|USFDC Home | USF Electronic Theses and Dissertations||| RSS|
This item is only available as the following downloads:
Beyond the Business: Social and Cultural Aspects of th e Atlanta Life Insurance Company by Alisha R. Winn A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Anthropology College of Arts and Sciences University of South Florida Major Professor: Susan D. Greenbaum, Ph.D. Cheryl Rodriguez, Ph.D. Kevin Yelvington, Ph.D. Antoinette Jackson, Ph.D. Barbara Shircliffe, Ph.D. Date of Approval: April 5, 2010 Keywords: black, entrepreneurship, preserva tion, museum, herndon, class, segregation, identity Copyright 2010, Alisha R. Winn
Dedication For my father and my mother, Ulysses and Alice Winn. You supported me all the way to the end. I love you so much. I am so blessed to have such great parents. What you instilled in me, will never part. Thank you for your unconditional love.
Acknowledgments I thank God for giving me the strength to get through this disser tation process. He sustained me. I give Him the glory. I woul d like to thank the current and former employees of the Atlanta Life Insurance Co mpany and the Atlanta Life Financial Group and the Herndon Home Museum for their suppor t and cooperation. I would also like to acknowledge various other individuals and organi zations that prepared me for, and aided and inspired me in the course of, this research: the Alonzo F. and Norris B. Herndon Foundation, Auburn Avenue African American Research Library, the Department of Anthropology at the University of South Florid a, the Department of Africana Studies at the University of South Florida, the late Dr. Trevor Purcell, the late Dr. Ginger Baber, the late Ms. Kathy Watson, Dr. Deborah Plant, Dr. H. Roy Kaplan, Dr. Susan Greenbaum, Dr. Cheryl Rodriguez, Dr. Kevin Yelvington, Dr. Antoinette Jackson, Dr. Barbara Shircliffe, the late Mr. Ronald Brown, Mr. Wesley Chanault, Mr. Lonnie King, Mr. Charles Black, Ms. Kerrie Williams, Dr. Ca role Merritt, the Herndon Home Museum, Mr. Rod Hale, Dr. Doug Falen, Dr. Joan Holm es, Dr. Jonathan Gayles, Dr. Elgin Klugh, the Florida Education Fund and the McKni ght Doctoral Fellowship Program, Dr. Elizabeth Bird, Dr. Arthur Murphy, Dr. Kathryn Kozaitis, Dr. Susan Love Brown, Dr. Betsy Schumann, Ms. Roberta Phillips, Ms. Debbie Roberson, Mrs. Sue Rhinehart, Mr. William Stanley, Dr. Beverly Ward, Dr. Samu el Wright, Dr. Naomi Yavneh, the Winn Family, the S Avenue Church of Christ, Pa stor. Jonathan B. Young, Mrs. Lada Harland, Bethune-Cookman University, a nd all those who supported me.
i Table of Contents List of Tables ................................................................................................................ ..... iv List of Figures ............................................................................................................... .......v Abstract ...................................................................................................................... ........ vi Introduction .................................................................................................................. ........1 Importance of the Study ...........................................................................................7 Preservation of Archives ..............................................................................7 Telling the Atlanta Life Story ......................................................................9 Desegregation and Public Accommodation ...............................................11 A Native Anthropologist Researching A Legacy ..................................................12 Content Summary ..................................................................................................14 Review of the Literature ....................................................................................................17 Economic Community Development and Mutual Aid ..........................................17 African Economic Systems ........................................................................20 Challenges ..................................................................................................21 Freedmans Bank .......................................................................................23 The Solution: Mutual Societies ..................................................................24 Insurance ....................................................................................................26 Black Business and Segregation ................................................................19 Women .......................................................................................................30 Economic Anthropology ............................................................................34 Identity and Class ...................................................................................................36 Producing Identity ......................................................................................36 Black Institutions: Beyond the Business....................................................38 Civil Rights and Black Business ................................................................42 The Changing of Business .........................................................................44 Debates and Opposing Views ...................................................................47 Defining the Black Elite .............................................................................51 Class Distinction ........................................................................................53 Desegregation and Class ............................................................................54 The Anthropology of Museums .............................................................................57 Defining History, Defining the Past...........................................................58 Emergence of African American Museums ...............................................64 Case: Remembering St. Peters burg Oral Hist ory Project ..........................67 Challenges in Museums .............................................................................70 Maintaining Items ..........................................................................70
ii Funding ..........................................................................................71 Proper Operations ..........................................................................72 Methodology ................................................................................................................... .78 Challenges in the Research ...................................................................................78 Research Questions and Methods ..........................................................................79 Archival Research ..................................................................................................80 The Herndon Home Museum.................................................................................83 Museum Politics and the Unexpected ........................................................83 Auburn Avenue Research Library .........................................................................87 Archival Data .........................................................................................................88 Ethnohistory ...........................................................................................................89 Preserving the Archives .............................................................................90 Participant Observation ..........................................................................................91 Interviews ...............................................................................................................94 Oral History ...........................................................................................................96 Informant Types .....................................................................................................98 Former Employees .....................................................................................88 Current Employees...................................................................................100 Affiliates with the Company ....................................................................100 Former Museum Employees ....................................................................101 Informants and Participants .....................................................................101 Analysis and Interpretation ..................................................................................103 Reciprocity and Ethnical Considerations .............................................................103 Settings: A Humble Journey to Success ..........................................................................106 Atlanta: the City of Opportunity ..........................................................................106 Racial History ..........................................................................................107 Atlanta Riots ...............................................................................107 Auburn Avenue ........................................................................................108 Historically Black Colleges .....................................................................109 Atlanta Life Background and History ..................................................................110 Alonzo Herndon: From Slave to Barber ..................................................110 Herndon Home Museum ..........................................................................112 Insurance Entrepreneurship .....................................................................113 Atlanta Life Tradition and Character ...................................................................116 Atlanta Life Today ...............................................................................................119 Results A: Role in Local Economy ..................................................................................122 Development of Local Economy .........................................................................122 Perspectives: View of the Company ....................................................................126 Like a Family ...........................................................................................126 Growth and Economic and Social Mobility.................................128 Producing Identity ........................................................................131 Growth and Development ............................................................135 Security, Protection, Awareness ..................................................136
iii Paternal Leadership ......................................................................137 Women .........................................................................................138 Practices in the Firm ............................................................................................143 Class: Apparent or Disguised ...............................................................................145 Black Elite: Role Models? .......................................................................151 No Negative Words ..............................................................................................154 Desegregation: Declin e of the Company? ...........................................................158 New Leadership vs. Old Leadership ........................................................160 Downsizing ..............................................................................................165 Results B: Civil Rights.....................................................................................................172 Discrimination in Atlanta .....................................................................................172 Creation of Pickett Signs .....................................................................................174 Mediators .............................................................................................................175 Motives: Sacrifi ce or Incentive ............................................................................178 Contradictions ......................................................................................................181 Political Campaigns .............................................................................................183 Community Involvement .....................................................................................184 Campaigns Today ....................................................................................185 Segregation: Strengthening the Relationship .......................................................186 Results C: Herndon Home Museum ................................................................................190 Unexpected Loss ..................................................................................................191 Herndon Related Buildings ..................................................................................192 Preservation and Data Collection Challenges ......................................................197 Museum Maintenance ..........................................................................................198 Inconsistencies of Museum Closing ....................................................................204 Museum Closing: Memories and Heritage ..........................................................204 Constituting Valuable Information ......................................................................209 Efforts to Preserve Herndon History....................................................................210 The Untold Story ..................................................................................................213 Inevitable or Preventable? ....................................................................................214 Pictures .................................................................................................................216 Discussion and Conclusion ..............................................................................................225 Revisiting the Research Questions.......................................................................226 Toolkit for Identity Producing .............................................................................230 Economic Gain or Community Uplift and Autonomy .........................................232 Romanticizing the Past ........................................................................................232 Limitations of the Research .................................................................................237 Future Research ...................................................................................................238 Recommendations and Applications....................................................................240 Benefits of the Research .....................................................................................242 Cited References .............................................................................................................. 243 About the Author ................................................................................................... End Page
iv List of Tables Table 1 Demographics of Study Participants ........................................................102
v List of Figures Figure 1. Alonzo F. Herndon ...................................................................................217 Figure 2. Atlanta Life Staff, 1922 ...........................................................................217 Figure 3. Atlanta Life Building 1930s.....................................................................218 Figure 4. Atlanta Life Financial Group ...................................................................218 Figure 5. Herndon Home Museum ..........................................................................219 Figure 6. Herndon Home Museum Interior .............................................................219 Figure 7. Herndon Home Museum Interior .............................................................219 Figure 8. 1954 Employees .......................................................................................220 Figure 9. ALIC Choral Ensemble ............................................................................220 Figure 10. ALIC Protestors, 1960s ............................................................................221 Figure 11. ALIC Protestors, December 5, 1960 ........................................................221 Figure 12. Muhammad Ali at ALIC ..........................................................................222 Figure 13. ALIC Tampa Branch, 1942 ......................................................................222 Figure 14. Old Atlanta Life Building and Annex ......................................................223 Figure 15. Damaged Herndon Home Museum Exterior ...........................................223 Figure 16. Rucker Building, 1960s, Demolished in 2001 .........................................224 Figure 17. Herndon Building, 1979, Demolished in 2008 ........................................224
vi Beyond the Business: Social and Cultural Aspects of the Atlanta Life Insurance Company Alisha R. Winn ABSTRACT The dissertation research is an examinati on of the social and cultural dynamics of the Atlanta Life Insurance Company (ALIC) in Atlanta, GA. During the Jim Crow era (and post Jim Crow era), the ALIC provide d economic mobility through employment, home loans, life insurance, and community solidarity. The company was one of the largest and most successful Af rican-American financial institution in the country during the 20th century. It was founded in 1905 by Alonzo F. Herndon, a prosperous black barber and entrepreneur who rose from enslavement to become by 1927 the wealthiest African American in Atlanta. Renamed as the Atlanta Life Financial Group (ALFG), today the insurance company remains the leading African American stock-owned insurance company in the nati on. I examine how Atlanta Life employees conceptualized their relationships within the company (past an d present) and the larger African American community of Atlanta, along with the role th e institution played as a shared space for producing cultural identities through social in teractions. I explore the multiple roles of the company that impacted the community in th e past and current role s within the African American community. I also explore what the possible closing of the Herndon Home Museum mean for memories and heritage, and the Herndon familys accomplishments if the home were torn down.
1 INTRODUCTION Everybody had Atlanta Life. This was a consistent theme from those I interviewed about the Atlanta Life Insura nce Company and its role in the African American community. I had never heard of the Atlanta Life Insurance Company, when in 2000 I applied to work for the Herndon Home Museum, the 1910 residence of Alonzo F. Herndon, Atlantas first black millionaire, and founder of the company. As a graduate student recently arrived in Atlanta, I had no idea of the fascinating story behind this beautiful mansion and its owner. In turn, I also gained understanding of the great legacy of his business, similarly represented by a large building, Herndon Plaza, in downtown Atlanta. Once I learned of Alonzo Herndon, I visited the company which he founded. I remember staring at this monument that to wered in the air, as I looked up admiring its stature. This is Atlanta Life? Wow! I said to myse lf. As I walked in, there were marble floors, elaborate paintings on the walls, and the surroundings reflected an elegance which I did not expect. Although I never assumed th at Black companies were not successful, or did not represent themselves well, I rememb er immediately straightening up my posture, hoping that I looked like I belonged. This was a Black company, with its physical appearances equating to its gr eat history and achievement, wh ile keeping its legacy alive even through an exhibit in a small room in the lobby disp laying pictures, documents, and artifacts of the companys history, giving ever yone a brief history of its origin before venturing to the next level on the elevator. I had never seen anything like this; it was unbelievable.
2 My exploratory journey into the history and culture of Atlanta Life began in 2003, while working on my M.A. in Anthropology at Georgia State University. I was employed as an archivist and occasional tour guide at the Herndon Home Museum. During that time I preserved, arranged, and categorized 6,000 Atlanta Life Insurance Companys historic photographic prints and negatives dating from 1918-1993 (the bulk dating from 1950 to 1970) as a part of the National Endowme nt for the Humanities grant, Preserving a Business Legacy. This grant supported the preservation of the history and culture of Atlanta Life through photography and primary documents. I created a finding aid for the photographic collection, while ot her museum staff processed the ALIC documents, to be mounted on the World Wide Web to be availabl e to researchers intere sted in the history of the insurance company. I received most of the photos and negatives in boxes without any particular order, which were stored in the basement of th e insurance company. The photos were, however, well preserved and mostly in excellent condition. Many photos included some combination of date, name, or year on them Those that did not have any identifying factors required research a nd investigation to ascertai n information from former employees of the insurance company, individuals familiar with the company and its history, the examination of other archival da ta, and/or negatives for its match to the photographic prints. Once I iden tified most of the photos, I carefully photocopied the images, placed them in plastic sleeves, and put them in various folders and boxes for preservation. Processing the 6,000 photographic prints and negatives of the Atlanta Life Insurance Company required a year-long pro cedure to organize th e collection into
3 categories. By the end of the processing th ere were 21 boxes of negatives and 23 boxes of photographic prints organized in 10 series From this process, I documented the collection of many of the photographs and negativ es of Atlanta Life directors, officers, staff, special events, and community activities of the company. Through the categorization process, I found there were thousands of phot o prints and negatives of Atlanta Life events and social groups within the company beyond the business of insurance. Hundreds of images in the colle ction were of conferences of all types; managers, supervisors, auditors, and cashi ers located all throughout the United States. This collection of images collectively reveal ed a breadth and distinction in the company and its interconnectedness to the Bl ack community as a whole. Nanda (2002) asserts that museums are the repositories of material culture: created to collect, preserve, a nd publicly interpret a wide rang e of artifacts or objects that represent the best of the past and the present in human societies. The collection provides the preservation of history and culture of Atlanta Life through photography and documents. This would allow those interested in its history to understand the magnitude of the company, its role, and its place in the community and the place of Black business in many cities across the United States. This collection revealed the scope and excellence of one of the greatest African American financ ial institutions in th e country, its founder, and their connection to the Af rican American community. Research on the background images of buildings and structures revealed that Atlanta Life sponsored many of the conferen ces on the campuses of historically black colleges throughout the United States, like Be thune-Cookman University in Daytona Beach, Tennessee State University in Nashville, and Dillard University in New Orleans.
4 Most notable among the collection were th e photographs taken by company photographer Maurice Pennington (1923-pres ent) who recorded civil ri ghts activities in Atlanta involving Martin Luther King and the visits of prominent persons such as William Tubman, President of Liberia. This was an indication of the prominence, influence, and prestige of Atlanta Life. Images of Atlant a Life events, as well as community events represented thousands of photographic pr ints and negatives in the collection This reflects the involvement of Atlanta Life in activities beyond business. During this process of categorizing a nd developing the finding aid, along with examining quotes in the newsletters from in terviews of former employees, I put on my anthropological lenses and asked many que stions. Why were there so many photos of Presidents of African countries and notable African Americans such as Martin Luther King Jr., and Cassius Clay, (now Muhammad Ali), amongst these pictures? Why were there so many photographs of civil rights pr otests, along with Christmas and Halloween parties, conferences, and other events outside of the company? Why would such images be part of the photo collection of an insura nce company? What doe s this say about the company? As I sat processing and preserving, I consistently took my own notes, and kept track of my thoughts of what I repeatedly viewed and concluded during this process. Clearly, not only did the company provide insu rance, but there was also a social and economic context of the company beyond what I imagined. Therefore, my dissertation topic, fashioned several years later, stemme d from my curiosity about these unanswered questions. The dissertation research is an examin ation of the social and cultural dynamics of the Atlanta Life Insurance Company (ALIC) in Atlanta, GA. A major focus is the role
5 of ALIC in the economic development of the African American community. During the Jim Crow era (and post Jim Crow era), the ALIC provided economi c mobility through employment, home loans, life insurance, a nd community solidarity. Originally called Atlanta Mutual, the company was one of the largest and most successful AfricanAmerican financial institutions in the count ry during the 20th centu ry. It was founded in 1905 by Alonzo F. Herndon, a prosperous black ba rber and entrepreneur who rose from enslavement to become by 1927 the wealthiest African American in Atlanta. By 1915, Atlanta Mutual had become the largest Black industrial insurance company in the lower South. In 1922, Atlanta Mutual amended its charter, increasing its capital stock to $100,000, becoming Georgia's second Black legal reserve company, having the capability of selling all classes of insu rance and renaming itself Atlanta Life Insurance Company (Merritt 2002). Historically, the main objective was to prov ide sick, accident, and life insurance benefits to black policyholders. During this period, ot her African American Insurance Companies operated, such as Afro -American Insurance in Jacksonville, and North Carolina Mutual in Durham. Renamed in 2001 as the Atlanta Life Financial Group (ALF G), the insurance company today remains the leading African American stock-owned insurance company in the nation (Atlanta Life Financial Gr oup 2009). The financial group is a privately owned financial services company that helps consumers, businesses and communities build and protect wealth. ALFG consists of three operating units: Atlanta Life Insurance Company, Atlanta Life Investment Advisors and Jackson Securities. These companies provide a range of financial solutions that help individua l and institutional customers manage their insurance and investment need s (Atlanta Life Financial Group 2009). The
6 ALFG currently has a small staff of seventy employees, compared to at least two hundred and fifty employees in the pa st. Nevertheless, the company s resilience through the many challenges of the previous two decades confirms Atlanta Lifes great legacy, perseverance, and determination throughout a very long history. My research focused on the social and cultural, as well as economic, importance of this institution. I exam ined how Atlanta Life empl oyees conceptualized their relationships within the company (past and present) and the larger African American community of Atlanta, along with the role th e institution played as a shared space for producing cultural identities through social in teractions. I also explored the multiple roles of the company that impacted the commun ity in the past and current roles within the African American community. I attempted to answer the following research questions: (1) What roles did ALIC play in the developm ent of the local economy of the African American community? (2) How did the African American commun ity, ALIC employees, and ALIC policy owners view the company? (3) Did segregation strengthen the rela tionship between ALIC and the African American community and its economic development? (4) Did desegregation and the post-Civil Rights era contribute to the decline1 of the company, its multiple functions, and the African American community? What was the effect of ALICs support of desegregation? 1 The term decline is based on differences Atlanta Li fes impact nationally and success before the 1990s, and based upon responses of former and retired employees interviewed. It does not deflect from ALFGs current success.
7 Additional research included three foci: 1) the black elite and the extent to which, and the implications of, exclusion of particul ar classes of individua ls; 2) understanding the advantages and disadvantages of segrega tion, and its role in th e success and decline of the company, 3) and understanding and e xplaining theoretical issues surrounding the politics of African American museums. I a ttempted to answer: What does the possible closing of the Herndon Home Museum mean for memories and heritage? What does the physical structure mean as a symbol of Herndon's success, and what it will mean for memories of these accomplishments if the house were torn down? Importance of the Study Preservation of Archives and Museum The National Endowment for Humanities (NEH) Preserving a Business Legacy grant was intended to safeguard the hist ory and culture of Atlanta Life through preservation of photography and documents. The (NEH) grant awar ded the museum to preserve the archives of the company and the Herndon family. In June of 2001, the NEH awarded $195,000 to the Herndon Home for catal oguing the most exte nsive collection of Black insurance records availabl e in the nation. More than 3 00 linear feet of Atlanta Life Insurance Company and Herndon family pape rs dating from 1895 to 1980 were to be processed in a ground-breaking co llaborative effort of three A tlanta repositories: Auburn Avenue Research Library on African-American Culture and History, Emory Universitys Robert W. Woodruff Library, and The Herndon Home, the project sponsor (Atlanta Life Press Release 6/23/01). Unfortunately, in 2005, professional differe nces between staff and the executive museum board disrupted that purpose, and the home faced financial difficulties. The
8 closing of the Herndon Home, according to the chair of the Alonzo F. and Norris B. Herndon Foundation, was mainly due to lack of funding. The chair claimed that the home closed so that the foundation could redefi ne its mission. The chairman would not say what the financial goals were or how much money the home was losing (Suggs 2005). However, before the home closed, some boa rd members of the foundation wanted to reduce hours of operations from five to three days a week. The home did operate on Tuesday and Thursdays, from 9am-5pm, and by appointment only. More recently, some of the same issues from 2005 arose. Staff, in itially were told that they would no longer be employed and the museum was closing as of July 31, 2009 due to issues surrounding salaries, utilities, and repair s. However, board members again insisted that the museum was not closing, and some staf f members were called back to work at the museum. The directors employment was not continued, however. The museum is now operating with a staff of two, with uncerta in hours of operation. The Herndon familys historical documents and artifacts, and the ALICs phot ographic collection at the museum, are at serious risk due to the lack of staff, c ontinued break-ins in the museum, many needed repairs, and the lack of res ources to maintain them. The museums up-keep and future existence remain uncertain. The ALICs historical records and documents are housed at the Auburn Avenue African American Research Library, but the pict orial and other artifacts of th e company and Herndon family artifacts and papers are also extremely im portant; they reside at the Herndon Home museum. Recently, some of the Herndon Fa mily papers and Atlanta Photographic Collection were moved out of the museum to the Atlanta Life Financial Group building. There had been some discussion of housi ng the collections at the Auburn Avenue
9 Research, but no actions have occurred since. Th is dissertation research will highlight the importance of the museum and the company and focus on the need to preserve this heritage. Telling the Atlanta Life Story As stated earlier, the Atlanta Life In surance Companys legacy and place in history was unknown to me. Although there ar e many writings on the history of black business and insurance (Butler 1991; Gerena 2004; Green and Pryde 1990; Harris, 1936; Walker 1998; Weare 1993), knowledge of the history of African American entrepreneurship in the general public consists of silence, myth, and unfamiliarity. Weems (1997) describes three reasons why black businesses and businesspeople have been under-represented in African Ameri can historiography. He asserts (1997: 200), There has existed a pervasive belief that black business, histor ically, represented an unprogressive element of black community life second, even when black businesses were considered, their activities were anal yzed in a non-comparative vacuum which unduly diminished their significance. Finally, the racial integration and Civil Rights paradi gms of the 1950s and 60s, which focused upon black movement into the American mainstream, further marginalized community-based black business enterprise. African Americans who lived during the Jim Crow era talk about Black Businesses as service providers in their communities; which were business owners who enabled their communities to strive despite discrimination and racism. Black businesses therefore, fueled the African American community. There is, however, literature on the Atlanta Life Insurance Company. Alexa Henderson (1990) provides a detailed history of the development and progress of the business; however, she does not analyze it s impact on the commun ity nor describe the social and cultural history of the business. Carole Merritts (2002) The Herndons: An
10 Atlanta Family provides an excellent biography of Alonzo Herndon, founder of ALIC, and his family. In this book, there is a brief chapter on the establishm ent of his insurance company and the author does not focus on the socio-political dynamics of the company. Weems (1997:210) suggested, Persons intere sted in examining historic African American enclaves can benefit from using a local black business as a focal point. My research provides fresh perspectives on the AL IC and its social history, and attempts to connect this particular company to a more comprehensive understanding of economic assets, problems, and issues in the African American community, past and present. The Atlanta Life Insurance Company redefi ned the characteristic s of an insurance company. Beyond the business, Atlanta Life took on multiple roles that are important for us to examine and shed light on African Amer ican business, its hi story, and success. Its rich heritage in business pr ovides an opportunity in the ed ucation for youth, particularly African Americans, to gain a better appreciation of pioneering entrepre neurs and the rich legacy of African American insurance. My dissertation fills an educational gap representing the untold history of African Americans and the insurance business from a unique perspective; providing an ethnohistory and histography of Black business, and the complexities of African American community. This story can help interest and educate others in the area of insurance and African American history. Ultimately, my dissertation research attempts to: (1) examine longstanding patterns of social responsibi lity in this African Ameri can firm, and how the shared struggle for equal rights and fair treatment tr ansformed business enterp rise and ironically eliminated the niche that had facilitated its growth; (2) shar e the story of this difficult negotiation and connect this heritage with ongoing issues and concerns of African
11 Americans; (3) analyze the past and presen t relationships between the community and Atlanta Life. However, this research provi des a critical analysis of the company, examining and revealing the conflicting ideas of class and color during Jim Crow, the contradictions of gender, the companys uplift of the commun ity, and hierarchies within the company. Desegregation and Public Accommodations Therefore, it is necessary to understand th e major changes that effected African American communities, pre-and post segr egation. The Civil Rights Act of 1964s purpose was to eliminate racial discrimi nation in places of public accommodation throughout the United States, gi ving Congress all legal power it needed to integrate hotels, motels, restaurants, snack bars, swimming pools, and other public place (Loevy 1997). By July 1964, segregation in many form s was forbidden by law (Killian and Grigg 1965), ending segregation by law, in public accommodations (Loevy 1997). However, desegregation of schools was the leading issue. Brown v. Board of Education under the U.S. Supreme Court 1954 ruling banned raci al segregation in schools. However, desegregation of schools for many proved to be both a blessing and a curse. Black communities lost black principals, teachers, and children. Desegregation created the conditions for a virtual revolution in black e ducational yet it disp laced black children by busing them to unfamiliar white neighborhoods (Shircliffe 2001). Desegregation allowed African Americans to purcha se goods and services outside of the African American community, effecting Black businesses. Green an d Pryde (1990: 88) argued that the black community gave up more than it should have, and in the process lost thousands of small businessmen, teachers, and the social structures which undergirded them. Klugh
12 (2006:190) argued that when desegrega tion occurred, some African Americans considered the way it was implemented as a puni shment rather than as the justice they were seeking. Do I Really Want to Do This? A Native Anthropologist, Researching a Legacy When I decided to conduct research, I wa s confident of my success and access to all of the resources and data needed for my dissertation, through my previous work as an archival assistant at the Herndon Home, and connections with some Atlanta Life employees. In addition, I had experience c onducting research in African American communities, and as an African American, I believed my own life experiences would allow me to gain access into the Atlanta Life community. Because of my ethnicity, I expected acceptance in the community and full access. However, as I maneuvered through the rese arch process: gaining rapport with the museum foundation board and Atlanta Life employees, and the transitions of museum staff, and reviewing the archival data of the company and the Herndon family, I questioned researching a company and its comm unity of such prestige, class, and power. In the interview and participant observation process, I faced the challenge of conducting the research properly. I considered Atlanta Li fe as a larger entity, which I was unable to connect with. I was out of my comfort zone How could I study such a high-class group of people? Would they accept me? I am reminded of Naders (1972) emphasis on the importance of anthropologists Studying U p, through the examination of the middle and upper class. Although I am not studying th e colonizers (1972: 289), nevertheless I am analyzing the culture of power rather th an the powerless, the culture of affluence, rather than the culture of poverty (1972: 289). Researchers and scholars could argue
13 this, for during Jim CrowAmerica, Atlanta Li fe faced the challenges of segregation and discrimination in a larger society, affecting all African Americans, regardless of class. However, within the boundaries of the African American community, Atlanta Life, its employees, and those affiliated with the company could be identified as part of the Black elite, whether upper, middle, or working class. Atlanta Life was that company connected to a status that did not include all of the African American community. While researching this company, I cons idered myself a minority within a minority. Growing up in a working class fa mily, I could not identify with such a prestigious company and thos e connected; it was considered untouchable in my mind. Being African American was not the issue; it was class. The Imposter Syndrome (USF Counseling Center 2009) arose within me; f eeling inadequate and not cultured enough to conduct this research. Would I have to put on airs, during interviewing and at Atlanta Life events? I constantly asked myself. Th e examination of Atlanta Life provides a unique perspective of studying th e Black Elite, and would be beneficial; but at the same time, conducting research in a culture of African Americans in business would also challenge me in multiple ways, despite my own ethnicity. Narayan defines native anthropology as an an thropologist writing about his or her own culture from a position of intimate affinity, or as native or an insider (1993:671). However, I was still an outsider faced with my own internal and exte rnal challenges. As an African American, one would assume th at I would find great comfort studying an African American business. There is an assu mption that the community easily accepts the researcher, and there is an assumption that the community will expect the researcher to advocate the communitys causes (Garcia 2000). However, did an elite group, historically
14 and currently, need or want an advocate a nyway? I considered my own biases, as an African American, unfamiliar with prestige, wealth, and power, and as an applied anthropologist, conducting research in communities and neighborhoods that I considered larger society ignored. However, Rodrigu ez (2001:244) states, Anthropology at home can awaken us to creativity, resiliency, a nd diversity of our communities. Although for my dissertation, research did not take place at home, in my own community, home in this regard is related to research of my ow n ethnic group. Research on the Atlanta Life insurance company and the home of its f ounder provided an oppor tunity explore the diversity and complexity in th e African American community. Content Summary Chapter two consists of a literature revi ew probing conceptual themes and issues related to research on the Atlanta Life In surance Company; incl uding the functions of mutual aid societies for economic development, identity, and class, and the contemporary framework for creating and operating a sma ll home-based museum. The review analyzes community development and the importance of mutual aid societies and the challenges African Americans have faced in establishi ng economic stability, exploring the tradition of self-help and the changes after integration, the debates and concepts, and critiques surrounding black business and po ssible solutions for economic progress within African American communities. The changing relationships of class and identity in African American institutions preand post-segregation, their role in the Civil Rights movement and economic development, and community mobilization in African American communities are also examined. Finally, I ex amine the importance of history, power, and
15 African American museums, th e complexities of preserving history, its interpretation and (re) presentation, and reconstruction in wr iting the lives of African Americans. In the Chapter three (methodology), I provi de detailed descriptions of how I began the research process, basic design for answering the research questions, my interactions with Atlanta Life employees and museum affiliates, the limitations, challenges, and unexpected changes during th e data collection process; interviews participant observation, and ar chival research. Chapter th ree concludes with a brief description of how data were analyzed, limitations of the study, and a discussion regarding the ethical issues in the research. Chapter four opens with a brief section a bout the city of Atlanta. This section provides the settings of Atlanta Life, a nd its founder Alonzo Herndon. I explain the process of Atlanta Life leading to the presen t, outlining significan t historical landmarks and events. I also discuss th e history of the life of Alonzo Herndon, family life, and the construction of the Herndon mansion and barber shops. I explore the history of the Atlanta Life Insurance Company by describing its deve lopment, changes, and the state of the company today. In Chapter five, I attempt to answer th e four initial research questions, using archival data, some participant observation, a nd the personal storie s and experiences of individuals whose lives were intertwined w ith the company. The ch apter is broken into three sections to answer these questions, Atla nta Lifes contribution to the local economy and employees and affiliates view of the company; Civil Rights, and the Herndon Home museum. I pay close attention to the experi ences and opinions of former and current Atlanta Life employees, briefly compari ng and contrasting employees responses. I
16 examine themes and patterns from the interp retation of interviews. I provide a critical analysis of the company, examining the cont radictions of the company, regarding gender, civil rights, and class. I also focus on the uncertain state of the Herndon Home museum and its connection to Atlanta Life based on participant obs ervation and interviews. I review landmarks and sites, and their importa nce throughout the city of Atlanta related to Alonzo Herndon. In the discussion and conclusion section, chapter six, I comparatively analyze the museum, the company, and the African Amer ican community. This comparison resulted in a description of how the company influe nced the African American community, what the company meant to ALIC employees, and th e challenges to preserve the history and a legacy of the company and its founder. I conclude this dissertation by revisiting and addressing each of the research questions.
17 LITERATURE REVIEW The chapter will explore historical an d contemporary African American economic institutions and businesses. I review the literature of economi c cooperation, mutual societies to the development of insurance companies. Using examples, I will discuss African Americans consistent efforts to es tablish business enterprise and illustrate the challenges African Americans f aced in the establishment of economic stability, including economic development and gender. I also revi ew the literature on identity, class, and organizational culture. Lastly, I examine how power shapes and affects how history is (re) presented, the anthropology of museums, the interpretatio n, and misrepresentation of the past, and how African Americans have pr eserved their history throughout time. Using examples, I will examine the challenges of preserving African American history and culture through museums. MUTUAL AID AND AFRICAN AMER ICAN ENTREPRENEURSHIIP Myth: Black Business In my 9th grade American History class, I remember covering many events in the history of America. Although I vaguely rememb er all these events, I do remember in the corner of my History textbook, in one or two of the chapters, an event, or contribution of African Americans. I remember Harriet Tubman and the Underground Railroad; however, I didnt understand its connection to me. There we re not many sections of African American achievement in the text book. Therefore, contribu tions of Blacks in America, let alone, successful African Americ ans through business, had been foreign to
18 me until I took an African American History course in college. Even then, I had not understood the magnitude of successful African Americans, and the impact on the African American community. Wi thout this understanding, it is easy to dismiss ideas of African American business su ccess; accepting this myth of African American business tradition in America. Written in 1957, E. Franklin Fraziers The Myth of Negro Business was based on ideas of the failure of blacks to support bl ack businesses and the absence of a historic tradition of business par ticipation. According to Frazier ( 1957:173), It is fed by the false notions and values that are current in the isolated social world of the Negro, a world dominated by the views and mental outlook of the black bourgeoisie. The difficulty encountered by blacks in their attempts to de velop successful business enterprises, either on small or large scale, was to be unders tood within the context of a simple but fundamental sociological fact that the Negro lacks a business tradition or the experience of people that, over generations, have enga ged in buying and selling (Walker 1998: xix). According to Frazier (1957:29), the Bl ack bourgeoisie represented free Blacks before the Civil War, who acquired wealth. Fr ee Blacks were able to accumulate wealth through the ownership of real es tate (1957: 31). Frazier also addresses skin color playing a major role in this Black elite (1957: 20), stating mem bers light skin color was indicative not only of their white ancestry, bu t of their descent from the Negroes who were free before the Civil War, and those who had enjoyed the advantages of having served in the houses of their masters. Gatewoods (2000) description of the Black el ite identifies this class as a claim to a privileged status including record of achievement, status as antebellum free people of
19 color, culture, and education, and to a lesser degree wealth. In addition, the emphasis on respectability and valu es were reinforced on upper class children in schools. Gatewood (2000) argued that the educatio nal experience of the black u pper class conspired to mold into a replica of middle-and upper-class white American. The Black Aristocracy, the repectables of the race, was those who posse ssed a certain moral character and virtue (2000:113). It was not until after Emancipation that modern business enterprise took root among the Black elite, due to the associati on of the Freedmans bureau (Frazier 1957). However Frazier (1957:43) challenges the busin ess tradition of the Black Bourgeoisie, by stating, What has come known as Negro bus iness has consisted chiefly, with the exception of a few insurance companies, of a number of small banks, and newspapers, of small retail stores, restaurant s, undertaking establishments, and similar enterprises which serve needs of the segregated Negro communitie s. Frazier (1957) also asserted that the myth of the Negro businessman has been strengthened by the encouragement which the white community has given to the belief of Negroes that the accumulation of wealth through business will solve their problems. Butler (1991: 34) disputes the myth of Black business, by stating, Nested with the realities of racism, prejudi ce, and discrimination is a hi story of business enterprise which has been overlooked by contemporary scho lars of race relati ons. There are many misconceptions and historical untruths (B utler 1991:34) about African American experiences. Therefore, it is important for th e examination and exploration of the African American business and their role in the African American community.
20 African Economic Systems: E conomic Cooperation Black business did not begin in America; it extends far back to Africa before the slave trade, middle passage, and slavery. In order to understand the development of black business, it is essential to examine African economic enterprise and its survival in the New World. As Walker (1998:2) found, The pre-colonial African propensity for trading and marketing constituted a business ethos, which survived the Atlantic passage and consequently provided the foundation for the origin of the African American business tradition. The development of African Americ an business begins with the extension of entrepreneurship from Africa a nd the Caribbean to the U.S. Af rican countries did not lack financial security and expertis e. Prior to and after coloni zation, African groups practiced economic cooperation. Boscums The Esusu: A Credit Institution of the Yoruba, (1952) describes an economic institution, the esusu its functions, and some of its characteristics found in other African countries and the African Diaspora. The esusu is an economic institution of the Yoruba of Nigeria. Re sembling a credit union, the esusu is a fund to which a group of individuals makes fixed contri butions of money at fixed intervals. The total amount contributed by the entire group is assigned to each of the members in rotation. Herskovits (1941:62) found that tribes liv ing in the heart of the sl aving area (Gold Coast, the Dahomeans, the Yoruba of Nigeria and the Bi ni of eastern Nigeria) established economic systems as a form of production in a patte rn of cooperative labor, found not only in agricultural work, but also in the craft gu ilds, characteristically organized based on kinship; which also manifested in the distributive process.
21 In the Caribbean and Afro-Caribbean immigrants in the United States, cooperative institutions manifest them selves through Rotating Credit and Loan Associations (ROSCA). Purcell (1996) in his research data on Barbados, Jamaica, and Trinidad examines the case of the (ROSCAs) as representative of folk self-help cooperative tradition in the Cari bbean. Purcell asserts that ROSCA constitute a model of a functioning moral economy that preserve s social capital. ROSC A are associations formed upon a core of participants who agr ee to make regular contributions to a fund, which is given, in whole or in part, to each contributor in a cyclical rotation. Greenbaum (2002) examined the developing community of black immigrants, Afro-Cubans, in Ybor City and West Tampa, Florida the old cigar-making neighborhoods of the city. During a period of Jim Crow and racial discrimination, the Marti-Maceo Society, a mutual aid organization, served as a primary weapon of avoidance and resistance. The society was a central mechan ism for collecting and disbursing shared pool of wealth. It was a way for Afro-Cubans to accumulate wealth that was designed to protect the weak, the sick, to shield the members from an exploitative and competitive system. African Americans acquired economic and financial stability when they were faced with multiple forms of opposition. In spite of this opposition, blacks were able to maneuver themselves throughout the economic system to work to their advantage. Mutual aid and burial societies were the soluti on to limitations of black s particularly after emancipation. Challenges However, African Americans faced many challenges in the United States after emancipation. Some whites found it difficult to tolerate the economic success of any
22 individual black person, fearing that even isolated instances of black financial ability would threaten the racist order (Marable 1983: 141). The wealth of free Blacks and their successful business enterprises were impressi ve. But the obstacles that Blacks had to overcome prevented them from developing la rge enterprises or wealthy business class (Harris 1936:24). Harris (1936: 24) describes the strong dete rrents to the growth of enterprise and wealth: 1) The Difficulty of Obtaining Capita l 2) Low Wages 3) Mob Violence; 4) Occupational Restrictions; 5) Prohibi tions against Owning Certain Types of Property; 6) Denial of the Ri ght to Sue; 7) Restrictions against Settlement in the West; and 8) Civic and Educational Handicaps. In her description of African Americans participating in busin ess, Walker (1998: xvii) writes, The deliberate, systematic, and institutionalized actions of whites to exclude blacks from free access to and partic ipation in the American business community during the age of slaveryalmost 250 yearscont ributed a great deal to the myth that people of African descent lack a historic tradition of business participation. Jackson and Burns (2006:33), Ethnohist orical Study of the Kingsley Plantation Community2, a site east of Jacksonville, Florida, e xplored the challenges in the transition from plantation life up through the Civil War in what they describe as the expanded plantation experience. They found that this life for black s at the Kingsley Plantation community can be traced in terms of active re lationships of place. Life for negroes in Florida, for example, until the passage of the Civil Rights bill in 1964 was in many ways one giant plantation experience. Jackson a nd Burns examination of the lifeways and sociocultural patterns of slave owner, Zephaniah Kingsley, his descendents and 2 The Kingsley Plantation was operated by slave owner Zephaniah Kingsley. Located on the north tip of Fort George Island it was originally the home of Timucua Indians. Kingsley owned many slaves including first wife Anna Kingsley.
23 descendants of enslaved and fr ee persons of color who worked at the Kingsley Plantation, experienced of strict codes, expectations of behavior ( black codes), restrictions on mobility and access, and escalated violence a nd control tactics. Their study shows the resilience, progression, Black business leadership, and rise of African Americans as agents despite Jim Crow laws and racism. Freedmans Bank However, African Americans took some avenues to obtain financial assistance and independence. The chief undertaking directly after emancipation was the incorporation of the Freedmen s Saving Bank by the federal government. The role of the churches lodges, and mutual aid-benevolent a ssociations in creating financial institutions did not begin en masse until after the collapse of the Freedmanss Savings and Trust Company in 1874 (Lincoln and Mamiya 1990:245). The Freedmans Savings and Trust Company was a mutual savings bank establishe d for the benefit of black people. It was a non-profit concern which had no stockholders; a ll assets of the Bank were owned by the depositors in proportion to the deposits of each (Osthaus 1976:5). Established March 3, 1865 (Walker 1998), the bank was organized fo r blacks by their po litical guardians (Harris 1989). However, according to Walker (1998), the bank was a privately held institution. Owned and managed by whites (Walker 1998; Harris 1936), the Freedmans Bank was to give African Americans dire ction to share wea lth and wellbeing. The specific circumstance that led to the or ganization of the Freedmans Bank was the establishment of military banks as depositories for the savings of the Negro soldier and free laborer; to set up branches to serve sold iers still in service (Harris 1966). Deposits
24 were accepted from not only several thousand troops but also free people of color and freedmen plantation laborers. Unfortunately, the bank was tainted w ith Republican politicians. Although the bank was a hotbed for corruption and exploitatio n, it served to bring Blacks closer to the habits of thought that prevailed in th e capitalistic economy (H arris 1989:186). The period from 1866 to the panic of 1873 was one of reckless speculation, overcapitalization, stock manipul ation, intrigue and briber y, and downright plundering (Harris 1936:33). The bank remained in existence for nine years, failing in 1874 because of mismanagement (Walker 1998; Harris 1989). Despite these risks, the relatively successful record of some early black busine ss efforts prompted many blacks to conclude after the Civil war that priv ate enterprise was the only means to achieve black economic advancement (Marable 1983:141). This encour aged the development of mutual aid and benevolent societies (Lin coln and Mamiya 1998). The Solution: Mutual Aid and Benevolent Societies African American insurance companies like Atlanta Life, are descendents of mutual aid and benevolence traditions that extend into the early years of the nation (Greenbaum 1991; Henderson, 1990, Williams and Williams, 1991). These societies represent an institutionalized transiti on between traditiona l communal forms of economic behavior and skills and values appropriate while functioning in an individualistic market system (Greenba um 1991:112), offering access to capital and financial capacities that were unavailable to African American families and business. Jim Crow actuarial beliefs prevented standard insurance firms from writing policies for
25 African Americans (Harris 1936) opening a significant business niche for entrepreneurs like Alonzo Herndon. Thus, mutual aid societie s contributed to both social and business development in the African American community (Harris 1936; Henderson 1990; Greenbaum 1991; Williams and Williams 1991). The first known society began in 1778 in Philadelphia, with charter members including Richard Allen and Absalom Jone s; later founding the African Methodist Episcopal Church (Greenbaum 1991; Walker 1991; Henderson 1990). Mutual aid societies are the primary adaptive mechanisms used to serve as vehicles to promote and support efforts at survival in the face of adve rsity, particularly in the areas of economics and politics (Williams and Williams 1991). Many authors (Green and Pryde 1990, Henderson 1990, Horton 1992, DuBois 1969) describe mutual aids multiple functions. According to Greenbaum (1991), mutual aid so cieties not only provi ded sick and death benefits, they also sponsored social, educational, and cultura l activities, which reinforced ethnic networks and group identity. The extens ion of mutual aid soci eties to banking and other businesses, provided so lutions to African American entrepreneurs to obtain some form of credit and financial assistance to ha ve a sustainable busine ss, particularly during segregation. These societies operated within, a nd of necessity accommodations to the larger political and economic system (Gree nbaum 1991). They were designed to shield the members from the competitive exploitation i nherent in market systems, not to teach them how to be efficient e xploiters (Greenbaum 1991:97). Role of the Church Although mutual aid did not begin in th e church, benevolent societies organized either directly or indirectly under the leadership of the black churches were the most
26 numerous form of benevolent society during th e postwar period. For example, Rising Star Societies in Alabama were among the more popular names employed by the churchrelated benevolent societie s (Spencer 1985: 256). Congreg ants organized church beneficial societies to provi de sickness and burial reli ef for one another (Light 1972:152). Light (1972: 152) explains, These church beneficial societies repr esented the first insurance operations among southern Negroes even though th ey were operated on a nonactuarial, mutual-aid basis. Practically every chur ch of any size throughout the country has one or more such benevolent organizations attached to it. Membership in a church beneficial was open to church members on a voluntary basis. Although these societies were independent fr om religious congregations, mutual-aid assessment societies still had a moralistic tone ; it tended to take on a religious character and ritualistic ceremony (Harris 1936:20). Hist oric roots of mutual aid and benevolence among blacks in Atlanta are found in the city s black churches (Henderson 1990:11). Insurance Insurance companies sprang from these types of societies (Holloway 2005:196). In his article, Black Benevolent Societie s and the Development of Black Insurance Companies in Nineteenth Century Alabama, (1960), Spencer suggests that benevolent societies were the forerunners of the industrial insurance companies and served as the primary source of knowledge and experi ence upon which these companies were organized. Many of the black mutual aid be nefit societies were successful by any standards and served a crucial function fo r poor families who were otherwise unable to save enough to cope with di saster (Greenbaum 1991:102). In Harriss discussion on African Am erican banking and money lending and mutual aid societies development into the establishment of banks, he argued that in
27 African American banking and lending developm ent, the most difficult challenge was the inability to obtain capital and credit (Ha rris 1936). He writes (Harris 1936:22), Their lack of credit facilities wa s often a cause of serious anxi ety throughout the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Black mutual benefit societies by th e turn of the century were becoming increasingly entrepreneurial with a declining emphasis on fraternalism and ritual (Greenbaum 1991:104). Spencers (1 960) article illustrates that black benevolent societies organized in Alabama during the postCivil War played a role in the evolution of Alabamas first black insurance company. Spencer ( 1985:252) writes, The societies supplied group affiliati on and acceptance, which spread to emotional and financial assistance a nd support among members during crisis, which eventually led to the development of black insurance companies. However, the idea of profiting from a charitable enterprise was considered repugnant, but the financial instability of the benevolent societies gradually led to the acceptance of actuarial principles and businesslike methods, culminating in the founding of black insurance companies. Although some insurance enterprises were orga nized as cooperative ventures by African Americans for self-protection or grew out of church relief, mutual benefit societies, fraternal orders, or undertaking businesses, other were started by enterprising African American entrepreneurs who took an economic detour to use their talents and to serve their clients (Fletcher 1970). The first African American insurance company was founded in Philadelphia in 1810 as a response to white insurance comp anies (Butler 1991). African Americans insurance companies flourished because they made prompt payment of death claims; premiums paid into their companies had th e effect of creating employment (Henderson
28 1990; Butler 1991); and there was more frequent payment of disability claims (Butler 1991). Because black insurance companies provided African Americans with a needed service during the first of th e twentieth century, they emerged as the most successful instance of black economic developmen t (Weems 1996). The companies not only provided sick and burial benefits, many companie s invested more of th eir assets in real estate than did any other African Amer ican companies in general (Butler 1991). Insurance companies, banks, building and loan associati ons, and real estate and construction companies were the only enterprises that put large sums of money in the hands of blacks (Walker 1998:224). Black insura nce companies, during the first half of the twentieth century, were primary sources of mortgage loans and venture capital for African Americans (Weems 1997:210). African American insurance companies pr ovided an array of services to the African American community. North Carolina Mutual, one of the largest and nations oldest African American institutions, founded in 1898, provided relief for widows and orphans of the sick and those injured by acci dent, and the burial of the dead (Weare 1993). The Chicago Metropolitan Assurance Comp any is also one of Americas oldest black-owned businesses. Founded in 1925, it initially provided economical burial insurance to working class black Chicagoa ns (Weems 1996). Afro American Insurance Company was founded in 1901 in Jacksonville, FL, by seven men, including A. L. Lewis (see Jackson 2004; 2006; 2009); it was the first African American insurance company in Florida. With Dr. Mary McLeod Bethune as one of the board of directors, Afro American
29 Life provided low cost health and burial insurance to poor African Americans and made profit at the same time (J ones and McCarthy 1993:64). Black Business and Segregation Historically, segregation shaped business. According to Butler (1991:144) In the South, ten years after the Civ il War, Afro-American businesses did not serve only black clientele. But the passage of Jim Crow laws in the 1890s changed this pattern and forced all Afro-Americans businesses into one section of the business world. Either they had to develop their own instituti ons or they had to exist without them (Walker 1991). This man-made barrier (Butler 1991:77), pr evented African Americans, by law, from participating in their business enterprises in an open market (Butler 1991:77). Slavery, racism, and legal segregati on afflicted African Americans in a manner unique in comparison with other minority groups. These circumstances often are characterized as having stunted the development of African American communities and impeded their economic and social integration (Greenbaum 1991:95) in larger society. Therefore, segregation both stifled and encouraged th e development of companies (Greenbaum 1991:104; Jackson 2004, 2006). Segregation enabled economic developmen t for Black business; which in turn provided services for the African Americ an community. Gerenas (2004) article chronicles the historical deve lopment of African American bus iness. Gerena asserts that U.S. segregation necessitated the development of black self-help orga nizations to provide loans for new businesses and home ownershi p. African American, economic institutions served their own communities and African American patrons. African American entrepreneurs constructed thei r own hotels, theaters, and ot her buildings that provided
30 public space for black civic and cultural activities. Fo r Butler (1991:318) writes, It didnt matter if one owned a grocery store, a push cart business, or worked as a railway porter. There was a great deal of variation of what people did, but the key point was that they all came together in community orga nizations-such as Masons, fraternities, sororities, churches, and the likeone solid group. Because of racial segregation, the reality of African American entrepreneursh ip was a response with the development of business activity, (Butler 1991:18; see J ackson 2004, 2006). African Americans built churches, developed financial institutions to finance the bu ilding of homes, established fraternal societies, and started their ow n insurance companie s (Butler 1991:316). African Americans faced a unique dile mma of black business contending with Jim Crow laws. Economic segregation in whic h Butler defines as an economic detour (1991:144) is what makes the African Ameri can experience unique. African Americans suffered from the competition with white bus inesses in this process. Despite these limitations, African Americans developed businesses by any me ans available. According to Williams and Williams (1991), the system of segregation denied African Americans opportunities for self-expression, ac hievement, and self-fulfillme nt within the context of the larger society. However, this same system, which promoted segregation, fueled mutual aid societies, providing Africa n Americans their own space for economic development, stability, and survival. Women African American business, particular ly during the Jim Crow era not only provided African Americans economic devel opment; it also provided an opportunity for African American women. Therefore, the exam ination of Atlanta Life female employees
31 will contribute the discourse of African American business and economic development in a broader sense. Although th e literature on women addresses some of the personal case histories of women illustra ting real life experience (Woody 1992), and narratives of Black womens work (Harley 2002), there is li ttle documentation on the work behavior of black women (Woody 1992:127). There is little research on how employment shapes the income, experience, and skills of particular labor forces and how work has transformed the status of black women (Woody 1992:1). Woo dy (1992:2) notes that the tradition of viewing the economy exclusively as a marke t system where individuals compete on a relatively level playing fiel d, has not lent itself to ev aluating black women as a mainstream labor force, not addressing, gett ing hired, work assignments, hours of work, and levels of compensation. However, many authors (Woody 1992; Landry 2000), focus on women and work in the larger employmen t market compared to white women; not necessarily keying in on black women in th e workplace at prominently black companies, and its meaning for Black women. From Domestic to the Desk Historically, African American women have been confined to menial work and domestic service jobs (Woody 1992; Ammot and Mattaei 1991; Landry 2000; Harley 2002), characterized by low pay, limited work hours, instability, unpredictable task content, and a near total absence of be nefits and protection (Woody 1992:6). For Black women, racism barred black women from cl erical jobs, which according to Harley (2002:7) employed one in three white wo men, forcing Black women to work as domestics (Harley 2002:7).
32 However, World War II increased opportunitie s for better work for African American women, providing employment in factories and offices (Amott and Mathaei 1991). Even though women obtained better jobs they were pushed into what Bette Woody (1992:19) describe as a womens work subculture. It is characterized by limitations of what she calls womens jobs, which is restricted to the lower end of this market. The womens work subculture reflects the jobs of most Af rican American women in business, clerical jobs. In African American insurance, most men had positions of managers, officers, and agents; while women had jobs providing the everyday operations of the company through clerical work. For Black women, just as ma ny women, who confronted inequalities in the work place, it was a change from domestic work, and considered major progress (Woody 1992:6). Working with Families Black women working with families have been a common practice. In comparison, from the 1950s through the 1980s, Black married women had the highest labor-force participation rate, while white married women had the lowest, making Black families more dependent on womens income than white families (Harley 2002). Black women helped reduce the overall poverty rates among Black families between 1960 and 1980 and may have contributed to the success of entire industry sectors (Woody 1992:5). Black women as breadwinners emerged as part of this transformation of Black men to a higher status of work. Woody found that over 60 percent of all Black women of working age were in the work force by 1988 and had drastically increased the share of their contribution to total family income (1992:4) Therefore; African American women in the workforce are a reality, common in any field. It is worth exploring Black business and its
33 complexities of race, class, and gender, particularly examining Black women, and work, exploring opportunities provi ded by Black businesses, wh ile contending with unequal rights within and outside the opportunity space. Black women face opposition from within, from men, and the larger society s definition of womens proper role (Landry 2000: 70) Ethnic Enclaves The focus on Black business and segregati on, relates to Alejandro Portes (1995) concept of ethnic enclave economies, spatia lly clustered networks of businesses owned by members of the same minority; not disper sed among other populations, but emerge in close proximity to the areas settled by thei r own group. However, for African Americans this close proximity based upon segregati on as opposed to Portes examination on immigrants. Portes notes (1995:27) that Enc laves arise at first to serve the culturally defined needs of the co-ethnics and only gr adually branch out to supply the broader market. For African American insurance companies, like Atlanta Life, through Jim Crow, businesses served within the community. It was due to changes in services from health and burial insurance to providing financial services that the company attempted branch out to supply a broader market. O liver and Shapiro (2007:102), argues, When looking at other ethnic groups such as Cuba ns, Koreans and Jamaicans, racist state policy, Jim Crow segregation, discriminati on, and violence have punctuated Black entrepreneurial efforts of all kinds. Blacks have faced levels of hard ship in their pursuit of self-employment that have never been experienced as fully by or applied as consistently to other ethnic groups, even other nonwhite ethnics (Oliver and Shapiro
34 2007:102). Other immigrants in the US were ab le to participate in an open market and compete. Blacks were not able to do so. Greenbaums (1993) analysis on the Ma rti-Maceo, an Afro-Cuban mutual aid society in Tampa, reveals that this societ y functioned for the economic advancement on a more permanent level with sense of security knowing that individua ls in the societys income could not be threatened. The demise of this society di d not result with the possibility of integration, but simply the fina ncial collapse on a larger scale. This collapse is similar to Atlanta Lifes decline in business. The compa ny was not drastically effected by integration as the literatur e describes about the fate of African American businesses after the desegregation period. Economic Anthropology: African American Business African American economic institutions and businesses fit in the context of economic anthropology and corporate culture Economic anthropology links economics and social life, and attempts to describe anthropological characteristics rooted in economic factors. Economic anthropology examines historical accounts of early economies based on documentary evidence and oral tradition, economic change, economic organization. It also analyzes pre-industrial economies and their modern transformation, i. e. economic cooperation in Af rica to mutual aid/benevolent societies, to insurance companies (Dalt on 1978:25). Halperin (1994) combines scientific and humanistic methods for understanding the ec onomy in its many forms through time. For African American business, economic anthropology is appropriate in that, through time, it has evolved with changes to laws within slavery, Jim Crow, and the Civil Rights era economic, social, and cultural factors went hand in hand. Concepts for understanding
35 economic organizations such as African Am erican mutual aid societies and economic institutions require an analys is of pattern, variation, and ch ange in economies (Halperin 1994:9). Mutual aid societies relate to Karl Pola nyis substantivist view and ideas of the non-market economies. The substantivist view focuses on an economic system of groups or individuals who are dependent on nature and his fellows, and an interchange or interaction between his natural and social environment (Polanyi 1968:139). The human economy is embedded in institutions, both economic and non-economic. In the substantivist view, African American economic institutions consider the social relations, culture values, and ideas within the econom y in the African American community. Theoretical aspects of economic anthropol ogy in the context of African American economic institutions also relate to non-ma rket economies. Polanyi describes this kind of economy when there is production, trad e, and distribution of goods and services through mechanisms other than the market. Th ere is reciprocity of gift giving, where a person gives a gift expecting to be repaid at some unspecified time. Mutual aid societies and African American economic institutions before desegregation characterize these kinds of economies. Non-market economies consist of maintaining kinship, friendship and other relationships. Economic institutions and societies offered services to African Americans that went beyond the business, playing multiple roles, establishing community solidarity through economic means. Mutual aid societies were redesigned on principles of cooperation and sharing, similar to noneconomic markets (Greenbaum 2002). They are an indigenous form of economic system and strategies within a western economic system, representing an institutionalized tr ansition between tradi tional communal forms
36 of economic behavior and skills and valu es appropriate while functioning in an individualistic market system (Greenbaum 1991:112). IDENTITY AND CLASS Although throughout history, there have been many African American institutions; this section will focus on larger institutions that influenced the African American community. This section will explore identity, class, and the changing relationships of class and within African Amer ican institutions pre and post segregation, African American businesses role in the Civil Rights movement and community mobilization in African American communities. Producing Identity Within segregation, African American institutions played major roles in strengthening the African American comm unity. Community solidarity and collective identities characterized these institutions ; therefore, it is essential to examine organizational culture and identity. Organiza tional culture study is a way to understand an organization not as an economic or political entity, but as a socio-cultural entity placed in a particular society within a partic ular historical context (Hamada 1994:21). Anthropologist Tomoko Hamada (1994) atte mpts to clarify some anthropological perspectives on organizational culture, aski ng, Do universally applicable structural variables determine peoples behavior in orga nizations, or do national, racial, or ethnic cultural conditioning influence organizational activities (1994:19). Hamada argues (1994:6) that, Organizational culture st udies undertaken by anthropologists in contemporary western societies should be pl aced within a much larger framework of ethnology and socio-cultural an thropology of work and human relations across time and
37 space. This approach relates to African American business as it is within a larger capitalistic system. It also relates to the role of Black businesses soci ally and its influence within and outside of the business. A greater examination calls for studying the sociocultural aspects of Atlanta Life, and th e community to analyze how a company functioned providing multiple roles, defining different meanings. The provision of mutual aid societies, a nd the historical functioning of Atlanta Life, provides a space for identity formation and retention, and contemporary organizational culture directly rela tes to how people understand social phenomena and how they express themselves (Hamada (1994). Williams and Williams (1990) emphasize that mutual aid societies included members with common interest s or purposes and a discernible sense of pride and feeling of belonging. This sense of belonging provides group members with a sense of identity. Atlanta Life Insurance Co mpany was more than a business, it also offered a space for African Americans to de velop their identity, assist their own communities, and maintain and accumulate wealth. Greenbaum (2002) asserts that race and et hnicity cannot be separated from their political context, where groups and individua ls are differently endowed with economic power, and social and cultural capital (Greenbaum 2002). It is important to understand the role played by institutions in defining and maintaining th eir own identity (Greenbaum 2002). Gregorys (1998) ethnographic study of neighborhood activism in Corona reveals that the process of forming co llective identities is not onl y the key to our understanding of how and why people co llectively act; it is also a critical axis of conflict in struggles between people, the state, and capital. For A tlanta Life, this includes factors within the company: gender and class, the companys pa rticipation in the Civil Rights movement,
38 and conflicts between African Americans, the systematic barriers, and limitations brought by Jim Crow laws. There is a relationship between the fo rmation of collective identities and structural arrangements of power (Gregor y 1998). These arrangements of power can consist of larger structures of a capitalistic system which exclude and include the African American community and leaders of the in stitutions, the Black elite. Where social identities are organized and allocated, there will be a tendency towards interaction and the emergence of boundaries, which maintain a nd generate ethnic diversity within larger, compassing social systems (Barth 1969). There is a significance of identity formation and management among employees of the Atlanta Life Insurance Company within the boundary of segregation and the Black middle class. Hall (1996: 4) found that id entities are constructed with in, not outside, discourse, and therefore, we need to understand them as produced in specific historical and institutional sites within specific discur sive formations and practices, by specific enunciative. Greenbaum (2002) argues that mo st contemporary conceptions of ethnicity lack sufficient attention to the institutional underpinnings of group iden tity. Therefore, it is important to understand the role played by the Atlanta Life Insurance Company in defining and maintaining their own identity (Greenbaum 2002) in the past and present. Black Institutions: Beyond the Business Under the leadership of members of uppe r/middle-class Blacks, African American institutions served multiple functions w ith characteristics of members with common interests or purposes; and memb ers with a discernible sens e of pride and feeling of
39 belonging (Williams and Williams 1998). Many times these institutions roles overlapped with each other acting through business and education. Most economic activity took place w ithin Black-only communities, since segregation prevented African Americans fr om buying land or conducting business in white communities. Companies assisted in providing a shared space for Blacks for not only producing wealth, but also cultural iden tities. Banking and insurance institutions contributed to the economic growth and solid arity in community. Spencer (1960) in on Black Benevolent Societies and the Devel opment of Black Insurance Companies in Nineteenth Century Alabama illustrates that Black benevol ent societies in Alabama stressed their goals as the promotion of morals, intelligence, and education among the people, mutual aid to all brotherhood, and assistance and the care of families of the deceased or indigent members of their families. Black business established itself as more than a business; it was a family within itself, providing a space for employees to create or form identities, and extended itself into the African American community. This was also the case for many insurance companies like Afro-American Life Insura nce Company, who play a major role in community life (see Jackson 2004; 2006). Both Atlanta Life and North Carolina Mutual had company songs, which acknowledged the f ounders and presented line after line of pride and heritage. Atlanta Lifes song to th e tune of the University of Maine Stein Song, and North Carolina Mutuals Good Ol Mu tual Spirit to the tune of Old Time Religion, demonstrates the religious c onnection to the business. Weare states (1993:134),
40 The Mutual had more than its share of pe rsonality, much of it a given part of its racial heritage, and much of it develope d in concert between countless external and internal forces ranging from race rela tions to personal characteristics of its leaders Its style of management, the primacy of religion, reverence for the founders, a sense of mission and family, and a firm commitment to racial cooperation and uplift combined to form the salient features of its character. Atlanta Lifes song also attributed to rev erence to its founder, mission, and family. Mutual societies, which led into Black business, represented the most effective form of social and economic cooperation am ong African-Americans, and they helped to promote the ideals of the community inte rests and racial solidarity among the group (Henderson 1990). They supplied group affilia tion and acceptance, which spread to emotional and financial assistance and support among members during crisis, which eventually led to the development of Bl ack insurance companies (Spencer 1960). In addition, Black business enabled employees to form and enfor ce their id entities. The photographs, interviews, and stories of former employees reveal that Atlanta Life Insurance Company sponsored non-bus iness-related activities and community events, with sports teams, established comm unity committees to assist the poor in the community, and awards ceremonies for empl oyees for Employee of the Month for selling the most policies. This is evident for other companies such as Chicago Mutual, where employees were provided awards of various kinds (Weems 1993). During Chicagos Metropolitans formative years, 1927-1957, employee solidarity was often mentioned, describing the co mpany as a family that contributed to its development as an African American co mmunity institution. Weems (1996:71) found that leader of the company, Robert A. Cole created an environment that despite elements of paternalism, promoted inte rnal harmony and profitability.
41 Schools Schools not only provided edu cation, but it also served as space, specifically during segregation to produce and affirm identities and racial solidarity. African American school communities were overwhelmi ngly reliant on community initiative and collective action (Klugh 2006). Thus, these schools developed as community institutions wherein community members could focus th eir collective energies toward a common goalwhere they could invest in each other and actively create palpable resources to improve their lives (Klugh 2006:181). Shircliffes (2001) examination of former students and teachers of the schools in Tampa reveal themes that emerged in other or al histories of segreg ated schools: familylike atmosphere, strict and car ing teachers, and parental involvement. The community atmosphere of Middleton and Blake schools provided a sense a be longing and security. The students recall the family-like qualities a nd discipline of histor ically Black schools, and, in-part, attribute these qualities to th e success to these institutions, and to their ability to cope with whit e society later in life (Shi rcliffe 2001:65). Therefore, community institutions reinforced the edu cational and communal values that allowed their construction (Klugh 2006:181). Segreg ation developed and reinforced African American identity in schools. Schools: Historically Black Colleges Similar to churches, Black colleges were used as a space for protests, ideas, and the development of national Civil Rights l eaders. They were the headquarters for activism, space for voter registration, and voting. College students would many times lead the organized protests. The historically Black colleges produced much of the Black
42 civic leadership in this count ry, contributed greatly to the formation of a significant Black middle class, and provided pathways otherwis e unavailable to untold numbers of black Americans (Drewry and Doermann 2001). For example the Atlanta University Center's student civil rights organizat ion, the Committee on Appeal fo r Human Rights, led three years of nonviolent protests th at helped integrate the ci ty's movie theaters, lunch counters, and parks, according to the S outhern Poverty Law Center (Stern 2003). The Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC) was established on April 15-17, 1960, at Shaw University in Nort h Carolina. Under the guidance of SCLC's Executive Director Ella Jo Baker, the orga nization provided a way to harness the energy and idealism of Black and white youth (Mue ller, 1993; Carson, 1981). Blacks were not allowed to rent out facilities that were not black owned (Myric k-Harris 2005). Black colleges were also used for business conf erences, meetings, and other gatherings. Civil Rights and Black Business Black businesses played a major role in the Civil Rights Movement and the fight for equality for the African American commun ities. African American banks were crucial in not only providing financial services but al so giving members of the African American community a sense of security and confidence in the ability to gain a foothold in mainstream America (Ammons 1996:471). Atlant a Life assisted in voter registration, bailed protesters out of jail, and financed marches/protests, representing a continuous link with the broad social activism of Alonzo He rndon, reflecting the soci al consciousness of both the enterprise and its le adership (Henderson 1990). Ge orge Lee, manager of the Memphis branch of Atlanta Life Insurance and an activist in the leadership of the company, found in politics an important forum for racial leadershi p. His connection with
43 Robert Church, a wealthy Bl ack Memphian, and with the Republican Party enabled him to become involved in some of the lead ing issues of the race problem. Through his affiliations and connections, Lee worked to promote increased voting participation among blacks and enhanced their influence in the party and in the country generally (Henderson 1990:185). Walker (1998:263) found that the 1960s was an era where black leadership called for blacks to secure equal access to public accommodations and full civic and voting rights. For economic development to advance for African Americans, it was important for the development of business and investment activities (Walker 1998). Carson (1993:35) states, The institutions, the strategies, and the philanthropi c activity that characterized the civil rights era and fueled great tran sformations in American life are directly descended from the activities and instituti ons of the previous two centuries. Between 1957 and 1968, black organizations directed the efforts of tens of thousands of people, mostly blacks, in a na tional civil rights pr otest movement whose principal features were familiar: raisi ng money, collecting and distributing food, and carefully orchestrating boycotts, sit-ins, and marches (Carson 1993:36). According to Hamada (1994:26), Values are often consci ously perceived, and yet they influence organizational members behaviors, deci sion-making patterns, and emotional and effective reactions to organizational phenom ena. The fight for equality and economic development were the common goals of Af rican Americans. Institutions led the community in this movement to succeed in changing segregation laws. There are contradictions of Black busine ss. During the segregation period some leaders of Black business, who represented th e Black elite, serviced the Black community
44 and participated in the uplift of the Black community. Yet the literature there negative attitudes and beliefs about the Black poor by upper class Blacks, resulting in the upper class wanting to separate themselves from the masses (Drake and Cayton 1954). The Changing of Black Business However, with the establishment of de segregation laws, within that larger economic system, African American businesses struggled to maintain economic stability. As many laws sanctioned equal rights for African Americans, the business in the African American community changed. African American businesses thrived, particularly in the South, until the latter ha lf of the 20th century when desegr egation made them less vital to African American entrepreneurs and consum ers (Gerena 2004). Black entrepreneurs had to compete within the larger society; c onsumers could now purchase goods outside of their communities, and during this time, ur ban renewal began in African American communities. In the literature, desegregation laws changed the role of black business and contributed to their decline in African Am erican communities. According to Gerena (2004), in the latter half of the 20th century, particularly in the south, desegregation diminished the importance of African Am erican business (Ger ena 2004). African American businesses role changed; it no long er served the purpose of providing services in the confined space forced by laws. Black entrepreneurs had to compete within the larger society, consumers who could now purchase goods outside of their communities, and urban renewal infiltrated African American communities. Competition particularly affected bl ack business (Walker 1998; Butler 1991; Fletcher 1970; Weare 1993). Fletcher ( 1970:129) found that when companies faced
45 integration, white insurers anxi ous to increase their ratio of Black employees have found in the Negro companies personnel a prime sour ce of proficient black workers. The Black firms thus were major targets for a vast numbe r of recruiters. Concu rrent with the Black concerns, difficulties in preventing a crippli ng drain on their work force are increasing efforts by white firms to capture the Black market (Fletcher 1970). Therefore, black companies struggled to obtain a strong bus iness front without losing its employees to white firms. However, Atlanta Lifes survival as a strong business challenges this idea of the competition as consequences on a black business. However, it is important to examine if competition affects Atlanta Life today. Even though the company did not run the risk of white insurers anxious to incr ease their ratio of black employees; the company face competition of larger firms do mestically and internationally, as they compete on a more global market. Black businesses, particularly small ente rprises, struggled to survive a changing market and urban renewal. Butler (1991:297) states, Small enterprises could not compete with the expansion of larger re tail chains, shopping malls, franchises which developed. Thoroughfares like Rosemary and Tamarind Avenue in West Palm Beach, Central Avenue in Tampa, 22nd Street Sout h in Midtown St. Pete rsburg, and Sweet Auburn Avenue in Atlanta were all once enclav es of African Ameri can businesses in the heart of the community. They provided servi ces that were unavailable to blacks outside their communities (Rodriguez 1998). Today, due to urban rene wal, the incorporation of store fronts, lofts, and upscale apartments streets like Rosemary and Central Avenue show no trace of former African American businesses. Other areas like Auburn Avenue
46 consist of abandoned and demolished buildings, with urban renewal also settling to beautify the area from high-crime and dwindling communities. The desegregation era had both negative and positive consequences for blackowned institutions (Ammons 1996:477), for example banks. One of the outcomes of desegregation era was the reality that banks owned by African Americans no longer could depend entirely on their traditional customers and were forced to compete on the open market, pay competitive wages to keep their employees, and meet the needs and demands of a far more diverse population to stay in business (Ammons 1996: 477). This was the case for many black businesses providing these types of servi ces, like insurance. By the 1950s and 1960s, black business district s began to decline, as black consumers ventured into the white business commun ity, black business di stricts faced new competition (Gerena 2004). Historically, rapid black business growth occurred only during the period of rigid racial segregation, when relatively few white corporations attempted to attract black consumers. The Civil Rights Movement and desegregation permitted the white private sector to develop a variety of advertising strategies to extr act billions in profits from black consumers, all in the name of e quality (Marable 1983:164). Many companies struggled to survive. While previously disc riminatory white insurance companies made considerable inroads among black consumers, black companies could not similarly attract white customers. In the face of increase d white competition, companies like Chicago, Mutual never regained its prominence (Weems 1996:158). However, they were bought by Atlanta Life in the 1990s. Therefore, it is important to examine Atlanta Life for its economic survival.
47 Debates and Opposing Views There have been many ideas, debates, and concepts of mutual aid, the economic state of and the possible solutions to revi ve African American businesses and their communities. Authors such as Horton (1992), DuBois (1969), and Butler (1991), emphasize an independent black economy and the role of black leaders in the black community to uplift and assist those unable to gain financial stability. However, Green and Pryde (1990), Walker (1998), Childs (1989 ), and Harris (1989) argue for a more integrated or improved, larger scaled economy which include a broader spectrum involving all players in the economy; nationally and internationally. The incorporation of a more integrated economy appears to be a realistic approach to the economic success of African Americans. African Americans work and consume within a larger economic system no longer ope rating in segregation. As Green and Pryde (1989: 22) argued, The future of black busine ss success lay in an integrated business and financial community that would allow blacks to obtain gradually the skills they need to prosper as businessmen. They add, Busine ss formation in black communities, defined as a broad range of entrepreneurial activ ity, depends largely on the capital and labor markets of the American economy (1990:11) Therefore, African American success depends upon the larger market. However, Green and Pryde contra dict themselves by focusing their attention on the responsibility of the African American community as the cause of its economic failure, in their descript ion of the importance of an entrepreneurial culture in the economic devel opment process. There is a need for understanding how the individual choices of black Americans relate to surrounding economic and social conditions (Green and Pryde 1989:11). It is questionable who is responsible for the
48 economic status of the African American community: African Americans themselves or the larger economic market, which includes sy stematic structures affecting the progress of African Americans. In addition, Green and Pryde do not describe how African Americans should obtain the skills needed to prosper as entrepreneur s in an integrated business and financial community. Green and Pryde do not focus on the hist oric and systematic structures that paralyze the development of African Ameri can economic stability. But Marable (1983:2) argues that, White society has systematically excluded or segregated African Americans because of caste or racial discrimination. Americas democratic government and free enterprise system are structured deliberately and specifically to maximize Black oppression. Marable and Frazier be ar major similarities in thei r analysis of the past and present state of African Americans. Accordi ng to Marable, (1983:2) Blacks have never been equal partners in the American Social Contract, because the sy stem exists not to develop, but to underdevelop Black people. U nderdevelopment was a direct consequence of this process: slavery, sharecropping, pe onage, industrial labor at low wages, and cultural chaos. Franklin (1957) asserted that black Americans failed to develop a larger and more prosperous business sector. He ar gued that the core reason was that blacks lacked experience in buying and selling, which ar e at the heart of the spirit of business. Marable agrees with Fraziers initial critique as more va lid today than ever before (1983:140). However, Frazier does not seem to recognize the contri butions of African Americans historically in bus iness in spite of racial di scrimination and segregation. Frazier focused on the shortcomings of black culture instead of racial prejudice and economic exclusion.
49 There seems to be no clear and grounded answers for the success and development for a more stable African American economy. Both views alone lack sufficient detailed strategies for the success of African Americans in business. However, the two views combined appear to be su fficient. For instance, although Butler (1991) emphasized that community and broad-base d entrepreneurship go beyond economics and concentration on expanding enterprise within and outside the community, he believes in the return of the tradition of self-help. He (1991) suggests that Af rican American leaders and business owners can solve local social and economic proble ms by infusing public dollars and developing community-based organizations. Although the concept of self-help a ppears ideal for the development and success of the African American community, it is a challenge to have an independent black economy within a larger national a nd international econom y. Therefore, Butlers idea of returning to the trad ition of self-help where lead ers and business owners solve social and economic problems by infusing dollars and developing community-based organizations is inadequate. Further analysis of this subject could answer the question of how do African Americans conduct business a nd obtain success in a capitalistic society that is systematically structured in a white, male-dominated system. However, Robert Weems (1994) takes a more drastic approach in solving African Americans economic issues related to busin ess and insurance thr ough the establishment of a mega black insurance company. This mega insurance company, would be an enhanced capability to develop attrac tive products and services (1994:10). The individual African American insurers merging into one mega company, would expand the potential produce line (and profits) of the resulting mega company. It would include
50 a de-emphasis, if not eradication, of industr ial insurance. This type of company would serve the needs of African American consumer s, and it would be well suited to provide services to the burgeoning African marketpl ace. Weems argues that this type of insurance would in turn produce major i nvestment opportunities and benefit both the African and African American insurance industry. However, Weems does not provide a clear description and explanation for the mega black insurance company. In Sterling Browns interview with Atlant a Life secretary E. M. Martin in the 1950s about the state of Afri can Americans and equality, ( Tidwell 2007:175), Martin states, The Negro will never get to be a man, a free man, until he can go wheres hes got the right to go. The race will never get out of the barrel until we have business equality, the right to go in public places. I dont call that social equality. Martin adds (Tidwell 2007:180): The white powers that be, dont like to s ee the Negro get but so far in business. The Negro has got so little at present, not enough to worry about. The crumbs from the table. But if the Negro go so that he was a threat, an economic power, then youd have the same spirit as toward the Jew, only more accentuated. Right now, however, theres not enough wealth to worry them. The business field is wide open. Any kind of business if its half way run will make money down here in the South. But it is a mistake to speak of Negro capitalists. Theyre just pseudocapitalists, token capitalists. Theyre s hut out from the Chamber of Commerce, from the law making bodies. They arent in a place where they can even peek into what government and busi ness are all about. This statement made by Martin presenti ng this pessimistic outlook of the Negro as a hopeless case in America, never to obtain wealth and equality, re flects to Fraziers ideas about the social myth of Negro busine ss. Frazier (1957:153) argues that there were false ideas concerning the im portance of how Negro business have become a social myth and how this myth has been propag ated among Negroes. Calling it the myth of
51 the economic salvation of the Negro Frazier finds that this myth of salvation came through Negro business, created by the black bourg eoisie to compensate for its feeling of inferiority in a white world dominated by bus iness enterprise (1957: 153) Interestingly, E.M. Martin represented this same black bourgeoisie. Defining the Black Elite Ministers and/or deacons were often in powerful leadership positions of not only the church, but also the community. In the past, the church was one of the few places black men could take leadership roles, infl uence the black masses, and act as a major presence in the black community. Gatewoods (1993) examination of the occupations of specific families and individua ls throughout the United States and their roles in their communities offers perspectives on the relationship between African American institutions and the black community. Gatew ood asserts (1993: 27), In addition to those in the professions and in government positions, the black upper class included families identified with such service trades as cat ering, barbering, tailor ing, which brought them into regular contact with upper-class whites (see Jack son 2004 on Black elite in Jacksonville). Leaders of the institutions, like insurance companies, are among the black elite. Within the African American community, leaders of these institutions represented upper/middle-class blacks, who were highly re spected, and served the black community. Historically, the black middl e class are not only define d by education, occupation, and income. Blacks formed a middle class unto itself that was more about image, aspiration, values, and moral pretense than it was about economics (Bowser 2007:56). The lines are blurry between constituting classes for African Americans. For some, occupational status
52 has been seen as more significant and usef ul in placing blacks along a class hierarchy within the black community. The occupation of school principal, for example, which is considered middle class among whites, is ge nerally viewed as upper class among blacks. Factors other than purely economic rewards ar e clearly a factor in the attribution of classin this instance, varying interpretations of respectability and level of community involvement come into play (Green and Pryde 1990:58). Confinement and Service to the Community Prior to the civil rights movement a nd equal opportunity, the members of the traditional black elite were confined to segregated environments. They lived and attended schools in primaril y segregated communities. They were generally employed or self-employed in institutions serving th e black community (Benjamin 2005:44). The racism that the traditional black elite experienced was overt, and it was supported and sanctioned by the folkways, mores, and laws of the larger soci ety (Benjamin 2005:44). African Americans confinement limited thei r mobilization in the larger American society. However, it enabled the mobilizati on of African Americans within the black community. Forced to attend historically Black Colleges, for African Americans, according Boswer (2007:56), graduation from these schools was an automatic ticket into the black middle class. There were a small pe rcentage of black professionals who served the black population confined in a space. They were primarily small businessmen, ministers, teachers, and undertakerswith a few doctors, lawyers, and pharmacists. African Americans found minuscule white-co llar opportunities in ei ther the public or private sectors (. Harris1999:1). Bowser (2007 ) noted that within the segregated space,
53 service was open to blacks to provide services needed in the black community such as dental, medical, grocery stores, and schools. Class Distinction, Attitudes, and Exclusion The black elite or middle class leadership, which automatically stratifies the black community, in turn opens ideas for attit udes of each class about each other, as well as forms of exclusion. Williams and Williams ( 1990) assert that one of the functions of various African American self-help groups involves the exclusion of some people. Exclusion by class consisted of many lead ers serving the African American community. Gatewoods (1990) study of the black aristocracy af ter Reconstruction reveals how old families view themselves as the products of a process of natural selection and superior to other blacks in culture, sophi stication, and achievement; having to do with a sense of longevity and exclusiv eness (Bowser 2007:143). According to Dyson (2006: xv) Class in black America has never been viewed in strictly literal economic terms: the black defi nition of class embraces style and behavior as well. Hence, it is not uncommon to hear t hats so ghetto used to describe behavior associated with poor folk, whether one pi cks garbage or sets a pick-and-roll on the basketball court for a living. Drake and Ca ytons Black Metropoli s, (1954:559) which upper-class blacks description of lower-class blacks in Bron zeville, in Chicago in the 1940s, states, Upper-class are very definite in their conception of what constitutes lower-class behavior. It is not poverty that outrages their sensibilities, but lack of decorum what they call ignorance, boisterousness, unctuousness, lowbehavior. They add (1945:584), whenever a low-class Negro c onfronts a Negro of higher status, the atmosphere is subcharged with latent class antagonism. In Drake and
54 Caytons (1945:562) examination of upper cla ss attitudes of lower class behavior, Lower class people are those who give free re in to their emotions, whether worshipping or fighting, who dont know how to act, or dress correctl y, or spend money wisely. They added, (1945:559) Rowdy or indecorous behavior in public seem to be the one trait that in these expressions emerged most consistently as an index to lower class status. Green and Prydes (1990) study on three self-help organizations reveal that although the groups advocate self-help, group so lidarity, and mutual support, these organizations are comprised of upper/middle cl ass. Managers, direct ors, and supervisors of insurance companies represented the upper cl ass. For instance, many of Atlanta Lifes social events were initiated by and for the bl ack elite. Today this is still the case. In September 2005, at Atlanta Lifes Centenni al gala, hundreds of people gathered to celebrate Atlanta Lifes existence and succe ss. Civil rights activ ists Andrew Young and the sister of Dr. Martin Luther King, Dr. Christine King Farris attended. The inclusion and exclusion by class was apparent in that th e event was a hundred dol lar a plate gala. Desegregation and Class In the post-segregation era, class and identity relationships changed within African American communities, especia lly in relation to neighborhoods. Gregory (1998:65) in his examination on class, iden tity, and neighborhoods states, Class and status differences, real and imagined, rema ined crucial factors in reckoning black identities and social relations and in conditio ning the specific effects of racial exclusion, but the experience of neighborhood decline expos ed the vulnerability of black residents.
55 Where a person lived had become as important as how he or she lived in figuring black class identities (Gregory 1998:66). Many authors examine issues on cl ass and neighbor hoods surrounding the abandonment of the working class and th e poor by black elite or middle class. Sociologist William J. Wilson (1991) argues ho w the middle class left the poor in the community. Poor people looked to wealthier blacks as models of how to live and provided services in the community. The black middle class, however, left the poor to fend for himself or herself. Martin Luther King in years after the Voting Rights Act came to believe that the Civil Rights Movement ha d left behind the black poor. He lashed out at the middle class and accu sed them of betraying the black poor (Rhea 1997:120). However, other scholars (Williams 1999; Gre gory 1998; Patillo 2003) disagree with this, for class and neighborhoods are more complex than this. Michelle Boyds (2008) examination of how economic and policy shaped the goals of an African American Chicago neighborhood, addressing how integration stole the strength of the black community, wher e the black middle class abandoned the community to whiter neighborhoods, and left poor committed blacks or keepers to stick it out. Yet these poor bl acks are blamed for the decline and lack of upkeep of the community as well. Through interview of local residents, Boyd reveals this nostalgia of the past neighborhood filled with black entrep reneurism and black autonomy. Integration that stole the neighborhood fails to look at the larger economic systems and structures, not focusing on the broader economic, political, and policy shifts, usi ng culture to explain poverty and the demise of African American communities (Boyd 2008).
56 Brett Williams (1999) illustrates the not so pretty picture of the black community and revealing the black communit y, not as unified as it is portrayed. The abandonment idea excludes diversity in these places. However, middle class blacks left neighborhoods before the enforcement of desegregation laws. During the postwar, neighborhood decline sharpened the perception of class differences. For example in Gregorys (1998:65), study on two areas, East Elmhurst, a area of the black elite and Corona, mostly working class and poor resi dents, he found that during the 1940s, middle class blacks began purchasing homes in East Elmhurst along with new black arrivals from other areas of the city and from the S outh. Doctors, realtors, entertainers, and other members of Coronas black elite bought pr operties on Ditmars Boulevard, which became known as the Black Gold Coast. In West Pa lm Beach, before the segregation laws, at one point black professionals, all lived in the same neighborhood as poor blacks. However, when the development of new homes of Mangonia Circle was built, black middle class professionals moved out of the old neighborhood. This was before the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Therefore, blacks moved into a new neighborhood according to and with their class. Patillo (2003) found in her research of black neighborhoods in Chicagos South Side, that distinctions made by affluent blacks, which marginalize the behaviors and interest of their poor black ne ighborhoods, have real conseque nces for the distribution of neighborhood resources. Gregory (1992) also found that mi ddle class values of blacks were organized around issues that had more to do with their interest as homeowners than interests that could be associated with race. Therefore, space, its utilization, and abandonment of space are key factors in dist inguishing class of African Americans in
57 post-segregation period compared to se gregation which emphasized values, respectability, and achievement Within the analysis of Bl ack business, identity, class, segregation, and desegregation, it is important to explore how these factors are (re) presented. THE ANTHROPOLOGY OF MUSEUMS It is imperative to analyze the intenti ons of representation an d the ideologies in museum studies as well as the symbols pe ople chose to display and why. By examining the theoretical framework of the anthropology of museums, the discourse of museums, and the way public symbols are interpreted, a nd its themes, anthropologists can identify the means to prevent superficial viewpoints of museums and their functions. It is therefore necessary to examine history and its relation to presentation and representation. In this section, I will revi ew the literature on the comp lexities of the preservation of history by focusing on its manipulation, removal, interpretation, (re) presentation, control, and reconstruction highlighting the lives of African Americans. Using various examples of the consistent ch allenges African Americans face in efforts to preserve their history, and present the truth of African Americ an experiences and even ts, I will illustrate the development of the Afri can American museum movement and the emergence of African Americans presenting their own past. Using models of the Remembering St. Petersburg Oral History Project at the Carter G. Woodson museum and Preserving a Business Legacys Atlanta Life Photographi c Collection at the Herndon Home museum. I describe the technical, polit ical, and economic issues rela ted to museum development and operation, with a particular interest in African American history and communities with the use of these two Af rican American museums. Ther efore, it is important to
58 examine the literature on the an thropology of museums, reveal the importance of history, power, and economics in representation and disp lay. The literature wi ll reveal the role that museums play in the construction and presentation of displa y, interpretation, and representation. Defining History Defining the Past What is history? How is it determined? Who presents and/or represents it, and why? The definition of the past depends on indi vidual or group decisions to interpret it. It can not be clearly defined or distinguished, for, different versions of the past are communicated through various institutions, including schools, amusements, art and literature, government ceremonies, families and friends, and landscape feature that are designated as historical (Shackel 2001:656). According to Trouillot (1995:xix), History is the fruit of power. Benson et. al (1986) suggests that, history can empower people, although not merely by celebrating the past or by suggesting lessons to apply to the present. History can be used to teach people that the social, political, economic, and cultural institutions that delimit contemporary life are not timeless but rather th e products of human agency and historical choices. Museums are symbols and sites for the pl aying out of social relations of identity and difference, knowledge and power, theory and representation (Macdonald and Fyfe 1996). It is imperative to consider all aspects within the study of museums anthropologically. Therefore, a holistic appro ach by the researcher on this subject will ensure the proper representation of indivi duals, groups, and object s displayed within museums.
59 Sociologist Stuart Hall ( 1997b:155) asserts, Museums exist in order to acquire, safeguard, conserve, and display objects, artif acts, and works of arts of various kinds. They make statements and provide meanings for their audiences (Lawrence 1990). Museums consist of the display of material objects as emblems of class, ethnic, and national identity (Jones 1993). However, it is impor tant to bring theoretical interest to the material cultural studies within museum s, which examines the relations between anthropology and the people it represents. Who Owns History? Controlli ng and Reconstructing the past According to Strathern (2004), knowledge cannot be reduced to the realm of pure meaning or language. All knowledge operates as a historically situated social practice. Lowenthal (1985) questions, why do we change the past and what move us to alter and elaborate our heritage in all the ways. Ex amining history forces questions about the determination of its presentation, the purpose, and reasons for its use. History entails determined historical processes, determined within a stratified, differentiated reality, as well as an ideologi cal discourse about the past (Yelvington et.al 1992). According to Yelvington et.al, (2002:344), History is governed by the exigencies of authorizing, legitimizing pow er. This can lead to rec onstructing the histories of particular collections that re veal painful stories of greed, theft, racism, and exploitation by respected scholars and institutions (Jones 1993:214). According to Trouillot (1995), there are producers and consumers of histori cal discourse, and owners of the means of historical production and those who are di splaced from and not allowed access to ownership.
60 Erasing History and placing indi viduals outside of history Although the reconstruction of the past by those in power, frequently existed, history can also be erased and individuals can be set outside of history. Farmer (2001), found that history can be erased, rewritten, and ignored by the powerful. Therfore, power can be manipulated, and individu als can be moved outside of history. They are a part of the construction, (Yelvington et. al 2002:370) b ut not the product of, history that merges with ideas that they somehow own what th ey construe as their history, that their theirness (identity) is outside history, but th at history, gives their theirness direction. An example of leaving out voices (Jone s 1993:205) and neglecting local communities is the Whydah slave ship museums, in which many el ite wanted to promote the history of the pirates, yet leave out the history of the ship carried Af rican slaves during the slave trade (Yelvington et. al 2002). These challenges of historical represen tation and presentation are parallel to Gables study on (1996) Colonial Williamsburg museum. He found that white tour guides chose to focus on the lack of hard documen tary evidence on miscegenation as a reason not to discuss it, not real izing that by smoothing over a nd avoiding the topic, they actually reinforced the strength and persistenc e of the myths they were, as historical interpreters, trying to challenge Black tour guides faced a sli ghtly different problem; they had to consciously present the information by challenging the interpretations of the white guides. These actions are similar in the re-cre ation of the past in which Lowenthal (1985: xxii) asserts, Historical know ledge is shaped by subjectivity, by hindsight, and by the insurmountable gulf between the actual past and any account of that past. This subjectivity can also relate to Potter and Leones (1992) an alysis of museums Historic
61 Annapolis in Maryland, where they found thr ough observation that displays were partial and challenged historical in terpretations based on power and authority. Jacksons (2004, 2008) work on the National Park Services (NPS) Heritage Sites also counteracts this partiality of history, where she assi sted the (NPS) in 1998 in updating their representations of Plantation history to incl ude African American history and heritage resulted in the Snee Farm Study, the Jehossee, and Kingsley Plantation. Throughout history, African Americans f aced the challenge of preserving their own history that is representa tive of themselves. African Am ericans are challenged with decisions of what and how to preserve, di splay, and represent themselves, as well as provide and equally distribute written text on African Americ an history and culture. One example in efforts to preserve and display African American history was the Remembering St. Pete Oral History Project. This project involved youth (ages 14-18) and elders over the age of 65 in the Midtown-Fr ont Porch area of St. Petersburg at the Dr. Carter G. Woodson African American Museum in collaboration with the Front Porch Community Development Association, Inc. After the project ended in September 2006, I conducted follow-up interviews with student participants, which focused on the stud ents experiences with the project. When asked if they were taught Af rican American history and c ontributions in school, I found that nearly none of the students learned a bout Black history. If they did, it was during black history month; students were limite d to learning only about Civil Rights icons Malcolm X, Harriet Tubman, Rosa Parks, a nd Dr. Martin L. King, Jr. Students learned more about African American history through the oral history project. Most of the students did not know who Carter G. Woodson was until they began the project. The
62 history books used in the classroom consiste d of a small section of contributions of African Americans. Therefore, it is e ssential to ensure the proper presentation, preservation, and written hist ory of African Americans. According to Lowenthal (1985), the past plays very different roles in different cultures. African Americans history from the atrocities of slavery, Jim Crow laws, to the Civil Rights Movement, to their present and constant struggle of equality and justice, reveals a past that encompasses the need for telling ones own history. Where no history is readily at hand, it will be created (Thomp son 2000:1). However, powerful individuals or groups forget, ne glect, or create African Amer ican history not conducive to their reality. Not only is the history omitted, nu merous past and present events reveal the distortion of reality that eventually led to untruths in the written history of African Americans. Jacksons (2001) research on th e Snee Farm Plantation in South Carolina contributes to the examination of the dis tortion of reality, expanding the view of African experience within plan tation settings (2001:94), th rough examining the use of the label slave. This labeling denies the cons truction of entire communitys idenity into a single template-one defined by the imposed condition of slavery (2001:98). From her oral history and archival da ta, Jackson found that there we re wide ranges of roles in plantation communities: midwives, craftspeopl e, skilled cooks, musicians, and field laborers. The recent tragedy in New Orleans epitomizes the act of denying reality, which results in presenting a false history. Marables (2006) article, The Black South Katrinas Unnatural Disaster a Tragedy of Black Suffe ring and White Denial, examines what he calls the unnatural disaster of the New Orl eans tragedy of race and class in the context
63 of American structural racismthe denial by many whites of the reality of Black suffering. This denial enables a false histor y of African Americans based upon the events that took place in New Orleans. According to Marable (2006:2), much of the media coverage cruelly manipulated racist st ereotypes in its coverage. He writes: Television reports locally and nationally quickly proliferated false exposs about babies in the Convention Cent er who got their throats cut and armed hordes high-jacking ambulan ces and trucks. Baton Rouges mayor Kip Holden imposed a strict curfew on its facility that held evacuees, warning of possible violence by New Orleans thugs. Marable questions, Why the steadfast refusal to acknowledge the forensic evidence and the obvious human pain and suffe ring inflicted not only on the victims of racist violence, but upon their descenda nts? (Marable 2006:5 ). The refusal of evidence, perpetuates a portrayal of a series of false ideas of African Americans that embeds the minds of white America and the world; creating eventually a history with skewed evidence and occurren ces that wind up in the archives and history books of museums and classrooms. In continuance w ith Marables observation, he describes the outcome of African American portr ayal, racism, and exclusion. Exclusion of the Past The exclusion of the African American past, have been consistent themes in the literature. Shackel (2001) ar ticle, demonstrates the exclus ion of African Americans and their past, through presentation of a monuments of an official history of an event in the Civil War at the expense of another group. The community commemorated a white officer (Robert Gould Shaw) in the form of a statue, and minimized the role of the African American troop s that he commanded.
64 African Americans history suffered great ly from exclusion and manipulation of African American past throughout history. This coul d have led to the pressing need to African Americans to take on the role to rewr ite, reconstruct, and pr esent their history in their own space, conducive to their culture and ideas. Lowenthal (1985:325) writes, Seeing the past in our terms, we necessarily revise what prev ious interpreters have seen in their terms, and reshape artifacts a nd memories accordingly. But beyond involuntary alterations, explicit aims prompt us to re place or add to an adequate past. Emergence of African American Museums and Representation According to Stewart (1994), the search fo r truth of African American history was probably first launched by Carter G. W oodson, who founded the Association for the Study of Negro Life and History, (ASNLH) in 1915. He encouraged scholars to research, to write, and to publish in the area of black history. He also challenged the public history, becoming in the process the k eeper of the record of the African American struggle. Under Woodsons guidance, (ASNLH) began an d continued to hold annual black history programs that celebrate the survival of Af rican American people (Stewart 1994). From 1895-1930, the New Negro Era was a period of great vitality in the collection and preservation of elements of African Ameri can life, history, and culture (Ruffins 1992). This opened a door for artists, writers, a nd musicians to orchestrate exhibitions, publications, and performances; i.e., the Harlem Renaissance (Ruffins 1992). During this time, generations of scholars and activists created an explosion in the growth and celebration of Black art, history, and culture that ends the myth that the story of African Americans was unrecoverable. Th is included the formation of the NAACP, and the Urban League (Ruffins 1997).Those schola rs and cultural activists were able to
65 draw from many materials th at had been collected and preserved since the early nineteenth century but which were long negl ected by mainstream historians. Objects, documents, photographs, oral histories, and fo lk songs were collected by a variety of people who had different and conflicting id eas about which parts of the African American experience were importa nt enough to keep (Ruffins 1997). Stewart (1994) describes the history of the development of African American museums including the black museum movement and the search for truth in African American history. Stewart ( 1994) illustrates how the founders of the black museum movement sought to visualize the experi ence of their people by borrowing from European technology, while continuing to respect the oral tradition of Africa. She states (1994:71), They were guided by their dedicat ion to telling the truth about the African American struggle in America, as well as by their realization th at traditional museums were established under a discriminatory system and did not serve the needs of the African American community (Stewart 1994:71). Emerging during the late '50s, African -American museums were founded on the mission to preserve the heritage of blacks and to ensure its proper interpretation in American history (Williamson 1992). Accord ing to Ruffins (1992), the number of museums that are in minority communities, dedicated to specific people of color, concerned with important topics in African Am erican or ethnic history, have dramatically increased since 1976, when America's bicentenn ial triggered a tremendous interest in community history. Throughout this time, African Americans strived not to preserve their history, but also items and artifacts associ ated with that history (Ruffins 1992).
66 According to Stewart and Ruffins ( 1986:334), Afro-American public history arose out of the desire to promote a positive racial identity among blacks, to preserve a history in danger of being lo st, and to challenge the ra cist stereotypes and myths pervasive in American popular culture. There are many ex amples of the struggle to preserve and display African American histor y and heritage events. One example is the 1991 African Burial Ground where the remain s of more than 400, 17th, and 18th century Africans were discovered during pre-construc tion work for a federal building in New York City (www.africanburialground.gov/). With the involvement of archaeologist, city officials, contractors, activis t and residents, the burial gr ound was memorialized with a granite memorial commemorating African slaves. There is a challenge in distinguishi ng presentation of history from the presentation of truth. This is an issue becau se historically those in power and authority have presented history and because of their pos itions, has been presented as truth. Others have attempted to re-write history or what Jackson (2001) describes silencing history with partial truths, while Afri cans Americans attempt to present a different form of truth. In addition, there are local res earchers who strive to ensure the preservation of African American history and heritage. Dr. Susan Gr eenbaums, Central Avenue Projects (1998) research team redefined the meaning and im portance of African American history in Tampa through the development of a program the Central Avenue Legacies, to reconstruct the knowledge of Central Ave nue and explore the causes of its destruction. Dr. Antoinette Jacksons initiation of The Sul phur Springs Heritage project is part of an ongoing commitment to address the rising interest in, and need for, heritage management by communities, civic organizati ons, and other groups focused on preserving the past as a
67 key cultural resource (Jackson 2006). The proj ect promotes the assurance of telling and preserving of all portions of the history. Case Study: Remembering St. Pe te Oral History Project: However, museums board members, curato rs, directors, and staff face challenges in proper presentation and display within Af rican American communities. Just as the museums serves as multiple functions of display, there are multiple players. Karp (1991a:12) argues, All exhibiti ons are inevitably organize d based on assumptions about the intentions of the objects producers, th e cultural skills and qualifications of the audience, the claims to authoritativeness ma de by the exhibition, and judgments of the aesthetic merit or au thenticity of th e objects or settings exhi bited. Lowenthal (1985: xxiii) examined how and why we change the past, and the effect of changes on our environment and ourselves. Lowenthal argued that we are presented with choices, whether to keep relics or to remove them, to leave them in fragments or make them whole again. This virtually affects whose pa st is experienced. Challenges may consist of some African American community residents who want to forget certain parts of the past, i.e slavery, and those who want to remember. For slave descendents at the Snee Farm Plantation the, accounts of the past employed kinship and memories of individuals and of community relationships more than refe rences to slavery as memories to their grandparents and great-gra ndparents (Jackson 2003:105). The Remembering St. Pete Oral History Project provided an opportunity to present the historical voice and experiences of African Americans in the United States, Florida, and most importantly the City of St Petersburg in an effo rt to preserve this history for present and future generations of residents. During the development of the
68 exhibit, the collaboration between Front Porch Community Development Association, museum board members, exhibit designe rs, and an anthropologist, posed many challenges. The exhibit featured four th emes: Households, Entertainment-Fashion, Education, and Community Events During the interview process, students asked elders if they would like to donate items for the exhibi t. As a result, we received many items; from doll figurines, pictures, baskets, a cipher, a saw, African statues, and even old Avon bottles. Many of the items did work well with in the themes. Those items that did not fit or match the themes of the museum display were kept out of the exhibit. There was a dispute over the appropriaten ess of displaying certain items based on time and social relevance of the items and exhibit. The exhibi t designers and I disagr eed with others, with displaying some of the items, particul arly the Avon bottles and statues. As an anthropologist, I asked, In what c ontext are the Avon bottles significant? and Is there a story behind the bottles? This incident reflects the many challenges in the decision-making process of presenting African American history using items and artifacts. In the end, as project director, I made an executive decision not to use the Avon bottles, neither the saw, cipher nor the fi gurines. This parallels to producers and consumers of historical discourse, and owners of the means of historical production and those who are displaced from and not allowed access to ownership (Trouillot 1995). Therefore, ownership of the past determin es how past is represented, presented and displayed. In this case, those in powerful positions, as project director, decided was exhibited, and what counted as an important object in history. L eaders face decisions whether to display certain items or not. Th ey also face challenges in determining the proper place of those items. Th erefore, decisions for displaying certain objects, involved
69 those who created or directed the exhibit. According to Tabors ky (1990:74), museums have a social function to explore objects, as signs, as objects, which are socially meaningful, but an object on its own has no meaning, objects exist only as signs. Curators give license to sp eak for them (Jones 1993:215). Other challenges within the project in cluded: making certain the correct names and spelling of businesses, people, and la ndmarks for accuracy on the panels of the elders, and properly quoting elde rs. Students interviewed most of the elders in their own homes. Therefore, there was a level of comfort in the interview regarding what the elders said and how they said certain words. Many elders used African American dialect or code-switched when explaining or describing events or expe riences. However, we had to choose quotes appropriate to the exhibit wit hout losing its authenticity. We wanted to prevent any elder complaints of their presenta tion and display in the exhibit. Many of the elders were former teachers, lawyers, and ot her professionals, and we wanted to ensure that the elders had the best pr esentation of themselves possibl e. As a result, we carefully used one quote on their individual panels and we placed other quotes throughout the museums without a name underneath. S hopes (1986:249) writes, Developing links between a community history project and its community is difficult. Any such project that seeks to involve local pe ople in producing their own hist ory and to have meaning for the community itself much confronts comp lex social relationships and problems of interpretation.
70 Challenges in Museums Maintaining items With museums, particularly African American museums, there are many challenges in relation to funding, proper opera tion, maintaining items, and usage of space in regard to museum development and opera tion. Museums are symbols and sites for the playing out of social relations of identity and difference, knowledge and power, theory and representation (Macdonald and Fyfe 1996) In Kreps (2003) examination of the anthropology of museums and cu ratorial practices, he asserts that it is important to look at the museum and curatorial practices as cult ural artifacts in themse lves, or as cultural constructs located in specific social, politic al, economic, and histor ical contexts. In her article, Recovering Yesterday: Collecti on and Preservation of African American History Ruffins (1997) found how African Americans continue d challenge is to stamp their own name on history a nd claim their own artifacts. Bethel (2000), in her article on Africa n American museums, gives a structural approach to investigating th e recent history and status of African American museums, where data on African American museums and historical organizations is very incomplete. A recent example of the challenge of African American s maintaining items was the threat of the auc tioning of the King papers. The collection of handwritten versions of Kings Letter from a Birmi ngham Jail, his famous I Have a Dream speech, delivered at the 1963 March on Washi ngton, and his acceptance speech for the 1964 Nobel Peace Prize, were moved from the basement of the familys home to New York-based Sothebys auction house. Fort unately, Morehouse College housed the King Papers, which is worth $32 million dolla rs (http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15198573).
71 Funding One of the many challenges for African American museums is funding. According to museum researchers (Ste wart 1997; Ruffin 1994; Williamson 1992), African Americans face multiple funding probl ems to keep museum doors open. AfricanAmerican museums generally have never recei ved the kind of financial support available to larger institutions (Williamson 1992). W illiamson (1992:1) states, During these recessionary times, museums and other cultural institutions have become the sacrificial lambs on which state and local governments attempt to balance their budgets. Major cutbacks have forced most of the nation's muse ums to streamline their operations and in a few cases to close their doors. Historically, when America suffers an economic downturn, minorities and the poor are the hardest hit, so it is logical to conclude that the relatively young and struggling community of African-American museums would be faring miserably (Williamson 1992). Ebony Magazines (1994) ar ticle on African American museums, also illustrates the difficulties of fundi ng by stating, While Black museums are doing much to preserve the African-American legac y, Black museum directors constantly labor under the threat of cuts in arts funding. More often than not, Black museums, with a greater dependence on public money, are hit the hardest. The closing of the Herndon Home was ma inly due to lack of funding. Although Chair of the Alonzo F. and Norris B. Herndon Foundation, said that, the home closed so that the foundation could redefine its mission, the home faced financial difficulties and leadership conflicts between staff. The chai rman would not say what the financial goals were neither how much money the home was losing (Suggs 2005). This parallels with the
72 fate of the Carter G. Woodson African Americ an museum in St. Petersburg, Florida; it had not been a year since its opening in Ap ril of 2006, yet the museum had the same funding issues and the threat of it closing. According to the St. Petersburg Times (December 7, 2006), officials at the Carter G. Woodson History Museum said that they needed almost $27,000 in government subsidies to keep it running. Without that support, the museum likely would fold, they told me mbers of the St. Petersburg City Council. Other African American museums face simila r problems. In the face of this, private funding is a matter of life and d eath for black museums (Ebony 1994). Proper Operations: Lack staff and Inexperience African American museums must conte nd with the technicalities of museum operations. Many museums usually have sma ll staff members which prevents museum operations from running smoothly. The staff us ually takes on multiple responsibilities, such as answering phones, giving tours, ar chival work, and cleaning. Board members and volunteers are used in a greater capacity to help raise funds, and part-time staff and consultants have replaced full-time staff (Williamson 1992). The Executive Director of the California Afro-American Museum, Terrie Rouse, states that the museum began downsizing early on, from a staff of 44 two y ears ago to a current staff of 19. A team effort has emerged, in which staff will help out where needed instead of confining themselves to their areas of expertis e (Williamson 1992:3). At the Herndon Home museum, there was usually a paid staff of thr ee, with two volunteers. A strikingly similar scenario played out at the Carter G. Woods on Museum. With the passing of the former director, Dr. Ginger Baber, in 2006, the museum lacked staff, with one intern, and the board members at the Carter G. Woodson African American museum acted as staff until
73 they could afford to hire a director and additional staff. In this sense, board members whose role was to make decisions and a ssist in obtaining fundi ng took on additional roles. In addition, board members of the Woodson museum did not have knowledge about museums and its operation. When I inte rviewed the chairman of the board about the responsibilities of board members and operations, she informed me that they did not know enough and lacked the knowledge to run the museum properly. Many of the board members had been on committees, yet they never created or sat on a museum board before. The museum board chair added in regards to museum knowledge, If we had a book before we got started, I think we would be further along than we are (Winn 2006). Class: Ownership and the use of Space It is necessary to examine how community and political leaders, representing the middle class, influence the use of museum space. Sikes (1992) examined a museum for Native Americans, on its physical space, co llection, exhibitions, programs, internal organization, staffing. Sikes revealed a seri es of seven metaphoric structures. One of these structures examined museums as a political system; this structure relates to the fact that many of the volunteers and staff cam e from upper middle class communities in Phoenix, while Native Americans whose cultur es are on view were marginalized in the power system. This parallels to the execu tive board at the Herndon Home museum and the Woodson museum. For both museums, board members consist of prominent or wellknown individuals in their community. They c onsisted of present and former lawyers, professors, activists, church leaders, hist orians, and business ow ners. Although many of the board members were residents in th e surrounding communities of the Woodson
74 museum, most of the members consisted of elite and/or middle class residents. However, the surrounding communities for both museum s are located in low-income African American neighborhoods. For the Woodson museum, although some board members believed they are not the target audience, M iddle-class blacks would seem to be the museum's natural cons tituents (Gezar 2006). Each year the Herndon Home Museum hosts Christmas at Diamond Hill. Christmas at Diamond Hill is where the museum has different events for the community, such as Kwanzaa Day, Family Day and the Decorator Show house. However the main event for the museum and similar to many othe r events, is the Gala Reception and Live Auction. This consists of museum supporters and friends with food and a silent auction where bidding reaches $200-300. Celebrities li ke R&B singer, Jennifer Holiday have attended in the past. Museum members are often affiliated with the insurance company, representing the upper/middle cla ss. Most events at the home involve black elite, rarely catering to the surrounding geographic community. Likewise, at the Carter G. Woodson museum, the board hosted private receptions in one month for the opening of the Tuskegee Airmen exhibit and a visit to the museum by John Hope Franklin. Although the events were free, the event was by private invitation only. The Links, a prestigious African Ameri can organization for women, hosted the John Hope Franklin event. The events again, catered to upper/middle class blacks. The Tuskegee Airmen exhibit opene d for the public the following day. Based upon these two cases, it is clear th at class effects the determina tion of the use of space in museums. Those in power determine how history and the usage space that is designed to (re) present history. Although African American museums face many challenges in
75 maintaining and operating a muse um, African American elite could contribute to this challenge by using space for their ow n purposes, excluding th e larger surrounding African American community, and detouring from the init ial purpose the museum; to preserve and present African American history and culture. Museum events such as these are nece ssary, for community museums must have all classes of people involved, especially for fundraising purposes. And, it is necessary to have a museum board of those in power a nd wealth in the community, such as the Smithsonian appointing a 19-member adviso ry council of the National Museum of African American History and Culture. The council comprised of Oprah Winfey, music and multimedia producer Quincy Jones and Ti me Warner CEO Richard Parsons, (Roach 1998). Ironically, the museums did not charge anyone to attend the events, yet both the Woodson and Herndon museums face funding difficulties. The challenge in African American museums such as the Herndon and Woodson is decision-making in the proper usage of the museum space that enables usage for all groups of people. Although many museums goa ls are to serve multiple functions of education of African American historys ponsor community events, provide a space for community groups meetings, exhibits for the public, and strengthen the communityit is important that these multiple functions are carried out. In another 2006 article in the St. Petersburg Times on the Woodson museum, some residents questioned the purpose of the museum. As Gezar (November 28, 2006) states, ...the biggest challenge to the museum 's long-term survival may be the absence of a devoted constituency in the neighborhood su rrounding the little yellow building at 2240 Ninth Ave. S. One local resident suggest ed the conversion of the building, which
76 formerly housed the old Jordan Park leasi ng office, to a day-care center instead a museum; while other residents complained th at the museum is open very limited hours of 3 days a week, Monday, Wednesday, and Frid ay from 11-2 pm. These hours of operation remained even during the Oral history exhibit; even though the exhibit showcased residents from the community. In turn, this prevented residents who worked during the day from viewing the exhibit. However, duri ng the Airmen exhibit, the museum extended its hours to Thursday evenings and Saturday s. This is the same case for the Herndon museum, which opened Tuesdays and Thursd ay, however tours were by appointment only. As Karp and Lavine (1991: 2) state, Decisions about how cultures are presented reflect deeper judgments of power and author ity and can, indeed, reso lve themselves into claims about what a nation is or ought to be as well as how citizens should relate to one another. It is easier to unders tand the political and social im plications of such decisions when one looks at the museums of ot her cultures (Karp and Lavine 1991). For both museums, there is a disconnection between the public and the museums. Most of the time, museum space supplies the needs of the upper/middle class who do not currently live in the neighborhood. It is important to seek to develop an anthropology of reflections that takes into account how muse um goers and other consumers of history make judgments about how his torical things and writings they encounter, and how they position themselves in the context of object s and discourses (Yel vington 2002). Franco (1994) on his examination of th e collectors experience argue s that the public tends to understand history as a set of facts, and to become engaged with the past through personal or emotional connections. In history museums, interpreters of exhibits provide the necessary link between historians and the public, but historians have typically
77 discounted the professionalism of thes e communicators (Franco 1994). Gaithers (1992:60) discussion of African American museums and communities reveals that, The close relationship between Afri can American museums and their communities permits museums to validate the communities experiences. For this reason, the museums programs often have a familiarity and a truthfulness that cause the communities to feel a strong bond of kinship with the institutions. Using both conventional and new program form ats, these museums provide exciting models for forging community-museum marriages. This is not the case in the Herndon and Woodson museums. These are the continuing challenges and issues within Afri can American museums in which all players must be involved in the decision-making process, museum leaders must educate themselves on proper maintenance and operati ons, and choose a variety of individuals representing all classes and backgrounds, as well as funding to ensu re that the museum doors stay open. Some small African American museums like the Woodson and Herndon Home museums continue to confront the struggl e for this type of re lationship within their communities.
78 METHODOLOGY As I mentioned earlier, my initial involvement with this research developed through my employment at the Herndon Home museum as an archivist to create the Atlanta Life Photographic Collection. My inte rest in this story of black achievement caught my attention and prompted me to e xplore the legacy of Alonzo Herndon, and his company, professionally and personally. The long er I worked for the museum, the more I became engulfed in understanding the importance and impact the company had on the community and the US; particularly determ ining what this company meant to the individuals in the black and white photos th at spread across my table at work in 20032004. As I looked at their faces, I wondered what they must have been thinking or feeling at that moment or what it was like to wake up every morning to go to work for Atlanta Life, the epitome of success in the f ace of Jim Crow, Civil Rights movements, desegregation, and downsizing. I really wanted to key in on Atlanta Life employees experiences and reveal the value of the phot ographs, connecting the past and the present through ethnography. Challenges in the Research: The Process and Its Obstacles When I decided to carry out my disse rtation in spring of 2005, I immediately contacted my former supervisor and director of the Herndon Home museum. Unfortunately, the director informed me that the museum closed. The board dismissed the staff with two days notice. The director f aced legal issues with the museum board, and the politics surrounding its closing. However, th e director encouraged me to pursue my
79 research and contact the grants administra tor representing the National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH) grant awarded to the mu seum to preserve the archives of the company and the Herndon family. NEH aw arded the museum the grant with the stipulation that the collections would be acces sible to the public for research. However, without staff and temporary closing, accessibility would be difficult. Therefore, I did not understand how the museum could be in such ba d shape to close when we just completed developing and maintaining the collections. To date, I am uncertain of the resolution of the grant; however, there was some attempt to complete it by the interim director in spring 2008. Research Questions and Methods I attempted to answer the following questions: 1. What roles did ALIC play in the developm ent of the local economy of the African American community? 2. How did the African American commun ity, ALIC employees, and ALIC policy owners view the company? 3. Did segregation strengthen the relationship between ALIC and the African American community and its economic development? 4. Did desegregation along with the post-Civil Rights era contribute to the decline of the company, its multiple functions, and the African American community? Additional research included three foci: 1) the black elite and the extent to which, and the implications of, exclusion of particul ar classes of individua ls; 2) understanding the advantages and disadvantages of segrega tion, and its role in th e success and decline of the company, 3) and understanding theo retical issues surr ounding the politics of African American museums. I attempted to an swer: What does the possible closing of the Herndon Home Museum mean for memories and heritage? What does the physical
80 structure mean as a symbol of Herndon's succe ss, and what it will mean for memories of these accomplishments if the house were torn down? I designed a multi-method investigation using archival data, participant observation, and in-depth inte rviews with former and current employees, non-employees related to company and Atlanta Life policy ow ners. I examined the cultural perspective of historical African American businesses, l ooking at not only what happens within the institution, but also what it means (Hamad a 1994). My previous employment at the Herndon Home Museum and experiences greatly facilitated identifying informants and archival data. Through the research process, I unexpectedly discove red the importance of exploring the challenges and issues surroundi ng the Herndon Home Museum as well. In Fall 2005 I began the first of several short field trips to Atlanta to collect research data. Data collection continued until final interviews were completed in summer of 2009. Archival Research Many researchers and anthropol ogists use archival data to preserve history, tell a story, and understand the past. Archival data can be used to conducted qualitative or quantitative data for research, service, a nd other official and unofficial purposes by researchers, service organizati ons, and other groups. The data are stored in the formats in which they were collected (Rodriguez and Baber 2002). Archives represent governmental reports, newspaper archives, personal diaries, or photo collections, sc hool records, wills, deeds, and records of court cases (Bernard 1995 ). It also includes maps that can identify physical features and structures in comm unities and neighborhoods; municipal records of births, marriages, real-estate transactions, and property ownership; census, tax, and voting lists; specialized surveys; serv ice system records from human service
81 organizations; court proceedings; minutes of meetings of local groups (Rodriguez and Baber 2002). Other archival material include hi storical accounts are also placed in books, articles, theses, dissertations, and other unpublis hed work. In addition, the preservation of history can be found in company files, count y courthouses, journals, newspapers, State Departments archives, and museums. My work and experiences at the He rndon Home Museum not only enabled a better understanding of culture of the company, but also th e contribution and usefulness of archival data, museums, and historic pr eservation within applie d anthropology. It also highlighted the importance of seeking s ources beyond the mainstream, and African American sources of archival knowledge (see Jackson 2004). Rodriguez and Baber reveal the advantages of archival research by stating (2002:65), The use of data from archival a nd secondary sources can enhance the comprehensiveness of data collection by allo wing for cross-cultural and cross-national comparability and generalizability. It is possible to study issues using archival data that would be too politically cont roversial to study any other way. Archival data offer researchers the opportunity to develop resear ch models and test preliminary hypotheses prior to going into the field, and to situate th eir locally available data in the context of comparable populations or larger data sets (S chensul et. al 1999:202). Therefore, it is important to examine the significan ce of museums and anthropology. Material cultural studies within museums, examines the relations between anthropology and the people it represents. Museums are the repositories of material culture: they were created to collect, preser ve, and publicly interpret a wide range of artifacts that represent the best of the past and the present in human societies (Nanda
82 2002). Halls (1997a) discussion of two character istics of museum objects: their physical appearance and their meaning, suggests that objects are described as documents or evidence of the past, and are regarded as pristine material em bodiments of cultural essences, which transcend time, place, and historical contingency. Among those objects are photographs. While photographs are images, they are also objects, and this materiality is integral to their meaning and uses (Edwar ds and Hart 2004:2). The dominance of image content and the physical attributes of the photographs influe nce content in the arrangement and projection of visual informa tion. The history, storie s, and events that created the images of the Atlanta Life P hotographic Collection are examples of the importance of examining of what Earl Le wis (1996), caled for the connection among place, memory, and urban history. This sugge sts that memories of African Americans have of a particular place defined from the inside out. Race, gender class, ethnicity, age and other part of ones identity help situate those memories. However, Rodriguez and Baber (2002:65) caution that archival data cannot always be clean. It is impor tant to consider carefully all the possible sources of biases (Bernard 1995; Rodriguez and Baber 2002). Furt hermore, archival data are not always stored in ways that support easy retrieva l (Baber and Rodriguez 2002; Schensul et.al 1999). Bernard also advises (1995: 339) that it may appear that archival data are, cleanespecially if they come from modern data banks and already packag ed on computer disks or tape, coded, and ready to be analyzed, but they may be riddled with error. The important material issues for anthropologist s on this topic are the way records are kept,
83 what counts as a record, how knowledge of the past is transmitted, and where and by whom and under what circumstances it is retrieved (Yelvington 2002). The Herndon Home Museum The majority of the archival research took place at the Herndon Home Museum, and the Auburn Avenue Research Library in Atlanta, GA. The Herndon Home Museum houses the ALIC photographic collection, th e Herndon family papers, and interview transcripts of family members, former ALIC employees, and other individuals related to the family or the company. Owned and operated by the Alonzo F. and Norris B. Herndon Foundation, (a charitable trust) the 1910 mansion seeks to tell a story to a large and diverse audience through tours, exhibits, special events, pub lications, school programs, and other projects (www.herndonhome.org) During my employment from 20032004, the museum opened five days a week with fr ee admission. A few months before I left for graduate school, the museum began charging $3 for students and $5 for adults. After its first transition of directors, the muse um began opening on Tuesday and Thursdays, from 9 am5 pm, and by appointment only, w ith two staff members and a few volunteers to assist for special events or large tours. Throughout the transitions of new directors and the museums temporary closing and re-openi ng, the board continuously rehired the same two staff members who had been working for th e home since the departure of the initial director. After the most recent transition, it is uncertain of museum hours and daily operations. Herndon Home Museum politics & the Unexpected I thought that my previous employment w ith the museum would at least provide the opportunity to gain rapid access to move forward in conduct archival research.
84 However, this was not the case. The departur e of the director of the museum and its temporary closing posed many challenges. Wit hout my supervisor (g atekeeper), and with the museums closing, I could no longer us e the museum and its archives for my dissertation research freely. This resulted in the direct contact with museum board members. Although I was a former employee, most board members were not familiar with my previous employment and dissertati on research. I had to therefore re-establish relationships. I was an outsider all over again. Before traveling to Atlanta, I sent letters to the Chairman of the Herndon Foundation, presiden t and CEO at that time of Atlanta Life Financial Group, and lead archivist of the Auburn Avenue Research Library (which houses the Atlanta Life historical document s), to express my interest in conducting research on Atlanta Life and the use of res ources and space at the museum and the library for archival research. To conduct archival research, I had to rea ssure board members of my intentions at the Herndon Home. There was a lot of media attention questioning the decisions of the leadership of the museum, and the board wa s adamant about the proper presentation of the museum. Therefore, I had to tread very carefully, informing board members in advance through email, phone calls, and letters, of my visits to Atlanta and the museum, documenting every action and requests to c onduct archival resear ch; whether through signing in at the museum, informing staff of what documents I used for research, and how many hours I planned to conduc t research at the museum. It was extremely difficult to ask permi ssion for the usage of collections, one of which I created and developed myself. As an archivist and the developer of the Photographic Collection, I felt a sense of ownership. I spent an entire year creating the
85 collection. It was at my discre tion to create titles of seri es and folders for the photos. Therefore, I became an expert in this area of the visual imagery of the Atlanta Life. In the development process, I decided how a nd which images should be grouped. Grouping images based on various titles, such as: bui ldings, employees, groups, and events, this categorization process impacted the presentation of history. I played a major role in the preservation and presentation the African American business through imagery. Through categorization, I manipulated how Atlanta Life would be presented, in a structure that packaged the company hierarchal, socially, and economically. For instance, the first series consisted of Atlanta Life employees with the first folders comprising of Atlanta Life officers. Although the Photographic Collection enabled me to understand many aspects of the company, it was through my categoriz ation, that I was able to focus on those social and cultural aspects of the company. At one point, there was also uncertainty of the time of the re-opening of the museum. Without any staff members to ove rsee its maintenance and upkeep, due to transitions, the museum suffered major wate r damage, requiring massive renovations. In 2006, the board hired a temporary director to oversee their holiday ev ent Christmas at Diamond Hill. After the event ended the direct ors contract ended. The next year, in 2007, Herndon descendent, Anne Simmons, b ecame the interim director. The new director was a former Atlanta Life employ ee, a former board member, and well known in the Atlanta black business and so cial circuit. This was a gr eat opportunity to enhance my research. However, she was unfamiliar with procedures of museum management, the archives, and preservation of the collections in the museum.
86 After I repeatedly turned down offers by the new director to take over her position at the museum, I continued with the research. The new director and I were able to work together. Sometimes, I volunteered at the muse um and in turn, she allowed me to conduct archival research with liberty. Unfortunate ly, the new interim di rector was battling a debilitating illness; months later, she pa ssed away. Her death was devastating to me personally and professionally. Not only did I lose my museum connection to continue my research, I lost a close friend. Although the museum board at this point knew of my intentions, I still lost my direct contact and freedom to conduct research. In April 2008, the board hired a new director, Linda Richards Again, I had to re-e stablish relationships, informing the fourth new director of the goals and intent of my re search. Fortunately, I met Ms. Richards, a former volunteer, at the museum through Ms. Simmons during a prior visit. From this relationship, I was able to frequent the home with less hassle. In the data collection process, I spent tim e at the museum reviewing transcripts of past interviews of AL IC employees conducted by the first former director of the museum, the Herndon family papers that relate to th e ALIC, any other information related to the company and the ALIC Photogra phic collection,. I particularly examined collection series of ALIC employees and events such as partie s, conferences, and activ ities. Archival data consisting of the photographic collection of ALIC transcripts of previous interviews of former employees, and historical records of the ALIC, and museum newsletters, provided a basis for knowledge about the social a nd cultural importance of the company, beyond its business aspects. I also assisted at th e Home whenever necessary, through locating images, files, and documents that the tw o staff members were unfamiliar with and
87 advised the museum staff on day-to-day ope rations and decisions with the museum board. Auburn Avenue Research Library The Auburn Avenue Research Library on African-American Culture and History is a Special Library of the A tlanta-Fulton County Library System It is the first library of its kind in the southeast offe ring specialized reference and archival collections for the study and research of African cultures. The library is a public facility with noncirculating collections, servic es, and programs, free and opens to the general public. As the nation's second largest archives specializi ng in the history of African Americans and Africans in Diaspora, the Auburn Research Li brary is dedicated to preserving African America's heritage by providing a home to th e manuscripts, photogra phs, oral histories, books, periodicals and works of art that cont ain the history of peoples, of nations, of beliefs and dreams, of a past worth sharing with the future (www.afplweb.com/aarl/index.html). The libra ry houses the ALIC records and other collections pertinent to my research. The lib rary provides collections in which I could review documents, using a finding aid, specifica lly related to my research interests to complement the ALIC photographic collec tion and other ALIC sources from the museum. At the library, I examined specific records related to the companys social events, activities and the Af rican American community. By reviewing ALIC archival data, I gain ed an understanding of the structure, function, and activities of the company and its impact on the city of Atlanta and the United States. I examined the ALIC records, dating from 1894-1994, which primarily documents the operation of the company, and the role it played in Atlanta's African-
88 American community. The record included offi cers' files; financial records; insurance policies and claims; Atlanta Life publications and printe d material; non Atlanta Life publications and printed materi al; and architectural drawings calendars, certificates and diplomas (www.dbs.galib.uga.edu). I conducted research at th e library to review the Atlanta Life documents dating back from 1900 to 1990s and newspaper articles about Atlanta Life from the two popular black newspa pers (particularly during the 50s-70s), the Atlanta Daily World and the A tlanta Inquirer; the latter wh ich was bought by Atlanta Life through its former president Jessie Hill. Since I was unable to spend as much time as I needed to conduct the archival research at the library due to my living in Tampa, I worked out a system with Library Research Associate, Wesley Chenault. Us ing the ALIC Records finding aid, I picked documents that I thought would be beneficial to my research and sent my requests via email. Again, I focused on documents relate d to the Civil Rights Movement, employee information, and ALIC events. Mr. Chenau lt would then pull, scan, and send those documents to me. We continued this proce ss based on my research needs and interests during the data analysis and writing process. The corres pondences between Mr. Chenault and me proved successful, for Mr. Chenault was a former employee and archivist for the Herndon Home, where he assi sted in processing and developing the ALIC records collection and finding aid as part of the NEH grant as well. Therefore, he was familiar enough with the collection to determine what I needed for my research. Archival Data and Interviews from Both Facilities I was able to accomplish a significant amount of archival data and interviews due to the location of the research sites needed to conduct the research. The Atlanta Life
89 building is directly across the street from the Auburn Avenue African American Research Library. I conducted many interviews with info rmants at the Atlanta Life building. Once I finished interviews for that day, I would si mply go across the street to conduct archival research at the library. I did not visit the Herndon Museum as often as I had hoped however, I was able to review some of the interview transcri pts of former Atlanta Life employees and affiliates conducted by the former museum dir ector, that I found interesting as well as scan some of the Atlanta Life photos that I thought would be benefici al to my dissertation research. The ALIC Photogra phic and Document Collection aided me tremendously in my research. These documents were a major source and guide to the development of my research questions for interviews. Ethno history The documents provided the essential data fo r historical studies of all types, just as ethnography provides essential data for a ll non-historical types of research. The Atlanta Life Collection are desc riptive materials about a single society at more than one point of time. Axtell (1979:2) defines ethnoh istory as, "the use of historical and ethnological methods to gain know ledge of the nature and caus es of change in a culture defined by ethnological con cepts and categories. Ethnohistory is carried on by ethnologists who have learned studies of living cultures in the field with the us e of documentary sources or the same or related peoples in the library (Fenton 1996:72). Historical documents cannot be taken simply as factual (Ember, Ember, & Peregrine 2005:250; Euler 1972: 202), for different types of people with different goals and purposes wrote th em (Ember, Ember, & Peregrine 2005:250).
90 They must be analyzed in terms of cultu ral dynamics and in categories of modern ethnographic field investigation (Euler 1972: 202). Nevertheless, history does not belong only to its narrators, pr ofessionals, or amateur. While some of us debate what history is or was, othe rs take it in their own hands (Trouillot 1995:153). For this research, I examined the recollec tion of the past and analyzed dominant narratives, interpretations, and how individuals see their own experiences (Striffler 2002), reviewing peoples recollection of the company. As a critique on oral history, I review how past experiences sh ape certain things (Trouillot 1995). I used oral history to conduct ethnohistories. My contributions to this t opic and anthropology was to examine the voices of Atlanta Life and museum employees, that included those other than leaders and officers of the company, but women and those voices who have not been heard or read about in text books. Although prior work ha s been done on this subject (Henderson, 1991, Merritt, 2004), I hoped to enhance this re search to add to the models of African American business with the emergence of change in African American communities seen through the company and employees experience s. History needs to be anthropologized that includes the voice of the people (Yelvi ngton 2009). I looked at how experiences are always structured and how people remember things with their own perspectives (Scott 1991). Preserving the archives One of my initial applic able goals and contributi ons to the Herndon Home museum was to transfer the ALIC Phot ographic Collection to the Auburn Avenue Research Library to accompany the ALIC Do cuments and Manuscripts Collection. With the support of the head archivist at the library, we both wr ote letters to the museum board
91 chair to request this tran sition. However, nothing came of this, and the Photographic Collection is still housed at the museum. Partl y, this dissertation research was intended to help preserve an invaluable archive of artifacts and photos for future generations as a contribution to the preservation of history. My second plan was to s ecure assistance and resources to copy and scan images of th e ALIC Photographic Collection and Herndon family collection into a digi tal collection for preservation. This would have provided an electronic copy of the collecti on and enable the preservation of a rich and valuable collection for further research. These photos would also provide data on issues of interest in the research design and a c onvenient archive for my own anal ysis of the impact of the company over the past century. Therefore, during my visits to the museum, it was important to inform the new director of the value of the collection and the necessity of developing the digital collec tion. Fortunately, the director agreed and supported my goals. As a result, she formally presented my research ideas at a museum board meeting. The board supported some of my ideas. During my visits at the museum, I scanned the ALIC photographs, downloaded, and saved the im ages in files for preservation purposes for the museum and my own research intere sts. However, these ideas of scanning the ALIC collection did not come in to fruition due to my own fina ncial difficulties to travel continuously to Atlanta. In addition, ther e was never a discussion about how and who would finance the digital proces s and collection. The digital collection was tabled. I only scan photos related to my research. I conti nued visiting and volunteeri ng at the museum. Participant Observation Munck and Sobo (1998:259), define partic ipant observation as Fieldwork in which the researcher obtains da ta through a long term period of participating in the lives
92 of the people he or she is studying and obs erving their behavior. The research relinquishes experimental control over th e flow of data (Munck and Sobo 1998). According to Bernard, all participant obser vation is field work, or ethnographic fieldwork, which is the foundation of anthropology (1995:136). Participant observation is not simply a ma tter of living in close proximity to the people one wants to study. It is not just the collection of data, but a way of thinking about the people from whom one coll ects those data (Tierney 2002). Participant observation at contemporary ALIC events revealed if the company still provided a space for shared identity and economic cooperation, and if th e company still played a large role in strengthening the community. Occasionally A tlanta Life Financial Group hosts major events. Through contacts with Atlanta Life employees, newsle tters, and advertisements, I attended some ALIC-related events. Theref ore, the final fieldwork setting varied, depending upon the location of ALFG local ev ents. However, due to my location, I was only able to attend a few events to conduct particip ant observation. My first observation began in July 2005. From June to September the company hosted various events and activities to commemorate the success and legacy of Atlanta Life Insurance Company celebra ting their 100th anniversary. I a ttended an opera concert, the Atlanta Life Employee reun ion, and returned in Septem ber to attend the centennial gala. Amongst those at the gala were dignitaries such as civil rights activists Andrew Young and the sister of Dr. Martin Luth er King, Dr. Christine King Farris. I was also able to observe daily oper ations and events at the Herndon Home museum. During my visits, I observed staffs da ily routines, interactions with customers for tours and purchases, opening and closing of the museum and challenges staff faced to
93 properly, preserve the museum. Each year the Herndon Home Museum hosts Christmas at Diamond Hill. At this event, the museum hosts different events for the community from December to January, such as Kwan zaa Day, Family Day and the Decorator Show house. However the main event for the muse um and similar to many other events, was the Gala Reception and Silent Auction. This consists of museum supporters and friends with food and a silent auction where bi dding reaching $200-300. Celebrities like R&B singer, Jennifer Holiday have attended in the past. I volunteered as a tour guide, monitoring rooms throughout the home, and assi sted patrons with purchases. The silent auction in particular, enabled me to observe the types of individuals in attendance; those affiliated with the insurance company and muse um representing the upper/middle class. Bernard (1995:140) identifie s the reasons for rendering participant observation by listing five ideas. Bernard found that it, Makes it possible to collec t different kinds of data; it reduces the problem of reactivity; it helps you formulate sensible questions; it gives you an intuitive understanding of what is going on in a cu lture that allows you to speak with confidence about the meaning of data; and many research problems cannot be addressed adequately by anything except participant observation. However, the key advantage of partic ipant observation, according to de Munck and Sobo, is that it provides access to the back stage arenas of social life (de Munck and Sobo 1998). I was able to have a back stag e pass to the Atlanta Life and museum world. Nevertheless, participant observa tion also has it challenges. Participant observation lacks a systematic sampling proced ure. It frequently relies on information provided by one or two key informants. Ho wever, in my case my one or two key informants were either fired, passed away, or did not reveal extensive information for my research. Flick (1998) found that another pr oblem for the research er in participant
94 observation is defining a role for the observer which he or she can take, and allow him or her to stay in the field or at its ed ge and observe it at the same time. Since I was no longer an employee of the museum, it was difficult to define my role at the museum during my observa tion. I often volunteere d, which sometimes prevented thorough observation and note taking. I had to take field notes at the end of each day. Overall, participant observation is central to identifying and building relationships important to the research endeavor. Interviews In the summer of 2007, the department of Sociology and Anthropology hired me as a temporary instructor for Agnes Scott College in Decatur, GA to teach two courses for the fall semester, Intro to Cultural Anthropology and Research Methods for a professor on paternity leave for the first two months of the semester. I thought that this was a great opportunity to conduct re search and gain experience. Unfortunately, my teaching schedule took more time than expected; my classes fell on the same days as museum hours, and my free time that I anticipated for research and interviews, became occupied with grading papers and tests, and reading. Therefore, any time that I did have, I established contac ts with possible interviewees. The last few weeks of my time in Atlanta resulted in acquiring three interviews with former employees of the company. While in Atlanta, I relentlessly attempte d contacting the CEO of the Atlanta Life Financial Group to establish rapport and a po ssible interview. When I finally met with him to discuss my research and the importan ce of preserving the history of the company, he was very supportive of my efforts and agr eed to an interview. Regrettably, due to
95 complications from a surgical procedure in spring of 2008, the CEO passed away. I did not have an opportunity to in terview him. His loss was a nother setback; his support was vital to my research and ra pport with current Atlanta Life employees. After the CEOs passing and the retirement of a current employee, I had to re-establish relationships, like a researcher at the beginning stages of rese arch. I had to send emails, write letters to Atlanta Life board members, inform the comp any of my goals, and schedule meetings to discuss my research. In the fall 2008, I traveled back to Atla nta to continue my dissertation research. Two weeks before my arrival, I contacted a former co-worker at the Herndon Home Museum, to obtain any names of former and current Atlanta Life employees for potential interviews. She gave me a few names and I contacted individuals and informed them about research, my intentions, and possibly m eeting with them for an interview. A week before I arrived in Atlanta, I set up three interviews and through snow balling, was given additional contact information of other poten tial interviewees to follow-up with upon my arrival. At the introductory meeting with A tlanta Life current employees and affiliates, individuals introduced themselves and gave a brief summary of their role and experiences at Atlanta Life. After explaining my goals to the group, the Atlanta Life leadership formally supported my efforts. My final trip to collect research data in July 2009 resulted in interviewing two former museum employees, collecting archiv al data at the museum and library, and observation of the museums fourth3 change in leadership and the operation of the museum. I observed how staff and volunteers faced challenges in understanding museum 3 Since 2005, the Herndon museum has had four directors to operate the museum.
96 board decisions, volunteers and staff, comp rehension of these decisions, and museum daily operations during this time, while ob taining and scheduling more interviews. Oral History Accompanying photos and documents, and observation, there were narratives and stories. Oral History can be a means for transforming both the content and the purpose of history. It can be used to change the fo cus of history itself, and open up new areas of inquiry (Thompson 2000:1). Nevertheless, stor ies of the past are told by means other than pen and paper (Yelvington 2002). With in ethnography, oral history has been a method of anthropology and many other di sciplines. Murphy writes (1978:113), For anthropologists, studying oral literatu re is a way of inve stigating culture and social organization. As with other speech, people use oral literature to express their ideas, beliefs, and values, and negotiate through their net of social relationships. The essential task is to understand the relationship between this form of speech and its communi cative place in social life. Creswell (1998:49) defines oral history as An approach in which the researcher gathers personal recollections of events, thei r causes, and their effects from an individual or several individuals. This information ma y be collected through tape recordings or through written works of individuals who ha ve died or still living (Creswell 1998). In The Voice of the Past: Oral Histor y, Paul Thompson (2000:25) describes oral history as the first kind of history, and it is only quite recently that skill in handling oral evidence has ceased to be one the marks of the great historian. Oral history interviews can bring history to life. These memories co uld be lost to future generations without efforts. Yelvington (2002: 234) focuses on those who tell stor ies by stating, Oral tradition reflects the interest of the rememberers. In Shirc liffes (2001) article on oral histories of former students and teachers of Blake and Middleton High Schools in Tampa,
97 she discusses nostalgia functions in oral history as a moral tale in which individuals invoke past memories. Likewise, Trouillout (199 5) identifies, how history reveals itself only through the production of specific narratives What is important is the process and conditions of production of such narr atives. Lewis suggests (1996:136), Because most memories start as indivi dual recollections, then through a process of socialized learning they become attach ed to a group or national perspectives, it is imperative that we interrogate those me mories with a fresh attention to what they say as well as what they do not sa y. As we do so, we must take care to analyze how our memories rewrite the e xperience we document, describe, and analyze. One challenge in oral history is what Dunaway (1984) describes how many oral historians and ethnographers have little time to speculate on wh at users encounter as they sit down at their desks to make sense of the transcripts. In terpreting and documenting the oral history or life of an i ndividual can present many difficu lties. Another challenge in oral history is that it entails ideas of memo ry: forgotten, remembered, and left out. If for example, individuals are high status, they ha ve an easier time converting their traditions into public traditions that justify particular constellations of power, some historians have sought to differentiate between myth and hist ory by evaluating oral history against other evidence (Yelvington 2002:234). Yelvington (2002:237) adds, Memory is embodied, but it is the embodied in a person actively engaged in constructing (embodied) selfhood with reference to its unique past. Furtherm ore, according to Shackel (2001: 656) on the relationship of memory and power, Public memory is more a reflection of presen t political and social relations than a true reconstruction of the past. As memories change, so will the past. As present conditions change socially, politically, a nd ideologically, the collective me mory of the past will also
98 change. Individuals and groups often struggle over the meaning of memory as the power elite impose the official memory. Lowenthal (1985: xxii) desc ribes how individuals chose which items and stories are most important in time. He states, The pa st itself is gone all that survives are its material residues and the accounts of those who experienced it. No such evidence can tell us about the past with abso lute certainty, for its survivals on the ground, in books, and in our heads are selectively preserved from the start and further altered by the passage of time. Ruffins (1992:512) discus ses oral history in conjuncti on with African Americans, in that they have developed various narrative versions of the past. According to Ruffins, these narratives can be called interior, in th e sense that African Americans created them about their own experience. Ones own experience related to what Hirsch and Stewarts (2005:262) concept of historicity describing a human situation flow, where versions of the past and future assume presen t form in relation to events, political needs, available cultural forms, and emotional dispositions. Informant Types I had initially planned to conduct twenty interviews with five past policy owners of Atlanta Life, ten former employees, and five current employees. Uncertain of my travel to Atlanta and limited time and finan ces, I cut the interview number down to ten. However, in the end, I did interview a total of twenty individuals associated with Atlanta Life and/or the Herndon Home museum, in terviewing eight former employees, six current employees, two Atlanta Life affiliate s connected to the Civil Rights Movement, one Atlanta resident, one Atlanta Life po licy owner, and two former museum staff members.
99 Using open-ended, semi-structured ques tions, I conducted in terviews using a protocol of questions, audio ta ping, transcribing, sorting, and analyzing the content of the interviews by investigating any themes ba sed on the interview questions. I conducted the interviews varying in length from forty-fi ve minutes to an hour and a half. The openended interviews were not limited to questions on the protocol. The topics were based on the informants comfort level, time schedul e, and knowledge of the topics. For my research on Atlanta Life, I conducted in-dept h, semi-structured interviews with former and current employees, and individuals re lated to the company. I hoped to reveal descriptions of employees ev eryday interactions within the company and the African American community, socially and cultura lly. I decided to co nduct interviews to understand employees, residents, policy owne rs, and affiliates experiences at the company and the museum. The interviews assisted in understanding the companys outreach to the community through its institu tional development, and social activities within and outside the company (Merritt 2002). Former Atlanta Life Employees I interviewed eight former employees, all between the ages of sixty and eighty; four women and four men. Near ly all of the former employees worked for the company for at least 30 years. I was particularly inte rested in former employ ees fifty years old or older, who were employed with Atlanta Life during the segregati on period. I wanted to find out what it meant for employees to work for the company and their impact on the African American community during Jim Crow Some of the former employees worked in different Atlanta Life br anches throughout the country, an d others spent their entire Atlanta Life career at the home office in Atlant a. Most of the inte rviews took place at the
100 informants home due to ailments, age, and l ack of transportation, while other interviews occurred at informants place of employment. Current Atlanta Life Employees I also interviewed six current employees with the Atlanta Life Financial Group; four women and two men. These current employ ees ranged in age from forty-five to sixty-five. Three out of the five employees wo rked for Atlanta Life for thirty years, and two began working at the company in between 1990s and 2000. I wanted to get a current perspective on the company to compare w ith former employees perspectives and experiences. All of the current employee interv iews occurred at the Atlanta Life building in the cafeteria or their offices. Affiliates with the company I interviewed two individuals associated with Atlanta Life through the companys financial and professional support during the Civil Rights movement, to determine Atlanta Lifes impact and influence on the Civil Rights Movement through the eyes of Civil Rights activists who expe rienced these events. I also interviewed a policy owner, and one Atlanta resident familiar with the company. For policy owners, I was curious about the process or procedur e in obtaining a policy and if these procedures changed through time, and examine the interactions between policy owners and the company today. I hoped that interviewi ng an Atlanta resident, not nece ssarily affiliated with the company, and would give me an outside pers pective of the company. These interviews took place at the informants place of empl oyment or the Atlanta Life building.
101 Former museum employees In the last phase of my qualitative re search, I interviewed two former museum employees to understand their experiences wo rking for the museum, what the possibility of the museum closing means for memories and heritage, and how they felt about those who have now passed who were represented at the museum. Informants and Participants I did not interview some key informan ts (using a pseudonym) but they shared experiences about the museum and the company, which were valuable in this research process. I did not conduct a full interview with Barbara Ho ward, a former Atlanta Life Clerk, over the age of 65; or Ralph Lenton, co llege professor, 45 to 54; however they provided information for the dissertation. Basic demographic information about the twenty participants that I selected is desc ribed in Table 1 (pseudonyms are used for most participants). As stated earlier, many of the participants were selected based upon the number of years employed with the compa ny. I wanted to conduc t interviews with participants who experienced life and em ployment during the Jim Crow Era, the transition of the desegregation period, and post-desegregation. Other participants were employed at the Herndon Home museum, or were affiliates and policy owners of Atlanta Life.
102 Table 1: Demographics of Study Participants Name Age Range Company Role Employment Evonne Night 65 and Over Atlanta Life Management Former Charles Black **4 65 and Over Atlanta Life Affiliate Affiliate Evelyn Amos 65 and Over Atlanta Life Clerk Former Oliver Nelson 65 and Over Atlanta Life Management Former Linda Richards 22 to 34 Herndon Museum Employee Former Lynn Ocean 65 and Over Atlanta Life Clerk Former Helen Franklin 65 and Over Atlanta Life Clerk/Supervisor Former Edward Lyons 65 and Over Atlanta Life Management Former Lonnie King** 65 and Over Atlanta Life Affiliate Affiliate David Osborne 65 and Over Atlanta Life Management Former Carol Edwards 45 to 54 Atlanta Life Management Current Elaine Robinson 55 to 64 Atlanta Life Resident Current Edith Linton 55 to 64 Atlanta Life Policy Owner Policy Owner Rita Lowe 35 to 44 Herndon Home Employee Former Ira Thomas 55 to 64 Atlanta Life Employee Current Oscar Anderson 55 to 64 Atlanta Life Employee Current Elena Sutton 45 to 54 Atlanta Life Employee Current Alice Allen 55 to 64 Atlanta Life Employee Current Harriet Adams 65 and Over Atlanta Life Clerk Former Lois Nichols 55 to 64 Atlanta Life Resident Resident 4 Stared are the names of participants in without pseudonyms.
103 Analysis and Interpretation I originally planned to transcribe all interviews, but due to time and financial difficulties, I transcribed the first three interviews, and then decided to take notes and highlight pertinent information to answering my research questions. I initially began with five research questions. I divide d my five research questions into files, sorted through the data from the transcripts and notes of in formants, and placed quotes and information about informants in the files that would answ er the questions. I eliminated two questions and expanded one of the questions into two. From the interviews, I looked for statemen ts that answered my questions as well as revealing new information about what the company meant to individuals and the African American community, and what the preservation and future of the museum meant to employees. I attempted to align the informants data with archival data to validate the research. For Atlanta Life empl oyees, I analyzed and compared the process of how Atlanta life prepared employees for business; the operation of the company within; the individual journey of the employees into ALIC; their growth and production of their identity within the company; what it meant for them to work for such a prestigious and renowned company. Reciprocity and Ethical Considerations Since the dissertation was not funded, informants were not compensated for their time; they shared experiences. However, all of the informants were willing to share their stories and experiences without any compen sation. Each individual would be provided with a CD of his or her interview to keep for their personal records. Atlanta Life Financial Group will be provided with a copy of this dissertation as well. Informants
104 participation in the dissertation project was ke pt strictly confidential. Each participant was given a pseudonym used on all documents in place of their names. One major concern in this entire rese arch process was the possibility of detachment from the research. Since there were so many changes and challenges in the research (funding, informants leaving or passi ng away, politics, and lack of motivation), an entire year went by before traveling back to Atlanta. Although I tried to stay in touch with key informants, my lack of presence in Atlanta prevented me fr om attending Atlanta Life events, the day-to-day operations of the museum, and conducting interviews and possible follow-up interviews with informants Therefore, I was concerned that I would not have presentable research and findings. A primary ethical concern was my own bias. Since I did work for the Herndon Home museum, I felt that I came into the research with knowledge and views about the museum board and the company. When major changes and transitions took place at the museum, with the articles in the Atlant a Journal Constitution coming out about the museums pending future, I was upset and disa ppointed. Since I have such high personal interests and concern for the pr eservation of the home and its archives, I was afraid that my personal views might get in the way of the how I developed my research questions regarding the museum and went about conducting research. Another ethical concern was presenting the company and the museum properly. Atlanta Life impacted the country in treme ndous ways, and I did not in any way want to tarnish the companys name by presenting th e company negatively. However, I struggled with making sure I was honest and presented the truth about my findi ngs; particularly, the data that I collected from the interviews w ith former employees. I also struggled with
105 presenting my findings about the museum, its politics, and museum-related informants. Due to past conflicts and lega l issues, I did not want to cau se anyone to have legal action taken against them, or termination based on th eir interviews. However, again I wanted to be sure I was truthful about what I f ound in my research and findings. Despite all of these issues, I wanted to present a thorough story of the experiences, history, and findings about Atlanta Life and the museum. I wanted to tell the story of black achievement through Alonz o Herndons founding of a company and revealing his success through a mansion that should be preserved so that future generations would know the legacy of African American success.
106 SETTINGS:A HUMBLE JOURNEY TO SUCCESS Atlanta: The City of Opportunity When I decided to move to Atlanta in spring 2000 for graduate school, there was a sense of fear and excitement. I compared Atlanta to New York. Growing up in a very small town, I wondered how I could manage living in a city as big as Atlanta. But, this was not New York; it was still the south, with such a unique past, and a famous present. Many African Americans call Atlanta the Choc olate City, the Black Mecca, and the City with opportunities for Bl ack people. The city is known for its established African American community and elite; so much s o, that by 1940, Atlanta had by far the most extensive and accomplished black community le adership in Georgia (Tuck 2001: 56), and by 1970, African Americans constituted a majority of Atlantas population for the first time in history (Rutheiser 1996:62). However, Atlantas history is one of trag edy, and racism as well as civil rights, achievement, success, and change. Home of the 1996 Summer Olympics, and five historically black colleges, Atlanta is a city of complexity and im agination. In his book Imagineering Atlanta: The Politics of Place in the City of Dreams, cultural anthropologist Charles Rutheiser (1996:3) de scribes Atlanta as a metropolitan area that promotes the idea of the New New South not only good for business, but hospitable, progressive, racially harmonious and owing almost exclusivel y to the efforts of native son Martin Luther King, Jr., the cradle of the modern human rights movement.
107 However, Rutheiser adds (1996) that Atlanta is also one of the poores t and most racially segregated central cities in the United Stat es. This is a clear reminder, that despite Atlantas place of opportunity, it is the s outh. The 1906 Atlanta Race Riot constituted a major blow to the myth of racial harmony spun by both white and black proponents of the New South Creed (Rutheiser 1996:33). Racial History Atlanta Race Riots of 1906 From September 22-24, 1906, white mobs killed many African Americans, wounded others, and inflicted considerable property damage (New Georgia Encyclopedia 2005) in the citys Af rican American community and businesses. Their homes and businesses were destroyed as white mobs carried out senseless acts of fury and terrorism (Henderson 1990:49). This fury may have resulted from population growth, white fear of interactions with Blacks, and their success. In the 1880s, Atlanta had become the hub of the regional economy, and the city's overall population soared from 89,000 in 1900 to 150,000 in 1910; the black population was approximately 9,000 in 1880 and 35,000 by 1900. Such growth put pressure on municipal services, increased job competition among black and white workers, he ightened class distinctions, and led the city's white leadership to respond with restric tions intended to cont rol the daily behavior of the growing working class, with mixe d success. Such conditions caused concern among elite whites, who feared the social intermingling of the races. (New Georgia Encyclopedia 2005).
108 This fear led to an expansion of Jim Cr ow segregation, separating white and black neighborhoods and seating areas for public transportation (New Georgia Encyclopedia 2005). In addition, the emergence of the black el ite in Atlanta also co ntributed to racial tensions in the city. During Reconstruc tion from 1867-76, Black men were given the right to vote. During this time, Blacks became more involved in the political realm, establishing businesses, creating social networks, and building communities. Many whites were uncomfortable with the adva nces of the black elite (New Georgia Encyclopedia 2005). Unfortunately, Alonzo Herndon, owner of three barbershops and new owner of Atlanta Life, was caught in the middle this violence. One of Herndons glass windows of his barbershop was destroyed (Henderson 1990). Some of the victims of the riot were Black barbers, believed by many, due to envy by white businessmen and barbers. According to Merritt (2002:86), It was no accident that the fi rst battle of a race war was waged on Decatur Street, a couple of blocks from Peachtree. The area was Black turf, where boardinghouses, barbershops, restaura nts, and saloons, some owned by Blacks. By the end of the riots, although disputed by its low number, twenty-five Blacks and one white person died. However, there were ma ny blacks and whites inju red (Merritt 2002). Auburn Avenue After the riot, race-based zoning and othe r more informal means were used to enforce residential and commercial segregati on, and Decatur Street remained the center of African American retail and working cla ss entertainment, but the more successful black entrepreneurs concentrated themselves in a segregated busine ss district east of downtown and two blocks north of Decatur Street on Auburn Avenue (Rutheiser
109 1996:33). Referred to as Sweet Auburn, Auburn Avenue was known as the richest Negro Street in the World (Rutheiser 1996:33). It was considered sweet because money was sweet, and by 1945 the black-owned businesses of Atlanta had a combined worth nearing $30 million (Kruse 2005:28). Auburn Avenue was the headquarters for black-own banks, insurance companies and in 1932, the nations only black daily newspaper, the Atlanta Daily World (Rutheis er 1996:33). The concentration of black capital in Sweet Auburn helped to define th e entrepreneurial Black elite (Rutheiser 1996). Historically Black Colleges The black business elite of Atlanta connect to the citys historically black colleges known today as the Atlanta University Center The AU Center consists of: Clark Atlanta University, Morris Brown College, Interdenom inational Theological Seminary, Spelman College, and Morehouse College. The Black Me cca is attributed to the success of the citys native-born black middle class and the prospects afforded to educated African Americans around the country (Rutheiser 1996: 62). Rutheiser (1996:63) adds that in the Atlanta University area Roughly a quarter of the schools graduates stayed in the area following graduation and, through associ ations like the 100 Black Men, helped constitute a close kn it network of contacts and references. The Atlanta University Center is considered the largest group of historically African-American educational institutions in the country. It was or ganized in 1929 when three schoolsAtlanta University, charte red in 1867, Morehouse College, chartered, 1867, and Spelman College chartered in 1881, b ecame affiliated in a university plan. Atlanta University was to be devoted exclus ively to graduate edu cation, with the other two colleges providing undergraduate progr ams (Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia
110 2007). Later Clark College, chartered in 1877, Interdenominational Theological Center (1958), Morehouse School of Medicine (1982) and Morris Brown College (1885) also joined the university center's affiliation ag reement. In 1988, Clark College and Atlanta University merged to form Clark Atlanta Univ ersity, which is still part of the university center (Columbia Electroni c Encyclopedia 2007). Robert Boyd (2007:545), in his examin ation of the association between historically black colleges a nd universities (HBCU) and th e black business elite, found that HBCUs have a tradition of contributing to the membership of the business elite, especially in the south. He (2007:545) adds, Such institutions continue to be pathways into this select group of entr epreneurs HBCUs have produced a leadership class that has been instrumental to the social and economic progress of blacks as a group. These historically black colleges played major roles in the lives of Black elite and leadership in Atlanta. Many Atlanta University graduates made major contributions in the city of Atlanta to various fields: e ducation, law, religion, governme nt, civil service, social services, business, and the arts (Henderson 1990: 69). In addition, the survival and maintenance of some of these colleges are attributed to Alonzo Herndon and Atlanta Life. Atlanta Life Background and History Alonzo Herndon: From Slave to Barber The Atlanta Life Insurance Company was an institution of triumph, resilience, community uplift, prosperity, and success. Th ese characteristics mirror the life of Alonzo F. Herndon, its founder. Born a slave in So cial Circle, Georgia on June 26, 1858, Alonzo Herndons story began in the most unlikely way (Merritt 2002; Henderson, 1990; Stuart 1940). Born on a slave plantation in Walt on County, forty miles south of Atlanta,
111 Alonzos father, Frank Herndon was a white slav e master. Alonzos birth resulted from a typical encounter between a slave owner and his property, Alonzos mother, Sophenie Herndon. Alonzo did not receive any special treat ment, as the son of a slave-owner, for after emancipation, at the age of seven, Frank Herndon sent Al onzo, his mother and brother off the plantation. They eventually re turned to the plantation, as Herndon (Merritt 2002:6) states in his autobiogra phy, Our former master finally allowed us to take shelter in a one room log cabin with four other families. The family, like many other slaves, struggled to survive and worked as field la borers to earn money. His mother received as pay potatoes, molasses, and peas enough to keep them from starving (Merritt 2002). Alonzo worked as a sharecropper and remained in Social Circle until age twenty. Leaving the small town with just $11, and one year of formal education, Alonzo set out to improve his life, settling in Jonesboro, Georgi a, a suburb of Atlanta, where he learned the barbering trade and eventually opened up a barbershop (Ingham and Feldman 1994; Merritt 2002). Determined to succeed, Alonzo moved to Atlanta, Georgia in 1882, continuing his barbering business. At one time, he owned three barbershops with seventy-five black barbers (Walker 1998). Herndon ran the most prestigious barbershops in Atlanta. Although he served only white clients due to Ji m Crow laws, with all Black barbers, he used the segregated market to his adva ntage, with quality service (Merritt 2002). According to Merritt, in her descripti on of Herndons position during the Jim Crow period (2002:69), He would engage two worl ds of business, two separate markets, turning the deep and constant racial divide to his own advantage. Herndons shops were those of elegance, pr estige, and style. However, his most
112 elaborate and largest barbershop he opened was the Crystal Palace at 66 Peachtree in downtown Atlanta in 1902. Th rough his travels throughout Europe, Herndon decorated the barbershop with crystal chandeliers, gilt-framed mirrors and fittings, massive sixteenfoot front doors of solid mahogany, and beveled pl ate glass copied from his trips to Paris (Ingham and Feldman 1994:324). Herndons succ esses in the barbershops led to the beginnings of extreme wealth and prestige. He invested some of his earnings from the barbering business in real estate, acquiri ng some valuable property (Henderson 1990:24). By 1915, Alonzo Herndon owned one hundred rent al properties in the city (Merritt 2002). He was recognized as a viable lead er in the African American community (Ingham and Feldman 1994) and the city of Atlanta. Herndon Home Museum Alonzos visible display of wealth re sonated through the Herndons residence on 587 University Place NW, on the campus of Morris Brown College in the Atlanta University Center area, two m iles west of downtown Atlanta in the Vine City (Alonzo F. and Norris B. Herndon Foundation 2003). Designe d without any blueprints, by his wife Adrienne McNeil Herndon, an Atlanta Universi ty professor of elocution and actress, the Hendon mansion would have its own terraces o ffering views in all directions from both stories and the flat roof on top that could also serve as an open-air theater for Adriennes productions (Merritt 2002 :111). Built in 1910, by all Black craftsmen, the home is a two-story brick structure whose style is of B eaux Arts Classical. The home interior is a mix of styles from traditions of the Italia n Renaissance, French Rococo, American Arts and Crafts with mahogany paneling, oak parque t floorings, Venetian objects and beveled glass windows (Alonzo F. and Norris B. Herndon Foundation 2003)
113 Shortly after the completion of the home, Adrienne Herndon passed away, suffering from Addison disease. Adrienne He rndon was unable to enjoy her home. Yet, her son Norris Herndon ensured that his mothers memory continued.5 As a memorial to his father and to continue the familys philant hropy to protect the future of Atlanta Life and the mansion (Merritt 2002:213), Norris B. Herndon the only son of Alonzo and Adrienne, established the Alonzo F. a nd Norris B. Herndon Foundation in 1950. As a tribute to his mother, Norris designed the music room for her love for theater. The home is now a National Historical Landmark. This fifteen-room mansion tells the story of struggle and achievement (Alonzo F. and Norris B. Herndon Foundation 2003). Insurance Entrepreneurship: Atlanta Life Mutual Aid to Atlanta Life Insurance Company Five years before the completion of his home, Alonzo Herndon connected to an entrepreneurial insurance venture that enha nced the course of his life and impacted African Americans in the bus iness world and the community throughout the Southeastern region of the United States. The development of insurance and banks began toward the end of the nineteenth and at the beginning of the twentieth century (Lincoln and Mamiya 1990). Benevolent and burial associations were also an important economic base since many black funeral parlors and mortuaries gr ew out of them. By the nature of their function, all of the funeral parlors and mortuari es were also quasi-re ligious institutions with strong ties to church es (Lincoln and Mamiya 1990:246). Many poor people bought burial plans, paying 5 to 10 cents a week for burial insurance, which would assure them of a decent burial. The practice of segregated cemeteries in the North and the South and 5 Two years after Adriennes death, in 1912, Alonzo Herndon married Jessie Gillespie, a hairdresser from Chicago. Jessie was born in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
114 the difficulties of obtaining loans from wh ite lending agencies also led to the establishment of black cemetery associations and building and loan a ssociations (Lincoln and Mamiya 1990). The Atlanta Life Insurance Company st emmed from the Atlanta Benevolent and Protective Association, founded, and led by minist ers, Peter James Bryant, pastor of the Wheat Street Baptist Church in 1904. Atlant a Benevolent provided insurance where small organizations pooled their money for lifes unexpected. Each member paid five to twenty-five cents a week in dues in the event of sickness or death (Merritt 2002). The association was one of the numerous small se lf-help groups that had sprung up in African American church communities (Merritt 2002:76). Bryant and his assistant, James Arthur Hopkins was unable to raise money due to a newly passed Georgia Law which required mutual associations to deposit $5,000 with th e state to protect policy holders. It was Alonzo Herndons position of economic and soci al leadership in the black community that caught the attention of the two minister s. Hopkins wanted to prevent whites from taking over the firm, and both ministers, w ere determined it remained in AfricanAmerican hands (Ingham and Feldman 1994:325). Therefore, in 1904, for $140 Herndon purchased the small self-help associ ation known as the A tlanta Benevolent and Protective Association. The community saw buying Atlanta Benevolent as an act of philanthropy (Merritt 2002:78). In acquiring two other companies, the R oyal Mutual Insurance Company and the National Laborers' Protective Union, Herndon reorganized the three companies as the Atlanta Mutual (Henderson 1990). Herndon took over several small associations unable to comply with the Georgia law, reinsured several associations and organizations, and
115 changed their name to Atlanta Mutual, (Stu art 1970:120). As the second largest African American insurance company in the country, in 1910 the company had forty-two branch offices (Horton 2005). In 1922, Herndon increa sed the capital stock of the company by $100,000, and in the same year changed the companys name to Atlanta Life Insurance Company, authorizing to write all classes of life, and life-and disabi lity insurance from $10 to $100,000 (Stuart 1970:121). The company was originally located in a room in the Rucker Building, the first office building for African American's in Atlanta and owned by African American business owner Henry Rucker (Hamilton, 2002) on the corner of Auburn and Piedmont Avenues in downtown Atlanta (Henderson 1990:13; Stuart 1970: 120). The company began operations with an old fashion blind typewriter, two second hand desks, a table, half dozen old chairs (Merritt 2002:81) As the company grew, Herndon moved the company to 202 Auburn Avenue on the northeast corner of Bell Str eet. The new building was a three-story frame, the former Atlanta Loan and Trust Compa ny (Merritt 2002). It was remodeled in 1927, the same year of Herndons death. Alonzo Herndon ran the company for twen ty-two years. After Alonzos passing, his son, Norris Herndon succeeded as presid ent (Horton 2005). By the mid-1920s, there were at least twenty-eight branch offices in southeastern cities throughout Tennessee, Kentucky, Florida, Missouri, Kansas, and Texas (Henderson 1990). By 1968, the company had at least sixty-five branch offices which included Midweste rn states: Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio. Norris Herndon, ran the company from 1927 to 1973, until his retirement and the companys third president, Jessie Hill presided. Following Mr. Hills presidency, Don Royster presided as presid ent in 1992, then Charles Cornelius in 1996,
116 and the late Ronald D. Brown in 2004, pa ssed away in 2008. The companys board of directors named William A. Clement, previ ously the companys nonexecutive chairman, as interim president and CEO (Hughes 2008). Atlanta Life Tradition and Character In her historical documentation of A tlanta Life, Alexa Henderson found (1990: xi) that Alonzo Herndon combined personal bus iness acumen and a modest amount of capital to create the Atlanta Life Insuran ce Company. It was one of the largest Black businesses in the South during the Jim Crow era (Henderson 1990). Atlanta Life stemmed from the traditions of self-help and mutual aid that sustained African Americans (Henderson 1990:3). The mutual aid movement was a social investment. ALIC, like other mutual aid society-like businesses, charac terized socially responsible investing. The company represented the most effective fo rm of social and economic cooperation among African-Americans, and helped to promote comm unity interests and racial solidarity. In the mid20th century, Atlanta Life fostered revitalization in Black neighborhoods in Atlanta and other southern cities (Atlanta Life News Release6/23/2001) through the provision of home mortgages, civil rights, and other areas of community development (Henderson 1990). The company not only provided loans for th e establishment of African American businesses, churches, and homes, they also contributed to colleges to support and maintain local historically black educationa l institutions, being part ially responsible for the success of many African Americans and colleges in Atlanta. Alonzo and his son, Herndon contributed thousands of dollars to su pport and maintain local historically black educational institutions such as Spelman, Morehouse, Clark Atla nta, and Morris Brown
117 College. The companys involvement in race and community affairs was a commitment and involvement in everything of social significance (Henderson 1990). Although there were changes throughout the years facing the threat of decline from the depression, the civi l rights movement, desegreg ation, the companys progress continued throughout the 1960s, 70s and 80s. A ccording the Comparative Highlights a 1974 issue of the companys newsletter, the Vision it is reported the Atlanta Life acquired $74, 157, 593 of assets in 1969 and then increased to $86, 074, 462 worth of assets in 1974. Henderson (1990:205), states In the 1980s, even as the present leaders are concerned with the future probing new markets and new mergers, they are very mindful of the heritage and obligations of a race enterprise. The companys initiative was to improve its image in modern and effi cient methods and facilities, as well as new acquisitions additional life insurance co mpanies and noninsurance firms (Henderson 1990:204). Completed in 1980, the new office bu ilding, sits on the corner of Auburn Avenue and Courtland. According to Weems in hi s article (1994:5) on the decl ine of African American insurance companies in contemporary Amer ica, From 1962-1992, the number of African American insurers dropped from fifty to tw enty-three, a fifty-four percent decrease. Between these same years, the increase in bl ack insurance companies total assets lagged far behind figures for the i ndustry at large (Weems 1994:5) Weems argues that because of these decreases, African American firms have experienced significant staff reduction between the yeas of 1982-1992. However, Atla nta Life strengthened itself through mergers and acquisitions (Weems 1994:6) In 1985, Mammoth Life and Accident Insurance in Louisville, KY me rged with Atlanta Life, addi ng $28 million in assets and
118 approximately $5 million in premium to Atlanta Lifes operations and expanded the company to two states, Indiana and Wiscons in (Jet Magazine October 28, 1985). In 1989, while Atlanta Life had the smallest per centage of admitted assets in mortgage loans, its percentage of admitted assets in stocks and bonds exceeded that of the other top black firms (Weems 1996:121). In 1990, Atla nta Life purchased Chicago Metropolitan with assets reaching $231 million. The Chicago firm was demutualized and Atlanta Life purchased 100 percent of the stock for $750,000. Chicago Metropolitan was the nations sixth largest Black-controlled life insura nce company (Jet Magazine, December 17, 1990). However, Weems analysis on decrease of assets and African American firms staff reduction between the yeas of 1982-1992, re lates to Atlanta Life experiences of these reductions from downsizing in the early to mid-1990s. During this time, many pioneers and long-term employees retired, including 3rd president and CEO, Jessie Hill. Due to a decline in business, the first dow nsize in the early 1990s resulted in many branch offices closing, resulting in the ope ration of solely the home office (Robinson 2008). Atlanta Life suffered at least three downsizings. The last one occurred in late 1990s, early 2000. Atlanta Lifes customer serv ice was dispersed. In 1995, Atlanta Life contracted Liberty insurance, an outside company out of Greenville to conduct the customer service center, temporarily taking over claims, customer service, and premium accounting. Many Atlanta Life employees left the company, while the others who did stay, had to re-apply for positions, and went to the new company, Liberty, to maintain and manage Atlanta Lifes customer service. Eventually, Atlanta Life brought customer service back in, however; many employees w ho worked for the company for many years
119 retired, left for other opportunities, or were not rehired (Robinson 2008). Some employees worked for Liberty, and then eventu ally moved back to Atlanta Life (Sutton 2008). In the mid to early 1990s, there were three-hundred Atlanta Life employees; during 2000-2001, this dropped to less than two hundred. Atlanta Life Today Renamed as the Atlanta Life Financ ial Group (ALFG) in 2001, the insurance company today remains the leading African American stock-owned insurance company in the nation. The financial group is a privat ely owned financial services company that helps consumers, businesses and communities build and protect wealth. ALFG consists of three operating units : Atlanta Life Insurance Comp any, Atlanta Life Investment Advisors, and Jackson Securities. These compan ies provide a range of financial solutions to help individual and institutional customer s manage their insurance and investment needs. Confronting the challenges of a mo re competitive market, the company divested itself of its home insurance business in 2002. It was reorganized as a full-service financial company and was renamed Atlanta Life Fi nancial Group. The company operates in 17 states with more than $200 million in a ssets. The company has more than 2 million clients; $16 billion of life insu rance and it is the number one African American reinsurers of group life benefits (www.atlantalife.com). Atlanta Life Insurance Company provi des group life products to Fortune 500 companies and funding products to help consum ers preplan and prearra nge their funerals. Considered the flagship of Atlanta Li fe Financial Group, Atlanta Life Insurance Company is comprised of Group Reinsurance and Atlanta Life General Agency. Atlanta Life Insurance Company and its subsidiar y, Atlanta Life General Agency provides
120 insurance products to businesses and individu als. In 2004, the company created Pre-need insurance, and new product, named MemoirSM, which allows individuals and families to prearrange and pre-fund their funeral through par ticipating funeral firms in Georgia. With Memoir, the first of its kind funeral planning and funding product developed by a minority-owned insurance company, individual s and families can design a custom funeral experience that meets their specific financia l, cultural, spiritual, and emotional needs (Atlanta Life Press Release, 05-19-2004). Atlanta Life Investment Advisors portfolio products help instit utions and high net worth individuals build and protect wealth. Atlanta Life Investment Advisors was founded in 2001, with four investment produc ts: Large Cap US Growth, Large Cap US Value, Large Cap US Core, and Large Cap Core International (ww.atlantalife.com). Jackson Securities is a full service i nvestment bank that provides investment banking and brokerage services to institutiona l and retail clients throughout the United States. Established in 1987 by the late Mayn ard H. Jackson (former mayor), Atlanta Life Financial Group acquired Jackson Securities, where the transaction between the two firms created a comprehensive minority-owned financial services company integrating corporate reinsurance, asset management, a nd investment banking. Under the terms of the acquisition, Jackson Securities maintains its na me as an operating subsidiary of Atlanta Life Financial Group (www.atlantalife.com). One of the companys highlights occurred in June 2008, as Black Enterprise named Atlanta Life Financial Group its Fina ncial Services Company of the Year. The celebration was quelled just two short weeks la ter by the unexpected pa ssing of President and CEO, Ronald Brown. Atlanta Life Investme nt Advisors (ALIA) exceeded projections
121 and received $490 million in new assets in 2008. The Firm also leveraged both the manager-of manager and the direct funding program relationships. ALIA experienced growth with its external a ccounts closing the year of 2008 out with nearly 30 newly funded accounts. Annualized revenue closed out 2008 at over $3.7 million, a slight dip due to market turmoil. Jackson Securities (J S), in particular, was affected by the credit market crunch, but focused its market presence in Public and Corporate Finance. (Atlanta Life Annual Report 2008). Atlanta Life Continued Existence Although the company is still in existence, it currently has only a small staff of seventy employees, compared to at least two hundred and fifty employees in the past in the 1980s. Nevertheless, the companys resi lience through the many challenges of the previous two decades, confir ms Atlanta Lifes great legacy, perseverance, and determination throughout a very long history. Today most African American insurance companies no longer exist. Atlanta Lifes re silience and success re sults in what Weems describe as Atlanta Lifes tr adition. He links Atlanta Life (1991:121) to the historical tradition of prudent conservatism. Weems adds that Alonzo F. Herndon personified caution and stability. The stability that Herndon provided extended many years of success, wealth, and a positive impact on the African American community. Atlanta Life contributed to the community socially a nd economically, leaving a major impression on employees, the city of Atlanta a nd its residents, and the country.
122 RESULTS A: Role in Local Economy ALICs Role in the Development of th e Local Economy of the African American Community: Scholarship, Education, and Sponsorship This section of the chapter attempts to answer the question of what roles did Atlanta Life play in the development of the local economy, how ALIC employees, affiliates, and policy owners viewed the company, and the possible changes of the company during and after the desegregation pe riod. Atlanta Life discreetly contributed and maneuvered their way through American capitalistic society, en suring the economic productivity of the black comm unity indirectly and direc tly. Indirectly, Atlanta Life (was and still is) invested in the lives of the African Am erican community; contributing to the community through e ducation, scholarship and s ponsorship, and providing home and business loans. Scholarship Atlanta Life invested in the education of the African American community. Although Alonzo Herndon acquired only one ye ar of education, he supported and believed in the importance of education, in turn, mirroring the opera tion of his company. Alonzos son, Norris Herndons academic ach ievement, a graduate from Harvard University with a Masters degree in Busi ness Administration, also reflected Atlanta Lifes character, becoming a major suppor ter of scholarship and education, through financial assistance, whether for the Afri can American community or Atlanta Life employees. Norris Herndon connected with Mo rris Brown College, a historically black
123 college, following in his fathers footstep s, donating a vast am ount of money. (Adams 2008). Norris Herndon donated the land and money for the colleges football stadium in his fathers named, Herndon Stadium, (M erritt 2002). The Herndons also donated to the Carrie Steel Pitts Orphanage, and suppor ted a nursery for children. Former Atlanta Life employee, Harriet Adams, shared that du ring her employment with Atlanta Life, the company would financially a ssist parents for nursery sc hool, (2008) st ating, Some parents couldnt afford a nursery for their ch ildren, and they would pay so much money so where some parents could car ry their children to this nurse ry. This in turn would provide parents with childcare, enabling thos e parents to work to support their families financially. Education Current Atlanta Life employee, Oscar Anderson, who worked for the company since 1969, recalled how Atlanta Life provide d training and education to their own employees, (2008) stating If you were interested in goi ng to school, they would help you out. You had to be an employee to go to school. Whether it was financial support for tuition or textbooks for employees, the comp any assisted. In the Atlanta Life Records, a letter written by Atlanta Life executive board member Jesse Hill, to Vice President, E.M. Martin and senior investment officer Walter Smith expressed his recommendation of three female Atlanta Li fe employees to attend Business School (Atlanta Life Photographic Collection 2004; Series1H, B25, F8 1958 excerpt from letter) in 1958: August 18, 1958 From time to time I have discussed the offerings and M.B. A. Requirements to the Atlanta University School of Business with Mr. Sam Westerfield, the dean. We have several young ladies who are eligible to apply for the M.B.A program at the
124 school and Mr. Westerfield would accep t most of our other recommended workers as special students. I have an immediate recommenda tion along this line as follows: I am suggesting that we offer to Mrs. Bernadine Banks, Mrs. Bessie McMillan and Mrs. Alberta Thomas the opportunity to enroll in the Business School next month, assuming they are interested and ag ree to take courses prescribed by the Company or courses that are approved by the Company. Each employee would enroll for two courses this fall. One of the courses would be taken one hour during the day three days a week and the other courses would be taken in the Evening School. All expenses would be paid by the Company. The commitment to financially support the companys own employees to complete an M.B.A., particularly women, is key to unde rstanding the character of the companys campaign for academic achievement and business success through education. The company also provided textbooks fo r those Atlanta Life employees who took courses related to insurance and business. In a letter from one executive board member E. L. Simon, F.L.M.I, Director of Agencies to G. E. DeLorme ( Atlanta Life Photographic Collection 2004; Series1H, B25, F8 1957-1958 excerpt from letter) on August 2, 1957, writes: The entire Atlanta life official family is happy to note that Mr. F.V. Brooks completed successfully the five examina tions required by the American College of Life Underwriters for the designation of Chartered Life Underwriters (CLU). During Mr. Brooks study period, Atlanta Life furnished a good many of the textbooks. As a tangible token of our in terest, cooperation, and appreciation of Mr. Brooks efforts, we are enclosing a check for $194.45 to cover his expenses to Detroit Michigan for conferment of the CLU Designation at the meeting of the National Association of Life Underwriters. Sponsorship Just like many companies, Atlanta Life sponsored many events. Atlanta Lifes uniqueness however, relates to the African American community during segregation.
125 Atlanta Life involved themselves in whatever was going on in the city; anything to uplift the blacks in the city, the Atlanta Life woul d take part, they would always be a part of anything that was going to uplift the bl acks that was good, according to former employee Ms. Franklin (2008). When asked if other companies do this same type of involvement (2008), Franklin stated, The other companies would do it, but not on a large scale like the Atlanta Life did. They always thought of doing things big. They would get everybody who worked for them in it. Many employees discussed Atlanta Li fes countless acts of sponsoring organizations, groups, and events. One former employee, Evonne Night recalls Atlanta Lifes sponsorship of organi zations, particularly during ti mes when black organizations or groups could not acqui re sponsorship (2008): Well we were known for sponsor you know years ago SCLC or NAACP and Urban League and United Negro College F und, a lot of those places couldnt get the types of sponsorships that they can get now. So they depend on Paschals, and H. J. Russell and Atlanta Life, and Citi zens Trust to sponsor them and we were always one of the major sponsors we might not be able to give the 50,000 that Coca-Cola does, but well give ten. We were there when Coca-Cola didnt know we existed. This sponsorship continues today. Atla nta Life Financial Group sponsors and supports many organizations and students Recently Atlanta Life Financial Group donated money for a high school freshman to attend President Barack Obamas Inaugural Ball. Current employee Carol Edwards (2008) added, He will remember that forever. His family sent a letter. Atlanta Lifes name is in their mouth its a value that has no number on being able to have your name in someone elses mouth.
126 Perspectives: View of the Company This section explores perceptions of A tlanta Life by its employees, Atlanta Life affiliates, policy owners, and Atlanta residents. Based on emergent themes, I explore the companys role providing opportunities for eco nomic and social mobility for employees, support, and comfort. I will also investigate employees nostalgia for Atlanta Lifes past, the role of women in the company, and empl oyee belief systems based on the companys influence. Like a Family In my examination of the Atlanta Life family, was a consistent theme in employees description, particularly empl oyees who began working for the company from the 1950s to 1970s. However, most empl oyees, former or current, viewed Atlanta Life like a family. Oscar Anderson, (2008) Atlanta Life employee since 1969 describes his interactions between executive board members and leaders states, It was like a family affair, you didnt have to worry about, O h Lord here come so and so I cant speak to them it wasnt like that. You could speak to any of them their problems were your problems Helen Franklin began working for the company in 1947, shortly afterwards she went on maternity leave, pursued another job, and returned to Atlanta Life seven years later. She re-applied and was re-hired, wit hout any problems. Ms. Franklins name was still on the record and put b ack into the same department She (2008) explained what it was like for her to return stat ing, But at that time I didnt think anything about it. That was the first job I ever had. So to come back to it, it just seem like I was coming back home I enjoyed it thoroughly, working for Atlanta Life; it was like a family each
127 department depended on the other depa rtment for part of their work. The company connected through business, by being a family, knowing each other, and getting along (Franklin 2008). Although to day the company consists of a small number of employees, current employee Caro l Edwards who has been working for the company since 2000 assures that the company is still like a family (Edwards 2008). She recalls (2008: 3) how older employees did not have a problem with her coming in from the outside stating, We as a people, we ha ve certain people who take on a mother and father role, genuinely will look out for you . and those after a while warm up to you like blending a family . we as black people has always been li ke that. In this aspect, for Ms. Edwards, the traditions of African American culture attributes to the family-like nature of the company. This like a family practice consists of employee support and comfort during personal crises, birthday clubs, opportunities for upward mobility, growth, and the provision of safety and security. Support and Comfort: Birthdays and Condolences Current employee Alice Allen (2008) who has been working for Atlanta Life since 1969 at the age of 18, refers to the comp anys family-like characteristics by stating, Working here, you know you just get comforta ble it was not a lot of stress you came in, and you did your job and we all got along with each other we celebrated birthdays, and Atlanta Life to me was al ways concerned about an employee whos out sick, you know like with surgery or always concerned about family it was like family. Birthday clubs were common during the years of the 1950s and 1990s. Employees would come from all other departments, gi ve cards, gifts and money, with peanuts and candy, and sometimes the company would serve ice cream and cake (Evelyn Amos
128 2008). Alice Allen (2008) recall s her birthday experience, Everybody would bring their own little treats the candy and the peanut s or potato chips and you come in and you set your little table, and put your little treats all around and your reward was a card and everybody just gave towards your birthday, you know and it was like a birthday club. The Birthday club changed in 1999. The empl oyees no longer continued this event, however it was a tradition that Atlanta life carried out before Alice began employment (Allen 2008). When an employees family member would pass, the company would send flowers or attend any needs of the fam ily. (Anderson 2008). A retired Atlanta Life employee expressed Atlanta Lifes solidarity and family-like unit, by stating (Herndon Home Newsletter, September 2003), Atlanta Life was very supportive of employees I remember my brother passed and he had littl e children, the whole department came, and they brought all kinds of food They were more like a parent to you. Growth and Economic and Social Mobility The company became a refuge for employees in multiple ways. During segregation, the company provided a secure space for employees to expand their creativity, education, and grow, providing opportunities for upwar d mobility, skill development, and to gain status and presti ge. The company provided employees with an opportunity to travel, attend conferences a nd events. If many employees, particularly men, were not in these positions, they would not have been exposed to travel and leisure which characterizes a middle a nd upper class lifestyle. However, in the post-segregation era, the opportunity for growth and economic and social mobility changed. The firms prom otion of rewards as an incentive for high
129 sale production is no longer necessary. T oday, The Financial Group provides financial services, different from the companys past in life, health, an d burial insurance. Desegregation changed the dynamics, where se gregation provided a space for Blacks to grow through conferences, social interacti ons, events, and training, today employees are not confined to a space that played a role in this mobility. The firm today, provides different meanings than the past. Employment and Opportunities for Blacks After slavery, free African Americans w ith minimal resources, facing overt discrimination, were driven into menial urba n occupations, while nutritional, educational, and medical programs that had been created ma inly to aid them were eliminated (Lyons 2007: 45-46). African Americans were lim ited in opportunities during the Jim Crow period. Blacks had an inferior education or even possibly no education and did not have access to a decent job in legitimate busin ess (Hund 1970). According to Hund (1970:1516), this was a systematic exclusion from job opportunities which c ould have provided a base for entrepreneurship. African Ameri cans entered working lives without a decent share of Americas resources with lower life prospects than whites (Lyons 2007:46). After emancipation and during Jim Crow periods, many African Americans were concentrated in service jobs working as porters, waiters, and servants. (Glenn 2002:106). Black men were concentrated in a few occ upations, as skilled wo rkers in barbering, plastering, and brick making, wh ile being underrepresented in the higher paying fields of carpentry, plumbing, printing, and mach ine operations (Glenn 2002:107). Oliver and Shapiro argue us ing M. S. Stuarts (1970) Economic Detour on the history of insurance of American Negroes to describe how blacks faced an environment
130 where they by law were restricted from par ticipation in business on the open market, especially from the post-bellum period to the middle of the twentieth century (Oliver and Shapiro 2007:103). Oliver and Shapiro (2007) also discuss DuBoiss state of African Americans in DuBoiss book, Black Reconstr uction in America ( 1935), supporting his argument where he states that, Blacks were tied to a system of peonage that kept them in debt virtually from the crad le to the grave (Oliver and Shapiro 2007: 107). Oliver and Shapiro add to the work of DuBois a nd Stuart by arguing, What is often not acknowledged is that the accumulation of wealth for some whites is intimately tied to the poverty of wealth for most blacks (Olive r and Shapiro 2007:107). Due to difficulties obtaining services from white agencies, Blacks actions to strive for black entrepreneurship increased (Hund 1970:16). Companies like Atlanta Li fe provided opportunities fo r African Americans during a time of inequality and lack of opportunities in employment, business, healthcare, and education. David Osborne, who worked for the company for twenty-six years, (2008:2), described what the company provided stating It gave me an opportunity to be a business man, to be a business person, to c ontrol my destiny, to see what I can do for myself.... I never had a job that I worked fo r a white company Mr. Osborne was able to move up from the position as an agent, to a district manager during his employment with Atlanta Life. At the company, he was ab le to do this without a college education. Employment with Atlanta Life and many ot her black companies enabled employees to safely progress economically and socially. Atlanta Life was many employees first and only job.
131 Producing Identity Dual Roles Atlanta Life played dual roles in th e community and among its own employees. Black business established itself as more than a business; it was a family within itself, providing a space for employees to create or fo rm identities, and extended itself into the African American community. For instance, the Atlanta Life Photographic Collection consists of negatives and images of all ty pes of Atlanta Life sports teams, awards ceremonies for employees, homes, other businesses, ID pictures of employees, and committees developed that would as sist the poor in the community. Parties Among the Atlanta Life historic documen ts, were many well-preserved receipts and lists of entertainment expenses for the Spring Dance, Halloween Christmas parties, and banquets. There was also an Entertainm ent, Dance, and a Party committee. There were many ticket stubs and party invitations, recei pts to parties, bills for flowers, alcohol, and food catered, of all sorts in the collec tion. These documents coincided with many photos of parties and banquets in the collection. The compa ny hosted parties at the Royal Peacock, a local night club on Auburn Avenue, a nd then moved to larger hotels, and at the new Atlanta Life building. All former employees and some current talked about extravagant and numerous parties at Atlanta Life. Lyons describes (2007:15): Atlanta Life was known for was for its Ch ristmas parties we would have other kinds of parties, different events, so in a ddition to the parties that were held here at the home office of the company, each di strict office would have a party at different times; Atlanta Life people always find reasons to have a party. We were known for that We worked hard and we pl ayed hard; that was our reputation.
132 One former employee describes the parties as swanky. Most would go to work dressed for the party and a few would change during the day. She a dds, It would be a lovely party, plenty of food and everything. Just something you would look forward to (Amos 2008). One employee pulled out several albums and showed me many pictures of the elaborate parties hosted by Atlanta Life. Ther e were so many different types of parties with themes. Employees had parties like Christmas in New York or Christmas in Hollywood. Atlanta Life was known for hosti ng the best parties (Night 2007). Choral Ensemble The company had its own choral ense mble which members would sing at the funerals of deceased employees, as well as Natal Day celebrations to remember their founder Alonzo Herndon. The Atlanta Life Choral Ensemble had made quite a reputation for themselves singing at different places. In particular, they sang at funerals. When employees had family members to die, they would always get the Choral Ensemble to sing (Herndon Home News letter, 2003, September). The Photographic collection, particularly found in the file of Charles Greene, director of Public Relations (year,) consiste d of hundreds of funeral programs of former employees, the employees family members or individuals who contributed to the African American community. The order of service, listed the Choral Ensemble and/or an Atlanta Life representative to speak on behalf of the company about the deceased. There were also notes and receipts of floral arrang ements sent to the family on behalf of the company.
133 Natal Day Natal Day ceremonies occurred every year to honor the memory of Alonzo Herndon. Employees celebrated the Natal Celebrations up until the 1990s. Natal Day consisted of a program (Adams 2008), a sp eaker, and employees w ould participate in gravesite ceremonies, laying a wreath on th e Herndon graves within the family plot. (Robinson 2008). For Natal Day, employees me t in the auditorium, went through the procedures of reading the history of the co mpany and the founder, and provide a question and answers about company history (Thoma s 2008). The Choral Ensemble also sang during Natal day (Adams (2008). Company song Atlanta Life had company songs, whic h acknowledged the founders, with pride and heritage. At the Atlanta Life Employee Reunion in 2005, retired and older employees stood up to sing their companys theme song. Th ey passed sheet of the lyrics through the crowd, the employees proudly sang to the tune of the University of Maine Stein Song, Well stand and fight for A.L.C. Well fight til we overcome; Well give our all with might and main, Let every loyal agent sing. We ll fight till the day is done; Think of Herndon, our great Founder, The idol of our hearts always . Other retired employees in the audience joined the employees, who went fo rward to sing all three verses. This theme song written by the late George W. Lee, Seni or Vice President, is an example of the companys closeness, pride, and shared identity promoted through song. As former employee, who led the song at th e reunion, (Knight 2008) states:
134 That song was designed for the agents a nd for the field force. I remember it, (Singing) Well stand and fight for A.L.C, Well fight til the day is done, (humming the rest of the words, humming) fight, fight, fight, well stand, I remember that. But, the agents and all the men in the company would stand and sing that song and it was powerful, very powerful. And then they taught it to the clerks as well. Lanta Life gon Shine Tonight, L anta Life gon Shine Tonight My aunt sang this song to me as I inte rviewed her about her experiences working at Atlanta Life in the West Palm Beach branch office in the 1950s. I was amazed at her singing this song. I assumed that there was only one company song based on my observation at the Atlanta Life Reunion and inte rviews. However, as I listened, I realized how much the company impacted its employees, even in branch offices outside the city of Atlanta. This sense of pride and motiv ation sung (as she recal ls) by and for Atlanta Life agents permeates the views of Atlanta Li fe employees and those affiliated. This was prevalent; whether employees shared a closeness, or each member was given some form of responsibility. As my aunt, Lynn Ocean, reca lls of her time in the branch office in Florida (2007) states, All the staff they cared about each other. Everybody had a sense of responsibility. Everybody reported to wo rk on time . During holidays they would have potluck lunches in the office. We didnt have local restaurants open to us. Everybody was very warm and enjoye d having potlucks together. All of the employees and staff was just close knit. Atlanta Life sponsored many events, and when very prominent African Americans came to city, Atlanta Life play ed host for guests with the very best. The photographs, interviews, and stories of form er employees, reveal that Atlanta Life Insurance Company was more than a business, but a space for African Americans to retain their identity, assist their own co mmunities, maintain and accumulate wealth.
135 Therefore, as Lewis (1996:136) argues we mu st display a greater interest in how people construct their ident ities. Atlanta Life employees c onstructed their identities through social organizations and ac tivities within the company. NIA Atlanta Life conferences and National In surance Associations gave many Atlanta Life employees an opportunity for exposure to explore and travel the United States. The National Insurance Association, originally known at the National Negro Insurance Association, founded in 1921, c onsisted of the major black insurance companies in the nation. The association had a school called the NIA Institute, training employees by officers serving as principal instructors. Em ployees who had the potential to grow in companies were selected to attend the NIA in stitute (Night 2007). Employees could also win a trip to the NIA convention based on his or her performance. However, it was not necessarily a district in vitation, it was individuals, field agents, staff, or managers that could get invited (Lyons 2007). Atlanta Life sponsored the trips to the NIA conventions. Former District Manager and Director of Training Edwa rd Lyons (2007) describe this process, We would sponsor so many people, to a NIA convention based on their performance. NIA had nothing to do with how many people we were going to invi te other than letting them know how many people would be coming from Atlanta Life. So it wasnt NIA sponsored, it was sponsored by Atlanta Life ,but it was to NIAs annual convention or conference. Growth and Development The company provided growth and deve lopment through conventions and with the company itself. As Oscar Anderson states, Atlanta Life helped me out a lot. To be
136 around a lot influential blacks you see youd say, they can do it, I can do it too, you know, it meant a lot. The company also paid for Mr. Andersons classes based on his interests at the company (O scar Anderson 2008). For Mr. Anderson, the company helped him mature. Employees also learned that they could advance working in other departments. As Helen Franklin (2008) st ated, some places where you would stay in that rut the whole time you was th ere, but you could advance at the Atlanta Life as far as they wanted to go and as far as what they had to offer you to grow, you could there, you could grow In this sense, growth, and develo pment not only contributed in the companys allowance to gain knowledge, it also is attributed to other employees and officers influence. This idea of visible success of African Americans for others employees to witness, assisted in motiv ating employees to strive for success for themselves. Security, Protection, Awareness Atlanta Life was a space to work freely without criticism based upon the color of a persons skin; although it was a space that pr ovided critiques by leadership to improve work and skills of employees. Oscar Anderson (2008) describes his ability to work in his own space, Before the print s hop closed, I could create so me of my own and print it out it was just some idea plus to wo rk for an all black company we could communicate more together didnt have to be watching over your back, you know, I know you dont like me cause Im black you white Mr. Andersons statement illustrates the freedom for employees to work in a secure environment. Employees did not have to look over their shoulders in their work environment as they would have at a white firm or company.
137 The ability to establish oneself and co mmunicate with others, with protection, security, training, in a safe and secure space to grow and with opportunities, strengthened the family-like stance. The family-like unit en abled the company to function properly and allow employees to succeed. However, empl oyees were told by leadership to follow guidelines, behave properly, and do their very best. Paternal Leadership Everybody got along, it was a must. They w ould tell you in the very beginning, the requirement to do your work, that was understood no arguing, no fussing, and fighting, because if so, you would be out of th e door; type of employees that they had, were on that level that you wouldnt result to that anyway. This quote from former employee Evelyn Amos (2008) is a testament of the companys leadership using fatherly guidance. The company emphasized taking car e of their own, whether it was their employees within the company or the Black community. In the family, individuals could be themselves, share ideas, and easil y communicate with other employees, with the fatherly or motherly leadership of Atlanta Life officers, managers, and supervisors. In some families, particularly, a traditional nuclear American family, there are hierarchies; father, mother, and the children. In Carole Merritts interview with retired employee Robert Phillips (1999), she describe s this parental guida nce, paralleling how children should let their mother know of their whereabouts. Phillips states, My supervisor would say its ok to go to the cafet eria to get yourself a cup of coffee, but let me know youre going so if anybody asks, I can say that I know where you went But they treated you kind of like-they were your s uperior. They were the adults, and you were
138 almost a child because she even tell us, you have your hair br ushed neatly, but you need to go to the beauty parlor. And you didnt get offended. Leaders oversaw employees hygiene, gr ooming, and dressing. (Phillips 1999). Although Ms. Phillips is glad those days are gon e, she assured, It was a way to uplift you (Phillips 1999:32). Employees therefore, according Phillips, were treated like children. Employees accepted this treatment for they saw this as a way to improve their lives personally and professionally. This chastisement on employees benefitted them on multiple levels; it strengthened employees work ethic, skills, and encouraged excellence. Employers would also use tactics through ag ent production and sale challenges, putting agents and district offices on the spot for not selling enough insurance within months. Employees took their place in the family. Boundaries in the family presented themselves through parent-child relationshi ps; employees representing children and the leaders/officers and some female supervis ors representing the fathers and mothers. A child does not challenge the parents, accepts correction, and obeys. However, this parental leadership is divided into boundaries and limitations placed on women. Women Due to war-related industries, (H enderson 1990:143), the majority of the employees who worked for Atlanta Life dur ing WW II, were women. Just like many other companies, at Atlanta life women were hired in great number s, taking over the job of making weekly collections from drafte d men (Henderson 1990:142). Women proved extremely capable of maintaining large debi ts and made a significant contribution to debit-building during the wa r era (Henderson 1990:143). Although there were some
139 women agents, most of the women were clerks Women worked in cler ical roles such as bookkeeping. According to many female inte rviewees, whatever it took to run a company, it was women (Franklin 2008). Most of the supervisors were women (Franklin 2008). However, men were officers and managers (Franklin 2008). Employment for a company like Atlanta Life was considered prestigious for women. It was a job that was not a me nial job, Ms. Franklin (2008) states, You werent doing any housework, kitchen, cooki ng good jobs, sit down jobs; typewriters and adding machines, book keeping. It wasnt th e type of jobs that was usually given to young black women at that time The best job you could ge t was working at a store somewhere as a sales clerk... In his description of racial strati fication of urban labor markets, Glenn (2002:106), describes the racial and gender differences of employment of blacks between 1865 and 1890, focusing on Black women statin g, Black women were even more constrained. Only about 3-4 perc ent of those in the labor force were employed as skilled craftswomen and professionals. Most of the craftswomen were seamstresses, while the largest group of professional women as te achers. The overwhelming 80-92 percent of black women workers in southern cities we re employed as laundre ss or in domestic service as maids, cooks, and child nurses. Therefore, for women, employment with Atlanta Life provided rare opportunities for social and economic mobility. Atlanta Life affiliate Charles Blacks description of opportunities for women, (2008), he states: You have to remember this was a time wh en there werent a whole lot of black folk with good jobs, most women who were working were either teaching school or they were maids women were goi ng to catching that bus in their white uniforms, going to take care white folks homes and their kids. And so to come by a place like this where you have white collar looking people, you know dressed
140 up, come in here working in an office ki nd of environment that was impressive and it was an inspirational thing for the broader community. Women: Rights and Inequalities However, there were very few rights for women, even in the white collar world. Historically female employees did not make a lot of money, nor did they have many rights. According to one retired employee and informant, Barbara Howard, in the application process, Atlanta Life leaders would ask if female employees were going to have children, for too many children posed as a problem. Atlanta Life female employees who had too many children had to terminate themselves and write a dismissal. If a woman wanted to come back, she had to write out a statement, as former employee (Howard 2009) stated, Once I finish my leav e of absence I would like to come back. Howard adds that if word was out in th e building that that a female had too many children; it was grounds for possible terminati on. It was a mans wo rld back in the day. Women didnt have too much authority. The men got the jobs first (Howard 2009). Female agents would also have to get permissi on from their husbands indicating that their wives could work (Johnson 1999). It was not determined what constituted too many children. One former manager described in an interview with Carole Merritt, hiring practices during the 1950s, re garding women, stating that when he would review the applications, women were required to have their husbands approval to work (Johnson 1999). Barbara Howard recalls how as late as 1998 her husband had to agree to the type of retirement settlement that she would get: a lump sum versus increments. There was a conflict with her and her husba nd, because Howard wanted to get a lump sum. However,
141 her husband would not get money in this way. A settlement in increments would allow her husband to get a check. I thought it wa s horrible. Howard (2009:1) argued. Nonetheless, during the pre-desegregati on period, female employees were known for their beauty and fashion sense. Former employee Helen Franklin (2008) states, I think the people thought we made more money than we did because we used most of the money we made to dress. Many male em ployees and men affiliated with the company described beautiful Atlanta Life women and th eir focus of display during lunchtime. One Atlanta Life affiliate (Black 2008) descri bed female employees stating, they had beautiful women (laughs). You may have hear d the stories at lunc htime, people would drive by just to see the pretty ladies coming and going out of building at lunchtime. They were all very nicely dressed. Working for a prestigious company, women wanted to (re) present themselves and the company well. Th ey took pride having su ch a prestigious job at Atlanta Life. This also refers to female supervisors ensuring that women were properly dressed. These practices in the exp ectations and treatment of female employees challenge how Atlanta Life female employees were pr esented and perceived in public. However, the company presented female employees in a positive light. In their newsletter "The Vision," the company pays tribute to women titlin g their issue, "A Salute to Women," in March of 1969, with Mrs. Jessie Herndon, the founder's second wife on the cover. The Editor, George W. Lee uplifts the Black woman in America. Throughout the issue, there is a profile of Mrs. Jessie Herndon, article s about women employees, and successful African American women and their contributio ns to society. In a tribute to the women
142 issue, a field auditor, Grant T. Hallmon, wr ote a poem dedicated to female employees (1969) called, Ode to a Good Cashier," Soft spoken with a face full of smiles Spends many hours counting pennies, nickels, and dimes. Her figures are neat. Her ledgers are exact. She carries her bank balance forward-To keep the manager off of her back. She greets the policyholders with a merry ''HOW DO YOU DO'' When the Agents become disgusted she helps to cheer them too. Her hours are long are tiresome, She enjoys her work 'tis true. Her greatest pleasure comes however when some thoughtful agent says, ''Miss Cashier', How are you.'' Her work is always pressingShe receives neither glory nor fameThe Home Office bulletin seldom mentions her name. She's a key workerHer Company thinks she's well. When the payroll isn't ready all hands give her hell. A slave to her deskdedicated to her work, She never shuns duty nor shirk. When the pearly gates are openedWhen those that have kept th e faith begin to file past, St. Peter will stop all good Cashiers, and say, ''Welcome Home peace at last.'' The poem describes the model female employee, knowing her place, presenting neat and correct work, her dedication, ne ver complaining, tirelessly, quietly, and diligently doing her work at her desk. Yet sh e is a leader, who should be recognized and honored. The model female employee exemplif ies the type of excellence expected by leaders. Female employees played multiple roles pursuing education, supporting agents and supervisors, providing accurate work, and maintaining family roles at home. All of the former female employees interviewed were married while employed with Atlanta Life. Current employees were all married as well. Half of the women working during the
143 time one employee worked there from 1950 to 1990s stated that half of the women were married and the other half were not ma rried (Howard 2009). Therefore, many women, balanced work, and family throughout the de cades that challenged them based upon race, class, and gender. Practices in the Firm Employees nostalgia and ro manticizing memories of the company presents a persona as everyone getting along without many problems, with full support. Yet contradictions arise. In the interview process, there were comments about women obtaining better or higher posit ions in the company due to dating officers, discrimination in pay among women, and hiring based on skin color, where lighter skinned females were likely to be hired, despite faili ng application tests. Most of the photo images of female employees I reviewed, particularly images ta ken before desegregation, were fair skinned employees. A former employee who worked for the company from the 1950s to 1980s, indicated, that high yellow women were more likely hired than those women who were not, or a woman had to know someone. Re portedly, an uneducated, fair skinned woman could work for Atlanta Life. If she di d not pass the test, she still could get hired, if she knew someone. According to (2008) Ms. Howard, You could be a dumb black girl and be fair, you could get a job. This doe s not insinuate that all fair skinned women who worked for Atlanta Life were hired due to the skin color; it is important however, to consider such indications of how and why Af rican Americans were accepted for jobs and services. These unequal practices were not enough to keep women from pursuing employment these circumstances. It was bette r than conducting menial work, facing both
144 racism and sexism. These hiring practices and treatment of women in general in white collar jobs by men, relates to what Ma rable Manning (1983) describes in his book, How Capitalism Underdeveloped America. ar guing that from the very beginning of Black political activism in the United States African-American men had real difficulty in considering the triple oppr ession (race/class/sex) of Bl ack women with any degree of seriousness. He argues that part of the problem stemmed from the evolution of patriarchal institutions within Black civil society (Marable 1983:76) Therefore, the parental leadership in Atlanta Life pract ices could have also weakened the family-like structure of the company, preventing employees, particul arly women, economic mobility, promoting a form of belief systems to follow leader ship without question, excluding employees indirectly. From a different perspective, th e company, like any other family, could have been a dysfunctional one. There ar e many contradictions of this family, partly related to issues surrounding class within the company. Levels in the Company The company consisted of many different positions and levels for employees. In 1955, the Atlanta Life Board of Directors or Officers included: the President, who was also treasurer, 1st Vice-President who was also Secretary, 2nd Vice President, 3rd Vice President, Chief Medical Director, Distri ct Managers, Acting Actuary, Acting Agency Director, Manager for Departments, such as Printing, and Special Assistant to 2nd Vice President. These positions changed base d upon years (Atlanta Daily World June 26, 1955). The officers were mostly men, excep t for two women: Jessie Herndon, Alonzo Herndons second wife, who served as Vice Pres ident of Atlanta Life in 1927, and Helen Collins who was the Atlanta Life Board Ch airwoman in 1984. There were managers,
145 over different branch offices. All officers pr esided over a certain area, for example, accounting (Howard 2009). Each department had an officer or manager, and a supervisor. Each supervisor had a different department, with clerks, who were mostly women. Most of the women did not have high positions and titles. Agents collected policies and recruited potential policy owners. There were also employees who worked as auditors and printers. Atlanta Life provided opportunities for gr owth and developmen t through paternal leadership, encouraging family-like solidar ity, providing a sense of comfort in the workplace, where officers could empathize with employees and even chastise and critique employees work for improvement. Yet and still, the officers, and employees with higher-level positions presented them selves to other employees non-threatening enough to lower level employees to be a part of the family. Class: Apparent and Disguised It was like a family affair, you didnt have to worry about, oh lord here come so and so I cant speak to them. You could speak to any of them they problems were your problems (Oscar Anderson 2008). Mr. Ande rsons perspective indicates that there were not any boundaries between executive boa rd members and regular employees. Mr. Andersons comfort level enabled him to speak freely with an executive board member. He believed that people who interacted with each other, were not separate, employees knew each other and knew everything a bout each other (Anderson 2008), providing an atmosphere of comfort for all employees. However, current employee, Alice Allen ha s a different perspective on interaction with leadership of the company. Describing interactions with executive board member
146 and Atlanta Life president, Mr. Hills office was in the department where she worked, she states (2008), I was able to see (Mr. Hill) ev ery day, but he was like a person that was in and out. He came and he was always polite, you know, spoke to everybody and hell just go on about his business. A lot of the offici als didnt really inter act with a lot of the employees. In Alices experiences, interactio ns between officials or board members with employees were the opposite of Mr. Anderson s experiences. Financially and structurally, there were boundaries; Mr. A nderson, was a male, but was not in a position of power. Allen worked as a clerk. Perhaps Mr. Anderson s interactions could account for the fact that he is a man. His interactions with o fficers were based on the commonality of sex, preventing him from questioning th e actions of his leaders. In my archival research, I found many im ages of Atlanta Life board members, officers, and higher-level employees (manager s, directors, and agents who sold vast amounts of insurance), at many conferences events, and areas throughout the country. There were pictures of Norris Herndon, and friends, many of them officers, horseback riding, at Norris fathers winter home in Ta vares, Florida. Based on images, the summer home in Tavares was exclusive to some em ployees, particularly officers. The summer home was also used for regional conference s in the early days of Atlanta Life (Ebony Magazine 1955). It is clear th at not all residents were ab le to visit the home. Many photos and post cards of the Herndon Family collection consist of travels to Europe and other countries by Norris and the Herndon family. The lives of the officers represent an excl usive life of the Black elite. Parties, social interactions with wealthy whites, and famous blacks indi cate an upper class lifestyle by Norris and those in his circle, including many of the Atlanta Life officers.
147 Their prestige also resulted from helping to uplift the African American community, and the power that is associated with this uplift, in addition to giving to charities, sponsorship, and advertisement. This brought more attention and money to the company by black consumers. Most female employees were excluded from attending Atlanta Life and NIA conferences; mostly agents, managers, supe rvisors and officers. Although some women were agents, most agents were men. Men w ould bring their wives and families on these trips. Therefore, the beneficiaries of these trips were employees based on high levels of sales and productions agents, supervisors, ar ea directors, and managers could win trips (Osborne 2007). David Osborne (2007) described the trips th at some employees earned stating, Atlanta Life had these national insurance conve ntions that gave us an opportunity to be exposed to a lot of stuff. My children look forward to that because we went to various cities. See those are things th at benefit us, so the first time Ive driven to California, I was with the Atlanta Life In surance Company We we nt to Las Vegas these are national conventi ons, you earned these trips. The company invited those district managers in the top selling districts to Atlanta Lifes annual Christmas gala in Atlanta. On e former district manager of Miami recalls how the company rented a Greyhound Bus in Miami in the mid-1960s, and then came through Lakeland and picked up the managers to take them to Atlanta for the Christmas gala at the Royal Peacock. The company put the managers up in Paschals, an African American owned hotel at the time (Osborne 2007:9). This is not a new thing. In 1924, the company initiated special campaigns as incen tives for those who produced the largest debit during a campaign (Henderson 1990:93). In 1954, some employees were recipients
148 of the Norris B. Herndon Caravan, winners of a free trip to the World Series between the Cleveland Indians and the New York Giants The image of the winners in front of Progressive Field in Ohio holding a banner displaying their success, represents a separation between certain employees and their families with larger African American community, most female employees, employees in lower level positions, and employees who did not produce high enough sales to win a ll expense paid trips. This created an exclusion of certain groups, whether intentional or not. In Kevin Yelvingtons Producing Powe r: Ethnicity, Gender, and Class in a Caribbean Workplace (1995), his description of supervisors or managers in the factory reveals the structured position in the factory and workers w ho fall within the structures can relate to Atlanta Life. Power is definitional because it determines who can take up certain positions and the estab lishment of the rules and proce dures in a setting such as the factory. Yelvington illustrates or describes power and its relations hip to production. He sees power as something that is practiced or exercised as well as production through an economic process (1995:12). Power is achieved through means of resource that are hierarchically distributed ( 1995:15). There are dimensions of power that are relational, structural, definitional, historical, and cultura l. Individuals control resources based upon relationships. Those in powerful positions that are structured occupy power. Atlanta Lifes hierarchal structure reflec ts how resources are controlled. Class and Prestige When many African Americans could onl y acquire menial jobs and domestic work, particularly for women, the company of fered opportunities. Office or desk jobs
149 were a prestigious form of employment. For African Americans, the lines between middle class and working class are obsc ure with very ambiguous boundaries. The company was a space for producing not only cultura l identities, but also power and status for employees, despite their class. Although female employees did not particip ate in many conferences and trips as male employees, exclusion by higher-level employees were not exclusive to men. The majority of employees at Atlanta Life were graduates of AU and many attended First Congregational Church (Tuck 2001:57). The five former employees interviewed, who worked for the company from the 1940s to the 1990s, had all attended historically black colleges: Spelman, Morris Brown, or Clark Co llege. These were prestigious and popular colleges, particularly in the early to mid 20th century. One former female employee compared and contrasted her current liv ing environment and the Atlanta Life environment, which indirectly defined he r higher-class status compared to those individuals who lived in her bui lding (Amos 2008:2), stating: I say being in a building like this, all th ese different people from all walks of life but I dont deal with them because we dont have anything in common, you know. So many different types of people in a place like this. So I say, and I tell people, I say I cant compare that when I was at the Atlanta Li fe all those women, 150 women or so, because we were more or less kind on the same level, had something in common. When I asked Ms. Amos what she meant by same level, she replied, education and character. She recalled how she and other women workers went to the same type of schools; educated from Spelman, Morris Brown, and Clark. She added, There at Atlanta Life people were on the same level kind of compare this kind of getting to me like the projects what the projects feels like, peopl e from everywhere. Just because I live in
150 the building with them, you know you gonna spea k, but Im not going to associate with them, cause we dont have anything in co mmon, like we did at the Atlanta Life. Ms. Amos equated her current living envi ronment to living in the projects, and she did not belong. She appeared to yearn for her past times surrounded by members of her own class, Atlanta Life employees. A lthough women did not earn much income, their employment at Atlanta Life and education, enabled them to move upward in class and separate themselves from the masses. Not a ll current female employees were educated through the AU Center. However, they had some form of educational training in business and/or insurance. Class resonated with Atlanta Life social organizations as well. I asked current employee Oscar Anderson if he remembers the Atlanta Life Choral Ensemble. The ensemble consisted of mostly women who sa ng at the funerals of employees, programs and other Atlanta Life and community even ts. Mr. Anderson laughed and said (2008:5), I stayed there for about two minutes. Our conversation continued, jokingly, Alisha: You were in the Choir? Mr. Anderson: The Atlanta Life Ensemble (says properly) Alisha: Ensemble Mr. Anderson: The Ensemble (says prope rly in an English accent and laughs) Alisha: Why did you get out the choir? Mr. Anderson: That wasnt my thi ng. That wasnt my cup of tea. Mr. Andersons use of a proper, E nglish accent describing the ensemble insinuates a form of prestige among a gr oup even within the company. Even his correcting me when I used the word choir indicates the proper us e of language about the ensemble; illustrating a certain air a bout the group, its exclus iveness, and even private, excluding those who did not have the proper voice or class.
151 According to Yelvington, class is defi ned (Yelvington 1995:32) as an identity based on a cultural understanding of ones capita l resources and the mode of closure one habitually employs within the objective st ructure provided by capitalism as totalizing cultural system. Yelv ington examines class in connecti on to ideas of closure (1995:29); it is the process by which social collectivit ies seek to maximize rewards by restricting access to resources and opportuni ties to a limited scale of individuals. Exclusion results in lack of resources, based upon ethnicity and gender. Class is used to cover up racism which can also involve, for example pers onal conduct and manners (Yelvington 1995). Here we see the involvement of social and cultural capital. Issues of class and gender arise. There is a kind of people, and a kind of labor ( 1995:38), established historically and contemporaril y, that correlates with what the author describes how owners impose their own definitions of so cial identities of gr oups (1995:39), therefore reinforcing conflicts and sepa rations between who is acceptable or not in society. (See Jackson and Burns discussion on caste and class in relation to race of the Kingsley Plantation, 2006). For leaders, wealthy ow ners, and officers of the company, class income differences were hidden underneath their blackness, con cealed through their commonalities; a shared identity and struggl e with the impoverished masses. However, the impoverished Black community remained impoverished despite the presence, role, and impact of Atlanta Life within the community. Black Elite: Role Models? The wealthy owners role can be rela ted to what William Julius Wilsons book The Truly Disadvantaged (1987) describing owners as the role models of the black community, representing the rock and stabil ity of the community. However, critical
152 analysis reveals the reality of wealthy owners, representing what Brett Williams illustrates in her chapter The Great Family of Fraud of Postwar America, how family values depend upon the era of the Golden age for American families (1999:69). She demonstrates through examples of African Americans and whites during the postwar America, the complexity in both groups. The middle class promoted delusional values as a standard and ignored the diversity and heterogeneity in African Americans, and silenced dysfunction in the white American fa mily. This idea of the 1950s delusional values, are described by Williams (1999:75) who states, Women and men married, worked, went to church, and taught their ch ildren to obey the proper authorities. Poor people looked to wealthie r people for models of how to liv e ones life as living proof that racism was no obstacle to personal pride and professional success. Wilsons role model concept consists of the early years, where the bl ack middle and working classes were confined by restrictive covenants to communities also inhabited by the lower classes their very presence provided stabilit y to inner-city nei ghborhoods, reinforced, and perpetuated mainstream patterns of norms and behaviors. (Wilson 1987:7) Wilson found that the real problem with the poor is that they lost role models leaving the poor without model obedience, ma rriage, and self-esteem. However, Williams (1999:75) challenges this idea that excludes the possibi lity of the diversity of these neighborhoods, offering a generic version to capture the social life is segregated cities all over America. Williams also argues that Wilsons concep t rests on no historical or ethnographic foundation. Therefore, this idea of Black flight where middle class blacks left poor blacks to fend for themselves has no major basis for argument.
153 Although impoverished masses were fully aw are of their place in the community as well as the differences between their place and wealthy businesses owners, the masses took their position and played their role in th e larger capitalistic society; for what choice did they have? However, the wealthy owners of Atlanta Life took on the role of fighters for equal and civil rights for the impoverished masses, in the Civil Rights movement and providing assistance in the community. Wealthy owners themselves to some de gree could relate to the impoverished masses; they shared the goal of elimina ting discrimination that would end the monopoly, since the wealthy owners did not have full acce ss to the larger capitalist society, nor did they have equal rights fully. They still had to live in black neighborhoods, face discrimination outside the black community, w ith limited power to some extent, only to the black community. Therefore, physic al space bounded wealthy owners due to segregation laws, and economic space bounded th em globally, which helped diminish the reflection of the differences between wealthy owners and impoverished masses. There is an illusion of an equal playing field. Ho wever, some employees experienced some aspects of the privileges of working for th e company, i.e. no competition with whites, opportunity to grow and deve lop skills, safe work environment, and family-like solidarity. In addition, Atlanta Lifes attracti on and popularity related to the fact that all members of the African American community could acquire simple nickel and dime policies. Atlanta Life provided insurance fo r everyone, whether poor, working class, or black elite. Jacksons (2009) interview with Dr. J ohnnetta Cole, anthropologist, Kingsley descendant, and daughter Afro-A merican Life Insurance founder, A.L. Lewis, highlights
154 unique examples of dynamic and multiple constr uctions of identity and experiences of place (Jackson 2009:23-24), in the face of r ace and class. Jackson states, The experiences of Kingsley descendents highlig ht the conflation of race and class which often occurred in the face of legalized se gregation in America for African Americans. This was because anyone racialized as black, or labeled as non-white, was subjected to the same physical and social segregated place re strictions regardless of wealth or class. Coles father owned American Beach, an Af rican American beach on the east coast of Jacksonville, FL, where many African Ameri can middle class owned homes. For many years, this beach resort community served as the hub of recreation and entertainment for families and civic and social organizations (Jackson 2009). However, in the interview, Cole tells Jackson (2009:24), While A.L. Le wis in his wisdom and with his wealth had made sure that that beach was available, not just for his family, not just for the Afro, I mean people now live in Virginia, in Nort h Carolina who remember coming to that beach. But everybody knew that we were on th at beach and could not be on the other beaches. In this case, and many others, th e African American middle class and business owners through the U.S. still were confin ed to same space with other Blacks. No Negative Words Atlanta Life was a wonderful company. I enjoyed the work so much, oh I really did. It was a wonderful place to work. I rea lly enjoyed it (Evelyn Amos 2008). This comment made by former employee Evel yn Amos was the sentiments of many informants, particular former employees, a bout their experiences with Atlanta Life. Former employees were far more open to disc uss challenges and/or conflicts within the company, but not extensively. When I aske d former employees a bout the challenges or
155 issues during their employment, employees wo uld refer to changes or present leadership within the company, but not any problems occurring, for instance, with other employees or officers, working conditions or daily work-related issu es. Current employees were leery of discussing certain topics chal lenges, differences, and thoughts regarding leadership and changes within the company. Current employees seemed to discuss Onthe-surface issues making safe and positive comments about the company. Current employees would hesitate before answering a question related to ch allenges, with some employees requesting that I turn off the tape recorder, and then share limited amount of information. This probably was due to po ssibly fear of being reprimanded by the company. Every family has its problems. Howeve r, based on the interviews, employees did not share or reveal many family secret s. Former employees reminiscence about life during segregation and the Jim Crow period, re vealing an interpretation of a rosy vision of the past. The idea that things are not like they used to be, assumes that the past personified a perfect environment and a sense of comfort with African Americans issues and community. As Ms. Helen Frank lin (2008) states, Atlanta Life introduced you to a lot of things that you werent awar e of. You have to ge t along and be friendly when you worked there You talked about Atla nta Life yourself, and that would make other people interested .you never said an ything bad about it because they were a good company to work for. Employees refusal to say anything b ad about the company or air dirty laundry is not foreign to the African Amer ican community. Bill Cosbys airing the dirty laundry of poor Blacks in America was pr aised by some white Americans, and
156 considered bravery by some black constituencies (Dyson 2005: xiii), supporting Cosby who expressed what they were not willing to blurt out loud. Mi chael Eric Dysons critique presented Cosbys failure to recogni ze the habits and beha viors of other black communities which were spared public hashin g (2005:37). In this regard, revealing or exposing any negative aspects of Atlanta Life employees, who repres ented white collar workers, the black elite, the respected cla ss in the community, and the role models of the community, would be unthinkable. The taboo of employees airing dirty laundry of themselves and their employers results in self-censoring to prevent exposing the practices of the black community. This self-censoring could also simply be a l oyalty and pride of the company, obtaining a good job at a prestigious company, outwei ghing its negative experiences. Cole and Sheftalls (2003), Gender Talk: The Str uggle for Womens Equality in African American Communities, examine the Black communitys negative responses in airing dirty racial linen. In a s ection of the book, the authors analyze the differences between Black women and Black men, arguing why ther e is not attack on white media, taking responsibility for the popularity of certain books that slander and damage the Black community (2003:xxxi). Their examination reflec ts the ideal of secr ets and lack of disclosure by the Black community, partic ularly examining gender issues using examples like Anita Hills accusations against Judge Clarence Thomas of sexual harassment, and the issue of race loyalty becoming a prominent feature of ensuing public discourse (2003:73). Paula Giddings al so uses the Anita Hill example, describing the difference between race loyalty and race solidarity in her chapter of The Last Taboo, (1995:414), stating, solidarity so often requires suppressing information about
157 any African American of standing regardless of their political views or character flaws When those flaws are sexist, solidar ity can be especially destructive to the community. What makes the exposure wh at Giddings calls inappropriate to many people is that a black womans commitment to a gender issue superseded what was largely perceived as racial solidarity (1995:414). This can be related to the female employees who shared a limited amount of e xperiences regarding gender issues at the company. Giddings uses Darlene Hines descri ption of the culture of dissemblance (1995::432), where behaviors and attitudes of black women that created the appearance of openness and disclosure but actually shield ed the inner lives and selves from their oppressors (1994:37). Overall, all African Americans have expe rienced enough negative attention, enough flawed and inaccurate images of Black people. Therefore, why would Atlanta Life employees, particularly during segregation, reveal a negative view of a people or group who historically have been subjugated and portrayed by whites in such demeaning, discriminatory, dehumanizing, and distorted ways? Thus, it is necessary to consider how individuals ta lk about experiences and how they construct history. Many former employees referred to the comp any as the Atlanta Life, as if the firm was an economic entity (Ingham and Feldman 1994:325), as monumental, with a sense of honor and sacredness. The importa nce for African Americans to communicate loyalty and romanticizing the company and the black community resonated with former Atlanta Life employees, loyal to the busine ss. In any institutio n, there are always challenges. These challenges at the company did not compare to the beauty of working for your own people. However, from inte rviews, whether said or unsaid, I acquired
158 contradictions that counteract the romantic like a family persona through stories about low pay, poor leadership, be trayal, disconnect to community and customers, discriminatory hiring practices, complaints regarding poor choices of initiating changes within the company and older employees not wanting to share training and experiences with the new employees. Desegregation?: The Changes and Possible Decline of the Company, its Multiple Functions, and the African American Community It is an assumption that de segregation contributed to th e decline of the company, its multiple functions, and the African Amer ican community. However, according to interviews of former and current employees, there were multiple reasons for the companys decline other than desegregation. In this section, I re veal many informants ideas to explain the decline or as some w ho state the downfall of Atlanta Life, from out dated leadership practices, abandoning past leadership practices, moving into the new building, downsizing, hiring outside leadershi p, to simply getting rid of Atlanta Life social activities and organizations. I reveal the company changes throughout the years, and the critiques and challenges of and by em ployees, and Atlanta Life policy owners. Even though there was some competition with white companies after segregation, desegregation enabled blacks to conduct bus iness outside of the Black community, and middle class blacks to move out of the bound neighborhoods and live in different areas. Many black businesses were affected by desegr egation laws. In former employee Lyons (2007) discussion about desegr egation and Atlanta, sta ting that the unintended consequences of desegregation: had little to do with what happened to Atlanta Life there are a lot of other businesses and institutions that were ha rmed greater because of the unintended
159 consequences of integration than Atlanta Life . we werent bargaining to close all the black restaurants or dont have them We werent suggesting that a lot of people talk to us say we dont go to those places anymore, we go to the other place, you know, majority places or we dont we dont do business with these other institutions because now we can do it w ith the majority company. That was not intended, not the way it was intended to be That was unintended consequences of integration. I dont think Atlanta Life was not I wouldnt say not affected at all, but certainly not to the extent that a lot of other businesses were ended by, or negatively impacted by. As Lyons suggested, Atlanta Life re mained a power source, economically, socially, and in the African American community, flourishing. Helen Franklins experience echoes with Lyons. According to Ms. Franklin (2008), she did not see any changes due to the employees closeness, statin g, All of us were black, and so we just continued to do things that they had always done No majo r changes Atlanta Life was always liberal anyway. Another former employee, E vonne Night (2007) created a picture and reminisced about Sweet Aubur n Avenue, the hub of black businesses, recalling her times at the famous night cl ub, the Royal Peacock, and R&B singers on the street during segregation, stating: You look down the street and James Brow n walking down the street. . Aretha Franklin living right over there, cause shes entertaining at the Peacock. Then you might see Jackie Wilson, youll see the Supr emes staying at the Royal hotel down the street. You walk down the street at l unchtime it was filled with black business people.... B. B. Beamers restaurant, that s where all of the entertainers would come when theyre here and sit down a nd have lunch and you might go in there and see Aretha Franklin, you might see the Supremes, you might see the Temptations. Ms. Night (2007) recalls the losses of A uburn Avenue, resulting from desegregation stating. When they integrated, then these pl aces closed down, and blacks are so anxious to go to the white clubs, until they lost busin ess. Peacock just closed, they start opening up a civic center and places like that and the entertainers began to make fifty times more
160 than what they were making So we lost a lo t. This romantic version of segregation reflects many of the interviewees. Although desegregation contributed to the decline of the black business district, based on interviews of former and cu rrent employees, the change in leadership occurred during the early 1990s, hiring executives and officers from outside of the company contributed to major changes. According to former empl oyees, this in turn changed the dynamics of the relationships between wealthy owners, A tlanta Life employees, and the community. New Leadership vs. Old Leadership There were many criticisms, particularly by employees who worked for the company during between the 1940s and 1970s, re garding new leadership, those who were employed from outside the company or who ne ver worked for Atlanta Life. Many faulted the company for abandoning the old ways, hi story, and leadership practices, (Lyons 2007). Lyons stated, Its not the same thing that a lot of persons spen t their lives helping to build not to steal...it doesnt mean th ings dont change we had a core philosophy that I think the company eventually abandone d which was part of the downfall we got away from the philosophy that began this institution and carrie d it for a certain number of years. Lyons agreed that the company should no t still sell nickel and dime policies like they did in the twenties a nd thirties, collecting from them weekly at their home; he believed that change has to be manageable. Current employee Elaine Robinson whos been with the company for over thirty years, shares this same view of new leader ships lack of the u nderstanding companys history as well as the companys improper management of change. She believed that
161 executives came into the company not understanding what made the company. Robinson (2008) states: Im not saying that the changes were not necessary, but Im just saying sometimes you have to understand why things were done being done a certain way before you can come in and make changes for th e best. You got to understand what its all about. Listen to th e people you are telling you want to make the changes. Cause they can sometime help you to better make the changes. She felt that in order to survive Atlanta Life had to make changes in order to be competitive. However, executives did not realize that they needed to make changes a little slower than they did. She argued that the executives made continuous changes in short amounts of time (Robinson 2008). The chan ges occurred too quickly and leadership handled the changes improperly. Therefore, the change was not the problem, it was the way leadership executed the change; it was not the best way to handle the change (Robinson 2008).New executives lacked connec tions with people; employees and policy owners (Robinson 2008). However, David Osborne felt like stale l eadership, reproducing the same leadership from the 1960s caused the decline. He also believes that the company brought in noninsurance, imitating what the corporate pe ople do. Osborne (2007) continues, They tried, they made it an investment, they went out of the core market and now its more or less an investment company... wrong decision This was our liveli hood, and I still love Atlanta Life, but things are not the same And really, you dont know what they are doing. Theyre not Atlanta Life, they have no employees, not really, you know. So its not serving the same function. Osborne blam ed leadership for their use in similar techniques from the past to run the company, yet at the same time, the hiring of leaders not connected to insurance.
162 I expected employees to share the horror stor ies of the consequences of desegregation in the company. Instead, I found the gradual ch ange of leadership, types of services, and the company changing its strong connection to the community. Overall, many of the employees were disappointed in the path of the company, losing its connection with the history and legacy of Alonzo Herndon, the community, sense of value and worth and social roles within. The Atla nta Life family relationships changed, with a disruption in the family, disconnecting to the Atlanta Life source. As Helen Franklin shares, To businesses you would say that they have a dvanced, but as far as relationships, it will never be same. Now everybody is trying to ge t to the top, they will push you out of the way, they dont help you along, like it was when I was there, people would try to help... (2008). Ms. Franklin is indicating that the new type of employee functions within the company individually, abandoning the practic es of solidarity and group success. Atlanta Life policy owner Edith Linton expe rienced changes in th e procedure of her policy and bill, from receiving a signature from an agent validating her payment, to an electronic bill through a mediator service. Due to tec hnological changes, the company changed the way they conduct business (Linton 2008). She argues that through automation, facts and figures, you take out humanity. There was a personal and professional relationship in th e past, today its less pers onal and not in touch, stating, They want my bank account, but they could ha ve had my mind. She would prefer the company send something that lets her know that the company exists. By the mid-1990s, many of Atlanta Life social organizations ended. By 1993, the Choral Ensemble no longer operated (Sutt on 2008), however the company still had a basketball team. Today the company does not ha ve as many parties as they did in the
163 past. Although the company still participates in the community, this connection is not as extensive as the past. Natal Day ceremonies have not been consistently celebrated in the past few years, although it was celebrated in 2008. Employees partic ipating in Natal Day provided a sense of education about the hist ory of Alonzo Herndon and Atlanta Life and it promoted a connection to a long legacy of African American achievement and success. During post segregation and well into the ea rly nineties, Atlanta Life adjusted to the many societal changes. The dynamics of the role of the company differed tremendously from the role of the company today. Atlanta Life during Jim Crow and segregation periods contended with inequali ties, blatant discrimi nation, and injustice amongst all classes of African Americans. Th erefore, the motivation of Atlanta Life officers and leaders positi on was based upon not only economi c stability, but equality and freedom to participate in a capitalistic society. Besides desegregation, new technology, and cl osing departments, could have also contributed to the downfall. In 1995, the co mpany shut down its print shop, used for all the printing for all the branch offices throughout the countr y. There was no use for the shop when the branches closed down. Ho wever, according current employee Oscar Anderson (2008), That was back then, but now they wish they had kept it, I mean what people tell me Printing is high dont know why they got rid of it. This change, with intent of saving money, may not have cost the company more due to high printing cost of outside the company. Th erefore, based on the downsizing of the company, branches, employees, resulted in closing an important feature of the companies progress and maintenance.
164 Throughout the existence of Atlanta Life, women were the driving force when the company incorporated computers. Although th e first computer operator at the Atlanta Life was a woman, more men operated the m achinery in the company (Franklin 2008). Atlanta Life representatives had to be traine d at the IBM school, learning how to operate the machines. Ms. Franklin recalls this tr aining process, which took place outside the company. She states, It was funny how we went to school to learn how to operate the computer and we didnt have one It was like going to learn how to play a piano without a piano Before Atlanta life got one; employees had to send work out to companies where computers were. Therefore, dependency of wo rk changed to sources from the outside. What is an ironic change is the fact that th e chief operator was a woman; she was sent to school for training. Within this change, techno logy parallels with the changing role of women in the 1980s. Moving in a New Building The company began to rent out office space in the building to non-Atlanta Life employees and other companies during the other changes within the company. Today the building is occupied by busine sses unrelated to Atlanta Life The other floors of the Atlanta Life building, in the past few year s, had been home to service or community social oriented organizations like Jane Fondas G-CAPP, Georgia Campaign for Adolescents Pregnant Prevention, helping to eliminate adolescent pregnancy, 100 Black Men, Peoples Agenda, Rainbow Push, IM S Management, and IBG Construction Services, profit businesses ( Sutton 2008). At one time, Atlanta Life occupied all of the floors. Before the new buildings opening in 1980, employees operated in three buildings,
165 the print shop, the annex, a nd the castle, housing old Atla nta Life records. The new building was more convenient to interact w ith the departments, and employees did not have to go out of one building to another (Robinson 2008). For those who had not been at the company for a along time, it did not take as long to get acquainted with other people in other departments, based upon the close sp ace, employees were able to learn about each other quicker. Downsizing Due to the decline in business, downsiz ing was one of the main changes that contributed to what former em ployee describe as the decline of the company. By the early 1990s, there were close to 300 employees at the home office, and approximately 500 employees including the district offices. During this time, other organizations and companies began occupying the building (Su tton 2008). The downsize le ft a lot of space available, and the company had to compensate for all the space available. (Thomas 2008). The decline occurred before the company ch anged the type of insurance and services provided. The company still had the same t ype of insurance services before the downsizing, with the sa me core business. A series of three downsizes occurred, with the largest one in 1990. The company dispersed the customer service aspect of the company (Robinson 2008). Liberty Insurance intervened as a mediator for Atlanta Life. The company contracted Liberty insurance to operate the customer service center. Liberty took over claims, customer service, and premium accounting. In 1995, ma ny employees left or retired; employees had to re-apply for positions. Many of the employees, who left, were considered the core of the company (Robinson 2008). As cu rrent employee Elaine Robinson (2008)
166 states, Thats when the big drastic change really started a lot of people who had been here for many many years, that real strong bond was gone Some of employees did go over to the new company that they brought in to maintain, manage our customer service, and then those that stayed worked for approximately five years. The company began closing many of the branch offices between 1995 -1997. The home office was the only office operating. A nother downsize occurred in 2002, becoming what Atlanta Life is today. In the last dow nsize, the Investment Advisory Company came aboard. In late 1990s, early 2000, according to current employee El aine Robinson, the core company insurance size was hit the hardes t. Employees were laid off in two major times, in 1990 and 2002 (Robinson 2008). Robinson (2008) compares the loss of ma ny employees and its process like losing a family member stating, When big mama gone, and you dont have nobody to step in big mamas place, everything falls apart. When the last downsize happened it was devastating to the people that stayed and the people that left. Because we came in that morning, and they started turning people around. According to Ms. Robinson (2008) regarding how the change affected policy owners: When you dealing with people that dont have a whole lo t. You just cant throw hard changes on them, and especially older people I think we c ould not relate to our executives who were maki ng these decisions that our base core people were older people who were maintaining the majority of these policies on their family in my opinion, the change was too dramatic that was a lot of our downfall. She adds, When you lose that many tight-kni t people, at one time, it does change the whole. Cause that left the majority of the people who had not been here a good ten years... Therefore, there were many ne w people left to operate the company.
167 Although today the company st ill assists the community, this effort occurs on a smaller level than in the past. Today, A tlanta Financial group wants to operate and compete on larger level and to a global ma rket, trying to make major financial and employee contributions (Edwards 2008). Current employee Carol Edwards (2008) stated: We will be global. It is my desire that the Atlanta Life name transcend that state of this country. There is a unique divers ified group that work for this company that are very good of what they do. Some of the best in their particular fields and I cant wait until we have the opportunity to get in front of people who may or may not look like us. That is the epitome to be sought after because of what we do. Although the companys direction is global, the firm began a program characterizing the traditional practices of A tlanta Life. The company began its Pre-Need program, a modernized name for paying for funera l service before needed (Edwards 2008). A unit of Atlanta Life Financ ial Group, new product, named MemoirSM, allows individuals and families to prearrange and pre-fund their funeral through participating funeral firms in Georgia. Pre-Need program targets African American funeral directors and firms; an untapped market (Edwards 2008). Atlanta Life employee, Edwards believes that Atlanta Lifes vision today is similar to Alonzo Herndons vision. Edwards (20 08) states, The clientele in his barber shop. He only serviced white folks. He had to have that vision before he opened the shop. His heart was with his people, but he underst ood from a business perspective, he had to be open to some other things, and the same is true with us. We love who we are, but we dont necessarily need to lead with it. She goes on to say, T he folks who are our clients are not the same folks that were our clie nts even ten years ago. Its a different
168 environment. Herndon had whites only servi ce at barbershop and it is important to understand that mind set (Edwards 2008). Atlanta Lifes changes in clients and serv ices, with traditional beliefs resulted in resistance and apprehension from former employees and policy owners. Changes, however, according to an executive, were necessary. Edwards (2008) describes the change and its importance, When we stoppe d servicing the home business, that took, that touch point with the African American family that probably was generational, quite frankly away. And now our clients are fortune 500 companies are all institutional because of the nature of what we do we are a genui ne financial services company (Edwards 2008). Many former employees expressed disappointment that the company no longer conducts businesses the way they used to on many different levels. However, Edwards (2008) stated that she recei ved calls from both former employees and long-standing policy owners, stating how proud they are of the company. The company was featured in Black Enterprise magazine in 2008. There ar e those that are disappointed, whom she describes as more colorful. It was a difficult transition. But insist that the there was a place for the history and leg acy of the company, arguing: Thats only going to take us so far. Legacy isnt going to help us get asset management business, performance is, be nchmarks legacy is apart of who we are how we carry ourselves, how we c onduct ourselves as professionals, that speaks volumes. When they learn about the history, theyre impressed for a moment. When the decision comes down whether or not they decided to do business with Atlanta Life, thats an ex tra nice thing, performance is mandatory, what sets us apart from everyone else. According to Ms. Edwards (2008), Atlanta Life Financial Group is the only privately held African American firm that ha s the lines of businesses that we do in this
169 country. In my examination of the former employees and the changes in the company, there were major issues regard ing employees view of new l eadership and their practices. Former employees complained and criticized new leaderships lack of understanding the legacy, as outsiders; yet Ms. Edwards believ ed her acceptance in the company was due to her HBCU background. This is an interesting dynamic due to the current employees sense of acceptance in the company. I am curious about which employees accepted her, those who still work for the company, or t hose who have already retired. The need to globalize appears to be the driving force of the company today. However, former employees idea of success did not relate to globalization. There was a different idea of success. To former employees, success meant solidarity, Black autonomy; independent of outside operation, pride, loyalty, and keep ing the Herndon tradition, in an unconventional way through social capital. Today the company represents a different plan for success, developing relationships to compete in a larger, more global market. Today the company strives for what African Americans have always want ed, an equal playing field. A field which denied many African American entrepreneur s in South leading them to an economic detour, restricted from part icipation in business on the ope n market (Oliver and Shapiro (2007), limited to the African American comm unity. This type of open market, however, comes with new technology, integrated corporations, and cultural differences in language, practices, and ideas. Employees, who experienced the changes in leadership and remained with the company, experienced many challenges dur ing the downsizing, which they were unwilling to share in detail. It is apparent that the series of downsizing altered the
170 company in a dramatic way, resulting in a new type of company, providing financial services. But, how did the company get to th is place, given its su ccess leading up to the early 1990s? Are former employees correct to conclude the decline of the company was a direct result of outside leader ship? Since former president Jesse Hills leadership, in 1992, most Atlanta Life CEOs were hired exte rnally. It is necessary to examine how incorporating new leadership outside Atlanta Life after in the early 1990s leading up to the downsizing, may have contributed to the seri es of downsizing or ev ents that affected the decline of the company. In 1991, the c ontrol of Atlanta Life Insurance Company combined assets of over $250,000,000 and the Herndon Foundation which owned 73 percent of the company, shifted to a prom inent group of outside independent foundation trustees (Jet Magazine May 6, 1991). In 1995, Atlanta Life CEO Don M. Royster resigned after three years as pres ident, to work for Life of Georgia (Jet Magazine October 30, 1995). I am not aware of his reasoning for resigning. The company appeared to be flourishi ng in 1990, purchasing Pilgrim Health and Life Insurance of Augusta, GA and Chicago Me tropolitan by the end of that year (Black Enterprise, Feb. 1990; Jet Magazine Dec. 17, 1990). This was the fourth acquisition in five years (Black Enterprise Feb.1990). Howe ver, something happened to change these winning streaks of acquisitions. Leadership ou tside Atlanta Life refers to the company hiring presidents who did not work for th e company before taking the position as CEO and board members who were not employed with Atlanta Life. However, current Atlanta Life CEO was an Atlanta Life Board member and president of Jacksons Securities. It can be argued that historically, many of the former Atlanta Life employees and officers were hired from a previous employer not affiliated with Atlanta Life. However,
171 traditionally, all Atlanta Life presidents and board members, worked for the company for a number of years, before they were appoi nted to the positions Therefore, these employees were insiders. It is clear that there were many factors that attributed to Atlanta Life changes of its fate. However, Atlanta Life surviv ed despite all its modifications, challenges, downsizes, empl oyee complaints, criticism, segregation, desegregation, and transformation of se rvices, the company continues existing.
172 RESULTS B: CIVIL RIGHTS ALICs Role in the Development of th e Local Economy of the African American community: Civil Rights Historically, Atlanta Lifes tradition charac terized justice, uplift, and success of the African American community. A tlanta Lifes impact in Atlant a and the African American community resonated in subtle ways, thr ough major contributions and financial support for the Civil Rights movement, through voter registration, hosting protest meetings, creating Civil Rights picket signs for proteste rs, and influencing and financing campaigns for political candidates. Atlanta Lifes cont ributions to Civil Right s permeate national and international history. Using archiv al data and interviews, this section explores the role of Maurice Pennington, Atlanta Life photographer, former president Jesse Hill, VP E.M. Martin, and President Norri s Herndon during the late 1950s and early 1960s, and explores the perspectives of three Atlanta Life employees and two participants in the Civil Rights movement in the 1960s and the role of segregation. Discrimination in Atlanta Inspired by the February 1960 sit-ins in Greensboro, North Carolina at Woolworth where college students demanded service, Mo rehouse College student, and leader of the movement, Lonnie King and Charles Black, al ong with other student s from the Atlanta University Center protested Richs Department store a nd ten other businesses that discriminated against Blacks. This was a stra tegic plan by the students, who represented Morehouse College, Spelman College, Cl ark College, Atlanta University,
173 Interdenominational Theological (ITC), a nd Morris Brown College. On March 15, 1960, the students launched a movement and protested in eleven different places simultaneously. King (2008) proudly stated, We created a pandemonium like you wouldnt believe in this town. On March 9, 1960, the students drafted a document, An Appeal for Human Rights; it was the only document that students drafted during the entire movement. It appeared in most of the newspapers in Atlanta, white and black, and as a paid advertisement in the Atlanta Journal Constituti on. The document demanded e qual rights and justice in education, housing, employment, voting, hospitals, restaurants, entertainment, and concerts. The Atlanta Life Photographic Coll ection contains hundreds of photos and negatives of the civil rights protests in dow ntown Atlanta. The involvement of Atlanta Life in the Civil Rights arena represented a continuous link with the broad social activism of Alonzo Herndon, reflecting the social cons ciousness of both the enterprise and its leadership (Henderson 1990:169). As Henders on adds (1990:168) As business people and influential citizens, they could not watch quietly from the sidelines as blacks waged a desperate struggle for freedom and equality in America. Instead, these individuals, frequently attempted to use their positions in business and in their communities to inspire economic, political, and cultural developm ent among African-Amer icans (Henderson 1990:168). In the 1950s-60s, Atlanta Life presid ent Norris Herndon, son of Alonzo Herndon, would many times bail protestors out of jail and other Atla nta Life executives did the same. This knowledge explains the purpose of many of the pictures in the civil rights
174 movement. In Carol Merritts in terview with Maurice Pennington6, retired Atlanta Life photographer and artist for the Atlanta Inquirer, Pennington describes other officers, like Secretary Eugene Martins role in the Ci vil Rights Movement, stating (Herndon Home Newsletter, 2001), Mr. Martin, who was the secretar y, was responsible for bailing out youngsters He made sure that they didnt ha ve to spend a lot of time in jail Atlanta Life would bail them out. Atlanta Life wa s strongly supportive of that civil rights movement. Creation of Picket Signs Atlanta Life promoted and presented pr ofessionalism even in the Civil Rights movement giving it a businesslike appearance even in the creation of picket signs for protestors. Organizer and leader of the 1960 student movement, Lonnie King, Norris Herndon and Mr. Martin wanted him to attend a meeting (King 2008). King (2008) recalls how Mr. Martin, Vice Pr esident at the time, spoke wi th King and involved artist Maurice Pennington. After Mr. Herndon saw the protest on television, Mr. Martin wanted to talk to him, King states: Pushing this move, we need to look good, its Public Relations. The worlds going to be looking. They should not see the A tlanta University Center students with rag tag signs We had the most professional l ooking signs, Martin made it very clear to me when he called me that day about those signs. He was speaking for Mr. Herndon. Cause Mr. Herndon had seen our pi cket signs and he didnt like the way they looked. And felt that if we were going to do this thing and it was right, (whispering), they needed to look good. This need to look good, reflects past conc erns about proper pres entation in public, particularly proper presentation positive ly and professionally amongst African Americans. The maintenance and creation of picket signs by the or der of Norris Herndon 6Interviews with former Atlanta Life employees were published in the Herndon Home Newsletter, 2001.
175 relates to Greenbaums discussion on respec tability about African Americans and AfroCubans in her book (2002), More than Black: Afro-Cubans in Tampa. Respectability is an attribute defined by those in power as part of the ideological r ationale for their own superior possessions and authority (G reenbaum 2002:22). Greenbaum (2002:85) describes Willard Gatewoods description of resp ectability as values of thrift, hard work, self-restraint, refined behavior, and dressqualities that might earn the esteem of white middle and upper classes, whose belief system validated such traits (Greenbaum 2002). It was only through self-segregation in the black community that a full measure of respectability could be achieved (2002:87). Therefore, even in rebellion of the Jim Crow System, respectability and pr oper presentation were important. According to an Atlanta Life affiliate, Maurice Pennington was in charge of all of the art at Atlanta Life (King 2008). Charle s Black (2008), anot her leader in the movement also shared his experience with Pennington role in crea ting the picket signs, where the company: allowed Mr. Pennington to do professional picket signs for us. Nice block letters printed on poster board we probably ha d the best looking signs in all the movement, in the whole country (laughs ), because of Maurice Pennington. Support we got from Atlanta Life. They had the independence, of course to be able to do that, their clientele was black, you know so it was not possible or easy for them to be reprised against by the establ ished community, cause they were a power into themselves, so they were able to provi de that kind of support, as were the black churches, same kind of independence, allowed them to be supportive. Mediators During the movement, the ALIC hosted w eekly meetings between students and black leaders and businesses owners (King 2008). King (2008) describes these meetings and its purpose, asserting that many of the business leaders wa nted him to explain to the
176 preachers and other leaders what the stude nts were doing. He added We were doing something all the time and so they just want ed to know what we doing and what kind of support we needed. There were Atlanta repres entatives at the meetings: Chief Actuary of Atlanta Life, Jesse Hill and other employ ees who had time to come to the meetings. This could also been a way to keep track of students militancy and intervene if needed. While many black businessmen faced th e dilemma of losing money to white businesses threats due to involvement in the Movement (King 2008), Atlanta Life established some form of stability and comp romise, acting as mediators between students and black leaders. Jesse Hill usually represen ted Atlanta Life at the meetings (Black 2008). According to Black (2008), three tiers in the black community were unofficial designations: 1) Old Guard: students who were known at the time as militant. 2) Young Turks, which included Chief Actuary of Atlanta Life then president, Jesse Hill, Clarence Coleman of the Urban League; Professor of Clark Atlanta University, Clark College at the time, Carl Holman, and first black elected to state legislature, Leroy Johnson, and other men in this ag e range were the Hunter Street, MLK side of town. 3) Older more established individuals, minister s, and businessmen. This side of town consisted of Williams Holmes Borders, Daddy King (the father of Martin Luther King, A. T. Walden, and John Calhoun. Students in the movement challenged the es tablished black community in students efforts to fight for justice and equality. Many of the Black businessmen and leaders felt that the students made their point in the protest, it was enough protesting, and the leaders could take over (Black 2008). The establ ished black community was accustomed to fighting the battle with NAACP and the cour ts. (Black 2008). The established men had their own ideas of what students should do: go back to class. The students did not agree with that position, continued their efforts, and had a year long boycott of downtown
177 Atlanta, which resulted in the desegregati on of the public accomm odations. However, the conflict between the students and older black leaders resulted in the establishment of a group called the Adult-Student Liaison Committee. There are many companies today and in the pa st of origins of ethnicities that share closeness. Atlanta Life invested in the lives of their employees as well as their community. They knew the magnitude and impact of the company in the city and country. The company used their notoriety, wea lth, and status to their advantage. Their participation in the Civil Rights Moveme nt was involved in protests and voter registration. In the summer of 1960, Atlanta Un iversity Center students boycotted an A&P store (a white owned groc ery store). However, one bl ack business owner contacted the leader of the boycott to call off the boyco tt. The business owner had a very expensive ad with the store. A&P owners threatened to pull the business owners ad if he didnt stop the boycott. The students continued the boyc ott and A&P cancelled the ad (King 2008). Some black business owners ran the risk of losing ads or their businesses, however, Atlanta Life was so established, their sense of security led them to become mediators (King 2008) Atlanta Life employees also participated in the protests. Former Atlanta Life employee, Evelyn Amos (2008), who worked for Atlanta Life from 1947 to the 1990s, describes her experience picketing in downtow n Atlanta in front of Richs department store. Ms. Amos states, I went a whole month there. I was kind of nervous; you know I said to myself, I hope these white people don t bother me. Some Atlanta Life clerks picketed. If employees were arrested, th e company would bail them out; non-employees,
178 were bailed out of jail as well (Franklin 2008). Evelyn Amos (2008) recalls why she decided to protest stating: I just thought nothing a bout it cause Martin Luth er King, well his sister, Christine; we were in the same class from elementary school to Lab High. ML, we called him ML was younger of cour se...his sister called him ML, everybody else called him that. When they star ted the civil rights movement, well you know naturally I was interested for two reasons being black and for the fact that I knew him...so I wanted to be involved for those two reasons Motives: Sacrifice vs. Incentives Atlanta Life leaders supported the Afri can American community, yet accumulated wealth at the same time. These dual acts could have been normal to black business, particularly during the Civil Ri ghts Movement. It is difficult to determine the amount of tension Atlanta Life leaders and officers contended with in the review of the contradiction of uplift and economic growth. For them, economic growth and uplift of the African American community may not have been viewed as a contradiction at all. The company did contribute to the racial solidar ity in Atlanta through participating in the Civil Rights movement. The companys involveme nt put them in the forefront, socially and economically. The company used its re sources: advertising, public relations, connections, success, and wealth to take on in justices head on. This publicity also could have encouraged or influenced the African American community to obtain insurance from Atlanta Life; it could have be en a great advertising tool. On one hand, the company followed the tr adition and legacy of Alonzo Herndons uplift and racial equality, ye t they also followed the business tradition to accumulate wealth. The lines are blurry determining ec onomic, social, and/or conscious motives in the fight for social justice and equality during this period. The values and structure of the
179 firm reflected these issues perfectly. Alonz o Herndons life and legacy epitomized these values. As one of the nine men in the Niag ara Movement in July 1905, which resulted in the creation on the NAACP (Merritt 2004), th e first organized effort of African Americans to demand full citizenship (Merri tt 2004:73), Alonzo Herndon, understood the importance of the uplift of Black people. However, Alonzo Herndon was also a business man. As Kimbro and Hill reveal in their book Think and Grow Rich: A Black Choice (1992:61) about Herndons view on making money, stating, E ven in the later years, he (Herndon) refused to apologize for his copious ta ste, America is a capitalistic country, and I am a capitalist, he told those close to him. Atlanta Life functioned in a capitalistic society; they were a part of the Ameri can economic system. The company maneuvered through this system, benefitting economically by the African American community. One of Atlanta Lifes missions was to uplift th e African American community; however, their goal as a company was to increase business fi nancially. Therefore, th ere is a question of incentives vs. sacrifice behind this uplift. Was ALICs altruism a genuine strategy to strengthen the black community or were ther e motives behind this in order for the ALIC to establish more wealth and power for themselves as a company? There may not have been motives of up lift to establish wealth and power, for African American businesses derived from a more communa l form of organization and gradually changed to a more capitalisti c characteristic (Greenbaum 1991). In Greenbaums (1991:104) article on compari ng African American and Euro-American Mutual Aid Societies, she states, Black mu tual benefit societies by the turn of the century were becoming increasingly entrep reneurial, with a declining emphasis on fraternalism and ritual. The insurance busines s of Atlanta Life, which originated as a
180 mutual aid society, played a vital role in capitalizing the developm ent of businesses and homeownership in Black communities. Atlant a Lifes expansion and economic growth could have also contributed to the comp anys direction. This growth changed the traditional overlaps between family, residential, and occupational ties. According to Greenbaum (1991: 99), The larger the group, the greater potential for converting this combination into an important source of collective capital. However, increasing size inevitably attenuated intimacy and growth in scale conditioned hierar chal structures. Poet and ethnographer Sterling Browns documentation of African Americans experiences in the south dur ing the 1940s, are described in Tidwell and Sanders book, Sterling A. Browns: A Negro Looks at the South (2007: 171). Br owns interview with insurance executive E. M. Martin, secretar y of Atlanta Life, Ma rtin describes the reasoning for promoting and exhibiting the motion picture The Parade of Negro Progress, by Atlanta Life Insurance Compa ny, highlighting Negro life such as the Negro hospital in St. Louis, a commencement at Atlanta University and the celebration at Daytona Cookman Institute (now Bethune-C ookman University) during Mrs. Eleanor Roosevelts visit for Dr. Mary McLeod Be thunes anniversary (Tidwell and Sanders 2007:171). The machinery for the film be longed to the company and a photographer was employed for the filming and showi ng (Tidwell and Sanders 2007). From Browns interview with Martin, Brown describes Martins motivation for the film stating, Martin candidly admitted that the primary object of th e film was to make money, but in a clean honest way, he said, to build friendships, a nd to show others wh at were doing Martin believes the film to be worth thousands of dollars of adver tisement to the businesses and colleges pictured, but he settles for good w ill to the company. (Tidwell and Sanders
181 2007:171). Did these acts of kindness towards th e community serve as a cushion or back up if confronted with accusations of a profit-only business? This idea of profiting, hidden behind uplift, mirrors what Weems (2002:405) describes as the black businessman as vi llain thesis, a school of thought which is a similar critique to Abram Harris ideas in his book The Negro As Capitalist, (1936) describing the idea where black-owned businesses exploited lower class black consumers (Weems 2002:406). Harris argues (1936:50), th at black middle class businesses owners promoted racial pride and unity as a cove r-up to gain black s upport for middle classcontrolled businesses. However, Weems disput es this and (2002:407) argues If Harriss assertions contained an element of truth, it appears the majority of African American enterprises during this period where either single proprieto rship or tenuous partnerships and corporations. In addition Weems also describes Ralph Bunches support of this black villain theory that argues that (2002) despite black businessmen appeal to race and pride and loyalty, the black businessm an is not, distinguished by his civicmindedness, his efforts and sacrifices on behalf of his group. Did the companys altruism lead to lost income for social gain and trust of the African American community? Did the company lose income in assisting community? Contradictions: Civil Rights, Jim Crow, and Herndon Barbershop The companys participation in the Civ il Rights Movement called into question traditional practices and laws surrounding one of the Herndon Barbershops. In November 1965, members of the Southern Christian Leadership Council pr otested the Herndon Barber Shop for only serving whites. The protesto rs sat in all the chairs at the shoe shine stand in the shop and refused to leave until they were served. The protestors soon left
182 when the barbers refused to serve them and the shop closed for the day (Atlanta Daily World 1965). The shops owner reminded the pr otestors that the Civil Rights Act of 1964 excluded barbershops that are not loca ted in hotels or other places of public accommodations. When one of the protestors asked why Blacks could not receive any haircuts, the barber replied that he did not know how to cut that nasty, kinky stuff. However, a few days after the incident Blacks were able to get their hair cut, with the stipulation that not too many Blacks come at one time (Britton, 1965) The irony in all this is that Alonzo Herndon owned, designed, and ran this barbershop. Although at some point, Norris He rndon sold the shop to the barbers, the shops history of whites only continued until 1965. Martin Luther King, leader of the SCLC received money from Atlanta Life, and Atlanta Life contributed thousands of dollars toward the civil rights movement, yet the barbers at Herndon Barbershop, the original trade of the founde r of Atlanta Life, refused to support and serve Black customers. What would have Alonzo Herndon done if he were alive duri ng this time? It is uncertain whether Atlanta Life officers fought to integrate the one business, which they could have easily influenced to integrate. This calls for further examination of class, particularly exploring ideas surrounding kinky hair. Hi gh society services by Blacks excluded Blacks and their hair, viewing black hair as bad, unmanageable, and nasty. These same black barbers were excluding and criticizing themselves. One has to question if money motivated th ese actions or barbers were protecting their up scaled, whitened image of Herndon Barbershop, preservi ng the tradition to th e best service. Although Alonzo Herndon capitalized on Jim Crow laws through his barbershops, his insurance company capitalized on Black customers, keeping the two very separate.
183 This had to be a dilemma for Atlanta Life officers, including Alonz os son Norris, during the height of the Civil Rights movement. It could have been embarrassing for the company in 1965 to face the challenges of the shop of the man who promoted the economic stability and rights for Black peopl e. However, Alonzo Herndon was not a man in the forefront for fighting for equalit y. He let his money talk, promoting Black economic autonomy, and self-sufficiency. His son followed a similar path, quietly supporting the African American commun ity economically, providing financial assistance in the Civil Rights Movement, a nd supporting other orga nizations and their causes. This protest challenges racial and social solidarity of the African American community. Political Campaigns and Atlanta Life Atlanta Life supported the political camp aign of former Mayor, the late Maynard Jackson. Elected in 1973, Atlantas first Af rican American mayor, winning over 85% of the citys Black vote (Tuck 2001), changed th e face of the city and helped provide opportunities for Blacks. As current Vice Mayor at the time, and grandson of cofounder of the Atlantas Voters League, John Wesley Dobbs, Maynard Jackson had personal ties to the elder generation ((Kruse 2005:236). J ackson demonstrated that it was time for Blacks to reach for the citys highest o ffice (Kruse 2005: 236). He was committed to redirecting economic development to the sout h metro area and he was determined to use newly enacted affirmative action programs to gain construction of jobs for black firms and a large portion of airport jobs for othe r blacks (Keating 2001: 25). Atlanta Life was the main source for Mayor Maynard Jackson s induction into office. Within the same year of Maynard Jacksons election in 1973, Jesse Hill became Atlanta Lifes third
184 president. Hill became Jacksons campaign manager (Harmon 1996). Evonne Night (2008) describes Atlanta Lifes role in voter registration a nd the mayoral campaign in the late 60s early 70s, But when Maynard Jack son in 1973 was elected, it just shocked the nation We put him in office .Jesse Hill was his campaign manager... So anything that Maynard Jackson needed, it came through this company . Jesse Hill was able to do just whatever Maynard Jackson needed to help him cause we needed a leader out there. Atlanta Life Insurance insisted that all their employees register to vote. Atlanta Life also printed voter regi stration materials at minimal cost (Tuck 2001:62), promoting autonomy, and independence, providing more power. Jackson remained in office until 1981, when he was succeeded by Andrew Young, th e same year that Atlanta first had a Black majority city council. Jacksons vi ctory also reinforced black middle class involvement in the citys business and social affairs. Jesse Hill became the first black officer at the Atlanta Chamber of Commerce a nd even served a term as president at the end of the decade (Tuck 2001:223). Community Involvement For years, Atlanta Life has given dona tions to NAACP, Urban League, SCLC, and the Butler Street YMCA (Carol Edwards 2008) The Butler Street YMCA was not very far from the Atlanta Life Building, just like many other organizations, therefore Atlanta Lifes community involvement and connections to organizations were no surprise. This involvement extended to employees ch ildren. Helen Franklins son wanted to attend Georgia Tech; however, he had to take a college entrance exam. Jesse Hill, president and board member at that time, of fered to help and got someone to tutor Ms. Franklins son. Mr. Hill would do things like offering and do things like that for others.
185 The company would help anybody the same way. They were always doing something. Atlanta Life was a big part of th e community, (2008) she stated. Lonnie King whos known about Atlanta Life since 1945, and did not live far from the YMCA, (2008:3) states, There s no way you can be in the black community in Atlanta and not know about Atlant a Life and the Herndon family. This community involvement still exists t oday. In 2006, Atlanta Life Fi nancial Group established the Alonzo F. Herndon Scholarship through 100 Black Men7 of Atlantas Project Success (Atlanta Life News October 2, 2006) For Atla ntas Gospel Choice aw ards, Atlanta Life Financial group put together a CD to work out a deal for the awards that would enable artists to perform on stage (Edwards 2008). The Financial Group still has a connection with Herndon Elementary, assisting the sc hool in building a playground (Edwards 2008). Campaign today Atlanta Life Contribution The Atlanta Life Financial Group played a role in contributing to the 2008 presidential campaign. The company assisted and supported the politic al aspirations of others and African American communities Civil Rights Activist King, states, The people who are carrying the legacy of Atlanta Life now in my view are still true to the original intent and mission, and hopes of Mr. Herndon and Mr. Martin. By this I mean I formed a coalition, called a Coalition fo r New Georgia, which included 1000 black churches in the state of GA. King and hi s teams goal were to register 100,000 black registered voters in time for the Novemb er election. Every Sunday preachers preach about registering, and his group supplied church es registration forms, registering almost 200,000 in 2008. The first major contribution to Coalition came from Atlanta Life (King 7 100 Black Men of America was founded in 1963 to meet to explore ways of improving conditions in African American community.
186 2008). The legacy still exists today. They do it behind the scenes; people dont know its going on its the invisible hand of Atlanta Life, stated King. Atlanta Lifes wealth went beyond th e African American community. Although the companys customers were mostly Black, their wealth exceeded many white companies. From some employees and Atlanta residents view, Atlanta Life acquired the ability to compete with top white businesses. Herndon descendant and former chairman of the board, Oliver Nelson (2008) states: We created a company that was able to ma tch its own with other companies in the United States. The Atlanta Life was an outstanding insurance company. We insured people all over the country. I mean we are mostly in the southeastern part of the country; but had become an outsta nding individual as a company. And that was reflecting one thing, that black folks got as much sense as white folks. Lonnie King (2008) also discussed th e power of Atlanta Life and company leaders different roles, People like E. M. Martin was the most powerful next to Mr. Herndon, black man in town, in the business worl d. Martin had a lot of influence. He ran a hundred billion dollar institution in the blac k community. White folks didnt have that kind of money. Segregation: Strengthening the Relati onship between ALIC and the African American community and its Economic development African Americans faced a unique dilemm a of black business contending with Jim Crow laws. This economic segregation in which John Sibley Butler describes as an economic detour (1991:144; Stuart 1970) is what make s the African American experience unique. Segregation posted many negative aspects: 1) Preventing blacks, particularly businessmen and women to compet e in a larger market (Oliver and Shapiro 2007:103), restricting them to their own group or servicing whites only, limiting
187 economic success on a larger scale; 2) Lim iting black consumers to purchase goods and acquire insurance in a larger market preven ting business in a larger market. Despite this, African Americans developed businesses by any means availa ble. Therefore, Atlanta Life thrived on the crest of segregation (M erritt 2002:84), strengthe ning the relationships between the company and the community, and economic development. For Alonzo Herndon, his accumulation of wealth, paying the $5000 Georgia Law tax to maintain the insurance company, came through the lines of segregation. As former Atlanta Life employee Oliver Nelson (2008) states, Mr. Herndon made his money in segregation; opened a barber shop on Peachtree Street. Thats where he made his money; the money that enabled him to open up the Atla nta Life Insurance Company to start it Mr. Nelson (2008:4) adds, Cause when they started, think how the black companies grew so Mr. Herndon started At lanta Life from barbershop money from white people; he made a whole lot of money. Therefore, it was through segregation, the benefits of white money that Herndon was able to star t or maintain the company. This was the reality of most African Ameri can businesses during Jim Crow. Segregation also enabled black businessmen to accumulate more wealth from the Black community, resulting in more class differences enabling a larger gap in the Black community, contributing to the continuance of poverty of the larger African American community. Segregation enabled blacks to carve out social spaces within which alternative visions of societ y and community could thrive (Glenn 2002: 127). In these spaces, blacks built an oppositional culture, one that emphasized collectivist values, mutuality, and fellowships (Glenn 2007:127); it placed company leaders in a position to uplift the community, while black business ow ners at the same time could accumulate
188 wealth. Segregation served as a function to benefit wealthy owners of the company, but not necessarily for all of th e African American community. In this position, questions then arise: Was it black businessmens fault for this position to be responsible for the entire black impoverished masses? Or was it the larger white societys fault? Were black businesses owners, like Atlanta Life, simply responding to the circumstances given to them, or was the Company exploiting individuals from their own groups? It was inevitable for strong relationshi ps to develop between ALIC and the African American community. Segregation forced people together. Within this space, the company provided a service for the communit y, resources, and racial uplift. Whether these relationships were harmonious or not, segregation connected the business and the community. ALICs economic development was founded on the lines of segregation occurring through obtaining all black clientele. For Atlanta Life segregation was the impetus that strengthened the relationships, by what Edward Lyons (2007) called default; stating, You know in the thirties, and fortie s, and fifties, a lo t of black people did business with Atlanta Life because they were not courted by the majority companies. And so as a result to some extent by default we got a lot of these clients. Lyons compared the company to restaurants during segregation in th e fifties, arguing that blacks could not go to Ruths Steakhouse, so instead, blacks went to Moms Kitchen, and by default if a person of color wanted to eat, he or sh e was limited. Atlanta Life obtained black customers because they could not go anywhe re else, strengthening relationships because Atlanta Life did not have to compete with white businesses; it was automatic to have business for black customers. (See Jacksons interview with J. Cole on American Beach 2009; and additional Jackson articles 2005, 2006).
189 Segregation also provided qualified Bl acks with white collar jobs. Former employee Harriet Adams (2008) argued that she tried to get a job, every time, and the job that she would apply for, she could not get it. Ms. Adams states, I was so glad to get a black company that was hiring people you went to these white companies they wasnt hiring any blacks and then the other jobs that you would go to, theyll tell you that you overqualified for those jobs but you couldn t get the ones that you were qualified for. Therefore, segregation strengthened re lationships for employees in economic development. Lastly, segregation enabled the company to see about the communitys needs in a way that larger soci ety or whites would not provide. From employees picketing, creating and providing money for picketing signs, bailing protestors out of jail, assisting in re gistering people to vote, to mediating between student protestors and Black businessmen, A tlanta Life Insurance Company established themselves as key figures and financial s upporters within the Civil Rights movement.
190 RESULTS C: THE HERNDO N HOME MUSEUM I first learned about the Herndon Home Mu seum through the yellow pages. I was looking for a job. I had previous museum expe rience, and I figured I could easily get a job as a tour guide. Alonzo Herndon and his story were unknown to me. Why hadnt I heard about this mans life and history? As I learned of Mr. Herndons dream, success, and legacy and witnessing first hand the po ssibly of it being lost his life brought more value and meaning to me as well as a fear of future generations never knowing about it. I actually worked for the museum twice; once as a tour guide, str uggling to make ends meet during graduate school. I soon had to qui t, for classes, an assistantship, and an outside job, took its toll. I eventu ally re-applied for the job afte r graduation as an archival assistant to work on the Preserving a Busine ss Legacy grant. In the process of sorting through the images to develop the Atlanta Li fe Photographic Collect ion, I knew that I had more value in my hands than anyone could imagine. It was history in my hands, in which I controlled how and when it would be presented and pres erved. Control and power are key words that define this section. For, those who are in power, control how lives and legacies should be remembered or not remembered at all. This portion of the results section ex plores the challenges and processes of preservation and maintenance of the Her ndon Home museum, the Herndon Family papers and artifacts, and the Atlanta Life Insu rance Company Photographic Collection. In addition, this section examines the challenges of preservation and per ceptions of value of
191 the historic buildings that represent the legacy, history, and life of Alonzo Herndon, his family, and his company, exploring Herndon-re lated buildings. I attempted to answer what the possible closing of the Herndon Home Museum meant for memories and heritage and the people now passed who were re presented there. I also hoped to answer what the physical structure meant as a symbol of Herndon's success, and what it will mean for memories of these accomplishments if the home8 were torn down. Therefore, I interviewed former museum employees and talked with key informants about the museum and the companys value and legac y, and conducted particip ant observation at the museum, in the process. I also examin e the role of the Herndon Museum Board and their relationship to the fate of the museum and other Herndon related buildings in the downtown area of Atlanta. As I stated in pr evious chapters, my previous employment provided me with necessary connections to e xplore the issues surrounding the fate of the Herndon Home Museum. It was not an easy task to write field notes and conduct participant observation, for I struggled with my own personal feelings towards the drastic changes at the Herndon museum, while critica lly examining and observing these changes as an anthropologist. Unexpected Loss In James Oliver Hortons Landmarks of African American History (2005:8), he writes, The landmarks of American history ha ve a vital role to play in helping us to understand our past, because they are its physic al evidence. The sensory experience of a place can help us to construct historical events, just as archaeologists reconstruct vanished civilizations. It can also inspire us to empathize with those who came before 8 The Herndon Home and Herndon museum are the same facilities. I use them interchangeably throughout the dissertation.
192 us. The physical evidence of the life of Alonzo Herndons are either gone, disappearing or at great risk. There are five Herndon-re lated buildings in or near the downtown area on Auburn Avenue, once the hub of African Am erican businesses, which have been either demolished, at risk, or possibly overlooke d, in threat of the disappearance of the Herndon legacy from the landscape. The Henr y Rucker building, the old Atlanta Life building and Annex, the Herndon building, the current Atlanta Life building, and the Herndon Home museum; are located on Aubur n Avenue, except for the Herndon Home, located on the Morris Brown College campus. Herndon-related refers buildings or properties that were occupied, constructed, or affiliated with Alonzo Herndon and his company, Atlanta Life. Herndon Related Buildings Henry Rucker Building The Rucker Building was the first offi ce building for African Americans in Atlanta, owned by African American business owner Henry Rucker (Hamilton, 2002). Located on the corner of Auburn and Piedm ont Avenues in downtown Atlanta, the building was constructed in 1904. This was the first office space for Atlanta Life (Henderson 1990:13; Stuart 1970:120). In 1927, the building was remodeled with a style influence by Alonzo Herndons design of his mansion, company building, and barbershops (Horton 2005). Th e Rucker building was torn do wn after being struck by a sport utility vehicle in 2001 (Auchmutey 2008). Herndon Plaza, Old Atlanta Life Building, and Annex The old Atlanta Life Insurance office bu ilding was established by Alonzo Herndon in
193 1905. Atlanta Life was one of three financial institutions that were all headquartered in the Sweet Auburn district that served Blacks in Atlanta before the civil rights movement, for more than half a century (The Ne w Georgia Encyclopedia-2009). Originally a residence, (Hamilton 2002), in 1927, the building was given a Beaux Arts style facelift (Merritt 2002). In 1936, an annex was added, also in the Neoclassical style of the original building. When Atlanta Life moved into a new headquarters in 1980, it became vacant for many years, and sold to the Historic Dist rict Development Corporation (HDDC) in 1997. Pending funding, HDDC has plans to renovate it (Pousner 2009). In November 2009, the building was listed as one of 2010 Places in Peril by the Georgia Trust for Historic Preservation, along with Morris Brown Co llege, where the Herndon Home museum resides. Morris Brown College was the first school in Georgia founded and funded exclusively by African-Americans. Both the bui lding and the college were named to the Trusts roster of sites threatened by de molition, neglect, lack of maintenance, inappropriate development or insensitiv e public policy (Burns 2009). The Herndon buildings are boarded up, have been vandalized over the years and suffer from a lack of maintenance. Custom wood awnings, door fram es, marble floors, and hallways are in disrepair. The HDDC is in the process of hiri ng an architect and contractor for the project and is applying for Historical Preservation Certification to receive federal tax credits (The Georgia Trust 2009) Current Atlanta Life Building The six story 100,000 square foot Atlanta Life Financial Group building houses an auditorium and a commemorative area in honor of founder Alonzo Herndon and his
194 son Norris (Register for ALIC Record s 2004, SIC_B3_F2_Ground_Breaking_Press Kit 1978). On June 26, 1978, Alonzo Herndons birt hday, the company celebrated its ground breaking ceremony where Coretta Scott King and Georgia Governor George Busbee spoke and praised the company as one of th e strongest life insurance companies in the industry (RiffleManning, Selvage and Lee 1978; Atlanta, Atlanta Life Insurance Company Records). The building was comple ted in 1980, and Atlanta Life celebrated its grand opening with a highly publicized program. Atlanta Life occupied all of the floors of the new building. Today non-Atlanta affilia ted companies and organizations occupy the other floors in the building. Atlanta Li fe rents out space in the building that once occupied all Atlanta Life employees and depart ments. Although the building is not at risk for closing or demolition, the building that was once built as a symbol of black progress and a productive future for A tlanta Life employees, now opera tes as landlords to outside organizations and businesses. Herndon Building The 1924 Herndon Building was one of the city's early office complexes for black professionals. The four-story structure at 239 Auburn Ave, on the corner of Jesse Hill Drive and Auburn Avenue, offered 60 offices for African-American professionals and organizations, six storefronts and hotel space. The Herndon Building has housed the NAACP, Atlanta Urban League, The Savoy Hote l, Galanti Brothers Delicatessen and many black physicians. Catering to the new automobile age, Alonzo Herndon built the building and provided underground parking and a gas station ne xt door. At the top of the faade, Herndon signed his creation with mas onry that spelled out the year of the
195 buildings completion and the first initial of the Herndon surname: "2H4 (Atlanta Preservation Center 2003). In 2003, the Atlant a Preservation Center placed the Herndon Building on its list of most endangered stru ctures. The building had been vacant and decaying for many years.In March of 2008, the Herndon building was damaged beyond repair in a tornado that rippe d through downtown Atlanta. It was left partially collapsed, raining red bricks on a police precinct in a c onverted filling station next door. As a result the building was demolished (Auchmutey 2008). The Herndon Home Museum The residence of Atlanta Life founder and family was designed without any blue prints, by Alonzo Herndons wife Adrienne McNeil Herndon. The Hendon mansion was built in 1910, by all Black craftsmen; the home is a two-story brick structure whose style is of Beaux Arts Classical. The home interior is a mix of styles from traditions of the Italian Renaissance, French Rococo, Ameri can Arts and Crafts with mahogany paneling, oak parquet floorings, Venetian objects and be veled glass windows. As a memorial to his mother and to continue the familys philanthropy to protect the future of Atlanta Life and the mansion (Merritt 2002:213), Norris B. Herndon the only son of Alonzo and Adrienne, established the Alonzo F. and Norris B. Herndon Foundation in 1950. The home was open for tours in the 1980s with free ad mission. However, in 2001, the Home began admission fees. The museum has suffered the threat of closing many times, facing breakins, vandalism, loitering, neglec t, the constant transition of volunteers and staff, faulty machinery, and water damage. In 2007, the Georgia Trust for Historic Preservation placed the home on its list of Places in Pe ril, citing the water damage (Suggs, Atlanta
196 Journal Constitution, 2009). Yet the home is sill standing, facing more challenges. These five sites represent the life of Alonzo Herndon, two of which, no longer exist. Today, I am unaware of how people view these buildings. During my interviews and observations, there was not much talk a bout these buildings. A lthough there are a few historic markers on Auburn Avenue, one which recognize Herndon and Atlanta Life, there are not visible texts or images to pa int a picture of the history of the Herndonrelated sites and buildings. On my last visit to Atlanta, as I walked down Auburn Avenue, there were gaps of empty spaces between buildings. I remember on my walking tour taking pictures, standing in front of vacan t properties, I wondered, what was this building? It must have been a historic one. Every time I would come back to visit Atlanta, a building was missing. However, I did not realize th at some of these buildings were connected to Alonzo Herndon and Atlant a Life. Although there are some historic markers on the Auburn Avenue sidewalks, most people would not know what sat in those empty spaces in passing. I tr ied to recreate what Auburn Av enue must have been like during its height of success, and what it must have meant for Mr. Herndon to look down the Avenue and see his achievement through th e representation of th e buildings. Success was not simply wealth; it was al so seen through these buildings. Mr. Herndon may never have thought that these buildi ngs would no longer stand or forgotten. In this regar d, heritage rests in the buildings painting a visible picture of history. This heritage through visible space is rapidly diminishing. Heritage not only gives buildings, precincts, and ways of life that are no longer viable for one reason or another a second life as exhi bits of themselves: it also produces something new
197 (Kirschenblatt-Gimblett 1995). Heritage requires protection of what Barbara Kirshenblatt-Gimblett (1995:370) identifies as adding value. She argues that heritage adds value to existing assets that have eith er ceased to be viable like subsistence lifestyles, obsolete technologi es, abandoned mines, and the ev idence of past disasters. She states (1995:150), Heritage organizations en sure that places and practices in danger of disappearing because they are no longer occupied or functioning or valued will survive. It does this by adding the value of pastness, exhibition, difference, and where possible indigeneity. The value of visual representations of black success, racial solidarity, and African American community involvements worth has become less and less. Preservation and Data Collection Challenges In the mid summer of 2009, I received word that the museum was closing on July 31, 2009. Shocked, but not surprised, I immediately began to arrange to travel to Atlanta. In July of 2009, two weeks before its closi ng, when I arrived in Atlanta to conduct the final stages of my research, I went straight to the Herndon Home. As I turned down the street, and came upon the home, I first noticed a white covering around the top of one of the columns and the edges of the roof. The home has never looked in such poor conditions. The homes basement which housed the office, Herndon family artifacts, documents, and photos, was unorganized; ever ything looked moved around, tables were missing, boxes and books. As I made my way th rough the basement, I could feel the heat, and moisture in the home. There were one or two little fans keeping the rooms cool. I knew immediately that the photos, documents, a nd artifacts were in danger. The smell of
198 water, made me more nervous. How could it get to this point? What happened? I immediately went to the back where the arch ives were located, and boxes that were once placed strategically for preservation, proces sing, sorting were moved and missing from its original space. Before I moved Tampa, I marked some boxes Important to prevent anyone from mistakenly throwing away hist oric and valuable phot os or documents. However, the boxes were piled on top of each ot her in a disorganized manner in a corner; the actual corner where some of the wa ter damages occurred. Although the museum basement has always lacked space, I had neve r seen the home in this condition. This was devastating to witness. Because of my e xperiences, it was necessary to speak with individuals who loved and worked for the muse um to get their perspective of what the home stands for in the city of Atlanta and the African American community. First, it is important to understand challenges of the museum and its background. Museum Board The museum board is made up seven members. All board members are African American entrepreneurs, CEOs of businesses in real estate and i nvestment management, IT professional services companies, political offices, lawyers, architecture, and education. One of the members is a Herndon descenden t; a foundation requirement. There is not a structure process of how board members are c hosen. However, in the past board members were in some way related to Atlanta Li fe or connected to the Herndon family. Museum Maintenance For years, the museum faced challenges of maintenan ce. As a non-profit, it is difficult to operate a museum without the pr oper funding to obtain proper equipment and
199 technology. For instance, in my attempt to s can some of the photos from the collection, after spending almost an hour attempting to fi x the machine, the s canner would not work. The copier machine did not function, a nd other necessary equipment for daily maintenance for staff was not provided. These challenges would prevent researchers from copying or recording documents and images and daily tasks for employees and volunteers. In 2008, the home survived a major stor m, and in April 2009, a terrible wind storm, caused a 100-year-old tree to fall and damage the homes columns and gutters. The columns have not been fixed yet. Heavy rain resulted in water leakage and water damage in the home. As a result, the home su ffers from mildew and mold, particularly in the basement. The mold and mildew have settled in the archives room. As I was conducting archival research, examining the Herndon family and Atlanta Life photos and documents, I begin to get a headache and a so re throat. The room was too hot and moist. As I sat on the floor to review the boxes, my eyes began to burn. I could not stay in the room or the basement for a long time. Therefor e, my visits at the Herndon Home lasted twenty to thirty minutes. I would not have been surprised if any of the staff and volunteers were sick. After observation and que stions, the staff and volunteers had been experiencing respiratory and ot her health issues. However, th ey would not say that if was home-related. Water damage also occurs wh en the leaves are not removed from the gutters. If no one maintains this duty, the water sits on the roof, causing damage. Therefore, it is necessary to have an adequate amount of staff and daily maintenance of the home. Although natural disasters are unavoidable, the museum faced many threats
200 long before the storms hit the city of Atlanta. In 2005, when I requested in a series of letters, permission to conduct research at the museum, I also requested to have the A tlanta Life Photographic Collection moved to the Auburn Avenue Research Library, since th e library already housed the Atlanta Life documents. In July of 2009, some of the Herndon papers were moved to the Atlanta Life building. Unfortunately, shortly after some of the papers were moved, in September 2009, the Atlanta Life building suffered water damage and flooding. It is unknown whether the documents were damaged. Some of the Herndon papers were moved to the Auburn Avenue Research Libr ary (Bonner 2009), but it is uncl ear if the water damage led to this decision. Although m oving the documents could help to save the collections from possible future natural disasters, if any items are moved, they face the risk of being lost, stolen, or misplaced. The home has experienced a series of unw anted guests. It was broken into twice with thieves stealing historic and valuable artifacts and parts from air conditioning units. In October 2008, thieves strate gically dismantled the bevele d glass near the front door, and stole three pieces of silver. On Ma y 18, 2009, the copper from humidifiers air unit were stolen (Richards 2009), disabling the museums air conditioning, outside and in the boiler room, resulting in the heat and moisture problems One former employee found that homeless people were sleeping on the porch in the front. She also mentioned that one afternoon someone banged on the door during work hours, adding that people knew when she would leave the museum, and therefore sh e was concerned for her safety. Based on these issues, the volunteers and staff are at risk. In June 2009, someone attempted to
201 break in the carriage house; the storage space of the Herndon exhibit materials and other Herndon items (Richards 2009). Another former employee also believed that the home is vulnerable to squatters and damage (Lowe 2009). During my employment from July 2003 to June 2004, the museum employed five staff members, and at least three volunteers. After the dismissal of the first director in 2005, the museum employed only two to three st aff members, including the director. The foundation fired executive director in 2005, in an attempt to redefine its mission (Suggs 2009, Atlanta Journal Constitution). From April 2008 to July 2009, the museum has had up to twenty volunteers, working at different times. However, since the museums last transition in summer of 2009, it is uncertain if there are any volunteers who work at the museum. Although there have been a consistent number of volunteers lack of staff has been a constant challenge. Often, staff woul d have multiple responsibilities: answering phones, conducting tours, schedul ing appointments, assisting with events, assisting in preserving artifacts and documents, cleani ng, checking the home for any changes or damages, and ensuring proper transactions of photographic loans. This is common for a small, private museum. In a 2009 article of the Atlanta Journa l Constitution, it was reported that the foundation fired the director (Suggs; September 8, 2009), l eaving the home again with out anyone to run the museum properly. The home has had a consistency of two staff members who worked as associates, in past to oversee the museum. A representative from the foundation board stated We really wanted to have more focused times. There were a couple of days a week when no one came. And as you can imagine, having an
202 executive director comes in at a higher cost. We are just trying to focus resources in the best manner possible. However, the home is operated without the proper leadership to maintain its daily operations: preserving the documents, photos, and artifacts, recruiting volunteers, bringing in funds, da ily visitors with tours, a nd overseeing maintenance. In her report (2009) on the Herndon Home muse um, PSA Atlanta repor ter, Jeanne Bonner also found that the home is facing hard time Bonner interviewed se veral representatives of the Herndon home and preservationist, Jean ne Cyrique of the Georgia Department of Natural Resources. Cryrique argued that without set visiting hours or an executive director, the home will struggle to maintain itself, questioning if the home is never open, how are you going to get people to help keep it open. For any non-profit organization, particular ly a small-private museum, funding can be a great challenge. According to a recen t article in the Atlanta Journal Constitution, budget restraints have forced the homes admi nistrators to trim the staff, and tours are now available by appointment only (Gumbrech t 2009). However, according to Jeanne Cyriaque, preservationists of the Georgia Department of Natural Resources, the foundation has done a poor job of asking for help and partnering with other groups to help fund the museum (Bonner 2009), stating, Y ou have to build long time partnerships to position your self to fundraise. A f oundation board member (Suggs 2009) stated We are reducing our non-essential costs. Although another board member agreed that the foundation was slow to shift more activ e fundraising (Bonne r 2009), the foundation board removed the key force to raise funds the museums director, both in 2005 and 2009. I am curious how the foundation board defines non-essential costs.
203 When Norris Herndon established the founda tion, he did not want to charge admission for visitors to tour the home. Th e home received money from Atlanta Life. However, Atlanta Life faces its own challe nges. According to former employee, Ms. Lowe, Norris thought that the home would alwa ys exist. Ms. Low argued that Norris figured that the home would al ways be opened, she states, I f the company closed down, there would be enough left behind to mainta in the home. Until 2001, the home charged an admission fee due to lack of funds; in itially $1.00, then it increased to $3.00 for students, and $5.00 for adults. The staff had to find ways to raise money, whether through grant writing or hosting events. Bonner (2009) found that th e board moved some of th e documents to the Auburn Avenue Research Library, to free space for priv ate paid receptions, and in the future, the foundation will actively seek donations to put the homes finances back on track. However, freeing space for private paid recepti ons does not alleviate the risk of damage to the artifacts and documents. Yet, during my observation and meeting with former employee, in the summer of 2009, some of the documents were moved to the Atlanta Life building. It is uncertain if all of documents are at the Library. In 2005, the foundations goal was to fi nd sponsors to fund the effort to determine how the story should be told, and identify ways to use technology to tell it (Suggs 2005). However, based on the homes condition, efforts to find sponsors have been unsuccessful. Five years after the initia l closing, funding is still a major issue with the home. Initially the reasoning for the mu seums closing was redefining goals and technology; today the reasoning is unclear. Although funding is an issue, the termination
204 of the director contradicts the needs to f unction to operate and maintain the museum. Inconsistencies of Museum Closing Since 2005, there have many inconsistenc ies surrounding the museums closing. In 2005, the board fired the dire ctor and all staff, who were told that the museum was closing. However, the boards chairman mainta ined that the museum was not closed. Yet, for several months, the museum went without staff and maintenance, resulting in water damage from the rooftop and other problem s. Shortly after, one staff member was brought back to operate the home. In 2009, em ployees were told that the doors to the home were closing on July 31st (Richards 2009). However, the foundation chair stated that the museum was not closing, and the cu rrent director was reprimanded for making false statements. However, the directors employment did not c ontinue after July 31st. After her departure, that same staff member was brought back to operate and maintain the home. Former employee, Rita Lowe argued that in 2005, the staff was never given a reason for closing. Employees also never received a letter of termination (Lowe 2009). Lowe stated, We were completely clueless of the home closing down (Lowe 2009). In 2005, the foundation chair said that the home closed so that the foundation cold redefine its mission, stating that tours of the home failed to properly convey the history of Herndon and his family (Suggs, 2005). The Foundation board also told the Atlanta Journal Constitution that the museum closed due to the development of a new vision and to make the museum technologically savvy (Lowe 2009). Museum Closing: Memories and Heritage I was committed to the Herndon Home. We all loved the house. We probably would
205 have worked there for free. This statement made by Rita Lowe wa s the attitude othe r former museum employees and informants regarding the Herndon Home during their employment. I asked interviewees, however, what the museum s closing would mean for memories and heritage, and about the people now passed who were represented there. Former employee Rita Lowe (2009) states, It would be a tragedy .what does it sa y about how African Americans value their own history? Lowe implies that closing the museum would represent African Americans view of the history and legacy of Alonzo Herndon unworthy for operation, maintenance and ope n to the public. Former employee Linda Richards (2009) stated that the museums closing would be disappointing. One former employee felt that the museum board lacked awareness of what it takes to run a museum. Rita Lowe expressed her views of the board (2009:3), stating, they have no respect for this familys legacy why this home was built and to disregard its significance is very disrespect ful .thats what happens to people who dont have an understanding about their own hist ory .the creation of the home itself has relevance. One informant felt that both the museum and the Atlanta Life boards didnt prepare for changes and circumstances to prev ent the closing and decline of the company and the museum. Any board needs to understa nd a purpose or mission of the home (Lowe 2009). There were many comments from former employees about their disappointment with the museum. In his 2009 article in the opinion se ction of the Atlanta Journal Constitution, former Herndon Home Museum volunteer LaMo aye T. Gay Sr. extends blame to the
206 larger African American community and expr essed his disappointment in the current state of the museum stati ng, Theres no Al Sharpton expressing outrage that the Herndon Mansion, a 100-year-old testament to black entrepreneurship and tenacity, is being shuttered. Wheres the black media? Wh ere are the black celeb rities? And wheres the leadership from Atlanta Life Insurance Co.? He adds, In Atlanta, the city hailed as the Black Mecca, how hard is it to market the residence of the first black millionaire? (Atlanta Journal Constitution September 11, 2009). Former employee Linda Richards shares Mr. Gays questioning wealthy African Americans and their efforts to save the home. Richards believed that people have forgotten a bout the home or people dont know about it. It is hiding and surrounde d by trees (Richards 2009). The physical space of the home, located on a one-way street, is surrounded by un-kept landscapes, on the campus of, Morris Brown, leaves the mu seum a mystery and simply unknown or forgotten by Atlanta residents and visitors. Rita Lowe (2009) argues, If that home was ever destroyed, it would be devastating esp ecially when the home could be easily preserved. The home is still well-preserved de spite neglect 99% of the things in the home were purchased by the Herndons. There are things in the home that are irreplaceable (Lowe 2009). Value of Owing Land I examined what the physical structure, its grandness, means as a symbol of Herndon's success, and what it will mean for memories of these accomplishments if the home is torn down. One former employee stat ed that the home is symbolic. The Herndons bought land from Atlanta Universit y. Alonzo Herndon was one of the few who
207 could acquire the land. It probably also he lped that Adrienne Herndon, was a faculty member, and connected to the universitys pr esident (Lowe 2009). It was very important to Adrienne to have a house. The purchase of the land itself has historical significance (Lowe 2009). At one point Adrienne a nd Alonzo lived on the campus of Atlanta University, living in a dorm (Lowe 2009). A drienne refused to come back to live in a dorm, stated Lowe. The memory and the he ritage lie within the land. Significance goes deeper than the house. Alonzo Herndon was the largest land owner in Atlanta; he didnt just build any house. The hom e had symbolic meaning. Atlanta Journal Constitution s Ernie Suggs reported (2005) that the first former director said that the closing of the museum is the counter of everything that foundation was created for. Former museum employee, Linda Richards, (2009) reflected back on both the 2H4 Herndon building stating, Pe ople drive by the building everyday, dont know the connection. Yet, the Herndons repr esent every aspect of Atlanta (Richards 2009). Historical sites are some of historys best teach ers (Horton 2005:8). Any historical event is much better understood with in the context of its historical setting (Horton 2005). Why read a history book, when you can go and see history for yourself? For the Herndon Home, To see it with your own eyes makes history comes alive stated, Lowe (2009). Lowe belie ved that if the museum closed or was torn down, the Herndon history would be eras ed out of books. She adds, The Herndon family just recently received some attention, in the past 20 years and its because of the first museum director. According the Lowe, pe ople in the community would not know about
208 the home if it were not from the directors e fforts. Another contri buting factor to the Herndon visibility was the book, The Herndons: An Atlanta Family by Carole Merritt (Lowe 2009). Museum Politics It is impossible to place full responsib ility of the foundation board for the problems of the museum. Many museums, partic ularly, small institutions, face difficulties maintaining operation and funding, particular in these economic challenges today. Staff, volunteers, and board members faced the ch allenge of the necessary fundraising and make the necessary repairs to maintain th e home and the collections. However, former museum employees believed there was a disconnection between the foundation boards understanding of what it take s to operate the museum and its value. This disconnection stemmed from the boards lack of connec tion to Norris Herndon. Past board members had a relationship with Norris Hern don. Before 2004, there was someone on the foundation board that had known Norris He rndon. The Herndon descendent on the foundation board only recently discovered his relationship to the Herndons. If this is true, then in order for th e Herndon home to survive, board members should consist of those who had known Norris Herndon. This is impossible; however, this logic would make sense. Past board members who knew Norris Herndon and understood his vision and passion to preserve his family ho me, could possibly invest more interest in ensuring the homes exis tence vs. board members who had no direct contact with Norris Herndon. However, ther e are many individuals who understand and value Norris Herndons vision; museum sta ff, volunteers, preserva tionist, historians,
209 academics, and those who simply loved the Herndon story and home. If this is the case, then the Herndon Home and other histori cal landmarks are in great danger. Many smaller, private, and independent museums contain board members that are unaware of the operation of the museums. This may not be intentional; however, this disconnect is prevalent. As one former employee states, The board needs to understand the purpose or mission of the creator of a historic home or museum and if the board knew what the home symbolizes, they would be making the effort to save a ll what was in the archives, letters, clothes, keepi ng them in tact. Constituting Valuable Information It is important to explore what consti tutes valuable information. There are two subcultures, business, and museums; one is suspicious of the other. The business subculture values information differently from the museum subculture. Lenton (2009) suggests that there needs to be an intermedia ry to help one unders tand the other, because there is an issue of communica tion. As a result, there is a lo st of intuitional memory due to different people managing the collectio ns. Lenton argued that most people view history in textbook or histor y book, and those connected or have knowledge of museums, view history through documents, artifacts, and objects. Therefore, history and its preservation are valued di fferently. There were not many staff members who had extensive experience and knowledge about co llections and museum operation. And if there is no communication between past and present staff, when the director operates the museum, that individual does not know what to do; he or she is unable to talk with the previous person who operated the museum be fore; for instance not knowing the location
210 of finding aids, inventory and appraisal books, and overall museum operation (Lenton 2009). An informant stated that the most r ecent director was not given direction or guidance on how to run the home. The first mu seum director, employed with the museum for twenty-two years, since 1983, before leav ing, spent weeks organizing and preparing the museum for proper maintenance before her departure. But, there were no interactions with the director and other museum director s who came prior. This created a cycle of directors and staff difficulti es and board, in communicating with each other and the foundation board, and properly operating the museum. Efforts to Preserve Herndon History Solutions One former employee suggested that the foundation board should take an African American History course to understand beau ty and importance of history (Lowe 2009). Another former employee suggested that there should be a partnership with the university and home; a mandate for the university to gi ve money every year to the Herndon Home. In addition, the structure and operation should involve the people (Richards 2009), stating People who are connected to family should have more say. Citizens in community did things at home. The community should have a voice, should have a say. Efforts to Bring in Money There have been, however, efforts to bring money into the home. In 2001, The National Endowment for the Humanities awarded $195,000 to the Herndon Home to catalogue the Atlanta Life coll ection of documents and photos More than 300 linear feet of Atlanta Life and Herndon family pape rs dating from 1895 to 1980 were to be
211 processed in a collaborative effort of the Auburn Avenue Research Library, Emory Universitys Robert W. Woodruff Librar y, and the Herndon Home. The two projects arranged and described the Atlanta Life-H erndon Family manuscript collections and facilitated access to the colle ctions at the two libraries and the Herndon Home. In 2001, the home received two more grants through the C ity of Atlanta Bureau of Cultural Affairs and the Fulton County Arts Council (Herndon Home Newsletter 2001). The Home sponsored events such as the annual Christmas on Diamond Hill. In 2004, this event raised $30,000 for the Herndon Home (Lowe 2009). The museum hosted, Kwanzaa, and opera performances such as, The Opera Singer (Feb. 2000 Newsletter). The museum sold postcards, A tlanta Life Calendars, jewelry and holiday ornaments. They hosted book signings, and sold books by authors about the African American businesses organizations and the community, including Carole Merritts book about the Herndon Family. The museum also rents out the space for weddings and other events in efforts to bring in money for the home. And on February 16, 2000, the museum was declared as a National Historic Landmark. This was a great way to bring attention to the museum. Continuing the Herndon Legacy Among staff, volunteers, and the foundati on, there have been many efforts to continue the Herndon legacy, through communication, education, and community outreach. Since the 1990s, the museum produced the Herndon Home Newsletter. The Newsletter features board members, Atlanta Life employees, a calendar of events hosted by the home, funding efforts and awards, and Herndon family and Atlanta Life history,
212 through pictures and documents. The most recent newsletter, in 2008, called News from Diamond Hill, also featured scheduled events new board members, and recaps of past events. The newsletter is a great form of communication to th e community at the Herndon Home and how individu als could participate in the homes activities. Through the collaboration of the Her ndon Home Museum and the South West Atlanta Youth Business Or ganization, (SWAYBO), the Herndon Entrepreneurship Program was a series of study sessions for elem entary and high school students to learn about and experience entrepreneurship. Thr ough workshops, tours, training sessions, and market activities in April and May of 2004, the program taught students the process and power of business organization and the valu e of economic initia tive, through African American entrepreneurs introducing students to market and business concepts (Herndon Home Newsletter April 2004). Th is type of program was e ssential and beneficial to students who live during times of economic uncertainty, challenges, and changes that will affect their future. Unfortunate ly program has not continued. In 1995, eighteen teachers, curriculum coor dinators, and a media specialist from fourteen public and private schoo ls in Atlanta and Dekalb C ounty were selected to take part in the Herndons Curriculum Project for the 1995-1996 school year (Herndon Home Newsletter June 1995). In 2003, the museum produced a curriculum booklet for teachers and students, highlighting facts about th e Herndon family, the home, and their accomplishments. In 2004, Atlanta Life welcomed their 6th president Ronald Brown. Mr. Brown visited the home. His goal was to conn ect new Atlanta Life employees with the history of Alonzo Herndon, and encouraged employees to visit the Herndon Home.
213 Organized by the Herndon Home on August 10, 2008, community members spent the day ensuring students would start their fi rst day of school on th e right track, through the provision of hair cuts, school supplies, and games. This ev ent was an effort to put the Herndon name back in the forefront of community relations in the Atlanta area (Herndon Home Newsletter Summer/Fall 2008). U nder the most recent director, in 2008 to 2009, the museum hosted a Black History Month event, Tea on Diamond Hill Tribute to Adrienne Herndon, Christmas on Diamond Hill Gala and Kwanzaa, and a Legacy Tribute to Alonzo Herndon on June 26, 2008. Today, it is unknown how the home is being operated, what events are taking place. An Unknown Story During my interview with Atlanta Life employees and affiliates, many expressed their concern about losing the legacy and history of Alonzo Herndon and Atlanta Life. Former Atlanta Life employee Edward Lyons (2007) argues, As time passes by, people wont reco gnize Mr. Herndons name people who know about Atlanta Life because of it s involvement in social and economic justice, those persons would be gone I th ink its important that the history of Atlanta Life be preserved and even though the institution has changed radically from the company that I bought into in 1963, I still think its important that the institution be perpetuated and its legacy be perpetuated as well. Mr. Lyons believed that that there wont be anyone around who knows anything or those who related to Atlanta Life and the movement , and therefore would not be inclined to support this institution as there parent s and grandparents would have (2007). For instance, Atlanta Life Natal Day Ce remonies provided extensive programs and employee dedication to continue the le gacy and remember the founder is the preservation of the history, life, legac y, achievement, and contribution of Alonzo
214 Herndon to his company and the African Am erican community. Former and current employees were invited to many of the events These ceremonies helped employees past down the story of Alonzo Herndon, his life, a nd impact on the city of Atlanta. Today, ceremonies to commemorate Alonzo Herndon ar e no longer practiced like they were in the past. One Atlanta Life employee, who began working for the company in early 1990s, has never gone to the gravesite. In her book on the Herndons, Carole Merritt describes Norris Herndon, (2002:214), stated, The Herndon Foundation inherited his wea lth-Atlanta Life Insurance Company, and the Herndon mansion. The Foundati on has become Norriss child and heir to the Herndon legacy. There was no physic al child to past down the Herndon legacy, therefore through the Foundation, Norris Herndo ns goal was to create the Foundation as his son to keep the legacy alive. I am not sure if his son has lived up to his father, Norris Herndons expectations. Inevitable or Preventable? When I walked down Auburn Avenue, ta king pictures, I saw new buildings and new condos. The memory of the old Sweet A uburn no longer exists. I looked at the old Atlanta Life Building and I was so disappoi nted; the physical evidence of Herndons dream had become boarded up with graffiti on the walls. If I was a teenager, I would not know anything about this street and buildings that were once the place of the most successful blacks in the city; a place of triumph, endurance, prosperity and community in spite of racial segreg ation and Jim Crow. So whom do we blame when a teenager does not know about Herndon and his achievement?
215 It is important to question the purpose of the museum and its collections, if outsiders cannot learn, see, enjoy, and apprec iate them, to pass the legacy down to the next generation due to the museums closing? Whose fault is it if children do not know and appreciate their history? Is it the commun ity or those responsible for the operation of the museum? Atlanta Life affiliate and activis t Charles Black (2008) said to me, Its an untold story, a story that is not well-known generally in the community, and its important that you are doing this study to get th is aspect of this story out there, because this company and its founders made a treme ndous contribution to the uplift of the black community, over the years, for a hundred years. It is necessary to tell this story and ensure that generations unde rstand this great history. This study examines the importance of the Significance of Place (Jackson 2009:23). The examination of the Herndon-re lated buildings includes not only the physical site (Jackson 2009:23) of the Atlant a Life, but also the associated community, extending well beyond the physical boundaries of company (Jackson 2009), including all places where Atlanta Life employees, Herndon de scendants, and others associated with the company lived and worked. In this case, this study, an ethnohistorical analysis of an insurance company, its founder, his life, pr operty, and home. Therefore, this study contributes and adds to the significance of place, exploring the multiple aspects of a business and its surrounding community. It hi ghlights issues of leadership and the preservation of heritage.
216 Pictures The following images represent Alonzo Herndon, the Herndon Museum, Atlanta Life, and Herndon-related buildings. Figure 1 is the founder of Atlanta Life, Alonzo Herndon, along with figure 2, Atlanta Life staff in 1922; obtained from the Herndon Home Museum. Figures 3, 4, and 5 represen t the Hendon Home Museum, with figure 5 taken by the National Register in 2000. I took some of the images in 2007 and July of 2009; figures 4, 14, and 15; they all repres ent Herndon-related buildings. Additional Herndon-related buildings include figures 16, the Rucker Building by France Hamilton and Figure 17 the Herndon Building by Da vid Kaminsky and the Atlanta Journal Constitution. Many of these buildings are e ither demolished or at great risk of disappearing. Figures 8-13 images of Atlant a Life from the Atlanta Life Photographic Collection reveal the social aspects of th e company; company organizations, awards, activities, Civil Rights, visits by famous Af rican Americans. Figure 8 is an image of 1954 employees who won a free trip to World Series between Cleveland Indians & New York Giants, in front of Progr essive Field in Ohio. Figure 9 represents the Atlanta Life Choral Ensemble, who sang at Atlanta Life events, programs, and funerals of ALIC employees who passed away. Figure 10 is an im age of Atlanta Life employee protestors during the Civil Rights Movement. Image 11 of ALIC employee prot estors, was taken by the Atlanta Inquirer, an Af rican American newspaper w ho recorded the Civil Rights Movement. Figure 12 of Muhammad Ali visi ting Atlanta Life show s the popularity and prestige of the company. Figure 13 of a Tamp a Branch office, represents one of over 65 offices throughout the Southeastern region of the United States before the mid-1990s.
217 Figure 1. Alonzo F. Herndon, 1858-1927 (Courtesy of Herndon Museum) Figure 2. Atlanta Life Staff 1922 (Courtesy of Herndon Museum)
218 Figure 3. Atlanta Life Building 1930 s (Courtesy of Herndon Museum) Figure 4. Atlanta Life Financ ial Group Building (July 2009)
219 Figure 5. Herndon Home Museum (courtesy of Herndon Museum) Figure 6. Herndon Home Museum Interi or (Courtesy of Herndon Museum) Figure 7. Herndon Home Museum Interior (Courtesy of the National Register)
220 Figure 8. 1954 Employees (ALIC Phot ographic Collection, Herndon Museum) Figure 9. ALIC Choral Ensemble (ALIC Photographic Collection, Herndon Museum)
221 Figure 10. ALIC Protestors, 1960s (ALIC Photographic Collection, Herndon Museum) Figure 11. Atlanta Life Protestors, Dec. 5, 1960 (Courtesy of Atlanta Inquirer)
222 Figure 12. Muhammad Ali at ALIC (ALI C Photographic Collection, Herndon Museum) Figure 13. ALIC Tampa Branch, 1942 (A LIC Photographic Collection, Herndon Museum)
223 Figure 14. Old Atlanta Life Build ing and Annex (February 2007) Figure 15. Damaged Herndon Home Museum Exterior (July 2009)
224 Figure 16. Rucker Building, 1960s; demolished in 2001 (Courtesy of Frances Hamilton) Figure 17. Herndon Building, 1979; demolished 2008 (Courtesy of D. Kaminsky, & AJC)
225 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION I began the research introducing the study, and the initial reasons for the study. As stated throughout this disse rtation, my previous employ ment at the Herndon Home Museum prompted my decision to conduct research on the Atlanta Life Insurance Company. Through this research process, I str uggled with my own iden tity; how I fit into the world of the black business elite. I also explained the importance of the research: analyzing the past and presen t relationships between the community and Atlanta Life, providing a critical analysis of companys roles in the African American community, considering class and gender, and examine wh at the closing of Herndon Home means. The initial process of the dissertation was followed by a review of the literature, through the history and development of mutu al aid societies and its evolution to insurance companies, black business, and its role during the segregation period. The literature reveals the importa nce of studying organizational culture, issues surrounding class and segregation, producti on of identity, an examination of black institutions, concepts surrounding the future of African Americans economically, and desegregation. Finally, the literature explored the anth ropology of museums, how African Americans have preserved their own history and its ch allenges, and issues surrounding power and representation. I then describe d how the use archival data, interviews, and participant observation determined the data collected. I describe each of these methods and their importance in the research. I revealed the ch allenges of the research, reciprocity, and
226 ethical considerations within the research process. I presented background on th e dissertation research pr oviding some history in Atlanta, the Atlanta Life Insurance Comp any, and the Herndon Home Museum. I also described the role of the company and th e museum today. I presented my findings, breaking the results into three parts focusi ng on: the role of the local economy and perspectives, civil rights, a nd the Herndon museum. I provide d analysis and discussion throughout my findings. Revisiting the Research Questions For this dissertation resear ch, I have attempted to an swer the following questions: 1. What roles did ALIC play in the developm ent of the local economy of the African American community? 2. How did the African American commun ity, ALIC employees, and ALIC policy owners view the company? 3. Did segregation strengthen the relationship between ALIC and the African American community and its economic development? 4. Did desegregation along with the post-Civil Rights era contribute to the decline of the company, its multiple functions, and the African American community? 5. What does the possible closing of the He rndon Home Museum mean for memories and heritage? What does the physical structure mean as a symbol of Herndon's success, and what it will mean for memori es of these accomplishments if the house were torn down? The company contributed to the loca l economy in the African American community through education, sponsorship, scholarship, and civil rights. Based on findings, the company promoted the importan ce of their employees, men and women, to obtain the proper education and training need ed to increase th eir knowledge of the insurance business for a successful compa ny. The company also provided employment
227 for many African Americans, enabling social and economic mobility. Atlanta Lifes role in the local economy and the African American community came through their contributions in the Civil Rights Movement fi nancially and socially, acting as mediators, protestors, and as an economic f oundation, fighting for equal rights. Mr. Herndon and Mr. Martin created this air that we are with thes e young folks. So we didnt have anybody from Atlanta Life acting funny they were gon back this movement Here is Mr. Martin and Mr. Herndon backing a young guy We had all of these powerful black folks in town. And he res Atlanta Life ba cking this young guy and this new movement. It was revolutionary This quote by activists Lonnie King on Atlanta Life backing the student s is a powerful stance. Therefore, for Atlanta Li fe affiliates, like Lonnie King and Charles Black, Atlanta Life was a pow erful company, self-sufficien t enough to support the cause. Atlanta Life continued the Herndon legacy to fight for freedom and equality. Backing these students would be the natural thing to do. Such a great company as Atlanta Life, particularly, one of the richest Black men in the country, supported the college students. Most employees, former and current vi ewed the company like a family. These unique aspects of African American business in a shared experience of a family, represented a fascinating combination of security, support, protection, solidarity, paternalism, class, gender, exclusion, and inclusion with segregation and desegregation affecting these combinations. The reoccurring theme, like a family illustrates the functioning and dysfunctioning of any fam ily, and its contradictions. For some employees, the paternal leader ship of the company characterized a fatherly guidance of its employees by molding them into the p roper businessman or women. For women, these guidelines were more extensive. From proper grooming, hygiene to even how
228 women should dress were emphasized; at th e same time honoring women for their hard work and dedication. Within segregation, a segregated spa ce provided opportunities; it provided the right to succeed economically, obtain an education and a d ecent job, and participate in social activities. Segregation had consequen ces outside its space of that segregated boundary. Outside the boundary or space, blac ks experienced discrimination, racism, violence, inequality, and hum iliation. It was a market for black businesses in Jim Crow, and it was a paradox of community solidarity, cr eating an opportunity for action for equal rights for African Americans. According to former employees, change in leadership contributed to decline in company, not desegregation. Based on the lite rature, most black business and the black community suffered a great loss due to compe tition of business with whites. Based on my findings, for Atlanta Life the need to go global could have contributed to the decline, as well as bringing in outside leadership not fa miliar with the history and legacy of the company or understanding the tradition of the business and its services. Former employees stated that leadership not desegreg ation caused the decline of the company. For former employees the closing of th e Herndon Home mean t a disregard for history and achievement of the African Am ericans who faced challenges of surviving slavery, Jim Crow, segregation, and displacem ent. Based upon interviewees responses, there is a disconnection between board perspe ctives, museum staff perspectives, and the importance of Herndons legacy. Former empl oyees argue that there is a devalue of history of the Herndon legacy. The decisions to close the museum, temporarily or
229 permanently will be decided by the Boar d Foundation: a seven member committee, business owners in the city of Atlanta. Thos e in power decide when history should be (re) presented, preserved, stopped, and silenced (Troulllout 1995; Farmer 2001; Jackson 2001); this is unique in that thos e in power are not the typical controllers of history (white men). This research provides an interesting case. For, the African American elite hold the positions of power. Although people would identi fy the white men as controllers of the presentation and preservation of history; this is not the case. There seems to be a continued problem of the devaluation of African American history and achievement. There is also a challenge in the knowledge of preserving this history and achievement. Herndon-Related Buildings The demolition and abandonment of Herndon re lated buildings indicate the reality of society leaving the past behind; a changing society, w hose focus relates to urban renewal, beautification, and convenient living in the city. These buildings, which represented African American success and wealth in the community no longer, exist. Written records provide one means of acc ounting daily life (Jackson 2001:100) of African Americans and their businesses. These buildings disappearance reflects Jacksons (2001) argument of understanding the way in which silence is produced. The importance of Informing the Silence, character izes not only oral hist ory, but landscape and architectural analysis enables a more comprehensive portrait (2001:100), of Alonzo Herndon and Atlanta Life. However, this sil encing increases, when the Herndon related buildings face the possibility of being replaced with historic markers after redevelopment, urban renewal, and revitalization projects.
230 Toolkit for Identity Producing Employment at ALIC, produced and rea ffirmed their identity through what I identify as a toolkit for identity. The co mpany served as a shared space to produce identity through activities, which was a prot ected space to grow, and mobilize socially and economically. There were key factors, for many former employees that made up toolkit: Atlanta Life was thei r first and only job; the comp any provided training within. For employees first and only job, they could not compare their expe riences with other companies, particularly experience working for a white company. The employees did not have to compete or struggle with whites; this in turn could have produced a sense of self, pride, and identity. Employees did not have to go outside the co mpany for professional growth and development produced, the compa ny provided conferences and training at the company and at historically black colleges. Lastly, segregation played a major role in producing this sense of identity and belongi ng. Segregation was the back drop of these factors. This could have e xplained why former employees who began work between the 1940s and 1950s called the company this title T he Atlanta Life, viewed as a place to obtain knowledge. Evonne Nights story is a cl assic case of identity reaffirmation. She compared working for the company to attending a hi storically black college, which is known, particularly a small private college, for its cl ose knit, family-like, characteristics. The Negro Insurance Association trained her, wh ich occurred on black college campuses, she was educated at a black college, assisted in the civil rights movement, registering blacks to vote, and Atlanta Life was her first and only job, in which she worked for over forty
231 years. There was no comparing herself to the outside world of whites and their challenges of competition to determine ad equacy. Atlanta Life was a pl ace of production of not only economic power, but identity, with a secu re space to produce that identity. The collective identities of ALIC empl oyees challenges Knaufts (1996) argument to move away from older approaches th at portrayed culture as concrete, bounded, coherent, and systemic to one in which cultu re emerges as loosely integrated, weakly bounded, contradictory, conteste d, and subject to constant change. For employees, particularly, those who worked during Ji m Crow era and before the 1990s, shared experiences. Culture was an integrated entity, tied to a fixed group of people. It was not a shifting and contested pr ocess of constructing collec tive identity (1996:.44). However, in some cases, this research al so shows the complexities in the African American community and some aspects of culture as contradictory. For instance, beliefs about other blacks, like black barbers refusal to cut blac k hair in 1965 at the Herndon barbershop, arguing that they didnt know how to cut kinky hair, illustrates the attitudes towards other blacks. Issues of class and colorism are key factors in this analysis. Perhaps Black barbers at Herndon Barbershop, were content with segregation. Maybe they knew that if they integrated the barbershop with black customers, they would lose their white clientele. Therefore, for Black businessmen and entrepreneurs, motivation in some sense for decisions to uni fy or not, was about money in the face of segregation. Therefore, this research challenges how we s hould view Black business and their roles as well as the Af rican American community.
232 Economic Gain or Community Uplift and Autonomy There are questions of altruism as a genuine strategy to strengthen the black community or motives behind ALIC leaders a ttempt to establish more wealth and power for themselves as a company. Did these acts of kindness towards the community serve as a cushion or back-up if confronted with ac cusations of a profit-only business. Did leaders perpetuate the Black Villain Th eory (Weems 2002)? The company functioned within a capitalistic system, maneuvering thr ough this system successfully was two fold: the company took care of the community, a nd the community took care of the company. This traditional cyclical syst em of economic cooperative institutions worked successfully. In a capitalist society, black bus iness had to make money. Howe ver, I do not believe that their intent was deceitful. The Black community understood the black businesses purpose. They were not nave of the econom ic structures of the United States. Romanticizing the Past Company Life and the Black Community Quotes like, it was the life it was like family now things have changed we use to be were comments made by employees who worked for the company at least twenty years. This type of nostalgia and l onging for the past represents the common ideas surrounding a segregated past. Within the conf ines of segregation, life was great for the African American community. This longing for this past life of community solidarity (Shircliffe 2006; Boyd 2008), reflects Shircli ffes work on oral hist ories of Middletons high school alumni and their experiences of how their nostalgia of past stems from forced integration which ended in students being bused to white schools, and black schools
233 losing their principals and teachers. Th e idea of integration stealing the Black Community and losing the black middle class reflects Boyds work describing how the keepers , those residents, who stated after desegr egation laws passed, felt that the black middle class abandoned the neighborhood. Current Atlanta Life employee Alice Allen s (2008) recalls her conversations with retired employees confirming these repeated longings for the past and the companys operation. Allen states: They still love Atlanta Life, and most of them like to reminisce about what it was like back then, and a lot of them they had like thirty plus years with the company when they retired and they ge t in conversations about Mr. Herndon, and what it was like working for the company a nd they tell me their job title at that time so when you talk about Atlanta Life and I know we have to move forward but back in the day is going to always be there, cause thats what you remember the most anyone you get in a conversation w ith about Atlanta Life its going to be something that happened back th en because of the changes now you know with these new departments and were doing new things now a lot of the employees theyre mind is still back in the day. Black Neighborhood and Black Business This research not only dispels the myth of African Americans lack of business tradition, it also reveal s that African American business was not one-dimensional, for as Jacksons (2001) research on African slav es on plantations, reveal a continued representation of Africa ns in plantations masks the variety of roles Africans and their descendants played in American history. Af rican American businesses, particularly Atlanta Life, played multiple roles to assist and impact their communities. This idea that everyone got along and without many problems, with everyone supporting each other, contradicts with stories of low pay, poor leadership, disconnect to community and customers, discriminatory hiring practices complaints of the changes within the
234 company, and discrimination over pay among wo men. For instance, one employee talked about her acceptance in the company due to he r education at a local historically black college; however, former employees critici ze new leadership for not understanding the legacy and for being outsiders. Assumptions: Participants in the Civil Rights Movement I always thought that during the Civi l Rights Movements, African Americans came together, fighting for the same cause I thought of this sense of communal solidarity, with a positive vision of change. Ho wever, this united front was not true. Not all African Americans supporte d boycotts and protests by student protestors. Not all black businessmen during the Civil Rights move ment were supporters of the protests and boycotts. Atlanta Life mediated these mee tings between Black leaders and students. B0lack businesses intent was to make m oney. Plus, not all Atlanta Life employees participated in protests. However, the company would get twenty to twenty-five employees to protest. Many Blacks in the community were hesitant; because what it entailed, what they had to do and be willing to risk. Blacks were liable, they were taking risks; therefore, most of those who prot ested were students (N ight 2008). People had families, and could not risk going to jail. As former employee, Evonne Night who was single without children at the time of th e movement, (2008) describes the reasoning behind whether to protest states:
235 Heres the lady that got to go home because she got three children she had to pick up from a nursery I got to pick my husband up or my mother is sick and elderly and I got to go home to her when I get o ff, cause shes at a nursing home or a day care center like they keep elderly people And fortunately my mother was younger and healthy and I didnt even have a child then but I had to begin to understand why they were hesitant to be a part of it And then some were just not going to participate. But overall, we ha d a good number of people to represent Atlanta Life. No other company had that many people that we had participate. Strategies of Success Alonzo Herndon created a space for black pe ople to obtain self-sufficiency and success inside of a larger system, through se gregation, that preven ted Black people from obtaining equality and the freedom to obtain a decent life. For Atlanta Life employees, being apart of such a great legacy and histor y was larger than simply being an employee. It was being a part of an in stitution that defied Jim Crow system. Black banks, insurance companies, and real estate loan associati ons were not only symbols of the increased financial holdings of blacks but also an expression of de fiance to white attempts to impose a separate and subordinate status on Americas citizens of African descent (Walker 1998:193). The company and the Herndon Home were a symbol of defiance and affirmation of Black success, dispelling the myth of Af rican Americans lack of business tradition. Employment at Atlanta Life outweighed many ch allenges, issues, and contradictions that employees, officers, and leaders face duri ng their employment with Atlanta Life. Historically being a part of Atlanta Life was far greater or much larger than any minute discrepancy of class, gender, wealth, uplif t, discrimination, and even exclusion. All employees said the similar phrases, whether form er or current, or Atlanta Life affiliates, Atlanta Life was such a great place to work for, and to be a part of. Most employees,
236 former or current, had a sense of pride to work for the company, a pride that goes beyond any issues faced. Entrepreneurship changed the meaning of work for African Americans in that it gave them autonomy for their own way of life, setting th eir own standards of business, wealth, and success. It provided a space for economic and social mobility. Keeping or Breaking the Herndon and Atlanta Life Tradition From my interviews, older and former employees express much disappointment with how Atlanta Life is being operated t oday. For them, there was a tradition of the company to connect to and he lp the community. Segregatio n accelerated this motivation: fighting for similar causes, and sharing the sa me space that provided services to the Black community. The company benefitted economical ly, and the community benefitted from services provided by the company. Atlant a Life saw the importance of community connection. They understood that they had to be involved and had to have relationships with community if they were going to maintain their product. After Alonzo Herndons death, his son Norris Herndon took over as president leading the company for over forty years. Howe ver, Norris did not have children to carry on the family name and tradition. There was a breaking of the tradit ion of the bloodline; physically and philosophically. Although the company successfully operated using the traditional values and ideas and business practices, due to the changing economy, changes were inevitable. Today, the company competes with a large economic system. The companys future goal is to globalize thei r services, believing that a more globalized market would characterize success. Could this push for gl obalization help or hurt the company? The
237 company no longer provides the same serv ices, host activities within the company, participate, and contribute to the African American community as it did in the past. Could ALFGs structure, effect the connect ion to the African American community? Does the separation of ALFGs three compan ies impact the communal solidarity of the employees and African American community? Despite these questions, the Atlanta Life Financial Group continued existence is a testament of success. Limitations of the Study Due financial challenges, it was difficu lt to travel to Atlanta to conduct dissertation field work and arch ival data. My absence in Atla nta made it most difficult to do participant observation at Atlanta Life events, preventing me from attending retirement celebrations, honored employees for their services in the community and the company, reunion parties, and meetings organi zed by retired employees. My absence also prevented me from observing the day-to-day operations of the company and their interactions with the community and the mu seum. Therefore, I was unable to witness how the company participated in their ac tivities and events in the company, the community today and how it differed from the past. Time and finances allotted only one interv iew with each Atlanta Life and museum employees, and affiliates. I did not conduc t follow up interviews, which could have assisted in many unanswered questions about va rious topics in the dissertation research such as: land ownership, branch offices, and a more detailed descri ption of the downsizes and their effects on employees.
238 Challenges During the dissertation research proc ess, I faced two major challenges: my perceptions of company, produc ing a sense of discomfort a nd hesitance, and my ideas and biases about the black elit e. Therefore, I felt out of place and out-of-class. The company was so prestigious, that I simply felt like I was not the appropriate person to conduct interviews. As a former museum employee, I had some previous knowledge about some of the issues surrounding the mu seum; therefore, I faced the challenge of excluding known information before conductin g interviews and obtaining documents. Future Research Thus, this dissertation research compels further analysis of various topics and issues surrounding the company and the museum. It is important to examine if and how the company are affected by individuals who were brought in from outside to run the company. An analysis of past presidents, pa rticularly those in o ffice after 1973, would be the focus of the research. It is also important to examin e how and if the museum is affected by hiring outsiders, analyzing nonAtlanta Life employees and museum board members who are not family members, non hi storians, preservationi sts, and those who lack knowledge of museums ope ration and maintenance. Further analysis is needed on branch o ffices throughout the southeast region of the United States. These examinations will sh ed light on employees from other branches, their views on Atlanta Life, and how branch es impacted the local African American communities. It would also be important to examine property ownership of Atlanta Life to determine if the company owns the la nd which the branch offices resided.
239 Additional interviews and follow-up interviews would shed more light on issues within and outside the company. Interviewing more policy owners and their experiences with Atlanta Life provide good insight on these issues surrounding Atlanta Life motives of uplift of the community or economic gain. It would also assist in understanding an outside perspective on the companys role w ithin the African American community, how the company conducted business with customer s, focusing on customer service, and how differences of these interactions change d over time. Interviewing more former and current employee who experienced the downsiz ing period and follow-ups with previous interviewees would allo w more clarity of the major changes of the company, perspectives of those employees who experienced these changes, and what these changes meant to them. Examining the ALFG in the past 10 year s would reveal the most recent experiences and events in the firm. Additional interviews with ALIC employees would help explain how the company continued to exist when many other insurance companies like AfroAmerican Life and Central Life, similar to Atlanta Life did not survive. An examination of the dynamics surrounding the politics of the Herndon Home, through interviews of volunteers, former st aff, museum contributors, and Atlanta residents would provide a variet y of perspectives with less bi as perceptions and analysis. I am curious of how has the museums declin e and changes in the company affected the community. And if the changes in the compa ny benefit the community and their needs or the companys product they are trying to pus h. Further exploration are necessary on how surrounding communities are affected by these de terminations and to what extent the communities have a voice in this representation and usage.
240 Recommendations and Applications I hope this research can open dial ogues between business leaders, preservationists, and community residents to understand the importance to preserve physical landmarks of the history of Alonzo Herndons life and company. These collaborations could lead to developing possi ble solutions for the preservation of the Herndon Home and Herndon-related buildings. My findings can assist in developing a documentary about the company, telling the Atlanta Life story to a br oader audience, particular st udents. This documentary can assist in presenting the story of Atlanta Life visibly in the history, economics, math, and social studies classrooms, which would in turn help motivate students to strive for entrepreneurship. In addition, this research could contribute to curriculum development for business majors and economists providing a different perspective of business and the ALICs strategies for success. The research can contribute to how we define business success and roles. Museum It is important to re-evaluate the pr ocedure of foundation board selection and structure. It is also imperative to an alyze funding raising practices and beliefs surrounding these ideas. The museum board shoul d also consist of a preservationist or historian, familiar with heritage preservation, with an advisor to the board, particularly knowledgeable in preservation and archives. All board members should be required to fundraise as a stipulation to remain on the board. There should be a representative to monitor these efforts. Each board member should be required to meet with staff for
241 awareness of the day-to-day operations, ma intenance, and challenges of the museum. Board members should also be required to partake in workshops about museum operation, maintenance, and board leadership. Through fundraising, the board should hire at least five staff members: director, an archivist, and three museum associates. The museum should also consist of volunteers to assist in maintenance and operation of the museum. The museum should have a staff of five at all times to prevent multiple duties to few staff members and volunteers. The board should also appoint a mediat or between museum staff and board. Through my observations, there has been a tr ansit of staff at the museum in a short amount of time. As a result, there is a loss of intuitional memory (Lenton 2008) due to different people managing the collections a nd documents. When the next person is running the museum, that individual doesnt know what to do (Lenton 2008). Therefore, there needs to be an intermediary to help one understand the other. Creating an assessable preservation and inventory log outside of the museum, would prevent uncertainty of staff and volunteers to operate the museum. I recommend that the board hire an ar chivist to scan the ALIC Photographic Collection at the Herndon Home museum, and transfer of the ALIC Photographic Collection to the Auburn Avenue Research Library to accompany the ALIC records. Scanning the images of the ALIC Photographic Collection and Herndon family collection into a digital collection for preservation will provide an electronic copy of the collections. In addition, transferring the AL IC Photographic Collection will secure and prevent risk or damage of this valuable collection.
242 Benefits of Research This research revealed the longstanding patt erns of social responsibility in African American firms, and how the shared str uggle for equal rights and fair, treatment transformed business enterprises and strain ed the relationship between individualistic profit and collective interests. This research provided an examination of past and present relationships between the community and A tlanta Life; how integration changed those relationships, and the peculiar role that segreg ation played to reinforce the solidarity of the insurance company and the wide r African American community. The research can dispel the myths of Afri can Americans lack of business, which may contribute to some African American yout hs motivation to stri ve for excellence in the areas of business. The medias stereotypi cal, skewed, and negativ e images of African Americans have major influences on the minds and lives of youth. However, this research promotes and presents positive images and contributions to the economic and financial success and longevity of African American entrepreneurship.
243 References Cited Afro-American Life Insurance Company 1951 Golden Anniversary Booklet, 1951. Jacksonville, FL. February. Ammons, Lila 1996 The Evolution of Black-Owned Bank s in the United States between 1880s and 1990s. Journal of Black Studies, 26(4):467-48. Atlanta Daily World 1965 SCLC Protest Barbershop. November 28, 1965. AtlantA Life Financial Group 2009 Atlanta Life Press Releases. www.atlantalife.com Atlanta Life Press 2004 Atlanta Life Introduces MEMOIRSM, a New Product to Prearrange and Pre-Fund Funerals. 05-19-2004. http://www.atlantalife.com/press.asp?urh=pr_051804 (Accessed 01/22/10)) Atlanta Preservation Center 2003 The Herndon Building. www.pres erveatlanta.com/herndon.htm. Auchmutey, Jim 2008 Landmark a Victim of Tornado. Atlanta Journal-Constitution: 04/21/08. Axtell, James 1979 Ethnohistory: An Historians Vi ewpoint. Ethnohistory 26:1-13. Baber, Yvette Ginger 2005 The Remembering St. Petersburg Or al History Project Handbook. Carter G.. Woodson African American Museum and Front Porch Community Development Association, In c. St. Petersburg FL. Banks, Taunya Lovell 2002 The Black Side of the Mirror. In Sister Circle: Black Women and Work. Pg. 13-28. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press. Benjamin, Lois 2005 The Black Elite: Still Facing the Colo r Line in the Twenty-first Century. Lanham, Md.: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
244 Benjamin, Walter 1968 Theses on the Philosophy of Histor y. In Illuminations. Harry Zohn, ed. New York: Harcourt, Brace and World. Benson, Susan, Stephen Brier, and Roy Rosenzweig (eds) 1986 Presenting the Past: Essays on Hist ory and the Public. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Bernard, Russell H. 1995 Research Methods in Anthropology: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches. Walnut Creek, CA: Altamira Press. Bethel, Kathleen E. 2000 Plenty Good Room: African American Museums at the Millennium. Library Fellow Alice B. Kaplan Center for the Humanities and African American Studies Librarian. Northwestern University Library. March 6th, Paper. Black Enterprise Magazine 1990 Atlanta Life Buys Pilgrim, Moves into South Carolina. February 1990. Bonner, Jeanne 2009 Herndon Home Hits Hard Times. WABE Atlanta Board of Education (ABE) Public Broadcasting A tlanta (PBA). November 05, 2009. http://www.publicbroadcasting.net/wabe/ news.newsmain/article/223/0/1574378/ WABE.Features/Herndon.H ome.Hits.Hard.Times (Accessed 02/10). Boscom, William R. 1952 The Esusu: A Credit Institution of the Yoruba. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain. 82(1): 62-70. Bowser, Benjamin P. 2007 The Black Middle Class: Social Mo bility and Vulnerability. Boulder Colorado: Lynne Rienner Publishers. Britton, John H. 1965 G.A. Negro Shop Finally Agree to Clip Negroes Hair. Jet Magazine. December 16. Burns, Rebecca 2009 Herndon Plaza, Morris Brown on 2010 "Places in Peril" List. Atlanta Magazine Blogs. Atlantamagazine.com
245 Butler, John Sibley. 1991 Entrepreneurship and Self-Help among Black Americans. Albany, NY: SUNY Press. Carson, Emmett D. 1993 A Hand Up: Black Philanthropy and Se lf-Help in America. Washington, D.C.: Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies Press. Chakrabarty, Dipesh 1992 Postcoloniality and the Artifice of Hi story: Who Speaks for 'Indian' Pasts? In Representations 37:1-26. Childs, John Brown. 1989 Leadership, Conflict, and Cooperati on in Afro-American Social Thought. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Cole, Johnnetta B. and Beverly Guy-Sheftall 2003 Gender Talk: The Struggle for Women's Equality in African American Communities. New York: Ballantine Publishing Group. Columbia University Press 2007 Atlanta University Center..6th Edition. www.infoplease.com (Accessed 01/10). Corcoran, Mary 1999 The Economic Progress of African American Women. In Latinas and African American Women at Work: Race, Gender, and Economic Inequality. Irene Browne, eds. Pp. 35-60.New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Creswell, John W. 1998 Qualitative Inquiry and Resear ch Design: Choosing Among Five Traditions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Dalton, George 1978 Is Economic Anthropology of Interest to Economics? The American Economic Review. 68(2):23-27. de Munck, Victor C. and Elisa J. Sobo 1998 Using Methods in the Field: A Practical Introduction and Casebook. Walnut Creek, CA: Altamira Press. Drake, St. Clair and Horace R. Cayton 1945 Black Metropolis: A Study of Negro Life in a Northern City. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
246 Drewry Henry N. and Humphrey Doermann 2001 Stand and Prosper: Private Black Colleges and their Students. In collaboration with Susan H. Anderson. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press. Dunaway, David King 1984 Transcription: Shadow or Reality? The Oral History Review 12:113-117. Dyson, Michael Eric 2005 Is Bill Cosby Right? Or Has the Bl ack Middle Class Lost its Mind? New York: Basic Civitas Books. Ebony Magazine 1994 Black Museums: Keeping th e Legacy Alive. March. Edwards, Elizabeth, and Janice Hart 2004 Photographs Objects Histories: On the Materiality of Images. New York: Routledge. Ember, Carol R., Melvin Ember, and Peter Peregrine 2005 Ethnohistory. In Anthropology 11th Edition. New Jersey: Prentice Hall Euler, Robert 1972 Ethnohistory in the United St ates. Ethnohistory. 19(3):201-207. Fabian, Johannes 1983 Time and the Other: How Anthr opology Makes Its Object. New York: Columbia University Press. Farmer, Paul 2001 Infections and Inequalities: The Modern Plagues. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Fenton, William 1966 Field Work, Museum Studies, and Ethnohistorical Rese arch. Ethnohistory 13(1/2):71-85, Winter-Spring. Fletcher, Linda 1970 The Negro in the Insurance Industr y. Pennsylvania: University of Pennsylvania. Flick, Uwe 1998 An Introduction to Qualitative Rese arch. London: Sage Publications.
247 Franco, B. 1994 The communication conundrum: What is the message? Who is listening? In Journal of American History, 81(1), 151-63. Frazier, Franklin E. 1957 Black Bourgeoisie. Ne w York: Free Press. Gable, Eric 1996 Maintaining Boundaries or 'Mainstreaming' Black History in a White Museum. In Theorizing in museums: Representi ng identity and diversity in a changing world S. MacDonald & G. Fyfe. Eds., Pp. 177-202. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell Publishers. Gaither, Edmund Barry 1992 Hey! Thats Mine: Thoughts on Plur alism and American Museums. Ivan Karp, Christine Mullen Kreamer, eds. In Museums and Communities: The Politics of Public Culture. Pg. 56-64. Sm ithsonian Institution Press: Washington and London. Garcia, Maria Elena 2000 Ethnographic Responsibility and th e Anthropological Endeavor: Beyond Identity Politics. In Anthropol ogical Quarterly 73 (2):89-101. Gatewood, Willard B. 2000 Aristocrats of Color: The Educated Black Elite of the Post-Reconstruction Era. The Journal of Blacks in Higher Education. 29:112-118. 1993 Aristocrats of Color: The Black Elite, 1880-1920 Bloo mington: Indiana University Press. Gerena, Charles 2004 Urban Entrepreneurs: The Origins of Black Business Districts in Durham, Richmond, and Washington, D.C. Region Focus (Winter, 2004).Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond. Virginia. Gezari, Anessa 2006 Past's Future is in Doubt. St. Petersburg Times. Dec 7. Giddings, Paula 1995 The Last Taboo. In Words of Fire: An Anthology of African-American Feminist Thought. Beverly Guy-Sheftall, eds. New York: The New Press.
248 Glenn, Evelyn Nakano 2002 Unequal Freedom: How Race and Gender Shaped American Citizenship and Labor. Cambridge, Massachusetts : Harvard University Press. Gough, Samuel N. 2001 African Americans. In Cultiv ating Diversity in Fundraising. Janice Gow Pettey (ed) (AFP/Wiley Fund Development Series) John Wiley and Sons, Inc: New York. Green, Shelly, and Paul Pryde 1990 Black Entrepreneurship in Amer ica. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers. Greenbaum, Susan 1994 Mutual Aid Societies and Voluntary Associations. In The Encyclopedia of Multiculturalism. Mark Rehn (ed.) P p.1219-1222. Pasadena, CA: Salem Press. 1993 Economic Cooperation among Urban Industrial Workers: Rationality and Community in an Afro-Cuban Mu tual Aid Society, 1904-1927. Social Science History 17(2):173-93. 1991 A Comparison of African American and Euro-American Mutual Aid Societies in 19th Century America. The Journal of Ethnic Studies. 19(3): 95-119. Fall 2002 More Than Black: Afro-Cubans in Ta mpa. University of Florida Press: Gainesville, FL. Greenbaum, Susan and Cheryl Rodriguez, eds. 1998 Central Avenue Legacies. In Practicing Anthropology. 20(1):2-5. Gregory, Steven 1998 Black Corona: Race and the Politics of Place in an Urban Community. Princeton University Press: Princeton, New Jersey. 1992 The Changing Significance of Class in an African American Community. American Ethnologist. 19(2):255-274. Gumbrecht, Jamie 2009 Future Uncertain as Historic He rndon Home Approaches 100. Atlanta Journal Constitution. September 9.
249 Hall, Stuart 1997a. The Work of Representation. In Representation: Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices. St uart Hall, ed. Pp. 13-64. L ondon: Sage Publications. 1997b Representation: Cultural Repres entations and Signifying Practices. SF London: Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Halperin, Rhoda. 1994 Cultural Economies Past and Present. University of Texas Press, Austin. Hamada, Tomoko 1994 Anthropology and Organizational Culture. In Anthropological Perspectives on Organizational Culture. Tomoko Hamada and Willis E. Sibley, eds. University Press of America: Lanham, MD. Hamilton, Frances 2002 Sweet Auburn Avenue: Triumph of the Spirit. Masters Thesis. The Georgia Institute of Technology School of Information Design and Technology, May. www.sweetauburn.us/faq.htm Handler R. & Gable, Eric. 1997 The New History in an Old Muse um: Creating the Past at Colonial Williamsburg. Duke University Press. Harley, Sharon, Francille Rusan Wilson, and Shirley Wilson Logan. 2002 Introduction: Historical Overvi ew of Black Women and Work. In Sister Circle: Black Women and Work. Pg. 110. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press. Harmon, David Andrew 1996 Beneath the Image of the Civil Rights Movement and Race Relations: Atlanta, Georgia 1946-1981. New York a nd London: Garland Publishing, Inc. Harris, Abram L. 1936 The Negro as Capitalist: A Study of Banking and Business Among American Negroes. New York: Negro University Press. Harris, Robert L. 1999 The Rise of the Black Middle Cla ss. The World and I Magazine. Feb. 14(2): 40. Henderson, Alexa 1990 The Atlanta Life Insurance Comp any: Guardian of Black Economic Dignity. Alabama: University of Alabama Press. Herskovits, Melville J.
250 1941 The Myth of the Negro Past. Boston, MA: Beacon Press. Hine, Darlene Clark 1994 Hine sight: Black Women and the Re -construction of American History. Brooklyn, NY: Carlson Publishing. Hirsch, Erin and Charles Stewart 2005 Introduction: Ethnographies of Hi storicity. History and Anthropology. (16) 3:261-274. September. Holloway, Joseph E. 2005 The Sacred World Gullahs. In Africanisms in American Culture. 2nd Edition. Indiana: Indiana Un iversity Press: 187-224. Horton, Hayward Derrick 1991 A Sociological Approach to Black Community Development: Presentation of the Black Organizatio nal Autonomy Model. Journal of the Community Development Society 23(1):1-3. Horton, James Oliver 2005 Landmarks of African American Hi story. New York: Oxford University Press. Hughes, Alan 2008 Atlanta Life Mourns CEOs Passi ng. Black Enterprise. June 1, 2008. http://www.blackenterprise.com/magazi ne/2008/06/01/atlanta-life-mourns-ceospassing (Accessed 06/14/08). Ingham, John N., and Lynne B. Feldman 1994 African-American Business Lead ers: A Biographical Dictionary. Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press. Jackson, Antoinette 2003 Africans at Snee Farm Plantation: In forming Representations of Plantation Life at a National Heritage Site. I n Signifying Serpents & Mardi Gras Runners: Representing Identity in Selected Souths Celeste Ray and Luke Lassiter, eds. Pp. 93-109. Southern Anthropological Societ y Proceedings, Vol. 36, Athens: The University of Georgia Press. 2004 African Communities in Southeast Coastal Plantation Spaces in America. Dissertation. University of Florida. Department of Anthropology. Gainesville, FL.
251 2006 The Sulphur Springs Heritage Proj ect Proposal. University of South Florida. Department of Anthropology. Tampa, FL. 2008 Imagining Jehossee Island Rice Plantati on Today. International Journal of Heritage Studies.14(2):133-155, March 2008. 2009 The Kingsley Plantation Community in Jacksonville, Florida-Transition and Memory in a Southern American City, CRM: The Journal of Heritage Stewardship. v6 (1): 23-33. Winter 2009. Jackson, Antoinette with Allan Burns 2006 Ethnohistorical Study of the Kingsley Plantation Community. Published/distributed: November, 2007. Cultural Resources Division, Southeast Regional Office, National Park Service: Atlanta, GA. Jet Magazine 1985 Atlanta Life Cheers 80th Year with Mammoth Merger. October 28. 1990 Atlanta Life Purchases Chicago Metropolitan; Assets Now $231 Million. December 17. 1991 Atlanta Life Names New Board of Directors and New Management Team. May 6. 1995 Atlanta Life CEO Resigns to Take Nu mber 2 Position At Life of Georgia. October 30. Johnson, Johnny 1999 Interview with Author. Interview by Carole Merritt, June 11.Atlanta, GA. Jones, Anna Laura 1993 Exploding Cannons: The Anthropology of Museums. In Annual Review of Anthropology. 22:201-220. Jones, Delmos 1988 Toward a Native Anthropology. Huma n Organization, 29 (4): 251-259. Jones, Maxine D. and Kevin M. McCarthy 1993 African Americans in Florida. Sarasota, FL: Pineapple Press. Kaminsky, David J. 2009 Herndon Building. Sweet Auburn Historic District. http://www.nps.gov/hdp/exhib its/african/auburn.htm (Accessed 01/10).
252 Karp, Ivan, and Steven D. Lavine, Eds. 1991 Introduction: Museums and Multiculturalism. In Exhibiting Cultures: The Poetics and Politics of Museum Displa y. Pp.1-9.Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Keating, Larry 2001 Atlanta: Race, Class, and Urba n Expansion. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Kimbro, Dennis and Napoleon Hill 1992 Think and Grow Rich: A Black Choice. New York: Fawcett Books. Kinnon, Joy Bennett 2005 The 100-Year Anniversary of Atla nta Life. Ebony Magazine. December. Kirshenblatt-Gimblett, Barbara 1995 Theorizing Heritage. Ethnomusi cology. (39)3: 367-380. Autumn. Klugh, Elgin 2006 The Glover School Historic District Site: Rekindling the Spirit of an African American School Community In Schools as Imagined Communities.. Deidre Cobb-Roberts, Sherman Dorn, and Barbara Shircliffe, eds. Pp. 181-209. New York: Palgrave Macmillian. Kreps, Christina K. 2003 Liberating Culture: Cr oss-Cultural Perspectives on Museums, Curation, and Heritage Preservation. London and New York: Routledge. Kruse, Kevin M. 2005 White Flight: Atlanta and the Making of Modern Conservatism. Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press. Laundry, Bart 2000 Black Working Wives: Pioneers of the American Family Revolution. Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press. Lewis, Earl. 1996 Connecting Memory, Self and the Po wer of Place in African American Urban History. In The New African American Urban History. Kenneth W. Goings, and Raymond A. Mohl, eds. Thous and Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Pp. 116141.
253 Light, Ivan H. 1972 Ethnic Enterprise in America: Business and Welfare Among Chinese, Japanese and Blacks. Berkeley: Univ ersity of California Press. Lee, George W. 1969 A Salute to Woman Power. In The Vision. March 1969, Volume 1, Number 3. Atlanta Life Newsletter. Atlanta, GA. Lee, George W., Marjorie King, Gunn, L. J. and Simon, E. L. 1975 A Salute to Atlanta Lifes Graduates Managers Conference. In The Vision. Atlanta Life Newsletter. Volu me VI: 4. October. Atlanta, GA. Lincoln, Eric C. and Lawrence H. Mamiya 1990 The Black Church in the African American Experience. Durham and London: Duke University Press. Loevy, Robert 1997 The Civil Rights Act of 1964: The Passage of the Law That Ended Racial Segregation. Albany: State Univ ersity of New York Press. Lowenthal, David 1985 The Past is a Foreign Country. New York: Cambridge University Press. 1994 Identity, Heritage, and History. In John R. Gillis. (eds)Commemorations: the politics of national id entity Princeton, N.J.: Prin ceton University Press. Macdonald, S. & Fyfe, G. Eds. 1996 Theorizing Museums: Representing id entity and diversity in a changing world. London: Blackwell Publishers. Marable, Manning 1983 How Capitalism Underdeveloped Black America: Problems in Race, Political Economy, and Society. Cambri dge, MA: South End Press Classics. 2006 The Black South Katrinas Unnatu ral Disaster a Tragedy of Black Suffering and White Denial. Souls. 8:1-8. Merritt, Carole 2002 The Herndons: An Atlanta Family. Athens and London: University of Georgia Press. Murphy, William P. 1978 Oral Literature. Annual Revi ew of Anthropology. 7:113-136.
254 Myrick-Harris, Clarissa. 2007 The Origins of the Civil Right s Movement in Atlanta, 18801910. American Historical Association. Accessed March 3, 2007. http://www.historians.org/Persp ectives/issues/2 006/0611/0611ann5.cfm (Accessed 01/10). Myrick-Harris, Clarissa Ph.D. and Norman Harris 2005 Atlanta in the Civil Rights Move ment. Atlanta Regional Council for Higher Education. OneWorld Archives. www.atlantahighered.org/civilrights (Accessed 01/10). Nader, Laura 1972 Up the Anthropologist: Perspect ives Gained from Studying Up." In Reinventing Anthropology Dell Hymes, ed. Pg.284-311. N.Y.: Pantheon Books. Nanda, Serena 2002 Using a Museum as a Resource for Ethnographic Research. Michael Angrosino, ed. In Doing Cultural Anthropology: Pr ojects for Ethnographic Data Collection. Pgs. 71-80. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press. Narayan, Kirin 1993 How Native is Native Anthropolog ist? American Anthropologist, 5(3):671-686. National Register 2000 Herndon Home Museum. Interior Image. February 16.http://www.flickr.com/phot os/nationalregister/3694585071 (Accessed 04/10). Oliver, Melvin L. and Thomas M. Shapiro 2007 Wealth and Racial Equality. In Redress for Historical Injustices in the United States: On Reparations for Sl avery, Jim Crow, and Their Legacies. Michael T. Martin and Marilyn Yaqui nto, eds. Durham and London: Duke University Press. Osthaus, Carl R. 1976 Freedmen, Philanthropy, and Fraud: A History of the Freedmans Savings Bank. Chicago: University of Illinois Press. Pattillo-McCoy, Mary 2003 Negotiating Blackness, for Richer or for Poorer. Ethnography. 4(1):61-93. Phillips, Robert 1999 Interview with Author. Interview by Carole Merritt. February 4. tlanta, GA.
255 Polanyi, Karl 1968 The Economy as Instituted Process In Primitive, Archaic, and Modern Economies: Essays of Karl Polanyi. Geor ge Dalton (ed.) Pp. 139-75. Garden City, N.Y.: Anchor Books. Portes, Alejandro 1995 The Economic Sociology of Immigration: Essays on Networks, Ethnicity and Entrepreneurship. New York: Ru ssell Sage Foundation Publications. Pousner, Howard 2009 Preservationists fear for Herndon Plaza, Morris Brown, Other Sites. The Atlanta Journal-Const itution. November 4, 2009. Purcell, Trevor 1996 Local Institutions in Grassroots Development: The Rotating Savings and Credit Association. Paper. Wenner Gren Founda tion for Anthropological Research, Inc. Register of the Atlanta Life Insuranc e Company Photographic Print Collection 2004 Register of the Atlanta Life In surance Company Photographic Print Collection. Sanford, Lamonica, Wesl ey Chenault, and Alisha Winn. Digital Library of Georgia. Located at th e Herndon Home Museum. Atlanta, GA. Register of the Atlanta Life Insurance Company Records 2004 ALIC Records. Sanford, Lamonica, Wesley Chenault, Deborah McGuire, Joe Renouard, and Yinka Winfrey, Brenda Petty-Moore, Tashiana Scott-Cochran, and Alana White. 2002-2004; 2004-2005. Digi tal Library of Georgia, Online. Located at Auburn Avenue Research Li brary, Atlanta-Fulton County Library System. Atlanta, GA. Roach, Ronald 1998 Auctioning Off Yesterda y Protest Against the Sale of African American Historical Artifacts and Documents. Bl ack Issues in Higher Education. Jan 8. Rodriguez, Cheryl 1998 Recapturing Lost Images: Narratives of a Black Business Enclave. Greenbaum, Susan and Cheryl Rodriguez (eds). 1998. Central Avenue Legacies. In Practicing Anthropology. 20(1):6-11. 2001 A Home Girl Goes Home: Black Feminism and the Lure of Native Anthropology. In Black Feminist Anthr opology: Theory, Politics, Praxis, and Poetics. Irma McClaurin, ed. New Jersey: Rutgers University Press.
256 Rodriguez, Cheryl and Yvette Ginger Baber 2002 Reconstructing a Community thr ough Archival Research. Michael Angrisino, ed. In Doing Cultural Anthropology: Pr ojects for Ethnographic Data Collection. Pgs. 63-70 Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press. Ruffins, Fath Davis. 1992 Mythos, Memory, and History: Africa n American Preservation. Ivan Karp, Christine Mullen Kreamer, eds. In Museums and Communities: The Politics of Public Culture. Pg.506-611. Smithsonian Institution Press: Washington and London. 1997 Recovering Yesterday: Collection and Preservation of African American History. Black Issues in Higher Education. Feb 6th. Rutheiser, Charles 1996 Imagineering Atlanta: The Politics of Place in the City of Dreams. London: Verso. Schensul, Stephen, Jean J. Sche nsul and Margaret LeCompte 1999 Essential Ethnographic Methods: Observations, Interviews, and Questionnaires. Book 2. Walnut Creek: Altamira Press. Scott, Joan W. 1991 The Evidence of Experience. Crit ical Inquiry. Summer. The Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia, 6th ed. 17 (4):773-797 Shackel, Paul A. 2001 Public Memory and the Search for Power in American Historical Archaeology. American Anthropologist 103(3):655-670. Sharockman, Aaron 2006 New museum struggles for life. St Petersburg Times. November 28. Shircliffe, Barbara 2001 We Got the Best of that World: A Case for the Study of Nostalgia in the Oral History of School Segregation. The Oral Hi story Review. 28(2):59-84. Shopes, Linda 1986 Oral History and Community Involvement: The Baltimore Neighborhood Heritage Project. Benson, Susan, St ephen Brier, and Roy Rosenzweig, In Presenting the Past: Essays on History and the Public. eds. Pp. 249-263. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
257 Sikes, Michael 1992 Interpreting the Heard Museum as a Metaphoric Structure: A Critical and Ethnographic Study. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, The Florida State University. Stewart, Jeffery and Fath Davis Ruffins 1986 A Faithful Witness: Afro-American Public History in Historical Perspective, 1828-1984. Benson Benson, Susan, Stephen Brier, and Roy Rosenzweig, eds. In Presenting the Past: Essays on History and the Public. Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Spencer, C.A. 1960 Black Benevolent Societies and th e Development of Black Insurance Companies in Nineteenth Century Alabama. Phylon. (3rd Qtr. 1985). 46(3):251261. Strathern, Marilyn 2004 The Whole Person and Its Artifacts In Annual Review of Anthropology. 33(1):1-19. Stewart, Rowena 1994 The Empowerment of African Americ an Museums. Jane R. Glaser and Artemis A. Zenetou, eds. In Gender Pers pectives: Essays on Women in Museums. Pg. 71-81.Smithsonian Institution Press: Washington and London. Stuart, M. S. 1970 An Economic Detour: A History of Insurance in the Lives of American Negroes. New York: Wendell Malliet and Company. Suggs, Ernie 2005 Historic Herndon Mansion Shuttere d. Atlanta Journal-Constitution June 9. Taborsky, Edwina 1990 The Discourse Object. In Objects of Knowledge. Susan Pearce. Ed. Pp. 50-77. London; New York: Athlone Press. Taylor, Robert Joseph, Michael C. Thornton, and Linda M. Chatters. 1987 Black Americans Perception of the Sociohistorical Role of the Church. Journal of Black St udies. 18(2):123-138. Thompson, Paul 2000 The Voice of the Past: Oral History. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
258 Tidwell, John Edgar and Mark A. Sanders, eds. 2007 Sterling A. Browns: A Negro L ooks at the South. New York: Oxford University Press. Tierney, Gerry 2002 Reconstructing a Community thr ough Archival Research. Michael Angrisino, ed. In Doing Cultural Anthropology: Pr ojects for Ethnographic Data Collection. Pg. 9-17. Long Grove IL: Waveland Press. The Associated Press King Papers Find Home in Atlanta: Morehouse College Welcome $32 million Collection of Documents. October 9, 2006. MSNBC.com http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15198573 (Accessed 03/07). The Georgia Trust 2009 The Georgia Trust for Historic Pres ervation Announces its 2010 List of States 10 Places in Peril. http://www.georgiatrust.org /news/2010pip/newsrelease.php (Accessed 02/10). The New Georgia Encyclopedia 2005 Atlanta Race Riot of 1906. Georgia Humanities Council, in partnership with the University of Georgia Pr ess, the University System of Georgia/GALILEO, and the Office of the Governor. www.georgiaencyclopedia.org/ nge/Article.jsp?id=h-3033 September 23. (Accessed 01/09). The Herndon Home Newsletter 2003 Atlanta Remembers. Alonzo F. and Norris Herndon B. Herndon Foundation. 14:2. September. Trouillot, Michel-Rolph 1995 Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History. Boston, MA: Beacon Press. Tuck, Stephen G. N. 2001 Beyond Atlanta: The Struggle for R acial Equality in Georgia, 1940-1980. Athens, Georgia: Univer sity Georgia Press. University of South Florida Counsel ing Center for Human Development 2009 Imposter Syndrome www.usfweb2.usf.edu/counsel/ b_psy/p_selfhelp_main.html (Accessed 04/1/10) Tampa, FL.
259 Walker, Juliet E.K. 1998 The History of Black Business in America: Race Capitalism, Race, Entrepreneurship. New York: Macmillan Library Reference. Weare, Walter 1993 Black Business in the New South: A Social History of the North Carolina Mutual Life Insurance Company. Du rham: Duke University Press. Weems, Robert E. 1994 A Crumbling Legacy: The Decline of African American Companies in Contemporary America. The Review of Black Political. (23) 2:25-37. 1996 Black Business in the Black Metr opolis: The Chica go Metropolitan Assurance Company, 1925-1985. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. 1997 Out of the Shadows: Business Enterprise and African American Historiography. Business and Economic Hi story. Volume (26)1: 200-212. Fall. 2002 Where Did All of the Consumers Go ?: Historic Black-Owned Businesses and the African American Consumer Market. In Black Business and Economic Power. Jalloh, Alusine and Toyin Falola, eds. Pg. 405-423. New York: University of Rochester Press. Williams, Brett 1999 The Great Family Fraud of Postwar America. In Without Justice for All: The New Liberalism and Our Retreat from Racial Equality. Adolph Reed, Jr., ed. Pp. 65-89. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Williams, Charles, Jr., and Hilda J. B. Williams 1990 Mutual Aid Societies and Economic Development: Survival Efforts. In African Americans in the South: Issues of Race, Class, and Gender. Hans A. Baer and Yvonne Jones (eds.) Southern Anth ropological Society Proceedings, No. 25. Athens and London: The Univer sity of Georgia Press. Williamson, Arlene 1992 Museums in Crisis: A Strong Sense of Mission Helps Many Survive. American Visions 7 (1): 22-25. February/March. Wilson, William J. 1987 The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the Underclass, and Public Policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
260 1991 Public Policy Research and the Truly Disadvantaged. In the Urban Underclass. Christopher Jencks and Paul E. Peterson, eds, Pp. 461-481. Washington D.C.: The Brookings Institute. Winn, Alisha 2006 Interview with Museum Board Ch air of Carter G. Woodson Museum. Research Methods course. Susan Greenbaum. Spring. Yelvington, Kevin A. 2009 Anthropologizing History. Meeting w ith Kevin Yelvington. University of South Florida. Tampa, FL. October 26. 2002 History, Memory, and Identity: A Programmatic Prolegomenon. Critique of Anthropology 22(3):227-256. 2002 Whose History?: Museum-making and Struggles over Ethnicity and Representation in the Sunbelt. In Critique of Anthropology 22 (3):343-379. Yelvington, Kevin, Neill G. Goslin, and Wendy Arriaga 1995 Producing Power: Ethnicity, Gender, a nd Class in a Caribbean Workplace. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
About the Author Alisha R. Winn grew up in Riviera Beac h, FL, a neighboring town of West Palm Beach. She received Bachelor of Arts degrees in Sociology from Bethune-Cookman University, and Anthropology from Florida Atla ntic University. She is a graduate from Georgia State University with a M.A. in Anthropology. Alisha has worked on many African American community re search projects on heritage preservation, oral narratives with elders and youth, and inco rporating African American history and culture in the curriculum of public school systems. She curren tly serves as archivis t for the Association for Black Anthropologists. Her future rese arch interests include African American working class populations relate d to educational disparities, employment, and identity, and the impact that learning African American history from community elders instead of textbooks has on youth.
xml version 1.0 encoding UTF-8 standalone no
record xmlns http:www.loc.govMARC21slim xmlns:xsi http:www.w3.org2001XMLSchema-instance xsi:schemaLocation http:www.loc.govstandardsmarcxmlschemaMARC21slim.xsd
leader nam 22 Ka 4500
controlfield tag 007 cr-bnu---uuuuu
008 s2010 flu s 000 0 eng d
datafield ind1 8 ind2 024
subfield code a E14-SFE0003412
Beyond the business :
b social and cultural aspects of the atlanta life insurance company
h [electronic resource] /
by Alisha Winn.
[Tampa, Fla] :
University of South Florida,
Title from PDF of title page.
Document formatted into pages; contains X pages.
Dissertation (Ph.D.)--University of South Florida, 2010.
Includes bibliographical references.
Text (Electronic dissertation) in PDF format.
Mode of access: World Wide Web.
System requirements: World Wide Web browser and PDF reader.
ABSTRACT: The dissertation research is an examination of the social and cultural dynamics of the Atlanta Life Insurance Company (ALIC) in Atlanta, GA. During the Jim Crow era (and post Jim Crow era), the ALIC provided economic mobility through employment, home loans, life insurance, and community solidarity. The company was one of the largest and most successful African-American financial institution in the country during the 20th century. It was founded in 1905 by Alonzo F. Herndon, a prosperous black barber and entrepreneur who rose from enslavement to become by 1927 the wealthiest African American in Atlanta. Renamed as the Atlanta Life Financial Group (ALFG), today the insurance company remains the leading African American stock-owned insurance company in the nation. I examine how Atlanta Life employees conceptualized their relationships within the company (past and present) and the larger African American community of Atlanta, along with the role the institution played as a shared space for producing cultural identities through social interactions. I explore the multiple roles of the company that impacted the community in the past and current roles within the African American community. I also explore what the possible closing of the Herndon Home Museum mean for memories and heritage, and the Herndon family's accomplishments if the home were torn down.
Advisor: Susan Greenbaum, Ph.D.
t USF Electronic Theses and Dissertations.