|USFDC Home | USF Electronic Theses and Dissertations||| RSS|
This item is only available as the following downloads:
xml version 1.0 encoding UTF-8 standalone no
record xmlns http:www.loc.govMARC21slim xmlns:xsi http:www.w3.org2001XMLSchema-instance xsi:schemaLocation http:www.loc.govstandardsmarcxmlschemaMARC21slim.xsd
leader nam 2200385Ka 4500
controlfield tag 001 002028696
007 cr bnu|||uuuuu
008 090911s2009 flu s 000 0 eng d
datafield ind1 8 ind2 024
subfield code a E14-SFE0002804
Jacobson, Ginger L.
Realness and hoodness :
b authenticity in hip hop as discussed by adolescent fans
h [electronic resource] /
by Ginger L. Jacobson.
[Tampa, Fla] :
University of South Florida,
Title from PDF of title page.
Document formatted into pages; contains 65 pages.
Thesis (M.A.)--University of South Florida, 2009.
Includes bibliographical references.
Text (Electronic thesis) in PDF format.
ABSTRACT: Various forms of media penetrate our lives daily. Hip hop music has gained universal appeal and widespread success that permeates barriers of race, class, gender, age, and nationality. It is important for social service workers, parents, educators and other adults who interact with youth to understand the roles hip hop music and culture can play in the identities of those who are listening. In this study I conducted 12 open-ended interviews with adolescent hip hop fans about their music. The research presented in this thesis suggests that adolescent hip hop fans are making interpretations from the media and applying them to their understanding of themselves and the world. The findings of this study show that these adolescent hip hop fans most saliently describe their interactions and understandings of hip hop music in terms of authenticity. This thesis builds upon Armstrong's (2004) forms of authenticity, incorporating what participants discussed about themes of realness and hoodness. These interviews also indicate that fans relate music's lyrics to their own lives and what they understand of other people's lives. Youth may understand hip hop images and messages as types of lived realities. Although further research is necessary, these findings suggest there may be a need for adolescents to refine media literacy skills to be critical of media images and messages.
Mode of access: World Wide Web.
System requirements: World Wide Web browser and PDF reader.
Advisor: Laurel Graham, Ph.D.
t USF Electronic Theses and Dissertations.
Realness and Hoodness: Authenticity in Hip Hop as Discussed by Adolescent Fans by Ginger L. Jacobson A thesis is submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Department of Sociology College of Arts and Sciences University of South Florida Major Professor: Laurel Graham, Ph. D. Jennifer Friedman, Ph. D. William Tyson, Ph. D. Date of Approval: March 31, 2009 Keywords: rap, music, media, signified, performance Copyright 2009, Ginger L. Jacobson
Dedication This thesis is dedicated to Grandpa who encouraged me to pursue higher education. I know he was proud of my academ ic accomplishments and will continue to watch over me as I pursue a doctorate to be the next Dr. Jacobson of the family.
Acknowledgements I would like to thank Dr. Gr aham for collaborating closely with me on this project. Her detailed comments were metic ulously written and offered constructive, optimistic criticism. I would like to thank Dr. Friedman for coaching my interview technique and giving me confiden ce with this skill. I would like to thank Dr. Tyson for his attention to detail and continuous s upport. Thank you to my entire committee for taking me onto their workload and believing in my ideas. A special thank you to my sister who helped me get this ball rolling. As always, I would like to thank Papa for his endless support and advice that cons istently guide me through life.
i Table of Contents Abstract ...................................................................................................................... ........ iii Chapter One: Introduction ...................................................................................................1 Distinctions Between Hip Hop and Rap ..................................................................2 Youth Culture and Identity ......................................................................................3 Identity and Interpretations Among Popular Music Listeners .................................4 Capital and Authenticity ..........................................................................................7 Media Literacy and Adolescents ..............................................................................8 Hip Hop Culture and Race .....................................................................................10 Research Questions ................................................................................................11 Chapter Two: Methods ......................................................................................................13 Sampling Technique ..............................................................................................14 A Note on Performance in my Interviews .............................................................15 My Presentation of Self .........................................................................................16 The Interviews .......................................................................................................17 Examining Talk ......................................................................................................18 Meet the Participants..............................................................................................18 Darrius....................................................................................................... 19 Mimi ...........................................................................................................19 Ciara ...........................................................................................................20 Ty ...............................................................................................................20 Sarah ..........................................................................................................20 Charlotte .....................................................................................................21 Ronnie ....................................................................................................... 21 Angelo ....................................................................................................... 22 Jay ............................................................................................................. 22 Dave .......................................................................................................... 22 Guilli ......................................................................................................... 23 Pierre ......................................................................................................... 23 Chapter Three: Realness: An Authenticity Test ................................................................25 The Artist as a Real Person ....................................................................................26
ii Relatability .............................................................................................................29 What You See is What You Get ........................................................................ 31 Fake in Opposition to Being Real ..........................................................................33 Plies the rapper: Real or fake? ...............................................................................34 Chapter Four: Hoodness: The Characterization of BeingHood ......................................37 Coolness .................................................................................................................39 A Hood Meaning ............................................................................................... 40 Been Through a Lot ........................................................................................... 45 Significations and the Hyperreal ............................................................................47 The Truth as Understood but not Experienced by the Listener .............................49 Chapter Five: Conclusion ..................................................................................................55 List of References ............................................................................................................ ..57 Appendix: Interview Questions .........................................................................................64
iii Realness and Hoodness: Authenticity in Hip Hop as Discussed by Adolescent Fans Ginger L. Jacobson ABSTRACT Various forms of media penetrate our lives daily. Hip hop music has gained universal appeal and widespread success that permeates barriers of race, class, gender, age, and nationality. It is important for soci al service workers, parents, educators and other adults who interact w ith youth to understand the roles hip hop music and culture can play in the identities of those who ar e listening. In this study I conducted 12 openended interviews with adoles cent hip hop fans about their music. The research presented in this thesis suggests that adolescent hip hop fans are making interpretations from the media and applying them to their unders tanding of themselves and the world. The findings of this study show that thes e adolescent hip hop fa ns most saliently describe their interactions and understandings of hip hop music in terms of authenticity. This thesis builds upon Armstrongs (2004) form s of authenticity, incorporating what participants discussed about themes of realness and hoodne ss. These interviews also indicate that fans relate musics lyrics to their own lives and what they understand of other peoples lives. Youth may understand hi p hop images and messages as types of lived realities. Although furthe r research is necessary, thes e findings suggest there may be a need for adolescents to refine media liter acy skills to be critical of media images and messages.
1 Chapter One Introduction Music is an ancient form of entertai nment and expression. As the traditional institutions of family, c hurch, and school become less influential in the social development of children, media and entert ainment industries con tinue to penetrate American lives and transmit culture (Kitwana 2005). In an increasi ngly mediated world, music is nearly omnipresent in the lives of children (Bosacki, Francis-Murray, Pollon, and Elliott 2006). Music plays on the iPods, CD players, computers, televisions, DVD players, video and electronic games of childre n and adults alike. The content of this media may provide models for identity deve lopment and may influence the way children and adolescents think and f eel about themselves and the world (Bosacki et al. 2006:369). Therefore, it is important for social science to study how music connects to listeners social and personal understandings. Some music genres, such as heavy metal, punk rock and hip hop, are the centerpiece of an entire culture or lifestyle through which listeners have shared beliefs, values, fashion, language, and experiences. Thes e music listeners are likely to identify with the music they listen to because of their connection to these aspects surrounding the music. My interest lies in hip hop music, which is embedded within hip hop culture. Little research has studied how adolescents1 apply hip hop to their experiences. Discovering this realm of youth identity ma y be found in answering the question: How do teen hip hop fans describe thei r understanding of hip hop music? Hip hops worldwide appeal and diffusi on through social barriers of race and class emphasizes its important influence. Cornel West (1993:127-128)stresses the AfroAmericanization of White male youth by noting the prominence of male athletes and the cultural weight of male pop arti sts: [the] Afro-Americaniza tion process results in white youthmale and femaleimitating and emulating black male styles of walking, talking, dressing and gesticulating in re lations to others This phenomenon is one result of hip hop cultures universal presence and growing ap peal. With such a strong presence in our society and its presence increasingly permeating all types of cultures, it is important for social service workers, parents, and edu cators to understand the roles hip hop music and culture can play in the iden tities of those who are listeni ng, especially impressionable 1 Adolescence and youth are two terms closel y related and are often interchanged. Both refer to the period of transition from chil dhood to adulthood. The differences are quite subtle and include the physical versus the psychosocial behaviors (Danesi 2000; Bucholtz 2002). For the purposes of this paper, the terms youth teens and adolescents are interchanged, referring to those who undergo the psychosocial development between the ages of 13-19 years.
2 youth. Policy makers can build upon the media li teracy skills that adolescents already possess in interpreting hip hop music fo r further media literacy mandates. While the literature on hip hop is wide a nd varied, little qualit ative research has been conducted on the hip hop fans themselv es. Much of the scholarship builds upon notions of race, authenticity, Black identity, and gender issu es through content analysis and other methodologies. In my review of the literature, I have found no studies interviewing American adoles cent hip hop fans about hip hop music in general. Studies that do exist focus on other intervening vari ables. For example one research study was framed around political awareness and rap musi c. Other studies might discuss rap music and listeners in another count ry. I begin this paper by firs t distinguishing between the terms rap and hip hop. I then review literat ure on adolescent hip hop fans and their understanding of hip hop music, which en compasses youth culture, popular music, identity, capital and au thenticity, media liter acy, and hip hop culture. Lastly I present the findings from 12 interviews with adolescent hip hop fans, concluding with implications of this study and suggestions for future research. Distinctions Between Hip Hop and Rap I must begin by addressing the use of the terms hip hop music and rap music. Both originate from hip hop culture which co mes from a set of cultural practices that began with graffiti, break dancing, MCi ng, and DJ-ing (Myer and Kleck 2007; George 1998; Rose 1994, Xie, Osumare, and Ibrahim 2007). It has also been defined in terms of African and Black traditions of art, dan ce, poetry, fashion, and experience (Love 2008, Rose 1994). Hip hop culture began in South Br onx in the 1970s. The three original DJs, Afrika Bambaataa, Kool Herc, and Grandmaste r Flash, created the disc jockey style of mixing and scratching records to get a desire d beat (George 1998). While the DJs spun, scratched, cut, or mixed recorded music, the MC, or the master of ceremonies or mic controller, was on the microphone to energi ze the crowd. These MCs are now commonly referred to as rappers. This music is now co mmonly referred to as rap or hip hop. Rap music evolved as a component of the larger hip hop culture (Love 2008; Pough 2004). Thus rap music is the music of hip hop culture although some refer to this as hip hop music. The terms hip hop music a nd rap music have diffe rent meanings for some. For example, the Billboard charts, an au thority of music airpla y and sales for over 50 years, have a chart for R&B/hip hop musi c and a separate chart for rap music. To further confuse the issue, R&B or urban mu sic is sometimes categorized as hip hop/rap, as seen with Billboard and RIAA (the R ecording Industry Association of America). Radio stations often claim to be the number one source for hip hop and R&B, reinforcing the relationship between hip hop and R&B with no mention of rap. The interviewees in my study did not assert th e distinction between rap and hip hop music which can sometimes arouse strong sentiments from lovers of true hip hop. Following the lead of the participants in this study and of much of the literature on hip hop music and rap, I interchange these two terms freely. The hip hop music genre is made up of several different subgenres. making it difficult to define hip hop culture within this broad spectrum Persaud (2006). Scholars categorize subgenres such as old-school party, mack/pimp, jazz/bohemian, reality, gangsta, materialistic/bling, crunk, and political (Borthwick and Moy 2004; Dyson 2007). Within these subcategories, participants al l seemed to be familiar with the same
3 mainstream music (radio Top 40) and artists, or at least discussed these the most. There were very few references to lesser-know n, underground, or even old school fathers of hip hop music. In response to my questions of Whos your favorite musical artist? or Whats your favorite song? they gave simila r answers from the more widely known list of artists who frequent the radio and music television, with some responses overlapping between interviewees. Included in their responses about rap or hip hop music were also artists that might be considered more R& B artists. However si nce R&B and hip hop are closely related, as noted above, and since my goal was to understand the views of my interviewees, I accepted their categoriza tions of artists at face value. Youth Culture and Identity Adolescence is a unique time period when identity and critical thinking develop. Because this study focuses on adolescent hip hop fans, it is important to understand how ones development during this time period differs from childhood or adulthood and could affect ones musical interpre tations. Adolescence is a time when teens are developing formal operational thinking, which includes abst ract and complex reasoning abilities, and also metacognition, which is the ability to be reflective upon ones thinking (Gruber and Thau 2003). With the development of these skills they are better able to decipher what is relevant and how it applies to them. At the same time, adolescents are developing their own self-concepts and may draw upon media influences. Adolescents are particularly vulnerable to the information they are exposed to because they are likely to use it as a basis for decision making without the cognitive ability to consider other decision-making pathways (Gruber and Thau 2003:442). This is one reason to be concerned about adolescents media use and me dia literacy. How well do they think critically about the media with which they interact? Like all individuals, youth need to feel accepted as a member within a social group. In the social jungle of human existen ce there is no feeling of being alive without a sense of identity (Erikson 1968:130). Social identification is wh en a person feels a connection with some other person or group. During the teenage years, language, dress, musical tastes, and other symbolic systems ar e integral to identifying with peers because they are concrete markers of identificati on (Danesi 1994). Although th e identity of people of any age is agentive, flexible, and ever-cha nging, the identity asso ciations of teens are important connections to how they will unders tand the world as adults (Bucholtz 2002). This transitional identity carries extra weight because it is a bridge to adolescents adult identity. Adolescence and early adulthood is a period for re shaping values and ideas, and exploring ones relationshi p to the world (Brake 1980:25 ). Thus it is important to examine how elements of adolescence, such as music, may or may not influence the transitional period of identity exploration. While youth culture offers a collective id entity for young people, this is often not enough to satisfy questions of individual id entity. Young people need an identity which separates them from the exp ectations and roles imposed upon them by family, school and work (Brake 1980:166). Erik H. Erikson discussed adolescent identity in his book Identity: Youth and Crisis (1968). He notes that adolesce nts are often preoccupied with how they appear to others compared to how they feel about themselves. This creates a search for a uniform identity that fits into others perception and the selfs perception (Erikson 1968). During this period of sear ching for identity, which Erikson terms
4 identity confusion, youth often find solace in groups or cliques that accept them. To keep themselves together they temporarily overidentify with the heroes of cliques and crowds to the point of an a pparently complete loss of individuality (Erikson 1968:132). Adolescents form cliques within subcultures on the basis of ideology, style, values, and lifestyle, in order to comfort each other duri ng the period of identity confusion (Erikson 1968; Brake 1980). Hip hop is a subculture with ideology, style, values and lifestyle that can offer a source of comfort for identity-seeking teens. How do adolescent fans identify with these aspects of hip hop? Theories that relate to cultural youth activ ities have been framed largely in the terminology of interactionism and subcultu ral resistance. Many youth participate in subculture resistance which is apparent through a set of uni fying symbolic artifacts and expressions that are often opposing parent culture or th e dominant culture (Laughey 2006). Accounts of resistance associated almo st exclusively with working-class youth subcultures implicate collective groups with shared demographic characteristics in the same structural relationship to the equally monolithic dominant/parent culture (Laughey 2006:52). This means that adolescents who have similar characteristic s are likely to unite in opposition to the dominant or parent culture. Identity and Interpretations Among Popular Music Listeners Each music genre within popular music ha s its own group of fans who often have particular markers of identity connected to the musical preferences they share. This is not to say that one cannot enjoy music from di fferent genres, but as Borthwick and Moy (2004) indicate, music genres are sometime s embedded within an entire culture and lifestyle, making it difficult to be a partial fa n. Hip hop is certainly not the only genre to have a lifestyle surrounding its music. Fans of heavy metal music believe their music is just one element in a whole way of life en compassing dress, social activities, hobbies and collecting, and implied values (Borthwick and Moy 2004:140). Similarly, punk music implies connections to punk politics, journalism, fashion, poetry, cartoons, fiction, cinema, and etiquette (Borthwick and Moy 2004). Punk rock addresses political, social, and economic issues of the times (Borthwick and Moy 2004), meaning that the fans most likely share these political lean ings in their daily lives. Adolescents can choose to identify with cultures surrounding their musical preference. Youth subcultures have been often organized around music (Blair 2004:498) and are even credited for making rock n roll possible. Deena Weinstein (1999) portrays youth and rock n roll as Siamese twins born in the 1950s. Teenagers of this time experienced an increase in ec onomic affluence and freedom from financial responsibilities. With this, they chose to spend their money on music that spoke to adolescent situations. Rock and roll was al so sexually expressive, which helped wedge the natural divide between t eens and parents. In the eight ies, the relationship between youth and rock and roll became less pronounced as the audience grew broader (Weinstein 1999). Still, one cannot argue with the claim that rock and ro ll began with support almost entirely from youth culture. Along the same vein, Andrew Ross (1994:3) argues for the contractual nature of youth music, claiming that the le vel of attention and meaning invested in music by youth is still unmatched by almost any other organized activity in society, including religion. Because adolescents invest so much of themselves in this music, it is appropriate to explore how adolescents interpret popular music.
5 Within youth subcultures, hip hop is am ong the most popular genres. According to the 2007 Consumer Profile from the R ecording Industry Association of America (RIAA), the rap/hip-hop genre accounte d for 10.8% of sales and R&B/urban2 11.8%. Consumers from 10-19 years old made up 23.8% of all record sale s in 2007. In 2001, hip hop music sales accounted for 89.2 million or 11.7% of the total 763 million albums sold (Xie et al. 2007). These subs tantial numbers represent the legally purchased music and do not account for the shari ng of music files or ill egal downloading of music. From a general economic impact, it is estimated that hip hop contributes $5 billion to the US economy through clothing, films, and television sales a ssociated with hip hop culture (Xie et al. 2007). Rap musics outcry against st ructural oppression speaks to teen resistance, giving youth challenging the dominant or parent cu lture a voice through hi p hop. Musical taste and the collective sense of identity to which su ch taste often gives rise may grow out of a shared sense of experience or the aesthetic a nd political values that members attach to a particular popular music genr e (Bennett 2000:50). Youth may identify with others who appreciate the same music and look for models to shape their behavior and values. As long as rappers are part of a dolescent lives, there is potential for these rappers to be seen as their role models (Richa rdson and Scott 2002; Anderson 1999). By asking fans to talk about hip hop, we can see what it is about th e music and culture that appeals to them-whether it be its rebellious undertones or th e rapping role models or something entirely different. Individual experiences c ontribute to how someone constructs meaning from music (Krims 2000; Esposito and Love 2008; Negus 1997). Not everyone will interpret a piece of music in the same way because not everyone has the same understandings or experiences. Research on popular music ques tions the listeners degree of active participation with music. Frankfurt School Cr itical Theorists such as Theodor W. Adorno (1990) believe that popular music is so predi gested that it leaves no room for audience interpretation thus eliminating the construc tion of personal meaning and significance of popular music. More recent cu ltural studies of music insi st that although the culture industries shape the music we hear and so me of our interpretations, popular music consumers take an active role in creating musical meanings (Bennett 2000). Individuals listen to music from their own personal pers pective and construct their interpretations from their unique point of view. Stuart Hall (1997)has claimed that texts have one reading that is most commonl y shared among people of the same culture, but he also acknowledges the likelihood of oppositional a nd negotiated readings that allow for a great deal of indi vidual variation. When examining the dynamics between music producers and consumers on a macro level, we can assume that most music is supported and funded because it promises to make money by targeting general listeners This popular hip hop, or mainstream, music sells to the market that is certain to buy, sometimes by appealing to the lowest common denominators of sex, violence, and other shoc king imagery in order to guarantee high sales (Gladwell 2005). At the same time, how well consumers receive popular music influences the music industrys decisions, as the music industry and its clientele are in 2 Includes R&B, Blues, Dance, Disco, F unk, Fusion, Motown, Reggae, and Soul which are sometimes cross-referenced with rap/hip-hop.
6 constant negotiation (Krims 2000; Negus 1997). In other words, if consumers passively purchased music, then the music industr ys decisions would go unchallenged and producers could release anything successfully. In this sense, listeners would be like robots who purchase music to follow a crow d or the music companies lead without thinking about the music. Asking how hi p hop listeners descri be their musical preferences will shed light on the extent to which they are active listeners who think about the music instead of robots dutifully pur chasing whatever is on the market. There is no way to be certain whether music influences listeners understandi ngs of the world or conversely listeners choose their music ba sed on their understandings. We can assume that there is at least a reflexive relationshi p at work in which li steners worldviews and their taste in music influence each other. Andy Bennett (2000) has researched how musi c contributes to a localized sense of identity. According to Benne tt (2000:195), Music not only informs the construction of the self, but also the social world in which the self ope rates. Among Bennetts general conclusions is the finding that young people use the local and familiar as their central point of reference when discussing what music means to them (Bennett 2000). Young people take the cultural resour ces provided by the popular culture industries and use the prescribed meani ngs attached to such resources as templates around which to construct their own forms of meaning and authenticity. Although the resulting variations in musical significance obviously retain a sense of conn ectednessfor example, hip hop enthusiasts possess essentially the same sensibilities of commercially communicated style, musical taste and street-talk irrespective of their location on the globeat the same time they become infused with distinctive knowledges and sensibili ties which originate from the particular region in which they are lived out (Bennett 2000:27). As Bennett highlights, hip hop fans have comm onalities that distingui sh them from other music genre fans. Social identification with hi p hop music and culture is one factor that influences how youth understand themselves and the world. Of course, youth have several templates that do this. Music might influence identity formation, but perhaps no more than the family, church, school, work, extra curricular activiti es, or peers. The degree of symbolic interacti on a hip hop fan may have with other fans, the music, or other components of hip hop culture will affect how integral it is to ones world. Greg Dimitriadis conducted a longitudina l ethnographic study of hip hops use to youth at a local community center. He concl uded that hip hop served as an unofficial curriculum. The young people he studied drew upon hip hop narratives to create meaning in their world. Popular media forms made a whole host of construc ts available to the young people at the community center where I conducted this research (Dimitriadis 2005:36). As a trusted authority figure, Di mitriadis was able to conduct informal interactions with the youth at the center. He listened to how they talked about important issues and how they drew upon dominant themes in rap musi c and movies to describe their lived experiences (Dim itriadis 2005). Two boys construc ted a sense of community and Southern values through Southern rap mu sic. The boys also referenced rap music when explaining notions of playing and player -hating in romantic re lationships and also notions of trust in friendships. Dimitria dis also observed th at hip hop artist Tupac represented a validated sense of self to the youth; Young people seem to be creating
7 myths that work to mitigate against inte nse feelings of vul nerabilityas young, black, poor, and gendered subjects in the United St ates today (Dimitriadis 2005:117-118). This study highlights the complexity of adolescents, but also demo nstrates the utilization of hip hop narratives in understanding onesel f and the world. Dimitriadis (2005) also stresses that it is important for policy makers to unders tand how youth create a sense of place in life before developing policies and in stitutions relevant to their lives. Bettina L. Love (2008) also conducted an ethnography of nine young Black students from 13-17 years old at a local comm unity center. Using interviews, focus group interviews, observations, and document analys es of media materials, she found four major themes of how rap music informed these youth on ideas of gender, race, sexuality, and education. Her participants understood the images of rap music to be authentic Black representations, leading the girls to believe th at real Black women have a large backside and a promiscuous character. The absence of White women from rap videos led them to believe that Whites make better choices and have better work options, which consequently indicates that they believe Black women are less intelligent and do not value their bodies as much. Love (2008) attributes these understandings to the significance her participants pla ced on media images, in combin ation with the girls lack of positive female role models and critical thinking skills. The stories of all youth are important to understanding raps impact and influence in todays growing technological world that is driven by mass media (Love 2008: 182). Her research calls for educators to teach students how to think critically about the media texts they consume. Capital and Authenticity Pierre Bourdieu proposes different form s of capital that are acquired through and exist in the social world. Cultural capital, the knowledge and skills acquired through socialization within a partic ular status group, can be turn ed into economic capital under certain conditions and may be institutionalized in the form of educational qualifications. This cultural knowledge can earn access to va rious social groups with similar cultural capital. Social capital is esse ntially membership and acceptan ce into a group or a durable network of relationshi ps (Bourdieu 2001). Sarah Thornton offers an image of subcultural capital which is similar to Bourdieu (2001), applying it spec ifically to the context of youth and music. Subcultural capital is a concept that describes markers of taste, preference, ta cit knowledge, and skills that pertain to a subculture but may be irre levant in the dominant, main culture (Thornton 1995). Bourdieus cultural capital focuses on how lear ned, academic knowledge functions as capital in social contexts. Thorntons subcultural capital focuses on how hipness functions as capita l in youths social contexts. More important than class, hipness is crucial to subcu ltural capital in the same way as knowledge is at the base of cultural capital (Huq 2006:51). Hipness is how well you can keep up with the dynamics within the subculture. To be hip is to be privy to insider knowledges that are threatened by the general di stribution and easy access of mass media (Thornton 1995:6). In hip hop culture it is how well-informed you are of new music, new artists, lingo, fashion, current events, and gossip. Therefore, subcultural capital is more relevant in the context of this paper because it pertains di rectly to the ways youth acquire and apply notions of hipness to their connection between music and social life.
8 Just as artists are judged according to their apparent authenticity, a fans awareness of various artists authenticity help s define that fans level of hipness. In fact, this effort to identify the real is a major preoccupation within hip hop culture and the term keepin it real has been a mantra sin ce the 1970s when hip hop began (Gaunt 2002; Forman 2002; Richardson 2007). Identification of what is real has ramifications for shaping individuals conceptions of what ma kes anyone, including themselves, real. For a hip hop fan, knowing what it takes to be real is a kind of insider knowledge. When fans assess the authenticity of rappers they are as serting their own subcu ltural capital in the process. By understanding how fans assess the subcultural capital of rappers, we can see a relationship to how fans understand their own social positions within hip hop culture. This thesis discusses how adolescent hip hop fa ns determine an artist s authenticity by invoking their own subcultural capital. Fans acquire a lot of the subcultural capital that allows them to make these authenticity assessments from the mass me dia. Thornton emphasizes this difference between her theory and Bourdieus theories, A critical difference between subcultural capital (as I develop it) and cultural capital (as Bourdieu develops it) is that the media are a primary factor governing the circulation of the former (Thornton 1995:13). The media are key because the difference between being in or out of fashion, high or low in subcultural capital, correlates in complex wa ys with degrees of media coverage, creation and exposure (Thornton 1995:14). Thus a lot of hipness is learned a nd acquired from hip hop music, fashion, and news itself. Sometimes it is transmitted through peers to other fans, but it commonly enters peer culture through the media. Hip hop audiences mirror what they learn from the media. Fans look into hip hop culture to search for understandings of hipness that they then repr oduce. The reproduction of hipness is part of the feedback loop: hipness is acquired from the fans and disp layed in the media, and fans acquire hipness from the media, reproduci ng it in a similar fashion (Goodman and Dretzin 2001). Bourdieus cultur al and social capital are usef ul concepts for my purposes, but Thorntons subcultural capital will be re ferred to most often because it pertains specifically to youth and music. Media Literacy and Adolescents Young people learn about themselves a nd others through the consumption of popular culture texts such as music, televi sion, and film (Esposito and Love 2008:32). In a Canadian study of 168 children in grades one through six, the researchers asked children questions about music preferences in open-ended and forced-choice questionnaires. The data indica ted that older children offered more complex explanations of why they liked a particular song. Older ch ildren also preferred hip hop and rap music more than the younger ones (Bosacki et al 2006). The researchers suggest that the change in preference could be attributed to the complex themes in hip hop and rap that might be better understood in later childhood, or perhaps the beat and the real life stories in the music (Bosacki et al. 2006). Th ey found that their participants played an active role in constructing their music co llection; Given the purchasing power of children and preadolescents in todays consum er society, parents and educators need to encourage children to become critical consumer s of the media, including popular music (Bosacki et al. 2006:380). This study pointed to the need for media literacy to be taught in schools, given that music played a part in these childrens persona l and social lives.
9 Cultural studies of media audiences aim to understand the power dynamics of mass media systems, the role mass media pl ay in peoples everyday lives, and the particular nature of audience experience (F isherkeller 1997:468). Jo Ellen Fisherkellers work with three middle schooler s revealed that they learne d from local cultures (family and peers) differently than from televisi on cultures (Fisherkelle r 1997). She examined comments about television from three particip ants to explore identity construction and cultural learning. She connected interpretations of a particul ar television persona to the viewers life circumstances, to their perceptions of self and the social world, and to their sense of the future. Fisherkell er (1997) concluded that her participants acquired guidance from real people and situations within their local cultures, but looked to television culture for imaginative strategies to help them realize their dreams and cope with personal dilemmas. While she recognizes that [c]ontex tual analyses of young peoples talk about television are valuable means for expl oring how young people build a sense of themselves as members of multiple worlds within which mass-produced cultural symbols are prominent and proliferating (Fisherk eller 1997:487), she also points to further studies of this nature with various forms of media. Analyses of how teens talk about music and other forms of media (films, vi deo games, books) can lend insight into how they draw upon music to make sens e of themselves and their world. While little has been written on medi a literacys implications for understanding music, there are numerous articles on the need for media literacy to counteract the possible negative effects of television vi ewing (Maness 2004; Krue ger 1998; Singer and Singer 1998; Brown 2002; Fisherkeller 1997; Grub er and Thau 2003). Media literacy is the ability to think critically about inform ation contained and c onveyed through a variety of non-print media (Maness 2004; Krueger 1998). It seems apparent that the artificial social reality of television does affect per ceptions of young children and that explanation or mediation is necessary to counteract the glamour and stereotypes of televisions portrayals (Singer and Singer 1998:167). These studies stress a need to research how youth ar e interpreting media and a need for them to formally learn how to be critical of media, so as not to interpret televisionor any other media for that matte ras pure truth (Krueger 1998; Singer and Singer 1998; Brown 2002; Fisherkeller 1997) In one national study 9 out of 10 American children reported living in homes with 2 or more television sets, 97% had VCRs, 75% had access to cable television, and more than half had a TV in their own room (Gruber and Thau 2003:441). These st atistics from a 1999 survey suggest easy access to television, which includes the then three large music video stations MTV, VH1, and BET. Between the ages of 8 and 18, Am erican children are exposed on average to almost 8 hours of media each day, more than 40% through television (Gruber and Thau 2003:438). The concern for adoles cents television viewing in cludes any viewing of these major music stations that play music videos and music related content specifically catered to their age group. In this sense, music is a media that overlaps with television and raises concern for the images associated with it, as studies on music videos point out (Jones 1997; Emerson 2002). Therefore music is a form of mass media that is traditionally in the audio form, but since the intr oduction of music television, it is also visual. Concerns about televisions effects can also apply to musics visual forms.
10 Steele and Brown describe a process wh ereby teens select particular media products, interact with those media in an in terpretive and evaluative process, and then apply aspects of the media produc t to their lives (Maness 2004). Jeanne R. Steele and Jane D. Brown ag ree that adolescents, like adults, use media for a variety of purposes: to enhance their mood, to sort through cultural norms and values, to make statements about their identity, to emulate desired behaviors (e.g., imitating role models), and to fantasize about a possible (alternative ) self (Manne ss 2004:47). Steele and Brown (1995) describe a process whereby teens select particular media products, interact with those media in an in terpretive and evaluative process, and then apply aspects of the media pr oduct to their lives (as cited in Maness 2004). Thus the media are appropriated and become part of lived experience, which motivates new selections of media. Similarly, David Buckingham and Julian Sefton-Green (1994:30) argue that media provides symbolic resources that young audiences use to define and resist the various social identities that are available to them. While adolescents might use media as diversely as adults, it is important to reme mber that young people use media to achieve goals that are intimately connected with their identity and their social interaction (Maness 2004:47). Particularly in the context of hip hop music, which is widely ridiculed for its hyper-sexualized and violent imag ery (Emerson 2002; Collins 2004; Pough 2004; Ogbar 2007; Rose 1994; Ward, Hansbrough, and Walker 2005; Richardson and Scott 2002), we need a better understanding of how literally youth interpret this music and how much critical music literacy they display in their interpretations. This is why it is important for adults involved with youth to understand how adolescents apply music and other forms of media to their lived experiences. Hip Hop Culture and Race Hip hop culture is inextricably linked to the Black community where it began. Hip hop music is still predominan tly produced and presented by Blacks. The superficial assumption is that Black youth will be more likely to perceive similarities between themselves and major actors of hip hop cultu re. Therefore Black youth may see rappers and producers as role models and listen to hi p hop music more than other genres. This assumption has a certain amount of support in the literature. The culture of hip hop has become the nexus from which youth (parti cularly lower income Black youngsters) can create their values, define their selfhood agai nst a social backdrop that has historically devalued their color and contributions (Richardson and Scott 2002:185). Although a persons identity formation is never based entirely upon one experience, but rather a combination of several influences, this statement may have some credibility. The street code is seen a nd reflected in rap music. Ch aris E. Kubrin (2006:434) discusses the link between rap music and the street code: Rap music speaks directly to issues of identity, culture, and violence, themes that permeate recent research on inner-city Black communities. Mostly ethnographic in nature, this [Kubrins paper] describes how structural disadvantage, social isolat ion, and despair have created a Black youth culture or street code that influences adolescent behavior, particularly with respect to violence.
11 It could be that in rap music, Black youth s ee themselves so accurately reflected in the music that it serves as a strong influence on identity formation. The street code and rap lyrics do not compel youth to act, but they provide an interpretive resource that can be drawn upon to understand as well as justif y social identity and behavior (Kubrin 2006:442). This notion can be applied to any lyrics because music provides youth with a resource for shaping their identity and behavior. While hip hop music may be influential in the identity formation of Black youth, it also has implications for other races. A common misconception is that hip hop music and culture create a template for how Black people understand themselves merely because of their racial identif ication with the artist. While it is true that hip hop may describe various Black identi ties, the identities cons tructed are not wholly and exclusively the property of people designa ted as Black people (Hylton and Miller 2004:374). The narratives in rap songs can be applied to and in terpreted by anyone listening, even though almost all its artists are Black. Black people may more readily describe the stories on display; however they are not excl usive properties or understandings of Black people (Hylton and Miller 2004:374). Through the media, hip hop culture has b een appropriated by the dominant White culture. This profitable move made it only natural that hi p hop is appropriated by races and socioeconomic levels other than th e one from which it was born. White youth purchase an overwhelming amount of hip hop music (Kitwana 2005; Diamond, Bermundez, and Schensul 2006; Krims 2000; Xie et al. 2007). This is debated for its implications about authenticit y, appropriation, racial integr ation, and morals (Kitwana 2005). Some scholars argue that the more ne gative the commentary surrounding rap, the more White audiences are drawn to it (Sam uels 2004; Richardson and Scott 2002; Riley 2005). The fact is that youth and adults of a ll races are exposed to and are purchasing hip hop music. Because of rap, the voices, images, styl e, attitude, and language of young Blacks have become central in American culture, transcending geographic, social, and economic boundaries (Kitwana 2002:196). Th e pervasiveness of hip hop in popular culture creates cultural identities in the media that represen t Black urban communities. However, with its central position in society, hip hop culture offe rs a societal norm with which adolescents of all different races a nd backgrounds can identify. The focus on rap as a source of identity among its artists and audiences is not discontinuous with recent concerns in popular music studies (Krims 2000). However, if rap music has been censored, continues to be questioned, and continues to stir Americans into moral panic (Bennett 2001; Krims 2000; Collins 2006 ; Chang 2005), then it has been assumed that hip hop listeners are influenced by either actively creating or passively absorbing meanings from the music. While there is a body of literature examining various aspects of hip hop culture, there is little that attempts to understand hip hop culture from the perspective of the young listener. Youth are cultural actors w hose experiences are best understood from their point of view (Bucholtz 2002:533). Research Questions After reviewing the literature on youth cu lture, popular music, identity, capital and authenticity, media liter acy, and hip hop culture, some qu estions remain as to how these fields relate to adolescent hip hop fa ns and their understanding of hip hop music. As
12 part of popular music, hip hop fans are critic ized for not thinking critically about their music. Are fans active listeners who think critically about their music or are they simply followers who passively purchase whatever music is considered popular at the time? Youth culture offers a collective identity for young people Adolescents are developing critical thinking skills during this period of transition when feelings of identity are significant. Theories relating to youth activ ities often discuss s ubcultural resistance. Hip hop is a subculture with ideology, style, values, and lifestyle that can offer a source of comfort for identity-seeking teens. How do adolescent fans identify with these aspects of hip hop? Previous studies (Bennett 2000; Dimitriadis 2005; Love 2008) indicate that hip hop fans use the music to inform the construction of their own identity. Some (Weinstein 1999; Ross 1994; Bennett 2000) claim that teens are dr awn to music that speaks to adolescent situations that can offer a sense of collective identity. How do teen fans identify with hip hop music? Does the music serve offer templates around which fans construct their own forms of meaning and authenticity? Studies on media literacy and television view ing emphasize a need to research how youth are interpreting media and a need for them to formally learn how to be critical of media (Krueger 1998; Singer and Singer 19 98; Brown 2002; Fisherkeller 1997). How well do teen hip hop fans think cri tically about the media with which they interact? These questions seek to reveal how y outh interpret hip hop music and how their relationship with hip hop music relates to their understanding of the world and issues of identity. The key research questions that incorporate all the questions above are: How do adolescent hip hop fans desc ribe their interaction with and understanding of hip hop music? How critical are hip hop fans about the media with which they interact? I believe that a study addressing these que stions will yield important information pertinent to hip hop fans as well as social service workers, parents, educators, policy makers and others who interact with young hip hop fans.
13 Chapter Two Methods The question of how to st udy Black culture and hip hop culture has been debated in the literature. Black culture in general has been widely misinterpr eted historically and still suffers from misrepresentation in soci al science. As Kelley notes (2004:120), there has been research on Blacks in the past th at was likened to the ethnographer exploring concrete jungles, where more often than not, they do not let the natives speak. Kelleys concern is that ethnographer s are less likely to captur e the essence of the Black experience when Blacks are conceptualized as the exotic other, espe cially if there is little interaction with those studied. Because of the popular association between Black culture and hip hop culture, this tendency to ex oticize can become an obstacle in research like mine. There are many possible ways of overcoming these problems in research, and each research method has st rengths and weaknesses. In investigating youths interpretations of hip hop, I am in step with the third generation of cultural studies research as de fined by Pertti Alasuut ari (1999). Audience studies have taken on various forms in cultura l studies research. Alasuutari argues that there are three generations of media audi ence research. Alasuutari sees the third generation, which takes a constructionist view as the future of audience studies. This method starts with peoples daily lives as the ob ject of research. The objective is to get a grasp of our contemporary media culture, both as a topic and as an activity structured by and structuring the discourses within which it is discussed (Alas uutari 1999:7). It also studies medias role in everyday life as opposed to an isolated analysis of texts. My research is grounded in this third generation of audience re search which recognizes the need to examine how media are used in everyday lives as well as the discourse surrounding media. Since I am interested in how adolesce nts understand hip hop, listening to them discuss it will be more effectiv e than observing their behaviors. The goal of this research is not to understand the collaborative cons truction of meaning, for which focus groups would be most useful (Tiggeman, Gardiner, and Slater 2000). In my view, the strongest method for gaining access to the individual interpretations of yout h is the open-ended interview. One-on-one open-ended interview of fer a venue for interviewees to address topics that are relevant to them. It also allows participants to construct their own responses rather than choose fr om a list of given responses. Stephens and Few indicate that interviews with youth provide the most direct window into adolescents experiences through rich descriptions that can detail fact s that are not easily quantified (2007:254). Open-ended interviews are designed to gain a wealth of information from the interviewee with the option for the researcher to question further on particular t opics that arise. Kubrin seems to advise the interview as an ideal methodology for my specific purposes: An essential follow-up to this st udy would take research ers into inner-city
14 communities to talk with residents, particular ly those who listen to rap music. Face-toface interviews are necessary to understand how residents re spond to, interpret, and are influenced by rap musics content (Kubrin 2005:454). I aimed to accomplish this very thing in asking low-income Black youth a bout hip hop music. At the same time, I included other races and socioeconomic classes to more accurately represent rap musics varied audience. A Canadian study examining the popular musical preferen ces of 168 children concluded that Future researchers shoul d explore how children make meaning or construct their persona l interpretations from popular music (Bosacki et al. 2006:381). Lipsitz (1994) and Kitwana (2005) both st ress the need to understand what young people are communicating through their dance, dre ss, speech and visual imagery. Thus, for my interest in hip hops role in the lives of youth, there is not only a need to listen to youth themselves, but a lack of their voices commen ting on musical influences in the literature. In studying hip hop culture and asking youth about the music, I seek to reveal the ways youth talk about rap music. Interviewing youth about hip hop can pr esent methodological challenges. The methodological challenges I faced in this proj ect concern: 1) my position as an easily recognized outsider and potential ly also as an authority fi gure; 2) the ways in which adolescence (and in some cases, non-White st atus of the interviewee) can encourage youth to adopt particular poses as research re spondents, tailoring thei r comments to fit the currently circulating vocabul aries of motives (ways of acc ounting for their own actions and thoughts) for liking hip hop. These challenge s are addressed below in the following sections that detail the sampling techni que, performance in interviews, my own presentation of self, the interviews, and examining talk. Sampling Technique The adolescents from this sample varied in their race and class backgrounds. My 16 year old family friend was the first member of my snowball sample, and she referred me to other hip hop fans she knows from her high school. As part of the snowball sampling process, they were all initially contacted on my behalf by someone they knew personally, who portrayed me as a friend. Th ese participants were informed by their friend that I was doing a research project interviewing hip hop fans. When I set up interviews through text messaging their cell phones or talking to them on the phone I informed them that I am a graduate student in sociology interested in what adolescent hip hop fans have to say about music. I told them that I wanted to in terview them for about an hour and listen to their ideas about hip hop music. I also offered to buy them food and met them at various restaurants near their homes. Prior to this project, I had been a 4th grade teacher for three years at a local elementary school. To obtain additional partic ipants for this project, I contacted a fellow teacher from that school and asked her to pu t me in touch with any former students of hers who were also hip hop fans. She conn ected me with three interviewees. These students had remained in informal contact with her and had attended the school where I once taught while I was teaching there. At that time, several years ago, they had interacted with me frequently. When they knew me best, they saw me in the teacher role. My first challenge in these interviews was thus to break down some of the authority vs. student status hierarc hy in order to enable a less encumb ered discussion. I had to be sure
15 to present myself to them as almost an equa l. Before turning on the tape recorder, we had brunch and talked about acquaintances we ha d in common such as family and friends, and also different things goi ng on in entertainment gossip. All three interviewees who had known me in the teaching capacity were Black and from low income neighborhoods. A Note on Performance in my Interviews Erving Goffman discussed how individuals construct themselves in the presence of others according to circumstances and set tings of the encounter. He asserts that individuals generally try to control the impressi on they give off in the presence of others (Goffman 1959). Goffmans point is that in any social circumstance, in addition to whatever else we are accomplis hing, we are also performing our self for others who are observing us. In every given situation, we co mmit to a particular performance which can change during the course of the interaction. The individuals initial projection commits him to what he is proposing to be and requi res him to drop all pretenses of being other things (Goffman 1990:135). Full commitment to a specific role is called embracement. To embrace a role is to disappear completely into the virtual self available in the situation, to be fully seen in terms of the image, and to confirm expressively ones acceptance of it (Goffman 1990:102). Goffmans theories of performance apply directly to the participant/researcher or interview ee/interviewer positions. Before committing to a particular performance, the interviewees eval uated me to determine what performance of self they were going to embrace. In conversation I believe that I was able to assure them that they could perform their hip hop inside r self because, being an insider myself, I understood their language a nd cultural references3. Clearly they were engaged in impression management, but in sharing my own understanding of hip hop references and love of the music, I made every effort to impress upon them my status as a peer rather than as an authority figure. In other words, I managed my own performances in a way that I thought would make them relaxed and co mfortable so that they would speak to me as if speaking to a peer. As described below, my particular stat us does not perfectly match that of my interviewees in terms of age, education, or class. When asked their race, none of them identified as biracial like me, White and Asian. I find my qualitative experience to be similar to Elizabeth Chins in that Certainly, peoples idea of who I was influenced them in their relationships to me, and vice versa. But none of us were wholly reinvented for these encounters (Chin 2001:23). Instead, I perfo rmed a particular self that positioned me as a hip hop insider and less as an author ity figure so they would speak to me as a peer or friend. Similarly, interviewees perfor med a particular self for me. They may have given me answers that they assume I want to hear, answers that they believe will appease me, or answers to annoy me. Regardless, the pe rformances are useful for revealing one of the many ways the interviewees make thei r relationship to hip hop understandable to others like myself, through thei r presentation in their langua ge, means of expression, and ideas. 3 Goffmans notions of performance are also re levant and discussed in the data analysis, lending insight into how fans determin e the authenticity of rappers.
16 My Presentation of Self The social interaction between the inte rviewer and intervie wee has long been examined as problematic. Negotiating the researcher role, issues related to the insider/outsider status of the researcher and matters of rapport have long concerned qualitative researchers (Best 2003:896). Crossi ng barriers of race, gender, class, or age may yield skewed data. The participant might cater their answers fo r the interviewer in terms of what they think the right or w rong answer might be depending on whether they respond based on what they think the interviewer wants to hear or even if they want to purposely distort the results. Therefore, it was necessary for me to present my subcultural capital to position myself as an insider to minimize barriers between myself and the participants. I displayed my own subcultural capital th rough the questions I asked, the statements I made, and the mome ntary, spontaneous thoughts I brought up as I would in normal conversation. Before the interview, the participants a ll knew I was studying to get my masters degree in sociology and that my thesis was on hip hop music. Knowing this automatically earned me somewhat of an insider status in hip hop culture because they assumed I knew about hip hop. I also selectively employed both proper English and hip hop slang as I would if I were talking to my own friends. Finally, the fact th at we were talking about the rather neutral topic of a musi c genre that appeals to people of all races may have also minimized any significance my race or other barriers could have had in the interviews. Before conducting this research, I was warned that my race would be very problematic because hip hop is predominan tly represented by Blacks. As mentioned earlier, hip hop fans are not homogenous so I could not assume that my participants would or would not be White or Asian like myself. Ethnically, I am half Swedish and half Korean. By other peoples perception I can f it neatly into the White category, but I have also been classified as Latina, and most of ten as Chinese or racially ambiguous. My own ambiguous racial status highlights the soci ological premise that race is socially constructed; race is an ongoing interactional achievement and not an essential attribute (Best 2003). My presentation of my own race may have mitigated intimidating perceptions of Whiteness or Asian-ness. As a number of prominent Black anth ropologists have pointed out, being of the same race as the people you are researching is no guarantee of mutual understanding and can pose obstacles for discovering information. Racial groups are far from homogenous and factors other than race may facilitate or impede effective fieldworkeven in the hyperracially conscious United States (Chin 21-22:2001). This is not to say that my race is unproblem atic, but rather, that it may be less of a problem than some outsiders to this subculture may presume. Other factors were my age, which is 712 years removed from the ages of my participants, my sex as a female, and my class status as a graduate student. Some respondents knew that I was once a teacher. In situating myself as an insider genuinely interested in what they had to say, I a ttempted to minimize these differences. The participants who asked my age all guessed that I was closer to their age than I actually was. I cannot be sure how my class or gende r may have affected their responses, but it did not seem like there was much distance be tween myself and the interviewees as we spoke, since they were willing to talk to me extensively about topics that could only be
17 understood by a fellow hip hop fan. In addition, I certainly joked around with them to put them at ease during the interview. Essentially, I presented myself and played my role as a researching hip hop fan which situated me clos e enough to the particip ants to allow them to relax. Some of them had access to my My Space page before we met, so they may have looked at it, gaining insight into the social networking site aspect of me. On my My Space page I have pictures of myself with frie nds from various trips, myself with family members, and also pictures taken from onlin e sources of some of my favorite artists. Some of my My Space friends are also some of my favorite hip hop artists. I feature a song and some of my favorite music videos on my profile that change with my mood. On the about me section I ha ve quoted an author, The real question is this: why shoul d hip-hop generationers continue to participate in and support a multibillion dollar industry if it fails to in any way address the critical problems f acing our generation? What good is rap music if it does nothing more than give young Blacks the opportunity to 'dance to our own degradation'...and if it enriches only a few at the expense of the many? -Bakari Kitw ana, The Hip Hop Generation. If participants viewed my page, they may ha ve seen that my personal musical preferences lie within the more critical corner s of the broader genre of hip hop. Regardless of how participants may have pe rceived my race, class, or status, they quickly understood that I was well versed with their language and that I shared in their subcultural capital. They were comfortabl e in these interviews mentioning names, concepts, events, and other insider knowledge with the assumption that I knew what they were talking about. I demonstrated my subcu ltural capital enough to convince them of my insider status so that they did not feel the need to translate their language and could speak more freely than they could have with some other researchers who do not share in their subcultural capital. The Interviews Before each interview began, I read the participant the IRB approved informed consent form appropriate for their age (eithe r the child form for those under 18 or the adult form for those over 18). They signed a copy and were given a copy to keep along with my contact information. For those unde r 18 years old, I spoke with their parent beforehand and collected written consent from them as well. Each interview lasted about one hour, the shortest being forty minutes a nd the longest being one hour and forty-five minutes. In the interviews, I actively encourag ed participants to describe hip hop music and artists. Specifically when they brought up real hip hop or rappers, I probed about this definition to gain insight into what they understood the realness of the music to be. I had a list of questions (see Appendix) befo re me that I used to guide me through the interviews, but most often my questions were constructed spontane ously in response to matters the interviewee brought up. For each in terview, I presented the Billboard Music Charts Top 10 Hot Rap Tracks and Hot R&B/Hip Hop Songs to get an understanding of how they talk about the popular songs for that week. Throughout the course of the interviews, there was minimal weekly variation of the songs and artist s so that in using these charts, I collected comments from all th e participants regarding a rather uniform and standard set of songs and artists. All twelve intervie ws were conducted in a quiet
18 corner of a restaurant near their residence, except three participants (Dave, Darrius, and Sarah) who were 18 or older. They were in terviewed in my apartm ent upon their request. Examining Talk The second challenge of interviewees perf orming for the interview, is a problem for any project that asks respondents why they do something. Asking about motives can be problematic because the motive for why someone does something or likes something is unknowable (Mills 1940). Mills argues that sometimes people constr uct the why for a behavior only when questioned. However, there is something to be said for the vocabulary people use to describe motives. This imputation and avowal of motives by actors are social phenomena to be explaine d. The differing reasons men give for their actions are not themselves without reasons (Mills 1940:904). Responses reveal which subjects are important to the participants in what is br ought up most often. These are subsequently also markers of insider status in the hip hop world, and in conversation, I learned how the participants use their subcultural capital in so cial situations. Specifically, responses to my questions revealed the ways adolescents talk about music with me in an interview since I cannot be sure what teens will say when I am not there. In interviewing youth about hip hop mu sic, I can examine the meaning surrounding the words/terms used instead of tr eating the responses as straight-forward explanations. Discourse invol ves ways of being, doing, and knowing and c ontributes to social processes and meaning making (Ric hardson 2007). Language has the power to create and shape reality (Ede r et.al. 1995). Since we can ne ver be completely certain about our true motives for doing things, the ways adolescents talk about hip hop reveals how they bridge understanding between hip hop music and themselves. This shows their understanding of culture--revealing what th ey deem appropriate or inappropriate; important or unimportant. Most significantl y, it shows how they understand themselves and the world in relation to hip hop music. Meet the Participants Almost all of my interviewees were friendl y and talkative, if not in the first ten minutes, definitely by the end of the interv iew. Only one participant, Jay, was on the quiet side and appeared sli ghtly uncomfortable. He was al so the youngest interviewee at 14 years old. In each instance, I had some kind of background information about the interviewee before actually turning on the ta pe recorder. The source of that information came from a variety of places--either from the person who referred me to them, from their myspace page, or from talking to them at some point before the interview. Since individuals interpret things base d on their individual understandings and preconceived notions of the world, it is importa nt to provide a basi c overview of how my interviewees presented themselves to me and what kind of knowledge they are working with as a listener of hip h op. Information about the partic ipants helped define the interviews and what I could expect of th em (Goffman 1959). The participant in an interview setting chooses what role to play, what to reveal to the in terviewer, and how to define themselves within the context of the interview. As mentioned earlier, I positioned myself within hip hop culture as an insider so that th e participants were as comfortable as possible in performing self to me as if I we re a peer. Although they were all presenting a
19 self specific to our conversation and context, there was no reason for me to believe that at any point they were playi ng a role other than that of their everyday selves. Darrius Darrius is a young Black man of 19 who lives in a nice subu rb of the mid-size city of about 1,000,000 where all the interviews o ccurred. He lives with siblings and his mother in a relatively new apartment comp lex. A recent graduate of high school, where he played for the school foot ball team, he was interviewe d during the summer when he was occasionally playing around recording in the booth at a local studio. His friends father owned or had rights to the recordi ng studio so Darrius would mess around with two of his friends recording rap songs. He claimed that he is not trying to get serious with the music industry or trying to break into the rap game. He stands just about 60 tall with big baggy clothes hanging off his lean body. Most of his dreds were pulled back in a r ubber band, those that werent fell just below shoulder-length. Darrius came across as very knowledgable about hip hop music, artists, and the community in his interview. He mentioned that he bought and has watched documentaries of his favorite rap artists. He also indicated that he surfs the internet, specifically YouTube and learns new informati on about various rappers there, too. It was as if he had done his homework before my inte rview, but in reality th is subcultural capital he displayed was all just information that he knew already because it was part of his lived experience. He spoke with authority on different artists. His frie nds father was involved in making music, so Darrius had some sort of affiliation to rap artist Plies but was unspecific in our interview about this. Darrius seemed to convey that he is situated in a group of friends that is very interest ed in and involved with rap music. Darrius entered my apartment and sat slouched on my couch, comfortable and laid-back as he answered my questions. At times he was more animated than others and sat up, sometimes leaning in and using his hands to explain what he was talking about. At the end of the interview he shared that it wa s really fun to talk with me. While he had discussed music before, he had never talked about hip hop from this angle. This was something a lot of the partic ipants shared with meCharlotte, Ronnie, Angelo, Dave, and Pierre. Mimi Mimi is a darker-skinned Black girl of 15 years old who has embraced her larger size. The size of her body reflects her presen ce and draws you to her beautiful face, often radiant and smiling. She is a social butterfly. She sees to it that she is well known among her peers and community. She has grown up in a low-income community with her grandmother with little to no contact with he r biological parents. She is active in a local church with her grandmother. She has a st rong personality and has no problem expressing that she is very opinionated. I knew Mimi when she was a student at my school and I was a classroom teacher. When Mimi was in elementary school she did no t learn to read at the same pace as most other students but was much farther behind. I beli eve this is why she feels so confident in discussing hip hop; it is part of her everyday life and it is something she can command easily. In her interview she conveys a sense of agency and knowledge when discussing
20 hip hop. Mimi indicated that she likes some songs because she can relate to them. Mimi also mentioned that she used to perform hi p hop dancing and still plays around with her friends in a dramatic lip sync style. Ciara Ciara is Mimis best friend who she me t in her current school and they came together. I interviewed them one after the othe r. Ciara is a boister ous light-skinned 15 year old Black girl with woma nly curves and tight curly, sh oulder-length extensions. In my presence she was obvious in trying to be mature and on her best behavior. This was evident when she mouthed words like bitch instead of speaki ng them. But since I interviewed her and Mimi together, she was mo re herself when interacting with Mimi and I was able to get a taste of how Ciara behave d with peers or when she was not trying to act mature. Ciara expressed interest in the female artists and the soulful aspects of music. She seemed to speak of the emotional music with the most passion and even mentioned that she would like to be a good singer one day. Because she is in a relationship now, Ciara was acutely aware of the songs that discusse d relationships and she favored songs that she could relate to. Ty Ty is a Black 18 year old who stands a bout 60. When I interviewed him he had just graduated high school where he was a cross country runner. He has a long wiry frame naturally built for running miles and m iles. That same energy is communicated when talking to him with his compelling personality and smiley baby face. Ty lives in a very typical nuclear fam ily of his mother, father, and younger sister. They live in a house in a new gated community in an up-and-coming area of the suburbs. He was planning on attending a mid-size Univer sity on the other side of the state on a cross country scholarship. Over the summer he was working at his fathers restaurant which had opened only 7 months before our interview. Business seemed slow and he attributed it partially to racial factors. He said that white people look at the menu in the window of their restaurant all the time, see Black folks and then keep on walking to the next storefront. Ty seems to be very conscious of racial dynamics and his place as a Black male. He spoke proper English and did not have as much of a cultura l dialect as the other Black interviewees did. When he mentioned that one of his favorite songs was Boys in the Hood by Easy E, he said that it is about B lack guys in the hood as if there was really nothing more to it. He did not go into deta il or discuss how he related to it. Our conversation led me to wonder if perhaps he st ruggles with his place as a Black male fan of hip hop who has not experienced living in the hood firsthand. Also, Easy-E is an oldschool artist who I was surprised to hear abou t from someone of Tys age. This indicated a wider breadth of hip hop exploration, in te rms of history at least, on Tys part. Sarah Sarah is a focused 17 year old White girl with straight long br own hair that rests upon her strong shoulders attached to her solid st ructure. Shes an avid golfer and has her eyes set on top-ranked colleges and universities for next year Before the interview she
21 expressed how tonight was a good night to m eet because it fell on a rare day where she was not studying for one of her AP classes. Despite this being a more relaxed night, she was still focused on our goals of the interv iew. We got straight down to it and she answered questions expediti ously and frequently um-ed when searching for her response. It was interesting to interview Sa rah because she was the one who turned my sister on to rap music, and she proudly took cr edit for this achievement. She lives with both of her parents and her sister in a young suburban area, in an upper-middle-class gated community that has its own golf course. She seems to have a close relationship with her mother and sister as she mentioned that they all share music, slightly to her mothers chagrin. Sarah said that she gets a lo t of music from her si ster or downloads it herself and is constantly trying to turn her mom onto new hip hop. Charlotte Charlotte is a 15 year old Black girl who lives with f our guys: two older brothers, a younger brother and her father. It is safe to say she is a daddys girl and loves him very much, even as he struggles to keep a steady job. In talking to her it wa s apparent that this living situation affected her outlook. She is a beautiful girl who wears her own hair straight to her chin, and ha s a quiet and unassuming disposition. She dressed simply and comfortably in jeans and a t-shirt. Charlotte answered questions effortlessly and it seems she is surrounded by music--specifically that of her brothers tastes She expressed how it sometimes irritated her when her brothers play music that she is not fond of. Charlotte grappled with the criticisms of hip hop duri ng our conversation. She seemed to take on a defensive position, acknowledging that some rap is just talking about money and sex and women and labeled some songs that we disc ussed as bad but that not all rap is like this. Ronnie Ronnie is a 14 year old Black boy who ha s an extensive family, many of whom live with or near him in a low-income area. Ronnie arrived well dre ssed with a long shiny silver cross displayed above his striped pol o shirt. His neatly twisted dreds brushed against his shoulders and fell between his s houlders. Ronnie plays football and hopes that he can play for the high school he attends next year. I know him from my elementary school teaching days. His mother and father have raised him and his 5 siblings with traditional Jamaican cultural values and norms. R onnies older sister has two small children, and various significant others of his sisters have had influence on him. In particular, he told me about how his nephews father was killed a few months earlier in a random shooting at a nightclub. He was sad about the situation, and I could see that the man was a role model for Ronnie. Most of all, I could see how it pa ined him to see his si ster upset over the loss of her babys father, as they were scheduled to marry soon. Ronnie is a sweet boy who really loved to talk about something he knows well. More importantly, he loved to be heard. It s eemed like he was not used to such attention, and he relished in our discussion, commen ting that he enjoyed it at the end.
22 Angelo Angelo is an 18 year old young Black man who recently began rapping. A family member owns a local studio where he has begu n to develop himself as a rapper. Before meeting with him he was secretive about where he lives, claiming that he stays in various nearby towns. This led me to believe that his parents were not together and that he lived partially with both of them, and/or other family members close by. He is has portly build, with focused eyes resting on his round face. He wore a large t-shirt that said lea ving Brooklyn forget about it in big block letters, which indicated his affiliation to Brooklyn that he later spoke about. Angelo was prepared for our interview. He thought about things he wanted to say and was reflective about his experience rapping and what he thought about ot her issues in the rap game. He seemed to want the conversation to move quickly and spoke as if he had a lot to say but was rushed to do so. I certainly was not the one to rush him, as I sat relaxed and listened pleasantly. At the end he said that he enjoyed our tal k, in which he did near ly all of the talking. When he rapped some lines, he consistently and frequently touched his nose as if quickly and lightly pinching it with a half-opened hand between his thumb and pointer finger. It was like a nervous tick, but it seemed to be a concentration technique. Ive seen it with battle4 rappers specifically but less persistently, so perhaps it is something he picked up from a mentor or someone. Jay Jay is a 14 year old darker-skinned Black boy with a sweet face. Still growing, he looked younger than his age to me. He is quiet and shy and seemed slightly uncomfortable talking to me, which I attri bute to his age and natural disposition. His interview was different for me since all the interviewees previous to him were forthcoming and engaged in our conversation. Hi s dark eyes seemed to hide what he was thinking-which could have been about footba ll practice that he had afterwards. Jay told me he really would like to play on the hi gh school football team this upcoming year where he would be a freshman. He did not co me across as knowledgable or interpretive of music as the other participants, which c ould have been the source of his discomfort. Although we did not talk extensively about his family, I learned that Jays parents are divorced and he liv es with his mom. He seems to spend time with both parents quite evenly. His father is remarried and has a todd ler with his current wife. His father works full time in the pro shop of his communitys go lf course. I interviewed Jay in the club house of this golf course. Dave Eighteen year old Dave casually entered my presence with a mop of long shaggy hair that fell past the bottom of his ears and slightly over his blue eyes. The 4-inch dark roots told that he was not a natural blond. Otherwise he could pass for a blonde White boy even though he shared that he is Cuba n. His speech was very much the laid-back surfer type and he sat comfor tably spread out on the floor of my apartment. He wore a collared shirt with loose comfortable jeans th at matched his loose comfortable attitude. 4 Battle rap is a component of hip hop culture that features two rappers who freestyle rhymes head to head, often in intimate settings with small responsive crowds.
23 He met me after work, where he does manual labor in a warehouse. He lives with his mom and younger sister. Dave mentioned that his mom had gone through some abusive relationships that made his childhood less-than ideal but things have been calm at the household for at least hi s high school years. Guilli Guilli is a wiry 19 year old light-skinned White and Latino boy with long wavy hair that was pulled back in a puffy frizz ball. He wore a long black tshirt into which 4 of him could have fit and baggy jeans to comp lete the hood look. He sat down at the restaurant booth with his ha nds extended in front of him loosely clasped together, displaying his tattoos. On eight knuckles, he has a small tattoo of a bleeding heart which he explained to me when I asked. He slouched in the booth and spoke softly during our interview which was heavily l aced with the phrase know wh at Im sayin? He lived nearby our meeting place in a small unkempt ap artment building with a roommate in an underprivileged part of town. Guillis mother is Puertorican and his father Italian, but he identifies as Puertorican since he grew up with his mother and his father was not around. He told me that his mother is a pastor and would love fo r him to be an evangelical gospel musician. He grew up with his mom and does not feel she supports him, but would like to prove himself to her and share his future success with her. Pierre Pierre is a 19 year old darker skinned Black male with a young face. He has a thin frame and wore an oversized t-shirt that, like Guilli, could have easily fit more than one of him. He usually works in the shipyard cleaning and fixing different watercraft. The day we met he took off work for the intervie w. I could not tell if it was a justifiable excuse in his mind or if I should be honored that he felt this interview was important enough to clear his schedule. Pierre was soft-spoken, and gave the impression of someone with a lot of thoughts but reluctant to share them. He was informative with his thoughts, but after every respons e, I felt like he had more to say and I wanted to hear more. He shared that growing up he move d around a lot, attending various low-income neighborhood schools-even my place of former employment at one point. He almost didnt finish high school because he got involved with a troublesome crowd. Both Guilli and Angelo are involved in rapping and producing music and were certain to make this clear. Guilli fully embraced the role of a young man who experiences the streets and emphasizes it throughout our interview. As seen in the interview, his point of view affects his understanding of a nd place in the world, which served to inform my data. However, being that he is a performe r by trade, he has much more invested in an authentic presentation of someone from the st reet than someone who is not involved in the music industry (discussed further in Chapter Four). The rapper role is evident throughout both Guilli and Angelos interviews. Angelo focused less on a gangsta5 image, which is not so much his style, and more on the rapper 5 Gangsta is used throughout this thesis as opposed to g angster because it is more accurate in referring to illegal ghetto activit ies involving Blacks. Gangster references
24 role in general. In fact, he introduced himsel f with his rapping name and I had to ask his real name. He clearly presented himself as Angelo the rapper. Unfortunately, Angelo spent a lot of the interview talking about hi s own music including spitting actual lyrics from his songs for me. While it was all inte resting, it distracted from the goals of discussing rap music in a broader sense and I did not use much of our conversation in data analysis. Interestingly, Darrius and Pierre also have experience in the recording studio but did not present this aspect of themselves as strongly. Darrius has also spent time in the studio rapping, but to a less serious extent than Guilli or Angel o. In his interview, Darrius maintained an average interviewee role and did not stress a rappers role like Guilli and Angelo. Pierre has serious goals for his ra pping but like Darrius, he did not emphasize this role in our conversation. These different methods of presentation seemed to be due to personality differences, although I c ould never be entirely sure. organized crime, most notably the Mafia. Th e gangsta discussed here, mainly in Chapter Four, does not necessarily have any relationship to organized crime.
25 Chapter Three Realness: An Authenticity Test Throughout the interviews, ther e was a consistent theme of realness as a desirable quality of both rappers and hip hop music. Inte rviewees discussed what it means to be real as a rapper and what real music is. Although the realness criteria vary among the participants, all of the participants administer an authenticity test of sorts to rappers. In the literature, realness falls unde r the larger notion of authen ticity. The hip hop industry is heavily invested in defining authenticity and similarly, the fans are heavily invested in specifying what is real a nd what is not (Dyson 2007; Fo rman 2002; Huq 2006; Epstein 1994). Authenticity is not inhe rent in the object designate d as authentic. Instead, an audience confers auth enticity on the object it is a socially ag reed-upon construct (Armstrong 2004:338). This paper examines th e ways my interviewees describe and determine the authenticity of rap artists and ra p music. Essentially, my interviews address the question, How do adolescen t hip hop fans assess the authen ticity of rappers and their music? E.G. Armstrong (2004) defined three forms of hip hop authenticity in rap music: being true to oneself, claiming local a llegiances and territorial identities, and establishing a connection to an original source of rap through locale, style, or links to an established artist. My data builds upon Armstrongs typology of hip hop authenticity. His first form, being true to oneself, can be lo cated in the congruen ce between the artists words and deeds. It also demonstrates the values of self-creation and individuality (Armstrong 2004). This is a major theme of my data and is discussed in the first chapter with authenticity and realness. The second fo rm emphasizes the importance of spatiality in terms of where the rapper is from and the place with which he identifies. This criterion is also prevalent in my data and is addressed in the hoodness chapter. The third form is most concretely define d in terms of who the rapper knows, what kind of associations he has with respected individuals in hip hop. This is more apparent in Armstrongs case because he examines the rapper Eminem, a White artist whose associations are closely inspected by observers in order to validate his authenticity. But this third form was not a topic directly di scussed in any of my interviews. Therefore Armstrongs third form of hip hop authenticity is not discussed in this paper because it was not present in the data. It is, however, ar guably an element of hip hop culture that is transmitted through popular culture. This chapter highlights Armstrongs first fo rm of authenticity of being true to oneself, which is most commonly referre d to here as realness. Hip hop ideology demands that its practitioners keep it real, by speaking from thei r lived experience not an ideal from dominant discourses (Ric hardson 2007). Since each interviewee has a different perspective and understanding about the world, their ideas of realness vary based on their cultural context. My interviewees discussed several characteristics of being true to oneself, as discussed in the following s ections of this chapter: The Artist as a Real
26 Person, Relatability, What you see is what you ge t, Fake in Opposition to being Real, and Plies the rapper: Real or fake? The Artist as a Real Person Goffman (1959) writes that in everyday life, it is our habit to assume sincerity in the acts we see performed by others. While everyone is always performing an act tailored to their audien ce, everyone is also socialized to ignore such role playing. In this sense, everyone is socialized to give actors the benefit of the doubt and believe that there is sincer ity in peoples performances of their roles. Interviewees essentia lly described real rappers as artists whose thoughts, behavior, and personality seem unchanged be tween their performance as an artist and their performance as a real life person6. Being true to onese lf is present in how believable the rapper is as a person. Authentic rappers are understood as fully embracing their role as an artist in both their personal and professional lives. The rappers who earn the most respect from my interviewees are ones who play the rapper role well, but are pe rceived as real people at the same time. The person rapping onstage is the same person you w ould run into on the street, or observe chillin at home with his friends or family. As Charlotte says, Do you believe what he is saying in his song?7 Charlotte: Yeah just the way he moves, because the way he-the way he is in other interviews, he really sounds like a real person. Yeah like you know how some people you can tell if theyre fake or not and th eyre just trying to smile and be fake and be pretty? Well he just seems like an honest person. He does have a hard time getting his words out in interviews. Charlotte likes how T.I. talks like an averag e person might in an interview. His lines do not appear rehearsed which gives a genui ne feel to his ove rall character. Sarah expands upon the idea of rappers a ppearing genuine in the public realm by expressing themselves as a real person, not an artist. When referring to Kanye West, Sarah says, Sarah: Well I think cause hes kinda controversial. He has that statement about George Bush, uh he hates black pe ople or whatever, uh and I think it was great like thats just him and hes not trying to hide it. He doesnt try to fit any mold that anyone else has made. The kind of things he touches on are not things that are gonna be uh, politically corre ct or acceptable. Sarah believes that Kanye speaks his mind even if it is not politically correct and that shows his true personality. She is referring to a comment Kanye made during a benefit, A Concert for Hurricane Relief on NBC. Kanye was a featured celebrity speaker who said, among other things, George Bush doesn't care about black people. This comment was publicly received in various ways, and Sara h represents one common response among hip hop listeners. Sarah also di scussed Jay-Z with me, 6 The term artist here refers to the musical persona presented publicly while the term person refers to the artists private self. 7 Materials from my interviews are enclos ed with quotation marks unless they are passages, which are set apart with inde ntion. My words are italicized and the respondents words are in regular font.
27 Sarah: I feel like his music is so re al but everything Ive heard is just really cool. Um I dont think hes-lik e kinda like Kanye-hes not trying to make like the most uh forward songs or the most mainstream songs but he just makes great music and hes taken that pretty far so. Jay-Z makes good music effortlessly, which shows that he is making music that is true to himself. Hes not trying too hard. This is wh at makes his music real. Sarah thinks of JayZ as an artist who makes music th at fits his personal style inst ead of one who tries to fit a particular mold. Sarah: But he um, I just think hes true to what he says and he doesnt make like a public spotlight of himself. Like hes really like concealing of himself or whatever with like Beyonce, but I think that like he lets his music speak for him. By saying that He lets his music speak for him, Sarah indicates that Jay-Z the artist expresses what Shawn Jay-Z Carter th e person would like to communicate publicly He conceals private matters such as his relati onship with Beyonce, but what Sean Jay-Z Carter does share in his music is perceived by Sa rah as what he actually believes. Ciara makes an interesting comment about the emotion that her favorite artist, Lyfe Jennings, conveys through his music. Ciara: He just-he been through a lot in his life and he is just-I love how he just-Hes like a rapper but he sings. Yea. And its like how do you know hes been through a lot in life? cause you can, he, he writes about it through his songs and you can like feel it. and you feel it so you believe its true, hes not making it up or... Yeah cause like, its real, its not like stuff you cant believe. Ciara believes that Lyfe Jennings sings about his life because the scenarios are realistic and he sings with such emotion. She is convi nced that the lyrics are his words. Above, Sarah refers to this as coming from the artists heart. To Ciara, and the others, the artists present themselves as realistic people. Th ey feel, think, and experience things that average people do so that fans do not percei ve artists as personas, but rather as an extension of the actual person behind the artis t. Ciara sees an outs poken quality in one of her favorite rappers, Eve, which is also a quality she desires in her friends. Ciara: She says whatever. I just love her cause she says whatever she thinks about. Like she doesnt care. I like people who outspoken. I like people who say what they want to say and like she gon say what she wanna say, she gon say what she gotta say, and thats why I like Eve. If you say what you wanna say and say wh at you gotta say, you can be my friend. Be real with me, dont-dont be playin. Here the artist Eve is equal to the person Eve Jihan Jeffers. Eve seems like someone Ciara could befriend and someone who is not a fraid to be herself as an artist. These qualities make the artist more real. For Ty, realness is associated with sexua l imagery in hip hop. Ty addressed sex in the context of rap music, whic h is a particularly salient issue in all forms of popular music. He enjoys the sexually explicit quality of rap music and explains that the sexual content is just one way for rappers to de monstrate that they are being real. Ty: How I like how its sexually explicit? Cause some people, that turns people off, why do you like it? Oh. Cause you get to be real you know, like, not everybody needs to know like, Oh they said something nasty, change the channel. Or the reason why theyre doi ng that is the reason why youre here. Mm
28 hm. Cause its not like youre such a saint that you havent done anything. You get to the club and youve done some things that your mom wouldnt expect you to do
29 Relatability Another dimension of realness is how true a songs theme or narrative is to the listener. Participants shared how they relate to the firstperson narratives of songs. One way listeners can relate to songs is to imagine that they wrote the song about themselves. Ronnie agrees with the messa ge in the song Get Like Me by David Banner featuring Chris Brown and Yung Joc, in that he believes people need to be like him and thats what makes the song good in his eyes. Ronnie: Its got its got li ke the truth. People need to stop tryin to get like like, get like me. They need to get like me. They need to? Why? Whats so great about you? cause its like its like what I do, how I play, everything yeah. He feels like he could be able to place hi mself in the rappers position and the lyrics would still be relevant. Charlotte and Mi mi also expressed similar first-person connections to music. Charlotte: What about teenage love affair? She talks about having like a crush. Shes in college but everyone can relate to it like--like having a crush,
30 its relatable to you? Yeah relatable to me. Relatable to my perspective. As a comparison, Sarah says that Chris Brown is mo re relatable to her because of his age. More relatable to me yeah um like just lik e the things hes talk ing about you know hes not gonna be like youre gonna understand it or understand that situation no matter what. Dave discussed the truth as something th at listeners in general can relate to personally. Dave explains that Lil Wayne says th ings that are true, as if he simply points out the obvious. Dave: But if you like if you actually sit down and listen to his lyrics and analyze his music like I do cause I like music a lot, you can, you hear his lyrics and when you hear something that you like youre like holy shit thats so true or thats crazy, you know? Yeah it just, it like if somethings happened to you bad in your life that you wanna reflect on but you dont like thinking about it or listening to it or talking about it. Mmhm. Like if you hear it in a song its like oh yea, true, youve been through the same thing Ive been through, hes been through the sa me thing Ive been through. You know, you say, true, you know. And is that also why it appeals to everybody? Yeah like cause, not only that but cause it c onfronts them with something in their life that happened but just like a lot of stuff he says is genuine like 100% true Like, well, thats what makes you a different type of person as far as music goes like if you like a style of music then youre going to have to relate to the music. Like the lyrics. Like rap has a lot of lyrical background. It has beat but a lot of pe ople that like rap is because of the lyrics. Dave says that a listener will recognize some thing as true if they have had a similar experience and this is what draws listeners to their songs and music of interest. He says Lil Waynes lyrics are genuine like 100% true. In this sense, bei ng true to oneself is also talking about things that are true in listeners lives. He goes on to talk about how listeners relate to Tupac. Dave: Tupac has like more of the, he s another rapper that people can listen to and relate to cause he has a lot of music that talks about him and growing up and all the things around the world that are just so bad to him that are bad to other people that li sten to him too Th eres another song he sings about its called Dear Mama just sings to, hes trying to sing a song to his mom saying how much he appreciates everything and how bad of a kid he was and how she struggle d to, to like, support her two kids on her own and how happy he is. You know Like when I listen to that song I think of my mom. Hes talking about how his mom used to sell crack. My mom didnt used to sell crack but when he says certain things like what hes thanking his mom for and shit I m just like aw, I just think about my mom and Im just like wow this is crazy. The way it makes me feel. While Dave tells me that he cannot relate to everything Tupac addresses, he tells me that he does relate to Tupacs feelings toward hi s mom in the song Dear Mama. With this, Dave does not feel the exact same way as Tupac because his circumstances were different. However, he thinks about the aspect of the song that he can relate to. It almost
31 surprises him how the song makes him emotiona l when he listens and connects it to his own life, his own mother. Later in our conversation Dave says When I first started li stening to [DMXs music] I was like 10 or 11 and cause I--I lived in a bad part of town where a lot of bad shit happened. And I listened to rap all the time so like stuff like this made me feel better about certain situations I was in and stuff. Here he is explaining to me how he got into rap music. DMX helped him cope with his ci rcumstances out of his control. While he no longer lives in the same circumstances, Dave still listens to rap music and finds other things that relate to him in the music. These comments indicate that one dime nsion of realness is relatability. These adolescent fans find ways na rratives or messages of songs relate to their personal circumstances or social lives. Since listeners have experien ced similar feelings, thoughts, or events as discussed in relatable songs, lis teners know that these things exist firsthand. Therefore, rappers that communicate about relatable themes through their music are perceived as real. What You See is What You Get In addition to rappers being true to th emselves, and being relatable, the rappers who are classified as real all have a take it or leave it attitude, as if they are themselves no matter what anyone else thinks They are individual and will not change because of what others, or the record labe l, might think. When Dave talks about Lil Wayne, he says Like all his shit is like le git. Its--most of its original and goes on to explain that by legit he means Its real. 100% what you see is wh at you get you know? In this explanation, Dave is demonstrating that he sees Lil Wayne the rapper as Lil Wayne the person, with no front or performa nce occurring. This falls in line with Goffmans (1959) idea that people tend to assu me that performances are not contrived. To Sarah, a song is real if theyre not tr ying to talk about what you expect. She considers real songs to talk about things th at listeners do not exp ect to hear. Regarding the artists that are not real: Sarah: Theyre just tr ying, theyre just following an equation. Theyre trying to get a certain outcome so they do what someone else does to get that outcome. Um theyre not taking like new paths or avenues to get there. Um, in terms of rap theyre not just like the drugs, sex, alcohol thing. Your audience is not gonna be uh, supporting uh fans. Theyre gonna be just someone who hears it in their car or wherever its played and I just feel like its not real Its not anything th ats coming from this guys heart or this girls heart, uh it s just kinda like what their executive is telling them to write about and its so obvious to me. Real artists do not respond to what the musi c corporation or the audience wants, but instead they do what feels true to themselves Sarah feels like songs are real when they come from the artists heart and are creative. She also expresses a higher respect for an artist who has devoted and supporting fans, a nd these fans cannot be people who just listen to music on the radio. Indeed, audience response to the same music varies across different listening populations. We can dist inguish between greatest hits fans and critical listeners whose involvement in th e music is broader and deeper (Riley 2005).
32 Supporting fans, to her, appreci ate rap music that finds crea tive ways to discuss more than just drugs, sex or alcohol. Artists are real when they make creative music that isnt an obvious attempt to appease the record company or the executives When the artist isnt afraid to try new things it conveys that he is being true to himself and that he will not allow his creative expression to be stifled by what others think. On a larger scale, real artists are able to escape the corporate machine that mainstreams themes for the general public and is often understood as stifling crea tivity (Goodman and Dretzi n 2001). Sarah comments specifically on Ne-yo, He is kinda like established in the fa ct that like he knows who he is, he dresses the way he wants. He wears t hose whack hats to the side and he doesnt care
33 like a real person who feels, thinks, and act s like a friend or someone that a fan could know in their life. This criter ion builds upon Armstrongs first form of authenticity being true to oneself, which incor porates specific factors that hi p hop fans seek among rappers. While it was difficult for the participants to be specific with how they know a rapper is real, it was much easier for them to point out how they know that a rapper is fake. Fake in Opposition to Being Real Realness and fakeness operate together in a dichotomous relationship. Goffman comments on how we all attempt to distinguis h real from false performances. We tend to see real performances as something not purposely put together at all, being an unintentional product of the indi viduals unself-conscious re sponse to the facts in his situation (Goffman 1959:70). This is how a real rapper is describe d, as real person who performs their artist role in line with their unself-conscious, everyday self. And contrived performances we tend to see as so mething painstakingly pasted together, one false item on another, since there is no reality to which the items of behavior could be a direct response (Goffman 1959:70). Rappers with contrived performances were fake according to interviewees. In practical lived experience, we make a great deal out of th e distinction between real and false performances. Fi rst we assume people are ge nuine unless a performance is compromised and becomes seen as unnatural or artificial. Dyson notes that authenticity was debated from the beginning of hip hop cu lture perhaps because their culture was under assault by older members of black cult ure and society at large (Dyson 2007:6). Those who were inside of the hip hop cu lture began to determine authenticity and identify the legitimate outlines of their culture from their perspective as opposed to outsiders imposing it upon them. Thus the othe r dichotomous relations hip that surrounds hip hop, as with most subcultures is the insi der-outsider relationship. Insiders to hip hop culture are able to cite which rappers are r eal or fake because they share subcultural capital. Part of distinguishing realness comes from the deducti on that it is not fake, and vice versa. One method of distinguishing a fake ra pper is to study if their words are inconsistent with their actual experiences or behaviors. Ty shared an interesting scene from the MTV show Punked, on which celebrities are tric ked into thinking horrible things are happening to them while being videotaped for the reaction. Ty: T.I. they called him out on uh, they got him on what is it, Punked with Ashton Kutcher? Ok, yeah Punked. They got him real good with uh, with Punked. They said they found guns on hi s private jet like AKs and stuff. Right. That boy was cryin. Really? That boy was cryin!
34 because he snatched somebodys camera and started runnin away--I mean he was gonna act a fool. Then that might make me buy the buy his album cause like that dude cool! Ty explains here the inconsistency between T.I. s lyrics and rap image. He calls T.I. fake because his everyday behaviors as a person do not correspond to his reputation as an artist. He contrasts the T.I. example with Ka nye Wests reaction. Ty is careful not to say that Kanye is real for snatching a camera a nd running, but he is clear in saying that this makes Kanye cool. Kanye has demonstrated a component of the cool pose by acting deviantly, refusing to be subservient (Maj ors & Billson 1992). Here Kanye is being himself and is consistent with the personali ty seen in the media and his music which checks out with Tys authenticity test. Tys example with Punked follows Goffmans ideas in that the show is testing the rappers, looking for their unself-conscious (Goffman 1959), uns cripted reaction to given situations. Watching the show Punked could be one way that hip hop fans look for slip-ups of performance or a discrepancy of character. Gossip news and interviews are other media fans might consult for slip-ups. For example, Mimi mentioned that she keeps up with these things and that is how she knows about Mary J. Bliges life. Goffman (1959) notes that people are ge nerally aware of such discrepancies but since hip hop fans are heavily invested in authenti city, they will tend to be hype r vigilant of such slip-ups. Here the lesson is that rappers must be c onsistent with their ev eryday lives and their reputation as an artist because a slip-up be tween these two roles would deem them fake. Plies the Rapper: Real or Fake? Plies came up in a few interviews wh en talking about au thenticity. Plies hometown is close to my sample site, wh ere Plies reportedly has a home, so that interviewees were slightly more aware of hi m. Local artists make more appearances and tend to be promoted more heavily by the lo cal radio, but aside from this some of the interviewees claimed they had connections to people who know or knew Plies personally. Darrius considers Plies a fake rapper because of a personal experience hes had with Plies that he did not discuss in detail. He did o ffer explanation about what makes Plies a fake rapper. Darrius: But, like, I just know hes fake. He rap on a song likehe wanna rap about something but dont do it like,
35 Guilli also called Plies fake. Guilli: Hes a faker man. Everybody knows man. A lot of people aint doin what they say they are. So what is he saying hes doin? That he a real nigger, fuckin doin everything that he says he does. He kills people, he doesnt do all that stuff thats hi s brothers life he raps. I know people that know his ass know what Im sayin, personally. Plies says that he kills people but doesnt--he is claiming activities that his brother was involved in, not him. This causes him to l oose credibility, exposing that his words are inconsistent with his actions. To Darrius and Guilli, Plies is an ex ample of a rapper who is misrepresenting himself because his person a as an artist does not correspond with his life experiences and behavior s as a person. An incongruent performance of self is received very poorly among fans and others in the rap industry si nce authenticity is highly valued. Contrary to the rapper image, Ty a nd Ronnie mentioned th at Plies attended a nearby university and earned a degree. For most fans, this might cause Plies to lose credibility. Having a poor education is part of be ing real. This is part of the real nigga image that is highly criticized by scholars in terms of mins trelsy as Ogbar states here; One is not real by doing well in school, be ing rasied middle class, or even speaking proper grammar. The articulati on of a real nigga among ma ny MCs reads nearly exactly as a zip coon character of the early twentieth century (Ogbar 2007:34). Part of Plies image is someone from the streets, as Charlo tte indicated earlier when she called Plies, Rick Ross and Ludacris scary. This is t ypical of a rapper image-someone who grew up in impoverished conditions with very little resources, including little education. This rapper image has been criticized by academics as a replica of minstrelsy of the nineteenth century (Ogbar 2007; Watkins 2005; Cobb 2007) because it negatively portrays Blacks succumbing to dominant racial stereotypes by embracing them. Despite the dissonance of Plies street image and his al leged college degree, neither Ty nor Ronnie seemed to mind that Plies had a degree. Ty actually likes Plie s regardless of his pe rsonal experience. W hat if he did go to [name of the local university] would that change? Ty: Wouldnt matter. Go ge t your education.
36 (Bennett 2000:27). This interpre tive practice is seen here my participants responses. They draw from media sources to develop th eir subcultural capital and then apply this knowledge to understanding realness of rappers In addition, these interviewees indicate that they understand what it means to be real in their own everyday livesto speak your mind, express your emotions and thoughts, a nd to not care what others think. Hip hop offers certain meanings of authenticity, as seen here in what it means to be a real rapper or to keep it real with the fans.
37 Chapter Four Hoodness: The Characteri stic of Being Hood Realness is an ever-present el ement of authenticity that verifies if a person is who they claim to be. As seen thus far, fans wo rk to connect the perfor mer to their performed role to discern realness. Anot her aspect of authenticity is hoodness, the understanding of the ghetto and the experiences that occur within thes e neighborhoods. In gangsta rap and hip hop culture, auth enticity means being the realest, or the one most in touch (through pur portedly direct life experience) with the agonistic, tragic rule s of the subculturethe one most able to face, affirm, and overcome suffering and to report it unflinchin gly to others (Riley 2005:309). Notions of hoodness, toughness developed from a ghetto lived experience, indicate authenticity (Xie et al. 2007). To be authenti c, one can be real but not hood, or one can be both real and hood. Hoodness is a marker of subc ultural capital that enhan ces ones realness. Recall that subcultural capital is similar to Bourdieu s theory of cultural capital but recognizes the influence of media. Subc ultural capital is what rapp ers assert to affirm their membership within hip hop culture. Subcultural capital confers status on its owner in the eyes of the relevant beholder (Thornton 1995:11). Just like one cannot claim coolness without others confirming it to be so, one cannot claim subcultura l capital without the confirmation of others. During my interviews, fans confirmed the s ubcultural capital of rappers. Hardness and authentic ghetto centri city are of central significance. Most rappers would lay claim to describing realit y in some form or another (Huq 2006:114). According to my interviewees, hood rappers pres ent the reality of their life experiences within the setting of ghetto life. The hood is part of Armstrongs (2004) s econd form of authenticity, as described in Chapter One, local allegiances and territ orial identities. This is a prominent theme recognized by hip hop fans. Talk of a difficu lt ghetto life or challenges theyve been through serve to authenticate a rappers realness. It presents subcultural capital that is highly respected within hip hop culture, whethe r the fans have experienced it themselves or not. Armstrong (2004) also notes three othe r dimensions of rap authenticity: racial, gender/sexual, and social location. While race, gender, and sexuality were mentioned in some of my interviews, they were not nearly as prominent a theme as the social location of the ghetto. The notion of the hood, the streets, or th e ghetto, and the stru ggles that artists encounter in this neighborhood environment cam e up in nearly all the interviews. the emphasis on the real can also be linked to a range of emergent spatial concerns, especially those that are se dimented within the geocultu ral construct of the hood (Forman 2002:Xxviii). The extent of a rapper or rap pieces authenticity is partially
38 determined on how well it represents notions of the hood. As demonstrated in these interviews, characteristics of ghetto life carry with them credibility, as long as they are deemed real. The interviewees used several different terms to describe rap music and artists classified with a t ough, underprivileged, urban lifestyl e. Hood, gutter, the streets, struggle, gangsta, real, hard, and ghetto are all terms that were attached to this portrayal of a person who experienced difficult times in the ghetto. These terms were also attached to the music that expresses such experiences. Some participants stated that certain artists have been through a lot and alluded to this sort of ghe tto experience. The hood label is a component of authenti city that corresponds to subcultural understandings of rap music. For a listener to identify what is authentic, hood, or real, is to position themselves as an insider to this cultural component. As seen in the comments below, hoodness is an important component of r ealness to these fans. Darrius is a big fan of Young Jeezy, partially because he is so hood. Ok, what makes him your favorite? Darrius: Jeezy so hood man, he like What do you mean so hood? Like hood, likelikethe way he rap he like he rappin like he gangsta. He lik e--there some people who like go out there to rap and like theythey act like they gangsta. You know people who like, look at him like, why the hell he rappin like th at, he no gangsta. But you can look at Jeezy and I got, I got another documentary I bought, I bought from somebody and he was on ther e and he was saying stuff what he was into. Here Darrius begins to explain how Young Jeezy raps like a gangsta and plays the role well whereas sometimes others do not. Darrius stops himself and mentions that in a documentary about Jeezy other people vouched for him. People from Jeezys hometown talk about him in the documenta ry and confirm that Jeezy is as hood in person as he is in his rap music. Ok, so young Jeezys your favorite, cause hes so hood. Darrius: So hood-H to the double O-D. What makes him so hood? So hood, Jeezys so can you describe the hood, its the swagger8? Its the swagger, its yea-Is it what they rap about ? Its what they rap about and the way they, I guess, and the way they act. We see Jeezy on like shows and stuff, interviews and he be so cool, like, he just
39 higher authority about criminal activity and to do so is to rupture bonds of loyalty. To be hood means to have strong opinions that align wi th stereotypical notions of gangstas. In addition to the baggy pants, shoes, hairstyles tattoos, and jewelry ch aracteristic of hip hop culture, violence is a valued commodity of rap music and has been argued to be a marketing tool (Richardson and Scott 2002; Kubrin 2005). Gangstas are typically callous and connected to criminal ac tivity that creates a strong an ti-snitch sentiment within the gangsta subculture (Xie et al. 2007; Hurt 2006) Jeezys line stands out to Darrius as hood because it is strongly connected to this gangs ta mentality. In this instance, Jeezys tough attitude does not seem forced, does not seem like a basic marketing tool, but rather Darrius perceives it as genui ne. Jeezys hoodness adds to his realness. After crossreferencing with documentaries, Jeez y passes Darrius authenticity test. Many of the participants at tributed their knowledge of rappers real lives to YouTube videos, interviews, and things they learn from listening to their music. Darrius went so far as to get documentaries on hi s favorite rappers and referenced those to support his claims. Darrius: You just look at rap and they be on their songs like I did this, I killed such and such and I sold such and such. I dont know if they did it, but like you see this documentary and you go through and see the actual people still stay like in they neighbor hoods or whatever, but go on and tell you what this happened this and how it is. In looking for the consistency between the ra ppers life as an artist and his life as a person, Darrius is searching for s lip-ups (Goffman 1959) in Jeezys presentation of self. Because Darrius did not find any inconsistencies, Jeezy has done a thorough job of what Goffman (1959) calls impression management. Such successful performances are a constant negotiation between avoiding performance disruptions and possessing attributes that support ones role (Bell 2008). Young Jeezy convinces fans like Darrius that his real life is hood. Talking about it makes his music real, and demonstrates that he is being true to himself. Coolness Another hood characteristic Darrius mentions is the relaxed, chill, cool pose. Jeezys demeanor is described as so cool as he is just chillin in interviews. Coolness is part of subcultural capital. To be accepte d within hip hop culture, an artist must be perceived by audiences as cool. This is also a gangsta quality and is described by social scientists as a coping mechanism in response to dire conditions (Majors & Billson 1992). It is also regarded by th ese ethnographers as a peculiarly black expression of masculinity. Indeed, the entire discussion of cool centers entirely on black men (Kelley 1997:24). The hip hop industry is comprised of predominantly Black men so coolness is a factor of hip hop culture. Cool manifests in various fo rms. It is an aesthetic, a style, and an art form expressed through language a nd the body (Kelley 1997).Coolness is an adaptive strategy that will be found most frequently among t hose who experience racism and poverty as found in ghettos. Being cool is a survival technique wh ere one acts competent and successful to be more interesting and attract ive to others (Kelle y 1997). Those who are perceived to be cool can manipulate others with this charm of coolness. An air of admiration surrounds those who are labeled c ool. Ciara also says Out of anybody I
40 could meet, I would love to meet [Lyfe Jenni ngs]. I would love to meet him cuz hes, hes hot too. Naw, hes c ool, I would love to meet him. For someone who has been through a lotof presumably difficult stuff as discussed belowit is no wonder that rappers who are so hood have adapted with poise under pressure and the ability to maintain detachment, even during tense encounters (Majors & Billson 1992:2). Naturally, hood rappers will also be cool in their mannerisms and behaviors. Swag is something fans recognize that f actors into a rappers coolness. Short for swagger, often pronounced swagga, this is a te rm used to describe demeanor or how one carries oneself. Similar to how hoodness can enhance a rappers realness, swagger can enhance a rappers coolness. A rappers sw ag encompasses ones personal style of rapping, dressing, and even moving. Therefore it can be apparent in ones presence, but it was most often discussed in my interviews as something understood from a rappers style of rapping. Angelo gave me examples of ly rics without swag, and then with swag, demonstrating that the delivery and flow of words reveal ones swag. Swag is like a rappers signature because as Angelo remark ed, When people hear the song they already know its you from the way words are delivere d. Angelo also made the point that swag can make a song or a rapper a success. A ngelo: Sometimes, sometimes I dont like Lil Wayne but I respect him that he--that he--that he got swag like in hi s song. Even though Angelo may not like Lil Wayne as an artist, he admits that he has swag and this makes him a respectable artist. Guilli spoke in more detail about swag. People tell me I have a very distinct vo ice. But it doesnt give it swag. What would give me swag? Guilli: I would say speaking naturally. The way you carry yourself, your body language your choice of words, the way you sayin it. Ok. Its all faded know what Im sayin? Its just how you come off. You come off a little
41 does he have? A hood meaning, like a hood meaning. Lupe dont rap like he in the hood. He just rap like he tryin to, like he came from like, he wasnt a problem. He had a good life a nd he just decided to become a rapper, like thats how I see it with him. Rick Ross he started from the bottom and he made it up to the tippy. Here Darrius indicates that a song with a hood meaning entails a rapper who has had a problematic life. He contrasts Rick Ross to Lupe because Lupe is not a gangsta rapper. Rap is from the streets, the music of the underclass essentially opposed to those enjoying a bourgeois suburban life (Arm strong 2004:338). It seem s to Darrius that Lupes rap reflects a bourg eois suburban life. some people actually make it seem like poetry like Lupe Fiasco. His raps are like poetry Hip hop saved my life know what Im saying, like he he actually like he rap about, I guess stuff with meaning Like I tell you Lupe, he rap about more realistic stuff like stuff thats just more, I dont know how to put it but he just Lupe just Even though Lupes music is not hood, he can still be real because Lupes poetic rap can be whats true to him and real for experi ences that arent hood. According to Darrius, hood rappers would be those who came from a place of few resources, the bottom and worked their way to success or the tippy top. These rappers then take the ghetto life theyve experienced and communicat e it through their music. Guilli has a slightly different perspec tive than Darrius because he writes and produces various types of rap songs, includ ing hard, gangsta ones according to him. Guilli: Its just very, its whatever--a gangsta song, um rep-your-city type song. Whatever you feel at the moment. So like a gangsta song, what are those like? Real hard shit,
42 I did not ask him to elaborate on street struggles, perhaps b ecause I assumed myself that these were things depicted in hip hop--drug issues, death, violence, crime, etc. Indeed these were all things that Guilli addressed at some point in the conversation. Guilli: Please show me respect and I will show you the utmost resp ect. But if you gotta take it to a hood level, I live it. I live the streets. I live the whole bangin sh it. I live that life so life aint a party whatsoever. What Im telli ng you a lot of people want. Guilli tells me that he experiences the hood, th e streets, the rough life that a lot of rappers wished they could detail firsthand. The hood life is not resp ectful and involves illegal and unpleasant activities. As mentioned earlier, Guilli clearly presents himself as someone from the streets, probably because he is a rap ar tist and has more invested in a hard image than the others. He describes that he lives ghetto life a nd then discusses another component of hood authenticity; illegal drug activity. In the impoverished inner-city neighborhood, the drug trade is everywhere, and it becomes ever more difficult to separate the drug culture from the experience of poverty (Ande rson 1999:29). Since drug deali ng is connected to ghetto life, it is another aspect of experiencing the hood and adds to ones realness. Guilli spoke to me about the relationship between the i llegal drug business and the rap industry. He does not agree with rappers bl atantly discussing their drug bu siness and explains why he thinks it occurs. Guilli: You got Weezy saying $750 buc ks for a pound. Why are you going to do that? For what? What do you think they thin k it adds to them, I mean like Jeezys calls himself the snowman. Yeah they think that it adds that gangster appeal to it, its something very commercial cause everybody wants to look cool. Everybody wants to be a gangster but dont nobody want to be a gangster. So having the gangster image is cool. Thats--thats what you see so much. You know people nowadays they think that theyre gangster. 95% of them dont even know half the fucking--everybody wants to be Scarface thats what it really boils down to. Everybody wants to be that man, know what Im sayi n, that super guy that controls the fuckin platoon of blood thirsty killers. Does it have to do with drugs or is it everyone? It could be anyone its all about power, everybody wants to be God a ll of em, a lot of em are dead. A lot of them want to be held higher th an they are. The higher they are held the more persuasive a man is. A lot of people wanna be gangster, not everyone wanna be gangster. Itll ma ke you throw up. Being gangster will make you shit on yourself.
43 achieved through the drug or rap business than through education and legitimately successful endeavors. Bourdieus use of the terms acquire a nd accumulate when describing capital (2001) are purposeful because they indicat e accretion over time. Guilli is describing how street knowledge through accumulated experiences with drug and gangsta activities is relevant. In following Thorntons subcultural capital theory, street knowledge that Guilli describes is valued in hip hop culture. This ki nd and form of capital is not always useful or valued in the wider society, but it is capital nonetheless. It is recognized and valued on the streets, and to lack it is to be vulnerable there (Anderson 1999:105). Guilli finds it absurd that people would want to live a gangsta lifestyle because he experiences it himself and according to him, it is a hard and painful life. Guilli speaks about ghetto life just like hood rappers do in their songs. He offers a vocabulary of motives, or logic to his words above: talki ng about the absurdity of glorifying the hood that he experiences personally serves to elevate his own hoodness and realness while dismissing so many others as mere performers and wannabes. He points out that a lot of people want to be recognized as gangsta to earn respect, but nobody ac tually wants to live a gangsta lifestyle because it is not as glorio us as it is portrayed. To him, living in the hood, experiencing the streets, or being gangsta all develop as a neces sity, as a method of coping with difficult circumstances A lot of people in the gh etto are trying to get the hell up out of there. They dont want to romanticize it (Dyson 2007:11). Dyson (2007) argues that rappers can expre ssively orient themselves ar ound the ghetto and logically legitimate the ghetto in rap discourse because it serves as a common reference point of understanding. Xie et al. (2007) proposes that cultural tourists or outsiders are drawn to ghetto life and are most likely to romanticize it To attract these audiences, a caricature of the street life is perpetuated. Life in the hood is serious, and it is ironic to Guilli that people want to claim a life of the streets simply for the respect that it yields. However, it makes perfect sense to assert st reet knowledge for the subcultu ral capital it represents and the respect that it earns, bot h important factors of hoodness. This suggests that hood may be make-believea complete performancein most rap music, a point I will return to under Significations and the hyperreal below. Of all my interviewees, it was most transparent that Guilli lives in an unfavorable part of town. What he told me about his pa st, his dress, speech, seeing the actual place where he lives, and the self he presented to me, all revealed to me how he connects his lived reality to the hoodness char acteristics of hip hop. For Guilli to be telling me that he experiences hood life, he is a sserting his own auth enticity. By calling out other rappers for trying to have a gangsta appeal, Guilli is reaffirming his own authority in presenting a gangsta self to me. It demonstrates the perv asiveness of the hood ch aracteristics in hip hop culture: one could disagree that the gangsta image should be coveted, yet continue to perpetuate such an image because it is so respected. Of course, Guillis firm stance on being true to oneself suggests that no matter how desired or undesired a gangsta image is, he would continue to present this self since it comes from his actual experience. Pierre expands upon ideas of the struggle and difficult experiences. He recognizes that rappers talk about their experiences but that they shoul d not be glorified. He uses Jay-Zs music as an example of a rapper w ho talks about his difficult experiences but does not necessarily praise them.
44 Pierre: Like whats goin g on in the context theyre living in and the world around them. A lot of times, violence is whats going on around them. But [Jay-Z]s sayin that in order to entice people to do violence, like you talk about violence in a form--you should ta lk about it cause you would have to do it. I know its a bad idea and stuff. Pierre is emphasizing that Jay-Zs lyrics of violence are a reflection of his experiences and are framed in a manner of necessity, not recreation. Critically su ccessful rappers like Jay-Z have to establish that their authentic connection to street life. They will often justify the violent themes, drug references, and profane languag e in their music as honest reflections of the real-life environments from whence they came (Rodman 2006:105). As Pierre described above, Jay-Z is doing th is very thing, justifying violent themes as a reflection of his experience. Guilli does this same sort of thing when claiming that his music represents his personal struggles and th en talks about how his life is very street which alludes to drugs and violence. As Thor nton (1995) notes, Guilli is learning the best way to apply subcultural capital from the me dia in order to be successful in the rap business. As an aspiring rapper, Guilli learns to replicate this process of justifying rap themes as lived experience from re spected rappers such as Jay-Z. Guilli also shares insight into how he thinks rap music is perceived by larger society. He talks about how Lupe Fiasco, an ar tist he respects for his creativity, writes innovative lyrics. When discussing metaphor s in a song by Lupe, Guilli says that He personifies the streets know wh at Im sayin? And Im like dang! Cause thats what yo ure supposed to do, you re supposed to bring, youre supposed to bring up cause of all the people I could listen to, majority is trash man. So when you bring good music like that around, if more music like that was around, I betc ha the rap game would be a lot more respected and not be seen as ever y man, time for me to get out of the hood or something like that. Guilli likes Lupes use of language and the literary elements su ch as personification that he incorporates into his craft. Guilli mentions Lupe as an example of an artist who brings literary art to his music. He thinks that peopl e do not perceive rap music as art but rather a means for men to escape the hood. Somehow he feels this sentiment is transmitted through rap music and images. He is telli ng us that the hood is understood as an undesirable place to be by those who do not live there. In discussing this, Guilli is regretful that people only see rap music as so mething rappers create to get them out of poor circumstances in the hood. Instead he w ould like to see higher quality rap music, according to his standards. At the same time he admits that a lot of rap music is trash, almost agreeing with the idea th at a lot of it is created to get rappers out of the hood. Charlotte interprets the streets as a hostile place to be as well. She says one of her favorite rappers, Akon, communicates the negati ve aspects of the street life. Charlotte: He talks bout the streets and how its not somewhere to be cuz youre not going anywhere. Its just difficult and youre going to get arrested or shot or something like that. Her description here with or some thing like that indi cates she does not experience the streets as Akon de scribes it. She is showing he r distance from this sort of life. It seems that this perception of the ghetto is understood by liste ners as a miserable place to live, where residents struggle to survive.
45 Ciara used the term gutter to depict a gangsta characteristic that specifically applies to girls. She explained it from a slight ly different angle. Rather than referring to street struggles or criminal activity, she men tions more subtle behaviors that seem to outline a general attitude. But I like, I like women rappers. I love Eve. Oh yea? Shes like a dude. Like, like shes so gutter! She do nt care. She got a song its called Lets Talk About and shes like I wanna talk about fake,
46 my, I dont even like peanut butter sandwiches. You would have to if you were him! Oh man! You can tell by--hes be en to jail too. He--like he says in his songs he was in jail. Um, I thin k he went to jail for like 12 years, no 10 years! 10 years for like hustling and stuff Going through a lot in life means you have endured difficult situations. Ciara describes going through a lot as growing up as a kid in a ghetto neighbor hood without much in terms of things, food, and even hope. The rapper says he looked up to hustlers, demonstrating a lack of legitim ate role models in his life and the admiration a kid in his position held for those involved in illegal act ivity. Hes been to jail for hustling which adds to his street credibility and proves th at he went through diffi cult situations both inside and outside of jail. Th e fact that he was in pris on for so long exaggerates the coveted gangsta image since he must have been involved in some serious crime to receive such a long sentence. Mimi used been through a lot in refe rence to circumstances that arose during adulthood. She is a big fan of T.I., even j okingly claiming that hes her husband. She talks through T.I.s recent comeback followi ng his arrest for federal weapons charges. Mimi expresses that she will always be a fa n and support T.I. and takes an understanding perspective. Mimi: I think I like T.I because he b een through a lot in his life and he always come back on top. So you think now hes gonna come back on top? He already back on top. A h, like, he did all these remixes. Like he did a Umma do me remix. He did like-he talks about like what happened and like stuff like that. Other people got mad at him when he got like, other people got mad at him and st opped bein his fan cause he got arrested and not me. W hy do you think that people get mad at him for getting arrested? Well thats how people is. Some people get jealous. No, I dont wanna say jealous, they get-I dont know the word like, so they gon think thats not what hes sup posed to do, hes supposed to know better, but they dont understand how many people out to kill him! Yeah. So like he think safe and stuff. I dont care, Id do the same thing too! Mimi is referring to T.I. going through a lo t of troubles with the law in his current situation. She supports him because she be lieves he possesses weapons for his own protection against people who want to kill him. The implication is that if T.I. has people who want him dead, he must have done so mething to upset them, assumingly something illegal. Such actions would also fall unde r the going through a lot category. She also indicates admiration for T.I. because no matter the obstacles he has faced, he has always persevered triumphantly. Mimi talked with slightly more detail a bout what Mary J. Blige has been through. Mimi: My favorite artist would be Mar y J Blige. Shes been through a lot in her life andshe like, Mary J. Blige shell tell you her life story. But youll see her all over the news about whats going on in celebrity life. But Mary J. Blige is like, when whats his name used to beat her she told everybody. And shell make you cry and shell show you bout the pain you go through but I
47 One example of Mary going through a lot was the abusive relationship that became known to the public. Mimi loves how Mary ex presses the emotion and pain of such hardships through her music which also reveal th at shes been through a lot. Both T.I. and Mary J. Blige have different experiences but both have endured difficulties which have earned them another level of respect that adds to their authenticity as a real person. T.I. faces legal challenges as a consequence of hi s gangsta activities while Mary J. Blige has survived domestic abuse and by sharing these stories in their music they earn authenticity. Throughout the interviews the participants expre ss an underlying sense of admiration for various hip hop artists. There is a theme of perseverance among a lot of the artists. Darrius voiced a phrase that we h ear a lot of rappers saying in their songs when he said, Rick Ross he started from the bottom and he made it up to the tippy. The whole idea of escaping the hood is perceived as a difficult feat and for some rappers to have been through a lot but turn out successf ul is respectable. Mimi discussed Mary J. Blige and T.I. as her favorite artists who have also been through a lot. Surviving and sharing their hardships earns artists respect for being real, but is also admirable. When Pierre and Charlotte talk about their respect for not only the rappers success but also how they address issues of their past circumst ances in their music. Pierre likes how Jay-Z approach es violence from a contextual angle. He feels like Jay-Z talks about how violence was embedded in hi s upbringing and does not exactly praise it. Charlotte similarly likes how Akon talks bout the streets and how its not somewhere to be cuz youre not going anywhere . Pierre and Charlotte both highlight how these rappers frame the struggle in a way that does not glor ify street life or vi olence. Hip hop fans are already keenly aware of a rappe rs authenticity, as discussed in this paper. It earns a rapper respect when they have a rags-to-rich es story that demonstrates the American dream of bettering oneself. This makes the hood experience even more respectable, since becoming a successful rapper shows determination in the face of adversity. Fans seem to find such perseverance admirable. Hip-Hop in corporates much of American culture, and also the outlaw hero of Americas myt hology which mirrors the violence that has plagued American society since its begi nnings (Rose, 1994). Ultimately, [hip hop] symbolizes the struggle for survival which has always been at the basis of African American culture (Xie et al. 2007:457). Surely, hip hop and its embodiment of American values will continue to be admired by fans. Significations and the Hyperreal The interviewees are outlin ing a certain perception of ghetto reality from what they have heard and seen in the media. They are drawing from what the media has taught them about the hood to verify that rap stories are true. The media are not simply another symbolic good or marker of distinction, but a network crucial to the definition and distribution of cultural know ledge (Thornton 1995:13-14). Thus fans learn the definition of hood from hip hop and other sources, and then they look for markers of hoodness in particular hip hop artists and pi eces. My participants characte rized certain aspects of hip hop as hood based on the cultural representations that have been labeled as such. These media representations can be framed with in Barthes mythologies and signification ideologies.
48 What my participants have come to understand as ghetto life or the streets originates in media representations of what it means to be hood, not necessarily from their own life experience. The hood can be s een as a sign in the word itself or as an idealized place that exists in a signified stat e. The hood refers to the spatial image of the ghetto but is more flex ible in delineating local ity without the negativ e connotation of the word ghetto (Forman 2002). The term hood even signifies a special meaning separate from ghetto, referring inwardly to local sites and the specificities of place while simultaneously constituting a concept that isolat es a real or imagined here from other places, from there. (Forman 2002:65). The term hood thus provokes an us and them relationship and its use establis hes the in status of its user. Following the significations and mythologies logic of Roland Bart hes, the signs or signifiers construct a signifie d story of hip hop as a hood reality. Images, gestures, and stories that circulate in hip hop culture signify the concept of the hood. All the things my interviewees described as characteristics of hood--an independent and hard attitude, violence, drugs, cool demeanor, and going th rough a lot, are all si gnifiers that convey the signified story of the hood. Th e participants described the story of the signified hood: it is an unpleasant place to live, rife with struggles involving drugs and violence; to live in the hood one has to be hard and tough, gangs ta. Reality, conceived of as the physical and material plane where actual social practices occur, exists at a crucial remove from the textual representations that circulate in its name (For man 2002:14). Representational forms are based on a foundation that can be identified as realit y, but always can be only partially real (Forman 2002). What was once reality has been removed from its context and circulated throughout the media to repres ent a signified place, the hood. This story of the signified hood connects to a larger myth that hoodness is intrinsi cally related hip hop authenticity. Hip hop signs such as fashionable Nike s hoes or Jordans, baggy pants, oversized plain white or black t-shirts or words such as hood, gutte r, struggles, serve as signs within the greater hood mythology. Such sy mbols are commodities of hip hop that connect the user to the hood myth and place th em as an insider of the signified hip hop culture. Commodity signs provide people with real social indicators of identityafter all, consumers do use signs to construct iden tities and to make invidious distinctions between themselves and others (Goldman and Papson 2000:92). Participants applied signs of hip hop culture in our conversations pa rtly to indicate their identity as a hip hop insider. The conversations reveal that th ey understand a hood reality from what theyve learned from media representations. These representations, having been removed from context and redefined for audien ces, no longer stand for reality but rather a reified myth. The hip hop mythology exists outside of reality. Hip hop musics cultural text tells a story that has been so oversignified that it now exists in a state of hyperreality. Congruent with Baudrillards theo ries, this level of existenc e is a detached state where signs and signifiers represen t actual reality, but have been distorted by continuous replication to become a signification of a si gnification. The hyperreal is an artificial simulation with endless reproductions of f undamentally empty appearance (Baudrillard 1994). Thus hoodness and realness do not always draw from the audiences experience but rather from what the media have presented to audiences. This seems to be accepted among my interviewees who adm it their lack of personal expe rience with ghe tto life, but are proud to speak with authority on somethi ng they have essentially studied through hip
49 hop. By speaking to the authenticity of a ra pper or his music, my participants are positioning themselves as insiders of hip hop culture because of their understanding of the greater mythology of the signified hood and hip hop culture, regardless of their personal experience. The Truth as Understood but no t Experienced by the Listener My participants talked about rap music and rappers speaking the truth. When fans believe rappers are speaki ng the truth it adds to the arti sts credibility. There were a few different meanings to this label of trut h. Truth could be expre ssed through an actual experience or event that can be verified by the audience such as growing up in the hood or being in a car accident. A rapper could be speaking the truth because he is true to himself. Commonly interviewees labeled ra p music or the rappers themselves true because they felt they could relate, as discus sed above. It could also be that the listener agrees with what the rapper says insomuch as it is true to the listeners experience or understanding of the world. Some interviewees labeled music true if the rapper addressed larger social issues that might not have directly affected them, but do exist in the world. Sometimes music was labeled true when listeners understanding of other peoples experiences is described in the music. Participants interestingly expressed that rappers could be spea king the truth of a hood life that exists in hyperreality. On the topic of relatability, they both acknowledge how other people can relate to songs they do not relate to themselves. My participants learned what other people could relate to through hyperreal media portrayals of ghetto life. This is an example of how the hyperre al representation of hood life is understood and interpreted by listeners, a nd then applied to their unders tanding of the world. Even if he hasnt experienced things a song addresses himself, Dave, for example, perceives these things as real and things that actually happen. He is assuming from his understanding of the world that people experience this signi fied ghetto life discussed in songs that really only exists as a myth. Da ve: That song everything he talks about, it not necessarily all happened to me but theres certain parts of the song where he says like, wow hes speaking the truth you know. Not onl y is relatability understood as something a listener can personally relate to, but also something that other people can relate to. The reified concept of th e hood is present in my c onversation with Sarah. Her descriptions of Lil Wayne and Jay-Z demonstr ate the complexities of how listeners might apply the signified hood to their understanding of reality. Sarah says that Lil Wayne has been through a lot. What kind of stuff do you think hes been through? Sarah: Um I think hes hes been through poverty, been th rough, definitely been through drug abuse. Uh family issues for sure, um probably been through great highs, great lows. I think the best musician s are the ones whove gone through the most. The verification on Lil Waynes background rests on the general consensus Sarah perceives. And how, what makes you think that hes been through po verty, drugs, and family? Is there like a source that youve learned it from? Sarah: Um I think the fact that he can just relate to so many groups of people just like demonstrates it. Like people arent giving--like give him respect because
50 hes raised in a high class family and hes rappin about the streets--quote on quote the streets. Um but its just I think its obvious like his demeanor, the way he walks, the way he talks, like he definitely wasnt raised in Beverly hills. Its blatantly obvious. So yeah just his overall look I guess. She puts the streets in quotation marks. Perhap s this is because she herself knows that the streets exist as a media fabrication of realit y. Sarah knows that she ha s not lived in a lowincome area and could only trust her unde rstanding based on what the media, and specifically hip hop, have presented to her. She attributes Lil Waynes demeanor and look to his upbringing. In additi on to that, Sarah says that other people respect him so this validates his street credit. Sarah also respec ts Lil Wayne and demonstrates this by saying he is a rapper that she would listen to for hi s opinion whereas other wi th other artists she would not be so inclined to do so. She me ntioned that Lil Wayne has one song, Just Dont Understand that ends with minutes of him talking about his opinion on things. Sarah: Just the fact that he--you kn ow he has knowledge about the stuff hes talking about and hes been thr ough stuff. And when you listen to his music I think its pretty cool that he could like have some of that all of it in a song. I mean when you know that so meone has an opinion its cool to listen to it rather than someone whos just talking bout whatever he talks about so. His street credit earns him more respect from others as well as Sarah, and makes him more of a reliable source. Lil Wayne is not just talking about whatever because his opinion is based on experience a nd wisdom of the streets. Sarah talks about music that she can relate to personally, and is actually the first interviewee to use the term rela tability with me, but agrees that music can still be very real even if she does not relate. Sarah: Jay-Z just like, he is like hip hop. Like him, Di ddy, all those guys who just took rapping and turned it into an empire. Like and still his music is what hits home for me most, no t even like relatable to him because clearly not gonna relate much to Jay-Z on a direct level. Thats just cause youre not a guy? Yea, Im not a guy, I haven t been through anything prolly that hes been through. Yeah I mean Im not a black male thirty-five or that is getting there. But like he, I feel like his music is so real. Jay-Z might not be representing Sarahs realit y, but he is expressing his, and because she believes in his performance, that makes it re al and true. According to Sarah, real music talks about something different from the sta ndard themes of rap music, comes from the artists heart, or it is something relatable to the listener. Sarah categorizes Jay-Zs music as so real because she perceives it to be an expression of his thoughts and experiences as a person. Jay-Zs status as a hip hop mogul and business icon reinforce her opinion that his music is real. This is where authentici ty prevails; when an artist is not relatable, they could be respected and well-liked for their overall authenticity. Although it might not have happened to him, Darrius talks about the rapper Lil Boosies experience with the hood. Darrius: Like a lot of rappe rs rap about stuff that happened or stuff that might happen or did happen. K now what Im saying so like to them? To them or the world, or like everybody, most of the people its just C an you give me an example? Like uh, like uh, Lil Boos ie, Lil Boosie? He got
51 a song called my struggle. He talks a bout the struggle he had when he was young and stuff and everything, know I feel like I know people, I know people who deal with that type of stuff --or whatever -that he was talking bout. Do you think the stuff hes saying is real? Like thats actually what happened to him? Yeah cause like I got a documentary on him at my house and like pretty much like it go es through his whole hood and stuff he still know everybody and everything In this sense Lil Boosie talk s about true situations that ar e within Darrius understanding of struggles, but not necessarily from his pers onal experience. He can relate because he knows other people who experience similar stru ggles. This struggle, just as Guilli discussed, refers to difficult situations en countered while growing up in poor conditions of the hood. Therefore Darrius believes Lil Boosies struggles based on what he has learned from friends, people he knows, and fr om rap music. Darrius also believes Lil Boosies claims because, in looking for slip-ups he has verified Boosies claims with the documentary. Charlotte made an interesting statement about what audiences can relate to when talking about Plies. Um, Plies is
52 and get plastic surgery, commenting that the ly rics to this song and the accounts in the movies are SO TRUE not because he has expe rienced these things himself, but because he has learned from the media that these practices are real among celebrity culture. Mimi was also enthusiastic in discu ssing how the truth is communicated in rap music. She says that Lil Wayne is stupid but deep and that he raps the truth. Mimi pulls from other favorite artists of hers to describe what deep means in slightly more detail. Whats so great about Lil Wayne, he was the first one you said? Mimi: Cause the stupid stuff hes sayin an d hes so good, like when he raps, its like he rappin the truth! Its like, and Lil Wayne is ra ppin hes rappin the truth! And his stuff is so stupid it s like, it be, you can relate to what hes sayin, and he be rappin is so deep. Gotta listen to him! So its stupid but deep? Yeah stupid but deep, thats wh at Im sayin, stupid but deep Mimi says that Lil Waynes rap is stupid but deep. Later in the conversation she explains that by stupid she means that there is a sill y quality to his mode of expression and points out that he makes up words as an example. Lil Waynes material is the truth and also something relatable. She adds that Lil Boos ie raps true life and also makes her think. Mimi: Like Boosie rap true life and it be real so its not stupid. Its like daaang, I aint never think of that but Lil Boosie say stuff like that. I aint think of that! But it makes you think lik e when he raps. Thats why I like Boosie When Mimi listens to Lil Boosie, he encourag es her to think about real life situations. She provides more detail about how Cassidy also encourages her to think critically about true life experiences. Mimi: Cassidy is just another Lil Wa yne, but his stuff dont be stupid. I dunno about Cassidy. Its like his stuff deep. Most of all the rappers on his crew, they deep, real deep and Cassidy real deep like What does he talk about? Talkin bout women getting pregnant out of wedlock and hes talking about true life! And thats like, like, dang, make me wanna cry when Cassidy rappin. You be like dang. I used to think that he was stupid but when you think about it, he rappin, make you wanna boo-hoo cry
53 rap song what would it be about? Mimi: About me! Ok. Talk about me or I--I dont talk about, itd be about [city]. You know I love my city so. Talk about livin in [city] and true life. Mimi definitely understands that ra p music has a serious, social dimension that discusses true life experiences and situations. Sarah elaborates on the term deep when discussing Lil Wayne and shares the meaning of what is deep with Mimi. Sarah: Well like I know they have songs and he also talk s about like an issue. Whether hes talking about like a girlfriend or hes talking about politics its like when you hear him like hell say something and itll be like a metaphor. Like you dont expect like something like maybe its something else. Or hell bring in some thing thats a political issue or um, a social issue just things you dont expect. Like Mimi, Sarah finds that rap music some times makes her think about political or social issues. Sarah also feel s like rappers who talk about pe rsonal experiences will relate to a wide audience. She calls this being honest with their music. Mimi: Like I was talking to someone who like after Nellys sister died and I was like Oh hes gonna have a great album. Like I fe lt bad but I was like his next album is gonna be really good because if it talks about what theyve been through, like so many people have gone through--like so many people can relate to going through a tragedy. Mm hm. And you know that theyre gonna like if theyre really being honest with their music thats gonna come up. So I think that Lil Waynes prolly been through a great deal. She attributes Lil Waynes success to the rela tablity and honesty of his material. If fans feel like they can relate to what a rapper talk s about, they are more likely to think he is talking about his own life. This earns him ch aracteristics of being real and speaking the truth. Occasionally my interviewees spoke about what they think other listeners would like and why. Just as they assume they know what the hood is like, they assume to know what would appeal to others. As seen above Sarah seems to estimate that listeners like Lil Wayne because they relate to him. Ty gue ssed that other listener s relate to certain songs because they share similar experience wi th what the song depicts. When looking at the Billboard charts Keyshia Coles Heav en Sent Ty made the following remark. Ty: I guess a lot of people will pick Keyshia Cole for number one cause shes like, she brings both of em t ogether. Like urban and the prayers. Like sent from heaven I guess oh you re like the best thing that ever happened to me. Mm hm. So I guess the young girls consider like that I guess. Say to their little high schoo l boyfriends
54 to be and I-Im like a, a, we dont n eed to be talking bout that right now. If you do care about a if you do care about a female a lot, you feel like it is meant to be and God, and God made that up so. I like that song a lot. It seems from these comments that listeners use music to either le arn or affirm beliefs about how other people think, experience, or believe based on what they have learned from the media. The interv iewees understand hoodness as a signification of ghetto life based on what they learn from the media. B ecause the hood is really an abstract creation of the media, no one really lives a ghetto experience as it is described through hip hop media because it is all a media caricature of actual ghetto life. However, these media conceptions are valued by my interviewees as reality, suggesti ng the power of media messages. In addition, if you are hood, you are automatically deemed real. Ones hoodnesswhich is essentially a performance mimicking a signi fied realitycan surpass the authenticity test and earn a rapper the realness label.
55 Chapter Five Conclusion The research presented in this thesis suggests that adolescent hip hop fans are making interpretations from the media and applying them to their understanding of themselves and the world. This study shows that these adolescent hip hop fans most saliently describe their inte ractions and understandings of hip hop music in terms of authenticity. In determining the authenticity of rappers, participants demonstrated their belief in the signified concept of the hood as an accurate portr ayal of ghetto reality. These interviews also indicate that fans are attract ed by stories of persev erance. They respect artists who have worked hard for their succes s, which encourages the optimism of the American dream. Hip hop music is a form of media that is carefully followed and criticized by insiders and outsiders to the culture. My in terviews revealed teens to be critical of rappers presentation of self. These participants use their subcultural capital to administer an authenticity test where artists only pass if they are true to themselves, as Armstrong (2004) states in his typology. This st udy builds upon this form of Armstrongs authenticity typology because thes e interviews revealed the di mensions of this realness. These are: 1) The artist as a real person: The artist speaks their mind and expresses their thoughts and feelings through their autobiographi cal music or in interviews, and acts like a real person listeners might know personally. Their music is real b ecause it incorporates the artists individual creativity; it comes from their heart or personal thoughts and/or conveys realistic emotions. They include things from their real life experience, from sex to their personal struggles. 2) Re latability: An artists music is true to the listeners life or communicates experiences, feelings, or thoughts that listeners can rela te to. 3) What you see is what you get: Rappers are always bei ng themselves, paying little mind to what others might think. They do not try to fit a co rporate mold or fulfill others expectations. 4) Fake in opposition to real: Rappers must be consistent with their everyday lives and their reputation as an artist to avoid being labeled fake. Hoodness is a characteristic of realness that can enha nce a rappers authenticity. Hoodness falls under Armstrongs (2004) second form of authenticity in his typology, described as local allegian ces and territorial identities. This study builds upon this by specifying how fans identify these allegiance s. Some qualifications for a rapper to be hood include that he has been through a lot or experienced ghetto lif e, portrays toughness or a gangsta quality, and has a cool demea nor. Hoodness is a quality learned through the signified hyperreal hood that hip hop media has created. Par ticipants referred to these representations of the hood as actual reality. Wh en discussing the truth with me, listeners described how they use hip hop texts to learn or affirm beliefs about how other people think, experience, or believe. They describe d the truth of other pe oples experiences as they understood them from the media. This demonstrates the strength of music and
56 images transmitted through the media to adol escents who saturate themselves with a genre of music. As Thornton (1995) notes, subcultural cap ital is heavily intertwined with messages transmitted through mass media. The pa rticipants internal ized the importance of authenticity among rappers in terms of real ness and hoodness. They assume that artists are performing a genuine self, but are constan tly seeking affirmation and looking for slipups, which is consistent with Goffmans (1959 ) assertions about performance. In this sense, fans are no more critical in their reception of hip hop than anyone is in their reception of performances by people they interact with daily. In their search for slip-ups, they are indicating that they know everything is a performance. In another respect, interviewees indicate d that they are list ening to hip hops critical perspective of our culture. They talked about how hip hop describes underprivileged living, drugs, violence, and th e consequences of se xual behavior. Drugs and violence in particular are understood as normalized adap tations to underprivileged living, survival techniques to aspects of the hoods impoverished conditions. In this sense hip hop offers a critical view point that fans understand as logical consequences of poverty. However, being that these were openended interviews where they could discuss whatever they wanted regard ing hip hop music, there was not much discussion involving critical thought about the larger issues of r ace and gender. This leads me to believe that these participants are not so critical about what the medi a presents to them. Instead, interviewees were more interested in discus sing how their subcultural capital operates in their view of the world. Although hip hops predominantly Black arti sts suggest the topic of race would inevitably arise, there was little discussion about race in my interviews. The topic of gender roles arose on occasion but was omitted from many of the c onversations, partly due to the fact that interviewees focused mo stly on male rappers. Female rappers are not as common and females are most often featured as accessories in rap videos (Littlefield 2008, Stephens and Few 2007, Stephens and Phillips 2003, Reynolds-Dobbs, Thomas, and Harrison 2008, Emerson 2002, Ward et al. 2005) In future studies hip hop fans can be asked to address the complexities of au thenticity as how they pertain to race and gender. Since this study is limited by the sma ll sample group of 12, future studies should include larger generalizable numbers. It is important for social service workers, parents, educators and other adults who interact with youth to unders tand the roles hip hop music a nd culture can play in the identities of those who ar e listening. This study indicates that youth may understand hip hop images and messages as types of lived realities. Although further research is necessary, these findings suggest there may be a need for adolescents to refine media literacy skills to be critical of media images and messages.
57 List of References Adorno, Theodor W. 1990. On Popular Music pp. 301-314 in On Record: Rock, Pop and the Written Word, edited by Simon Frith and Andrew Goodwin. London: Routledge. Alasuutari, Pettri. 1999. Intr oduction: Three Phases of A udience Research. Pp 1-21 in Rethinking the Media Audience: The New Agenda edited by Pettri Alasuutari. New York: Sage Publications. Anderson, Elijah. 1999. Code of the Street. New York: W.W. No rton and Company. Armstrong, E. G. 2004. Eminems Construction of Authenticity. Popular Music and Society, 27: 335-355. Baudrillard, Jean. 1994. Simulacra and Simulation. (Sheila F. Glaser, Trans.) Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Bell, Elizabeth. 2008. Theories of Performance. Los Angeles: Sage Publications. Bennett, Andy. 2000. Popular Music and Youth Culture: Music, Identity, and Place. New York: St. Martins Press. Best, Amy L. 2003. Doing Race in the Context of Feminist Interviewing: Constructing Whiteness Through Talk. Qualitative Inquiry, 9: 895-914. Blair, M. Elizabeth. 2004. Commercialization of the Rap Music Youth Subculture. Pp. 497-504 in Thats the Joint! The Hip-Hop Studies Reader, edited by Murray Forman and Mark.A. Neal. New York: Routledge. Borthwick, Stuart and Moy, Ron. 2004. Popular Music Genres. New York: Routledge. Bosacki, Sandra, Francis-Murray, Nancy, Pollon, Dawn E., and Elliott, Anne. 2006. 'Sounds good to me': Canadian children's perceptions of popular music. Music Education Research, 8: 369-385. Bourdieu, Pierre. 2001. The Forms of Capital. Pp. 96-111 in The Sociology of Economic Life, edited by Mark Granovetter a nd Richard Swedberg. Cambridge: Westview Press.
58 Brake, Mike. 1980. The Sociology of Youth Culture and Youth Subcultures : Sex and Drugs and Rock 'n' Roll. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Brown, Jane D. 2002. Mass Medi a Influences on Sexuality. The Journal of Sex Research 39: 42-45. Buckingham, David and Julian Sefton-Green. 1994. Cultural Studies Goes to School: Reading and Teaching Popular Media. London: Taylor. Bucholtz, Mary. 2002. Youth and Cultural Practice. Annual Review of Anthropology, 31: 525-552. Chang, Jeff. 2005. Cant Stop Wont Stop. New York: St. Martins Press. Chin, Elizabeth. 2001. Purchasing Power: Black Kids and American Consumer Culture. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. Cobb, William Jelani. 2007. The Devil and Dave Chappelle. New York: Thunders Mouth Press. Collins, Patricia H. 2004. Black sexual politics: Afric an Americans, gender, and the new racism New York: Routledge. Collins, Patricia H. 2006. From Black Power to Hip Hop: Racism, Nationalism, and Feminism. Philadelphia: Temple Univeristy. Danesi, Marcel. 1994. Cool: The Signs and Meanings of Adolescence. Toronto: Univeristy of Toronto Press. Diamond, Sarah, Bermundez, Rey, and Schens ul, Jean. 2006. Whats the Rap About Ecstasy? Popular Music Lyrics and Drug Trends Among American Youth. Journal of Adolescent Research. 21: 269-298. Dimitriadis, Greg. 2005. Performing Identity/Performing Culture. New York: Peter Lang. Dyson, Michael Eric.2007. Know What I Mean? Reflections on Hip Hop. New York: Basic Civitas Books. Eder, Donna, Evans, Catherine C., and Parker, Stephen, 1995. School Talk: Gender and Adolescent Culture. New Jersey: Rutgers University Press. Emerson, Rana A. 2002. Where My Girls At?: Negotiating Black Womanhood in Music Videos. Gender and Society 16:115-135.
59 Epstein, Jonathon S. 1994. Misplaced Childhood : An Introduction to the Sociology of Youth and Their Music Pp. xiii-xxxiv in Adolescents and Their Music: If Its Too Loud, Youre Too Old, edited by Jonathon S. Epstein. New York: Garland Publishing Inc. Esposito, Jennifer and Love, Bettina. 2008. More Than a Video Ho: Hip Hop as a Site of Sex Education about Girls Sexual Desires. Pp 27-50 in The Corporate Assault on Youth: Commercialism, Exploitation and the End of Innocence. edited by Deron Boyles. New York: Peter Lang Publishing. Erikson, Erik H. 1968. Identity: Youth and Crisis NewYork: Norton. Fisherkeller, Joellen. 1997. Everyda y Learning about Identities among Young Adolescents in Television Culture. Anthropology & Education Quarterly 28: 467-492. Forman, Murray. 2002. The Hood Comes First: Race, Space, and Place in Rap and HipHop. Middletown: Wesleyan University Press. Gaunt, Kyra. D. 2002. The Two OClock Vibe: Embodying the Jam of the Musical Blackness in and out of its Everyday Context. Musical Quarterly 86: 372-397. George, Nelson. 1998. Hip Hop America. New York: Viking Penguin. Gladwell, Malcolm. 2005. Blink. New York: Little, Brown and Company. Goffman, Erving. 1959. The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. New York: Anchor Books. Goffman, Erving. 1990. The Presentation of Self. Pp 129-140 in Life as Theater: A Dramaturgical Source Book. Edited by Dennis Brisset and Charles Edgley. New York: Aldine de Gruyter. Goldman, Robert and Papson, Stephen. 2000. A dvertising in the Age of Accelerated Meaning pp 79-98 in The Consumer Society Reader, edited by Juliet B. Schor and Douglas B. Holt. New York: The New Press. Goodman, Barak (Director) and Dr etzin, Rachel (Producer). 2001. The Merchants of Cool [Documentary]. Boston: WGBH Educational Foundation. Gruber, Enid and Thau, Helaine. 2003. S exually Related Content on Television and Adolescents of Color: Media Theory, Physiological Development, and Psychological Impact. The Journal of Negro Education 72:438-456.
60 Guevara, Nancy. 1996. Women Writin Rappin Breakin. Pp 49-62 in Droppin Science: Critical Essays on Rap Music and Hip Hop Culture, edited by William Eric Perkins. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Hall, Stuart. 1997. The Work of Representation. Pp 13-74 in Representation: Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices (C ulture, Media and Identities Series), edited by Stuart Hall. Los Ange les: Sage Publications. Hess, Mickey. 2005. Hip Hop Real ness and the White Performer. Critical Studies in Media Communication 22: 372-389. Huq, Rupa. 2006. Beyond Subculture: Pop, Youth and Iden tity in a Postcolonial World. New York: Routledge. Hurt, Byron (Director), and Ne lson, Stanley (Producer). 2006. Hip-Hop: Beyond Beats and Rhymes [Documentary]. Northampton: Media Education Foundation. Hylton, Patrick. L. and Miller, Hugh. 2004. N ow That Weve Found Love What are we Gonna do With It: A Narrative U nderstanding of Black Identity. Theory and Psychology 14: 373-408. Jones, Kenneth. 1997. Are Rap Videos More Than Violent? Style Differences and the Prevalence of Sex and Viol ence in the Age of MTV. The Howard Journal of Communications 8:343-356. Kelley, Robin. 1997. Yo Mamas Disfucnktional! Fighting the Culture Wars in Urban America. Boston: Beacon Press. Kitwana, Bakari 2005. Why White Kids Love Hip Hop. New York: Basic Civitas Books. Krims, Adam. 2000. Rap Music and the Poetics of Identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Krueger, Ellen. 1998. Media Literacy Does Work, Trust Me. The English Journal 87:17-20. Kubrin, Charles. E. 2005. I see Death Ar ound the Corner: Nihilism in rap music. Sociological Perspectives 48: 433-459. Laughey, Dan. 2006. Music & Youth Culture. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. Lipsitz, George. 1994. We Know What Time it Is: Race, Class and Youth Culture in the Nineties. Pp.17-28 in Microphone Fiends: Youth Music and Youth Culture, edited by Andrew Ross and Tricia Rose. New York: Routledge.
61 Littlefield, Marci Bounds. 2008. M edia as a System of Racia lization: Exploring Images of African American Women and the New Racism. American Behavioral Scientist 51: 675-685 Love, Bettina. 2008. Dont Judge a Book by its Cover: An Ethnography about Achievement, Rap Music, Sexuality & Race. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Georgia State University, Atlanta. Majors, Richard and Billson, Janet M. 1992. Cool Pose: The Dilemmas of Black Manhood in America. New York: Lexington Books. Maness, Kevin. 2004. Teaching Media-Savvy Students about the Popular Media. The English Journal 93:45-51. Mills, C. Wright. 1940. Situated Actions and Vocabularies of Motive. American Sociological Review 5: 904-913. Myer, Letrez and Kleck, Christine. 2007. Fro m Independent to Cor porate: A Political Economic Analysis of Rap Billboard Toppers. Popular Music and Society. 30:2: 137-148. Negus, Keith. 1997. Popular Music in Theory: An Introduction Cambridge: Polity. Ogbar, Jeffrey O.G. 2007. Hip Hop Revolution: The Culture and Politics of Rap. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas Persaud, Elarick. R. J. 2006. Ghetto ec hoes: Hip hop's Subversive Aesthetics. in Dissertation Abstracts International, A: The Humanities and Social Sciences 67: 351. Pough, Gwendolyn D. 2004. Check it While I Wreck It. Boston: Northeastern University Press. Reynolds-Dobbs, Wendy, Thomas, Kecia M., Harrison, Matthew S. 2008. From Mammy to Superwoman: Images that Hinder Black Womens Career Development. Journal of Career Development, 35: 129-150. RIAA. 2006. The Recording Industry Association of America: 2007 Consumer Profile. Retrieved April 22, 2008, from http://www.riaa.com/keystatistics.p hp?content_selector=consumertrends Richardson, Elaine. 2007. She was Workin like Foreal: Critical Literacy and Discourse Practices of African American Fe males in the age of Hip Hop. Discourse Society, 18: 789-810.
62 Richardson, Jeanita W. and Scott, Kim A. 2002. Rap Music and its Violent Progeny: America's Culture of Violence in Context. The Journal of Negro Education, 71: 175-192. Riley, Alexander. 2005. The Rebirth of Trage dy out of the Spirit of Hip Hop: A Cultural Sociology of Gangsta Rap Music. Journal of Youth Studies 8: 297-311. Rodman, Gilbert. 2006. Race and Other Four Letter Words: Eminem and the Cultural Politics of Authenticity Popular Communication. 4: 95-21. Rose, Tricia. 1994. Black Noise: Rap Music and Bl ack Culture in Contemporary America. Hanover: Wesleyan University Press. Ross, Andrew. 1994. Introduction. Pp.1-13. in Microphone Fiends: Youth Music and Youth Culture, edited by Andrew Ross and Tr icia Rose. New York: Routledge. Samuels, David. 2004. The Rap on Rap: The Bl ack Music that Isnt Either. Pp. 147154 in Thats the Joint! The Hip-Hop Studies Reader, edited by Murray Forman and Mark.A. Neal. New York: Routledge. Singer, Dorothy G. and Singer, Jerome L. 1998. Developing Critical Viewing Skills and Media Literacy in Children. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 557: 164-179. Steele, Jeanne R., and Jane D. Brown. 1995. "Adolescent Room Culture: Studying Media in the Context of Everyday Life." Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 24: 1-76. Stephens, Dionne P. and Few, April L. 2007. The Effects of Images of African American Women in Hip Hop on Early A dolescents Attitudes toward Physical Attractiveness and Interp ersonal Relationships. Sex Roles, 56: 251-264. Stephens, Dionne P., and Phillips, Layli D. 2003. Freaks, Gold Diggers, Divas, and Dykes: The Sociohistorical Developm ent of Adolescent African American Womens Sexual Scripts. Sexualities, Evolution & Gender, 3-49. Thornton, Sarah. 1995. Clubcultures: Music, Media and Subcultural Capital. Cambridge: Polity. Tiggeman, Marika, Gardiner, Maria, and Sl ater, Amy. 2000. I Would Rather be a Size 10 than have Straight As: A Focus Group Study of Adolescent Girls Wish to be Thinner. Journal of Adolescence 23, 645-659. Twenge, Jean M. 2006. Generation Me: Why Todays Young Americans are More Confident, Assertive, Entitled and more Miserable than ever Before. New York: Free Press.
63 Ward, Monique L., Hansbrough, Edwina, and Walker, Eboni. 2005. Contributions of Music Video Exposure to Black Adol escents Gender and Sexual Schemas. Journal of Adolescent Research, 20: 143-166. Watkins, Craig S. 2005. Hip Hop Matters: Politics, Pop Culture, and the Struggle for the Soul of a Movement. Beacon Press: Boston. Weinstein, Deena. 1999. Youth. Pp. 101-110. in Key Terms in Popular Music and Culture, edited by Bruce Horner and Thomas Swiss. New Jersey: Wiley, John & Sons, Inc. West, Cornel. 1993. Race Matters. New York: Vintage Books. Xie, Philip Feifan, Osumare, Halifu, and Ibrahim, Awad. 2007. Gazing the Hood: HipHop as Tourism Attraction. Tourism Management 28: 452-460.
64 Appendix Interview Questions
65 1. Can you tell me about the last time that you listened to music? When was this? What did you listen to? How long did you listen? Was there something else you were doing at this time? 2. How would you describe this kind of musi c? Do you listen often to this kind of music? Are there other kinds of music that you listen to? 3. Can you describe the different kinds of rap and hip hop? Which kinds do you like best? How come? 4. How do you get music? Do you download it, buy it, borrow it, pirate it? 5. Can you describe your favorite musical artist? 6. Can you describe your favorite song? Can you describe what it is about?