the computer lab use.
17 A grand total of 19 individuals were witn essed using the stacks across five days, which averaged out to 2 percent of total library use. Finally, 31.8 percent of recorded persons made up the other category. Conclusions Most individuals are not using the library as a library (i.e. using the librarys books or electronic resources), but as a study hall. Though it is unclear how many of the 47% of students who were studying or using their laptops in the library were doing so with the aid of books obta ined from the stacks, with the consistent extremely low volume of attendance in the stacks themselves it seems unlikely that it is a large contingent. The second largest group, 32% is not using the library at all, but rather occupy the building for the use of the computer stations. The pattern of the use of the library building wo uld change if the computer la b and/or the Starbucks were moved to other facilities.
18 At 2%, the use of the stacks presents th e heart of the problem. I do not have the figures for the percentage of floor space used, but from observation is it ea sy to say that it could be no less th an 75% of a massive six story building. When considering environmental technolo gy costs alone, one might question the amount of storage space devoted to books, periodicals, microform, and ot her physical media. Unfortunately not all of those items are available electronically, and represent an intellectual legacy that must be maintained for the time being. It is clear to me why the students choose the library as a st udy hall. There is a general quiet, and food and drink are permitted. There is not only space, bu t many degrees of space. Some choose to work in clusters where there is a gentle hum of activity. Some students spread out to inha bit every corner of the buildin g, some choosing to occupy cramped desks at close quarters with wa lls and stacks, possibly feeling that the claustrophobic nature of that setting helped them focus on their work. This is not the same as a study hall lined with desks. It is the labyrinthine nature of the library which makes it desirable as a place to work. Ther e is a blandness about the sett ing, and yet a surreal escape from the ordinary which is very conducive to concentration. However, if one were to simply to replace all of the stacks with porous multicolored barricades, would it make little difference? They are acting as environmental features, not as the reason to be there. They are agents of the special quality, atmosphere, the character of the setting, and have little to do with the setting beyond that.
19 Figure 3: USF Library North Elevation
20 Table 1: Tuesday, May 20th
21 Table 2: Wednesday, May 21st
22 Table 3: Tuesday, May 22nd
23 Table 4: Friday, May 23rd
24 Table 5: Saturday, May 24th
25 Table 6: Total & Average Users
26 Figure 4: Activity Pattern, Baseme nt Red dots indicate activity.
27 Figure 5: Activity Pattern, 1st Floor
28 Figure 6: Activity Pattern, 2nd Floor
29 Figure 7: Activity Pattern, 3rd Floor
30 Figure 8: Activity Pattern, 4th Floor
31 Figure 9: Activity Pattern, 5th Floor
32 CASE STUDY 2 Four Hillsborough County Public Libraries The purpose of this study was to discover, at a glance, the most prominent traits of several Hillsborou gh county public libraries on the same day within the same relative time peri od. I began at 11 am, one hour after the libraries opened. First, I looked at the libraries location relative to majo r highways or intersections an d other public features. The libraries relationship to their surroundings is as important as the contents within. Second, I looked at the basic fl oorplan of each library, taking inventory of it s features but only concerning myself with that which was directly accessible to th e public. How noise was controlled and how light was brought into the room was of major concern. Finally, I considered the general feeling and atmosphere of the place, using often intangible and unquantifiable properties from which to generate thoroughly subjective opinions.
33 Temple Terrace Public Library The first library I visited was lo cated a block away from a major intersection (56th str eet and Busch) near a fire department and an elementary school. I arrived slightly before 11 am. It was very easy to find, in spite of never having been here before. The building seemed fairly new, with a slight buzz of activity in the large and welcoming covered entryway. The floorplan was fairly open and clear, with the exception of a large partitioned childrens section which occupied about a fourth of the floorspace. The partition was glass from about waist high to six feet, allowing for the feeling of one continuous space but still creating a sound barrier between the childrens area and the main space. Th e stacks were divided into two sections, reference and circulatin g, each pushed up against the wall away from the main open sp ace in the center. This open space was filled with computers on long desks. A single staff Figure 10: Temple Terrace Public Library Exterior
34 counter occupied one side of the room. There was a single meeting room and a small study room, though both were hard to find and tucked out of the way. It was busy, but quiet. I did not venture into the childrens area, where several seemed to be playing. The partition was doing its job of keeping the nois e away. Many users were at the PC terminals and several more on laptops in a work area which stretched the length of the room and separated the PC users from the stacks. Several others were in a very small reading lounge off to one corner of the room. Many windows offered generous daylighting, but most-if not all, of it was feeding the stacks areas. The centrally located computer hub was as far away from the windows as it could get, and the work area was not much closer. Only the loungelike reading area was positioned to take advantage of the Figure 11: Temple Terrace Public Library Front Desk
35 daylight. The rest of it was be ing used to sun-bleach the book covers. The library had a pleasant small community feel to it, and seemed to strike a balance between the many factors of activity, noise, and peace. Admittedly, my first impression upon entering was, This is it? as I searched for a second room or a stairway to a second floor. Figure 12: Temple Terrace Public Library Stacks
36 Figure 13: Temple Terrace Public Library Central Area
37 Jimmie B. Keel Public Library I arrived at the second library just past noon. It is located on a highway (Bearss) not far from a major intersection ( Dale Mabry). The location had an isolated, out in the woods feeling to it. The covered entryway was actually much larger than the previous library, and was thus much less inviting. There was much more activity ou tside and around the building. The building also seemed new. The layout was very similar to the Temple Terrace Library, but with the grave exception of having no partitioned childrens area. In other regards they were cut from the same mold. The stacks were pushed up agai nst one wall, though there were twice as many here. The cent er of the room was given to a generous computer area, though here it was arranged in a circle with a staff co unter located in the center. A second staff counter, this one the circulation desk, was off to one side of this area. Figure 14: Jimmie B. Keel Public Library Exterior
38 The lighting situation was the same. Generous windows were set to sun-bleach the book cove rs and all work areas, which were predominantly computer st ations, were kept away. A small reading lounge hugged one wall between the stacks and the windows, offering a pleasant view into Floridas natural scrub forest. The opposite wall was host to a series of meeting and study rooms of similar size but different layout. Most of these were in use. At the opposite end of the bu ilding from these was another computer lab, which was just as busy as the central one. In fact, just like with the Temple Terrace Library, the majority of adult activity was centered in the two computer areas. The building was dominated, howe ver, by the aforementioned lack of a partitioned childrens area. There were many children in the building, and they made their presence abundantly clear by running, playing, and screaming with no boundaries to their Figure 15: Jimmie B. Keel Public Library Stacks
39 rampage. Even the circular ba rricade of computer desks did not deter their almost brownian motion throughout the building. It was out of control. The building felt like a hybr id between a library and a playground. Though light comp uter use would be possible, I could not imagine trying to fo cus on anything serious or requiring any concentration in this library. Even if the children were removed, the space would st ill feel dysfunctional. The layout which was similar to the Temple Terrace Library did not work was well here simply because the room was slightly larger. It was just large enough so that the open floorplan lost its cohesion and became a spra wling, nebulous space. Figure 16: Jimmie B. Keel Public Library Central Area
40 John F Germany (Downtown Tampa) Public Library The largest branch in the Hillsborough County library system is located in downtown Tampa. Its one of the first things you encounter when entering the area from the main interstate 275 exit, located adjacent to a park ing garage (expensive) and the performing arts center. Thes e buildings along with several others serve, in a sense, as Downtown Tampas Gateway. The building is decades old. It can be described as ugly, but with personality. It doesnt ha ve a library look but the look can be associated with a library. The interior seems chaotic. A desk is front and center, and everything else seems scattere d. There are actually two libraries here, each with a main entrance with a front desk and a narrow corridor connecting them back to back. One central stair in the front building connec ts the two floors. There seems to be no way to get to the 2nd floor of the back building. A Figure 17: John F German y Public Library Exterior
41 strange artifact exists betw een the two buildings, a domed shaped structure with flanking doors, with no apparent function. The doors leading to the courtyard where this structure sits are blocked. As usual, the computers are centered, away from the daylighting which feeds the stacks areas, which have been pushed to the perimeter. Computer areas are scattered mostly on the second floor of the front building. The second floor of the front building seems more cozy and intimate. Voids break up the space. The interior of both buildings is very quiet. There is an empty feeling; drained, lifeless. Th e two buildings seemed to have fewer people inside than the much smaller local libraries. The separation contributed to the lack of energy. Figure 18: John F Ge rmany Public Library First Floor Central
42 The back building seems to be the childrens / young adults / embarrassing fiction / video sectio n. It has a bookstore, but no clear meeting rooms or study rooms, or any other community or civic type functions, but most of the building was inaccessible. Figure 19: John F Germ any Public Library First Floor Computer Use
43 Figure 20: John F Germany Public Library Second Floor Reading Area
44 Port Tampa City Public Library This library is located near the southern tip of the Tampa peninsula, after a long drive down Westshore Boulevard. It is a low density urban area with apartments and other businesses nearby on its side of the st reet, and a ditch and strip of wilderness on the opposite side. The building, a classically styled marble structure that was built as a bank, is extremely small and intimate. When youre inside it feels like youre in on a secr et or an exclusive club. It was the only time a librarian greet ed me when I came inside. The collection of books is small; almost negligible. Still, it shared similarities with the first two libraries I visited, with the desk up front, a clear space in the center, and the stacks pushed to the back. The childre ns section was in one corner, completely open though no children were present, with Figure 21: Port Tampa City Library Exterior
45 computers occupying the central space, but also lining the walls. Every inch of the very small enclosure is maximized to fit in as much as possible. The entire second floor is meet ing rooms and study rooms, with exhibits here and there explaining some historical facts. There was a notable abundance of model boats. As I sat downstairs at the single table, the librarian asked me if Id rather have one of the private study rooms. I declined happily. The main library room was very quiet, but did not have the same empty feeling as the John F Germany Library. There was a restful tranquility about it; very peaceful. Very large windows lined the halls and fed the entire space with daylight, not just the stacks. Th e size of the windows combined with the very tall ceiling created a very well lit space. Figure 22: Port Tampa City Library Interior
46 The room was slightly reminiscent of the New York City Public Library building, but on a much, much smaller scale. For a library of its size and with such a small offering, it was remarkably busy. Several patrons came in and checked out material as I sat for about a half an hour observing. It is worth noting that this is the library that my Design 3 project was based on in that st udio we designed an addition to this building. Thus, I was much more familiar with it and have a much greater attachment to it than the other libraries. Figure 23: Port Tampa City Library Exterior
47 Conclusions There is a chronic problem between the layo ut of the buildings and the daylighting. This light is optimal for reading, but the space where it is most abundant, the perimeter of the building, is always occupied by stacks. Some libraries attempt to amend this by placing small lounge areas in th e perimeters between the wind ows and the stacks, but these lounges are inappropriate for work. The computer areas, which are now the dominant feature of every library, are centralized both to avoid screen glare from the daylight and because it is where most of the traffic will be. Though daylight is good for reading, it is bad for the books themse lves as the ultraviolet rays deteriorate the book spines. A separate childrens areas is essential for the operation of the Library, not merely to provide the children with fun things to read, but to simply get them away from the main library space and the peace an d quiet which is essential to concentration. The Temple Terrace Libr ary did this best with the glass partitio n, so that the children may have their place and their various adult supervisors ca n keep watch over them at a glance fr om wherever they are conducting their business. This is in opposition to the John F Germany library, where the childrens section is in an entirely different building and would require the adult ei ther be in there with them, or th ey be left totally unobserved. Computers are forcing the books into the periphery. They take up far more sp ace than the books do, require far more elaborate facilities and see much much more traffic than the book areas. Tw o of the libraries had only one desk for all of the customer/guest needs. In one ca se this was a long multipurpose desk with various people working there with
48 various functions. In another case there was only one desk and one person, but the library itself was so small that no more was possible. In one case, two desks were provided but with different functions, and adjacent to one another. Finally, two desks at oppo site ends of the library were provided with a pparently identical functi ons, each designed to serve the need for the customers/ guests in that part of the library. Thus, a wide range of setups for user/staff interface is practiced, with no clear arrangement being preferred.
49 CASE STUDY 2 ADDENDUM Central Brevard Public Library A fifth library was visited in order to compliment this case study by including a facility that was part of a different county library system, and was of a design and layout which contrasted greatly with the four libraries of the study. The Central Brevard Public Library was chosen becaus e it met all of these criteria, but is also a library I am intimately familiar with, having taken advantage of a wide range of its services for more than a decade, myself. It is kept as an addendum and not edited into the original case study because the size of the library and the amount of information to convey on it is nearly as great as all of the four Hillsborough libraries combined. Figure 24: Central Brevard Public Library Exterior
50 Location It is located on Forrest Avenue, which bran ches off of Highway US 1 and overlooks the Indian River in Cocoa Florida. It is four blocks north of the Cocoa Village historic district. The village is a fairly dense pedestrian area, but the SR520 highway limits pedestrian traffic to this area. Aside from the gap, it is a short distance walking from the village. Drivers on US1 or SR520 would have to be aware of its location, as you cannot simp ly stumble upon it nor can you see it from the highway. If known, it is very easy to find for drivers. It is not located adjacent to any other civic or public institution, with the possible exception of a nearby Masonic Lodge and Christ Scientists building. The Building It is oriented towards the river, with it s back to the street. However, the park ing is between the building and the river, so it is really oriented towards the parking lot with the river beyond. The building itself is massive, much larger than any others in the area, but is broken up into smaller wings to keep it from being monolithic. A covered entryway is the most prominen t aspect of the front of the building, which broade ns and wraps around the elevation to form a porch-like area with some seating and sh ade. Several people were making use of this space to loiter and others to relax. Some of these people were possibly homeless.
51 Floorplan The building is large, and the layout can be confusing for those not familiar with it. It is in some respects divided up into many smaller libraries, as each major area has its own front desk and self contained facilities. One chamber in particular stood out as the primary space. It varied dramatically in appearance and atmosphere from one end to the other. At the start, nearer to the front entrance, the ceiling is low and lights dim (comparatively) with a tighter, intimate feel to it, though it lacked any partitioning. This is where a large reference desk (the primary one of the library) sat along with most of the reference materials. A small fishbowl-like computer lab sat adjacent with a mere eigh t PCs inside. Aside from that lab the computer presence wa s minimal; several antique terminals which had been presen t since the buildings opening Figure 25: Central Brevard Public Library Reference Area
52 in the 80s sat with burned in CRTs while a few more contemporary models accompanie d them with LCD displays. The middle section of the room is where the main stacks of the library were held. Here the ceilin g rises to a full second story or maybe even three bringing in a great deal of light from above. The entire east wall was glass, bringing in not only additional light but also a view of the river beyond the parking lot. The stacks themselves were tall and close together, with a light frame holding tubes of florescent lighting directly above the aisles, creating a sense of being closed in while you are among them, even though the ceiling looms an other twenty feet above. At the opposite end an open sp ace offered both task-oriented seating areas and a more relaxed lounge-like seating area. The ceiling here is lower than in the center but still much higher than the start. In this spac e a pair of men sat having a Figure 26: Central Brevard Public Library Reading Room
53 conversation at higher than norm al conversation volume (it was like they wanted the whole libr ary to hear their political commentary) and no one made any effort to quiet them, even though several staff people were nearby reshelving books. The entire north wall is glass, offering a view into an isolated and vacant garden area, adorned with large abstract sculptures, a fountain, and seating areas and walkways, though there is no discernable way to actually enter this garden. Figure 27: Central Brevard Public Library Garden
54 Additional areas are as follows A bound periodicals room also was the home to three group study rooms, each of which were occupied. One seemed to have a tutor and a pupil, anot her a man working alone (with a compass and t-square no less) and another with a group of potentially high school students, who were making a bit of a racket. A small but still impressive law library was adjoined to this area. The large and thoroughly deco rated childrens area and adjoined young adults section s eemed sufficiently self contained with its own staffed desk area. The audio/video multimedia area had a collection of outdated machines by which the material could be viewed, but also had a large and fairly current collection of DVDs. Figure 28: Central Brevard Public Library Periodicals
55 A library for the blind and phys ically handicapped was walled off though glass partitions and a llowed a few inside. It seemed quite extensive and well staffed. Two large meeting rooms were ava ilable for public use. They could potentially hold 100 (s eated) to 200 (standing) occupants. One was in use at the time of my visit, with the room so full people were stan ding outside the open doors looking in. A small second and third floor co ntained additional archives but not for public browsing. They were not off limits to the public, but visiting these areas requir ed an escort or a schedule appointment, or both. Scattere d throughout the library were enclosed glass cases showing of f the work of a local model building club, with miniature pl anes, trains, automobiles, and starships Figure 29: Central Brevard Public Library Special Needs Collection
56 In a hallway connecting the front desk area through the young adults section and finally terminating at the multimedia area was an art gallery, with variou s framed works of all subject matter and medium, many of which were for sale. Figure 30: Central Brevard Publ ic Library Current Periodicals
57 Addendum Conclusions The Central Brevard Library does not succumb to many of the problems that the Hillsborough Libraries create for themselves. However, it does bring up several new ones. The Hillsborough libraries tend to have simple, straightforward, open layouts, where the Brevard Library is sprawling and can be confusing to naviga te. The dividing of the building into several small library units is reminiscent of the John F Germany Library in downtown Tampa, but the Brevard library takes it much farther. On the other hand, this contributes to the maze-like layout, as one can easily loose orientation when there are so many front desks. Light is handled much di fferently in the Brevard library, with spaces flooded with generous light that f eed work areas and relaxed reading areas, though most of the building is left in cave-like darkness. The childrens section is a world unto itself in the Brevard library, and though this effectively keeps the little ones out of the hair of those doing serious business, it is impossible for the parents of the children to keep watch unless they are in the childrens ar ea with them. Unlike the Hillsborough Li braries which have placed a focus on computer presence and access, it is an afterthought in the Brevard Central library. A small computer section exists, but it is comparatively insignificant to the computer labs of the Hillsborough libraries and pushed out of the way so that it can be difficult to find. From my own knowledge of the bu ilding I can vouch for its unwillingness to adapt and change. The only thing that has altered in the past twenty years is th e position of some of the pink chair-like objects throughout the building.
58 CASE STUDY 3 Four Major Attempts This case study looks at four major urba n libraries and their attempts to break th e mold. All were completed during the first decade of the 21st century. Each represents di fferent approaches, different leve ls of innovation, and different successes and failures in different areas. They are listed in ch ronological order by completion date. This case study will not be looking at the architecture or ev en the layout of these bu ildings, but rather focusing on the ideology of the innovations and its relationship to the traditional library.
59 Sendai Mediatheque (2000) The Mediatheque in Sendai, Japan is the greatest disappointment because it falls so short of its original conception. The aim was to cr eate the next evolution of library; the creators so firm in this assertion that they proposed it assume the fictitious name Mediatheque in place of Library to make it clear to all that this was something new. (Witte) The original design involved workshop-hubs that were to be centers of creation and teaching, that connected a series of distinct functions revolving around the various mediums of creation; books and writing, art and grap hic design, video and cinema, music and composition. In the end, political concerns and design by committee stifled the pr oject, and we are left with what I am about to describe. The Mediatheque owes its identi ty to the division between floors. Each area is comprised of one or more floors, and bears little relationship to the others. The ground floor need not be Figure 31: Sendai Mediatheque Exterior
60 the ground floor of a library at all there is a reception area, a large performance area, a bookst ore gift shop, and a caf. Above it is a library, comprising two floors, one of which is split with a mezzanine. Above that is an art gallery; if it were the second floor, or even the only other floor of the building, it would not have made a difference. All relationship with what is above and below is cast away, presenting a pure art gallery that could have been in any building, anywhere. Finally, the top floor is dedicated to multimed ia of an audio/video nature. An expansive library of stored media is available, along with more than adequate facilities to view this media. The Sendai Mediatheque is a seri es of fragments that occupy the same glass box. It is an informal performance hall; this area performs its function well. It is a library. Again, this function is performed well. It is an art gallery, and functions as properly to that end as any art gallery should. Finally it is a multimedia access venue, organized, up to date, and with all of Figure 32: Sendai Mediatheque Lobby
61 Figure 33: Sendai Mediatheque Stacks
62 Figure 34: Sendai Mediatheque Elevator the required technology and quantity of that technology to serve that function perfectly. If this had been the design goal, then the Mediatheque woul d have been a success. But, as mentioned before, the disappointment comes in how far short it fell. There is no relationship between the functions. The concept of the workshop, to bring the aspect creation into the library and have these work shops serve as hubs, central spheres of inspiration and energy from which all other parts of the institution derive their ideology, is completely absent. This building serves as a great warning to how easy it is to succumb to hesitations and cut th e concept short, one line at a time, until it falls apart completely. Because of its failures, more can be learned from the Mediatheque than any of the other examples. One cannot simply take the different fields of creative expression and place them in the same building and
63 Figure 35: Sendai Mediat heque Overlooking Street expect to create some new para digm of library evolution. Proximity does not breed synergy. I feel that the other danger that befell the Mediatheque is the crime of architecture for architectures sake The creation of the building itself as an objec t of glass and steel and the development of the spirit of the Mediatheque were divorced processes. It has been said th at the building could have easily become an office building. No other example need be given, as the office building is the perfec t expression of homogeneity and the generic. It is a blank template. Though this was seen as an advantage by those who work ed out the other half of the design; what to put in this generic box, the nail in the coffin was the lack of an architect or master builder on their side. If a strong leader with a strong vision and convictions had been present, the Medi atheque could have possibly rendered the Icomde unnecessary.
64 Salt Lake City Public Library (2003) The committee that designed the pr ogram for the Salt Lake City Public Library wanted more than just a library, they wanted a public city-center that was also a retail, commercial, and political center. The result is a bloated institution which combines the features of the traditional library with the layout and contents of a shopping ma ll, a landscape that creates a vast public plaza, and a physic al connection to the city hall building. It appears as if no compromises were made, and no expense spared. (Graham) This is indeed a powerful attempt at making a new kind of library, but rather than changing what a library is, the tactic is to throw as many other things into the mix as possible, to create the ultimate Library And. Figure 36: Salt Lake City Library Concourse
65 Figure 37: Salt Lake City Library Exterior
66 Figure 38: Salt Lake City Library View to Plaza It spirals up into the sky, with a touted three-sixty degree view of the city. Retail spaces o ccupy bays not unlike any typical shopping mall. Even the library facilities mimic this arrangement. The young adults section becomes a cantina though it is very unlikely that alcoholic beverages are served. The childrens section becomes more amusement park than library, though it also bears re semblance to a daycare. The bottom floor is dubbed a browsing library and resembles a current big-box bookstore, comple te with a caf and what has been described as a staff who are more trained to be conversationalists than librarians. A rooftop garden completes the eclectic assortment of environments offered. In some ways this mirrors the way distinct technologies have melded and merged into compos ite devices. Just as the personal computer combined a se ries of distinct tasks decades ago, and mobile pocket device s are similarly merging today, the Salt Lake City is attempting the idea that if the Library is
67 Figure 39: Salt Lake City Library View into Concourse obsolete on its own, take the technological model and simply add as many other functions to it as possible until it offers enough things to draw a large enough crowd. In cases where this combined similar technologies and functions, for instance, a printer/scanner/fax machine, it becomes very reasonable. In other cases, such as the popula r combination of the cell phone with the camera, it makes less sense. A cell phone does not need a camera nor does it fu nction better with one; and similarly being attached to a ce ll phone certainly guarantees a shoddy camera, but it offers an additional selling point, and a convenience to those unco ncerned with quality. So, in which category does the Salt Lake City Library fall? It seems to be a little of both. Some functions naturally complement one another, the merging of public, civic, and political institutions into one, whereas others seem tacked on and slightly superfluous; namely the addition of retail to the mix. I do not believe there is an ything wrong with adding retail
68 space to a library, indeed many common 20th century libraries include gift shops, cafes, and used book stores, but it solves nothing. It is an addition for the sake of having an additional selling point, that does nothing to face the true issues. It gets people to the library who would not normal ly go; but then anything else could be substituted for the library and the visit there would be the same. This library utilizes beautiful architecture, grand spaces, a plethora of appealing function s, and indeed a loosening of library tradition by conforming it to a different organizational model, but if all of the additives are removed from the mix, what remains is still a simple library, unchanged in conception, and sharing the fate of all libraries everywhere to fade into obscurity as print media is transferred online and to othe r electronic sources that do not require a building to store them.
Figure 40 : : Seattle Library Fi c c tion Area 69 Seattle L When it w 21st cen t that thi s whatsoe v vocabula physicall y However architect In spite o offers v e deal in u do som e stacks t compare d filled co m L ibrary (200 4 w as completed t ury. (Marshal l s library mak e v er. If by 21 s ry, then perh a y resembles n o as stated al r ure, it is conce o f its insistanc e e ry little that i s nique abunda n e thing new, d o t hemselves s e d to the lavis h m puter areas, w 4 ) it was hailed l ) On closer i e s no innovat s t century they a ps the term o library built r eady this stu d rned with libra r e that it is so m s unique, tho u n ce. The idea o something c u e em to be a h living-room-l w ith various gi as the first lib i nspection, it i ions or parad mean only a r can be accep in any other t d y is not conc e r y design. m ething novel, t u gh it does of f seems to be, i f u rrent, very m a lmost an a f ike lounges a n mmicks such a rary of the s revealed igm shifts r chitectural ted, for it t ime, ever. e rned with t his library f er a great f you cant m uch. The f terthought n d gadgeta s a fiction
70 section laid out like pickup sticks and a nonfiction section laid out in a spiral, possibly to distra ct the users into believing that they are experiencing something ne w. The benefit of playing it so close to the cuff is that there is truly little else to criticize about it. It functions as a curre nt library and offers all of the equipment and spaces one would ex pect from a current library. It is also reportedly very successful, and in spite of the unparalleled quantity of person al computers at the publics disposal both a waiting list and a time limit are required for these machines. Being a current li brary with no true change to the way things are done, it is difficult to evaluate from a simply ideological perspective, as th ere are no unique nor risky ventures to analyze. It does provide an excellent control subject. It is what one can ob serve as the standard course for the current library model to take if no innovations or ideological changes are attempte d. It can be treated as a benchmark against which new id eas can be measured. From that perspective, it is a very useful example. Figure 41: Seattle Library Exterior
71 Figure 42: Seattle Library Front Lobby
72 Figure 43: Chicago State University Library ROVER Chicago State University Library (2006) In this radical example, stacks are replaced with storage bins arranged in tight shelves wher e no browsers are allowed. Every book, CD, and DVD in the sch ools facility is tagged with a radio-frequency ID chip. Robots; named ROVER, (R etrieval O nline V ia E lectronic R obot), tall, forklift-style machines that run on tracks stow the materials in these bins contained in a three-story-high storag e facility. It takes about 35 seconds to get your book; one of 850,000 books in the robots storage, though there are an additional 250,000 books still in traditional stacks with some crosso ver. (Biba) (Graham) If the only advantage The Intern et had over the library was the way information was accessed, then the Chicago State University Library (CSUL) would ha ve just put itself at par. Assume for a moment that the entire library followed the new system; the 250,000 books still in traditional stacks did not
73 Figure 44: Chicago State Univer sity Library Interior Views exist, and the entire circulatin g collection was contained in storage bins and accessed by ROVER. At the users terminal, which does not even have to be in the library, the user conducts his or her search using an interface that is, fundamentally speaking, The Inte rnet. The user arrives at a selection using means identical to those which may be used in an internet search, an d then the user goes to get the book, not by searching again in a labyrinthi ne set of stacks, but by going to the dispenser and having the book hand delivered to them. However, in spite of appearance s at being at the cutting edge, the opposite is possibly true. Wh at has been described in truth bears less resemblance to the wa y we access the information online and much more to how it is done in the libraries of last century for example the Humaniti es Library in New York City. A request for a book is made. How the request is made is much different, but it is a re quest all the same. Someone some other person that is definitely not the person making the
74 Figure 45: Chicago State University Library T raditional Stacks request goes to where the book s are stored, in an area where the request-maker definitely canno t go, and if they did go, they would be unable to navi gate it and handily acquires the book and brings it to the requestor. The comparison becomes even more amusing when the existenc e of the dumbwaiter in the Humanities library is added to the mix, and thus the way the requester obtains the book becomes identical to the way it is obtained in the CSUL from the po int of view of the requester. The robot librarian, ROVER, does not ask for time off, but it can break down, and will break down in a power outage. It does not have to be given a paycheck, but it does require electricity for its motors and computers and radio frequency receptors. It is also only as smart as the one making a request. If the requester is looking for a book on the gravitational fields of quasars but can only find a general lexicon of astronomical phenomenon in the data search, ROVER is unable to tell the requester that the exact topic they need was actually covered
75 Figure 46: Chicago State Un iversity Library Exterior Figure 47: Chicago State Univ ersity Library Front Lobby by the March issue of Astronomy in 2004. (This is not the case it is simply an example.) Furthermore, if the requester actually went into the stacks themselves to find the book, it is very likely that right next to the lexicon of astronomy could be a book on gravitational fields. The ability to browse the contents of the Library is one of the key advantages it still possesses over online searches. This is lost in the CSUL. Th e advantages gained are, from the users perspective, no different from returning to a model abandoned decades ago. Of course, there are true advantages; the storage bins do not require the same environmental technology (lighting) as traditional stacks, and thus the energy costs of the robot are offset by the far grea ter energy savings. Less floor space is needed, saving on cons truction material. Indeed, no human other than technicians ever need lay eyes on the world of ROVER, so all creature comforts may be abandoned in favor of a purely mechanic al environment.
76 ROVER does the job of dozens of library staff-people who woul d need to be paid and have their needs catered to. From the management perspective, it is a dream come true. However, even this is not the case though information on th is topic conflicts, some resource s report that it requires an army of staff-people to keep ROVER user-friendly. The bins which contain the books do not contain a single book, nor can ROVER sort through them. These bins, which can come to the loading bay as many as twice a minute, contain four stacks worth of books each, which must be sorted through by humans now servants to the robot it seems before it can finally reach the requestor. The CSUL is the only library in this study which does not take the Library And approach, but instead focusing on changing the way the library actually work s. As dramatic a change as it is, it simply mimics an outdated system and replaces the human component with a mach ine, and trades one set of advantages and disadvantages for another set. It is also an important reminder that a prob lem will not be solved by simply throwing advanced technology at it; one must be certain that more problems ar e not being created than solved.
77 Conclusions Sendai Mediatheque is an example of great aspirations that fall short of the original conception. It illustrates a situation where compatible elements that should be integrated are kept separate fr om one another, in sp ite of being under one roof. It is a facility that attempted to redefine library, an d went as far as to invent a new name for itself, but instead falls short of this plan and becomes simply a library with several other features adjacent. The Salt Lake City Library is the most striking example of the Library And, though unlike the Me diatheque it is not taking elements that naturally integrate and combining them, but rather ta king elements that have lit tle to no relationship with one another and forcing a conglomeration. It seeks to reinvent the library not by evolving the concept along the lines of the information revolution, but by forcing a commercial sce nario a scenario that is successful an d unlikely to diminish in the hopes that some of that success will rub off on it. The Seattle Central Library is simply a standard library in a very impressive new container, but the container does little to progress the co ntents in any direction that is meaningful, innovative, or evolutionary. It takes what is current an d accepted and safe and adds more and more of it, all within a situation that is visually arresting, while adding nothing new to the table. The Chicago State University Library takes a far different stance the library is a pure library with no attempts at ot her features either integrated or made adjacent, nor is it concerned with taking what is current and simply wrapping it up in a new envelope. What it is doing however is taking a current problem and applying a ve ry old solution using very new tools. It mo ves forward by going backwards. It tackles the issue of access by simply adding a new middle-man, a hum an librarian replaced by a ro botic one, thus moving the problem around rather than actually addressing it.
78 A great deal can be learned from all four examples. It is difficult to take programmatic elements which naturally lend themselves well to accompany one anothe r and integrate them spatially in any me aningful way. It is tempting to simply create a melting pot of features, always adding more and more components to make up for the weakness of any one particular idea, until a conglomeration is created that si mply gets along because of the sheer inertia of the contents, and not because of any particular locomotive merits. It is a dead end to attempt to override the issue of innovation or development by simply adorning old ideas with progressively sleek an d aesthetically pleasing sk ins. Architectural heft alone is insufficient to cope with the depth of the problem. Finally, a solution cannot be reached by simply doing old things in new ways, by throwing more and more advanced te chnology into the mix, with identical beginnings and ends. If a true advancement is to occu r, there must be evolution at all points of the spectrum.
79 CASE STUDY 4 The Nexus at 5th and 40th What occurs at the intersection of 5th Avenue and 40th Street in midtown Manhattan is what I am calling a Nexus. It is a crossroads between a late 18th century library built in the early 19th century, The Humanities and Social Sciences Library; a mid to late 20th century library, the Mid-Manhattan Library; and an early 21st century library (arguably still a late 20th century library), The South Court, within the Humanities Library. All of this is within or adjacent to the context of Bryant Park, or more specifically the 5th Avenue terrace of the park, which acts as a threshold to the Humanities Library. The Humanities Library is a mighty Beaux Arts building that is perfectly at home surrounded by buildings five times its height, for in spite of this lofty distinction it manages to overpower all of its neighbors handily. It is a rare moment in New York City when your attention is so clea rly and effortlessly fixed on one Figure 48: New York City Humanities Library
80 distinct aspect of the cityscape and this is certainly one of them. Appropriately, the same is true for the interior of the library itself; the vast reading room has a similar effect on the contents of the building, even though it is only a small part, a mere fraction, when you consid er the total interior square footage. Part of the charm, or even quaintness, of the Humanities Library is the way the vast majority of it is simply off limits to the general public. This creates a mystique to the building, as if you were a visitor into a fore ign land with new customs which you must follow or face expulsio n. The five stories of stacks which remain hidden to the public eye can be seen as a metaphor for the contents of the books themselves; you have no proof that what is within is actually true, but you take it on good authority to be fact. These books cannot be taken from the library, thus compounding the mystique and feeling of being in a foreign land. No matter what you see and do within, Figure 49: Humanities Library Plans
81 no matter how much time you spen d, you can only depart with what you brought in with you, with the exception of the newly laid contents of your mind. There is an undeniable, almost tangible feeling associated with being within the vast reading room of the Humanities library. A hush falls upon all those who enter. In some ways it is merely an interaction between the physics of sound and human nature. We know we must be quiet within a library, but within this space the slightest noise bounces and echoes at an increased intensity such that the source of this noise is quickly made very self conscious. It is the amplification of the noise which demands that those within be quiet. But it is far more than a simple behavioral trick into a state of quiet. Something about that space is very conducive to feelings associated with study, learning, and thought. Why this is so is much more difficult to pin down, but I do have a theory. Figure 50: Humanities Library Sections
82 Figure 51: Humanities Library Reading Room
83 It has a great deal to do with the vast empty space that one finds ones self suddenly in Immediately the human scale is torn away with staggering effects. Suddenly, humility takes precedence. When I say humility I am not talking about self humiliation, which has come to be the popular meaning, but the older, spiritual variety of humility, which simply means to completely forget yourself. Forg etting yourself, that is to say, forgetti ng all of the thousands of trivialities which bounce around in our heads at every conscious moment, is the first step towards reaching a state where we can achieve anything remotely resembling studious. But, again, it has to be more than this. If it were simply the humility achieved by having the human scale violently torn from us in the direction of vastness, any great space would be a good spot for study. I imagine that this is not the case at all. One has only to look in the immediate vicinity to see other examples of vast open interior spaces: Grand Central Station, and any of the many great cath edrals in Manhattan. Though scale itse lf varies among these three examples, (Grand Central being much larger and most cathedrals not as large) in comparison to the human scale all three are equally vast. But why does the interior of the reading room elicit a feeling of thoughtful, scholarly meditation whereas these other spaces elicit nothing of the sort? Vast as th ey are, the shapes are different. Grand Central station involves a series of arched barrel vaults, creating a round dome-like interior. The arch is an excellent symbol for a gateway, for passage and thus transportation. A cathedral will use triang ular forms, indicating towards heaven and the divine. The reading room in the humanities library however is rectilinear.
84 It is a box. A box is for storage; here the storage of books. But what does that have to do with the quiet, contemplative ambience? An arch or a barrel vault indicate passage they evoke an attitude of what is forward, ahead. The pointed chambers indicating towards heav en indicate what is beyond as well, though here in a spiritual sense of the almighty unattainable and perfection. Both of these work well with the sense of humility, but in taking our focus away from ourselves, they are thrusting our attention so far out of ourselves as to render it improper for focused st udy. However, a box indicates no directions but simply inside and outside. Thus, when you are inside, your focus turns to within. Thus it is the simultaneous flood of humility combined with an inward focus, not inward into ourselves but inwards to whatever lines of thought we are internalizing, which is the source of this strong feeling a ssociated with the reading room in the Humanities library. It is the cause, and the rest are Figure 52: Humanities Library Fountain
85 simply fortifications: the colors, textures of the materials, the quality of the light, the intricate carvings of the woodworks, the fundamentally decorative books lining the walls. All of this is context which gives the already present foundation a fine tuned shape. It would still be very possible to feel this way without all of these surface details present. But with them present, it is impossible to feel any other way. It is not simply a room; it is a finely crafted emotional engine. Attempting the skeptics point of view, then shouldnt any sufficiently vast rectilinear chamber also evoke this feeling? As I mentioned above, surface detail s can be the deciding factor. For instance, unless one is totally ignorant beyond any recognizable measure of anything that has to do with indoor sports, a gymnasium will produce enough contextual identity to quickly override the effects of be ing a vast box. On the other hand, a similar chamber in a museum can potentially overpower the artwork present if the artwork is very bland Figure 53: Humanities Library Reading Room
86 and disinteresting and produc e in one present a state of quiet, inner reflection which would happily take the form of studiousness were a book and a ta sk thrust into the hands of the one bored by the artwork. (I am speaking from personal experience, when my visit to th e MoMA produced an excellent chance to open up my new cameras users manual.) Even if no book or task is thrust into the hands of the one present in the Humanitys Librar y reading room, the feeling is still inescapable because of the flood of catalysts for it. Still, if one is intent on avoiding any emotion one will usually find a way to do so, and this is no exception. But first one must find that intention, and I think that most would find that thought rather unappealing when it comes to this space. That is why this room is important. It is something only it can do. Icomde cannot match this, however, one must always be aware that there is usually more than one road to a desired Figure 54: Humanities Library Lobby
87 destination, especially when the destination is something so open ended as a feelin g. But then, just as we are ensorcelled so enthrallingly by the ambience of this chamber, nearby is something very new and very different that inspired a very different effect. I am talk ing about the South Court. (Barreneche) Where the reading room deals with the profound, the South Court deals in the novel. But it is merely novel. It is an interesting attempt at something clever, though perhaps it is its own cleverness that becomes its undoing, as it seems to be unable to cast off the shackles of being simply and utterly novel. It sets itself up as strikingly new in contrast to the antiquated to such a degree th at it cannot go beyond the contrast. It exists simply to provide the contrast, and any use or meaning beyond that becomes lost. As useful or successful or important as it may or may not become, and in saying this I am taking the position that it is neither useful nor successful Figure 55: South Court Ceiling
88 nor important, it could potentially be so some day. It can never escape the stigmata of being the shiny new bit of metal surrounded in a sea of aged marble. It is the novel eternally butting heads with the quaint. As long as the two are preoccupied with each other, little else is possible. Perhaps my attitude towards it would be diffe rent were I allowed into the glossy center of this contemporary gem, but restricting access to the public a dds a layer of mystique to it which does not do it any credit at all. Mystique has little place among the novel; that which is novel thrives on frankness and openness. In the humanities library the vast troves of restricted area, floors upon floors of material which is restricted from the public eye, hand, and foot, is an integral part of the character of the building. But to translate this character into the south court was a mistake. It is possible I was simply there at a poor time and that the south court really is as transparent, open, and completely accessi ble as its contemporary Figure 56: South Court Edge
89 architectural vocabulary would su ggest, but if this is the case there was no indication of when I should return for a second attempt. By all measures, it was closed; restricted; the great gold coin clutched in the palm that has no value in any real sense because the owner would never be willing to part with it. Icomde would, at a glance, posse ss much more in common with the South Court than it would with the Humanities Library. However, the South Court provides an excellent example of the first thing not to do. If you build it they will come; but not if you lock the door. Perhaps I am being unreasonable, as the South Court was not actually designed to be a new library within an old library, but simply another branch or division within the Humanities Library; a symbiote, not a partner. The strife begins with the presentation of the building and ends with the chafing disappointment which ensu es when one realizes the truth. This is simply not an attempt at creati ng a new 21st century library. Figure 57: South Court Entrance
90 It is a set of offices, a few cl assrooms, a theater, and several other multipurpose spaces which compliment the floorplan of the Humanities library. It is a triviality that it also happens to be a fine work of architectural imagination. This hurts it more than helps it, because of the gr and expectations it builds which ultimately have an impossible payo ff. The same old thing is far worse when it is dressed up as something new and different. This brings us to the third point in the nexus, a place that is neither novel nor quaint the Mid Manhattan library. Just because it lacks novelty of any sort does not mean that it is also devoid of the frankness which novelty requires; in fact it possesses frankness in great abundance, as if it were its proudest asset. In truth, the Mid-Manhattan library could be comprised entirely of unadorned concrete slabs filled with rows of shipping palettes stacked to the ceiling with cardboard boxes filled with books and it would make little differe nce, provided that the same Figure 58: Mid-Manhattan Library Exterior
91 quantity of places on which to assume a seated position and surfaces at which placing the ob ject of our interest is at a comfortable distance to both our eyes and hands were present. Here I could easily launch into a debate concerning what is architecture versus what is building versus which is strictly shelter, but to do so would be irrelevant, because this building renders any such thought proce ss as irrelevant. It stores books. It keeps them at a proper humidity to prevent mold and keeps direct sunlight from blea ching the coverings. It keeps the snow and the rain out. It pr ovides places to be if you do not wish to leave with the books, and if you do, the staff and equipment necessary to make this as painless a process as possible. It is the quintessential late-20th century library. It does not care to be anything else, and in fact cares about nothing at all, for no component is capable of eliciting any feelings at all from those within. I am not saying that this is inappropriate. If one is interested Figure 59: Mid-Manhattan Library Stacks
92 in a book, the building is not important. Much the way some will insist that a church is not a building but the people in it, and the building itself is irrelevant, here the library is the collection of books, and the bu ilding they happen to be in is irrelevant. While I was visiting this library, I was audience to a conversation which I could not have avoided, for the confines of an elevator car turn eavesdroppers into confidants. A visitor to the library was outraged that the first staff person she encountered was unable to help her, but instead pointed her to someone else. Now, in a differe nt situation one can clearly see how foolish this is. If one calls the plumber and a secretary answers the phone, one would not expect the secretary to come and fix the pipe s, nor would one become outraged if the secretary tells you that the pl umber, a completely different person, will be able to help you on Tuesday. However, in a library, it seems not so trivial at all and one may be tempted to Figure 60: Mid-Manhattan Library Reading Area
93 take this outraged individuals side. But in another sense it is an even greater absurdity to expect that the person at a desk is at fault for referring the guest to someone else for help, when one considers that the plumber s secretary could, assuming them physically fit for the task, do a plumbers work with only a few weeks of training, whereas a librarian will go to school to achieve this noteworthy title for many years of intense education. This is relevant because I do not expect the same thing would have happened at the Humanities library. The situation could have been exactly the same, but it is possible that the guest would have displayed understandi ng and patience, maybe even an awareness of why this was happening at all, in that, comparatively speaking, holy ground. In the Mid-Manhattan library, you are in a warehouse, and those who attend to you are not librarians, but warehouse workers, and in a warehouse, though there is still a hierarchy, the only distinct difference Figure 61: Humanities Library 5th Avenue Terrace
94 between the workers is that some have forklifts and others do not, and it is very plain for an outsider to tell the difference between a task that requires a fo rklift and one that does not. To the guest at the Mid-Manhatta n library, they expected that the help they needed did not re quire a forklift, and were thus offended when the worker, wh o was identical to all other workers present, indicated that a forklift operator was needed. If the three libraries are the no des in the nexus, then the 5th Avenue terrace of Bryant Park is the fabric of it. The Humanities Library is a resident of the park, not its purpose. During one of my visits, the 5th Avenue entrance to the Humanities library was closed. The library was not closed, but that way in was barricaded. Ho wever, the congestion on the terrace was not diminished due to this detour; in fact it was the most congested I had seen it. It was around noon, and thus many people were on the terrace seated enjoying takeout or bagged lunches. The fact that the entrance to the library was Figure 62: Mid-Manhattan Library Proposed Renovation Exterior
95 closed had no significance to th is end. The people gathered here are here for the park, not th e library the library provides context and a sense of place, bu t it is not the destination. Therefore, there is room for more. If this were not the case, if the parks sole purpose was to serve as a threshold to the Humanities Library, than putting Icomde on the 5th Avenue terrace would be a mistake. It is not simply a matter of if there is physical space, but if there is an appropriate expanse within the fabric of the nexus to allow for another node. There is. The situations described in this discussion are temporary; there is impending change. There is a progressing plan to remodel the Humanities library a remode ling so dramatic they will even change the name of the library (NYPL.org) as well as a proposal for a complete reconstruction of the Mid-Manhattan library which is even more of a departure than what is planned for the Humanities Library. (Gwathmey Siegal & Associates Architects llc.) Figure 63: Mid-Manhattan Library Proposed Renovation Street Edge
96 Figure 64: Mid-Manhattan Library Proposed Renovation Section Perspective Little information is available at the time of this writing, but the plan as publicized is to mode rnize the Humanities library by thrusting it into the late 20th century. Yes, the model they are proposing is cutting edge for la st decade. A great excavation under Bryant Park is planned to create a new high density storage space for the stacks pac king them in tighter than ever before, and the expansive 5 stor ies which have thus far been inaccessible to the public will be opened up for purposes yet vague and unspecified, though hints of information access are promised. The grand reading room is expected to remain mostly unchanged, except that it will no longer be the main public feature of the library; focus will be shifted to the new facilities, staging a war of old versus new within those halls. Of course, this is simply my perspective on the hyperbole-filled press releases concerning the plans.
97 Plans for the Mid-Manhattan Library are even more dramatic, though at the moment they remain on the drawing board. The structural shell and facade of the building is all that will remain, serving only as a template for an undulating column of steel and glass which will rise out of the site to twice the buildings original height. The plan for the completely new interior has echoes of the Salt Lake City Public Library, that is the commercialization of the library, creating a mixed library/retail/convenience outlet forged fr om the most contemporary of architectura l vocabularies. In spite of this bold plan, the cryptic use of indefinable term s such as information commons renders their intentions for innovation of function within this re-imagined building anyones guess. Though several hundred deskto p and notebook PC terminals for free public use are promised, this parallels the current dead-end folly of trying to bring the library into the information age by simply adding more and more PCs. One cannot turn a steak into a pastry by simply pouring sugar and flour on it. It is clear from both of these redesigns though one is moving forw ard and the other is simply a proposal at this point that the Public Library System in New York City is aware of the need for the library to change. It is also clear that they are committed to taking incremental, timid steps to this end, fo r as public institutions they are utilizing public funds, and this combination is inherently diluted. The need for a leader in this transition, something to take the bold, risky leaps that the public institutions are unwilling or unable to take, will be filled by Icomde. The other nodes in the nexus will be serving as a dramatic contrasting backdrop to highlight just how much of a leap Icomde is.
98 There will be no grand reading room in the same sense as in the Humanities Library, nor will there be a warehouse-like store of tomes as is publicly available in the Mid-Manhatta n Library and hidden from the public touch in the Humanities Library. It is unlikely that these roles will be removed from the existing facilities, and thus there is no need for Icomde to replicate or mimic what is already done That is the most important reason fo r Icomde to be set within this nexus the functions which it does not intend to fulfill will be fulfil led by its neighbors. It can be forged as a pure, complete vision and not diluted by ex pectations of convention.
99 CASE STUDY 5 The User Generated Revolution We access our information diffe rently today than in past decades and centuries. Why is th is a revolution? We still use books and radio, cable and broa dcast television, and now the Internet. The Internet can fill the basic role of all of these previous forms of information communication read, heard, and viewed but we are still merely reading, hearing, and viewing. The distinction lies in the directions the information travels. In previous eras, on ly a small few could write, and even though in modern times mo st people are literate, there are still only a scant fraction who are able to have their written works published for all to see. The same goes for radio and television it is consumption by the many the production of the few. However, with the Internet, the information travels in all directions at once. Figure 65: The Traditional System, 1800s to Present
100 To explain further, I will illust rate the case for books, since most of the information on the internet is text. For books, four players can be identified; authors, publishers, libraries (or bookstores), and readers. Traditional systems provide a linear approach where authors work through publishers to get their work to their readers, with the library as one possible outlet for this work. There was no way to get your work into the library without first going through a publisher usually a highly competitive corporation which has the bottom line as its highest priority thus the library, a fundamentally non economic/capitalist institution, is at the mercy of fundamentally economic/capitalist institutions to provide them with content. The internet has bridged the gap and connected authors to readers directly, and in effect, actually blurs the distinction between the authors and the reader s. The linear arrangement has been reorganized into a concen tric one. Authors are part of a reader community rather than disconnected through Figure 66: The Internet Bypass
101 Figure 67: Concentric Arrangement corporate publishing monopoli es, with these communities possessing the power over publishing and this power is almost always kept ex tremely egalitarian. This user generated revolution has been dubbed Web 2.0 (O'Reilly) by some (though the idea is tenuous considering that it was user generated content th at drove the Internet from its original conception) so that is the moniker this case study will use. Several distinct aspects of Web 2.0 have been identified, and this paper will briefly look at each in turn.
102 Figure 68: Social Networki ng Example Myspace Music Social Networking Though most immediat ely think of corporate goliaths such as Myspace and Facebook, in truth social networking groups on the Internet are extremely numer ous and varied. Though some use a specific theme, the fu ndamental design of social networking is to turn keeping ones address book into a gregarious and often competitive game. Users create a homepage which on the one hand resembles a personals ad, with biographic information, ph otos, and an onslaught of that users tastes, and on the other hand a constantly evolving and self updating address book, with all of that users friends, acquaintances, family and enemies, organi zed and just a click away. (O'Reilly) While Social Networking could be seen as the least productive or creative of the Web 2.0 aspects, it is also an important tool in allowing the aspects that are creative and productive to flourish. If a person does create something a story, a video, a song,
103 music, and so forth if they are involved heavily in social networking, they will have a much stronger chance of having their work seen and heard by many people than one who merely focuses on the creative works themselves.
104 Figure 69: Wiki Example Wikipedia Wikis If social networking is the mo st social and least productive aspect, then the wikis are its in verse. Apparently egoless and completely devoted to raw information, Wikis are compendiums of knowledge both factual and fictitious on every topic imaginable, designed so that any member user can add, and modify any content he or she choose s, as long as it conforms to the basic rules of that wiki. (O'Reilly) To one viewing a wiki, those who edit it can be completely invisible it is about the topic at hand, not those who are interested in that topic. To those involved in wiki creation, it can be a chance to associate with others who are as passi onate and knowledgably about a given topic as they are. The danger of the wiki is as old as information itself misinformation. Since they are written and maintained entirely by whoever wishes to, the risk is always high for the spread of ignorance, and outright malicious misinformation. The wiki is a
105 self governing system however, an d the hope is that over time, the content that rings the most true will rise to the top and the content that is false will eventually be edited out, but this is an idealization. Some wikis attempt to restrict access to certified experts on a topic, but this causes two problems what constitutes an expert, and does this make the resource no longer a wiki at all? However, one must not lose slee p over the idea that this tremendous phenomenon is the propagator of lies and deceit, considering that a major publisher is just as likely to publish a bestselling nonfiction book that is just as prone to malicious misinformation as any wiki.
106 Figure 70: Political Blog Example Texas Rainmaker Blogs Bridging the gap between social networking and the wiki are the blogs sometimes referred to as blogosphere when talking about the world of blogs. (O'Reilly) Like social networking, blogs are a gregarious, egocentric realm where who knows you is at least as important as what you know. Like the wikis, blogs are about information or simply what the one running the blog knows, thinks, or thinks th at they know. Blogs are often highly political, pridefully opinionated, intensely competitive, and ideologically driven. On the other hand, for every biledriven politically polarized rant-blog on the Internet, there is one devoted to photos of fluffy cute animals. An offshoot of the blog is the online journal, which unlike blogs, are not devoted to information that is either relevant or pertinent, but simple stories ab out the daily life of the author, written in the hopes of finding empathy, or merely to blow off steam. The dividing distinction comes with the idea that a blog
107 is somehow a work of amateur jo urnalism, whereas the other is merely an amateurs journal. Th e dividing line between the two can be difficult to pi n down, and some blogs/journals hard to categorize as one or the other, but it comes down to this. A blog is about a topic other than the author him or herself. An online journal is enti rely about the author.
108 Figure 71: Folksonomy Tag Cloud Artist's Interpretation Folksonomy The folksonomy is not a type of online site in itself, but a method of organization a site ma y use which makes it a part of Web 2.0. (O'Reilly) It is the technique of using tags to categorize content rather than a simple linear hierarchy. These tags are often generated at will by users rather than drawn from a list of prepared topics, and displayed to browsers as an alphabetized list in a justified block with each word a different size and boldness depending on how frequent the tag is. The folksonomy is used whenever a site is dedicated to the hosting of user-submitted content, such as video, art, photography, fiction, or music. However it is also widely used in social networking, wikis, and blogs. As a method of organization, it brings the ideology of Web 2.0 to the forefront. Often seen as a bottom-up approach to
109 classification, it empowers th e users and popular demand to shape the structure of the online environm ent, rather than delegating it to a small group of in the know individuals who must decide what goes where, what is more important, and who should know what. The orga nization is web-like, allowing a topic to exist under multiple si multaneous classifications, and organized in two directions at once alphabetization allows a browser to easily find the tag they want, and size distinction allows the browser to easily see what is the most or least popular.
110 Figure 72: Community Forum Ex ample Through the Looking Glass (TTLG) Forums The web forum is as old as the Internet itself, and as such often not considered a part of Web 2.0. Forums take many shapes and sizes, but basically come down to the ides of discussion. It is about many users sharing a place where topics can be freely (or not so freely) discussed among equals. Unlike social networking, a forum is devoted to a specific topic and it is that topic which takes precedence. Un like a wiki, no poster present may truly take the guise of authority and present information as fact all that is presented is done so for the purpose of discussion and debate. Unlike a blog it is not the case of many coming to read the words of a few all are granted equal voice, with no figurehead preaching to the masses. All of these are, of course, idealizations. Forums, like any area for human discussion, are prone to all of the pitfalls listed above, but somehow the idea is maintained.
111 I speak here from personal ex perience, as I am the founder and administrator of a forum which was founded in 1998, devoted to the discussion of cert ain carefully selected computer games. This forum ( www.ttlg.com/forums ) has over twenty thousand registered members (though only about a thousand are ever active at a time), and has generated well over a million posts during those ten years. At any given moment, about ten to forty of those regi stered members will be online reading or posting, with arou nd one hundred nonregistered guests viewing. In spite of its considerable size and popularity, only a staff of about a dozen ar e required to moderate this forum. Once a tone or style of governing as been established, as my staff and I have done over the past decade, the forum becomes remarkably self govern ing, with users knowing what to expect, what is and is not acceptable, and most conforming to these norms. Most infractions are given to new members who do not understand the forums culture with the moderation of long-time user s being extremely rare. Figure 73: Forum Example TTLG Threaded Topic View
112 Information as Place A strange phenomenon is taking place. People are beginning to associate in formation with place. I have noticed this occurring time and again on my own forum over the past de cade, with the users of this online community repeatedly expressing feelings of location, being, and even being at home, towards someth ing that is apparently no more than information displayed on a monitor. Yet, somehow, to many people, it is much, much more than that. It is not simply the deep camaraderie th at develops between members, or even the relationships that develop (some of which have resulted in marriage!) over the years. Many co nsider the forum, social networ king site, wiki or blog or folksonomyorganized media archiving site they frequent to be a place th at they go to to be with people that they know and like, and even greatly prefer to th e places that they go to be with people in the real world. I stress that this has nothing to do with virtual worlds presented with 3D graphics of visually-defined locati ons where users may control representations of themselves to interact with others (thoug h this thing I described certainly exists) it is common on the most simple, entirely text-dr iven discussion bulletin boards. How does this occur? I cannot pretend to understand the psychology behind it, but it is clear to me that it is the communication, the sharing of knowledge an d creative talents, which creates this bond and this sense of place about mere information. We cannot develop th e same sense from a book, newspaper, ra dio or television broadcast, because we are simply the audience. There is no thing to connect us to other people through our contributions and it is this
113 connection and sense of contribution which cr eates this idea of being in a place. If opening a book was able to connect us directly to the books author and allow us to interact with them in both directions, rather than simply one direction, then it is possible that a book too could ge nerate a sense of place. What is more interesting is that th ese are places that exist nowhere and we can take with us anywhere. I can just as easily go to my forum from my apartment, from studio on my laptop, or from the information commons in the librar y, and have the exact same ex perience (provided of course that their keyboards are in proper working order). Conclusions It is not merely the organizational shift from a linear top down arrangement of information from a small number of sources to a massive audience to a concentric one of source/audience communities wh ich defines the information revolution, nor is it the idea of millions of people worldwide sharing their knowledge and talents freely and with profound opportunities for finding that au dience. It is the strange sense of place that is generated from these virtual locations where information is shared, topics are discussed, talents are presented, and bonds are built. It is the revolution of information creating a sense of being and location and a reality that is, while maybe not more real, but somehow preferable to the real one. This is the information revolution which my thesis seeks to embrace.
114 CASE STUDY 6 Technologies Various emerging technologies impact th e design and nature of Icomde. Some of these will directly determine the programmatic functions and nature of the spaces, whereas ot hers are more conceptual in nature or tailor users experiences and do not necessarily have an impact on the architectural or visual design of any spaces. This case study will begin with the two most important aspects of computing: input and output.
Figure 74 : : Organic Light-Em itting Diode 115 Output Display t e first light essentiall y were ext r surprisin g feasible a embrace d plagued t energy t o angles, a n CRT, sim p T he orga n in displa y demand f image fid e Computing a e chnology can bulb. The fir s y that; extrem r emely bulky a g that when li q a nd affordable d Though the t he CRTs, the y o run, brought n d though the y p ly not thin en o n ic light-emitti n y technology. f or thinner dis e lity, and offe r a s Architectu r be traced bac k s t cathode ray t ely complex li g a nd heavy. C o q uid crystal di s display techn o LCD solved m y still required new problem s y were extrem o ugh. n g diode (OLE D Though curr e plays that us e r complete por t r e k all the way t t ube (CRT) dis g ht bulbs. As o nside r ing tha t splays (LCDs) o logy, they w e m ost of the pro an enormous s such as limit e ely thin comp a D ) is the next e ntly in its in e less energy, t ability is drivin t o Edisons plays were such, they t it is not became a e re quickly blems that amount of e d viewing a red to the great step fancy, the have high g research
116 and development of the OLED to make leaps and bounds. The OLED actually uses organic ch emical luminescence discovered from examining deep sea creatures. It requires no back-light, which allows the display to be millimeters thick, viewable in direct sunlight, and most dramatically, actually flexible. (Kageyama) Unlike CRT and LCD displays, the OLED would not be limited to restrictive bit-depths and aspect ratios, but able to take any shape and size. Because it is flexible, it allows for the possibility of curved displays that wrap around the users field of vision or, more excitingly, and with many more years of development, displays that can be freely rolled, twisted, and deformed as easily as a sheet of thin plastic. The OLED becomes pertinent to architecture when one ceases to see the computer as an object to be placed on a desk or table, and imagines it as part of the built en vironment. A computer could be the desk or table, or better yet, a window, or an entire wall, or even the floor and ceiling. If the OLED Figure 75: Flexibility in OLEDs
117 truly holds the promise that it pr esents, there could be no limit to how it could be incorporated into our daily environment. To truly grasp these possibilitie s, input must be discussed. Figure 76: Sony's 11" OLED TV
118 Figure 77: Traditional Input Device: Keyboard Input Active Input devices for computers evol ve slowly and greatly resist change. For example, the most advanced computers we use today still require devices similar to last eras typewriters for input. However, as paradigm s rapidly break down and the minds of innovators become open to new ideas, things are rapidly beginning to change. Input device s are being redefined into systems that allow computer s to understand active inputs such as touch and gesture, and understand passive input such as facial expressions. Touch screens themselves have existed nearly as long as personal computers themselves, but they remained inaccurate, slow to respond, and most import antly, only able to interpret a single input at a time. This me ant that only a single on/off command was possible no move ments or gestures, and no multiple inputs. Development progressed quietly in the form of
119 artists drawing tablets, improv ing the accuracy dramatically and implementing moti ons and gestures. Touch as an input device would no t come to the forefront until a system was devised to allow for multiple simultaneous commands, which suddenly allowed control over the interface to take on a much more natura l, organic system; no longer were users limited to poking with a fingertip or stylus; now one could dig in with both hands. This technique went mainstream with several popular products by Apple corporation, as well as lesser known but far more ambitious products by Microsoft, such as a computerized coffee table. While Apple was attempting to put a multi-touch interface in our pockets and Micr osoft in our living rooms (both at prices prohibitive to most) Perceptive Pixels much more Figure 78: Multi-Touch, Multi-User Microsoft Surface Table Computer
120 dramatic and ambitious design of creating wall-sized multitouch interfaces brought the technology into use by CNN and the US military. The input does not have to be human nor even intentional responses can result from an y detectable change in the environment. The key is that it is not simply multiple inputs that the devices can respond to, but different qualities of those inputs as well. Touch varies in pressure, speed, and proximity. A firm press is a different command than a wave or a tap. The touch of a cold finger or objec t can be interpreted differently from a warm or a hot one. Th e devices can tell the difference between fingers, stylus es, pinpoints, or broad surfaces such as cups or books; the weight of th ose objects; a full cup versus an empty one, a massive textbook versus a slight magazine. On a keyboard a key is either pressed, or it is not. A mouse is either moved, or it is not. With a multi-touch input, the quality of input becomes a vast array of possibilities, and the only Figure 79: Perceptive Pixel's Wall Computer
121 limitation is our ability to imagine different ways to make the machines respond to these inputs. With the multi-touch interface, graphics on the computer display can be treated by the user as if they were physical objects, with software appr oximating mass and friction amongst the objects so that they behave naturally, allowing for completely intuitive designs that do not require menus or complicated commands. It does not exclude these, however. Any type of system which prev iously required mouse input easily converts to the multi-touch interface. However, for text input, a typewriter-like graphic is still summoned to allow the user to type in letters a keystroke at a time. As Jefferson Han at Perceptive Pixel points out, it is only a matter of time before text input evolves to be tter suit the paradigm shift. Another element to the way mult i-touch will change how we use computers is the idea of multiple users. A personal Figure 80: Object Manipulation, Citywall, Helsinki Finland
122 computer is designed to be us ed by one person. When two people attempt simultaneous us e, the results are awkward and frustrating. With a multi-touch interface that allows for a practically limitless number of inputs, the number of simultaneous users for the inte rface is limited only by the physical size of the device and sp ace around it. As long as the shape of the device and ther efore the architecture of the work space allows for it and the computational power of the computer can meet the demand s, teams collaborating on a project can all work on the same machine, allowing for perfect synchronization of their work. Figure 81: Citywall, Helsinki Finland
123 Input Passive The multi-touch interfaces become truly powerful when combined with passive input syst ems that reach far beyond the users immediate commands an d into the way the interface tailors itself to the individual. Because the interface itself is the display, there are no mechanical parts to adjust, so the design of everything can be adjusted on the fly based on trends in the users activities. Specifically, head tracking is a technique that allows the computer to, at its most basic form, understand where the users eyes are. While the idea itself is extremely basic set up a camera with software that can identify the human face the possibilities behind this are complex. With a large multitouch interface, many users could be interacting with the same computer at the same time. Head tracking would allow the computer to understand how many Figure 82: Head Tracking
124 users it has, where they are, an d where their focus is placed. Suddenly a sea of input data becomes specific user experiences, tailored to each specific user. An additional benefit to head tracking is through simulated perspective in a three dimensional virtual environment. The position of onscreen elements can be adjusted to various degrees to create the illusion of depth, allowing these types of interfaces to be much more me aningful, and the simulation of on-screen elements as physical objects much more convincing. In action, the results are entirely believable, though it breaks down if an observer is present, as they would only be able to see the simulated perspective fr om the point of view of the primary user. The system grows in complexity if the computer is programmed to understand facial expressions. Prototypical examples of this are already in use at help desks where an artificial intelligence Figure 83: Depth Illusion in Head Tracking
125 can interpret the moods of th ose approaching and have the animated character on the disp lay react accordingly. The ability of software to recognize individual identities from facial recognition is lagging behind, however. Passive input taken a step farthe r results in body awareness. When integrated into architecture, this technique has less to do with a computers user interface and more to do with a computers understanding of wher e people are in the building. With this data, the computer could potentially create extremely efficient environmental control that adjusts on the fly to inhabitant activity or even the direction of the suns rays. It could also be a valuable aid in the case of an emergency. The walls of private offices could be come clear or opaque based on occupation; the same could be done with restrooms. Figure 84: Body Awareness
126 Input Multiple Devices Multi-touch need not be limited to multiple users on a single machine. It could also involve multiple machines or devices. Wireless technology has reached a point in our everyday lives where it is not only reliable, but taken for granted. Any potential new user interface must incorporate it as naturally as multi-touch can allow. The multi-touch coffee table, Mi crosofts Surface, is a good example of this. All one must do is place a wireless device on the table top in this case using Microsofts Bluetooth technology and the interface immediately assimilates it. A menu opens up surrounding the device with configuration options. Data such as photogra phs can spill out from a camera across the tables surface. The co ntents of a Blackberry expand to fill the entire interface. Figure 85: Wireless Interaction
127 Amusingly, physical objects ot her than wireless devices can interact with Microsofts table, though the results are more playful than productive. If a hot coffee cup is placed on the surface (it is a coffee table, afte r all) animations expand around it based on its weight and temper ature. It would warn us when our drink is getting cold. Childrens building blocks can be placed on the table with simple games that respond to the size and shape of the blocks. System s identical to these examples already exist in bars, such as th e iBar in Las Vegas, and many arcades in Japan. Figure 86: Multi-touc h Object Interaction
128 Input and Output as One Both of these emergent technologi es are in their infancy. The multi-touch display is sufficiently advanced and has already seen broad application in the pa st years. The OLED is much farther behind, and has the most room to grow. However, neither of these two ideas will ha ve come to their full potential until they are combined. It is not a question of if, but of when. The multi-touch display allows for a natural and invisible human/computer interaction, and the OLED allows for a natural and invisible integration of computer and the build environment. The successes an d advances of one will drive the other, as they naturally complement one another. Combined, a situation develops where a wall becomes transparent when a sensor detects a pair of eyes focused upon it. It responds to the pr oximity of a human being by immediately manifesting tools on its surface. Fingertips can glide across the surface or even hover above without Figure 87: Present Day Double Sided Touch Screen Interface (Otani)
129 touching to issue commands. Then, the person walks away and the display resumes being simply a wall. This person sits at their desk, which is simply a place where the wall is distorted to become a plane comfortable to rest ones hands upon, and the display once again springs to life. We communicate, create, and are entertained through this su rface that is at once a part of the architecture and a complex piece of multifunctional technology. The person gets up, and all that remains is the form. As an aside, taken in the other direction, one could conceive of a future where the OLED displays are built into eyeglasses (or something even more intrusive) and controlled either by eye movements themselves, or through some small and subtle bridge interface. Figure 88: Near-Future Multi-touch OLED Interface
130 Cloud Computing The idea of cloud computing is not new, but as bandwidth increases it has become more and more feasible. Cloud computing is simply software applications as a service rather than a product. For example, in the traditional system, when one wants a word processor, one would go to the store and buy a boxed piece of software, install it, run the application from their hard drives (which eats up valuable space which could go to data) and then save their work to the same hard drive. With cloud computing, no produc t is purchased. One connects to the internet, logs into a website devoted to that service, (maybe for a fee) and then uses the tools available to do the work they need to do. The pers onal computers processor does not handle the workload of the application. The application itself is not stored on the users hard drive (allowing that Figure 89: Of f -site Computing Warehouse
131 valuable space to be free for data) and if the user so desires, even their work can be kept on the remote server hosted by the company offering the service. In the end, the personal computer is then free to focus on the input and output experience, and the heavy lifting of the software application is handled by a powerful machine in a climate controlled warehouse far, far away. Thus, with cloud computing, it allows the design of computers as architecture to focus on the input/output experience of the machines use, and frees the de signer and the owner from the issue of providing climate-co ntrolled space fo r the powerful, and expensive, machin es to run the software. All that is required is a robust connection to the internet and a great deal of bandwidth. Figure 90: Cloud Computing Example Google Docs
132 Noise Cancellation Artificial silence co uld be conceived of as a simultaneous passive input and output system. In simple terms, microphones listen for nois e. Software interprets the waveform, and creates an invers ion of that waveform. The inverted waveform is sent to speakers, and if the volume is matched, the two sounds cancel each other out. More complex versions of the software can even distinguish one sound from another, so that everything but human voice is eliminated or only human voice is eliminated. In everyday situations, the benefits of a noise cancelation curtain are welcome. In a library setting, they are revolutionary. Childens areas would not need to be sealed into so undproof boxes, but open area, with all of the uproarious clamor on the inside of the invisible curtain, and blissful silence on the other. Groups working in study rooms would no longer need to monitor their voices, and private business meetings would not need to fear eavesdroppers. Figure 91: Noise Cancellation Earpiece Jawbone
133 Human to Human Input Computers can also aid in communication between human beings. Presently, several distinct technologies exist which can be brought together to allow people who do not speak one anothers language to have a conversation. Speech recognition can pick up what the speaker is saying, maybe with the help of a microphone-earpiece. The spee ch, converted to text, is sent to a translation server which converts message into the language of the other user. Finally, with a phonetic engine, the text is converted back into speech, and played back in the listeners own microphone-earpiece. Though all of these technologies are far from perfect at the present time, they are advancing, and it is only a matter of time before this can become a reliable system. In a library, especially one located in New York City, this could be an extremely useful tool, and a tremendous draw. Figure 92: Science Fiction Transl ation Device Babel Fish from The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
134 SITE ANALYSIS The site is located at the northe rn corner (considered northwest corner) of the intersection of 5th Avenue and 40th street in Midtown Manhattan. (Figure 14) There is no existing lot for this site, but is an intervention onto the lot of the Humanities and Social Sciences Library of New York City, formerly known as the Astor Library, completed in 1903. Extensive analysis of the Humani ties Library and accompanying Mid-Manhattan Library and South Court is present in case study 4. The street grid is shifted from the cardinal poles by approximately 33 degrees, though 5th Avenue is considered to run north-south. Figure 93: Midtown Manhattan
135 Figure 94: Bryant Park Area Diagram
136 Nearby areas of importance incl ude Rockefeller Center to the north, Times Square to the west Madison Square Garden to the southwest, Grand Central Station to the west, Central Park to the distant north, and Downtown Manhattan to the distant south. The Humanities Library and Bryant Park represent a break from the norm in the city fabric, a basin where an icon sits surrounded by towering struct ures many times its height (Figure 17), but still manages to dominate them all. Bryant Park is one of the largest parks in New York City (though it is still minute compared to Central Park, which could engulf several other large cities whole) Human activity density peeks directly in front and behind the Humanities Library, as well as the far end of Bryant Park centra lized around a great fountain. The northern edge of The Humani ties Library is more populous than the south, due to the secondary entrance to the Library as well as a major subway gate at the corner of 5th Avenue and Figure 95: Bryant Park Area Arial Figure 96: Building Heights
137 Figure 97: Figure Ground and Population Density 42nd street. New York City has many parks, but lacks green cover throughout most of the stre ets. The 5th Avenue edge of the Humanities Library is one exception to this, with many large trees providing shade to the surrounding street edge. The proposed location for Icomde would dislocate some of these trees. The area is immensely dense; on e of the densest locations in the United States. Density in midtown Manhattan is relatively homogeneous, and continues to be so north until far beyond the edge of Central Park to Up town where it gradually lessens, and to the south where densit y increases dramatically in downtown. Figure 97 illustrates this density with both figureground and activity (shown in red).
138 Figure 98 illustrated indicate a hierarchy of views as well as sight lines. The Humani ties Library, the red slice, is the most compelling element, visually, at the location, both due to its dramatic presentation and pr oximity. The nearby Knox Building, the dark orange slice, is noteworthy due to its unusual appearance, contrasting both th e Humanities Library and the surrounding cityscape A towering structure to the north reminds the viewer both of the Empire State Building, of which this is a predecessor by the same architect, and the Rockefeller center to the north, which shares its design vocabulary. The Mid-Manhattan Library to the sout h stands out due to its small size among giants; its closer relative nature to the human scale makes it much more accessible to the eye. Figure 98: Views
139 The forces diagram (Figure 99) indicates the intangible elements which push and pull at the sight, and cannot be quantified by any one factor, but rather is a sum of the whole. 5th Avenue is a major driving forc e, with the push and pull of traffic, vehicular and pedest rian, creating a constant turbulence. The magnitude of the Humanities Library easily overpowers this however, and creates a substantial edge which must be heeded beyond all other factors. The proximity of such centers as Times Square and Rockefeller Center are rendered nearly inconsequential due to the im mediacy and grandeur of the Beaux Arts building. Figure 99: Forces Diagram
140 The terrace itself can be broken up into several zones (Figure 100). The street edge wraps around all sides and connects to the terrace at three points. The central terrace makes up the main path to the Humanities Library, and is flanked by the north and south wings. At the far north and south are additional courts, separated from the main by a set of stairs, but connected directly to the street edge. Figure 100: Terrace Organization
141 The highest amount of motion (F igure 101) occurs at the street edge, where heavy tra ffic dominates the ro ad and pedestrians walk quickly along the wide side walk. Comparatively speaking, the activity on the terrace itself is still. Figure 101: Pedestrian Movement
142 The central portion of the terrace lined with steps and flanked by lions, fountains, and stone vases, is the most highly populated (Figure 102). Most ch oose to sit on the steps in direct sunlight than seek the sh ade of the nearby trees and the chairs provided there. Figure 102: Stationary Population Density
143 Circulation (Figure 103) is prim arily from the street to the central court, directed to the Hu manities Library interior. The north and south wings of the ma in court can be crossed to reach the north and south platforms. Figure 103: Circulation
144 The orientation of the site bathes it in full morning sun at all times of the year (Figure 104), th rough the towers to the east will cast long shadows across it. In the evening the bulk of the Humanities Library blocks ou t all direct sunlight. Figure 104: Solar Angles
145 During midday, shade is provided by many trees and the covered entryway of the Huma nities Library (Figure 105). However, due to the climate most visitors choose to avoid the shade in favor of direct sunlight throughout the year. Figure 105: Shade
Figure 10 6 Figure 10 7 6 : Icomde Logo 7 : Early Concept: I I comde 146 PROGRA Turning Icomde r and prop a architect u offshoot o beings, t integrate d Prototy p T his is a based in a of the lib r previous hubs an d becoming M Point r epresents a c a gation, huma n u ral integratio n o f the library, heir buildings d p e prototype for a specific plac e r ary would coe x eras or stand d propagating commonplace c rossroads bet w n computer i n n It is not but a turning and their i n a new breed e or time, but a x ist side by si d alone, starti n to other lar g in any small t o w een informat n terface, and c simply an e v point in the w n formation tec h of institution t a n epoch. Thi s d e with its iter a n g in major in g e cities, bef o wn. ion access c omputer v olutionary w ay human h nology is t hat is not s evolution a tions from ternational ore finally
147 Midtown Manhattan, New York City: 2020 The selected site is the northern corner of the intersection at 5th Avenue and 40th street; on the south terrace of the monumental beaux-arts New York City Humanities and Sociolog y Library, considered to be one of the most important libraries in the world, directly opposite the contemporary Mid-Manh attan Library. The existence of these two important buildings, plus the South Court, an addi tion to the Humanities Library which in tegrates modern technology and design sensibilities into the old building, creates an information and cultural nexus. Nexus It is important that the first Icomde be placed among information centers of pre vious eras, and not isolated from them. It declares that this is something new and different, and is not hiding from the past nor is it trying to overwrite it. The three very different institutions will coexist and allow each to be as unique as they need to be without overlap of functions. The Humanities Library is a cathedral to kn owledge. The Mid-Manhattan library is a warehouse for the storage of information. Neither of these functions will be attempted by the Icomde. It will allow the Icomde to focus on what is new and different rather than attempting to fulfill niche expectations.
148 Technology Multi-touch is a human/computer interaction technique and the hardware devices that implem ent it, which allow users to interact with the machine using multiple simultaneous touch points. It also allows for a potentially unlimited number of simultaneous users at one ma chine. There are numerous methods for detection of these touch points, the most common of which is relative finger pressure. Body Awareness uses a variety of sensor and detection methods with computer softwa re that can apply data on occupant location and activity to provided a variety of functions, including reactive environmental control, the ability to distinguish between users in close proximity, computing experiences better tailored to heavy or light traffic, or to aid in the management of an emergency. Figure 108: Multi-Touch
149 Head Tracking uses video input of the human face for application use, such as the creation of natural perspective in a three dimensional scene, interaction with an artificial intelligence, or personal identification. OLED displays employ organic light -emitting diodes, which are light-emitting diodes (LED) whose emissive electroluminescent layer is composed of a film of organic compounds. Development of OLED technology is leading in the direction of very thin, completely flexible, highly transparent electronic display materials that can be made into any shape or form. Noise Cancelation is a process that involves a microphone, software, and a speaker. Waveforms are picked up by the microphone, the software inte rprets them, and sends an inversion of that waveform to the speaker. The speaker emits the new sound, and the two waveforms are canceled out. Figure 109: Organic Light-Emitting Diodes
150 Cloud Computing is a style of computing in which IT-related capabilities are provided as a service, allowing users to access technology-enabled applications from the Internet without knowledge of expertise with, or control over the technology infrastructure that supports them. It puts a cons iderable amount of computing power at the users fingertips without needing the processing power to support it. Wireless Data and Power transfer means that any buildin g component that involves comp uter technology need not be tethered to any single location, and may roam freely. This allows furniture and partition walls outfitted with computer interfaces to have very flexible uses and configurations. Personal Mobile Devices of any type or form should be able to interact with the technology present intuitively, invisibly, and automatically, whether its transferri ng ones work from a mobile device to a work terminal and back again, viewing the display output on an OLED equipped eyeglass rather than on the interface itself, or quickly accessing a users customized settings. It is the combination of these technologies which defines th e human/computer/architecture relationship in the Icomde.
151 Cascade The cascade is the omnipurpose tool of the Icomde, an OLED computer display with multitouch technology through which all information interaction and creative pursuits take place. It will also feature wireless integratio n of function with personal mobile devices. It will be present in several variations, very similar in technological aspects, but differing in the way it is architecturally utilized. Cascade Plaza. In this arrangement, the cascade exists as isolated features in an open air public plaza, and can be accessed and used by any casual passe rby. It is distinct in that it is a completely stand-alone piece, neither connected visibly to the Icomde itself or to one another, but free-floating units. Most of the cascade plaz a is situated on the 5th Avenue terrace of the Humanities Library, but much of it also exists on the street edge of 5th Avenue and 40th Street. Figure 110: Early Concept: Cascade
Figure 11 1 1 : Early Concepts: Cascade Workflo w w & Team Pod 152 Cascade shapes s comforta b tables an d continuo u either rej o of the cei l Ether. hypothes i observabl and tran s space of completel Workflow. In s imilar to de s b le for prolong e d desks howev u s piece, which o ins it at the o l ing or floor. This comes f i zes a substan c e emptiness. s parent panel s areas betwee n y open or fille d this arrange m s ks and tabl e e d, focused act er, the Cascad separates its e pposite end, o r rom the me a c e that fills all Because the c a s ether is us e n strips of the d with comfort a m ent, the cas c e s to create ivity by the us e e-workflow wo e lf from the wa r changes to b e a ning of the space, regard a scade is esse n e d to describ e cascade. Eth e a ble seating. c ade forms situations e rs. Unlike uld be one ll and then e come part word that less of the n tially walls e the f loor e r is either
153 Pods In this arrangement, the cascade is separated into isolated ringlets to create private work areas for small groups. These chambers feature both privacy sh rouds, which occurs when the OLED display becomes completely opaque, and noise cancelation. Team Pods. Small chambers of various size designed for use by three to six people. Studio Pods. Larger chambers designed for use by approximatly a dozen people. Edu Pods. Similar in size to studio pods, but with the work interfaces oriented inwards with an open center. In this configuration users focus is on one another rather than Figure 112: Early Concept: Cascade Terrace
154 simply their interface, with room for an instructor to interact with the entire group or individuals in turn. Conference. Similar to the Ed u Pods, but without the open center, for a fully egalitarian environement. Other Features Caf A, B, C. Two locations will be offered that serve refreshments, one amidst the cascade terrace, dubbed Caf C, and another on the sixth floor of the interior, dubbed Caf A, B. Gallery. A perminant exhibition hall for temporary exhibitions, either to be rented by the community for presentations or displays, or orchestrated by the staff of the icomde to present works created by its members. It is divided so that several exhibits may be displayed si multaneously and separately. Figure 113: Early Concept: Cascade
155 Childrens Area. The play area will be heavily shielded with noise cancelation. Head trac king and body awareness will allow parents to keep tabs on their children from anywhere in the building, through the use of observation cameras. Additionally, animated characters living in the childrens cascade panels could be controlled by parents anywhere in the building, allowing them to interact from afar. Auditorium. Rows of seating are oriented towards a lectern and the twenty foot ta ll cascade wall behind it. The speaker at the lectern has control over this cascade wall from the interface on the lectern itself.
156 Figure 114: Early Concept: Cafe
157 Organization The First Icomde will consist of three components. The first, Cascade-Plaza, is already discussed above. The features of the ground floor will spill out into the main terrace of the Humanities Library, until breaking up into stand-alone units that are placed sporadically until the edge of the central terrace. The core, which is centralized ov er the south-most court of the terrace, will be the hub of all Icomde activity. It will be narrow at the ground floor and above, but widen considerably towards both the street edges and the te rrace as it goes upwards to a total of fifty feet. It will contain within all features of the Icomde, with the exception of the cascade-plaza. The South Wing extends halfway down the Humanities Library s southwestern elevation. Th is space will not exist as distinct floors, but as an open span wi th spiraling catwalks that gradually make their way from floor to floor. These catwalks will be domina ted by the cascade; a fully function al programmed circulation space. Figure 115: Early Concept: Organization
158 Total Square Footage: 65327 sq.ft. 1st Floor & Street Edge Total: 8997 sq.ft. Cascade Street Edge 6123 sq.ft. South-most Terrace 1556 sq.ft. South-most Terrace Interior 823 sq.ft. Restrooms 183 sq.ft. Circulation Core 312 sq.ft. Second Floor and Terrace Total: 17069 sq.ft. Cafe C 838 sq.ft. Gallery 1736 sq.ft. Reception 2665 sq.ft. Edu-Pod 857 sq.ft. Cascade Plaza 7361 sq.ft. Cascade Workflow 1918 sq.ft. Ether 1382 sq.ft. Circulation Core 312 sq.ft. Figure 116: Cascade Plaza
159 Third Floor Total: 10860 sq.ft. Children's Area 2809 sq.ft. Beux Arts Edge 718 sq.ft. Team Pods 838 sq.ft. Ether 6183 sq.ft. Circulation Core 312 sq.ft. Fourth Floor Total: 12354 sq.ft. Terrace Observation 1282 sq.ft. Open Air Workflow 2246 sq.ft. Cascade Workflow 2235 sq.ft. Team Pods 700 sq.ft. Ether 5579 sq.ft. Circulation Core 312 sq.ft. Figure 117: Team Pods
160 Fifth Floor Total: 11405 sq.ft. Conference 565 sq.ft. Auditorium 893 sq.ft. Staff Offices 691 sq.ft. Edu Pod 597 sq.ft. Studio Pods 412 sq.ft. Cascade Workflow 1811 sq.ft. Ether 6124 sq.ft. Circulation Core 312 sq.ft. Sixth Floor Total: 4642 sq.ft. Cafe A 788 sq.ft. Cafe B 568 sq.ft. Ether 2857 sq.ft. Restrooms 117 sq.ft. Circulation Core 312 sq.ft. Figure 118: Auditorium
161 FINAL SCHEMATIC DESIGN IMAGES
162 Plans Figure 119: Plans Site Plan
163 Figure 120: 1st Floor Plan
164 Figure 121: 2nd Floor Plan
165 Figure 122: 3rd Floor Plan
166 Figure 123: 4th Floor Plan
167 Figure 124: 5th Floor Plan
168 Figure 125: 6th Floor Plan
169 Figure 126: Rooftop Plan
170 Sections Figure 127: Street Section 5th Avenue
171 Figure 128: Street Section 40th Street
172 Figure 129: Section A Through Terrace and Core
173 Figure 130: Section B Through West Wing and Core
174 Elevation Figure 131: Elevation 5th Avenue
175 Rendered Perspectives Figure 132: Rendered Perspective 1
176 Figure 133: Rendered Perspective 2
177 Figure 134: Rendered Perspective 3
178 Figure 135: Rendered Perspective 4
179 Figure 136: Rendered Perspective 5
180 Figure 137: Rendered Perspective 6
181 Figure 138: Rendered Perspective 7
182 Commissioned Perspectives Fi g ure 139: Watercolor and Ink Pers p ective 1 Commissioned
183 Figure 140: Watercolor and Ink Perspective 2 Commissioned
184 Model Photos Figure 141: 1':0.1" scale model, acrylic, plastic, and wood
185 Figure 142: 1':0.1" scale model, acrylic, plastic, and wood
186 Figure 143: 1':0.1" scale model, acrylic, plastic, and wood
187 Figure 144: Site Model, 1:400 scale, Icomde piece courtesy of Engineering Dept. Rapid Prototyping
188 Figure 145: 1:400 scale, Icomde piece courtesy of Engineering Dept. Rapid Prototyping
189 REFERENCES Barreneche, Raul A. "Davis Brody Bond Give s New Life to a Beaux-Arts Grande Dame, with the Modern New South Court of the New York Public Library." Architectural Record 190.11 (2002): 134-41. Biba, Erin. "Biblio Tech." Wired 15.1 (2007) < http://www.wired.com/wire d/archive/15.01/start.html >. CityWall, Helsinki. "CityWall." 2008. < http://citywall.org/ >. Graham, Jefferson. "Here's America's Unquietest Library." USA Today < http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2003-10-13-library-usat_x.htm >. Gwathmey Siegal & Associates Architects llc. "The New York Public Library Mid-Manhattan Library Renovation and Expansion Projec t." 2007. < http://www.gwathmey-siegel.com/port folio/proj_detail.php?job_id=200001 >. Kageyama, Yuri. "Sony Bends Video Display." AustralianIT (2007) < http://www.australianit.news.com.au/s tory/1,24897, 21805296-501304 0,00.html >. It Toyoo, and Ron Witte. CASE--Toyo Ito, Sendai Mediatheque Munich; Cambridge, Mass.: New York; Prestel; Harvard University Graduate School of Design, 2002.
190 Marshall, John Douglas. Place of Learning, Place of Dreams: A History of the Seattle Public Library Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press, 2004. Microsoft. "Microsoft Surface." 2008. < http://www.microsoft.com/surface/index.html >. NYPL.ORG. "New York Public Library Unveils $1 Billion Transformation Plan." March 11, 2008 < http://www.nypl.org/press/ releases/?article_id=86 >. O'Reilly, Tim. "What Is Web 2.0? Design Patterns and Business Mode ls for the Next Generation of Software." September 30th, 2005 2005. < http://www.oreillynet.com/p ub/a/oreilly/tim/news/2005/ 09/30/what-is-web-20.html >. Otani, Takuya. "Double-Faced Touch Panel Display Debuts." Tech-On (2008) < http://techon.nikkeibp.co.jp/en glish/NEWS_EN/20080829/157145/ >. Percetive Pixel. "Perceptive Pixel." 2008. < http://www.perceptivepixel.com/ >. Rybczynski, Witold. "Borrowed Time, how do You Buil d a Public Library in the Age of Google?" Slate (2008) < http://www.slate. com/id/2184927/ >. Council on Library and Information Resources, and Geoffrey T. Freeman. Library as Place : Rethinking Roles, Rethinking Space Washington, D.C.: Council on Library and Information Resources, 2005.
191 BIBLIOGRAPHY Bazillion, Richard J., and Connie Braun. Academic Libraries as High-Tech Gateways : A Guide to Design & Space Decisions 2nd ed. Chicago: American Library Association, 2001. Conference on Integrated Online Library Systems, et al. IOLS 2000, Integrated Online Library Systems : Proceedings--2000, New York, may 17-18, 2000 Medford, NJ: Information Today, Inc., 2000. Cox, Sarah. "New York Public Library Restores anothe r Beautiful Space [Map Division]." Architectural Record 194.2 (2006): 34. Crosbie, Michael J., and Damon Douglas Hickey. When Change is Se t in Stone : An Analysis of Seven Academic Libraries by Perry Dean Rogers & Partners, Architects Chicago: Association of College and Research Libraries, 2001. de Laubier, Guillaume, and Jacques Bosser. The most Beautiful Libraries in the World New York: Harry N. Abrams, 2003. Ferguson, Amalin. "NPS Libraries Co me of Age: Building the NPS "Vir tual Library"." CRM: [bulletin] .6 (1998): 36-8. Foster, Nancy Fried, and Susan Gibbons. Studying Students : The Undergraduate Research Project at the University of Rochester Chicago: Association of College and Research Libraries, 2007. Kellogg, Craig. "The Mid-Manhattan Library Under Wraps." Oculus 63.7 (2001): 6-7.
192 Kenney, Anne R., Council on Library and Information Resources, and Anne R. Kenney. E-Journal Archiving Metes and Bounds : A Survey of the Landscape Washington, DC: Council on Library and Information Resources, 2006. Lueder, Dianne C., and Sally Webb. Administrator's Guide to Library Building Maintenance Chicago, IL: American Library Association, 1992. Mitchell, Marilyn. Library Workfl ow Redesign : Six Case Studies Washington, DC: Council on Library and Information Resources, 2007. Pace, Andrew K. The Ultimate Digital Libr ary : Where the New Information Players Meet Chicago: American Library Association, 2003. Schultz Jones, Barbara. An Automation Primer for School Library Media Centers and Small Libraries Worthington, Ohio: Linworth Pub., 2006.
194 Appendix: Icomde Story The following short story, done in the st yle of a single chapter excerpted from a novel, was part of the early design process done to illustrate what a visit to the Icomde might be like. Furthermore, it was taken beyond the scope of a mere descriptive narrative and into the fr amework of a novel chapter to coincide wi th the spirit of Icomde as a creative outlet, in a culture where writing is no longer limited to prof essional authors, and storytelli ng can be shared with anyone the world over. Icomde Story. Chapter 2. Morden Wakes Up It was just a bit past two in the morning. She just got finished telling me I told you so. In more words. Yeah, I said in reply. Youre a real Cassandra. Does that mean youll never believe me no matter how many times Im right? No, it means no matter how many times I do believe you, youll only remember the times I didnt. .
195 It all started when I got the call at half past eleven on a Tuesday morning. Mister Morden, the voice said, sounding like it had been sucking air through a filter since it was ten. My name is Calhoun. I hear youre good at dealing with people. You heard wrong, my own voice said, probably sounding like I had just swallowed a porcupine. Im good at observing people. Its my partner who does the dealing. Whatever the details are, he replied qu ickly, I am sure will be made apparent as they are appropriate to make apparent. It took me a second to untangle his odd statement. Any mi nd that could work linguistic loops like that was not one I wanted to spend very much time talking with. And who de cides that, you or me? I wa s already on guard; already sparring. It was like I had been talking with him for an hour already. This was where the conversation was going to go, so there was no point in delaying it. If the details are mine; I decide. If they are yours; you decide. Why are we talking about this? Is this how you always deal with potential clients? Ah, but you did just tell me that it is your partner who does the dealing. Should I have called him? Her, I said, knowing full well that he knew that my partner was a she. Florence Point. He was feigning ignorance. Everything was a game to this one. I knew it as soon as he laid down that BS about me being good with people.
196 Ah, so Doctor Point is a woman. Well then, perhaps I should speak with her ? I yawned, a long cat-like yawn which I was sure gave him a clear mental image of a long furry beast arching up its back to twice its normal height. Shes not exactly sitting acro ss the desk from me holding her hand out for the phone, was all I said. I figured he was old enough to remember the days when phones we re objects that could be passed from person to person. This conversation wa s pointless. Why was he being so rounda bout? He was stalling for some reason. He was trying to reason me out; that or giving me someth ing to reason him out with. Did he want me to know the truth, or was this some show to misl ead me? More importantly, why was my glass empty, and how could I survive the next minute if this wasnt corrected? I reached for the bottle on the shelf as I waited for his calculated reply. I can see you have a sense of humor. That was nonsense. If he has born witness to my sense of humor hed have dropped the phone because he was laughing too hard; or to pick up a blunt object in order to bludgeon himself to death. I think you and I will get along after all, Mister Morden. He has been planning to say that all along, but was probably hoping that there would have been a better lead-in to it rather than that BS about my sense of humor. I waited as he pronounced every syllable hoping that his next sentence wo uld have some relevance, and not be just some rhetoric designed to make me more amicable without knowing why. I was way, way too disconnected from the normal human thought process for that. We should meet along with your partner, and discuss this matter further. I think I can pay your rent for the rest of the year, if all goes well.
197 In that case, I had better find better di gs. As long as youre spouting vague promises I may as well take advantage of their full nebulous implications, eh? Ill see you at Ostafs Burgers in two hours. I could tell from the start that this was going to be all abou t long pointless conversations designed to trick the listener into revealing something about his-or her character that coul d be used against them. Or maybe this guy was just as bad at dealing with people as I was. Either way, I had Flow on the line next and was yammering the spiel to her. He actually said that? she said in the least deadpan to ne she was ever known to make unless she was deliberately putting on a show. It was how I knew she was amused. Or irritated. With her it didn t really make a difference, because she usually found her own irritation to be a source of amusement. She was, of course, talking about the part where Calhoun pretended to think she was a man. One of the problems of that whole Doctor thing, I said, taking her infinitesimal display of emotion to be an invitation to tease. Makes that glorious sex appeal you try so hard to manufacture all pointless. No pun intended? she asked, but completely dry that time. Figures shed latch on to the unintentional wordplay and completely dodge my ribbing. But, that was how I knew she liked me. If it was anyone else shed have played along. She didnt like playin g along. It was how she avoide d actually bonding with anyone. I met her on the way there. A trench coat? was all I said when she finally caught up with me. This time of year?
198 Your comment about my glorious sex appeal cut me to the core. I figured I may as well go unisex today. I wasnt going to look her up and down. I was walking too qu ickly down a busy sidewalk, an d wasnt nearly cool enough to walk without watching where I was going without tripping or ramming into someone, so my reply had to go without the sight gag. You really dont understand people, do you? Far sooner than I wanted but far later than my legs cared for I was sitting in a booth at the di ner with Flow at my elbow. The waiter came up, spoke the only English words he probably knew, and she and I both replied, Coffee. A few silent seconds later and I was drinking the stuff. It was half as strong as I liked, and much too sour. This is why I hated places like this. On the other hand, the burgers would be to die for, if I hadn t already eaten two hours ago. Still, the smell of bacon from the kitchen was taking my mind off that burrito I had just crammed down. So if were meeting him here, he knows what we look like, or you know what he looks like. I doubt the girl at the front is going to act as our liaison without prompting. She sounded annoyed. I probably interrupted her during an exciting date with a frogs brai n she was dissecting. Fatso, I just said. What? The name of this place. Ostaf. Its Fatso backwards.
199 She stared at me in silence for a moment before saying, OK. Id say hes about five-eleven, but thinks hes six-two. Tw o sixty pounds, at least, with forty of that in his gut and twenty in his shoulders. He moves like hes used to having a gun in his pocket, but hasnt worn one for years. Hes used to wearing sunglasses, but doesnt anymore so he squints all the time. Way too much hair gel. Did you get all of that from talking to him on the phone, or is he walking up to the table right now? Neither. NotFlinn just sent an image to my mobile. Huh, she said as she craned her neck to see the photo glow ing from the small display. So hes important enough that NotFlinn could dig up an image of him just like that. This should be interesting. Havent you ever egosurfed be fore, Flow? I bet I could call up a photo of you from the web, cold Hell, I bet I could even find one of you in a bikini. That would be a neat trick, consid ering that Ive never worn one. Dont be silly. Dont you know that these days photoshop comes with an au tomatic make into racy tabloid photo filter? Came out back in 25. How do you think that industry survived the outlawing of paparazzi? These days all celebrity photos are complete digital fabs. And how do you know all of this? Considering a career change?
200 And so it went on. We always had our best conversations when we were bored and had coffee. We were both on our second cup of coffee when he arrived. Th e photo was old. It looked more like fifty of the extra pounds were in his gut now, and there wasnt enough hair to ge l anymore. If he ever got a new photo taken he definitely would want to use some type of filter. The take off twenty years and fifty pounds one was especially overused. Without having to say anything Flow switched on her earpiece, and I did as well. Good thing youre so skinny, I subvocalized to her, when he sits down hes going to smash with th is table. Why did we have to get a booth? She gave no reaction to betray that sh e had heard me, but I had gotten far too us ed to using the earpieces to have any doubt that she did. Every sarcastic remark, every joke abou t his balding head would be he ard loud and clear, while to him it would look and sound just like we were picking food out of our teeth with our tongues. So good of you to both come, he said, with the same vo ice I had heard on the phone bu t with a completely different attitude. Either it was the diner settin g, the promise of food, or the presence of a woman that changed his demeanor, or this was just another one of his games. I braced myself for the impact of the table against my ribs. Then I remembered another reason why I hated diners; I wanted a smoke. Lay it on heavy, I told her silently. Hes caught off guard by you. He doesnt expect to be treated well by a woman, so you can put him off his game.
201 Ask me to walk over hot coals, why dont you? After she got done complaining, Flow smiled warmly and said, Not at all, Mister Calhoun. Im always excited to meet with new clients! Oh, please Doctor Point, call me Martin. And must I remain so formal with you? She gave a musical laugh and said in her best sing-song voice, Doctor Point isnt formal, Marin, its flattering. Dont overdo it. I think I just threw up a little. Are you sure its not the coffee? She sweet talked him and I kept my mouth shut, or at least, thats what he would think. I never stopped feeding her information. She talked, I observed, and what I observed Id tell her; raw information, what he was thinking. I couldnt read his mind, but everything he did stood out to me like it was blared through a bullhorn. I noticed every twitch, every glance of his eye, ever y change in tone. I come to you on the behalf of an asso ciate-friend of mine. Hes in a bit of trouble you see, and we need a third party to quietly intervene an d help him disappear. Associate-friend? He broke eye contact. Hes gripping the pointer finger of his right hand with his thumb, tugging at it several times before letting go. He keeps glancing outside. As he said disappear he shifted uncontrollably.
202 She knew what to do with it She couldnt see it herself that much was lost to her, but she knew what it all meant that much was lost to me, and how to react to it. How to me asure him. How to figure him out. It was how we always worked with clients. It was how we always worked with en emies. People who were clev er and knew about the latest gadgets would possibly figure out that we were communi cating subvocally, but no-one knew about our particular talents and how we worked together. He goes by Willard. Perhaps youve heard of him? Back in the revolutionary days they would have called him first in line to be hanged! No-one knows who he is, except his closest friends of course, and he aims to keep it that way. There are those who dont like what he thinks or says. Those that would mean him harm. Well thats about to happen, but not if you can help me help him. I relayed everything to her as I saw it, quickly, silently. I co uld subvocalized far faster than he could talk. Do we even need to go through this? Even I can tell this guy is lying his fat ass off. No, hes not lying his ass off, but hes misrepresenting his own position concerning what hes saying. I wouldnt be surprised if he was the one Will ard needs protection from. How can he be th at obvious? Does he think were stupid? No, he just doesnt know youre brilliant. Save it for the pillow-talk. Yes ma`am.
203 Well I am sure we can help, Martin. I can tell that his safety is very important to you, she said without skipping a beat. She was good at this; having two conversations at once I was terrible at it. Pleas e, tell us what you need and we can begin at once. The soft, motherly tone was alien to her lips. The look of empathy in her eyes was like a neurotoxin in my brain. Sometimes I could barely stand to watc h her, the cold, stoic woman who only I could really get, put on her clown costume and do her little dance of make believe, behaving however she needed to in order to get the reaction we needed from whoever she was dancing for. If I hadnt know n it was all a game Id have run away screaming. When we werent working on someone, when it was just me and her speaking one on one, th e only reason I could deal with her at all were her subtleties. With everyone else it was like talking during a hail storm. Id get lost in the torrents of nuance from their facial and body language, and render everything an overwhelming jumb le. Theyd be talking on and on and all Id notice was how many times they tapped their finger or blinked. Oh, I could still carry on with the conversation. I could make sense of it eventu ally, but I was slow, and I tended to overanalyze. Interacting with her was, I assumed, something like how normal people interact with other normal people. She was still. Every action deliberate. She never fidgeted. Hardly ever blinked. Her fi ngers did nothing she didnt consciously tell them to. Her eyes were steady and locked onto mine like nothing else in the room existed. Her speech was smooth and monotone, never betraying more than the slightest hint of meaning beyond the dictionary description of the words. She was normal to me. I got her.
204 Still, I guess I had my edge too. She could have two conversations at once, and I could pay attention to two people at once. Even as I reported every twitch and inflection of Calhoun, Flow herself was at the forefront of my mind. As I watched her it was like there were two people sitting on the booth beside me; the division between her true self and the person she was showing our client was that extreme. I guess I could pay attention to three people at once. It is very simple really, Calhoun said after rambling for a minute about political stuff that anyone who read the BS they plastered on the front page of every new sstand from here to Hoboken knew. There is a data file being held at the 5th Avenue Icomde, under the strictest confidence, or so we thought, which contains the identity of Willard and enough information to track him down. I relayed to her what I saw, and waited fo r her to reply, either to me or to him. I felt useless in a way; this guy had absolutely no control over the way his body acted out what he was really thinking; what he really wanted to say. But I had to remember that her knowledge was all theoretical and not practical. Sure, she knew what it all meant, but she wouldnt know it if she saw it. People were incomprehensible to her, like driving down the street and all of the sign posts were turned around so all you coul d see was blank metal. Sure, sometimes th e shape of the sign helped, but if it was anything more complicated than stop or yield she didnt have a clue. But she was even more blank than that to other people. It was almost im possible to tell if she was happy or sad, if she was surprised or bored, if she loved you or hated you. I could tell, but then again, I wa s nuts. So was she. We were both nuts.
205 But someone there betrayed us. We alre ady know who, and wont be taking any action against her, but the data must be removed and all trace of it expunged. What does he know about us? The voice of NotFlinn buzzed in my ear out of nowhere. Of course he was listening in. He always listened in when we worked. Flow and I werent the only ones analyzing him. NotFlinn was researching. Every scrap of information was a lead, an d our man on the web wanted to know. He wasnt in this business because he really cared about our cases; he just want ed to know. If he could turn informatio n into food hed eat it a hundred times a day and never touch a scrap of meat or vegetable as long as he lived. I doubt he knows about you, Flow subvocalized to him and then said, near ly cutting Calhoun off, Were not hackers, Martin. We cant do that kind of work. Morden here is a consulting detective. We talk to people. Thats what I need! He said adamantl y, or at least Flow told me it was ad amant after I had explained the exact way the veins in his forehead popped out. Someone to talk to people. Intervie w people at the Icomde without letting them know you are. Figure things out. Get the story about what happened. Find out where that file is. Once we get the details, my own hacker friends can to the rest. If I dont do it first, NotFlinn buzzed. Very well Martin, Flow said after only a moments hesitation Even the hesitation was part of the show. But do you really want to discuss the details here ? And look, your burger has arrived.
206 Calhoun erupted into a display of delight as a steaming pl ate of stacked meat and bread was placed before him. I couldnt stand to watch people eat; no t even Flow. There was so mething about the way their neck and cheeks deformed with every slosh of food matter shoveled into their folds of flesh that made me nauseous. I turned to look at Flow, thinking that excusing myself from this biological display would be forgivable. I am almost convinced that hes the one that Willard needs to be afraid of, she said to me. Almost? I thought it was pretty damning from the get-go. He wants Willard to disappear alright, but hes the one who will be deciding what that me ans, and it probably has something to do with moving his body parts as far away from one another as he can get them. This guys a nobody, NotFlinn chimed in. Hes got nothin g on him. A middle man. He doesnt believe what hes saying because hes not stupid either, but he doesnt care. Hes being paid to make sure you help whoever hes working for take this guy down. What do you know about Willard, NotFlinn? she asked. I dont think his burger is big enough fo r me to tell you everything. I can fill yo u in later, but I can start by mentioning that hes recently gotten a few very powerful people believing that his ideas about the Poli-Sci Monopoly are their own ideas, and thats bad news for the P.S.M. Its one thing to convince people youre right; its another to convince them
207 that your ideas are the ones they came up with all by themselves. Thats real power. I dont think it takes a magnanimous leap to say that whoever Calhoun is working for is tied up with the P.S.M. I say we take the job. We can make up our mind s what to do with what the job gives us later. You cant turn Willard into the P.S.M! NotFlinn shouted, th ough to anyone sitting two inches from my ear it may have sounded like rather quiet fly buzzing. Do you know what a huge crime will be committed if that happens? I am not talking about murder! I am talking about the first amendment! Settle down, NotFlinn, I studied Flow, half because I couldn t stand to watch this guy devour his lunch, and half because I wanted to know what she was thinking. She was worried. She didnt like working for this guy, or being caught up in things so damned political, but she knew that this was a big chance to do something actually important for change. I didnt know how I knew all of that from looking at her; I just did. I wondered if shed be able to get anything like that from looking at me. Yes, I got her, but I wasnt su re if she really got me. Ma ybe she just kept me around because she needed someone who got he r. One sided relationships sucked. Eventually he tried to talk while eating, which I found unbearable. Thankfully Flow knew it and didnt expect me to watch him. He had already dealt his hand anyway; there wasnt much more to be psychoanalyzed.
208 We can play it by ear. I cannot expect specific results fr om you, because we are unsure wh at specific results are even possible. However, we will gauge your efforts and compensate you accordingly. Why, for even meeting with me I can promise you at least 250 ICs. Well that will hardly pay our rent for th e rest of the year, I said, focusing my eyes some distance be hind his head so I wouldnt actually have to see him, while still making it look like I was addressing him. But two months isnt bad. Oh believe me that is the very barest of bare minimum which you can expect. Shall we appoint a time tonight to reconvene, possibly remotely, an d discuss your findings for the day? Say, eight oclock? I managed to fix my eyes on th e rather pleasant shape of a waitresses lower portion as she leaned over a table. Hindends didnt have much capacity for emot ing, so they naturally had a calming effect on my senses. I let Flow answer. Yes Martin, that sounds very fine indeed. She wrapped up the meeting, an d then very skillfully convinced him that he was paying for our coffee without even asking, and got me out of there before I became a real basket case. Is this it? I asked as we approached the corner of 5th and 40th. A strange form of transp arent extruded polymers and crystallized silicon most folks called it glass was perche d precariously at the corner, like it was about ready to roll away into the street and float off into the sky at the same ti me. It was hard to tell where it actually touched ground,
209 both because of the tree cover which still lined the front of the nearby terrace, and becaus e of the way the form melted into obscurity the closer it got to the ground. I remember when this area l ooked like a slum, Flow mused. If thats so, then youre older than you look, I remarked dryly. How is that anyway? Youre not exactly a paragon of healthy lifestyle. Its because I never feel guilty about what I do to myself. I was about to turn and head for the entrance, when I saw Flow take off in another direction. What? I said. This isnt it? It is. I need good coffee. Then I saw where sh e was going. I caught up. If you need good coffee well have to go to my place after this. The rat-piss they serve he re is worse than the diner. I am certainly glad I am not you, Morden. You hate everythi ng, and so youre always miserable. Well youre not exactly miss I-love-sunshine either, I said as I caught the door which she didnt hold open for me. Look, Icomde has a caf too. That way you can enjoy your coffee and we can pretend like were working, right? You can interview the barista, or whatever the he ll they call the person who makes the stuff.
210 She stopped, looking longingl y at the menu which she had no doubt co mmitted to memory ages ago like a dope fiend craving her next fix. With a minimum of fuss I had her out the door again, following me back to the Icomde with a chip on her shoulder that coul d have sunk the Titanic. This way, I said, leading her past those two iconic stone lions that had been standing there for over a century. It was very hard to ever get a feeling that a place was old in this part of the world. Here was one of the few places that managed it. I lead Flow around the doze ns of seated bodies, reclined on steps where people just like them had reclined millions of times, heading towards the shaded area wh ere the staggeringly contempo rary intervened with the antiquated. The way it dissolved in this direction made it difficult to understand where the terrace ended and the interior of the Icomde began; but it also made you not re ally care. It was also di fficult to see where the peop le who came here to be at the Icomde began and where the people who were just loitering on the terrace en ded. Again, I didnt think it really mattered to anyone. The library and the Icomde were both public institutions, and no one really cared if they invaded eachothers space. Not yet, anyway. Here the sight and sounds, and smells, of people enjoying their lunches didnt faze me as much. I knew Flow was oblivious to almost all of it; she just wanted her damned coff ee. Soon the light canopy of branches gave way to a semitranslucent covering as we approached th e counter of the Icomde-run caf. I wasnt sure why she took so long to look over the menu it was exactly the same as the other place, and she always, always orde red the same thing. In a
211 moment she would touch her mobile to the counter which woul d instantly transfer the credits, and they would pass her an intricately engineered, pain stakingly designed, abhorrently organic coffee-derived bevera ge, the name of which could be no less than five words. She sipped at a huge cup of brown gravy she could consider the swill coffee if she wanted even before we took our seats in the most remote corner of the area we could manage. It was a good va ntage point to watch the people go in and out via the terrace opening, some just looking for a little mechanically assisted climate control, some only interested in the delicacies afforded by the co unter, and maybe even one or two peop le who genuinely wanted to enrich themselves by this fountain of culture. Whatever. I watched Flow as she sile ntly took her medicine; she could down caffeine all day and never got the jitters. Not much to this place, I said, craning my neck to look at the wall of glass before me. The whole building was transparent, probably to keep it from obscuring the view of the massive old library, thou gh there was certainly enough of that to go around without having to worry about this littl e building upstaging it. I could easily see three stories above me, filled with tables and desks and loung e chairs. Wherever someone came up to the glass wall, their face to us below, it dimmed slightly and a display came to life, seen in revers e from our point of view, with a cascade of interfaces that deformed and slid to and fro at the users commands; fingertips hovering over the glossy surf ace. I figured that the day when they got the machines to respond reliably to proximity of touch rather than touch itself they finally became worthwhile. Otherwise theyd have to invest a small fortune in cleaning supplies. I was sure they still did; some people
212 never quite got the hang of it, and smeared their greasy hands all over the di splays. I could see a few tell-tale signs of this on some of the walls. No matter how adva nced technology got, they still couldnt make people better. That thought drew me back to the lounge chairs, oddly colo rful and plush in their worl d of smooth glass and polished aluminum. The people in this place were like visitors in an alien realm, and those chairs were the liaisons. No matter how sufficiently advanced to use the old euphemism, the interfaces got, a good old comfy chair was as hard to make better as people were. Part of the upstairs area looked like a museum; desks and shelves lined with reli cs of past decades, absurdly primitive and yet even I wasnt young enough to not remember a time when it was all we had I spotted a few antique LCD displays, so bulky and rigid, held aloft fr om the desktop by a plastic stalk, forever locked to on e size, one shape, and the only way to make them transparent was with a trick where a camera was mounted on the back. I couldnt see them from here, but I assumed they even ha d keyboards attached to them. Why anyone thought that simply modifying a typewriter into a computer input device was a good idea was beyond me. We may as well have been carving figures into clay tablets. And then, as if the keyboards werent novel enough, I spotted someone actually using paper The only places that still used paper were the old libraries that got gran dfathered in, after paper pr oducts were outlawed. NotFlinn would say that the PoliSci Monopoly was behind th at law. I assume he got that from Willard. Most of it is underground. Thats where the bulk of the terminals are. But humans still enjoy natural light for tasks which dont involve backlit displays.
213 It took me a second to realize what NotFlinn was respondi ng to, and then I remembered my throwaway comment a few seconds before I was lost to nostalgia. You sa y that as if you arent one, I replied smugly. What makes you think he is? Flows sense of humor was unflappable. A few more minutes slid by calmly without much change in activity inside. I let out a sigh of restrained impatience. Ever been in one of these places before? I asked Flow, speaking normally for a change. One of these places? I thought this wa s the only one, she said as soon as she could pry her thin unpainted lips away from the plastic lid. I could see the wr iting on the side of her cup from here: Made from 100% recycled material. Intended for single use only. Oh, the irony was suffocating. Oh no, not at all! NotFlinn spoke up. This was the first one though, built back in 2010. But now theres dozens of them across the country. I hear theyve even put a few in Japan. Are you always listening in, Flinn? I said with unhinged irritation. Im not Flinn! And you can disconnect me any time you want. He hated, of course, when someone called him just Flinn, so I was happy to do so when it suited me. He never did tell us the story behind that handle. Yeah, but dont you ever get bored of cons tantly eavesdropping on two nutcases?
214 Flow interrupted our unintended co nversation with an answer to my original qu estion. No, Ive neve r been inside one. But I take it NotFlinn has? Only my local branch. I already have the floorplans of the NYC one though. Its- Just feed us information as we need it. You know I cant memorize anything you say, I told him. Apparently that was his cue to launch into a monologue. Heres what I find odd about this whole situation. So this Calhoun guy says that this Icomde has information on Willard. Th ats just bizarre. As much as it is to be venerated as a paradigm shift in public information access, its still just a wr iting lab with a publishing center. Back in the old days that meant that they printed books, but now it just means they have a staff who help people get their work presentable for digital distribution, since most books have gone electr onic and the Icomde is supporting that. Now, maybe Willard has friends here and he needed them to get in touch with him in the physical sense. But if thats so, why would he have a data file with the information that could kill him sitting around on the harddrive on a computer in a public writing lab? It makes no sense. No, youre right, it makes no sense. Flow said in her usua l bored tone. But somethings going on here, and it suits us to figure it out, doesnt it? For once the three of us were in agr eement. NotFlinn, are you in any kind of communication with this Willard?
215 Oh, no way. Hes way too paranoid for that. Im just a ho bbyist, remember? It was only an accident that I got mixed up with you detective sorts. I nodded. NotFlinn didnt like admitting when he couldnt do something, so I figured he was seri ous. Is there any conceivable reason why this Icomde would be involved? Ill try to figure it out. Ill let you know if I think of anything. Well keep the channel open. But we re probably going to split up, so I hope you dont mind listening to two conversations at once. I dont have wacked out brains lik e you two, but Ill do my best. Shall we get on with this? I said, impatient. Mm, was all she replied as she tossed the still half full foam-plastic cup into the waste basket. Some things never change. You spent at least .5 IC on that drink, and you just throw it away half done? I said in a scoff, more interested in taunting her illogical reliance on th e beverages than her actual waste.
216 If we had gone where I wanted, it would have been worth th e .5, and I would have finished; but no, you wanted to go here, and so now its your fault that twenty seven mil limeters of coffee and soy prod uct are now residents of the wastebasket. She stopped, and lowered one eyebro w just a tad. And how did you know, anyway? The level of exertion as you heaved th e cup airborne. Way the cup arced through the air on its way to the basket. The distinct thud as it made contact with the plastic lining. All very tell-tale. But most of all I know how long it takes for you to drink a medium, and you finished exactly two minutes too early. The world is an open book to you, isnt it? Yeah. And I know all of the nouns and verbs too bad Im lost on the grammar. The entrance was worked into the edge of the old terrace brickwork, and was like a distant echo of the main entrance to the library that loomed over it. It was a curious gesture, striking me as both mocking and venerating at the same time. Going inside gave the odd sensation of being embraced by the ground while tr anslucent sheets of structure hovered effortlessly above us. As transparent as the building seemed from the outside, once inside I had a feeling of being wrapped in something dense and tangible, though I couldnt put my finger on where that was coming from. Maybe it was the cascade of images and informatio n what flowed gently around the peri meter of the enclosure on those glass interfaces I had already seen from the outside.
217 Unlike the interfaces up stairs, these were always on. I a ssumed that a lot of it was realtime news feeds, coming in from thousands of news sources across the planet. A few screens sh owed conversations however, scr olling chat logs, possibly informative debates or possibly mindless banter. Not all of it was text though. Dozens of the displays were animated, some showing video broadcasts, others an imations, some music videos and even a few sports broadcasts. I shifted my attention to the people around me. Some were sitting, others standing. Some we re stationary, their gaze locked onto the displays, others were walking, browsi ng. A chance glance at a nearby sign informed me of how to connect the audio feeds directly to my earpiece, or how to download any of th e broadcasts directly to my mobile. The former was free to guests. The later required member authorization. I soon forgot my own contemplation as my gaze became fixed on an exhibition which took up the center of the ground floor. There was a glassed in area; probably sound insulated as I couldnt hear even a fa int murmur of what was going on beyond, where a group of people seemed absolutely en tranced by what one other wa s saying and showing them. The cascade behind him was interrupted by the flow, instead displaying various di agrams and depictions I couldnt even guess the nature of. From the way he was gesturing and moving around I could tell that he felt his entire livelihood was on the line at this moment. I could only guess that he was presenting some invention to potential investors. Without thinking I checked my mobile for public broadcast bands, to see if I could listen in to what was so important to soundproof from everyone outside, but saw only locked frequencies. So we could look but not hear; fine, have it your way.
218 There was a desk nearby where a woman sat, and Flow was already over there talking with her as I took the place in. I shifted my attention to the conversation playing discretely in my ear, as I casually fixe d my eyes upon the seated attendant. oh not at all, you see, the Icomde isnt just about news and writing; we support the vi sual and performing arts as well. Not only do we have our terminals equipped with hi gh fidelity wacoms and wave tables, but we have actual physical facilities for painting and illustration, as well as recording equipment and environment. We even have practice rooms for people who have neighbors with delicate ears. Paradise, isnt it? NotFlinn buzzed in my ear, interrupting the sales pitch. Guess for an information addict like you, I subvocalized to him, and then, not to play captain dummy or anything, but what the heck is she talking about? A wacom is an electronic interface for illustration. You can paint into the computer just as you would with a pen or a brush. A wavetable is a method of music composition using a library of pre-recorded note samples. I think it should be all anyone needs, but the Icomde tends to also bend over backwards to accommodate the old ways of doing things, for people who still think that theyre good for that kind of thing. They even keep a collection of DTEs upstairs. I knew DTE dead tree edition, affectionate slang for a book. Flow, we just need some computer access. Dont make her think that were ready to sign her into our wills.
219 She conveyed my thought to the clerk, as if it had been her own. The girl replied, Oh yes, anyone may access our services on the sub-1 level. We actually offer most all amenities present in the design hubs on this floor, but its all individualized and not conducive to collaborative projects. For that, the design pits excel. So if my friend and I want to work on someth ing together, we have to rent a design pit? No, not at all, but youd have to work just as you would if you were using two separate te rminals in separate rooms. The pits offer complete synergy of function. Morden? She buzzed in my ear. She couldnt bu y a toaster without my say-so in the matter. What? I replied, as if I didnt know what she was asking. I thought you were listening. What kind of membership do we need? Were not here to design anything, Flow. The public terminals will be fine. You should know that. As soon as you get tired of being in char ge, let me know. Ill be happy to make decisions then. But if thats the case, you wont get a say anymore. I see. Thank you. Well just have the free membership then for now. Very well, I just need you to I stopped listening.
220 Flow, ask her if anyone in particular ever uses this place. Noteworthy people. Celebrities. Not movie stars or BS like that, but important figures in the media. She asked, though she phrased it far mo re eloquently than I did. The girl at the counte r seemed irritated at the question, taking a why should that matter? stance and fe d Flow some line about various news anchors and journalists who have visited. I am afraid shes not going to just come out and tell us if Willard has been here, Morden, Flow said to me even as the girl rattled off her recoll ections of people who she thought were noteworthy. Right, but even that tells us something. Finish up and let s get to work. She completed her transaction with the clerk and then turned to me, addressing me as if it was the firs t time we had spoken since she left to go to the counter. Morden, mobile. I pulled the device from my pocket to see a message glowin g on the display, asking for identity confirmation and acceptance of terms for membership in the Icomde. I glan ced at the Yes box and the re tinal scan opened up all the access filters, allowing them access to my identy-packet, or IP. In theory, it was the IP of Willard that they had stashed away here.
221 Flow approached, putting away her own mob ile as she did. I think we can do ev erything we need on sub-1. Please, lets not go poking around on the top floor finger painters or wherever they keep all of th e children who want to play at making music. Do you have that much contempt for people who prefer to still use physical objects? I said in my best attempt to sound like I was teasing, even though I was actually annoyed. I knew she wouldnt be able to tell. Its wasteful. The chemicals used to physically create images on another phys ical material are noxious, and require ventilation that puts an undue strain on the environmental control systems of the building, she said, like something straight out of the PSMs manifesto. Maybe they, I dont know, open a window? Why else would they be on the top floor? And the amount of materials per square foot needed for certifiably soundproof spaces needed for recording studios would make that floor cost more than two of the other floors combined. Maybe thats why they put it three levels underground? Come on Flow, stop being spiteful of the creatives. Her usual blank expression had a hint of frustration in it, but it only lasted for an instant. Their private database now has our IPs. Not Flinn, she continued, beginning to subvocalize, use our data as a signpost. If you can find it in their systems, it might lead you to Willar ds. With any luck you can detect it by remote and we wont have to do any work ourselves.
222 Does this mean I get paid for the job instead of you? Youll get your cut, she said, before looking up and me to say, Lets go. We walked slowly down the sculpture of glass and aluminum that connected all s ix floors, finding ourselves in an open space with controlled lighting, a high ceiling, and a low murmur of activity throughout the sleek, polished scenery. The arrangement was similar to what I saw in the floors above, but much more densely packed, no orientation concerning the edges as they were merely blank walls and many, many people busy at terminal s. I tried not to be too nosey as we crossed the floor to an uninhabite d spot, but being nosey is my job, so I couldn t help but notice that there were almost no trends in activity. Here the cascade which surrounded the peri meter was opaque it had to be since we were underground, and it split off from the wall here and there to fold over into various shapes that eventually became places to sit and interact with the displays on a more intimate level. I watched as a man sa t down before a blank portion of the continuous surface, and interfaces sprang to life both where the wa ll folded in to meet his fingers and at eye level. A few twists of his wrist later a series of images spilled out over his view, each one a blur of color until they came to be still. He was reading a comic book. The more things change, the more they stay the same. Ah, heres something, NotFlinn said, A trail of breadcrumbs at least. Working, working. What kind of breadcrumbs? was my partners reply.
223 Usage statistics. Login da ta. Stored keystrokes. Theyd keep that kind of data onhand? I asked, a little baffl ed that theyd log keystrokes. Is that even legal? Of course the term wasnt even accurate an ymore, since it referred to the now scarcely used input devices of old, but the term stuck even when you were talking about a simple log of every input command of any type the user committed to action. In another ten years no one would even remember wh ere the saying came from. Sort of like how people would dial on a phone. I wasnt even sure where that one came from. Its legal if the PSM says it is, was NotFlinns reply. Will you cut with the conspiracy theory crap? NotFlinn may have thought that Flow was irritated, but that was her teasing voice. Ignoring it, NotFlinn continued, "Hey, do yo u guys want to be full members for a day? What have you got? Theres this old promotional thing in thei r system from around this time last ye ar. Noone at the de sk could trigger it, but with a few illegitimately gained permissions I can tag bo th of your accounts, so that one of the design pits downstairs will recognize your IDs and think that its your turn to use it for this hour. Wont that get us kicked out? Flow was a pillar of optimism.
224 Nah, it will look like a computer glitch. Just play dumb. But as long as you act like youre doing exactly what you should be, no one will question you. Thats my motto! We turned around and went back to the stair. The floor below was similar, but much more organized and had a hush about it. It seemed counterintu itive at first since this was supposed to be the collaborative area with design pits but then I realized that the same soundproofin g I had seen upstairs with the presenta tion must be at work. The floor was divided into partitions of various shape and size, some of which were opaque to eye level and some of which carried on up to the ceiling. I then realized that privacy glass was at work here, and that the users within could no doubt set the opacity of their enclosure. They could probably see out just fine. I didnt know where I was going, but I ke pt moving. Right on cue, NotFlinn buzzed in my ear, Take this one. It wont be occupied for another four hours. I touched the swivel panel and it gave way effortlessly. I held it open to allow Flow passage and then spun it shut just as gently. I saw that where my hand was touching it a gl owing display had revealed itself, resembling a slider. I pushed it upwards, and a message appeared showing that the privacy glass was now se t to full. I could have also told it to make the opacity two way, but I left it in a state where we could observe what was going on outside by standing up. Flow sat. As soon as she sat various welcome messaged appeared on the surface before her, as well as directions of use. She pulled out her mobile and set it right on the surface, the part that cu rved forward and a ke ypad would appear
225 if needed. An outline appeared in a pale blue and various applications began to sprout from it like vines. For an instant I wondered what it would be like to spend time with a woman who was thrilled by pretty things, as I watched Flow sit there with no discernable interest in the artistic nature th e display was set up. I didnt think about it for very long. I went to sit down next to her. Similarly the display lit up as soon as weight was applied to the chair. So, I said watching the presentation, Whats so synergistic about these pits? Without speaking she raised her hand to the display before her, and gave one window a ge ntly tap with his fingers, hovering a centimeter above the surface. As if it were spring-loaded, it flew across the seamless gap between her space and mine and slowed to a halt right in front of me. Ah, was all I could come up with. Thats easier. Then I saw what the window was. NotFlinns usual animated avatar a lizard man with a Mo hawk of colorful feathers, was peering at me in profile. Hi NotFlinn. He didnt exchange pleasantries I couldnt help but laugh as the lizard ma n began to speak in NotFlinns voice. Hes been here. In this building. I found access to their security video logs. I think I can let me see. Decrypting, decrypting How many laws are you breaking, No tFlinn? she said in the same tone. Laws that are worth a damn? Zero!
226 You dont get to decide that. Turn me in then. I had no reason to be alarmed. Acting like this was how those two bonded. Or something. I leaned back in my chair to see what some people were doin g to one side of the room. Th ere was a row of big displays, each six feet tall and about eight feet wide, arranged in ai sles. Each one was a touch screen, and generated a view of a bookshelf. The people using them were scrolling along the shelves, zooming in and out, tapping books and having a virtual representation pull free from the shelf and spread open before them, wher e they could leaf through the pages or send it back to its place, only to push the image of the bookshelf around some more until they came to an edge and a menu popped up allowing them to choose a new section. Nove l. I thought I saw a few of these on the upper floors too, but no one was using them, and there were nt as many. It was one way to get your stacks into the library without having acres of moldy DTEs stinking up the place. I indulged my curiosity and stood up. Anyone who didnt have their privacy screen up wanted to be observed, anyway. There was a group of three in the pit besi de me. It looked like they were pretty well entrenched. It was impossible to see where one workspace began and the other ended. One beyo nd was much simpler, and a rather impressive sight; I recognized their work, they we re editing a waveform, but the display had co mpletely wrapped around the perimeter of the workspace, meaning they were surrounded in 340 degrees a gap for the door with the waveform and accompanying manipulable notes. From th e look of the two men, or boys, working on it I imagined they had just been downstairs playing and recording the song, and were not tweaking it.
227 My survey was cut short by NotFlinn. Whoa, okay, this is me ssed up, he said in a sudden bout of panic so congealed it almost dripped out of my earpiece and down my neck. I sat back down at once and observed the reptilian cartoon, now positioned halfway between Flow and I. I found the video logs alright, and its like they meant it this way. Guess how many security vid logs are there in the database? Theres like eighty of them. So? Flow said, playing stupid for my benefit, maybe. So there should be more like eight th ousand of them. And I checked a few ot hers theyre completely random. Real security logs should be mind numbingly or ganized or theyd be useless. They just put enough in here so that any newb who looked in the folder would go, oh he y, detdeet! Look a bunch of security logs! There ar ent enough in here to even be for a full day! Actually eighty for a building this size would be around two days, fifteen hours- Whatever. Look, heres the best part The operating system records all sort s of timestamps on the files. Date accessed, acquired, completed, received processed, authenticated, authorized imported, exported, yadda yadda, but guess what for video files only date created is displayed at the standard observation level, and that is set to be two days ago. All of the other timestamps? Totally out of whack. This files been bouncing around from place to place for weeks, if not longer. I wouldnt be surpri sed if the whole thing is just a c&p job. Can someone alter timestamps?
228 Of course they can alter timest amps! I could crack open the file right now an d change them all! Oh, read only? Readonly my ass! Files havent been read-only since the old days when we kept information stored on little bits of reflective foil on fragile plastic wafers! So what does the video file show? Wi llard breaking in and abusing the comput ers? Are they trying to frame him? No, worse than that. They show him meeting with the Icomdes vice-chairperson! How is that oh. Theyre not after Willard at all. Theyre after the Icomde. If they show that hes in cahoots with the higher-ups of this place, then whatever they pi n on him they can also pin on Icomde, and yo u can bet they have much deeper pockets for a settlement. NotFlinn, I am surprised at you, Flow spoke up, surprising me. I doubt theyr e after a settlement at all. Whoever isnt after Willard isnt after cash for slander. They want hi m silenced for good. Theyll want the same for places like this who let people like him thrive. So what do we do? I asked.
229 Flow answered. We bail out. This whole job stinks. Its like a double or a triple setup. Were private contractors. Its in our contract that we can end the co ntract for any reason. We only forfeit pay. As usual Flow was taking the responsible attitude. Its too hot. Dont touch it. Dont get drawn in. I think we should dig deeper. I said, turning to look at he r for the first time since we sat down. Lets get ourselves a new client. State the case to the director of the Icomde here and see if he wont let us take it up for him. Hes got a lot to lose. Chances are he doesnt even kn ow whats going on. He may not be able to pay as well as Calhoun, but you know me. Id always rather work for the good guys. Always the skeptic, Flow answer ed, How do we know these are the good guys ? How do we know that by bringing down the Icomde, whoever hired us is nt doing everyone a favor? And NotFlinn answered for me. We only know what they let us know, Flow. Thats how it will always be. Well look back on this and all sources will point to us making the wrong choice. Thats why we have to depend on whats in our own heads to make up our minds, and not whats force-fed in to our brains whenever we connect to the local channels. Back in the old days everyone believed what was so because some guy in a robe told them thats what God said. Well now weve got some guy in a suit saying the same thing, bu t now its what Science says. We traded one tyrant for another, but this new tyrant changes his tune whichever way th e wind blows. Well I dont blow in the wind, and neither do you.
230 Ah, you always present such lofty ideals. Are you trying to impress me, NotFlinn, or did Willard connect to our private net and youre trying to impre ss him? She said sarcastically. NotFlinn piped in with his usua l impeccable logic. Come on. Do you possibl y expect me to believ e that the guy in the burger joint was the good guy? He was ugly. Good guys are never ugly. Theyre pr etty, like you and me, Flow! I answered for him. You have no id ea what she looks like, Not Flinn. And you should know, I am the one thats pretty. Charming, she said, finally turning to look at me. Dont be obtuse, Morden. Like you said yourself in the diner, itd take me ten seconds in an image search to track down a picture of our lovely Florence Point in a bikini no less! I winked at Flow. Knowing NotFlinn, he had taken my hint and fired up photoshop on the spot. Alright NotFlinn, whats the directors name? Connect me to him right now. One of the benefits of having a personal techie on a private line was never having to dial a phone. Dial there was that wo rd again. Where did it come from? What did an ancient device for telling time have to do with communications? Miss Alleture, and dialing.
231 Dial a phone. Dial tone s. The sound of ringing at the other end. Antiques. What di d the sound even mean? It was just the noise you heard before the person youre calling hits the accept button, or lets their line of sight pass over the accept box, or mutters it, or even thinks it; depending on how wired they were. NYC Icomde, Lacy Alleture speaking. I could talk to people more easily if I co uldnt see them. But I could hear it in her voice. She wanted to sound cheerful; this person calling could be a new member, or a perspectiv e member. Maybe it was the press wanting to do a story about how successful this place was. Bu t it wasnt anyone she knew. She woul d have the call IDd at once, and we werent willing to pay the fee to keep our IDs totally invi sible. Besides, no one picked up IDless calls. There was uncertainty in her voice; she was worried about something. Lacy, this is Isaac Morden, PI. Flow taught me to always use a persons first name if they gave it. People like the sound of their first name. I am sorry to spring something so urgent in fron t of you so abruptly, but I have a hard time with not getting to the point. Some unknown person or orga nization means ill against this institution, and Ive pretty much decided to defe ct to your side. What do you say? She was silent. Flabbergasted probably. Flow was probably angry at me for no t being more delica te, and NotFlinn for not being more covert. I would have been angry with him for being too secr etive and with Flow for sugar-coating everything.
232 Youre a private eye? She was worried Scared maybe. She also suddenly sounded much younger. I caught her off guard alright, and then probably sucker punched her. But it would be for the be tter. Shed be used to just getting things straight from me from now on. Flow co uld sugar coat and NotFli nn could obscure later. Yes. Thats what PI stands for. Though, its kind of funn y since theres no I in eye, bu t there is one in investigator, which is what PI really stands for. I gave her a moment to see if she was going to have anything else to say. She did. What are what are you talking about? Means ill to us whats going on? We should meet face to face and talk about it. I didnt want to tell her it was so I could observe her and feed Flow information and let Flow handle her delicately. I think my blunt nature was too much for her. Oh, okay my office is well you know how to find ? I think I can find your office, if youre in it. Were on sub-2. Ill be there in a mome nt. I closed the connection. Isaac Morden, Private Investigator, Hero of the Ages, Frightener of Children, Flow said in her usual deadpan. Hey, how was I supposed to know? And whats that got to do anything? I doubt she s a day older than NotFlinn. No way man, Ive got ten years on her at least. And I am no social giant, but even I know thats not how you talk to a girl.
233 Right, you guys can finish roasting me when weve saved the world again, kay? NotFlinns image vanished from the display, and then the whole thing went dark. We let ourselves out, and then oriented. The staff offices were at the far wall of th is floor, where we would find Miss Child Director. I could see her get up as she saw us approach. It must ha ve been Flows trenchcoat. Everyone knew that PIs wore those. Hi, come in, she said as she opened the glass door. The name Lacy would have fit the panicking girl I heard at the other end of the line, but not this woman, even though the voice was the same. She had her totally black hair tied up tightly behind her head, an d small wireframe glasses set in front of her slightly Asian eyes. She sat at a desk that wa s as sleek and minimalist as ev erything else in the building, though her figure was anything but minimalist. The desktop was animated with a blue sky and light clouds slowly moving across it; which told me just a little about her personality. I usually think up a whole script of what to say beforehand, but Im afraid youve got me on this one. Ca n you tell me again, more slowly, whats going on, and how I can help? Were not here looking for your help. We re here to help you. Though well need your help if were to help you, of course. Morden, let me, Flow said, using her, I am talking in front of another female voice, which was much different than the one she used with Calhoun. She explained to her the situation with Calhoun and Willard, and then had NotFlinn bring up
234 what he found in their systems on her te rminal. We even watched th e video NotFlinn found. Throughout all of this, she was mostly silent as we told her of the admittedly very brie f happenings of the day. She didnt even seem worried or alarmed that NotFlinn was able to hack them so easily. Bu t then, she spoke. I am not sure how good this guy who isnt Flinn is supposed to be, but Im told it should be very hard to break into our systems. And they are organized nothin g like these. Its not ju st the folder with the video logs that are fake... everything in here is. Its sort of lik e the file structure we have here, but it looks like what the free users see. The actual file structure is much different. It was designed to fool you or people like you, and I guess it didnt work. Doesnt need to work on us, I said. Just on whoeverll be doing the damning. And even if it does go to court, you know how braindead juries are. Everyone on there is exactl y the kind of person who was t oo stupid to get out of it. They wont even know what youre talking about if you try to explain it away with technical jargon. But I dont see why this is worth anything. Ive read Willards editorials and essays. Hes interesting, but hardly I mean, why would it matter if he was seen talking to anyone in our upper management? Pin the tail on the donkey. It will mean whatever they want it to mean. Any link, however tenuous, is all people like them need. Theyll twist it to mean whatev er they want and then pat themselves on the back. Ive seen it happen so many times. The question is not why anymore, or even what they plan to do. The question is how to get you out of the targeting recital.
235 She shut the display off. I dont see wh at the point is. If it is like you say, and they want to shut us down, what can we do? I mean, theyll find a way. It may take them ten years, but theyll find a way. NotFlinn spoke up, but this time Lacy could hear him too, as he was broadcasting out of her terminal speakers too. Theyve got the media corporations in th eir pocket. Theyve got the publishing ho uses too. And the universities good God do they have the universities. Control the information and you control the people. Well, this is the only source of information that they dont control yet. Sure, theyll never be able to control the entire net. But they dont need to. Its a net, its scattered, diffused. But in Icomde its taken a shape, its an institution people can get behind, and that means its something they want to control. Last millennium it was Jerusalem you had to control. Now its the mobile inside everyones pocket. She gave a fatalistic half-smile. I see you guys have a Willard fan on your hands, she said. Thats one of his favorite quotes. Really? NotFlinn said, a feign of surprise in his voice. M aybe I should sue he had to have stolen that from me! Flow and I sort of faded into the backgrou nd at that point. NotFlinns reptilian avatar appeared on Lacys desk and the two began a very involved conversation on all things Willard. She was bluffing when she said she thought his work was interesting. What she meant was Im obsessed with it. And it seemed to me that NotFlinn was quickly becoming
236 obsessed with her. Flow eventually turn ed to give me a look which I knew to mean and were here why? but I just smiled and kept listening. By that point she had the vice-chairperson and the national di rector on the line, who was ou t of town on extended leave and had left Lacy pretty much permanen tly in charge. The NYC branch was th e headquarters branch, but it seemed that this guy was going all over the country getting new Icomdes set up. They were doing their best to, to be blunt about it, make it seem like Flow and I were crazy. I felt like my head was going to explode, but at least at the end of the conversation everyone seemed pretty sure that the worst they could do was bring up a frivolous lawsuit against them. I tried to pipe in a few times, but this wasnt detective work anymore. It was pretty clear that this was NotFlinns game now, and it had been from the start. Ever so discreetly, I thumbed my mobile to disconnect NotFlinn so only Flow could hear me. So how are we going to deal with Calhoun? I asked subvocally. Do you want him to pay our rent for th e rest of the year? was her reply. I guess we give him exactly what he wants. If his people planted this here, then it woul d be pointless for us to not present it to him on a silver platter. If we dont do it someone else will, and then some one else will be involved. I still wasnt sure. Still, the fact was that they, being whoever Calhoun worked for, were testing the waters, but theyd find piranhas. It was naive of three of us and even Calhoun, to believe that the Icomde wo uld be so susceptible to this
237 kind of thing. They built their entire concept around de flecting the attacks of those who would shut them down or control the flow of information. I just wasnt optimistic about it. But then, I never was. . The digital display on the wall flicked to 1:59 am. I started at it with restless eyes. We had met with Calhoun alright, and gave him exactly what he wanted. We told NotFlinn an d the Icomde people, of course what we were doing, and they agreed with our logic. But it was in their court now. Well, theirs and NotFlinns anyway. I spent some time today wondering if this meant hed suddenly become scarce, if he d become Icomdes man on the web rather than ours. But that wasnt the only thing that had been on my mind. Flow, I said into the darkness with my head pr opped up against the folder arms behind it. I heard her stir nearby, and mutter a hrm? What if going to the Incomde Director was exactly what Calhoun wanted us to do? I heard her shuffle around to prop herself up, and let out the faintest of sighs. She alwa ys got emotional when she was sleeping. Why, to make su re I didnt get any sleep?
238 I ignored her comment. What if its a decoy. A red herring. A Are you looking for another analogy? May I suggest a moose call? What if Willard was working for Them all along? What if his job was to create a caricature of the type of person they are afraid of, so that he can be shown to be a villain? I mean, we couldnt see his face in the video what if Wait, what did you say? I blinked and looked over at her, barely making out the shape of her thin pointy nose in the darkness. We couldnt see Willards face in the video. Why did NotFlinn tell us that it was Willard in the video? How did he know it was him? Noone knows what Willard looks like. My brain did a summersault. Maybe th at was the filename? I dont know. The NotFlinn I know isnt that careless. And for that matter he doesnt make things this personal. He seemed awfully close to this. Are you suggesting that
239 We trust him, and we have very little reason to. But we bo th do because he seems right and we both see ourselves as such perfect judges of character. But weve never even seen His face. This is crazy, Flow. Are we suppose d to get paranoid about NotFlinn now too? Is he in on all of this? Maybe he planted those videos th ere, right then, right as he was entering the systems. What if he is part of all of this. Why else would They come to us. This could have been in the works for years. Or not. Maybe they came to NotFlinn recently and Or maybe NotFlinn works for Willard and this is part of his plan to bring THEM down. They go after him, he lets them think theyve got him, but is really drawing them into a trap. I unfolded my arms and let my head fall back on the pillow. I am not going to be able to sleep tonight, now. No, neither am I. Damn you, I said, turning to look at her once more. Well find out later, was her usual reply to me telling her to go to hell. We shouldnt have gotten involved. Should have pulled out when we had the chance. Wouldnt have mattered. NotFlinn still tipped his hand.
240 Yeah, but still. Maybe Id have fallen asleep tonight before I figured it out. You figured it out? I thought that was me? I could usually tell when she was being funny. I would have figured it out sooner if we hadnt spent all of that time talking with the Icomde people. If you had just listened to me, wed have gotten to the heart of the matter in stead of running in circles. Yeah, youre a real Cassandra. Does that mean youll never believe me no matter how many times Im right? No, it means no matter how many times I do believe you, youll only remember the times I didnt.