|USFDC Home | USF Electronic Theses and Dissertations||| RSS|
This item is only available as the following downloads:
xml version 1.0 encoding UTF-8 standalone no
record xmlns http:www.loc.govMARC21slim xmlns:xsi http:www.w3.org2001XMLSchema-instance xsi:schemaLocation http:www.loc.govstandardsmarcxmlschemaMARC21slim.xsd
leader nam 22 Ka 4500
controlfield tag 007 cr-bnu---uuuuu
008 s2010 flu s 000 0 eng d
datafield ind1 8 ind2 024
subfield code a E14-SFE0004560
An exploratory study of the intrapersonal, socio-cultural, and behavioral factors that influence hiv risk behaviors among ethnic subgroups of black heterosexual men :
b the intersection of the beliefs and perceptions of black women
h [electronic resource] /
by Shalewa Noel-Thomas.
[Tampa, Fla] :
University of South Florida,
Title from PDF of title page.
Document formatted into pages; contains X pages.
Dissertation (PHD)--University of South Florida, 2010.
Includes bibliographical references.
Text (Electronic thesis) in PDF format.
Mode of access: World Wide Web.
System requirements: World Wide Web browser and PDF reader.
ABSTRACT: Twenty five years after AIDS was first scientifically described, the disease continues to take its toll on the human population. HIV/AIDS disproportionately affects marginalized groups such as poor, underserved, minority populations. In the United States, Blacks become infected with and die from HIV/AIDS more than any other ethnic or racial group. Despite a vast body of literature on HIV/AIDS, little research has focused on black heterosexual men and even fewer studies have explored the context of risk among subgroups of black men. Using qualitative research methods and a socio-ecological framework, this study explored the intrapersonal, socio-cultural, and behavioral factors that influence sexual behaviors in ethnic subgroups of black men who identify as heterosexual. Further, the study examined black women's perceptions of the sexual behaviors of black men. Conducted in a metropolitan area in Southwest Florida the study consisted of two phases: 1) semi-structured in-depth interviews were conducted among U.S.-born (N=15) and Haitian-born (N=14) heterosexual men who are 18 years and older and have lived in the U.S. for at least 3 years. 2) Using focus group methodology, phase 2 explored black women's (N=23) perceptions of black male sexual behaviors. Study findings have significant implications for public health education, research and practice. Findings reveal that while Haitian-born and U.S.-born men have high levels of knowledge about HIV, they also ascribe to HIV conspiracy beliefs and practice high risk sexual behaviors such as unprotected sex and partner concurrency. Results show that black men's sexual behaviors are influenced by socio-ecological factors such as family norms, hip-hop culture and religious beliefs. Female study participants perceived factors such as masculine ideologies, socialization, and the male-to-female ratio imbalance as critical influences on male sexual behaviors. While intrapersonal approaches are important to address HIV risk behaviors, ecological frameworks are necessary to inform the development of HIV prevention programs that address the socio-ecological factors that create an environment of risk. This inquiry underscores cultural and gender differences in the conceptualization of HIV/AIDS. Findings have implications for HIV prevention and demonstrate the need for gender-specific and culturally relevant HIV prevention approaches for U.S.-born and Haitian-born blacks.
Advisor: Bruce Levin, Dr. P.H.
Theory of Gender and Power
x Community & Family Health
t USF Electronic Theses and Dissertations.
An Exploratory Study of the Intrapersonal, Socio-cultural, and Behavioral Factors that Influence HIV Risk Behaviors Among Ethnic Subgroups of Black Heterosexual Men: The Intersection of the Belief s and Perceptions of Black Women by Shalewa Noel-Thomas A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Community and Family Health College of Public Health University of South Florida Co-Major Professor: Bruce Levin, Dr.P.H. Co-Major Professor: Ellen Daley, Ph.D. Julie Baldwin, Ph.D. Michael Knox, Ph.D. Nancy Romero-Daza, Ph.D. Date of Approval: June 23, 2010 Keywords: Haitians, African Americans, Immigrants, Qualitative Methods, Socio-ecological, Sexual H ealth, Health Beliefs, Theory of Gender and Power Copyright 2010 Shalewa Noel-Thomas
Dedication To Mavis Lloyd-Johnson To all who continue to fight to erad icate HIV and AIDS across the world.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The pursuit of this doctoral degree has been a long process made possible by the support, friendship, love and prayers of a wonde rful group of individu als. I extend special thanks to my committee members who have provided optimal support throughout my doctoral studies. To my co-major professo rs Dr. Bruce Levin and Dr. Ellen Daley who provided their tireless suppor t and encouragement throughout this journey. To Dr. Michael Knox who provided my first professi onal introduction to the field of HIV and has supported me ever since. I am ever so thankful for your mentorship and support. To Dr. Romero-Daza who has provided tremendous support and encouragement throughout my graduate studies. To Dr. Julie Bald win, thank you for your endless support and invaluable feedback. I am sin cerely thankful to my family for all their support throughout this process. Special thanks to my gra ndmother, Mrs. Mavis Lloyd-Johnson, who taught me the value of education, professionalism, and independence. Sincer e thanks to all my friends and co-workers who listened and s upported me over the years. To my husband, confidant, and best friend, Troy Thomas, you have been a guiding light throughout this journey. Words cannot express my apprecia tion for your friendship, humor, love and encouragement. To God who makes all things possible. To the co mmunity stakeholders, Josette Toulme and Fabien Louissaint, w ho provided invaluable community linkages. Finally, Id like to sincerely thank all those who were willin g to share their stories and lived experiences to make this study a reality.
i TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES................................................................................................vii LIST OF FIGURES.............................................................................................viii ABSTRACT...........................................................................................................ix CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION......................................................................1 Statement of the Problem.............................................................................1 Burden of HIV/AIDS in the U.S..................................................................2 Burden of HIV/AIDS in the U.S. Black Population....................................3 Rationale for the Inquiry..............................................................................4 Research Questions......................................................................................7 Delimitations................................................................................................8 Limitations...................................................................................................8 Definition of Relevant Terms......................................................................9 CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW........................................................11 Overview of HIV/AIDS Res earch on Risk Behaviors...............................11 U.S. Black Immigrant Population..............................................................13 Burden of HIV/AIDS among Black Men in the U.S.................................14 Burden of HIV/AIDS among Black Women in the U.S............................15 Burden of HIV/AIDS among Blacks in Florida........................................15 Burden of HIV/AIDS among Blacks in Hillsborough County, Florida.....16 Burden of HIV/AIDS among Immigrants in Florida.................................17 Burden of HIV/AIDS among Haitians in Florida......................................18 Rationale for Focus on Haitian-born Blacks..............................................18 Risk Factors for HIV Transmission in the Black Population....................18 Intrapersonal Factors......................................................................19 Social Factors.................................................................................21 Economic Deprivation.......................................................21 Gender Disparities.............................................................26 Discrimination and Racism................................................27 HIV/AIDS Related Stigma................................................27 Immigration Status.............................................................30 Cultural Factors..................................................................31 Behavioral Health: Substa nce Abuse and HIV Risk......................39 Substance Use....................................................................39 Purpose of the Inquiry................................................................................42 Theoretical Frameworks Informing the Inquiry........................................42
ii Socio-ecological Model of STD Ri sk and Protective Factors...................42 The Health Belief Model...........................................................................47 Theoretical Additions to the Health Belief Model.....................................53 Application of the Health Belie f Model to Health Behaviors....................54 Theory of Gender and Power.....................................................................57 Application of the Theory of Gender and Power.......................................59 Criticisms of the Theory of Gender and Power.........................................60 TGP Applied to HIV Risk and Womens Health.......................................60 CHAPTER THREE: METHODS..........................................................................64 Purpose of the Inquiry................................................................................64 Research Questions....................................................................................65 Phase I: In-depth Interviews with Heterosexual Men................................65 Phase II: Focus Groups with Heterosexual Black Women........................66 Qualitative Research..................................................................................68 Overview of the Research Design..............................................................69 Study Population........................................................................................69 Location of the Study.................................................................................71 Immigration in Florida...............................................................................71 Phase I: In-Depth Semi-Struc tured Interviews with Men..........................72 Inclusion Criteria for Individual Interviews..................................72 Exclusion Criteria for Individual Interviews.................................72 Sample for Individual Interviews...................................................72 Phase II: Focus Groups with Women........................................................75 Inclusion Criteria for Focus Groups..............................................76 Exclusion Criteria for Focus Groups.............................................76 Sample for Focus Groups with Women.........................................76 Recruitment for Phases I and II.................................................................78 Strategies to Addre ss Researcher Safety....................................................79 Data Collection Procedures........................................................................80 Phase I: Individual Semi-Structured Interviews............................80 Setting................................................................................81 Demographic Data.............................................................81 Individual Semi-Structured Interviews..............................81 Interview Procedure...........................................................82 Categories of Interview Questions.....................................82 Development and Refinement of Interview Guide............83 Pilot Study..........................................................................84 Incentives...........................................................................84 Phase II: Focus Groups with Black Women..................................85 Setting................................................................................85 Demographic Data.............................................................85 Focus Group Procedure......................................................86 Multiple-category Design..................................................86 Development and Refinement of the Focus Group Guide.87 Pilot Study..........................................................................87
iii Incentives...........................................................................88 Technical Research Process.......................................................................88 Audio-Taping Interviews...............................................................88 Transcription..................................................................................89 Field Notes.....................................................................................89 Establishing Trustworthiness.....................................................................89 Credibility......................................................................................90 Transferability................................................................................90 Dependability.................................................................................91 Confirmability................................................................................92 Researcher Bias..........................................................................................93 Data Analysis.............................................................................................95 Reliability of Coding......................................................................96 Data Interpretation.....................................................................................98 Management of Data................................................................................100 Protection of Hu man Subjects.................................................................100 CHAPTER FOUR: RESULTS............................................................................101 Phase I Results: Semi-Structured Interviews with Black Men................101 Demographic Information: Phase I..............................................101 What are black mens knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs about HIV/AIDS transmission?...................................................................108 U.S.-born Men.............................................................................108 Knowledge of HIV Risk a nd Protective Factors..............108 Conspiracy Beliefs...........................................................109 Haitian-born Men.........................................................................112 Knowledge of HIV Risk a nd Protective Factors..............112 Conspiracy Beliefs...........................................................114 What are the risk behaviors practi ced by black men who identify as heterosexual and what factors are as sociated with these behaviors?.115 U.S-born Men..............................................................................115 Multiple Sex Partners.......................................................116 Condom Use.....................................................................118 Women and Condom Use................................................121 Behavioral Health: Alcohol and Substance Use..............123 Haitian-born Men.........................................................................126 Multiple Sex Partners.......................................................126 Condom Use.....................................................................127 Women and Condom Use................................................130 Behavioral Health Alc ohol and Substance Use............131 What cultural norms influence sexual behaviors among black men who identify as heterosexual?............................................................133 U.S.-born men..............................................................................134 Family Attitudes and Communication about Sexual Behavior.........................................................134 Peer Norms.......................................................................138
iv Hip-Hop Culture..............................................................141 Attitudes and Beliefs about Homosexuality and Bisexuality.................................................................144 Haitian-born Men.........................................................................147 Family Attitudes and Communication about Sexual Behavior.........................................................147 Peer Norms.......................................................................151 Hip-Hop Culture..............................................................154 Attitudes and Beliefs about Homosexuality and Bisexuality.................................................................157 How do gender norms influence se xual behavior among black men who identify as heterosexual?............................................................161 U.S.-born Men.............................................................................161 Financial Decision-making..............................................161 Condom-use Decision-making.........................................162 Haitian-born Men.........................................................................167 Financial Decision-making..............................................167 Condom-use Decision-making.........................................168 Phase II Results: Focus Groups among U.S.-born and Haitian-born Women.........................................................................172 Demographic Information: Phase II.............................................173 What are black womens percepti ons of the risk behaviors practiced by black men who identify as heterosexual?......................177 U.S.-born Women........................................................................177 Condom Use.....................................................................177 Women and Condom Use................................................178 Multiple Sex Partners.......................................................181 Behavioral Health: Alcohol and Substance Use..............182 Haitian-born Women...................................................................184 Condom Use.....................................................................184 Women and Condom Use................................................185 Multiple Sex Partners.......................................................187 Behavioral Health: Alcohol and Substance Use..............188 What are black womens per ceptions of the gender and cultural norms that influe nce sexual behavior among black men who identify as heterosexual?..........................................189 U.S-born Women.........................................................................190 Masculine Ideologies.......................................................190 Sex Ratio Imbalance/Lack of Female Empowerment.....190 Socialization of Women and Girls...................................191 Sexual Abuse and Trauma Histories................................192 Lack of Male Father Figure.............................................193 Lack of Family Communication about Sexual Health.....194 Influence of Hip-Hop Culture..........................................196 Haitian-born Women...................................................................197 Lack of Family Communication about Sexual Health.....197
v The Role of Voudou.........................................................198 Differential Socializatio n of Girls and Boys....................199 What are black womens percep tions of the ways in which black mens sexual behaviors affect their own health?.....................201 CHAPTER FIVE: DISCU SSION AND CONCLUSIONS.................................203 Section I: Summary of Study Results......................................................203 Section II: Theoretical Analysis...............................................................206 Analysis of Study Results within the Context of the Socio-ecological Model of STD Risk and Protective Factors.............................................................206 I or Microsystem Level................................................206 Family and Relational or Mesosystem Level...................207 Community/Peers or Exosystem Level............................208 Societal or Macrosystem Level........................................208 Analysis of the Study Results within the Context of the Theory of Gender and Power.................................................209 Section III: Synthesis of Research Findings............................................210 Knowledge, Attitudes and Beliefs about HIV/AIDS...................210 Conspiracy Beliefs.......................................................................212 HIV Risk Behaviors among Black Men......................................213 Multiple Sex Partners.......................................................214 Condom Use.....................................................................216 Behavioral Health .......................................................................221 Cultural Norms.............................................................................222 Family Attitudes toward Sexual Health Communication..........................................................223 Hip-Hop Culture..............................................................225 Cultural Attitudes toward Homosexuality and Bisexuality.................................................................226 Peer Norms...................................................................................228 Gender Norms and HIV Risk.......................................................228 Sex Ratio Imbalance....................................................................229 Childhood Sexual Abuse and Trauma Histories..........................230 Influence of Religion...................................................................231 Structural Factors.........................................................................232 Strengths and Limitations of the Study....................................................234 Study Limitations.........................................................................234 Study Strengths............................................................................236 Section IV: Implications for Public Health Education, Practice, and Research.......................................................................238 Public Health Education and Practice..........................................238 Public Health Research................................................................242 Dissemination of Findings.......................................................................244 REFERENCES....................................................................................................245
vi APPENDICES ..................................................................................................... 265 Appendix A: Epidemiological Da ta: Figures 1-2 and Tables1-2.............266 Appendix B: Population Data : Tables 1-2..............................................270 Appendix C: Recruitment Flyers.............................................................271 Appendix D: Eligibility Checklists..........................................................273 Appendix E: Demographic Survey..........................................................275 Appendix F: Informed Consent for Interviews........................................277 Appendix G: Informed Consent for Focus Groups..................................281 Appendix H: Interview Guide..................................................................285 Appendix I: Focus Group Guide..............................................................289 Appendix J: Itemization of C oding by Independent Coders....................291 ABOUT THE AUTHOR.......................................................................END PAGE
vii LIST OF TABLES Table 1: Theory of Gender and Power as it Relates to Womens Health.........................................................................63 Table 2: Research Questions and Theoretical Concepts............................67 Table 3: Phase I Study Population..........................................................74 Table 4: Phase II Study Population.........................................................77 Table 5: Demographic Charact eristics of Male Sample..........................102 Table 6: Demographic Characteristi cs of U.S.-born Male Sample.........103 Table 7: Demographic Characteristi cs of Haitian-born Male Sample.....105 Table 8: Emergent Themes: Phase I........................................................106 Table 9: Demographic Character istics of Female Sample.......................174 Table 10: Emergent Themes: Phase II.....................................................176
viii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: The Cycle of HIV/AIDS Stigma and Discrimination................29 Figure 2: The Socio-ecological Model of STD Risk and Protective Factors........................................................................44 Figure 3: Modified Socio-ecologi cal Model of STD Risk and Protective Factors Applied to Research Study............................46 Figure 4: The Health Belief Model............................................................52 Figure 5: Template Organi zing Style of Analysis.....................................99
ix An Exploratory Study of the Intrapers onal, Socio-Cultural, and Behavioral Factors that Influence HIV Risk Beha viors among Ethnic Subgroups of Black Heterosexual Men: The Intersection of th e Beliefs and Perceptions of Black Women Shalewa Noel-Thomas ABSTRACT Twenty five years after AIDS was first scientifically described, the disease continues to take its toll on the human populat ion. HIV/AIDS dispr oportionately affects marginalized groups such as poor, unders erved, minority populations. In the United States, Blacks become infected with and di e from HIV/AIDS more than any other ethnic or racial group. Despite a vast body of literatu re on HIV/AIDS, little research has focused on black heterosexual men and even fewer studi es have explored the context of risk among subgroups of black men. Using qualitative research methods and a socio-ecological framework, this study explored the intrapersonal, so cio-cultural, and be havioral factors that influence sexual behaviors in ethnic subgroups of black men who identify as heterosexual. Further, the study examined black womens perceptions of the sexual behaviors of black men. Conducted in a metropolitan area in Southwes t Florida the study consisted of two phases: 1) semi-structured in-depth interv iews were conducted among U.S.-born (N=15) and Haitian-born (N=14) heterosexual men who are 18 years and older and have lived in the U.S. for at least 3 years. 2) Using focus group methodology, pha se 2 explored black womens (N=23) perceptions of bl ack male sexual behaviors.
x Study findings have significant implications for public health education, research and practice. Findings reveal th at while Haitian-born and U.S.-born men have high levels of knowledge about HIV, they also ascribe to HIV conspiracy beliefs and practice high risk sexual behaviors such as unprotected se x and partner concurrency. Results show that black mens sexual behaviors are influenced by socio-ecological factors such as family norms, hip-hop culture and religious beliefs. Fe male study participants perceived factors such as masculine ideologies, socialization, and the male-to-female ratio imbalance as critical influences on male sexual behavi ors. While intrapersonal approaches are important to address HIV risk behaviors, eco logical frameworks are necessary to inform the development of HIV prevention programs that address the socio-ecological factors that create an environment of risk. This inquiry underscores cultural and gender differences in the conceptualization of HI V/AIDS. Findings have implications for HIV prevention and demonstrate the need for ge nder-specific and culturally relevant HIV prevention approaches for U.S. -born and Haitian-born blacks.
1 It is people joining forces in a time of great need. It is hope, it is sharing the burden. It is people caring for their own and finding love, and surviv ing, and believing in the future even when we are hurting more than we have ever hurt before .It is AIDS. (Chris Brownlie 1951-1989) CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION Statement of the Problem Racial and ethnic disparities in the in cidence and prevalence of HIV and AIDS continue to exist globally and in the Unite d States. Blacks comprise 13% of the U.S. population, but account for almost half (49%) of the more than 1 million people living in the United Sates with HIV/AIDS (CDC, 2008a). Cr itical to fighting this racial divide in the AIDS epidemic, is an understanding of h ealth disparities and the devastating impact these inequities have on minority communities. The National Institutes of Health defines health disparities as differences in the in cidence, prevalence, mortality, and burden of diseases and other adverse health conditions that exist among speci fic population groups in the United States (NCI, 2007). According to the Nationa l Minority AIDS Council (NMAC), a more systematic approach that ad dresses public policy is urgently needed to address the root causes of the health in equalities that devastate black communities (NMAC, 2006). Therefore, efforts must be ma de to address the need for new, innovative, multi-layered, mixed-methodological approach es to understanding appropriate and effective interventions. The Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV ), the virus that causes Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS), was first identified in the United States in June
2 1981. Since then, this disease ha s caused significant morbidity and mortality both in the United States and globally. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), as of December 2008, there were approximately 33.4 million people living with HIV/AIDS globally. In 2008, including 2.7 million people were newly infected with HIV. In this same year, 2 million died from the disease. Of the 6,800 people who were infected each day in 2007, 96% lived in low and middle inco me countries, 50% of the infections were among women and 40% among young people be tween the ages of 15 and 24 years (WHO, 2009). Burden of HIV/AIDS in the U.S. Likewise, the epidemic in the United States is far from over. Latest Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimat es show that over 56,000 new infections occur every year one person every 9.5 minut es (Hall, Song & Rhodes et al., 2008). The CDC estimates that at the end of 2003 there were 1,039,000 to 1,185,000 persons in the United States living with HIV. In 2007, the es timated number of deaths of persons with AIDS in the United States and dependent areas was 14,561 In the 50 states and the District of Columbia, this included 14,105 adults and adolescents, and 5 children under age 13 years. The cumulative estimated number of deaths of persons with AIDS in the United States and dependent areas, through 2007, was 583,298 In the 50 states and the District of Columbia, this included 557,902 adults and adolescents, and 4,891 children under age 13 years (CDC, 2009a). While HIV prevention and education efforts have been in existence for over 25 years; the United St ates continues to f ace the heavy burden of HIV and AIDS. HIV/AIDS continues to be a devastating disease wh ich ravages the lives of individuals and communities.
3 Burden of HIV/AIDS in the U.S. Black Population The black population is disp roportionately infected and affected by HIV. African American males continue to bear the great est burden of HIV infection. In 2006, the HIV diagnosis rate for all black males in 33 stat es was the highest of any group more than 7 times that for white males, more than twice the rate for Hispanic males, and more than twice the rate for black females. African Am erican females are also disproportionately affected by HIV infection. In 2006, the HIV diagnosis rate for black females was more than 19 times the rate for white females (CDC, 2008a). In addition, the rate of AIDS diagnoses for black adults and adolescents is 10 times that for whites and 3 times the rate for Hispanics. In 2007, African Americans accounted for 51% of the estimated 42,495 new HIV/AIDS diagnoses in the United States (see Appendix A, Figure 1), (CDC, 2009b). Blacks also experience disparities in HIV-related deaths and survival outcomes. Si nce the beginning of the epidemic, 38.6% of AIDS deaths have been among blacks and this proportion is increasing. According to the Health Resources and Services Administrati on (HRSA), critical issues related to the disproportionate rates of HIV in the black popul ation include: blacks are more likely to be uninsured than whites; blacks are three times more likely to live in poverty than whites; and blacks have poorer quality and worse access to health care than whites (HRSA, 2008). The effect of AIDS in the black comm unity has become more devastating over time. The AIDS case diagnosis in blacks rose from 25% of total cases diagnosed in 1985 to 49% in 2006. In recent years, this percenta ge has remained relatively stable (Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, 2008a). At the nationa l level, data are not collected for black
4 sub-populations. Rather, infection rates in sub-populations are reported as African American data. Risk factors for HIV tran smission within the black population are complex and require multiple approaches to address them. This study will increase our understanding of the intrapersonal, socio-cu ltural, and behavioral factors that may increase the risk of hetero sexual transmission among two ethn ic subgroups of U.S. black heterosexual men: U.S.-born and Haitian-born men living in the U.S. for at least three years. Rationale for the Inquiry In the United States, HIV/AIDS dispr oportionately affects minority populations with blacks accounting for half of the new inf ections each year. HIV/AIDS is one of the major health disparities between whites and blacks in the United States. Because of the complex factors that influence acquisition of the virus, the bl ack population remains vulnerable to HIV infection. These factors include poverty, stigma, lack of access to health care, discrimination, incarcerati on, homophobia, substance abuse and mental health problems (CDC, 2007a). Moreover, African Americ an women continue to experience high rates of infection via hete rosexual transmission. Yet, little is known about the risk behaviors of black men who id entify as heterosexual and who may be the transmitters of the disease to black hetero sexual women. Further, even less is known about the subgroup differences in HIV risk behaviors among black men. An exploration of the behaviors of black men is warranted to better understa nd the factors that increase the risk of heterosexual transmission. This study explored the know ledge, attitudes and beliefs about HIV and sexual behaviors among black men, and the influence of intrapersonal, socio-cultural, and behavioral factors on HIV risk behaviors. The findings
5 of this study have significant implica tions for prevention of heterosexual HIV transmission among blacks. Much of the research on the heterosexual AIDS epidemic in the U.S. has focused on women (Campbell, 1995). Likewise, research efforts regarding HIV transmission and prevention among the U.S. black population have largely focused on women and gay populations. Heterosexual men have been the forgotten group in this area of inquiry (Exner, Gardos, Seal & Ehrhardt, 1999, p. 347). According to Dworkin, Fullilove & Peacock, (2009), it is time to shift the HI V/AIDS discourse and prevention practice focused on heterosexually active men from ge nder-neutral to gender-specific and gendertransformative. Moreover, there is a paucity of research addressing the, socio-cultural, intrapersonal, and behavioral factors that influence HIV-risk behaviors in black heterosexual men. Even fewer studies have addressed the influence of these factors on sexual behaviors within ethnic subgroups of the he terosexual black male population. The rising proportion of U.S. blacks who are foreign-born is expected to affect the health profile of the black population in the U.S. (Read & Emerson, 2005; Read, Emerson & Tarlov, 2005). The HIV pandemic has reached all region s of the world, but Sub-Saharan Africa has been the hardest hit, followed by the Ca ribbean. In Latin Amer ica and the Caribbean, an estimated 2 million people are living with HIV/AIDS. Of these, 160,000 were newly infected in 2007 (Henry J. Kaiser Fam ily Foundation, 2008b). As of the end of 2007, an estimated 230,000 people were living with HI V/AIDS in the Caribbean, with 75% of those infected living in Haiti and the Domi nican Republic. AIDS is one of the leading causes of death in the Cari bbean among those aged 25-44 (Henry J. Kaiser Family
6 Foundation, 2008c). Based on these data, immi gration patterns may influence the HIV prevalence in the United States and ultimately affect the health profile of the U.S. black population. The literature reveals a critical gap in re search that acknowledges the diversity of the black population (Beatty, Wheeler & Gait er, 2004). Little is known about the sociocultural beliefs, knowledge, and attitudes related to HIV tran smission and risk behaviors among ethnic subgroups of U.S. blacks. Much of the current li terature assumes homogeneity among U.S. blacks and does not account for dis tinct ethnicity. While there are different and similar socio-cultural e xperiences across popul ation sub-groups, the differences need to be identified and speci fic interventions and prevention initiatives developed accordingly. There is a need to a dopt approaches to fi ght HIV/AIDS in the black community that consider the social, structural, and contextual environments (McCree, 2009). This study furthers the body of knowledge as it allows for an in-depth exploration of the socio-cultural, intraper sonal, and behavioral factors that influence the HIV-risk behaviors of U.S.-born and Haitian-born black heterosexual men. The study also allows for comparison of the perspectives of black men with that of black women from similar ethnic subgroups. The results of this study may be used to design quantitative instruments for future studies and broader ap plication. Study results also provide insights for HIV education and behavioral interventi ons to reduce HIV/AIDS health disparities within ethnically diverse black populations. Ba sed on the identified gaps in the literature, the following research questions were explored in this inquiry.
7 Research Questions Research questions were guided by re search objectives which included the following: Objective 1 : To understand the intraper sonal factors (knowledge, attitudes and beliefs) that influence HIV-risk be haviors in subgroups of black men (Native born African Americans and Haitian-born immigrants) who identify as heterosexual. Research Question: 1. What are black mens knowledge, att itudes, and beliefs about HIV/AIDS transmission? Objective 2 : To understand the socio-cultural and be havioral factors th at influence HIV risk behaviors in subgroups of black men (Native born African Americans and Haitianborn immigrants) who iden tify as heterosexual. 2. What cultural norms influence sexual be havior among black men who identify as heterosexual? 3. What are the HIV-risk behaviors practiced by black men who identif y as heterosexual and what factors are associated with these behaviors? 4. How do gender norms influence sexual be havior among black men who identify as heterosexual? Objective 3 : To discover how black women conceptualize and perc eive the socio-cultural and behavioral factors that influenc e black mens HIV-risk behaviors. 5. What are black womens per ceptions of the risk behavi ors practiced by black men who identify as heterosexual?
8 6. What are black womens percep tions of the gender and cult ural norms that influence sexual behavior among black men who identify as heterosexual? 7. What are black womens pe rceptions of the ways in which black mens sexual behaviors affect black womens health? Delimitations 1. This study was delimited to Haitian and African American heterosexual men who reside in Hillsborough County, Florida. 2. This study was delimited to Haitian and Af rican American men 18 years of age and older residing in Hillsborough County, Florida. 3. For purposes of this study, male participan ts included men who self identify as heterosexual. 4. This study included Haitian and African American women 18 years and older residing on Hillsborough County, Florida. 5. Only U.S.-born and Haitian-born black me n and women who volunteer to participate in the study were included. Limitations Limitations refer to limiting conditions or restrictive weaknesses inherent in the study (Locke, Wyrick Spirduso & Silverman, 2000) The following are limitations of this study: 1. Researcher subjectivity refers to the res earchers own perspec tive (Grbich, 1999). As is characteristic of qualitativ e inquiry, the views and perspe ctives of the researcher may have some influence over the study. My professional and personal background, attitudes, beliefs and worldviews may have influenced interpretation of the data.
9 2. The study findings were based on self-re ported data from study participants. 3. Individuals who volunteered to participate in this inquiry may be different from those who did not agree to participate. 4. The results of this study are based on the participants perceptions, recall and interpretation of their lived experiences. 5. Convenience sampling methods were us ed to recruit study participants. Definition of Relevant Terms 1. Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS): AIDS is the final stage of HIV infection. Having AIDS means that the immune system has been weakened and the body has a difficult time fighting infecti ons. To be diagnosed with AIDS, an individual must have a CD4 count less than 200 and/or have an AIDS defining opportunistic infection (U.S. Department of Health a nd Human Services [DHHS], 2010). 2. African American: An American of black African de scent. Persons who self-identify with African American ancestors who we re involuntary immigrants to the United States (Ogbu as cited in Lewis & Kertzner, 2003). 3. Behavioral Health: Behavioral health was first coin ed in the 1980s to describe the combination of the fields of mental hea lth and substance abus e. It focuses on the study of behavioral health problems such as depression, eating disorders, substance abuse, domestic violence, and anxiety disorders. 4. Blacks: Individuals of African descent. For the purposes of this study, black is used as the catchall term to describe all persons of Af rican descent.
10 5. Culture: A set of rules, standards, or beliefs shared by the members of a group that when acted upon by those members, produces behaviors that fall within a range considered acceptable and proper by those members (Matthews, 2004). 6. Haitian-born immigrant: A native of Haiti who migrated to the United States. For the purpose of this study, Haitian immigrants must have lived in the U.S. for at least three years. 7. Heterosexual: A person sexually attracted to pers ons of the opposite sex or a person who has sexual relations with the opposite sex (Medicine Net, 2008). 8. Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV): This is the virus that causes AIDS. HIV finds and destroys the immune system by attacki ng white blood cells (T cells or CD4 cells) that enable the body to fight disease (CDC, 2010). 9. Social ecology: The social ecology pers pective involves examin ing the behaviors of individuals within th e context of their social and phys ical environment (DiClemente, Salazar, Crosby & Rosenthal, 2005). 10. Substance Abuse: For the purposes of this study, s ubstance abuse refers to illegal drugs (e.g. cocaine, methamphetamines, ma rijuana etc.) as well as alcohol. 11. U.S blacks : Individuals of African descent living in the United States. For the purposes of this study, U.S. blacks refer to U.S.-born blacks and Haitian-born blacks living in the United States for at least three years.
11 CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW This chapter provides a review of the current literature on HIV/AIDS risk behaviors, knowledge, attitudes and beliefs about HIV risk, and the socio-cultural, and behavioral factors that influence sexual beha viors. This literature review will explore black population data including epidemiological data on HIV/ AIDS in the United States. Critical to this inquiry, is an analysis of the theoretical pers pectives that will inform the study. This chapter will present a modified socio-ecological perspective as the overarching framework as well as the health belief model and the theory of gender and power which will be used to inform specific aspects of the study. Overview of HIV/AIDS Re search on Risk Behaviors Historically, HIV/AIDS so cial science research has focused primarily on individual risk behaviors, personal agency and individual volition. Little attention has been devoted to the context within which se xual behaviors occur. (A dimora et al., 2001; Farmer, Connors & Simmons, 1996; Parker, 2001; Wight, 1999; Raiford, DiClemente & Wingood, 2009). The concepts of individual res ponsibility and behavioral individualism have dominated the sexual behavior research literature while social and environmental factors have seldom been considered. Th ese approaches are based on the idea that individuals have total personal control over their health behaviors which leads to the failure to conceptualize sexual behavior within a social and cultural context.
12 Clearly, the focus on individual psychology and subjectivity has done little to reduce or explain the increasing HIV infec tion rates in minority populations. Evidenced by the CDCs launch of A Heightened National Response to the HIV/AIDS Crisis among African Americans (CDC, 2007a), the epidemic continue s to be a signif icant problem in the black community. It has become clear that a complex set of social, cultural, economic and structural factors interplay to affect the dynamics of risk and individual level factors cannot fully explain sexual be haviors (Parker, 2001). The co mbined effect of social factors such as poverty, substance abuse, oppression, racism and oppression increases vulnerability to HIV inf ection (Farmer et al., 1996; Parker, 2001; Romero-Daza, Weeks, & Singer, 1998). Recognizing these influences is important in shaping the research agenda to better address these social and cultural factors that increase risk behaviors and susceptibility to HIV infection. Additionally, the HIV/AIDS literature has largely failed to address the risk behaviors of heterosexual black men. While many studies have focused on the risk behaviors and HIV interven tions among women and gay identified men, much less attention has been devoted to heterosexua l men. Ironically, in black communities, men are the main source of HIV transmission, yet little research has focused on their risk behaviors (Exner, Gardos, Seal, & Ehrhar dt, 1999; Miller, Serner & Wagner, 2005; OSullivan, Hoffman, Harrison & Dolezal 2006). It is therefore impera tive that research not only explore social and cultural determin ants of sexual behavi or but also that heterosexual men are included as the focal pa rticipants of future research studies.
13 U.S. Black Immigrant Population As immigrants from Africa, the Caribb ean, Europe, and Latin America continue to migrate to the United States, the U.S. population has undergone a racial and ethnic transformation (Kent, 2007). In 2000, 36.2 million or 12.9% of the U.S. population reported that they were black (U.S. Cens us, 2000).The number of foreign-born blacks more than tripled between 1980 and 2005 (Ken t, 2007). Approximately 10% of the black population is foreign-born. In 2000, 84% of the foreign-born blacks were from the Caribbean (60%) or Africa (24%) (U.S. Census Bureau, 2000). Black Caribbean immigrants primarily emerge from three count ries: Jamaica, Haiti, and Trinidad. Guyana also contributes significantly to the U.S. black foreign-born population (see Appendix B, Table 1). Since the founding of the United States, African Americans have comprised a significant proportion of the population. In 1790, they accounted for one-fifth of the 3.9 million Americans counted in the census. Du ring this time, African Americans were involuntarily brought to the Unite d States, a reality of the Af rican slave trade. After the slave trade ended, black immigration to the Un ited States was restricted while there was an increase in whites migrating from Europe to the United States. By the 1900s, blacks who migrated to the U.S. emerged primarily from the Caribbean and settled mostly in New York. Since the 1970s, there has been resu rgence in the rates of black migration to the U.S. As noted, many of these immigrants hail from Africa, the Caribbean and Latin America. In recent decades, immigrants from th ese areas have settled in major cities such as New York, Miami, and Wa shington, DC. (Kent, 2007).
14 Florida has an increasingly ethnically di verse black population with about 16% of the black population being foreign-born. In Hillsborough County, the majority of foreignborn black individuals are from Jamaica, Haiti and Trinidad & Tobago (U.S. Census Bureau, 2000). (see Appendix B, Table 2). In the past several years, the Haitian population in Hillsborough County has more than doubled. Between 1994 and 2005, the Haitian population has increased from 8,000 to approximately 20,000 (Lush, 2002). The influx of black immigrants has implicat ions for the HIV/AIDS disparities that persist in the United States. The impact of heterogeneity and divers ity within the U.S. black population is largely unaccounted fo r in HIV/AIDS research and national imperatives to reduce HIV/AIDS health dispar ities. To reduce these disparities, research must focus on the subgroup differences within the black population that may account for differential risk taking behaviors. Burden of HIV/AIDS among Black Men in the U.S. Black men in the United States are heav ily affected by HIV/AIDS. In 2005, black men accounted for 41% of men living with HI V/AIDS in the United States and made up 65% of HIV/AIDS cases among blacks (CDC 2009b; CDC, 2007b). Among black men living with HIV/AIDS, 48% of cases are rela ted to homosexual contact, 23% are related to injection drug use and 22% are related to heterosexual contact (CDC, 2007a). During 2001-2005, black males accounted for more new HIV/AIDS diagnoses than males from any other race/ethnicity in the Southern and Northeastern regions of the United States (CDC, 2007c). In 2005, the rate of AIDS diagnos es for black men was 8 times the rate for white men (CDC 2009b).
15 Burden of HIV/AIDS among Black Women in the U.S. According to the CDC, the HIV epidemic presents a serious health threat to women in the United States, particularly women of color. Today, women account for over 25% of all new HIV diagnoses. In 2004, HIV infection was the leading cause of death for black women aged 25-34 years, th e third leading cause of death for black women aged 35-44 years and the fourth leadi ng cause of death for black women aged 4554 years. In 2005, the rate of AIDS dia gnosis for African American women was approximately 23 times the rate for white women and 4 times the rate for Hispanic women (2008b). Between 2001 and 2005, among females, blacks accounted for the majority of HIV/AIDS diagnoses in the Sout hern, Northeastern and Midwestern regions of the United States (CDC, 2007c). The pr imary exposure category for HIV/AIDS among black women is heterosexual contact follo wed by injection drug use (CDC, 2008b). The data show the devastatin g impact of HIV/AIDS am ong black women who are at increased risk for infection. The dramatic and sustained increase in the rates of infection in black women is alarming and should be cause for concern among the black community, the public health commun ity, and the nation as a whole. Burden of HIV/AIDS among Blacks in Florida In Florida, the effect of the AIDS epid emic has been no less devastating within the black community. Similar to the national rates, blacks comprise 15% of Floridas adult population but account for 54% of AIDS cases and 45% of HIV cases reported in 2007 (see Appendix A, Figure 2). Among black males, the AIDS case rate for 2007 was 6 times higher than among white males. Among black females in 2007, the AIDS case rate was 20 times higher than among white females (Florida Department of Health, 2007a).
16 According to the Florida Department of Health s Silence is Death Report, more blacks are living with HIV/AIDS or have died from the disease in Florida than any other racial or ethnic group (Florida De partment of Health, 2006a). In fact, 1 in 209 white men compared to 1 in 44 black men are living with HIV/AIDS in Florida (Florida Department of Health, 2010). Through 2006, 1 in 68 black women were livi ng with HIV/AIDS compared to 1 in 1281 white women and 472 Hispanic women. Further, in Florida, HIV is the leading cause of death for black men and women ages 25-44 years (Florida Department of Health, 2008). These data show the severe HIV/AIDS disparities that exist in the black community in Florida. HIV/AIDS infections in the black community have reached critical proportions, as the diseas e continues to affect people of color. Burden of HIV/AIDS among Blacks in Hillsborough County, Florida Hillsborough County ranks among the top 5 co unties in Florida for persons living with HIV/AIDS and is one of the Emergi ng Metropolitan Areas for HIV/AIDS in the State (Florida Department of Health, 2006a ). In Hillsborough County, 48% of the adult HIV cases and 69% of the pediatric cases are among blacks (Hillsborough County Health Department, 2006) (see Appendix A, Table 1). Th e Florida Department of Health (2006a) reports that 1 in 85 blacks are living w ith HIV/AIDS in Hillsborough County compared to 1 in 375 whites and 1 in 309 Hispanics. Among men in Hillsborough County, 1 in 55 blacks are living with HIV/AIDS versus 1 in 157 whites and 1 in 177 Hispanics (Florida Department of Health, 2010). Among women in Hillsborough County, 1 in 92 women are living with HIV/AIDs compared to 1 in 1007 whites and 1 in 403 Hispanics. These rates closely mirrors the state and national rates.
17 Although the CDC has reported decreases in the infection rates among black women on the national level, the impact of this devastating disease in the black community at all levels of society is undeniab ly critical. As a result, the CDC (2007a) has issued a report called A Heightened National Response to the HIV/AIDS Crisis among African American s with the realization that the burden of HIV/AIDS in the black community continues to be monumental In addition, as part of the CDCs Act Against AIDS Campaign the CDC has launched a $10 million dolla r, five year partnership with key African American organizations to devel op and implement strategi es to continue the fight against HIV and AIDS in the black community. These initiatives along with a united community response will be necessary to win the fight against HIV especially in communities of color. Burden of HIV/AIDS among Immigrants in Florida As Floridas population conti nues to grow and diversify, it becomes even more critical to collect and analyze data for im migrant populations as we ll as tailor specific interventions that are culturally relevant and appropriate. In recen t years, the Florida Department of Health has implemented HI V/AIDS case reporting for Caribbean-born immigrants. Florida surveill ance data from 2008 show that a total of 24,069 HIV/AIDS cases among Caribbean-born individuals were reported through 2008 (see Appendix A, Table 2), 46% of which were reported among Haitian-born immigrants. Surveillance data also show that Caribbean-born blacks comprise the majority of HIV/AIDS cases reported among Caribbean-born individuals. Th rough December 2008, among Caribbean-born men with HIV/AIDS, 53% were black and 45% were Hispanic. Among Caribbean-born
18 women with HIV/AIDS, 77% were black, 21% were Hispanic, and 1% were white (Florida Department of Health, 2008b). Burden of HIV/AIDS among Haitians in Florida The Florida Department of Health also reports HIV infection rates for the subpopulation of Haitians who make up 1.05% of Floridas population. Of the black adults living with HIV/AIDS in the state of Florida through 2008 (N=42,973), Haitians account for 15% (N=6,647). Males comprised approximately 56% of the adult AI DS cases in this Haitian sub-population (Florida De partment of Health, 2008c). Rationale for Focus on Haitian-born Blacks Epidemiological data also show that th ere are also high infection rates in the Haitian population in Florida. Even though th ey comprise 1.1% of Floridas population, they account for approximately 7.3% of HIV cas es in the state (Florida Department of Health, 2008c). In addition, the influx of Af ro-Caribbean individua ls into Florida and Hillsborough County warrants an investigation of the cultural and so cial implications for HIV transmission and prevention. Most notab ly, the Haitian population in Hillsborough County has more than doubled in the past several years (Lush, 2002) Finally, there are distinct cultural differences between the Af rican American and Haitian cultures that may manifest in significantly di fferent beliefs and practices around sexual behavior. For example, unlike African American culture, Ha itian culture incorporates the concept of voudou a form of magic that often dictates be liefs around illness and health behavior. Risk Factors for HIV Transmission in the Black Population The widespread transmission of HIV/AI DS within the black population can be attributed to a complex set of intrapersona l, socio-cultural, and behavioral factors.
19 Embedded within these fact ors are issues of racism, discrimination, poverty, unemployment, denial, stigma, homophobia, limited access to healthcare, delayed prevention messages, HIV/AIDS conspiracy beliefs, incarceration, unstable housing, injection drug use, lack of awareness of HIV serostatus, high rates of sexually transmitted diseases, and risky sexual behavior am ong HIV-positive individuals (CDC 2007a; CDC 2008a; Florida Department of Health, 2006; National Minority AIDS Council, 2006; Plowden, Fletcher and Miller, 2005). Intrapersonal Factors Since the beginning of the HIV epidemic, mu ch of the social science literature and theoretical frameworks have focused on the intrapersonal behavioral correlates of HIV infection. Largely, the focus of this body of knowledge has been on the extent to which the individuals knowledge and perceptions influence ri sk behaviors (Parker, 2001; Rhodes, 1997). Social psychological theories ha ve been postulated to conceptualize the internal factors that explai n HIV-risk behaviors. Among these are the theories of reasoned action social cognitive theory information-motivation-behavioral skills theory the health belief model, stages of change and the AIDS risk reduction model Based on these psychological models, key factors posited to be associated with HIV risk include, knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, perceptions, self-efficacy, subjective norms, behavioral skills, and motivation (Bandura, 1994; Catania, Kegeles & Coates, 199 0; Fisher & Fisher, 2002; Montao & Kasprzk, 2002;. Prochaska, Redding & Evers, 2002; Rosenstock, 1974a). The health belief model conceptualizes si x key dimensions of health behavior change: perceived susceptibility, perceived s everity, perceived benefits, perceived
20 barriers, cues to action, and self-efficacy (Basen-Enquist, 1992; Janz, Champion & Strecher, 2002). These individual level concep ts are hypothesized to be associated with sexual behaviors and intentions. Even though the health belief model incorporates environmental influences, the cognitive dimens ions are the central te nets of the theory. Likewise, Bandura (1977) posits that cogni tive processes mediate change and selfefficacy is central to effecting behavior change. Self-efficacy is defined as the conviction that one can successfully execute the behavior required to produce outcomes (Bandura, 1977 p. 193). Bandura (1994) argues that self-regula tive skills and personal volition over sexual behavior and drug activities are re quired to translate health knowledge and information into effective self-protection against HIV infection. Therefore, with regard to HIV-risk behaviors; these critical cognitive pr ocesses must occur for an individual to take the recommended action to reduce HIV risk. The AIDS risk reduction model is comp rised of three stages that emphasize efficacy, emotional influences and interpersona l activities. Central to this model, are individual level influences on sexual risk be havior such as, knowle dge of risky sexual activities, belief in personal susceptibility to HIV, and be lief that AIDS is undesirable (Catania et al., 1990). Likewise, the inform ation-motivation-behavioral skills model (IMB) conceptualizes the psyc hological determinants of HI V preventive behavior. The fundamental assumptions of the IMB are th at HIV prevention information, motivation and behavioral skills are the basic determinan ts of HIV preventive behavior. Therefore, if individuals are adequately informed, are fully motivated, and possess the necessary skills, they are likely to practice HIV preventive be haviors (Fisher & Fish er, 1992; Fisher & Fisher, 2002).
21 These theoretical frameworks have pr ovided the foundation for many studies on HIV-risk behaviors in different populati ons. The hypothesized constructs have for decades dictated the way researchers con ceptualize HIV-risk behaviors but, used independently, provide limited perspectives on the factors that influe nce risk behaviors. According to Wight (1999), these models have been widely criticized for their focus on individual attitudes and beliefs while ignori ng social, cultural, and other factors that influence behavior. While intrapersonal fact ors are important to understanding HIV-risk, social, cultural and contextual factors must al so be explored to derive a holistic view of the epidemic. Through a holistic lens, beneficial interventions can be developed to more adequately address the multiple factors that influence HIV risk behaviors and HIV transmission. Social Factors. Among the most pernicious of the social barriers [to HIV prevention] are poverty, racism, gender inequality, AIDS-related stigma, and societys reluctance to openly address sexuality. (Institute of Medicine, 2001) The social factors that influence HI V vulnerability and transmission are interconnected and play a key role in determin ing the spread of the HIV epidemic. Social factors include economic deprivation and pove rty, gender inequalit y, discrimination and racism, social attitudes, and AIDS-related stigma (Adimora et al., 2001; Farmer, 1996; Parker, 2001). These factors contribute to be haviors that lead to the transmission of sexually transmitted diseases and HIV and continue to impede HIV prevention efforts. Economic Deprivation. Poverty and economic deprivation have he lped to fuel the HIV epidemic among poor populations. According to Farmer (1996), in the United States, urban poverty has
22 provided the perfect machinery for the spread of HIV. Blacks are concentrated in these poor urban areas which present a socially disadvantaged environment characterized by substance abuse, joblessness, welfare dependency, vigorous drug trade, high rates of incarceration, opportunities for unprotected sex, single parenthood, and lack of access to preventive care (Farmer, 1996; Massey, 2004; National Alliance of State and Territorial AIDS Directors [NASTAD], 2005). These so cial and environmental characteristics translate into high disease rates among blacks. For example, injection drug use is the second leading cause of HIV infection fo r African American men and women (CDC, 2007a; Center for AIDS Prevention Studies (CAPS), 2001; National Minority AIDS Council (NMAC), 2006). A complex nexus of social factors influe nce high-risk sexual behavior. Sumartojo (2000) points out that cost may be a barrier to the acquisition and use of condoms. Peterson et al. (as cited in Mays, Cochra n & Zamudio, 2004), found in their study of 250 African American men who have sex with men (MSM) that poor men were more likely to engage in high risk beha viors such as exchanging sex for money. Similarly, Wheeler (2006) discovered in his study of non-gay iden tified black men that economics and drugs were the root factors for engagement in hi gh risk sexual behaviors. Unemployed men in his study population exchanged sex for money, drugs and other resources. Plowden and colleagues (2005) found in their study of urban African Americans that condom distribution and needle exchange programs we re less effective because individuals were selling needles and condoms for money to obtain drugs. Low socioeconomic status may also affect the masculine sense of self. In the United States, a man who has weak economic capacity may compensate for his low status by controlling or conquering
23 females (Whitehead, 1997). This behavior in turn puts them a nd their partners at greater risk for HIV transmission. Economic deprivation and the drug culture have resulted in high rates of incarceration among black men. By June 30, 2006, an estimated 4.8% of black men were in prison or jail, compared to 1.9% of Hisp anic men and 0.7% of white men. More than 11% of black males ages 25 to 34 were incarc erated (U.S. Department of Justice, 2007). The CDC (2007a) reports that the incarceration of African American men presents significant risk for HIV transmission. The incarce ration epidemic is so extensive that it has become a reality of the dating and mate selection patterns in black communities. Whitehead (1997) found that black women in urban communities primarily consider incarceration history when sele cting sexual partners. Women are cognizant of the fact that incarceration is often linke d to high risk behaviors such as drugs and anal sex which may lead to HIV infection. Therefore, when considering a mate, black women may take into account a mans prison history. Within the prison population, si tuational sex is a common occurrence. Prison inmates often ex change sex for tangible goods and other services. In other cases, inmates are raped and sodomized further increasing the risk of HIV transmission. Injecting drugs and tattooing are also risk factors for HIV transmission within the prison environment. According to the U.S. Department of Justice (2004), AIDS is three times more prevalent in pris on populations than in the general population. In addition, the confinement of black men has created a sex ratio imbalance within the black population. A low male-to-fema le sex ratio has been hypothesized to be associated with multiple sex partners, concurrent sexual relationships, and other high risk behaviors among men. The sex ratio imbalance presents a context in which black men
24 may devalue women, seek multiple sex partners, demonstrate less tolerance for disagreements in relationships, and refuse to negotiate condom use with black women (Ferguson, Quinn & Sandelowski, 2006; Lane et al., 2004; Logan, Cole & Leukefeld, 2002; Thomas & Thomas, 1999). In their st udy of the social context of sexual relationships among rural Afri can Americans, Adimora et al. (2001) found that the relative scarcity of black men and the socioeconomic dependence of black women worked synergistically to influence partne r selection and women s sexual availability. Women put up with the men they have because there arent that many (p. 73). Clearly, the sex ratio imbalance creates a power disp arity that adversely affects mens sexual behavior making women more vulnerabl e to contracting HIV. As Wingood & DiClemente (2000) posit, the more power men have over women in heterosexual relationships, the more likely women will experience negative health outcomes. Among black women, economic dependence and the sugar daddy concept is one factor that contribute s to transmission of the virus to women. Women who are economically dependent on their male sexual pa rtners have less sexual power and control and are reluctant to negotiate condom use with their partners for fear of dismissal and abandonment (Turmen, 2003). Relationship power plays an important role in safe sex decision-making and HIV risk. Women with low levels of economic power in a relationship are less likely to report consis tent condom use (Pulerwitz, Amaro, De Jong, Gortmaker & Rudd, 2002). Further, women wh o live in poverty may have multiple concurrent sexual relationships for econo mic reasons. Bedimo, Bennett, Kissinger and Clark (1998) found that it was not uncommon fo r some African American women in their study to have sidekicks (p. 52), men who gave them clothes or money in exchange for
25 sex. Gadon, Chierici & Rios (2001) found th at even though Haitian women may suspect their partners of infidelity, they accepted unprotected sex in order to keep a mans financial support. Haitian women also refe rred to chache lavi or prostitution for economic survival. Therefore, being econom ically disadvantaged defines the sexual relationship as being male dominated and de pendent and limits a womans ability to negotiate safe sexual practices. In addition, women may engage in risky behaviors for economic gain. Clearly, women s HIV risk must be framed in the context of their relationships with male partners. Women who live in poverty ar e less likely to practice sa fe sex because they are more concerned with basic survival rather th an HIV-protective beha viors (Logan et al., 2002). Poor women, especially poor women of color, are at gr eater risk for poor health outcomes because of their low socioeconomic status. These women have less than adequate health care and are at greater risk for multiple diseases such as cancer, obesity, respiratory problems, diabetes, cardiova scular disease, and AIDS (Reid, 2000). According to Amaro, Raj and Reed (2001), wo mens sexual health is affected by their low social status. They argue that relegation to the lower segments of society has led to womens lack of sexual autonomy and lim ited access to health care and medical treatment. Women with lower income are also more likely to have higher levels of stress and riskier sexual partners indicating that so cial class is an important predictor of individual risk (Ickovics et al., 2002). Clearly, these social factors; poverty, income disparity, and lack of social capital all affect behaviors that facil itate HIV transmission.
26 Gender Disparities. Gender disparities are manifested by th e feminization of HIV/AIDS. Gender inequalities impact every aspect of health and illness. Women are more vulnerable to HIV infection than men not only because of their biological characteristics but also because of their relative inabi lity to protect themselves from HIV infection. The lack of widespread accessibility to female controlled barrier mechanisms (such as female condoms) and the socially constructed roles of male-dominated heterosexual relationships make women even more sus ceptible to infection (Vijayakumar, Mabude, Smit, Beksinska, & Lurie, 2006; Wel bourn, 2006; Mantell et al., 2006). African American women may find it more difficult to refuse sex and negotiate condom use than White women because of their relational or ientation, power differentials, and other factors such as the male-female ratio imba lance (Jarama, Belgrave, Bradford, Young & Honnold, 2007). The HIV/AIDS epidemic in women is an illustration of how women are stigmatized in terms of dis ease transmission. Women are largely viewed as transmitters of disease who subject their male partners and children to infection and are often seen as dirty, diseased and undeserving (Lawless, Kippax and Crawford, 1996, p. 1371). This idea is ironic since women are two to four times more likely to acquire HIV/AIDS infection from men based on the biological configuration of women and the high HIV/AIDS viral load detected in semen (Turmen, 2003). Nevert heless, these facts tend to be ignored in favor of the id ea that men are ultimately the victims (Lawless et al., 1996).
27 Discrimination and Racism. Racism and discrimination continue to a ffect the health outcomes of minority populations in the United States. Health inequities are the resu lt of structural racism that continues to pervade the health care system. Racial and ethnic dispar ities affect access to health care, education, and social services (B useh et al., 2006; Rei d, 2000). A history of racism, oppression and lack of trust in government al agencies present barriers to effective HIV prevention strategies among blacks (CDC 2007c). Historically, racism has affected the masculine ideologies of black men resul ting in a skewed concept of masculinity and sense of self. Denied access to economic pow er and the idealized masculinity of the dominant group through slavery and later in stitutionalized discri mination, black men have constructed alternate concepts of ma sculinity. Sexual promiscuity, aggressiveness, and thrill-seeking, have been hypothesized as ch aracteristics of the masculine ideologies of black men (Bowleg, 2004). The social c onstruction of black masculinity and the creation of a black machismo identity are dire ct responses to racism and discrimination that have translated into HIV-risk behavi ors such as the nondis closure of homosexual activity and multiple sex partners (Bowleg, 2004; Miller et al., 2005) Clearly, HIV risk behaviors must be analyzed through the lens of racism and discrimination, factors that continue to influence health behaviors. HIV/AIDS-Related Stigma. HIV-related stigma is also an element of marginalization that influences the HIV/AIDS morbidity and mortality among bl acks. According to Aggleton & Parker (2002), HIV stigmatization is a social process of devaluation that reinforces negative thoughts about persons living with HIV and AI DS and presents one of the greatest
28 barriers to dealing with the epidemic. HIV-re lated stigma has negative consequences on HIV prevention and care within communities riddled with stigma and discrimination. Stigmatization can create barriers to HIV te sting, adoption of pr eventive behaviors, reception of HIV prevention messages, condom us e, and disclosure of sexual orientation and HIV status to sex partners (Brooks, Etzel Hinojos, Henry & Perez, 2005). Within the black community HIV/AIDS is highly stigmatiz ed. These attitudes lead to concealment of homosexual behavior, lack of HIV testing, failure to seek treatm ent, and the generation of myths about HIV transmission. Many of these issues may in fact result from the prevalence of HIV stigma in the black community and the negative attitudes that accompany stigmatization and discrimination. Often, marginalized groups ar e the victims of stig matization and though their risk behaviors may influence HIV tran smission, stigmatization nourishes persistent negative attitudes towards th ese individuals and creates challenges to addressing the epidemic within these groups as well as the larger community. Stigmatization of marginalized groups also propagates the per ception that individuals who do not identify with these groups are not at risk of contracting the disease. These factor s create a vicious cycle of stigma and discrimination that make prevention efforts even more challenging.
29 Figure 1. The Cycle of HIV/AIDS Stigma and Discrimination Source: Parker, Aggleton, A ttawell, Pulerwitz & Brown, 2002.
30 Immigration Status Immigrants in the United States face significant barriers to health education, access to care, and treatment. In the United States, immigrants comprise a vulnerable population at risk for negative health outco mes. Undocumented immigrants face even more challenges because of their illegal residential status. Among immigrants, major barriers to HIV education, care and treatment in clude inability to pay for services, stigma by the health care system, language and lo w-literacy, immigran ts health seeking attitudes, cultural beliefs, fatalistic views about HIV, fear of deportation, lack of knowledge of the health care system, employme nt issues, and fear of isolation (Potocky, Dodge & Greene, 2007; Othieno, 2007). Undocum ented immigrants are particularly less likely to access services because they fear be ing reported to the authorities and ultimately being deported. In a study conducted among Haitians in Palm Beach County, undocumented immigrants reported that they could not seek health care for fear of deportation. Their fear of deporta tion was greater than their fe ar of dying (Potocky et al., 2007). In addition, immigrants are less likely to be knowledgeable of available health care resources and are therefore less likely to seek education and care. These barriers contribute to lack of HIV test ing, education, and treatment an d continued transmission of the virus within immigrant populations. Social factors act synergistically to influe nce HIV/AIDS attitudes, beliefs and risk behaviors within the black population. While individual level factors are important determinants of health behavior, HIV risk beha viors must be viewed within the context of the social environment. Without this lens we run the risk of failing to recognize
31 important contextual and social factors that may be critical in th e conceptualization and development of effective strategies for cu rbing the epidemic among minority populations. Cultural Factors Another factor that influences health beha vior is culture. Cultur e is defined as a shared system of knowledge and beliefs by which people order their perceptions and experiences and make decisions, a nd in terms of which they act. It is a shared system of ideas, a conceptual code that people use to interpret themselves and the world and to formulate behavior (Vivelo, 1978). Matthews (2004) defines cu lture as a set of rules, standards, or beliefs shared by the member s of a group that when acted upon by those members, produces behaviors that fall with in a range considered acceptable and proper by those members. Within the context of HIV transmission, culture is defined as the way of life among a social group, inclusive of the norms, beliefs, and traditions within that group that put group members at risk fo r HIV (Wilson & Miller, 2003). Among blacks and subgroups of the black popul ation, there are cultu rally determined factors that may be influential in HIV risk and prevention. Among African Americans, the cultural cont ext of HIV risk is characterized by homophobia, culturally defined masculine and fe minine ideologies, notions of the self, gender norms, culturally determined e xpressions of manhood and womanhood, HIV conspiracy beliefs, distrust of the medical sy stem, and religious beliefs. In the African American community, a culture of silence ex ists concerning HIV/AI DS. Perceptions that HIV is a gay disease lead to moral judg ments against those w ho are infected. This attitude in turn leads to homophobia which re sults in the rejection and isolation of gay and bisexual men by family, friend s and social networks (Buseh et al., 2006; Morin et al.,
32 2003). Fearful of rejection and physical harm, black men may not disc lose their bisexual behaviors thus putting women at risk for infection. From a cultural perspective, African Amer icans place significant value on family, social networks and religious standing (Har awa et al., 2006) The threat of losing these support systems may prevent African Amer ican men from disclosing their sexual identity. The result is men who have sex with men but identify as heterosexual, a phenomenon more commonly known as dow n low in the African American community. Heterosexism and the notion that gay or bisexual men are not real men, discourage black men from identifying as gay or bisexual. These ideologies of masculinity define normative masculine be havior within the black community and deviation from these culturally determin ed ideologies are viewed as weak, embarrassing, sinful and unnatural (B rooks et al., 2005 p. 738). Operario, Smith & Kegeles (2008) found that beliefs of Afri can American masculinity reinforce the portrayal of a tough masculine image and the nondisclosure of same-sex behavior. In addition, since same-sex behavior was pe rceived to be unplanned and spontaneous, condom use was less likely during same-sex in tercourse. Therefore, gender ideologies are central to HIV risk in the black community. The emphasis on toughness and heterosexuality as the ideal portrayal of masculinity within the black community may reinforce secrecy about same-sex relati onships, and unprotected, spontaneous sexual encounters which lead to great er risk for HIV and other STI transmission among male and female partners. The term Down Low denotes secrecy a nd has been used in African American vernacular since the early 1990s. First introduced in African American music, the term
33 has evolved to refer to black men who public ly present as heterosexual but privately engage in sexual relationships with other me n. The connotation of this behavior is that these men spread HIV to their unsuspecti ng female partners (Ford, Whetten, Hall, Kaufman & Thrasher, 2007; Millett, Male branche, Mason & Spikes, 2005). Closely related to the down low phenomenon is the homothug identity which is characterized by: 1) heavy involvement in the hip hop culture; 2) strong masculine identity; 3) homophobia and disapproval of femininity in me n 4) gangster image 5) secret sex with men (Ford et al., 2007; Mays et al., 2004). Often, African American men engage in compensatory sex with women in order to prove to their community that they are not gay (Buseh et al., 2006 p. 4). These behaviors place female partners at greater risk for infection. Studies have found that heterosexually identified HIV-in fected African American men who had sex with men had a high frequency of unprotected anal sex with their female partners and were at great risk of transmitting HIV to opposite sex partners (Wohl et al., 2002; Wolitski, Jones, Wasserman & Smith, 2006). A CDC study found that while 34% of black men reported having sex with me n and women, only 6% of black women acknowledged having a bisexual partner (CDC 2008d). This finding highlights the fact that many black women are either in denial or unaware of th eir partners high-risk sexual behaviors. In addition, failure to disclose sexual orientati on and internalized stigma may lead to lack of participation in HIV prev ention programs. Black men who have sex with men (MSM) often do not identify with pr evention messages designed for gay men, creating additional barriers to HIV preventi on within this marginalized population.
34 Among African Americans, condom use may ha ve socio-cultural implications that prevent consistent use. Studies have show n that male initiati on of condom use may conjure suspicions of infideli ty among their female partne rs (Whitehead, 1997; Brooks et al., 2005). In addition, women may be reluctant to insist on condom use because they fear rejection by male partners. Negotiation of condom use is also difficult because women who suggest condom use are suspected of infi delity (Worth, 1989; Heise & Elias, 1995). This situation puts women at risk for ab andonment and even violence. Bowleg, Lucas and Tschann (2004) found in their study of condom use among African American women that men controlled the initiation and refusa l of condom use regardless of whether women wanted to use condoms. As Wingood and Di Clemente (2000) argue, women who have low self-efficacy for using condoms and ne gotiating condom use are more likely to engage in high risk sexual behaviors. The social connotations of condom use have also been found to deter protective sexual behavi or. Whitehead (1997) found that condoms are traditionally used with women who are dirty or diseased. Therefore, women may not negotiate its use with male part ners for fear of being viewed as promiscuous or infected. Having multiple sex partners is also a signi ficant risk factor for HIV transmission. For black men, sexual contact remains the main HIV risk factor. According to the CDC, male-to-male sexual contact was the primary risk factor for 48% of black men with HIV/AIDS at the end of 2005 wh ile high-risk heterosexual co ntact was the primary risk factor for 22% of black men (CDC, 2008c). Bl ack women are most likely to be infected by heterosexual contact. Many wo men are unaware that their se x partners are engaging in unprotected sex with multiple part ners, thus putting them at greater risk for HIV. Sadly, black and Hispanic women account for 81% of women living with HIV/AIDS who
35 acquired the disease by heterosexual cont act (CDC, 2008d). In Florida, through 2006, 85% of back women living with HIV/AIDS ac quired the disease via heterosexual contact (Florida Department of Health, 2008). In their study of sexual relationships among rural African Americans, Adimora et al (2001) found that black men having multiple sex partners was a common occurrence. Study partic ipants reported that the male-female sex ratio imbalance cultivates this high-risk behavior. In additi on, concurrent sexual partnerships were particular ly prevalent among unmarried individuals. Sexual behaviors such as multiple sex partners present a significant risk for HIV transmission. Unfortunately, these risky behaviors are preval ent within the black community, leading to higher rates of HIV transmission. Family values and cultural norms that determine manhood and womanhood may also influence HIV risk. Among African American s, the socially constructed meanings of pregnancy may have implications for HI V prevention. Worth (1989) found that among minority women in New York City, fertility de fined their social roles and self-esteem. Therefore, the use of condoms is seen as a barrier to women fulfilling their role of motherhood. Since children are an affirma tion of adulthood, African Americans may be reluctant to use condoms (Bowser, 1992). Bedimo et al. (1998) also found that African American women in their study population valued pregnancy because it entitled them to material possessions they would not otherwis e receive. Therefore, the use of condoms prevents pregnancy which in turn prev ents social and economic privilege. HIV/AIDS conspiracy beliefs in the African American community may create a barrier to HIV prevention efforts. Klonoff a nd Landrine (1999) found that 27% of blacks in their study population believed that HI V is engineered by the government to
36 exterminate the black population. Likewise Bogart and Thorburn (2005) and Gadon & Rios (2001) found that a signifi cant proportion of the African Americans in their studies did not trust the government and believed that HIV/AIDS was engineer ed to wipe out the black population. Black men were especially su spicious of the governments role in the spread of the HIV epidemic, believing that HIV is a man-made virus and the cure for AIDS is being withheld from the poor. Endorse ment of conspiracy beliefs was also found to be strongly related to nega tive attitudes to condom use. Clearly, HIV/AIDS conspiracy beliefs persist in the black community and may negatively impact HIV prevention messages. Historical discrimination and ma nipulation by the U.S. medical system, as exemplified by the Tuskegee Syphilis Study (CDC, 2009c) in which black men who had syphilis did not receive the proper treatmen t for their illness, may contribute to HIV conspiracy beliefs in the black community. Thes e beliefs must be more fully investigated within the context of historic and current di scrimination within the health care system. Within the Haitian population living in the U.S., cultural factors such as relationship power imbalances, traditional ge nder roles, patriarchal belief systems, and cultural concepts of health and illness increase vulnerab ility to HIV infection. Folk beliefs are often used to describe the orig ins and transmission of HIV. Gadon & Rios (2001) found that male Haitian migrants a ttributed HIV infection to religious disobedience and spirits of the dead. HIV is seen as punishment to the desobeyian (p. 797). Likewise, Martin, Rissmiller & Beal ( 1995) found that Haitians incorporate traditional beliefs about health and illness in to their beliefs about HIV disease. HIV is therefore seen as a sickness sent from God to people who engage in bad behavior. HIV is also perceived as a product of Voudou (Haitian for Voodoo), a form of magic or sorcery
37 practiced by some Haitians. In the context of voudou, HIV is seen as a means of sending death or sickness for revenge or vengeance. Kout mo or mo SIDA (supernatural AIDS in Creole) is viewed as the unfortunate, supernat ural fate of the victim (Adrien, Cayemittes & Bergevin, 1993). In addition, some Haitian beli efs such as having sex with a virgin will cure HIV and lining a womans vaginal canal with barks and twigs will prevent HIV from penetrating are pervasive in the Haitian community (Potocky, Dodge & Greene, 2007). In addition to the health beliefs that may influence acceptance and practice of Western biomedical HIV prevention strategies, the socio-cultural milieu within the Haitian community also affects HIV-risk behavi ors. Similar to African American ideals, having children is important to Haitian me n and women. Therefore, conception is often more important than condom use and HIV tr ansmission. In addition, patriarchal beliefs facilitate tolerance of promiscuous male behavior within the Haitian population. As a result, men often have multiple sex partne rs, premarital sex, and practice unofficial polygamy, behaviors that are widely tole rated (Magee, Small, Frederic, Joseph & Kershaw, 2006). Stigma of HIV/AIDS in the U.S. Haitian community contributes to secrecy and failure to disclose HIV status to sex partners Historically, Haitians have been stigmatized as a high-risk group for HIV transmission. In the early years of th e epidemic, Haitians were included in the 4-H club of high ri sk populations: homosexuals, Haitians, heroin users and hemophiliacs. In addition to being perceived as unwanted immigrants, black peasantry, boat people, voodoo worshippers, crimin al aliens, Haitians were also seen as the member of the 4-H club (Nachman & Dreyfuss, 1986). These labels led to
38 discrimination and isolation of the populat ion. AIDS-related stigma and discrimination create significant barriers to HIV educa tion, prevention, testing and treatment. Coreil, Lauzardo & Heurtelou (2004) posit that stigma tization and racism towards Haitians in South Florida create socially based burdens that negatively affect access to health care services. Haitians therefore avoid seeking treatme nt and fail to disclose status for fear of rejection and isolation by the community. The legacy of stigma, discrimination, humiliation, and isolation towards the Haitian population has impacted the self concept and esteem of the community. Santana & Da ncy (2000) found that as a result of AIDSrelated stigma, Haitians felt that they are rejected by the dominant society and by fellow Haitians. Stigmatization can have deleteri ous effects on families and communities. Within the Haitian community, the effects of fo rmer labeling still linger as Haitians often feel isolated and rejected by the larger society. This rejection has been internalized by Haitians leading to feelings of less self worth. Moreover, AIDS-related stigma may negatively affect HIV-risk behaviors specifica lly related to disclosure of status, accessing HIV prevention services, and condom use. Furt her research is needed to explore the effect of AIDS-related stigma and discrimina tion on sexual behaviors in this historically marginalized community. In sum, the intrapersonal and sociocultural dynamics within populations can greatly influence the sexual behaviors that pr evail. These factors can have a significant impact on HIV-risk behaviors, behavior chan ge, gender ideologies, negotiation of safer sex, cultural concepts of health and illn ess, and culturally determined beliefs and behaviors. Understanding the interpersonal a nd socio-cultural factors that affect sexual
39 behaviors is paramount to be tter understanding the determinan ts of risk and identifying effective strategies for HIV prevention among black populations. Behavioral Health: Substance Abuse and HIV Risk Substance Abuse. Behavioral health was first coined in the 1980s to describe the combination of the fields of mental health and substance abuse. It focuses on the study of behavioral health problems such as depression, eating diso rders, substance abuse, domestic violence, and anxiety disorders. This study will focus on substance abuse as a crucial behavioral health risk factor for HIV transmission. Si nce injection drug use is the second leading cause of HIV infection for both black men a nd women, this study will focus specifically on substance abuse as a behavior al health problem. There is a need to further explore the influence of substance use among sub-groups of black heterosexual men and the correlation with high risk behaviors. The uni que aspect of this exploration is the discovery of differences in substance a buse behaviors between the subgroups being studied. According to the CDC, chronic and ca sual substance users are more likely to participate in high-risk behaviors such as unprotected sex with multiple partners and sharing needles. In addition, HIV-infected s ubstance users are less likely to adhere to antiretroviral treatment (CDC, 2008c). Behavioral health issues are major risk factors for HIV. The threat of HIV among persons with substance abuse problems is signi ficant and the spread of HIV disease in the United States is fueled by the substance a buse epidemic (Parry, Blank & Pithey, 2007). HIV is transmitted directly by sharing injection-drug paraphernalia and indirectly by sexual contact with HIV-positive injection drug users (U.S. Department of Health and
40 Human Services, 2005). In addition, the use of illicit substances impairs judgment and affects sexual decision-maki ng and risk-taking. From an ep idemiological perspective, injection drug use has directly and indirectly accounted for more than one-third of the AIDS cases in the United States. Racial and ethnic minorities are disproportionately affected by drug related AIDS. In 2000, inje ction drug use accounted for 26% of all AIDS cases among African Americans and 31% of cases among Hispanics compared to 19% among whites (CDC, 2002). Non-injection drug use, such as cocaine, also contributes to the AIDS epidemic because it impairs judgment making users more likely to engage in risky sexual be haviors. In addition, users ma y exchange sex for drugs and money and in this contex t are less likely to practi ce safe sex (CDC, 2007a). The link between substance abuse and sexua l risk behaviors has been established. Several studies show the link between substan ce use and high-risk be haviors. Individuals who are high or drunk are less likely to e ngage in safe sexual activity increasing the likelihood of exposure to HIV (Cederbaum, Coleman, Goller and Jemmot, 2006). Another study conducted by Brooks and coll eagues (2008), found that heavy alcohol consumption was a strong correlate of sexual risk. Alcohol abuse is highly correlated with having multiple sex partners, unprotected sexual intercourse, and sex with high-risk individuals. In another study among substa nce-abusing African American men, Eissen, Meshack, Peters, Ogungbade & Osemene (2005) found that African American men were often having unprotected sex with women while under the influence of drugs and alcohol. In addition, African American crack using men are more likely to have multiple partners and exchange sex for drugs. The drug epidem ic has fueled the incarceration trends now seen in the black community. With the war against drugs, more black men have been
41 incarcerated for drug possession and/or usage. Th is reality has had a significant effect on the social organization of the black commun ity. With a significant number of black men behind bars, the sex-ratio imbalance and situ ational sex have prevailed within black communities increasing the risk for HIV transm ission. Moreover, the drug epidemic itself is a risk factor for disease transmission. Purpose of the Inquiry The purpose of this study is to conduct e xploratory research to generate formative data on factors that influence HIV-risk behaviors among black men who identify as heterosexual. This study further seeks to e xplore potential variability in HIV-risk behaviors among ethnic subgroups (U.S.-born and Haitian-born immigrants) of black heterosexual men. Few studies address the so cio-cultural and behavi oral factors that influence HIV-risk behaviors in the black heterosexual male population. Even fewer studies have addressed the influence of thes e factors on sexual behavior within ethnic subgroups of the black male population. The invi sibility of this population in the social science literature needs to be addressed (Bowleg, 2004). In addition, the rising proportion of U.S. blacks who are foreign-born is expected to affect the health profile of the black population in the U.S. (Read, Emerson & Tarlov, 2005; Read & Emerson, 2005). While there are different and similar socio-cultu ral experiences across population sub-groups, the differences need to be identified and specific interventions and prevention messages developed accordingly. There is a need to tailor HIV/AIDS educa tion and prevention efforts to address the complex cultural, social and contextual ecologies which shape beliefs and behaviors (Stevenson, Davis, Weber, Weiman, & Abdul-Kabir, 1995).
42 This study, therefore, furthers the body of knowledge as it allows for an in-depth exploration of the socio-cultu ral and behavioral factors th at influence the HIV-risk behaviors of subgroups (U.S.-born and Haitian-born) of black heterosexual men living in the U.S. The results of this formative study may be used to design quantitative instruments for future studies and broader application. Study results may also provide insight for HIV education and behavioral in terventions to reduce HIV/AIDS disparities within ethnically diverse black popula tions in Florida and nationwide. Theoretical Frameworks Informing the Inquiry This study draws on three conceptual fram eworks: The Socio-ecological Model of STD Risk and Protective Factors, the Health Belief Model (HBM) and the Theory of Gender and Power. The overarching theory for this study, the socio-ec ological model of STD risk and protective factors, emphasizes an interdependent, multidimensional and multilevel concept of individual behavior (Grzywacz & Fuqua, 2000). The Health Belief Model and the Theory of Gender and Power will be used to theorize intrapersonal and relational factors that affect behavior respectively. The Health Belief Model is appropriate for this study because it explor es important constructs that influence knowledge, attitudes and beliefs. The Theory of Gender and Power is suitable for this study because it addresses structural fact ors such as gender and power and places gendered relationships between men a nd women within a social context. Socio-ecological Model of ST D Risk and Protective Factors Adapted from Urie Bronfenbrenners eco logical model of human development, the socioecological model of STD risk and protective factors involves examining behavior within the context of the individua ls social and physical environment. Socio-
43 ecological factors that might in fluence behavior include cultur al, family, relational, peer and societal influences (DiCle mente et al., 2005). In the past few years, researchers have begun to utilize the socio-ecolo gical perspective to examine health behaviors. Realizing that cognitive approaches may not fully ex plain behavior, resear chers in the social sciences have begun to look at public heal th problems through an ecological lens. In his classic work, The Ecology of Human Development Bronfenbrenner (1979) explains the importance of interrelated eco logical levels for human development. The ecological environment is conceived as a set of nested structures, each existing inside the next. Further, a persons development is affect ed by events occurring in settings in which the person is not even present. Another critical tenet of social ecology is that within each culture, environmental settings tend to be sim ilar, however, between cultures they tend to be strikingly different. The ne sted structures hypothesized in the theory are described as the microsystem, mesosystem, exosystem and macrosystem. The microsystem is the immediate setting in which the individual exists This level is the innermost level of the nested structures which represents the contex t in which an individual is behaving at any given time. Bronfenbrenner (1979) defines the microsystem as a pattern of activities, roles, and interpersonal relations experienced by the developing pers on in a given setting with particular physical and material characte ristics (p. 22). The mesosystem is a set of microsystems and represents a higher le vel in the social environment. The mesosystem represents the interrelations among major settings in which a person exists. According to Brofenbrenner (1979), the mesosystem compri ses the interrelations among two or more settings in which the developing person actively participates (such as family, work, social life) (p. 25). The next level, the exosystem is composed of contex ts that do not directly
44 involve the developing person but influences the persons beha vior and realities in some way. Lastly, the macrosystem is the highest level of th e ecology of human development which involves culture, belief systems, large institutions and public policy (Bronfenbrenner, 1979; Grzyw acz & Fuqua, 2000; Lerner, 2005). DiClemente et al. (2005) de veloped the socio-ecologica l model of STD risk and protective factors, an adaptation of Bronfenbr enners ecological model that explains STD risk and protective factors for adolescents. Depicted in Figure 2 below, the model is comprised of five concentric spheres of influence. Figure 2. The Socio-ecological Model of STD risk and protective factors. Source: R.J. DiClemente, L.F.Salazar, R.A. Crosby, & S.L. Rosenthal, 2005.
45 The innermost circle, labeled I represen ts the individual and the psychological characteristics that are intrinsically driven. The next sphere, the family, refers to the familial influences on individual behavior. The relational realm refers to the influence that intimate partners may have on an i ndividuals decision making and resultant behavior. The community and societal s pheres represent the peer, community and societal influences on behavior. DiClementes conceptualization of the socio-ecological influences on individual behavior is synonymous with Bronfenbre nners concepts of the microsystem, mesosystem, exosystem and macrosystem. Figure 3 depicts the factors within each sphere that affect sexual behavior as postu lated by DiClemente juxtaposed with Bronfenbrenners ecological levels Synonymous with Bronfenbrenners microsystem the innermost sphere represents the intraper sonal level which includes the individual and related psychological and beha vioral processes. The next two ecological levels, the mesosystem represent the family and relational influences on health behavior. These influences include family structure, family support, and partner communication. Next the exosystem includes community and peer influences on STD risk and protective behaviors. These influences include access to condom di stribution sites, drug culture, community culture, peer norms, and so cial capital. Lastly, the macrosystem or the societal level includes characteristics of the larger societ y such as socio-economic status, media, and healthcare policies that affect behavior on a broader level.
46 Figure 3. Modified Socio-ecological Model of STD risk and protective factors applied to research study. Source: Lerner 2005; R.J. DiClemente, L.F. Salazar, R.A. Crosby, & S.L. Rosenthal, 2005.
47 While the socio-ecological model of STD ri sk and protective factors has not been widely used to assess HIV ri sk behaviors, it provides a novel approach for investigating the multilevel factors that may determine HIV risk. The individual level, cognitive approaches to understanding HIV risk are not sufficient to address the multidimensional factors such as families, institutions, polic y, and social norms that affect behavior. Addressing risk behavior at the intrapersonal level lacks sufficient breadth to promote sustained behavior change. The socio-ecologi cal model provides a theoretical framework within which HIV risk and prevention can be viewed through a multilevel, multidimensional lens. The study was grounded in the tenets of th e socio-ecological model of STD risk and protective factors. The Health Belief Model was used to pr ovide a theoretical framework for the intrapersonal factors that influence HIV risk be haviors. Finally, the Theory of Gender and Power provided a framework for the assessment of the macrosystem factors, specifically gender and power, which influence HIV risk. The Health Belief Model The Health Belief Model has been widely used in the study an d conceptualization of individual health behavior and the determinants of health behavior change. According to Kasl and Cobb (as cited in Rosenstock, 1974a ) health behavior is an activity that is performed by a person perceived to be healt hy for the purpose of preventing disease or for detecting disease in an asymptomatic st age. For over four decades, the HBM has been used to conceptualize and analyze health behavior and to deve lop health promotion interventions (Strecher & Ro senstock, 1997). Since its deve lopment, the HBM has been applied to a variety of health problems in an attempt to explain the health behavior of the
48 individual. The model has been used to c onceptualize health be havior pertaining to infectious diseases, cancer, influenza, dental disease, polio, HIV/AIDS, and other health problems. The original concepts postulated by the HBM were perceived susceptibility, perceived s eriousness or severity, perceived benefits of taking action, perceived barriers to taking action and cues to action The model discussed the c oncepts of motivation and modifying factors of behavior such as dem ographic, socio-psychologi cal, and structural variables. Perceived susceptibility refers to the individuals ac ceptance of his or her personal likelihood of contracting a disease or condi tion (McCormack Brown, 1999). Within this conceptual definition, individuals fall into a spectrum or c ontinuum of possible levels of perceived susceptibility. At one end of the spectrum is the individual who denies any level of susceptibility to a condition. In the middle of th e spectrum is the individual who sees the statistical possibili ty of contracting a disease or condition but does not see him/herself as personally susceptible. On the other end of the spectrum is the individual who perceives a real danger of contra cting the disease (McCormack Brown, 1999; Rosenstock, 1966). Therefore, th ere are various levels of perceived susceptibility into which an individual may fall. The level of susceptibility depends on the individuals subjective perception of the risk of acquiri ng a certain condition (Janz & Becker, 1984). The second central concept of the model is that of perceived seriousness or severity This construct involves the individuals beliefs about the effect a disease or condition would have on ones life. This di mension includes the in dividuals perception of the medical consequences such as pain, de ath, and physical and mental disability as
49 well as the social consequences such as econom ic loss, and negative effects on family life and social functioning (Glanz et al., 1997; Janz & Becker, 1984; Rosenstock, 1974b). Perceived benefits of taking action and perceived barriers to taking action are also pivotal concepts of the model. Perceived benefit refers to the indi viduals perception of the benefits of performing a certain behavior. Even though perceived susceptibility and seriousness are important f actors, it is actually the perceived benefit of a behavior that will determine the final course of action taken (Glanz et al., 1997). Therefore, according to Janz and Becker (1984), an individual who is sufficiently threatened will not perform a recommended health behavior unless it is perceived as beneficial, effective, and feasible. Perceived barriers to taking action are the roadblocks to performing a healthy behavior. Therefore, an individua l may perceive an action to be beneficial to health status but the action may not be performed because there may be barriers to action that outweigh the perceived benefits For example, if the beneficial action is expensive, difficult, painful or inconvenien t it is highly likely that the action or behavior will not be performed (Rosenstock, 1974b). Glanz et al., (1997) suggest that within this stage there is an unconscious cost-benefit an alysis that the individual undertakes. This analysis involves an assessment of the costs of the alternative actions n ecessary to reduce the threat of disease. The model also postula tes the concept of cues to action These cues or triggers are necessary for health behavior to occur. The or iginal developers of the theory argued that readiness to perform a behavior was largely in fluenced by cues or triggers for action. The previous concepts discussed ar e not enough in and of themselv es to bring about a health
50 behavior. Instead, there are cues that must be combined with the previous concepts in order to induce health behavior. These tri ggers or cues include the media, posters, brochures, a postcard from the dentist, and so cial networks. These cues are the crucial factors that set the health be havior in motion (Rosenstock, 1974b). This consideration is also very important since the cues to ac tion are very influential within the lived experience of the individual. The model also discussed other variables such as demographic, structural, and socio-psychological factors. Demographic factors include age, sex, and ethnicity. Structural factors include ex isting knowledge about a conditio n and prior experience with a disease. Socio-psychological factors include socioeconomic status, peer influence and social networks, and personality dispositions. These factors are seen as indirectly related to health behavior. The concept of motivation was also introduced in the original model. However, it was soon removed but was la ter reintroduced (Rosenstock, 1974b). The model argues that motivation is nece ssary for action. The concepts of susceptibility and severity combine to impart the motivation for a he alth related behavior or action (Brown, DiClemente & Reynolds, 1991). Motives influe nce the manner in which an individual perceives the environment (Rosenstock, 1966). Ma iman and Becker (1974) assert that the concept of motivation is operationalized by two specific dimensions of the model: the individuals state of readine ss to perform the action and the extent to which the health behavior is perceived to be be neficial. Motivation is therefore, an internal inclination that promotes a desire to perform and maintain a he alth behavior and to avoid future illness. The concepts discussed above are the or iginal dimensions of the HBM. They explain critical elements of the health behavi or process. These elements act together to
51 instigate an action from the individual. Th ere must be a combination of the proposed variables to promote a behavi or or action. The HBM is summ arized in figure 1. It shows the connectivity between the variables and visually explains the movement from individual perceptions to likelihood of actions.
52 Figure 4 The Health Belief Model Source: Becker et al. as cited in Rosenstock, 1974b.
53 Theoretical Additions to the Health Belief Model The concept of self efficacy was introduced by Bandura in 1977. This concept was added as an additional dimension of the HBM. The concept of self-efficacy has added a vital component to the explanation of the ad aptation and maintenance of health behavior. Albert Bandura (1977) defined self-efficacy as the convic tion that one can successfully execute the behavior required to produce the outcomes (p. 193). The selfefficacy construct is based on the underlying not ion that psychological processes create and strengthen expectations of self-efficacy The acquisition of a h ealth behavior not only includes self-efficacy it also includes the dimension of outcome expectancy Outcome expectancy is the belief that a given behavior w ill result in a give n outcome (Strecher, DeVillis, Becker & Rosenstock, 1986). Bandura explicitly differentiates between outcome expectations (similar to perceived benefits ) and efficacy expectations. This distin ction is evident in the fact that an individual may have high outcome expecta tions of a behavior but may never perform the behavior because they do not deem themse lves to have the efficacy or capability to undertake the action (Bandura, 1977 and Strecher et al., 1986). Bandura argues that efficacy expectations determine the level of effo rt an individual will put into a behavior as well as the length of time for which the behavior will be sustained. Therefore, the stronger the self-efficacy the more likely it is that the he alth behavior will be initiated and practiced for an extended period. Accord ing to this theoretical orientation, self-efficacy plays a major role in determining the behavi ors undertaken by different individuals, the level of effort they will allot to a behavi or, and the sustainability of the behavior (Bandura, 1977).
54 Behavior change is therefor e determined by two factors: self-efficacy and outcome expectations Self-efficacy influences the acquisition of ne w behaviors, affe cts choices of behavior, and affects an i ndividuals emotional reactio ns and cognitive processes concerning a behavior or action. Glanz et al. (1997) view the lack of self-efficacy as a barrier to taking a required h ealth action or behavior. They argue that the original HBM did not include this construct because the mode l was initially develope d to explain single performances of a health behavior such as immunization or taking a screening test. As such, self-efficacy was not seen as a vital construct to be included in the formulation of the model. It may have been assumed that people who do partic ipate in these single health actions have adequate selfefficacy to undertake the be havior (Glanz et al., 1997). However, since its development, the HBM ha s been used to explain prolonged health behavior. Self-efficacy seems to predict the success of short-term as well as long-term behavior (Strecher et al., 1986). For behaviors such as sm oking cessation, exercising, and sexual habits, self-efficacy becomes an important cognitive construct for the individual who performs the health behavi or. Therefore, in addition to perceived susceptibility, severity, benefits, and barriers the individual must also per ceive themselves to possess the required self efficacy to perform th e behavior. Thus they must realize the efficaciousness of the behavior or action (Glanz et al., 1997). Therefore, in more modern depictions and explanations of the HBM, self-efficacy is an added dimension. Application of the Health Belie f Model to Health Behaviors Since its initial development, the HBM has been applied to numerous health behaviors. This section will analyze some of the health behaviors to which the HBM has been applied. The health behavior studies th at will be discussed are studies examining
55 preventive health behavior including screeni ng behaviors, sick role behaviors, and HIV risk behaviors. In applying the HBM to HIV risk behavior s, many studies have investigated the relationship between the reduction of risk be haviors and the variables that have been conceptualized in the model (Montgomery et al., 1989). Some studies have supported the use of the model to explain why some indivi duals are successful in changing their risky sexual habits. Basen-Enquist (1992) tested a mo del of safer sex behavior using variables from the HBM and other theories. In terms of HBM, she found that perceived susceptibility was significantly related to the intention to use a condom. Perceived barriers were inversely related to condom use where the greater the barriers the less frequently condom use was reported. Self-efficacy was also an important variable. It was significantly related to the intention to discu ss AIDS and past sexual history with current sexual partners (Basen-Enquist, 1992). Klein et al. (as cited in M ontgomery et al., 1989) conducted a study among homosexual male physic ians and university students. The study found that the subjects who belie ved that they were vulnerable or susceptible to infection were more likely to report decreased le vels of high risk sexual behavior. Valdisseri (as cited in Montgomery et al., 1989) found that homosexual men who were concerned about the personal threat of AIDS were more likely to use condoms during sex. Perceived threat includes the dimensions of perceived susceptibility and perceived severity. Therefore, this study showed the significance of two variables in the reduction of risk behavior. Valdisseri also found that the barriers to condom use among homosexual men included perceptions that condo ms affected the pleasure received from the encounter, were embarrassing to purchase, were disliked by thei r partners, and were
56 more of a contraceptive method for heterosexuals. Therefore, perceived barriers prevented the use of condoms in this popul ation. Likewise, Maes and Louis (2003) found in their study among older adults that lo w personal vulnerability to AIDS, which produces low perceived threat to AIDS, e xplained why their study sample did not use condoms to prevent HIV transmission. Self-efficacy has been shown to have a consid erable influence on the performance of healthy sexual behaviors. Janz and Becker (1984) have argued that low self efficacy has the same effect as perceived barriers An individual who does not perceive the recommended behavior as efficacious is less li kely to perform the behavior. In their study of HIV preventive behavioral intentions in college students, Zak-Place and Stern (2004) found that of all the HBM constructs, self-effi cacy was the only signi ficant pred ictor of intended condom use. They also found that se lf-efficacy was a significant predictor of other preventive behaviors such as STD and HIV testing while perceived susceptibility was negatively related to HIV testing intentions. Rosenstock, Strecher and Becker (19 94) proposed hypotheses for testing the HBM in relation to HIV and AIDS. Th ese hypotheses were recommended as improvements to the application of the HBM to HIV/AIDS risk behavi ors that have been done in the past. Rosenstock and colleagues suggested that perceived severity is necessary for perceived susceptibility to be a significant predictor of HIV-preventive behaviors. In addition, perceived susceptibility will not be significantly related to AIDSpreventive behavior. Rather, it will be a str ong determinant of intention to practice safe sexual behaviors. A high level of perceived threat is also necessary for perceived benefits and barriers to be strong predictors of change in behavior. Self-efficacy will also be a
57 strong predictor of health behaviors especially those that require so me level of skill. Therefore, self-efficacy may be a strong predictor of c ondom use. In addition, cues to action will have a greater effect on be havior if there is a high level of perceived threat (Rosenstock, Strecher & Becker (1994). Th erefore, Rosenstock and colleagues have provided a guideline that can be used by rese archers to assess HIV/AIDS risk behaviors using the HBM. The guide references the elem ents of the model that are strongly related and pinpoint the health behaviors that can be predicted by the different variables. Theory of Gender and Power (TGP) This study was also conceptualized accordi ng to the Theory of Gender and Power. In 1987, R.W. Connell developed an integrativ e Theory of Gender and Power. According to Connell, there are three constructs that characterize gendered relationships between men and women: the sexual division of la bor, the sexual division of power, and the structure of cathexis (Connell, 1987). The sexual division of labor is the allocation of different types of work to men and women. Women often are delegated womens work, such as child care, elderly care and housew ork. Since these jobs are uncompensated, women often depend on men for financial resour ces. Even in situations in which men and women are equally skilled, men tend to be more highly remunerated than women. Often, women are also discriminated against in training and promotion opportunities. This reality often leaves women economically dependent on men. The sexual division of power refers to the ability of men to exert influence over wo men. This power exists at the societal, institutional, and interpersonal le vels, and is manifested by violence against women, the construction of male dominated hierarchies of authority, and patriarchal belief systems. Closely related to the sexual division of labor is the sexual division of
58 power which supplies the infrastructure for control and coercion of women. Power structures are manifested in government, business hierarchies, institutional and interpersonal violence, and sexual regul ation and surveillance (Chapman Walsh, Sorensen, & Leonard, 1995; Raj, Silver man, Wingood & DiClemente, 1999; Wingood & DiClemente, 2002) The structure of cathexis refers to the emo tional or affective dimensions of social relationships. This structure dictates appropriate sexual be havior for women and defines the moralistic expectations of women s sexual expression. Connell argues that expectations of sexual behavior within social relationships are not merely different, but they are specifically unequal. Heterosexual wo men are sexualized as an object in ways that heterosexual men are not. These three st ructures define the gendered roles of men and women in society (Connell, 1987). Connell posits that these structures, though di stinct, overlap each other and can be used to explain the cultural dimensions of gender roles assumed by men and women. These structures are rooted in the fabric of societies and serve to determine the genderrelated norms that are learned within each cu lture. Moreover, these structures exist not only at the societal level but al so at the institutional level such as in schools, work sites, families, relationships, the media, and in h ealthcare delivery systems (Connell, 1987). The presence of these social mechanisms has significant implications for womens economic, political, and social positions in society by creating in equities in womens economic potential, control of resources, and expectations of societal roles.
59 Application of the Theory of Gender and Power The theory of gender and power has been used to conceptualize public health issues such as domestic violence against women (Raj et al., 1999). This study assessed the relationship between social and economic power and incidence of male-perpetrated domestic violence against low-income African American women. The authors hypothesized that sexual division of labor ( operationalized by receiving government assistance, receiving income from male pa rtner, low educational level and having children) would be highly asso ciated with relationship abuse. They also posited that sexual division of power (partner jealousy, lowe r levels of perceived empathy) would be associated with higher levels of abuse. Fina lly, the authors hypothesized that structure of cathexis variables (greater religiosity, empha sis on childbearing and perceptions of sex ratio imbalance) would also be associated with higher levels of abuse. The study findings indicate some support for using the TGP to explain levels of domestic violence among African American women. In pa rticular, sexual division of labor constructs were strong determinants of domestic abuse. Sexual di vision of power variable s were also strongly related to higher levels of abuse. Theref ore, higher incidence of male jealousy was strongly related to domestic abuse. The structure of cathexis construct was also highly associated with domestic abuse. Women who had higher levels of per ceived male unavailability, and placed great importance on childbearing were likely to have less relationship power and more likely to experience domestic violence. This study provi des an example of th e application of the TGP to a prevalent public health issue. The study showed that women who are disenfranchised and disempowered may be mo re vulnerable to male inflicted abuse.
60 Criticisms of the Theory of Gender and Power The theory of gender and power has not been widely utilized in the social science literature. Chapman Walsh et. al. (1995) crit icize the theory for framing questions that focus on the social progress of men being achie ved at the expense of women rather than focusing on solutions for a society that can provide good quality of life for all members. Wingood & DiClemente (2002) further criticize the theory for being difficult to test empirically. This difficulty arises because the constructs are difficult to operationalize. It is also difficult to isolate and quantify the effect a particular structure may have on womens health. Nevertheless, this theory provides a unique framework for analyzing womens position in society and the factors that may contribute to negative social outcomes for women. TGP Applied to HIV Risk and Womens Health Wingood and DiClemente (2000) expanded the Theory of Gender and Power to develop a public health model that examin es exposures, risk f actors, and biological factors that adversely affect womens heal th. This expanded framework will provide a theoretical underpinning for th is study. According to the expanded model, exposures are acquired risks that increase the probability of acquiring a disease. Risk factors are those elements such as knowledge, attitudes, belief s, and skills that are associated with indulging in risky behaviors. Ri sk factors operate at the in terpersonal level and can be socioeconomic, behavioral, or personal in na ture. Biological factors are the physiological factors that may predispose an individua l to contracting a disease. Wingood and DiClemente (2000) argue that the social structur es of division of labor, power, and cathexis produce gender disparities in public health and the social sciences. These
61 inequities are manifested as gender based diffe rences in exposures, risk factors, and biological properties that increase womens vul nerability to diseases such as HIV. The following is an analysis of Wingood and DiClementes expanded model of the Theory of Gender and Power which conceptualizes the re lationship between the original theoretical tenets, exposures, risk fact ors and biological factors. According to Wingood and DiClemente (2000), the inequalities that result from the sexual division of labor are manifested in the public health field as economic exposures and in the psychosocial domain as socioeconomic risk factors. The economic exposures refer to women who live in povert y, have limited access to health care, are homeless, have less than a high school e ducation and have a high demand/low control work environment. Women who experience these exposures a nd risk factors will have adverse health outcomes. Closely linked to the sexual division of labor is the second theoretical construct: the sexual division of power. As previously discussed, this constr uct exists at the institutional and interpersonal levels. At th e individual level, women who have limited or no power in their relationships are likely to depend on their male partners for economic resources. At the institutional level, wo men are often portrayed by the media as dependent, oversexed, and degrading. These por trayals add to the ne gative perceptions of womens roles in society. The sexual division of power is mani fested in the public health field as physical exposures to disease. These exposures, which can exist at the institutional and interpersonal levels, include a history of sexual or physical abuse, significant exposure to sexually explicit media, a high-risk sexual partner, a partner who resists practicing safe sex, and lack of acce ss to drug treatment or to HIV prevention
62 education. In the psychosocial domain, the sexual division of power is manifested by behavioral risk factors such as alcohol and drug use, poor as sertive communication skills, low condom use/negotiation skills, low self-effi cacy to avoid HIV, and limited perceived power in the sexual relationship (Wingood and DiClemente, 2000). The structure of cathexis, the final tenet of the theory, refers to the structure of social norms and affective attachments. Th e disparities, resulting from the social mechanisms of social norms and affective att achments, are manifested in public health as social exposures and in the psychosocial domain as personal risk factors. Social exposures include women who have older part ners, women who want to conceive, family influence that does not support HIV protective be haviors, mistrust of the medical system, conservative cultural and gender norms, and religious affiliation that forbids contraceptive use. The personal risk f actors include limited knowledge of HIV prevention, negative attitudes a nd beliefs about condoms, and a history of mental distress and depression (Wingood and DiClemente, 2000). Table 1 outlines the conceptualization of the Theory of Gender and Power as it relates to womens health.
63 Table 1: Theory of Gender and Power as it Relates to Womens Health Societal Level Institutional Level Social Mechanisms Exposures Public Health Domain Risk Factors Psychosocial Domain Biological Factors Disease Sexual division of labor Work site, school, family Manifested as unequal pay produces economic inequities for women Economic exposurespoverty, low educational level, unemployment limited health care, no health insurance, homeless Socioeconomic risk factorsethnic minorities, younger women Sexual division of power Relationships, medical system, media Manifested as imbalances in control produce inequities in power for women Physical exposures sexual or physical abuse, high-risk steady partner, limited access to HIV prevention Behavioral risk factorsalcohol and drug abuse, poor assertive skills, low self-efficacy, limited control over condom use Anatomical features, genetic determination, hormones HIV Cathexis : social norms and affective attachments Relationships, family, church Manifested as constraints in expectations produce disparities in norms for women Social exposuresolder partner, conservative gender norms, mistrust of medical system, family influence Personal risk factors lack of HIV prevention knowledge, negative safer sex beliefs, perceived invulnerability to HIV/AIDS, depression and mental distress Source: Wingood, G.M. & DiClemente, R.J. (20 00). Application of the theory of gender and power to examine HIV-related exposures, ri sk factors, and effec tive interventions for women. Health Education & Behavior 27 (5), 539-565.
64 CHAPTER THREE: METHODS Purpose of the Inquiry The purpose of this study was to conduc t exploratory research to generate formative data on factors that influence HIV-risk behaviors am ong black heterosexual men living in the U.S. This study further se eks to explore potentia l variability in HIV risk behaviors among ethnic subgroups of black heterosexual men (U.S.-born and Haitian-born). Therefore, this study furthers the body of knowledge as it allows for an in-depth exploration of the social, cultural, intrapersonal and beha vioral factors that influence HIV-risk behaviors within subgroups of black he terosexual men (U.S.-born and Haitian-born). The study also allows for comp arison of the perspectives of black men versus that of black women from simila r ethnic subgroups. The results of this study provide insights for HIV education and beha vioral interventions to reduce HIV/AIDS disparities within ethnically diverse black popul ations in Florida and nationwide (limited to the populations in this st udy). From a methodological persp ective, the findings of this formative study may be used to inform the de sign of future quantitative HIV behavioral studies on subgroups of heterosexual black men.
65 Research Questions Phase I: In-depth Interviews with Heterosexual Black men Research questions were guided by resear ch objectives which sought to explore and understand the intrapersonal, socio-cultural, and behavior al factors that influence HIV risk behaviors in subgroups of black me n (U.S.-born and Haitian-born) who identify as heterosexual. Objective 1 : To understand the intraper sonal factors (knowledge, attitudes and beliefs) that influence HIV-risk be haviors in subgroups of black men (Native born African Americans and Haitian-born immigrants) who identify as heterosexual. Research Question: 1. What are black mens knowledge, att itudes and beliefs about HIV/AIDS transmission? Objective 2 : To understand the socio-cultural and beha vioral health factors that influence HIV risk behaviors in subgroups of black men (Native born African Americans and Haitian-born immigrants) who identify as heterosexual. 2. What are the HIV-risk behaviors pr acticed by black men who identify as heterosexual? 3. What cultural norms influence sexual be havior among black men who identify as heterosexual? 4. How do gender norms influence sexual behavior among black men who identify as heterosexual?
66 Phase II: Focus Groups with Heterosexual Black Women Objective 3 : To discover how black women conceptual ize and perceive the socio-cultural, intrapersonal and behavioral factors that in fluence black mens HIV-risk behaviors. 5. What are black womens per ceptions of the risk behavi ors practiced by black men who identify as heterosexual? 6. What are black womens pe rceptions of the gender and cultural norms that influence sexual behavior among black men who identify as heterosexual? 7. What are black womens pe rceptions of the ways in which black mens sexual behaviors affect their own health?
67 Table 2: Research Questions and Theoretical Concepts Research Questions Theoretical Constructs Being Assessed 1. What are black mens knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs about HIV/AIDS transmission? Socio-ecological Model /Health Belief Model Perceived susceptibility/perceived threat/perceived benefit of protective behaviors/perceived barriers/self-efficacy/ perceived severity. 2. What are the risk behaviors practiced by black men who identify as heterosexual? 3. What cultural norms influence sexual behavior among black men who identify as heterosexual? 4. How do gender norms influence sexual behavior among black men who identify as heterosexual? Socio-ecological Model/ Theory of Gender and Power Sexual division of labor, sexual division of power, cathexis. 5. What are black womens perceptions of the risk behaviors practiced by black men who identify as heterosexual? 6. What are black womens perceptions of the gender and cultural norms that influence sexual behavior among black men who identify as heterosexual? 7. What are black womens perceptions of the ways in which black mens sexual behaviors affect their own health? Socio-ecological Model/Theory of Gender and Power Structure of Cathexis, Sexual division of labor, Sexual division of power, Cathexis: social norms and affective mechanisms. Socio-ecological Factors
68 Qualitative Research I think metaphorically of qualit ative research as an intric ate fabric composed of minute threads, many colors, different te xtures, and various blends of material. (Creswell, 1998) With the continued emergence of multifaceted public health problems, the need for multiple approaches to analyze public health problems has become more evident. According to Ulin and colleagues (2005), qualita tive approaches help to fill a gap in the public health toolbox (p. xiii ). Qualitative methods can be used to discover attitudes, beliefs, perceptions, culture, and lived experiences in a na turalistic manner. Qualitative methods help to provide deeper insight and meaning to public health problems within the context of the lives of the individuals bei ng studied. Qualitative research is defined by Creswell (1998) as: an inquiry process of unde rstanding based on distinct methodological traditions of inquiry that explore social or human problems. The researcher build s a complex, holistic picture, analyzes words, reports detailed views of informants, and conducts the study in a natural setting. Many public health problems such as HIV ar e deeply embedded in the social and cultural fabric of society. Confronting these issues and developing effective interventions require multilevel, multidimensional approaches that may be discovered by using qualitative methods. In addi tion, qualitative methods may be used to complement quantitative techniques and allow for deeper discovery of answers to the research questions being studied. Qualitative research al lows the researcher to explore the social realities and understandings of study participants from a holistic perspective.
69 Overview of the Research Design This study was an exploratory inquiry us ing qualitative research methods. The purpose of the study was to conduct exploratory research to generate formative data on factors that influence HIV-risk behavi ors among black heterosexual men. This study further sought to explore potential vari ability in HIV risk behaviors among ethnic subgroups of black heterosexual men (U.S.-bor n and Haitian-born). In addition, the study explored black womens percep tions of the factors that influence the sexual risk behaviors of black heterosexual men. To explore black mens knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors, semi-structured in-d epth interviews were conducted with male participants in the initial phase of the study. Subse quently, in the second study phase, focus groups were conducted to explore women s perceptions specifically with regard to the responses and information gathered from the male interviews. Themes from the male interviews were used to develop the focu s group guide for the second phase of the study. Study Population The study population was black men and women from two predominant ethnic subgroups (U.S.-born and Haitian-born blacks) 18 years of age and older. These two ethnic subgroups were chosen for several reasons: 1. The epidemiological data as discussed ear lier show that there are high rates of HIV/AIDS in the black population in Florida and in the Hillsborough County area. 2. Epidemiological data also show that th ere are also high infection rates in the Haitian population in Florida. Even t hough they comprise 1.05% of Floridas
70 population, they account for 15% of HI V cases reported through 2008 (Florida Department of Health, 2008c). 3. The influx of Afro-Caribbean individu als into Florida and Hillsborough County warrants an investigation of the cultural and social implications for HIV transmission and prevention. Most notably, the Haitian population in Hillsborough County has more than doubled in the past several years (Lush, 2002). 4. There are distinct cultural differences between the African American and Haitian cultures that may manifest in significan tly different belief s and practices around sexual behavior. For example, unlike Afri can American culture, Haitian culture incorporates the concept of voudou a form of magic that often dictates beliefs around illness and health behavior. The age group 18 years and older was sele cted because in the state of Florida AIDS is the leading cause of death for black men and women ages 25-44 years (FDOH, 2007b). However, HIV/AIDS is now a grow ing problem among middle aged and older adults. For example, among Haitians, men and women 50 years and older have the highest prevalence of HIV/AIDS cases (FDOH, 2008c). A total of 29 men were interviewed, 15 U.S.-born black men and 14 Haitian-born black male immigrants who have been living in the U.S. for at least three years. For the focus groups, phase II of the study, U.S.-born and Haitian-born black women 18 years and older were included in the sample. AIDS is the leading cause of death for black women aged 25-34 years, the 3rd leading cause for black women aged 3544 years, and the 4th leading cause of death for black women aged 45-54 years (CDC,
71 2008b). In Florida, AIDS is the leading cau se of death among black women ages 25-44 (FDOH, 2008a). The data support the asser tion that these age groups within the black population are at high risk for contracting and transm itting HIV. Based on these observations, it is imperative that behavioral research is conducted among this population to determine factors that contribute to risk in order to develop appropria te interventions to curb the spread of the virus. Location of the Study This study was conducted in Hillsbor ough County, Florida. Hillsborough County ranks among the top 5 Counties in Florida for persons living with HIV/AIDS. Through September 2006, there were 6170 reported cases of AIDS in Hillsborough County. In addition, 48% of the adult HIV cases and 69% of the pediatric cases are among blacks (Hillsborough County Health Department, 2006) The Florida Department of Health (2006) reports that 1 in 85 blacks are liv ing with HIV/AIDS in Hillsborough County compared to 1 in 375 whites and 1 in 309 Hispanics. Immigration in Florida According to the Federation for American Immigration Reform, Florida is the seventh largest growing state in the nation in terms of in flux of immigrants. Since 1997, over 3 million new residents settled in Florida, one-third of who were immigrants. Likewise, Hillsborough County has experienced an influx of immigrants. According to the U.S. Census Bureau (2000), 11.5% of the population in Hillsborough County is foreign-born including significant numbers from the Caribbean. Therefore, the influx of
72 Afro-Caribbean individuals into Florida and more specifically, Hillsborough County, is significant and may have cultural and soci al implications for HIV prevention. Phase I: In-Depth Semi-Structured Interviews with Men Given the sensitive nature of the questions explored, semi-structured interviews were appropriate for the male study particip ants. In addition, since the study questions elicited socially desirable res ponses, an individual interview format minimized biases in male participants responses (Debus, n.d.). Inclusion Criteria for Individual Interviews Eligibility criteria for inclusion in this study included: a) male sex; b) self-identify as non-Hispanic black and/or African American; c) self-ide ntify as heterosexual; d) reside in Hillsborough County; e) self-declare ancestry from the U.S. (African American) or Haiti; f) able to speak English and; g) 18 y ears and older; h) reside in the U.S. for at least three years. Exclusion Criteria for Individual Interviews Men who were younger than 18 years of age were not included in the study. Men were not considered for the study if they di d not identify as non-Hispanic black, African American, or Haitian. Further, the stu dy excluded men who did not identify as heterosexual and did not reside in Hillsborough County and did not live in the U.S. for at least three years. Because the researcher was English speaking and did not have the capacity to interpret Haitian-Creole, non-Eng lish speaking individuals were not included. Sample for Individual In terviews with Men Unlike quantitative research, the goal of qualitative research is to gather information-rich data from a sample most qualified to provide the information. In
73 qualitative inquiry, the individua ls who have lived the issues being studied are considered the experts. The sample chosen for this study was able to provide th e most accurate and holistic information on the study topic. The inte nt was to select pa rticipants who could provide a range of experiences and perspectives that are re levant to the topic at hand (Ulin et al., 2005). According to Neuman (2003) it is important for the qualitative researcher to focus on a sample that reflects social life. Qualitative research emphasizes the context of the problem. As Lincoln and Guba (1985) note, the objective of naturalistic inquiry is not to focus on gene ralizations, but to detail the specifics that give the context its unique flavor (p. 201). Non-probability sampling techniques were employed to determine the sample for this inquiry. The logic of non-probability or pu rposeful sampling is to select informationrich cases that can provide meaningful inform ation for the questions being studied (Gall, Gall, & Borg, 2003; Patton, 2002). This inquiry employed quota, snowball, and convenience sampling techniques. Quota sampling is used to achieve a preset number of cases in predetermined categories that will reflect the diversity of the population. The number of cases in each category of the sample is fixed (Neuman, 2003). A quota sampling matrix was used to delineate the predetermined categories and the number of cases needed for the inquiry. However, data were collected until saturation was reached (Lincoln & Guba, 1985). The act ual study population for phase I of the study is detailed in Table 3 below.
74 Table 3: Phase I Study Population Phase I: Males Ethnic Subgroup Age No. per age group Total 18-24 years 5 25-44 years 5 U.S.-born (African American) 45-54 years 5 15 18-24 years 4 25-44 years 5 Haitian-born 45-58 years 5 14 Total 29 29 Snowball and convenience sampling were us ed to select st udy participants. Snowball sampling involves as king qualified people (e.g. gatekeepers, key informants) and research participants to recommend cases for the study. Using community connections, the researcher contacted key in formants in the Tampa Bay area who were resourceful in recommending and referring pa rticipants for the st udy. This recruitment method was particularly helpful for recruiti ng Haitian men who may be less visible and accessible in the general community. The resear cher also located informants by asking each participant to suggest others who they thought might be well-suited to address the questions being asked. This process con tinued throughout the study and allowed the
75 researcher to recruit a sample (N=29) of information-rich ca ses (Ulin et al., 2005). According the Patton (2002), this samp ling technique produces good interview participants and makes the study more credib le. These sampling techniques are useful and typical for qualitative research (Neuman, 2003). Purposeful sampling has several character istics that are unique to qualitative inquiry. First, the sampling design was emergent. This means the sample was not drawn prior to the study but while th e study was being conducted. The snowball sampling technique also facili tated this emergent, serial selection sampling design. The study sample was continuously adjusted or fo cused throughout the data collection phase. Second, as perspectives and insi ghts were gained, the resear cher refined the sample in order to obtain the most information-rich and relevant participants. These naturalistic sampling techniques are designed to produce in formation-rich samples. The point of qualitative inquiry is not to faci litate generalization, rather it aims to gather deeper insight and meaning within a holistic context. The sampling techniques chos en were appropriate to achieve these qualita tive research goals. Phase II: Focus Group Interviews with Women To explore the perspectives of wome n, four focus groups were conducted among female research participants. The themes derived from the male interviews were used to inform the focus group discussions. The purpose of a focus group is to listen and gather information from individuals based on thei r experiences. Focus group participants were selected based on similar characteristics as they relate to a particular issue or experience. One advantage of focus groups is that the pa rticipants influence or feed off of the information shared within the group. This inte rview format is appropr iate to explore the
76 perceptions and feelings of black women as th ey relate to the sexua l behaviors of black men. Very importantly, focus group participants were asked to react to the responses gained from the male interviews. Each focus group consisted of between 3 and 10 women. While Krueger and Ca sey (2000) recommend a maximum of eight women per focus group, adjustments had to be made to facilitate 10 women w ithin one instance due to over recruitment and an unan ticipated show rate of 100%. Inclusion Criteria for Focus Groups Eligibility criteria for incl usion in this study included : a) female sex b) selfidentify as non-Hispanic black and/or African American or Haitian; c) self-identify as heterosexual; d) reside in Hillsborough County; e) self-declare ancestry from the U.S. (African American) or Haiti; f) able to speak English and; g) 18 years or older; h) reside in the U.S. for at least three years; i) must have had at least one African American or Haitian male sex partner. Exclusion Criteria for Focus Groups Female informants who were younger than 18 years of age, did not identify as non-Hispanic black, African American, or Hait ian, did not identify as heterosexual, live in Hillsborough County, or speak English or did not reside in the U.S. for at least three years and did not have at least one African American or Haitian male sex partner were excluded from the study. Sample for Focus Groups with Women Similar to the sampling technique used for the male individual interviews, nonprobability sampling was employed to determin e the sample for the focus groups. Quota sampling and convenience sampling techniques were also utilized in this second phase of
77 the study. Quota sampling was used to achieve a preset number of cases in predetermined categories that reflected the diversity of the population. A quota sampling matrix was used to delineate the predetermined categorie s and the number of cases needed for the inquiry. The actual study population recruited for Phase II of the study is detailed in Table 4 below. Table 4: Phase II Study Population Phase II: Females Ethnic Subgroup Age No. of focus groups No. per focus group Total 24-27 years 1 5 U.S.-born (African American) 43-65 years 1 10 15 3 Haitian-born 20-27 years 2 5 8 Total 4 23 23
78 Recruitment for Phases I and II Participants were recruited from lo cal community-based agency contacts, community stakeholders, health fairs, and pa rticipant referrals. Community venues such as a college campus in Tampa, and a local barbershop were used as recruitment venues where recruitment flyers were posted. Gatekeepers and key informants within black communities were asked to refer particip ants for the study. Through my professional involvement in the community, I was able to identify gatekeepers such as the executive director of the Haitian American Alliance, the coordinator of th e Haitian Breast and Cervical program at a local cancer center, the coordinator of a local charity-based organization, coordinator of the Knowledge is Power healthy lifestyles program as well as community activists and advocates. These individuals I have b een able to identify through my professional relationships devel oped in the community through the Tampa Bay Community Cancer Network, a group of community-bas ed organizations that work to address cancer health disparities. Because the stigma associated with HIV/AIDS might have discouraged participants, HIV/AIDS was not mentioned on recruitment flye rs. The flyers invited U.S.born and Haitian-born black men and women to participate in a confidential study about sexual health, and relationships in th e African American and Haitian community (Appendix C). Flyers targeting Haitians were designed to be culturally ap propriate and included information in both English and Haitian Creole. Recruitment materials encouraged prospective participants to cal l a local phone number to determine whether they met the eligibility criteria for the study (refer to inclus ion/exclusion criteria section
79 above). Participants received a $25 cash incentive, educational brochures on HIV prevention and information on local HIV testing services. The research assistant contacted intere sted individuals to conduct an initial eligibility assessment to determ ine whether interested callers were elig ible for the study. Once eligibility was determined, based on th e inclusion criteria described above, the research assistant scheduled a convenient time a nd place (public facility such as libraries, community center and fast food restaurants) to conduct the intervie ws and focus groups. Twenty-four hours prior to the interview/focus group, potential participants were called to remind them of their appointments. Strategies to Address Researcher Safety Conducting sensitive research has the potential to significantly impact the psychological and/or physical safety of the researcher (Dickson-Swift, James, Kippen & Liamputtong, 2008). Since this study explored sensitive topics and was conducted by a female researcher, it was important to consider issues related to re searcher safety. Often, in social research, we rightly address particip ant safety, but fail to address the safety of those conducting the research. Dickson-Swift and colleagues (2008) note that the Social Research Association has identified severa l factors that should be considered by researchers: 1. Risk of physical threat or abuse 2. Risk of psychological trauma 3. Risk of being in a compromising situation 4. Increased exposure to risks of everyday life 5. Risk of causing psychological or physical harm to others
80 To address researcher safety in this study, several strategies were used. First, to address potential psycho logical threats, I used informal and formal support networks of trusted friends, family members, and colle agues for debriefing throughout the research process. Second, to address physical safety, I conducted interviews in public locations such as libraries and fast food restaurants. While conducting the interviews, I carried a mobile phone that was easily accessible. Th ird, I remained astute and aware of my surroundings at all times. Researchers w ho do not appear confident and aware may increase risk of personal danger (Pears on, Gregory & Thorne, 1999). It was also important to wear clothing that was appropria te to the setting in which the research was being conducted. Finally, as P earson et al. (1999) note, re searchers should trust their instincts and conclude the dialogue if they f eel uncomfortable or se nse that something is wrong. However, there was no occasion during my research to prematurely conclude an interview or focus group. These strategies were adopted to increase personal safety while conducting research in the field. Data Collection Procedures Phase I: Individual Interviews with Black Men As discussed above, participants were re cruited by distributing culturally tailored flyers (Appendix C) in various selected co mmunity-based locations. Flyers instructed interested individuals to call a local phone number. Once th e researcher was contacted, an eligibility checklist was used to determine whet her interested callers were eligible for the study (Appendix D). At this time, pertinen t demographic information was collected.
81 Setting. Once eligibility was determined, based on the inclusion criteria described above, the researcher scheduled a convenient time and place (public locations) to conduct the interview. Most interviews we re conducted at fast food rest aurants, local libraries and meeting rooms at a local university. Twenty-f our hours prior to the scheduled interview, potential participants were called to remi nd them of their appointment. Once at the interview, the researcher developed rappor t with the participant and reviewed and discussed the informed consent form (A ppendix F), purpose of the study, the time the interview would take (30-45 minutes), plans fo r using the interview results, answered any questions from the participant, and collected the signed consent fo rm (Creswell, 1998). The interviewee was given a copy of the consent form. Demographic Data. Prior to the conduction of the interview, each interviewee was asked to complete a demographic survey which contained closed-e nded questions about age, race, ethnicity, sexuality, marital status, educational level, employment status, and income (Appendix E). All participants completed the survey. Individual Semi-Structured Interviews. In-depth interviews were used to collect information from male study participants. According to Ulin et al. (2005), highly sens itive topics, such as sexual behavior, may warrant use of the indivi dual interview format. In-d epth interviews involve conversational exchange between an inte rviewer and respondent. Interviews are essentially conversations with a purpose (U lin et al., 2005 p. 82). The semi-structured interview included a number of questions that were develope d using an iterative process
82 and pilot testing (described below). Questions were asked sequentially, but the researcher also probed beyond the responses provided (Berg, 2004). Interview Procedure. The interview questions were open-ended, in tended to elicit the experiences and opinions of the participants. Interviews we re conducted using an interview guide which was fully developed and finalized after the in strument was pilot tested and guidance was received from the expert panel (dissertation committee members). The interviews commenced with an icebreaker to develop rapport with the interviewee. Gall et al. (2003), assert that it is impor tant for the researcher to de velop rapport with participants especially when probing for personal or sens itive information. The researcher used the interview guide to keep the di alogue focused and structured a nd to elicit responses that specifically addressed the research questions. The researcher read each question aloud to each participant and engaged in a dialogue to gain information on the perspectives and meanings of life events and sexual behaviors as constructed by the participants (Grbich, 1999). Interviews lasted between 45 minutes and an hour. After the interview was concluded, the researcher once again explained the intended use of the data and the confidentiality procedures that would be us ed to store and mange the data collected. Finally, the researcher thanked the participants for their time, efforts and information and wished them well. Categories of Interview Questions. To fully explore mens thoughts, perceptio ns and lived experiences, the interview questions were framed to include desc riptive questions and probing questions. Descriptive questions moved from easy to more complex and were designed to elicit
83 detailed descriptions of know ledge, attitudes, beliefs, and lived experiences. Probing questions were used to derive a more deta iled discussion of responses provided in response to descriptive questions (Grbich, 1999; Ulin et al., 2005). Development and Refinement of Interview Guide. Based on the tenets of the Socio-ecologica l Model, the Health Belief Model, and the Theory of Gender and Power, the interv iew guide was developed using an iterative process. These guides help the interviewe r organize thoughts and cover the topics in sufficient depth (Creswell, 1998; Ulin et al., 2005). The interview guide is also important to create a more systematic and comprehe nsive data collection process (Patton, 2002). Guided by a review of the li terature, the objectives of th e study, and the theoretical frameworks informing the inquiry, a set of interview questions were drafted. Once drafted, the interview guide was reviewed by members of the dissertation committee. Based on feedback from the committee, the instrument was revised and pilot tested among a small sample (N=4). Feedback from th e pilot testing was then used to develop a final version of the instrument (See Appendi x H). Questions included in the interview guide were organized into tw o categories: descriptive and probing questions. Descriptive questions were asked during the early stag es of the interview and as the dialogue progressed, probing techniques we re introduced. Descriptive questions logically moved from easy and less threatening to complex in nature. Probes are follo w-up questions that are intended to elicit deeper responses to previously asked questi ons (Grbich, 1999; Ulin et al., 2005).
84 Pilot Study. Pilot testing was conducted prior to the im plementation of the study. In qualitative research, pilot testing is important to dete rmine the appropriateness of interview guides, or other data collection tool s (Ulin et al., 2005). The interv iew guide was tested among a small sample (N=4) of black men, one Haiti an-born and three U.S.-born men. All pilot study participants lived in the US for at leas t 3 years and have had at least one African American and/or Haitian female sex partner and were between the ages of 27-57 years. Pilot study participants were therefore repr esentative of the study population. They were asked to provide feedback on data collecti on instruments and tec hniques and to discuss themes and concepts that are important around the topic of HIV transmission, risk behaviors, behavioral healt h, and socio-cultural determinan ts of sexual behavior. By conducting this pilot study, I was able to determine whether or not the instrument addressed the relevant issues related to the topic, whet her participants would respond honestly and openly, and whether potential que stions were easily understood. Because of my gender (female), I asked participants to share their feelings and comfort level discussing intimate issues with a female researcher. Pilot interviews were recorded and transcribed. The findings of th e pilot study were used to guide the development of data collection instrument s and techniques. Incentives. All male study participants were given a $25 cash incentives. In addition, participants were given an educational packet consisting of low literacy HIV prevention brochures, a listing of HIV test ing sites, and male condoms.
85 Phase II: Focus Groups with Black Women Focus groups were used to explore the views and opinions of the women in the study and to confirm the responses provided by male interviewees. A focus group is a qualitative research technique in which part icipants are interviewed in a group-discussion setting. This technique promotes open disc ussion and self-expre ssion especially among marginalized groups (Neuman, 2003). Since wo men were asked for their perceptions of mens sexual behavior in general, focus groups allowed for an interactive exploration of these views. The use of focus groups for this phase of the study was appropriate because the researcher sought to elic it the range of ideas, feelings and perceptions women have about mens sexual behaviors. In addition, si nce differences in perspectives, based on nativity, was a central focus of this study, fo cus groups allowed for this discovery in a limited time. Setting. Focus group participants were contacted by a research assistant who determined eligibility for the study. Once a group of eligible women were identified, the researcher chose a central, public locati on at which to conduct the focus group. Group sessions were conducted in local community-based organiza tions, meeting rooms at a local university, and a private residence. Demographic Data Prior to the inception of the focus group discussions, each participant was asked to complete a demographic survey which contained closed-ended questions about age, race, ethnicity, sexuality, marital status, e ducational level, employment status, and income (Appendix E). All participants completed the survey.
86 Focus Group Procedure. The researcher ensured that the meeting room and recording equipment was set up and ready prior to the arrival of focus group participants. As partic ipants arrived, they were welcomed. The discussions began with purposeful small talk (Krueger & Casey, 2000, p. 103) which helped to put the participan ts at ease. Once all participants were present, the researcher welcomed the group, explained the purpose of the study, informed consents, discussed ground rules, and asked wh ether there were any objections to audiotaping. All participants signed the focus group consent form (Appendix G). A focus group guide was used to guide the questioni ng route of the discu ssion (Appendix I). The guide was fully developed and finalized af ter the instrument was pilot tested and guidance was received from the expert pane l (dissertation committee members). Focus group discussions lasted for approximate ly one hour. After the focus group, the researcher once again explained the intended use of the data and the confidentiality procedures that would be used to store and mange the data collected. Finally, the researcher thanked the participants for thei r time, efforts and information and wished them well. Multiple-category design. Using the multiple-category design (K reuger & Casey, 2000), 2 focus groups were conducted among U.S.-born women and 2 groups among Haitian-born women. The multiple-category design allows the research er to conduct groups within several target audiences, either sequentially or simultaneou sly. By utilizing this method, the researcher is able to make comparisons between groups and/or within groups. In this case, the researcher compared perspectives between U.S.-born and Haitian-born groups. To ensure
87 accurate data collection and an alysis, all focus groups were audio-taped and transcribed. Focus groups lasted for approximately one hour. Development and Refinement of the Focus Group Guide. Using theoretically driven approaches the focus group guide was carefully developed using the guidelines suggested by Krueger & Casey (2000). Questions were informed by the research ques tions and the theoretical framew orks and were clear, short, open-ended, and one-dimensional. The focus group guide began with general questions and gradually moved to more specific questi ons as the discussion developed. Questions were categorized as opening, introductory, transition, key, and ending questions. Opening questions were designed to develop rappor t and increase the co mfort level of the participant. Introductory questions introduced th e topic and urged partic ipants to think of how the topic was related to their lives. Tr ansition questions were used to move the discussion into the focal questions of th e study (Krueger & Casey, 2000). Once the focus group guide was drafted, the questions were reviewed by members of the expert panel (dissertation committee) and then tested am ong a small sample of women (N=2). During the development of the instrument, the expert panel and the pilot testing participants were specifically asked to review the focus group questions for clarity, appropriateness, and relevance to the research questions. Base d on the findings of th e pilot testing and feedback from the expert panel, the fo cus group guide was revised and finalized (Appendix I). Pilot Study. Similar to phase I of the study, pilot test ing was conducted prior to the initiation of focus groups. The focus group guide was tested among a small sample (N=2) of black
88 women, one Haitian-born and one U.S.-born. All pilot study participants lived in the U.S. for at least 3 years and had at least one African American and/ or Haitian male sex partner. Pilot study participants were ther efore representative of the study population. They were asked to provide feedback on th e focus group instrument and data collection techniques and to discuss themes and concep ts that are important around the topic of HIV transmission, risk behaviors, behavioral healt h, and socio-cultural de terminants of sexual behavior. As previously menti oned, pilot study participants were also asked to assess the focus group questions for level of understandi ng, clarity, applicability and relevance to the research goals. Incentives. All female study participan ts received a $25 cash incenti ve and lunch or a gift card for lunch. In addition, part icipants were given an edu cational packet consisting of low literacy HIV prevention brochures, a lis ting of HIV testing sites, and condoms. Technical Research Process Audio-taping Interviews and Focus Groups Before the interviews and focus groups began and after consents were obtained, participants were asked if they objected to the discussions being audio-taped. Audiotaping helps to supplement memory and provides a record of events that occur during the interview process. Audio-taping aids research er recall and preserves the data collected which can be reviewed by others after the interview has been conducted. (Gall et al., 2003; Neuman, 2003). To prevent participant re luctance to express th eir feeling freely and any other undesirable notions of tape r ecording, the researcher fully explained the
89 purpose of audio-taping in order to gain the trust of participants. In this study there were no objections to audio-taping. Transcription A professional transcription service was used to transcribe the semi-structured interviews. The researcher worked closely with the transcriber to ensure that the transcripts accurately repr oduced the interviews. All focus group discussions were transcribed by the researcher. Once complete, th e researcher read the transcriptions while the audiotapes were played back to ensure accuracy. Field Notes The researcher recorded field notes thr oughout the data collection process. It is important that good, clear, and detailed fiel d notes are taken to enhance the inductive research process of qualitative inquiry (Ulin et al., 2005). The field notes taken included both descriptive and reflective notes. Descri ptive notes describe the natural setting, interview activities and occu rrences. Field notes were dated and included specific observations such as who were present, what social interactions took place, and what activities occurred. Reflective notes were used to document the interview process and reflections on personal feelings regarding sp ecific interview or focus group activities (Lincoln & Guba, 1985). Establishing Trustworthiness Similar to the concept of validity in quantitative research, trustworthiness refers to the confidence one can have in the findings of naturalistic inquir y (Ulin et al., 2005). Lincoln and Guba (1985) provide four criteria for evalua ting the trustworthiness of
90 qualitative inquiry: credibilit y, transferability, dependabilit y, and confirmability. These criteria were applied in this study. Credibility Synonymous with the concept of face valid ity, credibility refers to the soundness of the design and methods of a qualitative st udy. Credibility refers to the confidence one may have in the findings of naturalistic inqu iry that the data accurately represents the social phenomenon being studied (Neuman, 2003; Ulin et al ., 2005). Credibility of the researcher refers to the training, experien ce and the presentation of self. Establishing credibility requires the use of rigorous methods that produce rich data (Patton, 2002). In this study, peer debriefing was used to establis h credibility. Peer debriefing is the process by which the researcher and a colleague/s an alyze the data collected to clarify the researchers interpretations. The debriefe r in this study was a health educator and behavioral science researcher with extens ive experience in health education within minority populations who during the debriefing process probed the inquirers meanings, posture and potential biases. According to Lincoln & Guba (1985), the debriefing process allows for the analysis of th e research design as the study progresses to identify needs for methodological modifications which may not be apparent to the researcher. Finally, debriefing and obtaining an outsi ders perspective allowed me to clear my mind of biases and emotions that may have created barriers to objective interpretation of the data. Transferability Analogous to the concept of generali zability in quantitative research, transferability refers to th e degree to which study findings are applicable in another setting given that there is similarity or fittingness between the contexts (Neuman, 2003
91 p. 584). Because qualitative resear ch is highly context specific, it is sometimes difficult to determine the level of transfer ability. However, as was done in this study, the researcher provided rich descriptions of the research context, the study participants, the social interactions, and the physical environment so that other researchers can decide how transferable the findings might be to another study context. According to Lincoln & Guba (1985) it is not the researchers responsibility to decide the in dex of transferability; rather the inquirer must provide th e proper rich description th at allows others to make judgments on the transferability of the findings. Dependability Dependability in naturalistic inquiry is synonymous with the conc ept of reliability in quantitative research. Dependability refers to whether the resu lts of the study are consistent with the data collected. According to Grbich (1999), reli ability in qualitative research is assessed by the reader and lies in the capacity of the researcher to present a coherent, complete and meticulously checked e xploration of all aspects of the topic under investigation (p. 59). To establish dependability, independent researchers with expertise in socio-cultural HIV research were asked to analyze the methodological process, the data collected, findings, and interpretations. Th ese investigators, members of the doctoral committee as well as a health educator and rese archer with expertise in health behaviors among minority populations, acted as auditors to examine the product of the inquiry through their own investigative lens. Any disagreements betw een the researcher and the independent auditors were thoroughly discussed until consensus was reached.
92 Confirmability Confirmability is established by determining whether the researcher has maintained the distinction between their own be liefs and that of the research participants. This determination is done by allowing extern al inspection and veri fication of the study process (Ulin et al., 2005). One approach to es tablishing confirmability is the audit trail. According to Grbich (1999), an audit trail involves tracing the c onceptual development of the project from the raw data through data reduction, analysis a nd reconstruction (p. 62). To establish confirmability, six categories of information were collected to produce a good audit trail (Lincoln & G uba, 1985; Ulin et al., 2005): 1. Raw data including written field notes, tape recordings, and interview results. 2. Data reduction and analysis products theoretical notes, list of codes. 3. Data reconstruction and synthesis products, notes showing how themes relate; themes, definitions and relationships; inte rpretations and inferences; final report showing connection between existi ng literature and study findings. Process notes, methodological notes; trustworthin ess notes; and audit trail notes. A good audit trail allows others who r ead the data to determine if the interpretations are grounded in the data collected. 4. Materials relating to inte ntions and dispositions, the study proposal, reflexive notes, personal notes about study motives and expectations, and IRB documents. 5. Instrument development information, interview guide, focus group guide, data collection protocols.
93 Researcher Bias Interviewer effect refers to errors in meas urement that can be attributed to specific characteristics of the interviewer (Davis Couper, Janz, Caldwell, Resnicow, 2010). Neuman (2003) posits that inte rviewer bias occurs when there is a deviation from the true response in the response received a nd recorded by the interviewer. Neuman (2003) outlines six categories of interviewer bias: 1) errors by the respondent; 2) unintentional error or interviewer sloppiness; 3) intent ional deviations by the interviewer; 4) interviewers expectations of how a respondent should an swer; 5) failure of the interviewer to appropriately pr obe answers; and 6) influen ce on the answers due to the interviewers appearance and demeanor. Errors by the respondent refers to the interviewee, forgetting, misunderstanding or editing responses. Davis et al. (2010) argue that the pr esence of the interviewer can affect how the respondent forms and answer or edits a response be fore communicating it. Further public health interviews may be espe cially open to response edits as individuals may perceive social harm by sharing inform ation on stigmatized behaviors or health conditions. To minimize this bias, the re searcher developed rapport with all study participants by creating an atmosphere for open dialogue prior to beginning interviews and focus groups. By doing so, the resear cher created an open and nonthreatening atmosphere whereby participants co uld share their experiences freely. Unintentional errors or interviewer sloppiness refers to interviewer errors such as misreading a question, omitting questions, reco rding wrongs answers to questions or misunderstanding the responses of study part icipants (Neuman, 2003). The researcher controlled this bias by ensuring that questions were not misread or omitted. The
94 researcher had extensive knowledge of the interview and focus groups questions and followed the semi-structured interview and focus group guides throughout the data collection process. In additi on, interviews were tape r ecorded and recordings and transcripts were carefully revi ewed and audited to ensure that transcripts accurately reflected the recordings. Intentional subversion by the interviewer involves purposeful modification of answers, and omission or rewording of ques tions (Neuman, 2003). As previously noted, this bias was controlled by careful adheren ce to the interview and focus group guides as well as careful transcription and auditi ng of transcripts. The fourth category, influence due to the interviewers expectations refers to the interviewe rs expectations about a respondents answers based on th e characteristics of the respondents such as appearance, age, race, or previous answers. The resear cher addressed this bias by ensuring that respondents were not judged or stereotyped. The fifth category, failure of the interviewer to probe or to probe properly was minimized by ensuring that probes were used to more deeply explore specific answers to questions. To ensure that questions were properly probed, probing questions were included in the interview and focus group guides. In addition, the researcher was adequately trained through relevant cour sework, professional experience and pilot studies, to properly administer interviews and focus groups. The final category as defined by Neuman (2003) is, influence on the answers due to the interviewers appearance, attitude, reactions and comments This bias was minimized first because the researcher is of the same race as the study participants. The researcher ensured that her physical appearance was non-thr eatening and allowed her to
95 blend in with the research participants. In addition, the researcher minimized the use of comments that were not directly related to the interview schedule, and ensured that her tone, attitude and body language were nonjudgmental and neutral. Data Analysis Results were analyzed using thematic analysis. Thematic analysis is a process of analyzing qualitative data through encoding and generating themes or patterns in the information (Boyatzis, 1998). Hand-coding and a qualitative software package ( Atlas.ti version 6 ) were used to generate, organize and cla ssify codes. Ulin et al. (2005) note that qualitative computer software programs assist with the analysis process by performing useful data manipulation procedures such as creation and insertion of codes, indexing, and selective retrieval of text (p. 151). Interview responses were recorded, transcribed, and coded for emergent themes. Ulin et al. (2005), propose five basic steps in qualitative data analysis that allow for an inductive research process: 1) reading; 2) coding; 3) displaying; 4) reducing; a nd 5) interpreting. These step s were followed to conduct a thorough thematic analysis of the data. Th e first step, reading, involves immersing oneself in the data to ensure complete unde rstanding of the data collected. During and after data were collected, th e researcher reviewed interv iew and focus group transcripts from all study participants. Then, the researcher again reviewed each respondents transcript to identify significan t statements within the scripts. Themes were identified using the cons tant comparative method in which the themes were compared within and across interviews and focus groups. Constant comparative analysis involves comparing data elements of each interview or focus group and comparing them with all others to derive similarities or differences. The themes from
96 each transcript were compared with all other transcripts with particular emphasis on identifying commonalities across respondents. Th e final result is the determination of relations between different pieces of data (Thorne, 2000). As the data were read, the emergent themes were identified and code d. Coding involves attaching labels to the pieces of text that represent emergent themes. Extensive coding techniques were utilized to apply relevant codes to the data collected. Open coding involved word-by-word and line-by-line analysis of the data. This allowe d the researcher to cat egorize segments of the data based on emergent concepts. Axial coding involved the development of expanded categories based on the smaller cate gories identified in th e open coding phase. Finally, selective coding involved the validation of the relationship between identified categories (Grbich, 1999). During the coding process, transcripts were first divided into meaningful units of text. Next, based on carefully reviewing interview and focus group recordings and rereading of the transcripts, codes were created, and units of text from the transcripts were assigned to one or more codes. Reliability of Coding The researcher solicited two additional researchers with graduate degrees in Public Health and extensive experience in qua litative research methods and data analysis to review and code 20% of the interview transcripts (N=6 ) and 25% of the focus group transcripts (N=1). The first secondary coder is a health educator and doctoral candidate with extensive health edu cation, qualitative data anal ysis and project evaluation experience. Her qualitative data analysis e xperience includes coding and analyzing data from research projects centered on Afri can American and Haitian populations. One
97 example of her experience includes her resear ch on assessing the feasibility of using barbershops as a venue for prostate cancer ed ucation. She was also chosen to assist with coding for this study because of her extens ive experience conducting community-based projects in the Haitian and African American communities. A third coder was chosen to independently code a subset of the male interviews. A public health doctoral student at a university in the southeas tern United States, she is experienced in conducting qualitative rese arch and has worked on multiple projects conducting qualitative data analysis. One such project includes her research conducting and analyzing focus group data which explored the communitys perceptions and beliefs about access and services at a local cancer center. The th ree researchers (including the principal investigator) independe ntly reviewed and coded the transcripts. The researchers then met to discuss codes and rationale for the codes assigned Any discrepancies regarding the codes were discussed and re solved once all parties came to a mutual agreement. Coders discussed emerging codes as they were identified. Coding disagreements were discussed until c onsensus was reached. Throughout the coding process, codes were constantly compared and revised as the researcher derived new understandings of the data (see Appendix J). The data were then displayed to detail each category identified and reduced to the most essential points. The data was interpre ted by searching for the meanings of thoughts and feelings as described in the text. Finally, an overall in terpretation of the data was compiled outlining the themes identified and the relationship between these themes. Demographic data were analyzed by using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences ( SPSS) analytical software. Descriptive st atistics were used to summarize the
98 data and report findings. Desc riptive statistics reported include mean age, income, educational level, marital status and race/ethnicity. Data Interpretation Interpretation is a complex and dynamic craf t, with as much creative artistry as technical exactitude and it requires an a bundance of patient plodding, fortitude, and discipline (Crabtree & Mill er, 1999, p. 128). As postulated by Crabtree & Miller, the interpretive process consists of five iterati ve phases: a) descri bing, b) organizing, c) connecting, d) corroborating/legitimati ng, and e) representing the account. Describing is a reflective phase in whic h the researcher steps back from the research and analyzes how the inquiry is progressing, how the research process has affected interpretation, how the researchers thinking has been challenged, and what the next research steps should be. In this phase, the resear cher revisited the research questions and the overall paradigm of the inqu iry and assessed whethe r the data collected was rich and representative of the context and behaviors being studied. In the organizing phase, the researcher us es the appropriate organizing style or scheme for relating to the text. Organizati on gives structure and provides a systematic process for analyzing and interp reting the data. In this phase, Atlas Ti Version 6 was used to organize the text and identify emergent themes. Connecting is the process whereby the re searcher discovers themes and patterns and makes connections and linkages between ca tegories. After the data are connected and linked, the next iterative phase is corroborating or legitimating. The corroborating/legitimating phase consists of reviewing the text af ter initial or later analysis, seeking to corroborate the multiple tru ths or perspectives voiced in the texts
99 (p. 136). In this phase, the researcher seeks to uncover the meanings and lived experiences of the participants, and evaluate the credibility and accuracy of the data collected. As previously discussed, member checking was conducted to legitimate the data. The final phase, representing the acc ount, consists of sharing the new understandings and interpretations, finding some way to represent an account of what has been learned in the research (p. 137). The cr itical aspect of this phase is presenting an honest and accurate account of the data coll ected. The researcher focused on presenting the information using a critical, ecological framework while respecting the multiple voices of the study participants. Figure 5 below depicts the iterative steps in the interpretation process. Figure 5. Template Organi zing Style of Analysis Source: Crabtree, B.F., & Miller, W.L. (E ds.). (1999). Doing qualitative research (2nded.).
100 Management of the data Using appropriate confidentia lity procedures, the data were stored and managed in a safe and secure manner. Each particip ant was assigned a separa te file including: informed consent, transcript, eligibility ch ecklist, interview guide, demographic survey, researcher log and debriefing notes that we re kept in a locked filing cabinet. All electronic files such as Atlas ti Version 6 files and interview audio files were kept on a password protected computer accessible by the principal investigator only. Once the audio files were downloaded from the recorder to the secure computer, the files were deleted from the recorder. The researcher ensu red that all measures were taken to make protect the confidentialit y of research data. Protection of Human Subjects An IRB application was submitted to the I RB at the University of South Florida. The application included: a description of the purpose, design, methods, data collection, and analysis procedures of the study. Info rmed consent was obtained from each study participant. Once at the inte rview or focus group, the resear cher developed rapport with the participant, reviewed and discussed th e informed consent form (Appendices F & G). The interviewee was given a copy of the cons ent form. Key elements of the informed consent process were explained to the partic ipant including: 1) purpose of the study; 2) confidentiality of responses; 3) the voluntary nature of th e study; and 4) the right to withdraw from the study at any time.
101 CHAPTER FOUR: RESULTS Phase I Results: Semi-structured individuals interviews with black men Comprised of individual semi-structure d interviews, phase I of the study was designed to address the following objectives: 1) to understand the intrapersonal factors (knowledge, attitudes and belie fs) that influence HIV-risk behaviors in subgroups of black men (U.S.-born and Haitian-born) who identify as heterosexual and; 2) to understand the socio-cultural a nd behavioral health factor s that influence HIV risk behaviors in subgroups of black men (U.S .-born and Haitian-born) who identify as heterosexual. An additional component of this section is a presentation of the demographic profile of the study population. In this section, the results of the content analysis of the qualitative data are presented by research question. Demographic Information: Phase I A total of 29 black men who identified as heterosexual betw een the ages of 18 and 58 years of age (M = 34.6, SD = 14.2) partic ipated in the study. All men identified as black or African American, 52% were U.S. -born and 48% were Haitian-born. Of the male study participants, 65.5% were never married, 35% had some college education, 35% had a college degree or higher, 28% reported a household in come of under $15, 000 per year, and 69% were employe d for wages. Detailed demogr aphic data on educational, level, marital status, household income, race and ethnicity are presented in Table 5 below.
102 Table 5: Demographic Characteris tics of Male Sample (N=29) Demographic Characteristics N Percent Age (range 18-58 years) 18-24 years 25-44 years 45-58 years 9 10 10 31% 34.5% 34.5% Marital Status Married Divorced Widowed Separated Never married Member of unmarried couple 7 2 0 0 19 1 24.1% 6.9% 0% 0% 65.5% 3.4% Ethnicity Hispanic or Latino Not Hispanic or Latino 1 28 3.4% 96.6% Race American Indian or Alaska Native Asian Black or African American Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander White 0 0 29 0 0 0% 0% 100% 0% 0% Educational Level Never attended school or only attended kindergarten 8th grade or less 9th to 11th grade High school graduate or GED Some college or technical school College graduate or higher degree 0 0 4 5 10 10 0% 0% 13.8% 17.2% 34.5% 34.5% Household Income Under $15,000 per year $15,000 $24,999 per year $25,000 $34,999 per year $35,000 $44,999 per year $45,000 $59,999 per year $60,000 $75,000 per year $75,000 or more per year 8 5 4 5 3 2 2 27.6% 17.2% 13.8% 17.2% 10.3% 6.9% 6.9% Employment Status Employed for wages Self-employed Out of work for more than 1 year Out of work for less than 1 year A homemaker Student Retired Unable to work 20 4 1 0 0 2 0 2 69% 13.8% 3.4% 0% 0% 6.9% 0% 6.9% Sexual Orientation Heterosexual Bisexual Homosexual or gay Other 29 0 0 0 100% 0% 0% 0%
103 Analysis of the demographic data by s ubgroup reveals that within the U.S.-born sample, the respondents ages range from 19 to 54 years of age ( M = 32.7, SD = 14.3). Of the U.S.-born male study part icipants, 100% identified as non-Hispanic, black or African American, 80% were never married, 27% had some college education, 27% had a college degree or higher, 33% reported a house hold income of under $15, 000 per year, 80% were employed for wages, and 100% identifie d as heterosexual. Detailed demographic data on educational level, ma rital status, household income, race and ethnicity for the U.S.-born sample are presented in table 6 below. Table 6: Demographic Characteristics of U.S.-born Male Sample (N=15) Demographic Characteristics N Percent Age (range 19-54 years) 19-24 years 25-44 years 45-54 years 5 5 5 33.3% 33.3% 33.3% Marital Status Married Divorced Widowed Separated Never married Member of unmarried couple 0 2 0 0 12 1 0% 13.3% 0% 0% 80% 6.7% Ethnicity Hispanic or Latino Not Hispanic or Latino 0 15 0% 100% Race American Indian or Alaska Native Asian Black or African American Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander White 0 0 15 0 0 0% 0% 100% 0% 0% Educational Level Never attended school or on ly attended kindergarten 8th grade or less 9th to 11th grade High school graduate or GED Some college or technical school College graduate or higher degree 0 0 2 4 4 5 0% 0% 13.3% 26.7% 26.7% 33.3% Household Income Under $15,000 per year $15,000 $24,999 per year 5 4 33.3% 26.7%
104 $25,000 $34,999 per year $35,000 $44,999 per year $45,000 $59,999 per year $60,000 $75,000 per year $75,000 or more per year 2 2 0 1 1 13.3% 13.3% 0% 6.7% 6.7% Employment Status Employed for wages Self-employed Out of work for more than 1 year Out of work for less than 1 year A homemaker Student Retired Unable to work 12 0 0 0 0 1 0 2 80% 0% 0% 0% 0% 6.7% 0% 13.3% Sexual Orientation Heterosexual Bisexual Homosexual or gay Other 15 0 0 0 100% 0% 0% 0% Within the Haitian-born sample, a total of 14 men between 18 and 58 years of age ( M = 36.6, SD = 14.3) participated in the study. Of the Haitian-born male study participants, 93% identified as non-Hispan ic, 100% identified as black or African American, 50% were married, 50% were never married, 43% had some college education, 36% had a college degree or hi gher, 21% reported a household income of under $15, 000 per year, 57% were employed fo r wages, 29% were self-employed, and 100% identified as heterosexual. Detailed demo graphic data on educational level, marital status, household income, race and ethnici ty are presented in table 7 below.
105 Table 7: Demographic Characteristics of Haitian-born Male Sample (N=14) Demographic Characteristics N Percent Age (range 18-58 years) 18-24 years 25-44 years 45-58 years 4 5 5 28.6% 35.7% 35.7% Marital Status Married Divorced Widowed Separated Never married Member of unmarried couple 7 0 0 0 7 0 50% 0% 0% 0% 50% 0% Ethnicity Hispanic or Latino Not Hispanic or Latino 1 13 7.1% 92.9% Race American Indian or Alaska Native Asian Black or African American Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander White 0 0 14 0 0 0% 0% 100% 0% 0% Educational Level Never attended school or only attended kindergarten 8th grade or less 9th to 11th grade High school graduate or GED Some college or technical school College graduate or higher degree 0 0 2 1 6 5 0% 0% 14.3% 7.1% 42.9% 35.7% Household Income Under $15,000 per year $15,000 $24,999 per year $25,000 $34,999 per year $35,000 $44,999 per year $45,000 $59,999 per year $60,000 $75,000 per year $75,000 or more per year 3 1 2 3 3 1 1 21.4% 7.1% 14.3% 21.4% 21.4% 7.1% 7.1% Employment Status Employed for wages Self-employed Out of work for more than 1 year Out of work for less than 1 year A homemaker Student Retired Unable to work 8 4 1 0 0 1 0 0 57.1% 28.6% 7.1% 0% 0% 7.1% 0% 0% Sexual Orientation Heterosexual Bisexual Homosexual or gay Other 14 0 0 0 100% 0% 0% 0%
106 Compared to the U.S.-born men, Haitian-born men in this study sample were more likely to be married, more likely to have some college education or a college degree, more likely to have a higher house hold income, and more likely to be selfemployed. Table 8 below shows the themes that emerged in Phase I of the study. Table 8: Emergent Themes: Phase I Domain of Inquiry: Intrapersonal Factors Subgroups Themes: U.S.born Haitianborn Perceived seriousness and severity of HIV/AIDS Yes Yes Conspiracy Beliefs Yes Yes Resentment for historical blaming of Haitians for HIV/AIDS No Yes Womens negative attitudes to condom use Yes Yes Domain of Inquiry: HIV Risk Behaviors Themes: Inconsistent condom use Yes Yes Perceived level of trust determines condom use Yes Yes Primary concern for contracepti on versus disease prevention Yes Yes Immediate condom availability determines condom use Yes Yes Lack of sexual pleasure with condoms Yes Yes Condoms unnatural No Yes Condom use contradicts religious beliefs No Yes Domain of Inquiry: Cultural Norms Themes: Parental religiosity as barrier to family communication about sexual behavior Yes Yes Parental embarrassment creates barri er to sexual family dialogue Yes Yes Violence against homosexuals and bisexuals No Yes Domain of Inquiry: Gender Norms Themes: Women need to feel empowerment Yes Yes Women need to have better knowledge of sex partners Yes Yes Need for female self-esteem Yes Yes Female promiscuity and self-degradation contribute to risk Yes Yes Women to use the female condom No Yes
107 Objective 1 : To understand the intraper sonal factors (knowledge, attitudes and beliefs) that influence HIV-risk be haviors in subgroups of black men (Native born African Americans and Haitian-born immigrants) who identify as heterosexual. To assess knowledge, attitude and beliefs about HIV/AIDS the following questions were asked: 1. When you think about HIV & AIDS, what comes to your mind? 2. What can increase a persons risk of getting HIV/AIDS? 3. What can a person do to protect themselves from HIV? 4. Where do you believe HIV originated or how do you believe it first started? Participants were evaluated as possessi ng high levels of HIV/AIDS knowledge if they answered correctly to questions two and three based CDC information. According to the CDC (2010), major risk factors for HIV in clude: 1) not using a condom during sexual intercourse (anal or vaginal) with an HI V-infected person; 2) having multiple sex partners; 3) unprotected oral se x; 4) sharing needles, syri nges and other equipment used for injecting illicit drugs and; 5) pe rinatally acquired. Less common modes of transmission include: 1) bei ng stuck by a contaminated need le; 2) blood transfusions and unsafe medical or dental pract ices; 3) eating pre-chewed food from an HIV-infected person; 4) tattooing and body pier cing and; 5) being bit by a person with HIV (skin must be broken). Next, the results of the male interviews will be presented by research question.
108 Question 1: What are black mens knowledge, attitudes and beliefs about HIV/AIDS transmission? U.S.-born and Haitian-born black men por trayed high levels of knowledge about HIV risk and protective behavior s and perceived HIV to be a serious disease. In addition, men from both subgroups endorsed HIV conspir acy beliefs, including notions that HIV is a governmentdriven form of genocide desi gned to eradicate th e black community. U.S.-born men Knowledge of HIV risk and protective factors. Overall, U.S.-born men interviewed por trayed high levels of knowledge about HIV risk and protective factor s as 87% (13) identified HI V risk and protective factors consistent with the CDCs listing noted above. They identified key risk factors such as injection drug use, sharing needles, unprotected sex, promiscuity, multiple sex partners, exposure to infected blood and bodily fluids, and lack of education or knowledge about HIV. U.S.-born men also possessed high levels of knowledge about methods and strategies for preventing HIV transmission su ch as abstinence, condom use during sexual intercourse, abstaining from injection drug use, engaging in open and honest communication with sex partne rs, and practicing monogamy. When asked to describe risk and protec tive factors for HIV, a single 45-year-old participant described his per ceptions and experience with a family member with AIDS, an event that taught him about HIV and AIDS. Not practicing safe sex means that youre having multiple partners. Not using contracepti ves or anything like that. And basically not being knowledgeable about your sexual partners or knowing the people you actually ha ve. Abstinence is the biggest thing. The other part is being knowledgeable of your partners, as I was talkin about. A lot of people have a different perspective of how they can contract AIDS, but AI DS cant be contracted through
109 touch and everything like that. Basically through the blood of sexual intercourse. So, I mean, that s stuff Ive learned over the years, cause my brother, he had died from AIDS. I was one of his main caregivers, because some of my family was nave about AIDS. They thought cause he had AIDS if you touch a cup or anything like that, they could ge t it. So its like me learning everything I could about AIDS. A younger U.S.-born participant, aged 21, sh ared his insights on HIV protective behaviors. To protect themselves you know condoms are you know made for a reason, you know. Dont have unprotect ed sex. Abstinence, but you know I dont do that anymore. You know, I got a kid. Be open with everybody because a lot of people get it and know they got it, but dont ever say nothing about it, you know, just keep continuing to sleep with other people and keep passing it on. Men also perceived that HIV/AIDS is a serious disease that is ultimately fatal. Men described HIV as a chronic disease, disease that kills, death sentence, terrible disease and the words HIV and AIDS invoked feelings of fear and worry. Gaps in HIV knowledge existed with relation to HIV testing. None of the U.S.-born male participants mentioned HIV testing as an im portant factor in HIV prevention. While there has been a national effort to educate the co mmunity on the importance of HIV testing, the men in this study sample did not seem to perc eive HIV testing as an important factor. This lack of awareness about the importance of HIV testing may be attributed to several factors including: 1) men may not want to know their status and; 2) heterosexual men may not perceive themselves to be at risk for HIV and hence may not perceive the need for testing, the importance of knowing thei r status or that of their partners. Conspiracy beliefs. The inquiry found that conspiracy beliefs play an important role in mens conceptualization of the HIV epidemic. Thes e beliefs emerged when men were asked to
110 describe their beliefs about the origin of HIV/AIDS. Among the U.S.-born men, 47% (7) believed that the HIV epidemic may be attr ibuted to government experimentation or conspiracies to control the black population. In addition, several partic ipants believed that there is a cure for HIV/AIDS that is onl y accessible to the wealthy and privileged. When asked about his beliefs regarding the origin of HIV, a 25 -year-old participant noted: It started, well I seen a video. It was, it was some white doctors experimenting on some Africans, an d I guess they was using them as test dummies or something. Bu t Africans was looking at it as, you know, they was trying to help them, but it was poisoning them You know there is thinki ng that HIV might have been created to destroy blacks .. I believe so. Another 29-year-old particip ant of middle socioeconomic status (SES) described his beliefs about HIV. I believe HIV started in a lab actu ally. And in my, in me reading about the different things, and I lear ned there are a lot of different contradictory information about it, and for me its hard to understand if, you know why is there so much conflicting information. So my personal belief is that [HIV] was created in a lab [for] population control. Yet another participant, 54 years old of low SES and HIV positive, blamed government experimentation for the spread of the virus. They say it came government was experimenting with something and the virus got out in there and a animal or mosquito something bit someone and thats how they contracted the virus not knowing they had contracted to their partner and their partner not knowing. Took the gov ernment a while before they realized what it was. A 51-year-old participant of low SES shared his views about a cure for HIV/AIDS. He talked about his beliefs as well as thos e of his friends and family members.
111 We have discussions. I mean, we agr ee that once you get it, you got it until theres a cure. Not yet, th ere hasnt been one. Not for us poor folks, anyway. A 19year-old father of low SES conveyed his strong feelings about the existence of a cure for HIV/AIDS. I believe it was something from th e white man that led that and everything. They have a cure but th ey dont want to give it out because if they had a cure so many people would be trying to get it, and you know, they want to tax people for it and stuff. Having taken care of his brother who wa s dying from AIDS, a nother 45-year-old participant stated his beliefs about a cure. After watching somebody die of AIDS, the suffering and everything they been through, its something th at, you know, when God feels its my time to go, thats some thing that I dont wanna go through. Because you slowly dyin of whats happenin. You know you gonna die. I mean they doin multip le researches...but its still right now til the government ac tually and I believe that they have a cure. Thats my belief. But in being that were both African American and stuff like that I believe they want us to die off a little bit more before they actually put a cure out. Cause I believe theres a cure. Me personally, I believe theres a cure. If they research so much other stuff, I k now for a fact that money that they done put in since 1982 when [HIV] was actually put out there and everything like that, you cant tell me that in almost 30 years that they havent found a cure in almost 30 years. Thats my beliefs. Findings reveal that U.S.born black men are knowledgeable of the behaviors that put them and their partners at risk for HIV and are aware of HIV preventative behaviors. As shown by the data presented above, HIV conspiracy beliefs were pervasive in the study sample. Participants shared a range of beliefs along the conspiracy continuum such as attributing the orig in of HIV to government experime ntation and population control, to beliefs that the government has a cure for HI V/AIDS that is not accessible to the general population and especially to the black community.
112 Haitian-born men Knowledge of HIV risk and protective factors. Haitian-born men also portrayed high leve ls of knowledge about HIV risk and protective behaviors as 79% (11) accurately identified factors included in the CDC guidelines noted above. A 20-year-old Hait ian man indicated that there are multiple factors that put an individual at risk for HIV and several ways to protect oneself from the disease. if you wanna get intimate with somebody, I think you should take it upon yall selves, both of us, both of yall, to like go and get tested for any type of STD, as to such-and-such, and stuff like that. And, yeah, always use protection, or well, then again, abstinence is always the best way. But, like, its always good to use protection. And um .yes, thats about it. Thats the way I see it. He also described factors and behaviors that increase risk for HIV transmission. Needles, blood transfusion. I w ould say oral sex with cuts, especially like, I mean, with protec tion or condom or stuff like that its way less likely. And but with t o me like oral sex, you have to really know the person and like, its more of an obligation to go and get tested. Another 20-year-old Haitian man emphasized the importance of abstinence or condom use. Number one number one thing is to be abstinent. And also to and if youre not going to be, you also should know your partner, your partners history. And also, always, always, always wear a condom or some kind of contraceptive when youre having sex, thats going to protect you from HIV and AIDS instead of just pregnancy. Cause some do just protect against pregnancy and not HIV and AIDS. But number one thin g is abstinence like I said and also knowing your partner. Collectively, Haitian men identified sharing needles, promiscuity, multiple sex partners, lack of education, and homosexuality as risk factors for HIV. Haitian men were
113 also knowledgeable of HIV protective behavi ors such as abstinence and condom use. Similar to U.S.-born men, Haitian men perceive d HIV/AIDS to be a serious and severe disease. A 22-year-old Haitian immigrant who lost a relative to AIDS attached a death sentence to the disease. Its [HIV] real. People die. Its real. I had an aunty. She used to be big, big and then she started to lose weight .I was shocked. She got skinny. HIV can live inside of you as long as you live and you will be big and then decrease until you pass. According to an 50-year-old Haitian man When I see HIV, I see like a dise ase that's pretty dangerous, that can kill me. And I know there's no real treatment for it, so it's a dangerous disease for me. Unlike U.S.-born men, older Haitian men ascr ibed a moral or religious component to HIV transmission. According to a 54-year-old participant: We always call it SIDA [AIDS]. People who involve in this kind of term is a kind of people lack of moral. Further, he indicated that contr acting HIV can be attributed to a kind of lack of behavior and people who dont respect themselves. A 50-year-old Ha itian participant noted that HIV is a disease of people who do not care about themselves. He also implied that God protects against HIV especially within the sanctity of marriage. I think it happen to people w ho dont care about themselves. I remember since I was in my count ry, before I left my country, I told that to my wife. I told my wife they say good favor God give me, I'm going to leave Haiti to come here and my wife with me. We come together. At this time, I said if I come to U.S. and I pick something like that, like HIV, I c an't blame God. It's on me who don't respect myself, who don't know who I am. And I said to her, I think she think to do the same way because even you not married, you still got some precaution y ou can take to make you don't pick something like that. But even if y ou married but God give you more and more protection. HIV is peopl e who don't care about their life and they family.
114 Conspiracy Beliefs. Similar to their U.S.-born counterpart s, Haitian-born men expressed HIV conspiracy beliefs about the creation and orig ination of HIV. These beliefs and attitudes emerged as Haitian men were asked to desc ribe their beliefs about the origin of HIV/AIDS. Moreover, 50% (7) of Haitian participants conveyed their anger and resentment that historically, Haitians ha s been blamed for HIV. Many participants referred to the 4 Hs whereby homosexuals, he mophiliacs, heroin addicts, and Haitians were identified as high risk groups and blamed for the spread of HIV/AIDS (Nachman & Dreyfuss, 1986; Santana & Dancy, 2000). Some say [HIV] comes from Haiti and that makes me mad. I am not sure how that could be. A 36-year-old participant voiced his views on the historic recrimination of Haitians. I think we always know most of the blame, whatevers going on, Haitians we I think kinda just accept pretty much everything they throw at us. But knowing, well, its not the truth. He also believed that HIV was created from research experiments. Aside from I guess for me, my knowledge really I think [HIV] was definitely, really formed in a lab. When asked where he believed HIV originat ed, a young 22-year-old Haitian man stated: Africa. Thats what they say but I dont believe its Africa. American started that. It was a white guy. Its not Africa. They say the water gave you HIV, but it s not true because black people are not like that. Its the white man started that. U.S.-born and Haitian-born men portrayed high levels of knowledge about HIV risk and protective factors with 83% (24) of the sample accurately identifying risk and protective behaviors. Men also perceived th e seriousness and severity of HIV and AIDS. A deeper exploration of HIV beliefs revealed that a 48% (14) of the total study sample
115 held AIDS-conspiracy beliefs. Moreover, Ha itian-born men expressed their resentment for the historic stigmatization and labeling of Haitians as AIDS-carriers. Objective 2 : To understand the socio-cultural and beha vioral health factors that influence HIV risk behaviors in subgroups of black men (Native born African Americans and Haitian-born immigrants) who identify as heterosexual. Question 2: What are the ri sk behaviors practiced by black men who identify as heterosexual and what factors are associated with these behaviors? The inquiry found that HIV risk beha viors were prevalent among the men represented in this study. U.S.-born men pr imarily reported risk behaviors such as inconsistent/lack of condom use, multiple se x partners, and alcohol use prior to sexual intercourse. Haitian-born men reported inconsiste nt or lack of condom use during sexual intercourse. Emergent within this portion of the study was the theme of the role of womens attitudes to condom use. Men from both subgroups indicated th at if their female partners did not endorse c ondom use, they were less lik ely to use condoms during a sexual encounter. To explore HIV risk beha viors practiced by black me n, the researcher inquired about concurrent/multiple sex partners a nd condom use. The CDC (2009) identifies multiple sex partners, unprotected sex, and substance abuse as risk factors for HIV transmission. Within this study population, hi gh levels of knowledge, perceived severity and, perceived seriousness did not re sult in HIV protective behaviors. U.S.-born Men U.S.-born men reported risk-taking behaviors such as multiple sex partners, inconsistent condom use, and al cohol and substance use/abuse pr ior to sexual intercourse.
116 Overall, 47% (7) of U.S.-born men reporte d current and past partner concurrency behaviors and 53% (8) reported incons istent or lack of condom use. Multiple Sex Partners. A 20-year-old participant e xplains the feeling of enga ging in sexual relationships with 3-5 different girls within a 5-month time frame. At that time man, it was there. Li ke man, theres no greater feeling to a guy as when you have 3 to 4, 5 different women that likes you. And all they wanna do is, you know, get some and go. And well, my stage back then, you know, like I sa y, I was I like to make people laugh. I like to be honest most of th e time, so I guess thats what a lot of women like. And a lot of people know women hormones are way stronger than us guys are. And just makin em laugh and bein honest with em turns them on. So I guess thats what I did and just had multiple a lot of them likeded me. A 19-year-old father of low socio-economi c status recounted his past promiscuous behavior. I used to be on it! After the relationship with his childs mother dissolved he claims, when we broke up I had (pause) five? Five, three, four, fiv e, five or six, five or six [female partners]. While acknowledging his current monogamous relationship, a 27year-old participant questioned his level of commitment. When asked how committed he was to his current partner, he stated: If I had to give it a number from 1 to 10, I would definitely say a 7.5. To be honest, Im a male, you kn ow. We are visually attracted to different women. He also rationalized the concept of black men having multiple sex partners. For me its not I think that nowadays, you know, the traditional marriage and husband and wife is over. With women now having jobs, and doing everything that a man can do, sometimes some men need to validate themselves. By validating themselves they have to please more than one woman. Thats why I think it is different now. You know, its not ju st this generation where African American men have had more than one relationship. Its been going on for a very long time. Its ju st that in African American
117 society, whatever happens at home stays at home. But now, its more out in the open. While ultimately wanting a committed relationship with a God-fearing woman a 45-year-old participant described his open re lationship with a woman whose lifestyle is unacceptable to him. We are friends with benefits. My part, it works pretty good. On her part, she kinda have a problem with it, cause of the simple fact that some women like to play and men do too . She is very sexually active with other pe ople she kinda want a serious relationship, but she cant change her lifestyle. A 54-year-old U.S.-born participant shared his risky behaviors despite his HIV-positive status. While he reported using condoms dur ing every sexual encounter and informs his partners of his HIV status, he admitted to having multiple sex partners, an average of 7 within the past 12 months. Id say that I done had relationship with a female, especially since it probably aint right since we not married, about maybe 7. When asked about his level of commitment to any of his partners he responded, No, no. I aint committed. I aint committed. Among U.S.-born men who participated in this study, a la rge proportion (40%) reported having concurrent sex partners indicatin g that this high risk behavior is fairly prevalent in the study population. As show n, the practice of having multiple female partners seems to give men a sense of validat ion. The encouraging finding is that most U.S.-born men (60%) did not report having multiple sex partners. However, while U.S.born men seem to understand the risks associated with multiple partners, partner concurrency is a fairly common sexual beha vior among black men represented in this inquiry.
118 Condom Use. This inquiry also explored the condo m use behaviors practiced by black men. While U.S.-born men reported high levels of knowledge about the risks associated with unprotected sex, study results s how knowledge levels do not translate into consistent condom use. In fact, 60% (9) of U.S.-born me n reported inconsistent or low condom use. When asked whether he always uses condoms during sexual intercourse, a 19year old father who had previous ly contracted an STD indicated: No. I feel I need to work on that. He reflected on his reasons for not using condoms. Because, my first time when I didnt have a condom it felt good, so I got used to th e, you know I feel I need to work on that. Thinking back to a sexual encounter when he did not use a condom he remembered thinking, Man, this is wet! Dang! However, after the encounter he regretted not using a condom. Damn, I should have used a condom. Participants described several barriers to condom use including: 1) immediate condom availability; 2) perceived trust in a sex partner and; 3) the belief that condoms remove the spontaneity from sexual intercourse. Men al so tended to report greater concern for contraception rather than disease preventi on. Therefore, condom use was deemed less critical if their female partner used ot her forms of birth control such as oral contraceptives. A 27-year-old man asserted th at he may not use condoms if they are not readily available. He described an expe rience in which he had unprotected sex. Basically it was a moment in ti me where me and my partner was together, and we were out for an evening, and at the end of the evening we chose to take a stroll on the beach. At that point in time, there are no gas stations or any kind of con venience stores where you may be able to buy or purchase condoms. At that point in time, the fact that we were going to have sex was not on my mind, so I didnt think to bring anything. It was one of those moments that was very spontaneous. I dont even think she thought it was going to happen. So thats th e moment I can think of right now where there was a point where we didnt use any protection.
119 A 29-year-old father who has been in a l ong-term relationship expressed his negative feelings about condoms. I think it definitely takes away the pleasure of the experience. Sometimes some females dont you know, it gives them irritation, or you know, they cant use them so, and it breaks the mood if you are, you know, you know trying to have relations and stuff like that, so it kind of interfer es with the flow of the mood. He also expressed his minimal concern for STD or HIV transmission within his relationship. Im not as concerned because li ke I had mentioned, we have been in a relationship for a long time, and there is a ce rtain level of trust there, but you know, that ma kes me pretty much less, um, you know worried about contracting STDs and stuff like that. A 25-year-old man who plans to return to co llege in the near future articulated his reasons for not using condoms with his ex-girlfriend. It was like, she dont want to get pregnant. You know, shes doing the school thing, and I understood th at, you know, and that was the smart thing to do. But it was to the point that we didnt have no condoms and then, thats what happened, so. And it, after the first time, and then it was, it happe ned again and again, so but you know I ended up using condoms again, but I guess I felt more comfortable, I felt more comfor table that she was a virgin I didnt use it [condom] because I, you know I cared about her and I loved her. I had that trust, y ou know, I had that trust in her. Similarly, another 27-year-old U.S.-born part icipant attributed his low condom usage to his high level of trust in his pa rtner and the fact that his partner uses alternate forms of birth control. Ive used the male condom before but its hard for me to have opinions because I havent used it as often. But Im not sayin Its just because most of my sexual partners, you know, we used to get tested together. And the ones be fore and we just had a level of trust. And then they would get the whats it called. I forgot what its called. Nuva Ring or somethin like that.
120 He described the concept of going raw a nd explained how he a nd his peers evaluate women with whom they would go raw or have unprotected sex. Would you go for it? Its like, Oh Halle Berry? Oh, I might have to go raw! You know, I might have to take that chance. You know? So theres things like that, theyre [peers] always like, I dont know. Shes so fine. I don t have a condom; I might have to raw dog it. According to the above evaluation, condom use may be determined by the perceived beauty of a potential female sex partner. Th e more beautiful or fine the woman, the less concern men might have a bout HIV and STD risk. Older men also reported inconsistent c ondom use. When asked why he did not use condoms consistently, a 51-year-old single man expressed his reasons for not using condoms. Ignorance. Dont have them. Too lazy to get them. The moment .You have to struggle with them sometimes if its not the rightTo me it [condom use] was like a waste of sperm. Prior to his HIV-positive diagnosis, a 54-year old man recalled his past feelings about condom use. I was young, nave, thinkin that could never happen to me. And the old sayin, that protection don t feel good. I like it raw in other words. And raw will get you messed up. Results show that while condoms are reco mmended as a public health strategy for preventing HIV/STI transmission during pene trative sexual intercourse, condom use may not be a typical behavior am ong U.S.-born heterosexual men who participated in this study. Several factors may create barriers to cond om use: a) trust in a sexual partner; b) use of alternate forms of birth control; c) perceived lack of sexual pleasure with condom
121 use; d) desire for spontaneity and; e) immediate unavailability of condoms during a sexual encounter. Women and Condom Use. Womens attitudes to condoms may also create a barrier to condom use among heterosexual couples. Men reported that thei r female partners may not encourage or address the issue of condom use giving them less impetus to use condoms. As a 20-yearold man explained, A high percentage of women don t tell us anything about putting condoms on. Cause thered be times I have sex and if I dont bring out the condom, she dont say a word. A 21-year-old father who is not ready to ha ve more children que stioned his partners motives for not supporting condom use in their relationship. To her, she feels you know because she loves me, but I love her but I dont love her to that point and you know [she says] lets try without a condom. No. So she feels t hat you know Im in love with you and this and that, she thinks or she is under the impression we are going to be together for the re st of our lives. I only met her 5 months ago so...I really do think she wants to have a kid, thats why she wants to do it raw [wit hout a condom] so bad. I think she just wants, she just wants to have my kid so bad that she just wants to do it without a condom, and I already have one daughter. You know, shes a handful by herself, so to me its, lets take it slow. Once the time comes when we are a little more stable, you know weve made it to that point of y ou know if we get a kid we can have a kid and all that stuff like that and I feel that much more comfortable, then okay. Another 25-year-old participant gave an acc ount of an encounter in which his casual female partner tried to convince hi m to have sex without a condom. You know I take that [condom use] seriously because there was a time, you know, we didnt ha ve no condoms and sh e was like, it was like she was giving me oral sex, right. And so I was looking for the condoms, you know I thought she hid them or something, and she said they ran out. And then she was like, you know, showing
122 me her pussy and I was like, Im sorry, youve got the wrong person! I say that because you know I take that very seriously and she was like, you know, she took se veral tests and said okay, thats nice but I was never you know, thats not my thing, you know, and so that was just...I dont know about her. Its like I can say, I can say yes she takes it seriously, but Im not sure, you know what Im saying, because were not in a relationship and, you know, she tried to pull a stunt on me. So, y ou know, thats a question right there. Similarly, a 29-year-old intervie wee shared his primary partne rs attitude to condom use. Well she dont mind not using condo ms. Usually, its me, for things that most of the stu ff like birth control and st uff like that, shes a little, I have to say that she real ly is against that. But when it comes to condoms and stuff like that you know, most of the time its me, you know, to make sure th at I have one, or state different rules like that. I dont th ink actually in my w hole life I dont think I ever met a female that would stop, hey, you have a condom? you know, I never really met a female that even said that before. A 45-year-old participant who is dating a dancer with a hi story of drug addiction is concerned about her resi stance to condom use. Now in my sexual lifestyle over the past 30 years, every woman I done ran across never wanted me to use contraceptives. They get upset over it. He shares the reasons women give him for not wanting to use condoms. Oh, I use birth control. You know and everything like that. It dont give you the same feelin. You know I told em, Well, if that should be your case, then Im the wrong person for you. Womens attitudes to condom use play a key role in male condom use behaviors. Negative attitudes to condoms held by female partners may hinder condom use in heterosexual relationships. This study reve als that both heterosexual men and women may have negative attitudes to condom use leading to high levels of unprotected sex within the study population.
123 Behavioral Health Alcohol and Substance Use. Among the U.S.-born male sample, behavioral health issues such as heavy alcohol use and substance abuse were commonly. St udy findings reveal that alcohol use was prevalent in the U.S.-born study population as 87% of U.S.-born male study participants admitted to intoxication in past and current experiences. Some participants reported heavy drinking and frequent intoxication. Men between the ages of 45-60 years tended to report a history of drug and alc ohol abuse. Critical to this inquiry is the finding that intoxication during sexual in tercourse was a prevalent behavior. Denial of alcohol impairment was commonly reported within th e behavioral health domain, as 46% of participants who admitted to intoxication dur ing sexual intercourse perceived that their behavioral skills relevant to safer sex were not impacted by alcohol or drug use. As such, some men perceived that they were able to think about and use condoms during sexual intercourse while high or intoxicated. With weed, you are slowing down, so you know, its like you got time just to be sitting there. Y ou might sit there for a little bit and get a condom, strap up, this and that. Another 27-year-old participant who claime d that he and his female partners are sometimes intoxicated prior to sexual interc ourse asserted that his condom use decisionmaking skills are not impaired. The difference between alcohol or any kind of recreational drug use, it basically, basically gets ri d of all of your inhibitions. It makes them smaller. The things th at are not important to you are lesser important. But you have to remain in that fact and that state that using condoms doesnt, it gets to the point where it doesnt just protect you from receivi ng anything, it protects you from having her pregnant. No matter, I mean, I can only speak for myself. Me myself, that is very, very important to me. That is something that I decided when I was very young that I wont have children until I am married. So no matte r what state I am in, that is
124 very, very important to me. So I, I can speak for myself, only myself included, that that is not a deterrent. A 25-year-old U.S.-born partic ipant attributed his ability to make safer sex decisions while drunk or high to his strong mind. Im more of the type, you know, if Im going drinking, Im at home, Im going to drink, Im not going nowhere, you know. When youre not at the house, you know. And even with sex, like if Im drunk or high, you know, I still know better. Like Im not going to let that take over my mind and you know go ahead and do it, like whatever. LikeIm a strong minded person. Men between the ages of 45-60 years provi ded insights on their experiences with substance abuse and impairment of their be havioral skills. 100% of U.S.-born men interviewed within this age gr oup reported that substance and alcohol use prior to sexual intercourse inhibits their ability to practice safer sex behaviors. A 45-year-old man with a history of alcohol abuse shared his experien ce with alcohol and its effect on his sexual decision-making. The people, my friends from a pr ogram, some of 'em come in and out...And it plays a big part because so me of my closest friends are alcoholics, as well as the girl that I'm dating. So ninety-nine percent of the people except for my son's mother, either rare abusive alcohol drinkers or drug user s. Some of the people that I deal with on a daily basis are still drug users and alcohol users. So, it plays a big part in my life even though I understood about what my mom taught about feari ng God, and everything like that. It's just that, you know, when I was in college and everything, everything was fraternity It wa s drink, it was doin' some bud, everything like that. So it's natural when I got out or when my friends got out, that's what they di d in college, so after a long day of work, why don't I come home and open up and drink some wine or some beer, smoke a bud and go to sleep. And then on the weekends, it's like okay, whatever. You know, that's the thang. Monday through Friday, you have people who like everyday people who work Monday through Fr iday, but once 6 o'clock get there...the weekend here, and sometimes it throw caution into the wind, regardless. And that's where a lot of people wake up on Monday, "Oh, my God. I can't beli eve on the way to work, that I
125 did that." I consider risky us e comin' with alcohol and drugs and can play a big part of not really thinkin'. "Okay, well I don't have to use a condom this time." HIV-positive men in the 45-60 age range reflec ted on their past drug and alcohol use and incarceration histories a nd attributed their HIV status to their past risky behaviors. Past relationships. Thats how I got HIV. Drinking and partying and not having protected sex. Here, there, everyday. For one thing, I used to be a dope boy when I was younger. So you went out there partying. Stack some money here. Stay in a motel 3 and 4 months like that. That party lifell do it too. You never look back. Oh, it aint gon happen. Pass me that Cavasier, that E & J, Cognac. Poll me up a blunt, lace me one. I been there and did that. ...Alcoholll tell you anything. W eed. You not clear. When you sober [thinking back], Awe man. Did I do that man? Who is that chick there man? Who is her? Y ou dont even know if you did it or not. Or how many you did. For real! Another 54-year-old particip ant related his experience with drug and alcohol abuse. Well, I'm gonna tell you how it star ted. When I was in prison, I was doin' 15 years. I did about 7 of them. And I used to jog a lot...I'ma try to make this quick as possible. And a guy...they have crack in prison, heroine...anything you want on the street, you can get in prison. So I was runnin', guy holla'd at me, told me to come here. So that's when I used to read about it. That was back in the 80's. It was good. That crack was out there then. And I went in his room. There was a homosexual sittin' on his bed, right? And he was in there, he went in th e bed, and pulled out a can...coke can with holes and ashes on it. I say, "Man, that's that stuff I been readin' about in the paper." He said, "Shut up, man." So I'll try anything, so "Try this, man." And I tried it and it had my sexually aroused also. And that's how I st arted. So ever since then, it been havin' an effect on me since I got ou t of prison. I used to drink. Since I take medication, I don't drink. Likewise, a 53-year-old recovering alcohol ic and drug abuser who is HIV-positive admitted to the debilitating eff ects of alcohol and drug use. Quite a bit. Because I remember my last relapse of...I had it about 6 years ago...and I relapsed. And the lady that I relapsed with jokingly said, "Well, I relapsed on ecstasy." And she say, "Well, he used ecstasy as like Viagra." 'C ause it was like a sexual stimulant.
126 And they would wanna run around and watch lights and stuff like that. And that really wasn't my c up of tea. I was interested in the um...'cause it would...and it would make her do things. Make her sexual...um...act better, you know, and more enjoyable. You know? So, yeah. Then the alcohol, I was a bi g drinker. I know it released people inhibitions and they were free to not be so shy and the same way with the women. And the other drugs like crack and everything, people was just outta co ntrol. 'Cause they'll be out there doing anything. I've heard some women 15 to 20 people a night. And theyre just tryin' to get the n ext one. And you can imagine being exposed to all kinds of germs. Haitian-born Men Multiple Sex Partners. Compared to their U.S.-born counterpart s, Haitian-born men were less likely to report partner concurrency. The results of this inquiry show that 71% of Haitian-born men reported monogamy. Young Haitian men were more likely to report serial monogamy. A 34-year old participan t shares his views on monogamy. Im the type of guy who likes to be with one person at a time. And unless its like that, I dont like to be with this person today and tomorrow. Because you dont know some individuals you meet, where theyve been. So for me, I th ink its better to be with a person for a long time before you ge t to the sexual intercourse. At least, thats how I was raised. Men over 45 years also tended to report high levels of commitment to their wives or partners. A 50-year-old married Haitian-bor n man stated that he would never be unfaithful to his wife. For my wife also, I say thanks to the God. Because maybe the same way I think the same way she think also. Okay, I dont go everywhere she go. I cant say one h undred percent she is perfect, but for this one I see, this one I knew. I know she keep her respect like I do. Another married interviewee expressed his vi ews about being faithful to one partner.
127 If you married, you got your wife, you got your husband, you don't go anywhere else...okay, that's it. That's the only real chance you got. Otherwise, whoever it is, y ou go with it, you just taking a chance. Haitian men were likely to report stea dy, monogamous relationships. Very few men in this subgroup reported partner concur rency. In fact, only two men admitted to having multiple sex partners. Therefore, in contrast to the U.S.-born sample, Haitian men were more likely to be married and less likely to report having multiple sex partners. Condom Use. Although Haitian men acknowledged the benefits of using condoms, this knowledge did not translate into consistent condom use. In fact, 71% (5) of single Haitian-born men (N=7) and 100% of married men (N=7) in the study sample reported inconsistent or no condom use. Study findings reveal that Ha itian-born heterosexual men may choose not to use condoms for several reason s including: a) trust in a female partner; b) perceived faithfulness in a relationship ; c) decreased sexual pleasure with condoms and; d) the natural feeli ng obtained during unprotected se xual intercourse. As a 20year-old participant stated: I think it [condoms] af fects sexual I mean erection a little bit. And then as in like, its not the same sensitivity. A young Haitian man of low socio-economic st atus and lower English literacy and proficiency explained his experience of cont racting a sexually transmitted infection after not using condoms. I did one mistake I didnt use condoms but luckily I wasnt infected I only got that thong that called um like when you keep waking up and peeing back and forth. Thats my first time. I never knew, I just wake up and start going back to the bathroom. At first I thought I drank water but no I aint drink no water. So I went to the doctor. He told me you got that little thi ng its not really like a big effect.
128 He gave me some medication and afte r that I always use one. Even though it didnt go in but I think the girl stuff was kind of her underwear was dirty and I just go t it like from a dirty thing. I had called her and said whats going on? And she said well I feel the same way too. I said well cause the underwear she was wearing wasnt hers. It was hers but her cousin used it thats how I got it. So I went to the doctor and they gave me medication and I got clean and I was clean. After that, I watch out man. But that was my first time. That was sc ary. I wasnt scared, scared but I was waking up in the middle of th e night. I was like what the hell is going on? Based on his account, this 22-year-old, sexuall y active Haitian man did not have a clear understanding of the biomedical transmission of STIs. While he realized that he had contracted a disease, the mode of transmission was not fully understood as he perceived that he contracted disease because his partners underwear was dirty. A 36-year-old Haitian-born man who has been involved in a sexual relationship with a steady sex partner for ove r 3 years expressed that condom use in his relationship is driven by levels of trust and pregnancy pr evention concerns rather than by HIV/STI prevention concerns. 'Cause I guess there'd never really be any kind of objection [to not using condoms]. "Okay, then well don't use it," or "Yeah, use it." Or, Okay, no. And I think the same feeling that I have, I think it's the same for her. It's just okay, hey, you know...I mean, I think given that we've been in th e relationship I guess three and a half years, so I think it's just more, "Okay, well we don't wanna have kids." So I think both of us really, I would say, have been tested, so we know exactly where we are. So I think now it's more, "Okay, I don't wanna have kids right now." And then, so... Likewise, a 32-year-old graduate student shar ed his feelings about condoms and the role trust plays in condom use decision-making. He also provided insight on the broader perception of condom use w ithin the Haitian culture. No, it's not easy to use because of the fact that it's foreign to your body in the first place. And then it diminishes what you're actually
129 trying to do. So, I would think t hat if you're only shagging, like people say, "Hey, I'm using this pr otective barrier just to do it." But if you're actually making love to somebody that you love, and you don't want her to get pregnant, it feels that there's always this layer between you and that person. So it's something that is just a sacrifice. If we were living in a world where it was disease free, condom wouldn't have to exist. But it's either you get used to it or you play that Russian roulette until you actually get a bullet. You know? So, it's not that easy to use, but I'm thinking that with technology they will have something that is like a micro meter size that it...you don't even feel, you just spray something and it's "Shhhh," that's it. You know? I almost always [use condoms]. The only time is probably when I was dating somebody for a long time, but even then, because of the fact that I didnt f eel like we needed to actually get anybody pregnant, so why use condoms. But if you actually take a Haitian that was like from a different part, let's say in a rural part where the mindset is mostly the more kids that you have the better bec ause some economic factor that's no longer the truth. Because in th e past, if you have 2, 3 kids you probably would be able to actually grow more crops, then sell more, and then get more money. Etcetera, etcetera. But now it's no longer the same question, because we're not growing anymore crops. But they still making as many babies as before. So they would come here and a lot of them probably would not use condoms. Because they believe th at, "Well, I'm supposed to...I don't like the feel of it. I didn't use it back home. A 55-year-old married participant who admitted to his infidelity, acknowledged his negative feelings toward condoms and gave an account of his failure to use condoms with an outside partner. To be honest with you, thats a man thing. The main problem I have with condom, Im not comforta ble with it. Then I have to get I got to have it. Thats one reason I stop messin around, because last time Id wanna go with out it, and when I put it on, I dont feel comfortable with it. So, to me, its not really enjoyment. So, it dont feel good with it .Oh, like I said, the reason why I didn't use it because I feel li ke...Number 1, I meet the first woman...the person I know, I know this person not too much really. Mess around with people, you know. I think it was safe for me to mess with her without it [condom]. She was like outside partner, but she was still kinda tied with me, so I just takin' a chance. I feel like, well, maybe I should've started us in' it with her, then I use it,
130 you know what I mean? But in th e beginning I start not to use it for a while. Yeah. He further commented on the unnatural feeli ng he gets when he uses condoms and difficulty finding condoms that are durable. Because, to me, it look like uh, fa ke. You know, its not real. It dont feel like its me. It look like something else. Im tryin to use the best they have. But see, a c ouple of times I had a problem with it, cause they be bustin on me and stuff. I be lookin for the largest and sometime they still mess up. When I wear em a certain time when I start usin em, they bust. Another participant attached a relig ious perspective to condom use. According to my belief, you know Catholic church doesnt believe in the protection that science gi ves us. We got our own protection. We can talk together how we can make it. Study findings reveal that condom use ma y not be a preferred sexual behavior among Haitian-born men in the study sample. Several factors related to condom use emerged in the exploration of condom use behaviors among Haitian men: a) trust in a female partner; b) perceived faithfulness in a relationship; c) decreased sexual pleasure with condom use and concerns about the aesthe tic feel of condoms a nd; d) the natural feeling obtained during unprotected sexua l intercourse. In ad dition, Haitian men conceptualize and rationalize condom use within the contex t of the Catholic religion wherein condom use is not endorsed. Women and Condom Use Similar to the U.S.-born sample, w ithin the Haitian-born study population, condom use is also driven by womens atti tudes to condoms. A 22-year-old aspiring musician described his experience with cont racting an STI after his female partner insisted against using a condom.
131 sometimes the girl says put it in, put it in. And pap, pap we didnt go all the way but the tip of my penis touch the girl around her area. It didnt go in it just to uch the area and I think her area she didnt clean it and I felt like something was biting me, like mosquitoes biting my thing. I feel like I dont feel right peeing back and forth for no reason. So I went to the doctor and he told me I had that thing. I was like oh crap. Another participant, 55 years of age, described the ease wi th which he convinced his extramarital sex partner not to us e condoms during sexual intercourse. Yeah, some ask me to [use a condom], but sometime I say, Awe, no baby. You know I dont like it. They like, Okay! You know? I mean, but its true. Behavioral Health Alcohol and Substance Use. Alcohol and substance use were not found to prevalent behaviors among Haitianborn men. Most Haitian men reported no or mi nimal alcohol or drug use. One 32-yearold participant reported that alcohol use is frowned upon within Haitian culture and because there is no legal drinking age in Ha iti, children grow up experiencing small amounts of alcohol at an early age making alcohol less appea ling and mysterious in later years. Same way that my mom actually opened my...I mean, just like talked about human reproductive systems, etcetera, with me or how people actually just like come about, is the same way that she did not try to make alcohol taboo. And because I'm from a French type of base culture, a kid that is 10, 11 years old on Sundays could actually have a small amount of wine while eating. So it wasn't something I was totally fo reign to, like, "Oh my God, I'm not supposed to touch any alcohol and everything." And I think that's the reason why you don't see the issues that we have here with students binging on alcohol co mpared to other places in the world. Because you've been with alcohol all your life, you know the danger of it and then you actually know that, "Okay, I drank it with my mom. Okay, when I'm 15, 16, I could actually drink a beer." Because at 16, the drinki ng age...there's not really any drinking age in my country, but you know better not to actually become an alcoholic, you know? Especially when it comes to
132 drugs. This is something that is frowned upon in my country as well. So, it never really played a on my part. Within the Haitian male study sample, one 55-y ear-old participant reported alcohol use prior to sexual interc ourse and noted the inhibitive a nd mind-altering effect of alcohol and other drugs. Let me tell you somethin'. Let me tell you somethin'. When you really...I don't know about nobody el se, but I'm tellin' the fact...I like to tell the truth. When you use alcohol or drugs, you don't really care about none of that [condom use]. You know, 'cause all you here about is, "I'm gonna enjoy myself. I'm gonna be havin' fun." And just goin' off. Bec ause the first thing you gon' think in your mind is you don't have it[a condom]. If you don't really into it, like using it all the time...that means you don't have it. You gon' say, "Awe, that's okay. It ain't gon' hurt one time." It's like, "I'll get over it." And if you have it some time, you might say, "Well..." Or you might have one, 'cause this happened to me before. I might have one the first time I use it, then I run with her like that. "Okay, now I'm out. I don't have no more. So let's do it without it. Okay. So you don't really focus these things. Though the men (U.S.-born and Haitianborn) in this study acknowledged the benefits of using condoms, 72% (21) particip ants reported inconsistent condom use into their sexual relationships. Severa l intrapersonal and contextual factors seem to influence condom use among U.S.-born and Haitian-born heterosexual men. Some men complained about the lack of sexual pleasure when using condoms. A recurrent theme around condom usage was the concept of trust where by the more a man trusts his partner, the less likely he is to use condoms. Likewise, me n who perceive that their female partners are faithful are less likely to use condom s. In addition, condom use was found to be motivated by pregnancy prevention rather th an HIV/STI protection. Other barriers to condom use were immediate un availability of condoms a nd the belief that condoms remove the spontaneity from sexual interc ourse. Among Haitian men, additional barriers
133 to condom use included the perception that condoms are unnatural and are not endorsed by religious beliefs. In addition, womens attitu des to condom use seem to play a critical role in condom use decision-making within heterosexual relationships. Several men reported that their female partners held negative attitudes toward condoms giving them even less motivation to use condom s during sexual intercourse. In terms of emergent themes around beha vioral health issues, the theme of uninhibited behavioral and cognitive skill s emerged among U.S.-born men who reported alcohol and/or drug use prior to sexual activity. U.S.-born men in the younger age ranges (18-44 years) reported a perceived ability to cognitively and behavior ally apply safe sex behaviors while under the influence of dr ugs and alcohol. Conversely, U.S.-born men within the 45-60 age range reported the inhibitive and mind-altering effects of alcohol that significantly affect safe r sex behavioral skills. Haitia n-born men were less likely to report any alcohol or drug use. This low pr evalence of substance abuse issues may be related to cultural norms that ascribe negative attitudes toward alcohol and drug use resulting in less participation in these substance use behaviors. Question 3: What cultural norms influ ence sexual behaviors among black men who identify as heterosexual? A key component of this inquiry was an exploration of the cultural norms that may influence HIV risk and protective behaviors among U. S.-born and Haitian-born heterosexual men. Findings reveal that social, ecological, and cultural factors play a role in mens conceptualization and adoption of HI V risk and protective behaviors: 1) family attitudes and communication about sexual beha vior; 2) peer norms; 3) hip-hop culture and; 4) cultural attitudes to homosexuality and bisexuality.
134 U.S.-born Men Family Attitudes and Communi cation about Sexual Behavior. Of the U.S.-born male participants in th is study, 60% (9) reported that they never discussed condom use with their parents and/or family members A 20-year-old young man commented on the risky se xual behaviors he observed am ong his father and brothers and his beliefs that his personal religious faith prevents him from adopting similar behaviors. Oh, my family. Well, speaking from my family, my father is...he's a player himself. I'm not gon' lie. As I said, I am the fi fth child out of ten kids. And my dad was gettin' it on. You know? And my brothers, theyre so sexually ac tive. So it's like, you know, it's kinda funny. And him coming, you k now, 'cause my brother comes from the islands. And he came to the U.S., and the first thing he was feigning for is some women. "I need some women, I need some women, I need some women."And me, it was kinda...it's kinda hard. It was kinda hard, because I'm real ly different from everybody in my family. I'm more humble, wise type. But I'm funny, also. But I'm just so humble and wise. But e verybody in my family is just so...whatever they can get, they can get. The only person who stands out in my family is my mother and my two little brothers, because we are so religiously str ong. You know, it's that we don't stand against most of that stuff. But as far as my father and my brothers, man, they get it on. A 21-year-old father reflected on the lack of family communication about condoms use and HIV prevention. Seemingly, this lack of family dialogue led to him and his younger cousin experiencing father hood at a fairly young age. No one really said anything. Everybody says the same thing My cousin, one of my little cousin s was the main one that was just like hed been with this girl for a couple years, and he used to be like, man, it feels so much goode r without a condom, and this and that, and I used to tell him all the time to strap up with a condom, and now his girl is pre gnant I think it was for one thing, I think my dad was nervous about talking to us about it. My mom really had too much on her plate to really deal with trying to talk about it, so she didnt, I mean they just never did. I think my
135 dad said one thing and I was like 18, like you know, use a condom when you have sex or so mething like that. But he never actually, you know, got into detail, you know, or talked about it, or anything like that, so. He continued to share that he received c ondom education in school and from peers. I would say school, just bei ng around friends, you know, and growing up the way you grow up, you know you always find out about different stuff. You always find out about sex no matter what. Likewise a 26-year-old student reported that his family taught monogamy and abstinence until marriage. They have instilled in us, you know, one partner, you know, its always there to wait until marriage, you know, even though thats kind of unrealistic these days! Similar sentiments were echoed by a 29-year -old participant who noted his fathers silence about sexual issues a nd mothers warnings not to get a girl pregnant. We never talk. I have a father, been in my life my 29 years and you know, we never talked about it [condoms]. Very church-going people, so they tend to not discus s some of those type issues because you arent supposed to be doing it. He recalled the external venues whereby he le arned about condom use. He attributed his early initiation into fatherhood to the lack of sex educati on in the home environment. I learned about condoms, um, I learned actually through researching at school, you know I think everybody takes a health class that, you know, is going to give you a little information about protection and STIs and stuff like that, so I guess thats pretty much where I learned my, um, besides my mom, you know, would tell you, you know, tell me the dont get a girl pregnant, you shouldnt be having sex and stuff like that, but um, nothing in depth, so the majority of the info rmation I learned from school in programs like health and stuff. So um, me personally, I was raised with the old abstinence religion ty pe issue. And actually I was talking with my sister about this earlier. We both had our children at a young age, 16 and 17. And I think if there was more emphasis on prevention, you know, with condoms and stuff and just a not a message of just abstinence and not to do it, then I th ink it, it would
136 have been, things would probably have been a little different. And I teach, well me, my personal belief s, Im going to teach my son, you know, to have something available if whenever he needs, and stuff like that, so. He wont have any issue, you know, HOPEFULLY he wont have any issues, some of the issues that I ran into when I was growing up, so. I definitely want to keep open communication when it comes to that type stuff. Not only does 29-year-old college graduate and father acknowledge a lack of family communication about condoms and HIV pr evention, he also felt pressured by his uncles to initiate sexual activity at a young age. My family is like hardcore ancie nt. Like they need to start usin condoms. I dont know what theyre thinkin. I have an uncle who has like seven kids with seven di fferent women The first time I ever heard about a condom, I think I was in I was like in elementary school. And it was my ol der cousins. And they were just like, You need to get a rubber. Im like, Get a rubber? Im thinkin like rubber band or someth in. And that was the first time they told me about condoms. T hat was probably and then after that, it was school. Like I said, when I said I was pr essured before when I was younger and when I said I pressured into sex, this wasn't from my peers. This was from my uncles. I have 4 uncles and they've always pressured me into sex, but they' ve never pressured me into the use of condoms or anything like that. [T hey would say] "Hey, you gotta have sex. Have sex, have sex." They've never said anything to me about condoms ever. I really don't th ink any of my...Well, I have 4 uncles. I know for a fact 2 of th em cheat on their wives. Well, one of them is not even married. I don't know if he's ever gonna get married. He's the one with the seven kids with seven different women. And then my other uncle, hi s wife just divorced him. So those 2, they just runnin' ar ound like baby makin' machines. Another 25-year-old par ticipant described his fathers failure to communicate with him. My dad (sigh) like my dads a working man, like he works 24/7. Like hes always on the go. He dont have time for nobody. Like, he talked, like we probably talked like not even ten minutes, you know, he started to see how y ou were doing. So we dont really have that relationship, like you know, oh lets go out and do this and that. So hes just busy-busy, ca ll you when he has time. But he
137 never he, I remember him talki ng about it [sex] like you know once in a blue, hes more like: Stay out of trouble. Family communication around sexual beha vior and condom use seems even less prevalent in the lived experiences of men in the 45-60 age range. As one HIV-positive 54-year-old participant i ndicated, when he was young there was no knowledge of condoms. When I came up, there was no such thang as using condoms. I was raised by my grandparents. Thats real old school. You know how that is. Thats how nobody talk about condoms. I only heard about condoms when HIV already done hit and messed up a lot of lives. A 45-year-old father of two claimed he lear ned about condoms from his brother who died from AIDS. My mother and father my father condom, never. Never, never. They didnt know what a condom wa s. But my mother had to work. My brother contracted AIDS. Besi des him teaching me, she was the one that actually wanted to know more about it herself. Cause I said when they were growing up, it [AIDS] wasnt somethin that they worried about. The most they ever had to worry about is contracting, not herpes, but what is syphilis. That's basically all they worried about. You know, so the concept of the AIDs and everything was somethin' me and my mother both learned about. She was also...talked to my ot her sisters and them about usin' contraceptives and stuff. And everything about that once...what happened with my brother. Like th at saying, in the 80's it was a new thang. A 54-year-old HIV-positive participant expres sed his discomfort discussing condom use and HIV with his family. We dont talk about it [condom use] Since they know about me, they dont never talk like that. Cause they always ask me, my sisters, my nieces, and my daughters, theyll say, A I using condoms? I tell them, Yeah. I just dont feel comfortable talkin to my family members. Which I should, but I dont.
138 The study findings reveal that parental/f amily interactions and communications around HIV prevention and risk reduction are virtually non-existen t. Men who reported minimal sexual dialogue within the family not ed that the discussion primarily centered on abstinence. Therefore, children obtain sex educat ion from avenues that are external to the family unit. Families are not educating their children and adolescents about HIV risk and protective behaviors. Parental religiosity em erged as a barrier to sexual dialogue and fathers often fail to communicate with their sons. The dearth of communication seems to have a generational effect whereby subsequent generations seem to be disengaged from the sexual behaviors of their children. Peer Norms. Findings reveal that peers e ngage in risky sexual behavi ors such as inconsistent condom use and concurrent sex partners. Even though men reported that their peers discuss HIV and AIDS and perceive it to be a serious disease, their sexual behaviors do not reflect their HIV knowledge or perceptions of the disease. Condom Use. 60% (9) of U.S.-born male study participants repor ted that their peers did not like to use condoms and used condoms inconsistently. A 20-year-old student described his peers sexual behaviors. Well yes its something I talk about with my boys. Because you know, me being from the environment and the neighborhood I was from, oh my gosh. When I was a 5th grader, most of my homeboys was havin sex already at the 5th grade. Yeah, they knew how to touch the women body in the right way and everything like that. And it was really crazy. We tal ked about it [HIV/AIDS]. Most of em do get scared. They are afraid that they do have it. Most of em refuse to take the test bec ause they are afraid if they do have it that they might end up killing th emself. Like, for example, I had a friend...he was a real good friend of mine. We knew each other since the third grade and he had sex w ith this girl. I told him, you know to go and get it tested 'cause the girl he had sex with has
139 been sleepin' around with...thi s was back in high school, and he...the girl slept with mostly half of the football team. And so..also, me and my homeboys, we told him, "Gotta get it tested." And to find out, he did get test ed and he was positive and end up shootin' the girl and went to jail for the rest of his life. However, he reports that most of his fr iends struggle with condom use. Some of them struggle with it [condom use]. Some of them really do struggle with it. Cause some of them they feel as if you put on a condom, youre not getting 100% feeling of it. Most of em struggle with it. Likewise, a 45-year-old participant stated th at his peers have nega tive attitudes towards condom use. His friends say: Its [condom use] as waste of time and a waste of money. They like to, as they call it, raw dog. Referring to his peers attitudes to HIV/AIDS he states, They not worried about it. Never happen to them. They know the women that they messin with. They know that they not doin nothin and everything like that. You know, nave. Just cause it feel good dont mean it aint gon kill you down the line. Multiple Sex Partners. Over 70% (11) of U.S.-born men reported that their friends and associates tend to have multiple sex pa rtners. As one participant reported: All of them [friends] seem like, y ou know, Im going to talk to this girl, Im going to talk to that gi rl, and they are itching to hump, I mean, they do what they want to do. A 20-year-old participant articulated his beli efs about multiple partners among his peers. We could get as many [women] as we want. Some guys actually had bets to see how much girls th ey could sleep with in the night. And yes, African American males they do have multiple females. But really, it is the male but sometimes you really put all the blame on the male, because sometim es the female open themselves up to the male. Several interviewees expressed their be lief that men engaged in risky sexual behaviors as a means of occupying their sp are time. When asked why he thought his peers had multiple sex partners, a 26-year-old man stated:
140 I mean just to fit in, I guess. A lot of times they dont have anything to do with their time, you know, they need something to do. Another 29-year-old par ticipant remarked that his peers of ten need a way to appease their boredom. They find it more interesting to have more than one partner, when it gets mundane being in a monogam ous committed relationship so that, you know, most of them ta lk about how they get bored, you know, being in, you know just one relationship. Of middle socio-economic status and a coll ege graduate, a 27-year-old man gave an account of the conceptualization of relations hips and multiple sex partners from the perspective of his peers. So, it's just not a norm, unfortunatel y. Especially in the African American community, you know, it' just...Even men that I know that's in love with their significant other, you know, it's still...they don't have that whole...this is th e person you're gonna be with, but they still fool around with other people and just say, you know, I'll worry about that once I'm married. It's almost like if you're not married, it's free will. Once you get married, you know, you know, thats the time to do that. And this is not just I know All these are my college buddies, you know, so they're all professionals now. This is from doctors, from lawye rs, to like, you know, who knows what they're doing now. And none of them are married and all the not married ones, you know, like one of my friends is actually He just became a lawyer in South Fl orida and he's actually thinking about bringing up his girlfriend so he can have that whole, "Now I'm making a hundred fifty grand a ye ar, let me experience life a little and not be tied down by this girl who gives him nothin since like, since we were Freshmen in college .I call it like he wants to be a man whore .Unfortunat ely, thats our community and some women know, some women dont, some women are just very nave and dont wanna believe it. When asked to explain his thoughts on why so me men may have multiple sex partners he openly responded: Well, you ever heard the saying, "Show me one beautiful woman, and I'll show you a man who's tired of sleeping with them?" But like a lot of us are still y oung, you know...none of us...like...you
141 know...not even 30 yet. There not ju st...just not ready to be tied down and stuff. And they just so much more to explore, and then it's just...and I don't mean to be rude or vague but the always say, "There's no pussy like new pu ssy." I apologize for myU.S.-born men between 45-60 years of age also reported the practice of concurrent sex partners among their peers. A lot of my friends think that wome n are put on earth just to please men. And some of em, yeah, they might love one woman, but if they find somebody else who gon give it to them that night, they go with her. He further exclaims, but my friends, hey! Women are put on earth to please us. When I hit em with the Bible, they quote me back that, God created Eve to please Adam. That true? Thats their beliefs. A 51-year-old participant w ho reported to having monogamous relationships sees his peers as stupid and attributes thei r promiscuous behaviors to ignorance, lack of knowledge, and tryin to be players. Normative peer sexual behaviors reflect risk-taking such as inconsistent condom use and multiple sex partners. Peer norms may have a significant influence on the adoption of risky and or preven tive behaviors and must be co nsidered within the context of HIV prevention. Hip-Hop Culture. Results of the inquiry show that 80% (12) U.S.-born me n perceive that the media and hip-hop music have a negati ve influence on their sexual behaviors and communicate negative messages to the black community. Th e data show that hip-hop culture plays a significant role in black male identity and thei r conceptualization of sexual behaviors. In fact, study participants acknowledged that hiphop often promotes profanity, promiscuity and the degradation of women. As a 20-year-old man stated:
142 Oh, man. As far as hip hop, I for one don't think hip hop is really a good inspiration for anybody right now. Because all they do is, they do promote sex to the fullest. Now back in the days, it was ridiculous. But now, it kinda slowed down a little bit, but still, no matter how bad it slowed down, it's still promoting sex, period. Like, back in the days you didn't hear nothin' but, "Oh," you know..."Stick it in there, stick it in there. Drop it down low. Duh, duh, duh." But nowadays, you hear more of...I guess because of how strong the virus is gettin', most people are startin' to...well, more people are positive and more people are actually telling a story about it. But in my opinion...l ike myself, I hardly listen to rap. Like, if you ever hear me listen to hip hop, it's like once in a blue moon...because it promotes sex. One reason, because I have 4 sisters, and I refuse to let any guy call them, exc use my language, a bitch or a hoe. And that's what hip hop is all about. A 19-year-old father described the infl uence of hip-hop music and music videos. All them women, shaking their booti es, that, that do affect people. Because that gives you the urge to just urge to just want to have intercourse and everything, you know. A 21-year-old father also commented on the negative impact of hip-hop music and especially music videos. Hip-hop culture maybe because of the videos and you know the video girls, and then you know you got to have THIS type of girl and such and such, and you know, it puts pressure on people to go out and grab the baddest chic, and the baddest chic be the one that got something, and other stuff like that. Its just, I dont know, I think kind of how hip-hop focuses on it[sex] like, it makes it seem like they, theyre not really tryi ng to send a message to you, but just their videos and their words, you know, puts in the kids minds like its okay, yeah, like they think thats so cool because this person is rapping about it, this pers on made a video about it, such and such. A 26-year-old student voiced similar concerns. Um, I mean, hip-hop music videos scantily clad women all the time dancing, half naked, it seems li ke you rarely see artists who come out with something other than that has a topic other than sex because, you know, obviously sex sell s. So, with these, with this all in the media, you know, TV, radio, youre always hearing: Sex, sex, sex sex, sex, sex, so I thin k it affects your, um us as black
143 men to get involved, the sexual behaviors, and usually at an early age. Another 29-year-old participan t partially attributed the spread of HIV to the media. The media. I think the media has been, um, assisted in the spread actually. I think the whole question of the, you know, you know, being, you know, I think a lot of ki ds are influenced to have sex to, you know, approve, to be cool, or whatever, and I think the media actually, um, has a part in that, and sex sells, and its a big money maker, and so you know they are going to make sure they have a big hand in that. Hip-hop is a big, is a big influence for a lot of black males because its one of th e first avenues that gave a lot of black males voices and stuff like that. But then, the mainstream hip-hop is not really conscious of that, and its pretty much about making the money and stuff like that, and then promoting, you know, promiscuous life with male s, a lot of fema les and stuff like that, so, um, it definitely plays a role in you know, guys not using protection and stuff like that I believe. Men between the ages of 45-60 expressed concern for the influence of hip-hop on the younger black male population. One 53-year-old participant expresse d his belief that the hip-hop also promotes drug use. You know with the rap songs, they always have the ladies dancing, you know, in suggestive outfits. And so, you know, thats part of the culture in the hip-hop. See, the hi p-hop culture seems to promote drug use to a certain extent es pecially the weed smoking. Referring to hip-hop, a 54-year-old participan t of low socio-economic status exclaimed that hip-hop messes up everything. It just messes up everything. Makes a young man black men think its alright to have [sex] from behind, back, mouth, ear without protected. Not really thinkin abou t the consequence of someones life. Just out there for the money. Dont care what they say or how they say it on this music these day s. And thats how the epidemic just went, Boom! A 45-year-old participant be lieves that hip-hop demeans women causing men to lack respect for them.
144 Oh, hip hop culture influence sexual ac tivity because, fir st of all, it parade a lot of women in half nude clothes and stuff like that. And lettin' them know that, you know, women who dance hip hop automatically wanna go...you know, b ecause they like the music or anything like that...gonna automatica lly be sexually active after they leave a club or listen to some music or somethin' like that. You know, as far as me, you k now, in the hip hop culture...and I actually DJ. So Some of these people idolize these people so they wanna be like -these people on the video. Or they see a, 'xcuse my language, a big butt girl, they automatically think if this girl gon' dance like this, I would probably think that's what she gon' do for me in the bed. You know, not to say that most hip hoppers demean women, but they do. You know, they be like Oprah and Montell and all them, they put it on there how some of the hip hop rappers, you know, the word, the fema-....I don't use this word, I say female dog. They us e that word a lot. Or they use the H-word a lot. And our persona of a young black man come up thinkin' women are nothin'. Just like I said. Just like some of my friends did the same thang. Women are here to please them. And they ain't nothin' but female dogs and H's. You know, but I tell'em, I was like, "You were actually born from a female dog or a H. What do you think of that?" "Hey, dog. Don't go there. That's different." "How is that diff erent? That's still a woman." Research findings suggest that hip-hop culture may have a de leterious effect on sexual behavior, sexual identity and defin itions of womanhood and manhood in the black community. U.S.-born men believe that of hip-hop culture conveys negative sexual images and messages that are especially im pactful during the impressionable years of a young mans life. They perceive the message s communicated by hip-hop to be highly negative and have a significant influence on sexual behaviors and perceptions among black men. Attitudes and Beliefs about Ho mosexuality and Bisexuality. U.S.-born male study participants ex pressed negative attitudes toward homosexuality and bisexuality. Similar to the findings from previous studies (Stokes & Petersen, 1998; Brooks et al, 2005), homose xuality was perceived as taboo, bizarre,
145 confused, irreligious, and in sulting to black masculinity. A 20-year-old man expressed his homophobic beliefs: Its [homosexuality] a spirit. So if you can get that spirit of lesbianism, homosexualism out of you, then you wont have to have that problem. But most people, th ey don't say...I have a real strong problem with it, because most pe ople know that it's bad. One thing that these people don't do is pray about that prob lem that they have about bein' lesbian, hetero...whatever. So, my problem is if you guys...if they just prayed mo re about the problem that they have, they would really see that t hat's not the way to go. And like I don't...I'm sorry to say, but I'm really homophobic He describes a negative experience with a gay man. Because I'm not gon' lie, I do go to the gym a lot, I do work out, and I like to keep myself well-preserved, and guys tend to like that I was in class, I had this white gay guy like me. And I'm playin' basketball and you know, when we box up on each other and get the ball and stuff and playin' ball with this guy and I didn't even know he was gay...he just, and I'm all up on him tryin' to get the ball and he's actually likin' it. And then some of'em, th ey'll just walk by and just slide their hand on your behind and I don' t like that. And really that, that really gets me pissed off. I would literally knock somebody out if they ever touched me that wa y. Like, I don't care if I go to jail for it. But just through that experience, I just don't like it. I hate it. A 25-year-old participant attributed his negative attitude toward homosexuals to his familys religious va lues and beliefs. There was a kid in the school that was gay. Like I didnt even know the kid was gay, but they was picking on him, and he was getting in fights. He was beating them up. He was running home, and it was like, man, hes gay. Like that ju st blows me. He likes dudes. He likes boys. Like, you know what Im saying, and like because growing up, I never seen that, you know. And it was like, you know, like my dad, like you know, when he sees something like that, you know he will say something crazy, like you know what Im saying. So me seeing him, how he looked at it, I looked at it that way, too, like you know. And then like, you know, me being in a spiritual household, like you know, my mother, she was a religious woman, so she always, you know, she alwa ys did things according to the Bible. You know what Im saying? And we didnt have no gay friends coming to the house, you know what Im saying, my mama wasnt with that, like you know my dad, even my dad, so you know what Im saying?
146 A 54-year-old father of three with a hi story of incarceration also expressed his homophobic attitudes. I dont even wanna have nothin to do with them man. Period. I know some of them Well to be honest with you, I have 3 daughters. When I got out, I found out that one of my daughters was gay. Real pretty. I wish I brought pictures of them. And it kinda blowed me a little bit. So what can I say. Thats my daughter, so I just accept it. Expressing his feelings toward homose xuals, a 19-year-old father stated: I mean, I dont think, I dont think nothing wrong, Im still be cool, its just dont shake my hand. I don t want to be s een, I dont want to be seen with you! The study also found that within the samp le, U.S-born men of all age groups had strong feelings against the down low behavior. In fact some men expressed that the down low may be a causative factor in th e spread of HIV in the black community. I think its disgusting. I think its just ungodly and just wrong, because I dont know, in my opi nion, its like y oure keeping secrets. Another participant shared his thoughts about the down low. I think it passes I [HIV]t, really, because I dont think its right for you to lie to your partner or someone youre going to have sex with about your sexual orientations. Similarly, a 53-year-old HIV-positive partic ipant described his observation of down low behavior while he was in jail. Another reason why HIV is so prevalent, especially with the women, because a lot of the guys mess with men and then they bring it to their women. I went to prison overnight and these guys were talkin about their women and all these manly things. And then some gay guy came in and about all ten of them left the table and went to the gay guy and was doi ng this gay guy but yet, they were talkin about their gi rlfriends and all this.
147 Describing his disgust for men who are on th e down low or engage in homosexual situational sex a 27-year-old college graduate stated: [Down low is] someone whos havin g sex with a male or doing homosexual actions but doesnt beli eve that hes gay. Like a lot of people in prison are like that. Li ke, Yeah, I suck his dick, but Im not a gay man. I hate those faggots. Haitian-born Men Family Attitudes and Communi cation about Sexual Behavior. Among Haitian-born men, family discussions and communication about HIV prevention and condom use was virtually non-e xistent as 79% of th is subgroup reported little or no family communication about sexua l issues. Younger men reported that their parents and family members were reluctant to discuss sexual issues within the family unit. Any discussion about sexual behavior centered on pregnancy prevention. Haitian fathers admitted to being embarrassed and afraid to discuss sex and STI prevention with their children. Many Haitian men in the samp le indicated that c onversations about HIV and AIDS were typically initiated when a relative or friend died of AIDS. Referring to the lack of family comm unication about HIV and AIDS, a 20-yearold college student stated: They dont really they dont really talk about it like that. I guess, like, since we dont really have that conversation I guess, like, we dont even have a open conversation about that as in like, well aside from occasional, there mi ght be some testing on site on campus or at some, like, social community service events. Stuff like that. It never bar ely to never comes up. He recalled one of the few times his family discussed HIV and AIDS was when his uncle died of AIDS. When asked to describe what his family has said about HIV/AIDS he replied:
148 Well, what have they said about it? Well, nothin really. Except that last year, I had a uncle and abo ut 5 years ago that died. I was younger. Like, in 98 he passed out and then last year when I was like, just getting started about like 2 years ago. I just started havin girlfriends and stuff like that whatever. And thats when my mom told us that he actually died of HIV. A 36-year-old Haitian-born entrepreneur re called a similar experience while growing up. I dont think, you know weve ever re ally, I would say, really took time and really discussed I think we had maybe one friend we knew who died of AIDs, but th e conversation never really, you know, in terms of open conversa tion there was no conversation on that. Similarly, a 20-year-old partic ipant recalled having little to no family discussion about HIV and AIDS. Seemingly, the information communicated was inadequate and even incorrect. we havent had nothing, no conversation about sex or diseases. They like theyre like they know its out there. They taught us a little bit of stuff like, peopl e who have sex have HIV. Theyll like, if a news come in, stuff li ke that, thats when theyll say something about it. But never something like, well we sat down one-on-one or as a family talk about it. Thats why Im hoping to change with my family grow ing up in the near future. External avenues of HIV prevention edu cation was a common theme among research participants. As this 18-year-old indicated, his mother was reluctant to address the issue and tended to be somewhat vague in the me ssages she communicated, so most of his HIV knowledge came from his physicist (physician). My mother is the type that dont really talk about condom usage, but she always told me to if you ar e, to use it in order to protect yourself from getting a child at th e moment, and also there is STDs out there The main person that talked to me about it was my physicist. Before I came here, she was like, Oh yeah, there are girls out there. Yes, I know y ou guys are gonna get involved with them, so make sure you use prot ection and make sure you talk to them about it first.
149 Participants also reported their percep tions of the barriers to sex communication among Haitian families: a) parents are in de nial; b) parents are busy working and have less time to speak to their children; c) pa rents depend on schools to teach children about sex and STI protection and; d) parents are unc omfortable discussing the issue of sex and STI prevention. In fact, sex education within the family was stigmatized and viewed as taboo among Haitian families. The high prevalence of religious conservatism within the Haitian community further prevents open dialogue about sexual behaviors. My parents and I never had a sex talk at all they dont wanna think that their kids are having s ex. Also, theyre always working. My parents will work from 3-11 every single day. So coming from middle school around 3:30, I was by myself...well, with my siblings, by ourselves til about 11 and stuff like that. So we were all alone almost all the time. So we never had the chance to talk about it, I guess. And growing up, as we grew up, I guess they thought school would teach us or somethin' like that. But my father and I, and my mom never had anything about sex. But my uncle, actually not my uncle, my dad's uncle...Actually, when I was 15, he sat me down at the table, and he told me that if you're gonna have sex, you should wear a condom because it's gonna protect you from this and this and that. So that's my uncle...that was only one time for about 30 minutes. It wa s a pretty good talk, long talk as far as guys. But my mom and I never. My father never. Thats (condom use) something you dont ask growing up. You know, I never heard my parent talk ed about that because I grew up in a Christian home. So my nature was church, church, church, church...education and then you get married, that's it. Job and marriage, but never heard about that. But I've come to be education on condom actually th rough school. And also through some friends who talked about it. And also education that they have out there through community out reach or television ads, as well. So, that's how I've come to know... Another participant shared his experience le arning about sex and HIV prevention outside of the home environment. I can honestly say growing up in my household, we never had a conversation about sex. I learne d about it once I well actually I
150 learned by looking at TV. And also once I came to here, to University. Thats pretty much the way I learned about the different type of disease and things of that nature. I guess they automatically assume that you going to know what to do when that chance come. And also, it could also be like a comfort level. They really may not be comfortable ta lking to their kids about that particular issue. They figure that when that time comes, youll know. Participants reported that Haitian families are more likely to emphasize abstinence than STI prevention. A 36-year-old respondent stated: Okay, now this is the other side as far as the culture. I think, like, sexual conversations like that, I don't think really...ever really take, you know, took place. In certain instance, Okay, you should use it or dont use it. I think they on ly say, Okay, well you dont have sex. And I think that's the only thing that he taught you. But other than that as far as what to use, dont use condoms. No Due to the diverse age groups included in the study sample, the researcher had the opportunity to probe parents about sex co mmunication with their children. Parents reported that while they understood the im portance of sex education, they were uncomfortable and embarrassed to address th e issue with their children. Moreover, they held strong religious beliefs about abstin ence before marriage and did not think it necessary to educate their children beyond emphasizing th e abstinence only message. A 50-year-old father of five exclaimed, In the Haitian culture, we embarrassed! Embarrassed to talk to the kids about that (condom use). But its not because we dont know. We know whats best for them, but we dont do it. I dont know if maybe 1% or 2% of Haitian do it. But most Haitian dont. The lack of communication about se x and condom use is a generational phenomenon among Haitian families and a recurrent theme throughout the study. As a 58-year-old father reported, as a child he could not discus s sex in the presence of his
151 family while growing up. Likewise, he does not discuss sexual be havior or HIV/STI prevention beyond abstinence with his children. When you think about that (family discussion about condom use), in front of my family, stuff like that, they used to beat you up, because you not supposed to A 54-year-old father echoed similar comments. I dont encourage them to use this condom, nothing. I always, because we always talk about how to be committed. You know that? I always, because in Haiti, Ha itian families not easy to talk sex [with] their kids. When y ou live in a big country, your mind...you got a open mind on everything. That's why I always teach my kids how to preserve themself, you know? I always tell them, if you want to get sex, it's better to married with someone first. Because Bible is agai nst going to a woman without marriage. It say sin is a kind of fornication. You know? You know what fornication means? It's a po ison on your body. I always tell them, it's better to get somebody to get married, clear your void, fornication, adultery, thing like that I don't tell them to use any protection. Peer norms. Condom use. Similar to the U.S.-born sample, Haitian-born men reported that their peers held negative at titudes toward condom use. The perception that condoms detract from sexual pleasure as a barrier to condom use was a recurring theme in this inquiry. Remarking about his peers percepti ons of condoms, a 28-ye ar-old entrepreneur shared: The majority of them say naw they dont like using it cause it doesnt feel right. Or I get they wont ejaculate fast enough per se. Another participant shared his peers views on condoms. I think most definitely, you know, Id say, [they] prefer not to use it. I think the other thing is that it doesnt feel the same and it gets in the way and so a lot of them [peer s] really prefer not to use it.
152 One participant who reported inconsistent c ondom use himself, explai ns that his friends also have negative attitudes toward condom use which may result from their beliefs that AIDS is fake. Some say, Awe man, they just lie. There aint no certain thang bout AIDS out there. They just tryin to make money. Some of them dont believe its true, t hough. Even though they heard about it, they know its killing people and al l, but they think its fake. So thats their believin. Multiple sex partners. An exploration of the perceived peer norms around concurrent sex partners rev ealed that 64% (9) Haitian-bor n men believed and observed that their heterosexual male peers did not practice monogamy. A 20-y ear-old participant remarks that while his peers tend to be prom iscuous, he tries not to succumb to peer pressure. In high school, all my friends were like going to parties and having girls every week. Stuff like that but I never partake in those activities. First of all, my paren ts kept me straight. I couldnt go out and stuff like that. But my friends definitely have multiple partners at a time. No commitmen t and stuff like that. But I dont let that bother me or like get in to me cause I know I stand strong in what I believe and what I do, so I dont let that affect me. My friends definitely have multiple partners. Another 22-year-old Haitian man attributed his peers risky behaviors to hormonal activity. Their hormones kick but they dont think. Its when they done the mistake, they like look what I did. Its like they dont have no common sense that should prevent yourself from doing things. A 36-year-old entrepreneur who himself re ported partner concurrency commented about his Haitian peers. I think most Haitian men want to have a steady sex partner. But it is not uncommon to see some Haitian men with multiple sex partners.
153 Referring to the cultural influence on ma le sexual behavior, another 36-year-old participant echoed similar comments. Okay, I think part aside from just being Haitian, I think, I think it is a man behavior, also. Its ju st, hey, the more people you can have, the more macho people look at you. And I think thats why. I think really for me, living in Haiti and also being grow up here also, seeing the mentality. I think it boils down to if youre a man, the more women you can get the more acceptable your friends will see you. Just like, Wow, how you manage to have that? A 28-year-old married Haitian man who repor ted being faithful to his wife provided possible reasons for the infidelity he observes among some of his peers. It could be many things. I say bas ed on the satisfaction need that they may be seeking from a female For me, my personal friends female, so from a female perspect ive, they (male peers] may be looking at the breast size, the body gesture, the body type. So it could be many things that could in fluence them to, per se, go from one person to the other person. Referring to Haitian male sexual behavior, a recently married 32-year-old participant explained: It depends on the age group. If you talk about my fathers age group thats in like 50s to 60, mo st likely thats not in their vocabulary to actually have one s ex partner. As a matter of fact they are not even using condoms bec ause they feel that it was their right to actually populate. You know ? If you look at my age range which is 30 45, some of these guy s have the same kind of mindset because they look up to their fath er and they see their father just like sleeping around. Some of them mi ght use condoms, but a lot of them probably don wanna use it becaus e they just tell you they dont like the feel of it. And then they get sick. And its almost like, What can I do? So its kind of very tough because you have a person that decides like that 20 minutes to 2 hours was worth it and then they counting their days and say, Hey, cest la vie. A 50-year-old Haitian man who has been marri ed for 19 years, recalled the reaction he frequently gets from his peers toward his marital fidelity.
154 But some time I meet some Haiti an who tell me the same I just explain to you. And some of them told me if Im crazy! And I told them, You crazy! Me crazy? I dont forget that one of the Haitian and Spanish, both of them to ld me how I got married for one woman since 29 years I never go out with someone else? And I said to them, you know what, Im not crazy, you crazy. A 55-year-old Haitian-born participant who admits to having extramarital sexual relationships, explained that men in general tend to have multiple sex partners. A lot of them [Haitian men] th ey like to have different women. Well, really honestly, Ima tell y ou its a man thing. Most if the time, man always like different, its like you eatin a fruit, you want a different taste. Haitian men tended to report that monogamy is not a typical sexual pattern for their male friends and peers. While Hait ian study participants reported monogamy as their personal sexual behavioral preference and practice, they reported that many of their peers and family members practice partne r concurrency. Although mutual monogamy is an HIV risk reduction strategy, based on the f eedback obtained from Haitian men in this study, it may not be a behavioral choice for some Haitian men. Hip-Hop Culture. Similar to U.S.-born men, Haitian men (93% or 13) reported that mainstream hiphop culture and the media negatively influen ce sexual behavior primarily because they sexualize women and promote skewed, oversexed definitions of masculinity. A 20-yearold student described the effect of hip-hop on young men. But I think overall, its like as in like it has a big effect on it, as in like, well, okay, we have to be the if you dont have so many, so many chicks, youre not really a man, whatever.
155 While indicating that hip-hop does not have a personal effe ct on him, an 18-year-old shared his perceptions of the effect of th e hip-hop culture on early initiation of sexual activity. The hip-hop music may actually want to get people to have sexual intercourse from the way they talk about girls, from the way they elaborate certain stuff and certa in songs. And though they put on there that its explicit some kids still listen to it. And they may get them to get involved at a younge r age than they were supposed to be. A 20-year-old student gave an account of the images portrayed in rap music videos and the messages sent by those images. Women are not only sexualized but social definitions of beauty are reinforc ed in these videos. Rappers in the rap videos, all you see is girls booties shaking, titties bouncing, pretty girl s. I never seen a big [fat] girl in a video. I havent seen a ugly girl in a video. I mean, they always beautiful females that every guy wanna sleep with and stuff like that. So, I mean in the rap songs, the rap lyrics is like she do this, she lick me like a lollipop, all that stuff. You know what I mean? So the rappers and hip-hop are influencing a lot. Another young participant, a 22-year-old as piring musician fro m low socio-economic status commented on not only the sexual conten t of rap music but also the violent lyrics and the personal effect it has on his mental state. All they talk about sex and money. Say if you wanna have like, money, you gotta do somethin fo r me. They talk sex, how I wanna do this, this and that. You dont have to be scared to do anything, you grown. You gotta have self-contr ol to listen to it. I never knew nothing about hip-hop, cause I lo ve jazz. I used to love that. Suddenly, somebody say, well you gotta listen to hip-hop, hiphop. Im thinkin hip-hop rap. C ause I wasnt used to stuff like that. So I listened to it, then Cam ron [a rapper] had me [when he sang about], shoot somebody, gun, gun this and that. Yeah, it affect my mind. It affect me, Im not gonna lie. It does affect me.
156 A 36-year-old participant i ndicated that both men and women buy into the messages conveyed by the hip-hop world. I think its still the same mentalit y as far as okay hey, if youre African American, black male in ge neral, or Haitian I think its just hey, the more women you can get, the more credit you gonna have, not only with your boys, but all the women also flock to you, cause they know, Hey, he quote-unquote the man. A 28-year-old married man admitted to th e temptations he feels based on sexual messages conveyed by rap music and the media. Oh, well I think that's one of the bi ggest things that really affect a lot of black...black men in general, because I know for me, being that I am married, I still feel see a instant influence on the temptation on the temptation of going out and doing different things based on what you see on TV, based on the type of way that they depict women, and also based on that particular male preference. And TV will definitely sell you off right off hand if you don't have a good, strong foundation of who you are, that could definitely destroy you to make you do a lot of th ings that for a fact you know you said that you shouldn't be doing. So it does play a big role, especially in the rap videos. Some men made a distinction between Haitia n music and rap music which originated in the United States. Having been raised in Ha iti, a 34-year-old participant relates that Haitian music emphasizes love while Ameri can music promotes sex. Moreover, rap music fails to promote safe sex. For instance, the way they make those videos for instance. When you start to watch it, it seems lik e its encourage to go out there and do certain things. But some of them dont preach about you should take necessary steps to prevent certain things from happening AIDS. As far as Haitian bands concerned, media, I would say our song is more likely, the musician Im talking about its more into love! Yeah, its mo re into love. Its not like, compared to the media here, its like, Hey, this lady here and there and And thats how we do it.
157 A 50-year-old father voiced his concerns about the openness of the media and the dangerous influence of hip-hop music. For me, it's not a good thing for th e kids, but it's best they know but for me, I always think about it, and I say, "The media inform too much. Inform too much." It 's good for the know, but sometime too, you let them know too much. That's one of the dangerous for me for the youth. Because when they don't know and they hear or see, now they want to know what it is. Now they want to go to see and now because they want to go to see and sometime they don't have opportunity to do it. They can go anyhow, they can make it, they don't care anyhow they can make it. And now they can get AIDS. Anybody for example, a girl, any man, whatever, the same age or not. Because I know some Haitian girl up in school and high school get pregnant for old men who got many kids. And that happen because, how you say about music. They hear that, the musi c or they say, like the television. And they want to know how they hear it, how it's going to feel. And now, anybody who they got c hance talk to them, they don't care. Interviews among Haitian-born men indicate that the media and particularly hiphop culture have a strong, ne gative influence on sexual be havior. Sexual images of women, the promotion of multiple sex partners, and oversexed masculine ideologies may have a direct impact on the risky sexual behaviors practiced by some U.S.-born and Haitian-born black men. Attitudes and Beliefs about Homosexuality and Bisexuality. Haitian men expressed even stronger fee lings of homophobia and intolerance for homosexuals and bisexuals than their U.S.-bor n counterparts. In addition, they conveyed a culture of violence toward homosexuals, a be havior that is more extreme than that of U.S.-born men. Its [homophobia] more of a cultur al thing. As in here, when I moved here, its really like open. But in Haiti, nobody really dare come out saying that well theyre homosexual. Its more of a
158 under-the-table type of thing and stuff like that. So, I guess some day it could go as far as being beat up by people you dont even know just cause youre homosexual. An 18-year-old student explai ned his fear of homosexuals. I dont have any friends that are homosexual. Its not that Im I mean, I dont think I would feel comfortable around them in a way. Im scared of certain actions that they may have and actions they may have towards me esp ecially and stuff like that. Another 20-year-old particip ant explained that Haitian men who are homosexual are afraid to identify as such for fear of is olation and dismissal by friends and family members. Well, for Haitians, I know Haitians do not like the term, do not wanna see no homosexual people. They think it's the worse, so if a Haitian happened to be homosexual, it's gonna be on the down low for...maybe for life. They alwa ys say homo tendencies. I know pinky or whatever. Gettin' your nails done and stuff like that. So they gonna be on the down low for life because Haitians will not...past generations will never a ccept homosexuals. Maybe you are generous, you're 20 years down the road. We might let it end because we're gonna know a couple of people. But as far as down low, a lot of people are down low, because they're maybe just scared to come out the closet b ecause they fear what people might say or might think of them differently. Blaming the United States for homosexualit y, a 22-year-old part icipant recalled the treatment of homosexuals back in Haiti. Thats what I love about Haiti. They never accept no gays. Now its affected cause aint nobody listen to nobody no more, cause back in the day they beat the cr ap out of you and put you on jail and learn you a lesson and teach you. Say God created man and female, you gotta stick to it. Bu t since people come down here and have the mess around this country. Ga ys started in this country, thats how gays started.
159 Older Haitian men between the ages of 4560, viewed homosexuality as an ungodly act that contradicted the laws of creationism Three men in this age group expressed the following views. That [homosexuality, bisexual ity] dont go. That dont go. You dont even have to ask about it. That dont go. Its not fair, its not admissible. Its not admissible. I cannot see a man with a man, a woman with a woman. Its not th e way we were created. Back home when somebody is homosexual, you cant even pass the street that we live on .They gonna even throw rock at you. I don't know nobody...well, I seen people out there, but I don't really know, and I don't wanna k now nobody like that. That's weird. Most the time if I have seen somebody like that, what I do, I just stay away from them. I don't even wanna touch the people. See, I'm a Christian, I go to chur ch. I don't, you know...in general, people is people, I respect that. But I don't know, for some reason, when it comes to this here, I just ... ignorin' them. I like, I don't wanna know you. Just stay away from me. I call it [homosexuality] sinners work because the Bible said it, not me. In my country. its a shame to see that. In my country in Haiti, if you were homosexual, if you say that, you would be in trouble. People teasing you everywhere. Even beat you up. While some Haitian-born men had never heard the term down low, others thought the down low phenomenon may be a significant contributing factor to the high rates of HIV and AIDS among black women. I mean, that's the easiest way. If you have a wife or a girlfriend, and they thinking, "Okay, hey, my husband or my boyfriend...this is the only person." And they most likely, especially if it's a husband, a wife most likely will say, "Oka y, well there's no need to use protection." Thinking okay, well partn er's faithful. And even if it's a homosexual relationship, then also, I think going from one person to another person, so easy to just transmit it that way. Oh, that affect it a lot. I me an, especially by looking at the different things people do and the different body gestures people use. I mean especially when, I mean a male to male, I mean, they pretty much have to pretty much have sex anal. You know what I'm sayin'? And with that, I mean that 's one of the most sensitive parts
160 of the body. You know, and that par t right there could cause for a different disease to come in th rough you and in different ways. Actually faster than doin' it, I mean vaginal, you know. So that definitely have a big effe ct. And people that are not really that educated about it will definitely be hurt more. Especially the African-American population, and th ey tend to, I guess, they tend to want to go that route mostly. And that have a very big effect. You never know who, you never know who's who and who's not. You know? So you definitely have to be on the lookout every single day. Others expressed the perception that black me n may feel the need to be on the down low because homosexuality is stigmatized and shunned in the black community. Well, personally, I do not know anyone that's in that category, but I would say the reason that they do it it's probably...has to do with society. To do what society...the norm is to...if you're a man, you have to...should be married to a female. And vice versa. If you're a female you should be married to a man. But they may have...were born with a cer tain things in their heads or brain that triggered them to act certain...diff erent from the norm. But my opinion on that is as I was raised, I always said that I believe in marriage between a man and a woman, but who am I to judge. I'm a individual, I'm a sinner just like anyone else. But only God can judge a person's behavior. And a lot of times when I go to lunch for instance, very often the subject will go from a donkey to gay I don't know how, but let's say I have lunch with a few of my colleagues that are AfricanAmericans. And they would actually just like always come back to this. Who's gay on campus, who's not. You know? And it's something that there's...there's t hat prejudice with them that they feel it is something that is so unnatural, etcetera, etcetera. And that can stem from a lot of thi ngs such as religion. Because African-Americans typically are very religious. So when you have the down low, it's because it's a beha vior that is shunned that that's something that they do not like at all. The study revealed that both U.S.-bor n and Haitian-born black men hold strong feelings of homophobia and stigmatization to ward homosexuals. Haitian men, especially those over the age of 45 years, were more lik ely to attribute their negative attitudes to
161 religiosity. Haitian-born men were also more likely to identify a culture of violence against homosexuals as practiced in their native country. Question 4: How do gender norms influ ence sexual behavior among black men who identify as heterosexual? This study explored the gender norms that influence sexual behavior within black heterosexual relationships. Re ports from male study particip ants indicate that black women demonstrate financial independence and are not dependent on their male partners for monetary support. Findings also indicate th at within gendered relationships, men tend to make decisions about condom use. U.S.-born Men Financial Decision-making. A recurrent theme within the explorati on of gendered relationships was female financial independence. Most U.S.-born men reported that their fe male partners were financially independent and di d not depend on their male part ners for financial support. Both married and single men tended to report that their female partners were employed for wages and were fairly independent. A 20-y ear-old participant shared his views about financial independence. One thing I make sure, if I be with somebody, in order for me to take care of them, I gotta make sure that they take care of themselves, also. 'Cause my role, I like to be the big shot. Like, you know, I don't like to say I'm a co ntrol freak, nothin' like that. 'Cause I don't do nothin' like that. It's always a fifty-fifty thing with me. If she could do it and she n eeds help with it, I'll help her. But as far as payin' her bills and stuff, I'm her man, I'm not her baby daddy or nothin' like that. I am not her husband, I am just her man, her boyfriend, okay? Another participant with a history of incar ceration indicated that because of his unemployed status, his sexual partne rs cannot depend on him financially. They cant be
162 financially dependent on me c ause I aint got no income. A 53-year-old participant also shared that financial responsibility is about equal in his relationship. The theme of financial independence recurr ed throughout the inquiry as U.S. born men reported that their female partners were not dependent on them for financial resources. Condom-use Decision-making. A major finding regarding gender roles around condom use was mutual decisionmaking and male decision-making. Most U.S.-b orn men in the study sample reported that condom use decision-making was either equally sh ared with female partners or solely the decision of the male partner. Describing c ondom use decision-making in his relationship, a 27-year-old participant reported: I think in any kind of relationshi p you have to be 50/50. You cant just say well I am going to use th is brand and this is all Im going to use. Sex is between two people, not one person. So if your partner likes a certain brand of condoms, talk about it. Maybe thats better for her, even if it doesnt do anything for you. Sometimes its best to give in a little. Men who reported inconsistent condom use re ported that their female partners supported decisions against using condoms during sexual intercourse. A high percentage of women dont tell us anything. Cause I thered be times I have sex and if I dont bring out the condom, she dont say a word. Well, when we started off it [condom use] was automatic. But I think the first time that we, we stopped using condoms was the, it was a heat of the moment kind of thing. I actually went into you know, its while I was looking fo r a condom, I didnt have it, and kind of didnt and so we kind of, you know, came to a mutual agreement to let things go anyway. Well, she feels that shes okay w ith that [condom use]. Now from an oral [sex] perspective, shes not shes willing to take the risk. Yeah, shes willing to take the risk.
163 Some men reported that their female partne rs held negative attitudes toward condom use and encouraged their male partners not to use condoms during sexual intercourse. You know I take that [condom use] seriously because there was a time, you know, we didnt ha ve no condoms and she was likeit was like she was giving me oral s ex, right? And so I said I was looking for the condoms, you k now I thought she hid them or something, and she said they ran out. And then she was like, you know, showing me her pussy and I was like, Im sorry, youve got the wrong person!I say that because you know I take that [condom use] very seriously and sh e was like, you know, she took several tests and said okay, thats nice, but I was never, you know, thats not my thing, you know, and uh, and so, that was just Her, she, I dont know about her. No, she dont, well she dont mind not using condoms. Usually it, its me, for things that most of the stuff like birth control and stuff like that she have, shes a little, I have to say it in that she really is against that. But when it comes to condoms and stuff like that, you know, most of the time its me, y ou know, to make sure that I have one, or state different rules like th at. I dont think, actually in my whole life I dont think I ever met a female that would stop, hey, you have a condom? you know, I never really met a female that even said that before, you know, so. Themes such as the need for female empowerment, better knowledge and awareness of male partners, and honesty a bout STD and HIV status emerged when U.S.born men were asked to describe the role th ey thought black women played in the HIV epidemic. Men held women responsible for not insisting on condom us e and believed that women should be more aware of the sexual hi story of their sex partners. Some men also voiced concerns that women were irresponsib le in not knowing their own HIV status or not honestly sharing their sexual history with male sex partners. These themes are evident in the following quotes: But somethin' that most people don't realize is that even though women tryin' to put the word out, but there's women that's allowin' it. Women are just, I don't know...l ike I said, they just don't know the value that they have. And bec ause they don't know, they just let
164 anything get through. So, I mean, I give the women most props. And most women like to say that men are dogs, I agree with them a hundred percent. And we are dogs, but a dog can be tamed. And even in the Bible, God says a wo man is a man's foot. A woman can tell a guy anywhere to go. If you really want it...if you really want that sex that bad, all a women gotta do...a women could get a guy to do anything if a guy wants that sex. Most women don't know they have a hundred percent cont rol of a man. If you tell a man, "If you want to have sex, you have to do this, you have to do that. And I guarantee a hundred percent, a man would do it. But most women don't see that bec ause they don't see how strong and how powerful they are to a man. What women can do differently. In general, they make women condoms, so I mean, you can use those as well. And if your partner, the male, tells you he doe snt have a condom, be like No glove, no love. If you dont have one, were defin itely not doing anything. Dont fall into p eer pressure or anything Because a lot of women do just, you know, for th at one night, theyve got a one night stand, and thats the wrong thing to do. You know, try to, if women stop se rving basically they arent the ones to understand that you know disease is out there and just be okay, Ill find out about this person before I actually have sex with this person, then I think thats re ally the best way for them to prevent actually catching something or getting HIV. One 27-year-old participant pointed to the role of self-esteem in sexual relationships and its importance in empowering women to make safer sex decisions. Women play a larger role now becaus e of the fact that the statistics are higher. So, I hate to put everything on African American women because it takes two people, but for some reason they are not being careful enough. Whether it s they are not talking to their partners, they are not getting thei r partners tested, or they are just choosing to have risky sex. So, so mething has to happen. But they need to either take it more seri ously, or they need to be more proactive and dont let a man talk them into having unprotected sex, no matter WHAT they say. Some women haveits a lot of different issues. I mean, you can hav e a woman that has issues with men. Say if shes self-confid ent, she doesnt have enough confidence in herself, or shes ne ver heard the fact that shes beautiful before. Or, or have, have, have an older male figure hug her, or tell her that, you know, sh e is important, you know, who she is as a person is important. So if you have a woman that self-
165 esteem is not that high, she will do whatever it takes to keep the man that shes with, thinking that he is giving her the love that she has never gotten. One participant who was a strong proponent of the argument that incarcerated men who re-enter the genera l population are the major r outes by which black women acquire HIV infection, implored women to be aware of the sexual and incarceration histories of their sex partners. Well, what they are doing to put them at risk, my personal belief is that it is coming out of the pris on system. Guys go get in the prison system, and you know they are incarcerated for an extended amount of time, and actually I spok e to some guys that disclosed, you know, that sometimes they may do things in prison, you know, in your gang type thing, or like an induction type thing, you know, that they probably wouldnt do if they were out in the outside, and so I think more black women need to especially evaluate who you are dating, who you are with, and understand, you know, that backgroundthat more communica tion about you know some of their past experiences and different things like that, before you get, you know, before they would engage into sexual, you know activity with, you know, with their partner. A 27-year-old college gradua te related the story of hi s best female friend who continuously practices high risk sexual behaviors. He was perplexed as to why she puts herself at risk and believes that black wo men in general should be aware of their HIV status. .And then she is intelligent You know, college grad Doin well I mean supporting herself. And like I just cant think what was goin on through her head when you just meet this guy probably knowin for a week, and youre havin unprotected sex .So I believe black women has a major, major role in it. You know, and I think as a I think black women should get themselves tested all the time. I think they should really, really, really get themselves tested. Likewise, other men reported that HIV tes ting and partner notifi cation are critical to curbing the HIV epidemic in the black population. Some felt wome n can do more to be
166 aware of their own status and inform their partners of suc h. One 54-year-old participant shared the story two of his friends who are addi cted to crack and neglect to get tested for HIV. Like its a girl, two girls, th eyre friends, and I mess around with both of em. They like hot lil ma mas, you know, they out there. And I be tellin them to get test ed. And they keep satin they went, I dont think they went. Thats wh ere the drug thing come in, cause they be tryin to get cr ack, cocaine. And they will do anything to get that. So that w ould cause somebody else to get infected. Another 51-year-old par ticipant emphasized the role of f ear as a barrier to black women getting tested and discussing HIV with their partners. I would say [women play] a majo r role because some of them transmit it. Then they dont wanna discuss it. A lot of them not open, as open as men. And theyll pass it on. Dont wanna get the tests. Dont wanna know the outcome. Afraid. An HIV-positive man who is currently invol ved in a sexual relationship identifies substance addiction, promiscuity and physical abuse as risk factors for HIV among black women. In reference to gendered relationships he believes that women need to be empowered to be strong and independent. Well, you have to be wary especi ally of the women who are caught up in the disease of addiction. B ecause there's ladies who'll do anything for the next round. And those are the type women you will see at the bars, at the discos, and they're very promiscuous. And you have to be careful about the Internet, too. Because the Internet has a lot of...is anothe r area where people meet people and get involved in all kinds of situations. I've been approached on the Internet, and I'm just amaz ed about the approaches you can get on the Internet. I saw recently where felt...was saying that she was being abused by her partner you know, physically abused. But she felt like, "But he's th e breadwinner and he's making the money, so I'm puttin' up with this because he's paying the bills. And if I do put my foot down and he leaves me and I don't have a job, what am I gonna do? So you tryin' to hope things get better. So yeah, I could see where the same thing could be HIV.
167 The woman say, "Well, he'll just go somewhere else." Then I'll be left to do things on my own. So it' s up to the woman I guess, to be a strong woman, the woman needs to try to understand or not depend on someone else for their livelihood...bottom line. Haitian-born Men Financial Decision-making. Similar to U.S.-born men, Haitian-born me n (86% or 12) reported that their female partners were financially independent, contributed equally to the finances of the household and played a key role in making financial decisions. Within most Haitian households, both partners were employed for wages. Even men who were the primary breadwinners reported that they include their wi ves or partners in fi nancial decisions. As one 55-year-old participant stated: Well, I always invited her; you know what I'm sayin'...'cause the thing is that because I work, makin' money right now, but I'm thinkin' she's my partner so we supposed to help one another. While I'm makin' a decision, it mi ght be wrong decision, I always invite her. If I'm gon' do something, I tell her. Another newly married 32-year-old participan t reported that within his household, he compromises with his wife on financial decisions. We both work. However, because I'm usually the more savvy one, she trusts a lot of my decisions And at the same time, from times...let's say when it comes to inve stment. If it's for investment, she knows that I've done investm ent before, so she would say, "Okay, you do the analysis and then break it down for me in layman's terms." And then I'll say yes or no. And sometimes I'll make a case on the stuff, but basic ally the preliminary stuff I do. But when it comes to financial decision, we always come to a compromise, because of the fact that me personally, I don't want 5 years from now that somebody to tell me that I could have been in a better place, it's because of you. A 50-year-old participant who has been married for 19 year s reported equal financial decision-making within his relationship.
168 We did together. I got no cont rol about it becaus e...and she know I don't get any girlfriend. I don't get any kids out [of the marriage].. And the only thing, I got family on my country, she got family on her country, and we each other c an send a little bit money there when we can. But we work almost equalTherefore, findings indicate that Haitianborn men engage their female partners in financial decisions within their relationshi ps. Haitian men commonly reported that their female partners were employed and therefore contributed equally to the household. Thus, mutually financial decision-making was a typical behavior among the Haitian-born sample in this inquiry. Condom-use Decision-making. Among Haitian-born men, male decision-making emerged as the primary theme regarding condom use decisions. Most men repor ted that they made the decisions about whether or not to use condoms during a se xual encounter. An 18-y ear-old participant noted: Its usually me that says I want to use one. And most of the time, they are okay with it because th ey know whats out there and stuff like that and what may happen. So they were okay with it. A 22-year-old insisted on condom use because many of his female partners have a desire to become pregnant. Well, mostly me 'cause they too ac tive. Too this, "I wanna have a baby, I wanna-." I'm like, "Man, we not even close to...we just met each other and you talkin' about this and that, like nah, it ain't gonna happen." I say, "You gotta understand me to understand you. 'Cause if we don't have underst anding, we never will work." 'Cause Yeah, they too active. Likewise, a 36-year-old participant claimed that he does not nego tiate condom use with his female partners.
169 Well, I dont think I give them an oppor tunity to make that decision, you know? I make, you know better be safe than sorry. This inquiry explored Haitian mens pe rceptions about the role Haitian women play in HIV transmission within the black community. Similar to the findings in the U.S.born sample, the need for female empowerme nt emerged as a recurrent theme when condom-use decision-making was discussed. So me men asserted that within gendered relationships, women need to realize the power they have to negotiate condom use to better protect themselves from HIV and other STI infection. Moreover, discussions of the female condom recurred throughout the discus sion of womens roles as Haitian men argued that if it seemed impossible to ne gotiate the use of th e male condom, women should utilize a female controlled method such as the female condom. Well, they always say women have all the power. They always say...and they do. They do have all the power. If a woman say I'm not having sex with you unless we use a condom, I bet she's gonna wear a condom. Now they might try to sweet talk her, but if she's strong...if she stand by her morals an d tell him, "I'm not having sex unless you have a condom." he's definitely gonna wear a condom. Or he ain't gonna get none. So wome n definitely play the star role. The woman have all the power li ke they say. So women, I don't wanna say it's their...it's not thei r fault, but if e very woman would be like, "We're not having sex unless we have a condom," there would be a lot less HIV cases out th ere. So, they definitely have all the power, they should definitely tell their partners to use condoms. Or actually, there's also a female condom, so they too can wear a condom. So if he don't...if he real ly, really don't wanna wear it, she can wear one and then be safe in that situation. Describing how he thinks women can better pr otect themselves, a 20-year-old participant stated: Well, I dont know, just saying they wont have sex without a condom. Or, I dont know, if they use the women condom.
170 A 55-year-old, married participan t, who admits to infidelity and dislikes the unnatural feeling of male condoms, believes that wo men should take responsibility for using condoms. I think they can do the same th ing a man do, cause they have a woman condom. They can use them too. Probably better for them to use theirs, cause I dont use nothin. That way I feel more reality. Using a biblical anecdote, a 22-year-old Hait ian man implores women to be strong even though it is sometimes difficult not to succumb to mens persuasions. Well, females. Most fema les, even though they probably think...you know about HIV, but some times they like, "No, there is nothing. That ain't gonna happen." Giving them little soft words, you know guys. It's not far from females, but them little soft words like, "Yes, honey yes everything." They just do it like, yeah. For example, in the beginning Adam and Eve. Eve say "Try it." Adam says "Okay." That's it. Soft lit tle words. It's so tempting. You just gotta like, you gotta be strong. Even though you have selfcontrol, you just gotta learn to sa y no is no. It's hard. It's hard. Having admitted to inconsistent condom use, a 36-year-old Haitian participant fears that women may be voiceless with in sexual relationships. In terms of using protection, they [women] play a very big role. I think they are at the forefront of th is. If there's going to be any sexual transmission, sexual transm itted diseases, then, and if a condom is going to stop that or w hatever else is available to stop that, then, you know, they are at th e forefront to voice that. But I'm not sure if their voice may be he ard. But hey, you have to put your foot down to be heard, you know? T hat's what I think. In the heat of the moment, you know, you might never know what's going to happen. The theme of womens empowerment and th e need for women to exercise more power within sexual relationships continue d to surface throughout the exploration of womens role in the HIV epidemic.
171 I don't know if it's so much just black women or women in general definitely have, I guess, the power to make su re that the partners use protection. And so as much as the guy makes it, "Well, it doesn't feel the same. It doesn't this." But I think if black women would say, especially...I mean, even when you are married there are certain precautions you still have to take, but especially for those who are not married...I think regardless how good the relationship, make sure that the guy uses protection. Another emergent theme was womens promiscu ity and self-degradation as factors that contribute to high HIV rates among black women. Well, I think women play a big role, but, I mean...Even with the black population, I mean, that's one th ing I really want to do is to go out and talk to kids. Mostly y oung male, but even with the black population with females, I see a lot of females nowadays degrading themselves to a lower standard. And they're pretty much allow themselves to interact with people, just for nothing re ally, honestly. And especially with a lot of bl ack females, they're looking for something, but they're looking for it in the wrong direction. So it's easy for a black female coming from not the norm now, just I'm basing what I've seen based on w hat I've observed coming from a single family home without a father figure at home. And they more so tend to have more than one par tner and sleep with so and so, and do this and do that. And, I me an honestly, if the child doesn't have that type of foundation, educ ation aye, say don't be havin' sex with so-and-so. Aye, I mean, it's there, I mean, guys ain't gon' say no to it. And they gon' go in and take it especially if you don't say "use condoms." Aye, easier for them. So that's why it's a lot of the black females are getting those transmitted disease more, because of just a lack of information. Another participant stated, The same ways for the man, the same thing for the woman. If I go back to explaining the same thing I'm going to said. You met a man. You don't know who that m an is, you cannot the same day you meet that man you already go in relation with that man. You don't know that man. You got little bit information about that man. At this time, depend you can go in to relationship, but even too, you don't know that much, you use your protection. And tell him, okay, you have to!
172 Some men believed that women who dre ss provocatively attr act unwanted sexual attention to themselves. The way they dress can lead the man to wanna have sexual intercourse with them. A father of two daughters attrib utes high rates of HIV to the behavior and appear ance of young women. First, Im not gonna ask you to wear long dress, but at least wear decent clothes. Stay in school. St ay in school and listen to your parents! Relationship scripts from U.S.-born and Haitian-born men produced themes such as female financial independence and stabil ity. However, within sexual relationships, women seem less likely to make condom-use d ecisions. Themes such as male control and female submissiveness emerged within di scussions concerning condom use decisionmaking. Female endorsement of unprotecte d vaginal sex was also a common theme throughout the inquiry suggesting that while women may be fina ncially independent, sexual decisions are largely made by their male partners. Men in this study also ascribe responsibility for condom use and safer sex beha viors to their female partners. Themes of female insecurity, lack of self-esteem, and low levels of female assertiveness and empowerment emerged as men described their perceptions of womens role in the HIV epidemic within the black community. Moreover, Haitian men identified the need for Haitian women to use female controlled protective methods. Phase II Results: Focus Groups among U.S.-born and Haitian-born Women Phase II of this inquiry was designed to explore black womens attitudes and perceptions about black mens sexual be haviors. Using focus group methods, the following objective was addressed: 1) to di scover how black wome n conceptualize and perceive the socio-cultural, intrapersonal a nd behavioral factors that influence black
173 mens HIV-risk behaviors. This section presen ts of the demographic profile of the study population. While the original objective was to include a sample of Haitian women over the age of 30 years, the researcher expe rienced challenges re cruiting this age group primarily because community contacts were engaged with the Haiti earthquake relief efforts. After making multiple attempts to organize a focus group with Haitian-born women over the age of 30, several women cancel led due to unexpected travel plans to Haiti, a result of the massive, catastrophic earthquake that hit the island of Haiti on January 12, 2010. However, 2 focus groups were conducted among younger Haitian women between the ages of 20 and 27 years. In the section below, the results of the content analysis of the qualitative data obtained from focus groups are presented by research question. As quotes ar e reported, they will be labe led with the age group and the ethnicity of the participant w ho offered the quote. The term young is used to refer to women ages 20-27 years and the term older refers to women ages 43-65 years. Demographic Information: Phase II A total of 23 black women who identified as heterosexual between the ages of 20 and 65 years of age (M = 35.3, SD = 14.1) pa rticipated in the study. All women who participated in the study identified as black or African American, 65% were U.S.-born and 35% were Haitian-born. Of the female study participants, 65.2% were never married, 43.5% had some college education, 60.9% reported a household income of under $15, 000 per year, and 52.2% were employed for wages. Detailed demographic data on educational, level, marital status, household income, race and ethnicity are presented in table 9 below.
174 Table 9: Demographic Characteristi cs of Female Sample (N=23) Demographic Characteristics N Percent Age (range 20-65 years) 18-24 years 25-44 years 45-60 years 9 6 8 39.1% 35.9% 34.6% Marital Status Married Divorced Widowed Separated Never married Member of unmarried couple 1 1 1 1 15 4 4.3% 4.3% 4.3% 4.3% 65.2% 17.4% Ethnicity Hispanic or Latino Not Hispanic or Latino Missing 0 22 1 0% 95.7% 4.3% Race American Indian or Alaska Native Asian Black or African American Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander White 0 0 23 0 0 0% 0% 100% 0% 0% Educational Level Never attended school or only attended kindergarten 8th grade or less 9th to 11th grade High school graduate or GED Some college or technical school College graduate or higher degree 0 0 3 4 10 6 0% 0% 13.0% 17.4% 43.5% 26.1% Household Income Under $15,000 per year $15,000 $24,999 per year $25,000 $34,999 per year $35,000 $44,999 per year $45,000 $59,999 per year $60,000 $75,000 per year $75,000 or more per year 14 4 4 0 1 0 0 60.9% 17.4% 17.4% 0% 4.3% 0% 0% Employment Status Employed for wages Self-employed Out of work for more than 1 year Out of work for less than 1 year A homemaker Student Retired Unable to work 12 0 0 1 0 3 1 6 52.2% 0% 0% 4.3% 0% 13.1% 4.3% 26.1% Sexual Orientation
175 Heterosexual Bisexual Homosexual or gay Other 21 1 0 1 91.3% 4.3% 0% 4.3% Country of Birth United States Haiti 15 8 65.2 34.5 In phase II of the study, several themes emerged around HIV risk behaviors as well as cultural norms and gender norms that influence these behaviors. Table 10 below outlines the themes that emerged within focu s group discussions with black heterosexual women.
176 Table 10: Emergent Themes: Phase II Domain of Inquiry: Intrapersonal Factors Subgroups Age (years) Themes: U.S.born Haitianborn Sexual abuse histories among women Yes No 43-65 Depression in women Yes No 18-65 Womens negative attitudes to condom use Yes Yes 18-65 Women desire pregnancy Yes No 18-30 Domain of Inquiry: HIV Risk Behaviors Themes: Inconsistent condom use Yes Yes 18-65 Level of trust determines condom use No Yes 18-30 Primary concern for contraception versus disease prevention No Yes 18-30 Discomfort with condoms Yes No 43-65 Non-condom use equates to heightened emotional connection No Yes 18-30 Condoms decrease sexual stimulation Yes Yes 18-65 Domain of Inquiry: Cultural Norms Themes: Sex-ratio imbalance Yes No 18-65 Absence of father figure Yes No 43-65 Lack of family communication Yes Yes 18-65 Parental emphasis on contraception Yes Yes 18-65 Negative influence of hip-hop Yes No 18-65 Role of voudou No Yes 18-30 Domain of Inquiry: Gender Norms Themes: Masculine ideologies Yes No 18-65 Socialization of women Yes No 43-65 Differential socialization of boys and girls No Yes 18-30
177 Question 5: What are black womens perception s of the risk behaviors practiced by black men who identify as heterosexual? Findings of the inquiry reveal that U. S.-born and Haitian-born women perceive that black men practice unsafe sexual behavi ors. Women confirmed that black men often reject condom use and practice partner concu rrency. Women also iden tified their personal HIV risk behaviors, their aversion to condom use, and the influence of drugs and alcohol in their sexual decision-making. U.S.-born Women Women born in the United States identifie d lack of condom use and multiple sex partners as prevalent HIV-risk behavior s practiced by black men. Moreover, women confirmed mens assertions th at black women often neglect to suggest condom use during sexual encounters. Themes around womens se lf esteem, self-confidence, and mental health issues emerged as barriers to condom use negotiation among black women. Condom Use. Confirming the findings from phase I of the study, U.S.-born women identified lack of condom use as one of the primary HI V-risk behaviors practiced by black men. In their discussions, women stated the most comm on explanations black male partners often provide for their negative attitudes toward c ondom use such as: 1) small condom size, 2) lack of sexual stimulation a nd; 3) the unnatural feeling deri ved from condoms. U.S.-born women shared the following comments as they discussed mens attitudes toward condoms.
178 I mean I do hear that a lot in black men where they do say no I dont like the way it feels or it dont feel the same or it hurts, its too tight and youre like yeah ri ght but you know and yeah I mean my opinion about it I dont feel th e same way. I agree that you should definitely protect yourself. (Young, U.S.-born woman) They [black men] dont like to use condoms. They really dont. (Older, U.S.-born woman) Well some say, they have so many stories. Some say the condom might not fit right or it dont feel they rather be natural. And they have some kind of issue. (Older, U.S.-born woman) I think some of this is mind over matter. So guys most of them they always say they are too small and it has to be a magnum or nothing. (Older, U.S.-born woman) Women and Condom Use. U.S.-born women voiced con cerns about womens atti tudes toward condom use and eagerly shared their own personal perceptions and hesita tion to use condoms within their sexual experiences. An interesting finding in this inquiry is that while men have been identified as having ne gative condom use attitudes and behaviors, women also hold similar attitudes toward condom use. Howeve r, some of the reasons for non-endorsement of condom use among women are vastly different from those identified by the male study participants. While some women may not enc ourage their male partners to use condoms because they also desire the natural feeling derived from unprotected vaginal sex, others report feelings of low self-e steem, desire to trap a ma le partner through pregnancy, trusting a male partner, and vaginal discomfort associated with condom use. Commenting on womens desire to feel the meat or the natural penis, one participant noted: Well with some experiences I have been through, the woman will tell the man that she dont want him to use a condom. So he be um
179 surprised or skeptic about that because of the feeling they wanna feel the meat or whatever they call it. (Older, U.S.-born woman) Other participants discussed the social, emoti onal, and mental processes that may inhibit womens motivation to negotiate condom use with their male sex partners. I think sometimes some women act ually be going into the sexual act wantin to get pregnant. (Older, U.S.-born woman) With my experience I know with a past relationship I had in which I felt like I didnt want to use a condom because I wanted to trap him in. I kinda wanted to trap hi m, I kinda wanted to get pregnant, I didnt want him to go anywhere. My self esteem was down, I was depressed and I was like OK if we dont use a condom Ill get pregnant or something like that and I wasnt thinking of the sexual partners or anything like that so I really didnt have a problem with it. He gave me the whole Oh I dont like to use a condom and I was like no problem cause I didn t want to be t hat girl that said no to him and then he was going to leave me or something like that. And I was really depressed back then. (Young, U.S.-born woman) I have heard men say that a female did not want to use a condom and usually its because of a situa tion like what 5 star stated about wanting to trap somebody or wan ting to get pregnant whatever making sure that they have the c onnection with the guy for a long time so usually thats in the back of the females mind one of the main reasons why they will tell the guy that its ok to not use a condom. (Young, U.S.-born woman) Similar to findings from the male interviews, condom use is less likely and deemed unnecessary if a woman trus ts her male partner. Yes, I had an experience where I didnt use a condom with a guy but we was together for like 5 yea rs. And we did take the time out and went to the clinic and got teste d. It wasnt like I wanted to be pregnant cause I dont want any kids but you know pull out method [laughter]. You know we did that and thank God Im safe now and I dont know about him but Im safe. (Young, U.S-born woman)
180 Vaginal discomfort emerged as a con cern especially among women between the ages of 45 and 60 years. Many asserted th at condom use resulted in physiological discomfort that makes condoms less appealing. Well, you can tell the differe nce like when they use condoms and when they dont use them, your vagi na feels kinda sore or like raw like. When they use the condom you get like dry is what Im trying to say. (Older U.S.-born women) With the condoms with me its ver y discomforting because it does dry out my vagina. But I use it fo r protection purposes and a lot of times I have no problem with the male partner using the condom being that its either the condom or nothing at all so I dont have a problem with it but yes it does af fect my body and gives my body a dryness. It really does and sometimes it is uncomfortable. (Older, U.S-born woman) Attitudes toward the female condom were explored and revealed negative attitudes and experiences with the female condom as well as misconceptions about its use. Women agreed that it is very difficult to insert the female condom. If you dont insert it correctly, you will feel a lot of discomfort. If you do not put them in correctly, it will be very uncomfortable for the female. If they are applied co rrectly no problem. But you have to almost get all the way down and put your leg all the way up to make sure it over that cervix to not have an irritated effect. I am speaking about my body. The female condom, thats out! And that part about you can use it for 8 hours, thats another thing. With this its just me speaking but ther e is no way in the world Ima walk around with the same thing I have used for no 8 hours! (Older, U.S.-born woman) No it says you can wear it up to 8 hours before you have sex. (Older U.S.-born woman) It is obvious I misunderstood. I turned my brow I mean I had pure union on my face behind that foolishness. Im like Oh no! (Older, U.S.-born woman)
181 Study findings reveal that U.S.-born women confirm th at U.S.-born black men hold negative attitudes toward condom use a nd are therefore unlikely to use them during sexual intercourse. Factors that contribute to these attitude s include mens perceptions that condoms are too small and tight for th eir physique and condoms create an unnatural feeling during sexual intercourse. Findings also reveal that that black women also hold negative attitudes toward condoms and identi fied important physiological, psychological and social factors that cont ribute to these attitudes. Multiple Sex Partners. U.S.-born women identified multiple sex partners as an HIV-risk behavior practiced by black men. Many women reported personal experiences whereby their male partners engaged in concurrent sexual relationships with multiple women. The guys that I have dated or been with, it wasnt just me so I may not have known that right then and there but it wasnt just me so thankfully I was smart enough to protect myself and use a condom. (Young, U.S.-born woman) Yeah I agree too as far as, I me an at the beginning I dont think you are the only one as far as how I think men think. I feel they say let me just keep this one on the side and see how it go and play a little longer and see where it go and eventually once the relationship progresses then at that point then they may stop their ways or you once they see its real or serious or whatever, but I do think that at the beginning all bl ack men are just like tagging you along, hanging you along, pulling your collar until they I guess see or learn about you I guess. (Young, U.S.-born woman) I feel the same way as well. All th e relationships I have been in you really dont know at that moment if you the only one or not until alter on down the line. You might hear from somebody Ive seen him in town with somebody else. You might actually have caught him up with a girl number or so methin. Not till recently did I actually find somebody that I know isnt with anybody else. Well I cant say for sure but in my mi nd for sure [laughter] I know who he come home to. And until myself this the first boyfriend I am
182 actually living with and we are ar ound each other 24-7 I know that where he go I am there with hi m and I dont have a doubt in my mind theres nobody else. All of th e prior relationships though I know it wasnt just me sometimes there was 3 or 4 but you know they are promiscuous at times. (Young, U.S.-born woman) Yeah. I had went with a man, had more than more one woman at a time. He safe with me and not safe with himself. Im like no baby I cant do you no more. I mean two three women. I come over there, women leaving out the door. Oh they just friends. Yeah right. Um hmm. Where do they get that? (Older, U.S.-born woman) Women understood and recognized that their male partners have multiple sex partners, a phenomenon that was expresse d by many of the female U.S.-born study participants. Results from question B below will address the important question of how women respond to male sex partner concurre ncy and the cultural and gender-related factors that may contribute to this risky behavior. Behavioral Health Alcohol and Substance Use. U.S-born women did not confirm their male counterparts beliefs that alcohol and/or substance use prior to sexual inte rcourse does not inhibit their condom use decision-making. In fact, U.S.-born women reporte d that if intoxicate d or high, their male partners are unlikely to think about safe sex behaviors such as condom use. Women also expressed their experiences w ith alcohol and drug use expressing that substance use impairs their personal judgme nt and negotiation skills. I have had sex intoxicated as we ll as my partner and to me it was .. great! Yeah you know it gives you more courage and you a little more bold and wanna try new things when you intoxicated. From a mans standpoint I can say that them being intoxicated they wanna lay back and see what you gon do. I mean they have they liquid sex going on, their drin k, and then they have you and you willing to try, well myself personally, but to me they dont be thinking otherwise but let me see what shes about to do, let me go
183 ahead and lay back so well I guess y ou lead the way with how you feelin at the moment. When you intoxicated they run with it. (Young, U.S.-born woman) I dont think its a healthy decision. A lot of unplanned pregnancies occur through drugs and alcohol sex. In my personal experience being with someone w ho was intoxicated did not help the situation but being sober did not help the situation either so I dont know if thats saying a lot. I dont support it. They might forget that condom when they drunk. (Young, U.S.-born woman) It impairs your train of thought. Like driving a car, you aint supposed to do it. (Young, U.S.-born woman) You dont make good choices because you are not in control. (Young, U.S.-born woman) And sometimes a woman may want it right then, not saying you in a rush but ..you in the motion and your head not level with the alcohol, you may try to jump into it so thats why I usually try to keep my condoms close so [inaudi ble]. But you know sometimes you with your loved one and sometim e its just like right there bam! Somebody jump out the shower, well hello, let me shut on up. Yall know what Im trying to say. (Young, U.S.-born woman) One participant shared her experience with alcohol, drug abuse and prostitution and her impaired abilities to negotiate safe sex. Well not only men but any human being it will compromise your decision making if you use alcohol or drugs before any type of activity whether its sexual or w hatever because there is no rational thinking when you are under the influence. So yes it is a compromised state no matter what y our gender. In my experience I been under the influence of alcohol and drugs making money it didnt matter to me what they di d or how they did it except for I didnt do nothing in the butt. They told me no they didnt want to use no condom then no condom it was, but I was under the influence of drugs and alcohol and that makes a difference of course it does.
184 Substance abuse is a major risk factor fo r the transmission of HIV and other STIs. Results of this inquiry show that unlike U.S. -born male participants, female participants, some with substance abuse histories, understa nd that substance use impairs judgment and increases the risk of having unprotec ted sex and multiple sex partners. Haitian-born Women Confirming Haitian mens reports of ne gative attitudes toward condom use, Haitian women identified lack of condom use as a prevalent HIV-risk behavior among Haitian men. Contrary to the reports of Ha itian men, Haitian women identified multiple sex partners as a behavioral choice of Haitian men. An interesting dynamic in this discussion, however, were female reports that infidelity among Haitian men is relatively common and while Haitian wives may be aware of their husbands infidelity, they tend to tolerate the behavior in order to protect the integrity of their families. Similar to their U.S.-born female counterparts, Haitian-bor n women confirmed men s assertions that Haitian women often neglect to negotiate condom use during sexual encounters. Another factor that affects condom use among Haitian women is the focus on pregnancy prevention rather than disease prevention, a theme that also emerged in the U.S.-born scripts. Condom Use. Most Haitian women expresse d that within Haitian he terosexual relationships, condom use is often determined by the level of trust perceived by the partners involved. Once a certain level of trust is obta ined, condoms are deemed unnecessary. Once they get comfortable with the particular sex partner them they will stop using condoms. (Young Haitian woman)
185 Other women stated that men are suspici ous of women who negotiate condom use, believing that women who suggest condom use are unfaithful. Its a trust thing with some of them. If you are in a monogamous relationship supposedly, then if y ou ask them to use a condom its kind like, Why? Who you seeing on the side? But a lot of times its trust. (Young Haitian woman) Confirming Haitian mens perceptions that condoms are unnatural, Haitian women indicated that they often hear from their ma le Haitian partners that condoms dont feel right. I hear it doesnt feel right a lot. (Young Haitian woman) Women and Condom Use. Womens negative attitudes toward c ondom use emerged as a theme during discussions with young Haitian women (18-30 years). Similar to findings among U.S.born women, Haitian women report that among women, condoms are sometimes perceived as a barrier to sexual spontaneity and decrease the pleas urable feeling during sexual intercourse. A new theme that emerged from Haitian scripts was that not using a condom signifies a strengthened bond in a sexual relationship. A young woman who continues to use condoms in her long-term relationshi p shared the reaction she gets from her female friends. I have heard from women, Doesnt that take away from sex since you guys are together and there ar e no outside people, doesnt it take away from the spontaneity of when things happen? (Young Haitian woman) The concept of sex feeling better without condoms continued to emerge throughout the focus group discussions.
186 It just feels better without one. Sometimes you dont want youre like in a monogamous relationship or youre seeing someone for a very long time once you actually do it once or twice without a condom its really hard to want to go back to using condoms because it just feels so much better without one. (Young Haitian woman) Haitian women also indicated that not us ing a condom solidifies the bond between sex partners and signifies a hei ghtened level of tr ust and intimacy within a relationship. I think for most women its a form of a bond like an intimate bond. For the women I know its like y ou with this dude and you stop using a condom so its not li ke youre gonna be seeing Bob and John and them, its just strictly him so its kinda like a bond now and thats why most women probably dont want to use condoms because they feel more closer to their partner. (Young Haitian woman) Its like the trust has come into a relationship and now I trust you to be only with me and I am allo wing us to have sex without a condom because I know that y ou are not going to do it with anybody else. (Young Haitian woman) Haitian women are less concerned about disease prevention and more concerned about pregnancy prevention, a phenomenon th at is based in cu ltural values and socialization. Pregnancy prior to marriage with in the Haitian culture is seen as immoral, disgraceful, and reprehensible and is ofte n punished by family rejection. Therefore, emphasis is placed on oral contraceptives rather than condom use. I think with Haitian women its not so much getting a disease its getting pregnant and getting pregna nt is like the worse of the worse of the worse. When dealing with Haitian men, they put the responsibility of birth control on the women so are you on the pill. Even in Haitian movies they will be like mwen menm ki sou an grenn [Im on the pill]. As l ong as a person is on the pill then they are fine they dont have to use a condom because getting pregnant is like the worst thing that you can do. (Young Haitian woman)
187 Im 24 and thats my biggest fear. I mean. Every day at 9 oclock I take those birth control pills. I cant afford to get pregnant. Im like if I get pregnant the first thing I think about is my father just saying get out my house. And Im his only child and I can picture my father just not talking to me and just saying get out my face. And that is harder for me to imagine than the doctor saying oh you have gonorrhea. I dont care. For us [Haitians] its shame. (Young Haitian woman) Therefore, negative condom use behaviors exist among Haitian men and women. Condom use themes included concerns about th e aesthetic feel of condoms, relationship trust as a barrier to condom use, abandonment of condoms signifies heightened intimacy, and concerns for pregnancy prevention such that oral contraceptives are emphasized rather than condom use. Multiple Sex Partners. Haitian-born women reported multiple sex partners as a common behavior among Haitian men. However, if married, Haitian men tend to remain with their families while engaging in extramarital affairs. Haitian wives often are aware of their husbands infidelity but tolerate their marriages for the sake of their families and to maintain their status in the Haitian community. Haitian men cheat too but I think the difference is when it comes to black Americans and Haitian men, Haitian men they wont ever throw it back in their wifes face. Haitian men will keep it more discrete. A woman knows, a woma n is always going to know, but with Haitian men, they will still ta ke care of home and thats the thing, as long as you take care of home you can have 6 baby mamas around my house, I dont care. Long as my family and I are taken care of. (Young Haitian woman) In the Haitian culture if youre married and you are with your Haitian guy or whatever I think somehow it is more accepted for the guy to cheat. Its not like, as long as everything is discrete, I mean I come from a product of a household in which both parties
188 cheated but remained together fo r 23 years as long as my father was taking care of home my mom did not have a problem with it. And my mom knew the lady and everybody else knew the lady. Haitians, what you see is not ofte n what you get. Cause we were the perfect nuclear family, husband, wife, kids but behind closed doors it was something totally different. We always put on that front that we had everything together. (Young Haitian woman) Demonstrating promiscuity among Haitian me n, a young woman recalled the behavior of her uncle and exclaimed that sh e will not personally tolerate a partner who is unfaithful. I have an uncle he run around Haiti talkin bout I can give you twins because he had an affair with one woman and gave her twins, had an affair with another woman gave her twins, gave my aunt two sets of twins so hes te lling everybody he can give them twins. Why are you advertising that and you are married? Hes been married to my aunt for 40 years now and they have 10 kids together and he has I think 16 kids altogether. And for me growing up I was just like I can never be one of those women. And when it comes to cheating I tell people al l the time I despise cheaters, I cannot stand cheaters and even with me and my fear of commitment its because if Im with you Im with you. If you cheat I have no problem leaving you. A nd I dont wanna go through that. I cant be another stigma. Behavioral Health Alcohol and Substance Use. Haitian-born and U.S.-born women held si milar views about the influence of alcohol on mens sexual behavior. Haitian wo men reported that alcohol impairs their personal judgment and that of their male Haitian partners disabling them from even thinking about condom use. When youre drunk, not to the point where you pass out. When youre drunk to your limit, it doe s affect it. Cause you cant just say oh, let me go ahead and get a condom. I myself have been in that situation where it does af fect it. You don t think about the condom. Its like unless you on bi rth control, youve popped that pill thats about the only thing yo ull be responsible for but as far as the condom its li ke the last thing. (Young Haitian woman)
189 Cause you can be even if you ar e tipsy. I mean I dont know about anybody else but when you are tipsy, drunk or buzzed, you are kinda in a mellow state. You are just chill; you relaxed, you not trying to do anything out of the ordinary. You just wanna be you. Thats it, you just wanna chill. For a man to say yeah I can out on a condom maybe you are thinkin about it subconsciously but I dont believe that. Because something as simple as walking in a straight line you cant do. Somethi ng as simple as talking right or um knowing where you parked your car or where your friends at, you cant focus on that but y ou can focus on taking a condom, open it up, put it on the right way.. no. (Young Haitian woman) In sum, Haitian women identified several factors that increase risk for HIV transmission within the Haitian community : 1) negative attitudes toward condoms resulting in lack of condom use; 2) lack of concern and perceive d susceptibility to HIV/STI transmission; 3) multiple sex partners and; 4) alcohol use. Negative condom use attitudes are held by both Haitian men and wo men as condoms are seen as aesthetically unappealing. Moreover, non-condom use signi fies trust and monogamy in a sexual relationship. Women who nego tiate condom use may be per ceived to be disloyal thus discouraging women from discussing condom use. Of particular note is the finding that pregnancy prevention is the primary con cern for most Haitian women thus negating concerns about HIV/STI prev ention. These factors combine within the context of the socio-ecological environment to impact HIV risk within the Haitian community. Question 6: What are black womens pe rceptions of the gender and cultural norms that influence sexual behavior among black men who identify as heterosexual? The findings of this inquiry reveal that gender and cultural norms are important factors that influence sexual behaviors among black heterosexual couples. Several themes emerged that address womens perceptions of the gendered and cultural aspects of sexual behavior within black relationships. Speci fically, U.S.-born women identified social,
190 cultural, and gender-related fact ors that contribute to risky sexual behaviors in black men and women: 1) masculine ideologies, 2) sex-ratio imbalance and lack of female empowerment, 3) socialization of women and gi rls, 4) sexual abuse and trauma histories; 5) lack of a male father figure in the live s of black girls and yo ung women; 6) lack of family communication and dialogue about sexual issues and; 7) the negative influence of mainstream hip-hop culture. Haitian wome n-born identified: 1) lack of family communication, 2) differential socialization of girls and boys and; 3) the voodoo culture as important cultural and gender-related f actors influence risk behaviors among Haitian men. U.S.-born Women Masculine Ideologies. Themes of black masculine ideology emerge d as a factor that influences partner concurrency in black men. Culturally driven definitions of masculinity influence male behaviors within gendered sexual relations hips. As discussed by some women, men equate masculinity with having a high number of female sex partners. I dont think it has anything necessarily to do with the sex per se. Men from what I hear they enjoy havi ng it but I think its just to be able to say yeah man I hit this girl, I hit that girl whatever. Its just like a game for them. Its like th ey dont have anything else better to do. (Young, U.S.-born woman) Sex Ratio Imbalance/Lack of Female Empowerment. Women expressed feelings of helplessne ss to address their mens practice of having multiple partners because they feared losing their male companions. This fear is exacerbated by feelings that it is difficult to find a suitable black mate because of the sex
191 ratio imbalance that exists within the African American community which renders women powerless to negotiate safe be haviors within their relationships. I think because we outnumber men and men figures they can have as many women as they can. (Older, U.S-born woman) Like I see it too, any woman that got a booty call from a man, they going at it. They aint gon let it pass by. They aint gon just gon write that down, Ill do that to morrow. They going right at it and talk to him. (Older, U.S.-born woman) You have some women that know they man doing it and let them do it so thats why they keep doing it. (Older, U.S.-born woman) We are [responsible]. Cause most of us say well if he gon do it, let him do it. A lot of women know that their men have multiple sex partners but because they decide to have that man they just go on and settle for what they can get. (Older, U.S.-born woman) Socialization of Women and Girls. Women discussed the socialization of women and girls as a factor that contributes to womens inability to negotiate safe sex behaviors thus allowing men to continue to practice risky behaviors. The so cialization of girls to be submissive and the perfect woman or wife is a socio-cultural norm that inhibits womens abil ity to address sexual behaviors with their male partners. I agree with her that because women are who we are, we settle for the man coming and going and we know they have other partners. (Older, U.S.-born woman) It has a lot to do with self esteem. (Older, U.S.-born woman) One time for me, I was with this guy for 13 years. He had multiple sex partners. But it was just something about him. It didnt matter to me. I just wanted to be with hi m. I was in love. It didnt matter
192 to me that he had someone else he was sleeping around with but you know I just wanted to be w ith him. It didnt matter. Yes, I really thought that I needed a man. I really thought that I needed a man to be me. (Older, U.S.-born woman) It is taught to us at a young age. As African American female human beings we are gonna be home. We are gonna be the perfect woman or wife or whatever, how ever you wanna voice it. And this is a taught behavior to us as fe males. And then once we get our own way of thinking or get our own bad experiences to where we have actually had enough and we act ually are willing to change. Cause a lot of time we endure with it and we might not appreciate or like it. But until we get the strength or the wisdom or the will to change we continue on with it. But it is a behavior that is taught. (Older, U.S.-born woman) Sexual Abuse and Trauma Histories. Women with histories of childhood sexual abuse reported the impact of such abuse on their ability to successfully negotia te safe sex behaviors with their male partners. One participant who reported that sh e was unable to addre ss her partners risky sexual behaviors attributes her impaired ne gotiation skills to he r history of childhood sexual abuse. Where mine comes from I feel like is because I was raped at 12 by my stepfather and I believe that wh ere it [inability to negotiate safe sex behaviors] come from for me. I cant speak for no one else but I believe thats where it come from for me. Because after that I hated men. I hated just the thought of a man but um after years went by he was like the second guy I had been with so um cause I was scared for a long time in my young days but Im past that now. I think thats where mine comes from. (Older, U.S.-born woman) She talks about her experiences of men al ways wanting to be in control within relationships. For me, men want to be the dominant one. They wanna be in control and if theyre not in cont rol, oh man, aint nothing right.
193 Another participant shared her experience growing up in a household with domestic violence. The abuse she observed had a cripplin g effect on her relationships in adulthood. For instance as I was growing up like you know [inaudible]. My father, he used to drink like on weekends and he used to work over at the hospital. My mother was not no drinking lady. She would go to work, come back home. But when my father come in and we were kids, he would like come home and argue at my mother and that would get me so upset and I would get into a little shake and nervousness. To bring down the co mmotion, that used to hurt me so bad but there was nothing I could do to my father because I was a child and he was overruling my mother and cussing and this that and the other. That really took a toll as I was growing up. (Older, U.S.-born woman) Lack of Male Father Figure. Other women reported the lack of a male fa ther figure as an important factor in determining their levels of empowerment to address sexua l issues with their male partners. Some women argued that the absen ce of a father led them to remain in relationships that put them at risk for HIV infection. I think that with Afro Americans th at we come from homes that its not both parents and we didnt have a father figure, someone that you can look up to and know that you are safe. We come from broken homes Its just a cycle that goes on and on and you pass it to your children. Its just a cu rse that needs to be broken. (Older, U.S.-born woman) One woman described the hurt she experien ced by not knowing her father and her failed attempts to meet the man who helped create her. She admitted that she compensates for this lost relationship with her father by establishing sexual relationships with different men. I was, Im like I didnt have a fath er, didnt know him. I knew his name, you know, I knew my grandparents name. Never seen him. He never came in my life and my mama she was a strong woman but its just I was missing my dad. You know, nothing could take that place of my dad. And I told her, when I came home I said
194 mama I said look I said theres one thing I wanna do before I leave this earth I need to see my dad. I got home, I said mama I want to see my dad and she said well well l ook for him. I seen his aunt, she was married to his uncle, and sh e said girl I aint seen you in a long time and I said, my mama got me traveling all over the United States. She said you know your dad passed. I was like oh man no. Here I come home to look for my dad to find out now hes gone. I cant tell him the th ings I wanna tell him. I cant see his face. My mama always tell me look in the mirror youll see his face. I said when I look in the mirror I see you, I dont see my dad. I dont know what he look like so I cant say that. I say all I see is you. And she like you s till see your daddy. And Im like mom, you might see my dad but I d ont cause you know what he look like. I dont. Lack of Family Communication about Sexual Health. Similar to the findings from U.S.-bor n male interviews, focus group findings reveal that U.S.-born women in the study were denied sex education within the family structure. Due to high levels of religiosity and taboos against sexua l activity, the primary messages women received from their families and mothers pertained to abstinence and you better not get pregnant. When I was younger my mother rea lly really sheltered me a lot. She kept me away from everything. She said no sex period. So of course there was no sex, but when that time comes nobody taught me, nobody informed me on what to do. Nobody told me what a condom was until actually high school is really when I um, junior or senior year. I didnt lose my virginity until actually I went off to college. So that whole time I was ju st like ok, just no sex. But I wish I was informed at an earlie r age by being a female period even though my mother is very into the Lord you know what reality is and whats going on in civiliza tion you know in public schools as well to especially whats going on down here in the South. (Young, U.S.-born woman) A discussion not so much. I can r ecall the whole birds and the bees talk when I was 9. It really wasn t a talk. My mom just gave me a book and was like here [laughter all]. As far as a discussion as I got older it was more like you bett er not get pregnant because my mother was a teenage mother and sex was the last thing on my mind as a child of a teenage mother When I was 14 she took me to
195 the clinic to get birth control and I didnt even know, I dont even think I really fully understood what a penis was and where it went at the age of 14 because I was just a little girl, a kid at 14 years old. So it wasnt something that we sat down and talked about (Young, U.S.-born woman) I was more afraid of my mom finding out that I had sex versus because she thinks the guy I was w ith for 5 years took my virginity, it was one before so I didnt never te ll her that. I lost it at 16 but at age 14-15 my friends was telli ng me about it, oh its good oh its that. But my mom always to ld me your boyfriends is your books so I was always afraid of my mom you know to go to her and tell her I wanna have sex, Im thinking about having sex. And I didnt want to disappoint my dad. (Young, U.S.-born woman) Older U.S.-born women (43-65 years) ec hoed similar views about the lack sex education within their families. When asked about the level and types of sex education they received within their homes they responded as shown below: I had zero When I was in high school, through my hea lth classes. Thats how I really got my schooling, through my health classes I wasnt taught. My mom didnt teach us stuff like that. My mom was too religious. I was born in the 50s and then, they didnt talk about sex. We didnt talk about sex because you would get slappe d in the mouth. That was a nasty word. My mother was always the religious type. We didnt know nothing about no sex or none of that. I lear ned that when I got older. The only reason I got on birth control was because of my cycle to regulate it. I dont like those pills at all because they made me sick anyway. The worst thing I coulda did was when I went to my mother and told her I might be pregnant. I should have never have said nothing. It was like I was the wo rsest child ever since. So I went to that rebellious state and started acting all out of control and everything you wanna call it in school. Thats how y ou do though, if you can t talk to your own family, who can you talk to? Influence of Hip-Hop Culture.
196 Within the societal level of the socioecological context, women identified hiphop as a cultural phenomenon that has a significant effect on male and female sexual behaviors. Womens perceptions about rap and hip-hop confirm the responses received in phase I of the study from male study participants. Similar to the mens accounts of the effect of mainstream hiphop music and media, U.S.-bor n women perceive hip-hop to have a negative effect on the conceptua lization of sexual behavior, definitions of masculinity, sexual expectations of women, and actual sexual behavior. It gives men a lot of ideas both men and women a lot of ideas to start makin them do all kind of crazy stuff. (Older, U.S.-born woman) Women expressed that they too were influenced by sexually demeaning and derogatory songs. The younger group of U.S. -born women made reference to popular hip-hop songs such as Becky that explicit ly addresses womens role in oral sex. At first they promotin oral sex and this and that but after a while its repetitive and you st art singing that becky. I dont know if its the beat but you know just like having all the repetitive always playing, always on the radio, they got the video. But having it always out there at first you dont connect with until you constantly hear it and then you connect on kind of level. (Young, U.S.-born woman) Im telling you cause when you hear it over and over it gets stuck in your head. If they hearing it theyll be living it like they do everything else. (Young, U.S.-born woman) I swore up and down that I hated that song Girls around the world and all of a sudden I was like [singing], Im a open up and something that .. and Im si nging along and Im like oh my God am I really blasting this. Is somebody thinking like I cant believe Im singing it. (Young, U.S.-born woman)
197 U.S.-born women identified family, re lational and commun ity factors that influence sexual behavior within the U.S. -born black community. Factors such as masculine ideologies, male-to-female ra tio imbalance, sexual abuse histories, socialization, absence of male father figures, deficiencies in family communications, and negative influence of the main stream hip-hop music emerged as primary themes within the exploration of cultural and gender nor ms that influence sexual behavior. Haitian-born Women Within focus groups with Haitian women, three major themes emerged in reference to gender and culture norms that in fluence male and female sexual behaviors: 1) lack of family communication about sexual health and risk beha viors; 2) cultural association of HIV/AIDS with voodoo and; 3) differential soci alization of girls and boys. Lack of Family Communication about Sexual Health. Most Haitian women described Haitian cu lture as traditional and conservative. Therefore, Haitian parents do not discuss sexual health or behavior with their children. Issues such as condom use and HIV risk a nd protective behaviors are seldom discussed within the family environment. Haitians this is their mentality when their daughter get their first period its ok you have your period, you get pregnant, you get kicked out End of the discussion. Now as far as the men go for my male cousins they didnt get talked to about sex ever. (Young, Haitian woman) Noting that parents even opposed sex educati on in schools one participant took measures into her own hands to participate in sex education classes. I remember in middle school we had signed a consent form [for sex education] and I forged it b ecause my mom was like no and my dad didnt want me to hear anything about it and I forged my moms signature.
198 (Young, Haitian woman) Like sex was taboo pretty much. If you ask about it [parent would ask, why, are you having sex? Tampons, you couldnt use cause you would be seen as not a virgin. Attempts to shelter children a nd especially Haitian girls fr om exposure to sexual activity prevented women from taking thei r daughters for gynecological care. You couldnt go to the GYN bec ause and thats another thing I had a lot of friends who were havin g sex and they needed to go to the gynecologist but you cant. You cant tell your mom I have to go to the gynecologist. [She would ask] Why? You havin sex? (Young Haitian woman) Haitian women indicated that their male count erparts also did not receive sex education from their parents. Instead, they l earned from siblings and peers. The Haitian males that I have de alt with Not even their own fathers. Nothing. They didnt le arn about condoms unless they heard it from their big brothers, older cousins, or in school. (Young Haitian woman) The Role of Voudou. The role of voudou in the c onceptualization of HIV/AI DS emerged as a primary theme in the Haitian focus groups. Haitian-born women explained that Haitians held nonsexual, non-biomedical concepts of HIV tran smission, often believing that HIV is caused by someone putting voudou on you. In the African American culture, HIV is associated with the down low brothers. With Haitians, HIV and AIDS are associated with voudou. Somebody did something to you. (Young, Haitian woman) Its not necessarily youre having unprotected sex or youre having sex with this person, that person. If you have what we call SIDA or AIDS you messed with somebody and someone is getting you back or someone put voudou on you. They put something on you, it has nothing to do with sex it has something to do with voudou. (Young, Haitian woman)
199 You dont really have it [HIV], it s because of the voudou. I cant tell you how many times I have he ard the story especially for the Haitian women it a defense mechanism especially knowing that my husband has cheated on me, had unprotected sex with some woman and she burned him. Id rath er think that the lady got jealous and then gave him voudou and just put the AIDS on him. And thats what they say, its voudou. They dont even talk about that, they wont even talk about AI DS or anything in the church because, for what, its not something that you get, its someone sent it to you. (Young, Haitian woman) They openly talk about voudou. Like for instance, my aunt, my moms sister died a year ago and she died of AIDS and my mom knew it was AIDS. Like my immediat e family knew it was of AIDS but the rest of people jus cause sh e was involved with a lot with different guys, cause she was the one of the five that wasnt really married or with anybody and she was just one of those free spirits supposedly, thats what they call it, and it was of AIDS. Like through the doctor and everything it was confirmed it was AIDS but everybody else just covered it up, oh you know she was involved with too many people, it was something on her. And my mom knew it was AIDS but she continued to say, oh they put something on her, she was involved too much with too many people and stuff like that. They didn t acknowledge the fact that it was HIV. (Young, Haitian woman) Differential Socialization of Girls and Boys. A phenomenon that may not be entirely uni que to the Haitian culture, differential socialization of girls and boys, emerged as a recurrent theme throughout discussions with young Haitian women. The women expressed cultural and gender-based attitudes whereby boys are expected to be sexually expe rienced while girls are expected to abstain until marriage. As such, male early sexual initiation is accepted and even expected within Haitian culture. As women explained, a sexually inexperienced man may be viewed being homosexual, a sexual behavior that is not accepted within the Haitian culture.
200 Women believe that these cultural attit udes influence risky sexual behaviors among Haitian men. If a girl doesnt have sex she is a good girl but if a man does not have sex oh hes gay. And I think a lot of cultures its like that. (Young, Haitian woman) They [men] are allowed to do w hatever they want and so that mentality with sex when you think about it, its like I do what I want, I can have sex at 14, 15. There s really no consequence of a mother finding out. Cause if a mother finds out her son is having sex OK. A lot of my male cous ins were having sex at 14, 15, 16 years old in the house. The mother will cuss the girl out and call her a whore instead of calli ng the son a whore and Im like what? In my experience they are free to do what they want. (Young, Haitian woman) My male cousins what can I say. I remember one day I walked into my cousins house and he had condoms on public display just sitting right there and Im sure his mom walks in and out of his room do laundry and his condoms were on public display and I think it was more for her, he is having sex and I really dont care as long as he doesnt get somebody pregnant. (Young, Haitian woman) Study results show that Haitian women be lieve that cultural and gender norms within the Haitian community influence sexual behaviors among heterosexual Haitian men. Of particular note are the issues identified by female Haitian study participants such as: 1) lack of family communication about sexu al health and risk be haviors; 2) cultural association of HIV/AIDS with voodoo and; 3) differential soci alization of girls and boys. These factors are engrained within the fabric if the Haitian culture a nd continue to persist even as HIV/AIDS becomes more prev alent within the Haitian community.
201 Question 7: What are black womens per ceptions of the ways in which black mens sexual behaviors affect their own health? Both Haitian-born and U.S.-born women de monstrated an understanding their health is directly affected by the sexual behaviors of their male sex partners. As discussed in previous sections women identified several risk behaviors practiced by their partners such as multiple sex partners and lack of condom use. Women discussed the idea that these risk behaviors may have signi ficant implications for their own health. I would say with Haitian men, not al l but the majority or the one with the true Haitian mentality is again they dont, a lot of people dont know about condoms and so its like I have this woman, this wife whatever and Im not using protection with her but then I have this side piece and Im not using protection with her and so forth and they dont think about that Because the same thing goes back to us saying pregnancy, t hats all they ca re about is not getting the mistress pregnant or if they do get the mistress pregnant having to pay for her baby and then for his family. But they dont even think ab out these other things because the mistress who is she sleeping with? You k now, who is she having her own affair with and so forth? And I th ink thats where the problem lies because I think a lot of Haitian men are not aware of the diseases that are out there or they only k now of HIV. Thats all they know of. Its either pregnancy of HIV. But many of them and I think its that whole stigma of women where we are supposed to be quiet and nonsexual beings so if youre having sex with a woman, she is not having sex with another man. A nd she is clean, compared to the reality is she could be sl eeping with three other guys and sleeping with you. So thats how I see it. (Young, Haitian woman) Demonstrating the possible effects of ri sky sexual behavior, a young Haitian woman shared the experience of some of her friends. I know a lot of girls who get burne d literally when they are in the monogamous relationship with th eir boyfriend and they go for their pap or whatever oh you have gonorrhea. How did I get that? And a lot of them feel lik e betrayed yet some women still will go back to that same partner and not use a condom so I would say some women just dont like using it period.
202 U.S.-born women also identified some of th e potential consequences of having a male partner who practices HIV-risk behaviors. There could be a lot of consequences. I mean STDs, HIV, pregnancy. (Young U.S.-born woman) Drama with the pregnancy. Its the grass is always greener until you get on that side. (Young U.S.-born woman) Findings reveal that women have a good understanding of the manner in which mens sexual behaviors affect their own healt h. They perceive risk for HIV, STDs, and pregnancy as the major health and re productive consequences for women.
203 CHAPTER FIVE: DISCU SSION AND CONCLUSIONS Chapter five is divided into four secti ons. Section I discusses the summary of the study results. Section II analyses findings within a theore tical context. Section III provides a synthesis of the research findings for the two phases of the study, and outlines the strengths and weaknesses of the inquiry. Se ction IV describes the implications of the research findings for public health educati on, practice and research and concludes with final comments. Section I: Summary of Study Results In sum, study results reveal that intrap ersonal, socio-ecologi cal and behavioral health factors are critical within the holisti c context of HIV-risk and protective behaviors among heterosexually identified U.S.-born a nd Haitian-born men and women. Comprised of in-depth interviews among U.S.-born and Haitian-born men, Phase I of the study explored knowledge, attitudes and beliefs a bout HIV, actual risk behaviors practiced by black men, and cultural and gender norms that influence sexual beha vior. The findings of this inquiry show that while high levels of HIV knowledge, perceived severity, and perceived seriousness exist within U.S.born and Haitian-born populations, they do not translate into safer sex behaviors. Theories of HIV conspiracy also play a key role in the conceptualization of HIV among U. S.-born and Haitian-born men. Among U.S.-born men, findings reveal hi gh-risk behaviors such multiple sex partners, lack of condom use, and substance use prior to sexual activity. U.S.-born men identified the following barriers to condom use: a) trust in a sexual partner; b) use of
204 alternate forms of birth control; c) perceive d decrease in sexual pleasure; d) desire for sexual spontaneity and; e) unavailability of condoms during a sexual encounter. Moreover, U.S.-born men did not perceive alcohol use prior to sexual intercourse to be inhibitive of their ability to think about and use condoms. Among Haitian men, multiple sex partners and substance use were not commonly reported, however, lack of condom use was c onsistently reported as a preferred sexual behavior. Factors that presented barriers to condom use for Haitian men were: a) trust in a sexual partner; b) perceived faithfulness w ithin a relationship; c) decreased sexual pleasure and; d) the natural feeling obt ained without condoms. Moreover, both U.S.born and Haitian-born men were less likely to use condoms if their female partners held negative attitudes to condom use. Cultural and gender norms play a signifi cant role in the adaptation of HIV protective behaviors. The results if this inqui ry reveal that exosystem factors such as family and peer norms, and macrosystem fact ors such as hip-hop culture and cultural attitudes toward bisexuality and homosexua lity present challenges to HIV prevention within the black community. Pertaining to gender roles, while women seem to be increasingly financially inde pendent and share financial d ecision-making roles with their male partners, they are not likely to make condom use decisions or negotiate condom use within their sexual relations hips. Both sub-groups reported low levels of family communication about sexual behavior often related to embarrassment and religious beliefs; a highly negative influence of hi p-hop culture; and negative attitudes toward homosexuality and bisexuality wh ich may lead black men to s ecretly engage in high-risk same-gender behaviors.
205 Conducted among U.S.-born and Haitian-born women, Phase II of the inquiry explored black womens, a) perceptions of the black mens HIV risk behaviors; b) perceptions of the gender and cultural norms that influence black mens sexual behaviors and; c) perceptions of the ways in which black mens sexual behaviors affect their own health. Focus group discussions among wome n confirmed the HIV risk behaviors reported by black men including multiple se x partners, lack of condom use, and substance use prior to sexual intercourse. Interestingly, women al so described their personal aversion to condom use stating th at condoms produced discomfort and were sexually unappealing. Some women reported a de sire to trap their male partners by deliberately attempting to conceive. Within focus groups with Haitian women, the emergent themes regarding gender and cultural norms that influence sexual be haviors were, lack of family communication about sexual health and risk behaviors; cu ltural association of HIV/AIDS with voudou and; differential socialization of girls and boys. U.S.-born women identified family, relational and community factors that influe nce sexual behavior within the U.S.-born black community. Factors such as masculine id eologies, male-to-female ratio imbalance, sexual abuse histories, socializa tion, absence of male father fi gures, deficiencies in family communications, and the negative influence of hip-hop culture recurred as primary themes around cultural and gender norms. Finally, both U.S-born and Haitian-born women perceived that black mens risky sexua l behaviors may have detrimental effects on their physical and mental well-being.
206 Section II: Theoretical Analysis Analysis of the Study Results within the C ontext of the Socio-ecological Model of STD Risk and Protective Factors Results suggest that multiple factors interact to produce a context of HIV risk among black men and women. The socio-ecologi cal model of STD risk and protective factors (illustrated in Chapter 2) offers a comprehensive framework within which the multisystem risk factors that contribute to th e HIV epidemic in the African American and Haitian communities can be assessed. As this inquiry revealed, it is insufficient to analyze HIV risk behaviors within the context of intrapersonal factor s alone, as social, ecological, cultural, gender and behavioral h ealth factors are also key to understanding HIV risk behaviors. I or Microsystem Level. Within the innermost I sphere (microsystem) of the model, individual and psychological factors operate to influence be havior (DiClemente et al., 2005). To more closely assess intrapersonal level factors, te nets of the Health Belief Model were used. Study findings indicate that U.S.-born and Haitian-born men possess high levels of knowledge, perceived severity, and percei ved seriousness about HIV and AIDS. In addition, both subgroups hold conspiracy belief s about HIV and AIDS that might impact their receptivity to prevention messages and implementation of safer habits. Findings indicate that intrapersonal f actors may not translate into sa fer sex behaviors as U.S.-born and Haitian-born men with high HIV/AIDS knowledge levels did not automatically demonstrate safer sex practices. Further, some men in this study held nega tive attitudes to condom use which they attributed to: 1) the aesthetic feeling of condoms; 2) trust and faithfulness in a female
207 partner and; 3) lack of perceived susc eptibility and heightened concerns for contraception. Very importan tly, these findings emphasize th e need to consider socioecological influences on sexual behavior Among U.S.-born wo men, individual level experiences and personal factors such as ch ildhood sexual abuse, trauma, and depression increased engagement in risky sexual behavi ors. This finding highlights the need for specific strategies to address and alleviate th e effects of these stressors in the lives of black women. Family and Relational or Mesosystem Level. The family sphere (mesosystem) refers to th e familial influences on behaviors. Study findings show that family dynamics, structure, and support have important influences on sexual behavior. U.S.-born and Haitian-born men identified several familial factors that influence their sexual behaviors such as: 1) lack of family communication about sexual issues; 2) family pressure to ward early sex initiation among men and; 3) failed relationships or bonding between fath ers and sons. Female study participants reported similar family influences: 1) dearth of family dialogue about sexual behavior and; 2) lack of a male fa ther figure. Similarly, the relational sphere (mesosystem) exerts influence on HIV and other STI risk. Acco rding to DiClemente et al. (2005), the relational sphere refers to partner communication about sexu al issues. Findings reveal that men and women often find it difficult to discuss sexual history and disease status with their intimate partners. Voicing her inabil ity to discuss sexual history with her male partners, one U.S.-born woman shared: As responsible as I claim to be and as I would like to think I am with my body I have never asked that question [sexual history and disease status]. I have wanted to because I get tested every year so but it is such an uncomfort able question. But if I can be bold
208 enough to be having sex with somebody, I know that I have the right to ask them you know who hav e you slept with? But that is a difficult question to ask somebody. Combined with other risk f actors such as inconsistent condom use, the lack of communication about sexual history introduces an additional level of potential risk among black heterosexual couples. Community/Peers or Exosystem Level. The next sphere of influence is the community/peers level and is synonymous with Bronfenbrenners (1979) exosystem. With in this level, factors such as the drug culture, condom availability, peers norms, high ra tes of STIs and social capital interact to influence sexual behavior. Study findings reve al that among U.S.-born and Haitian born men, peer norms and the drug and alcohol culture exert influe nces on their sexual behaviors. Societal or Macrosystem Level. The societal level includes the broader so cial and cultural values and beliefs that interact with the othe r spheres of influence. Based on th e results of this inquiry, several societal factors affect sexual behaviors am ong the study participants. As reported by male study participants, critical influencing factor s include: 1) media and hip-hop culture and; 2) cultural attitudes toward homosexuals and bisexuals such as homophobia. Among women, important macro-level factors include: 1) gender roles; 2) cultural differential socialization of girls and boys ; 3) sex ratio imbalance in the black community; 4) hip-hop culture; 5) cultural defined masculine ideologies; 6) cultural association of HIV/AIDS and voudou [reported by Haitian-born women].
209 Analysis of Study Results within the C ontext of the Theory of Gender and Power Used to examine the gendered relationshi ps of black heterosexual couples, the theory of gender and power guided the a ssessment of gender roles within intimate relationships. Findings reveal that while women share in fi nancial decision-making, they are unlikely to make decisions about condom use. Womens inability or hesitation to negotiate condom use may be grounded in so cial constructions of gender roles that socialize girls to be passive and boys to be sexually aggressive. Women are often taught to defer to men in the sexual decision-maki ng process (El-Bassel et al., 2009). Moreover, the sex-ratio imbalance in the black comm unity exacerbates power inequities between black men and women. Fearing neglect and abandonment by scarce black men, women may decide against condom negotiation a nd safer sex practices. In addition, knowing their high demand, black men may engage in high-risk behaviors such as multiple sex partners, exercising their power and control ov er black womens lack of partner options. These social constructions a nd gendered dynamics impact wo mens abilities to protect themselves from HIV. In sum, the findings of this inquiry demonstrate the im portance of socioecological influences on sexual behaviors. While intrapersonal factors are relevant, increased efforts must be made to continue to assess and address the multisystem context of risk that contributes to the HIV/AIDS epidemic in the black community. The socioecological framework provides a comprehensive approach within which HIV risk can be addressed. As shown by the study findings, mu ltiple factors inter act to produce an environment of risk. HIV prevention scie nce and practice must therefore utilize multilevel approaches to address the HI V epidemic in the black community.
210 Section II: Synthesis of Research Findings Phase I of the study was designed to addre ss the following research objectives: 1) To understand the intrapersonal factors (knowledge, attitudes a nd beliefs) that influence HIV-risk behaviors in subgroups of black me n (U.S.-born and Haitian-born) who identify as heterosexual and; 2) To unde rstand the socio-cultural and be havioral health factors that influence HIV risk behaviors in subgroups of black men (U.S.-bor n and Haitian-born) who identify as heterosexual. Phase II of the study was designed to explore black womens attitudes and perceptions about black mens sexual be haviors. Using focus group methods, the following objective was assessed: To discover how black women conceptualize and perceive the socio-cultural, intrapersonal, and behavioral factors that influence black mens HIV-risk behaviors. Research findings are synthesized with the juxtaposition of the findings from Phases I and II relative to each topic assessed. Knowledge, Attitudes and Beliefs about HIV/AIDS Study findings reveal that U.S.-born and Haitian-born men possess high levels of knowledge about HIV/AIDS. Overall, they are aware of the risk and protective factors associated with HIV transmission and are cogn izant of the outcomes of HIV infection. Men identified HIV risk factors such as unpr otected sex, injection drug use, multiple sex partners, lack of education, and homosexualit y. Protective behaviors such as abstinence, condom use, open communication, monogamy an d abstaining from injection drug use emerged in male-focused discussions. Tenets of the Health Belief Model (HBM) emerged in the sexual scripts of the male study partic ipants as both U.S.-born and Haitian-born black men perceive HIV/AIDS to be a serious and severe disease that is ultimately fatal.
211 While this study did not assess all the constructs of the HBM, findings reveal that high levels of knowledge, perceived seriousness, and perceived severity did not translate into safer sex behaviors for black heterose xual men. In fact, findings show that male study participants practice risky sexual be haviors such as multiple sex partners and inconsistent or lack of condom use with 47% of U.S.-born men reporting multiple sex partners, 53% of U.S.-born men reporting in consistent or no condom use and 86% of Haitian-born men reporting inconsistent or no condom use. While the high levels of HIV knowledge among the study population is not a su rprising finding, it is discouraging to note that more 25 years after the HIV virus was first identified, high levels of risk behaviors are being practiced within the study population. Male study participants al so did not emphasize the importance of HIV testing. While HIV testing initiatives have been disseminated widely by the CDC and other national organizations, study participants may not perceive their susceptibility to HIV or may fear receiving a positive HIV status. As HIV prevention models move towards routine HIV testing in health care, these ga ps in HIV testing awareness need to be addressed. Study findings suggest that th e HIV epidemic cannot be viewed as an individuallevel phenomenon that can be addressed solely with individual-lev el interventions and programs. Rather, an ecological approach mu st be used to adequately address the multiple factors that interact to create an environment of risk.
212 Conspiracy Beliefs An exploration of mens beliefs abou t HIV/AIDS revealed high levels of conspiracy beliefs among the study population. These beliefs ranged along a continuum ranging from beliefs that HIV was created to control and ultimately destroy the black population, to beliefs that the federal governme nt has developed a cure for HIV that is accessible only by the wealthy and is de liberately withheld from the poor black community. An important finding related to cons piracy beliefs is that these beliefs were not confined to men with low educational or literacy levels. Many of the participants who endorsed conspiracy beliefs had higher educ ational levels includi ng college degrees. Interestingly, discussions with black women did not confirm these beliefs of conspiracy. In fact, black women rejected conspiracy belie fs indicating their surp rise that black men believed these theories. This finding is consis tent with previous studies that men exhibit stronger HIV conspiracy beliefs than women (Klonoff & Landrine 1999; Bogart & Thorburn, 2005). Further, mens conspiracy beliefs may be linked to more frequent experiences with racial discrimination and mo re recent experiences of racism (Klonoff & Landrine, 1999). Black mens feelings of conspiracy are em bedded within structural processes such as racism, discrimination, racial/ethnic oppres sion, and social cont rol. HIV conspiracy beliefs may present unique challenges for HIV prevention efforts. Root ed in mistrust of the medical system, conspiracy beliefs may further manifest into distrust of HIV prevention and treatment information dissemina ted by the health care system. Further, individuals who endorse cons piracy beliefs may be suspicious of HIV prevention recommendations such as condom use (Boga rt & Thorburn, 2005). HIV education and
213 prevention efforts must therefore consider th ese macrosystem factors that directly impact attitudes and beliefs about HIV. Gender-spe cific HIV prevention pr ograms that discuss conspiracy beliefs are needed for hetero sexual black men. These programs should be conducted by culturally competent black men and women to provide an open forum for the discussion of experiences of racial disc rimination, distrust of the government, AIDS conspiracy and HIV prevention. Interventions such as Nia, a video-based, small group level intervention to educate African American men about HI V/AIDS can be utilized to address beliefs about AIDS conspiracy and the importance of safer sex within a culturally competent framework (Kalichman, Cherry & Browne-Sperling, 1999). The inquiry found that among Haitian men, th e historic labeling of Haitians as carriers of HIV is offensive. Haitian men expressed their discontent with the discrimination and stereotyping they have expe rienced over time. These attitudes must be considered within the contex t of HIV prevention targeted to the Haitian community, as feelings of recrimination ma y create barriers to acceptance of HIV prevention messages. Efforts must be made to bridge the divide be tween historic discrimina tion, mistrust of the health care system among Haitians, and current HIV prevention efforts. Interventions such as Nia (Kalichman et al., 1999) should be adapted and tested for cultural relevance for the Haitian male population. Therefore, gender-specific, culturally appropriate HIV prevention programs are ne eded within black subgroup communities to appropriately disseminate prevention messages. HIV Risk Behaviors among Black Men As previously noted, although male study participants portrayed high HIV/AIDS knowledge levels, perceived severity, and perc eived seriousness of the disease, their
214 sexual behaviors were not reflective of know ledge levels. U.S.-born men reported risk taking behaviors such as multiple sex partne rs, lack of condom use or inconsistent condom use, and alcohol and substance use and abuse. Among Haitian men, lack of condom use or inconsistent condom use emerge d as the primary risk taking behavior. Multiple Sex Partners. Sexual scripts of U.S.-born men rev ealed that intrapersonal and sociopsychological factors contribute to the practice of partner concurrency. Needing a sense of personal validation of manhood, men seek to engage in intimate relationships with multiple women. Multiple sex partners may also be a direct result of the sex-ratio imbalance in the black community as heterose xual men may take advantage of their high demand (Ferguson et al., 2006). U.S.-born and Haitian-born women confirmed that their personal experiences reflect partner concurrency within their sexual relationships. Haitian-born women also indicated that w ithin the Haitian community, having multiple sex partners is a common be havior even within marital relationships. This behavior speaks to deeper cultural and societal infl uences that dictate definitions of manhood. Traditional notions of masculinity may fuel partner concurrency as male behavior is traditionally defined by sexual assertiv eness and multiple sex partners (Bowleg, 2004). The findings of this inquiry reveal that tr aditional masculine ideo logies continue to dictate the sexual behaviors of black men. Me n in this study, particularly U.S.-born men, validate their masculinity through risky sexua l behaviors such as partner concurrency. Societal and cultural concepts of masculinity are macrosystem level factors that must be addressed within a structural context. To addr ess definitions of masculinity, a shift in the thinking of acceptable male behavior vers us female behavior is necessary. This
215 deconstruction of the definition of masculinity begins with the soci alization of boys and girls by reinforcing the idea that sexual pr owess is not a defining masculine quality. These beliefs are rooted within the social fa bric of our society a nd addressing these deep rooted beliefs will require a multifaceted approach that considers the ecological factors that play a role in the current ideolo gies of masculinity and femininity. Interventions at the community level can be gin to address these traditional notions of masculinity. Community-based implemen tation of interventions such as Nia described above (Kalichman et al., 1999) that target black heterosexual men are important. Adaptation of these programs shoul d include key elements that address male perceptions and definitions of manhood. These interventions can begin to deconstruct current notions of masculinity by presenti ng alternative approaches to how sexual relationships are conceptualized by black me n. Interventions must educate men to deemphasize male sexual prowess and multiple se x partners. Deconstruction of traditional masculine ideologies must also occur within the family unit. Parents and guardians of black children and youth should be engaged in interventions that teach them how to educate their children and especially boys to devalue multiple sex partners and extensive sexual experience. Public health resear chers and practitioners should build on interventions such as ImPACT (Informed Pa rents and Children Together) by focusing on parental education and activities that enhance parents abilities to discuss appropriate male and female sexual behaviors within th e context of HIV prevention (Stanton et al., 2004).
216 Condom use. While consistent condom use continues to be the most effective HIV prevention method besides abstinence, the study found that inconsistent or no condom use is normative sexual behavior among some U.S. -born and Haitian-born black men who participated in the study. When condoms ar e used, pregnancy and disease prevention are the primary motivating factors. These findings are consistent with t hose of other studies that show low levels of condom use am ong heterosexual men (e.g. Bowleg, 2004; Flood, 2003; Harawa et al., 2006). Male study partic ipants identified eight main themes in describing their non-use of condoms: 1) c ondoms are not immediately available at a sexual encounter; 2) pe rceived trust in a sexual partne r deters condom use; 3) condoms make sexual intercourse less pleasurable; 4) use of alternate forms of birth control overrides condom use; 5) lack of sexual s pontaneity with condoms; 6) women have negative attitudes to condom use; 7) condom s create an unnatural f eeling during sexual intercourse and; 8) condoms are not endorsed by religious be liefs (Catholic religion). Men reported that they are less likely to use condoms if they are not immediately available during a sexual encounter. While understanding the risk of having unprotected sex, men and their female partners are unabl e to postpone sexual in tercourse if condoms are not readily availabl e. While condoms were found to be affordable for the male study sample, men reported that they forget to car ry condoms with them or do not think about condoms prior to sexual activity. These findi ngs indicate that condom use may not be important within mens conceptualization of sexual intercourse. Seemingly, condoms are not considered until the point of vaginal pene tration. HIV education e fforts must continue to emphasize the importance of condom use as a key component of everyday life and
217 address the significance of men and women carrying condoms and strategically placing them in areas where sexual activity is likely. Men reported that they are less likely to use condoms if they have developed a certain level of trust within their relationshi ps. Study results reveal that men discontinue condom use with a regular or steady partner when they perceive that trust has been developed. Condom use is even equated to lack of trust and casual sex. Therefore, using condoms with a steady sex partner denotes infi delity and distrust, making condom use a negative practice within a pe rceived monogamous relations hip. In addition, condom use is deterred by the use of alternate forms of birth control. Male st udy partners frequently referred to the pill indicating that if their partners used other forms of birth control, condoms are less likely to be used. An overarching theme was the emphasis placed on birth control rather than HI V and other STI prevention. While birth control is important, it seems to be the primary sexual concer n for many black heterosexual couples, overriding concerns for HIV and other STI prevention. Younger male study participants expre ssed concerns of fatherhood and the financial stress of procreation. However, the responsibility for birth control is placed on the female partner with expectations that she will take some form of contraception. Men expressed that if their partners took oral co ntraceptives or other forms of birth control such as the Nuva Ring they were less likely to use condoms. HIV education and prevention efforts must address condom use w ithin the context of contraception. Men and boys must be educated on the importance of male controlled forms of birth control to diminish dependence on female controlled met hods. Just as female controlled methods of HIV and other STI protection are needed, male controlled methods of birth control such
218 as the male condom must be emphasized. The male condom is often marketed as primarily an HIV/STI prevention method and wh ile this information is critical, condoms must be presented within th e context of birth control among populations that emphasize contraception over HIV/STI prevention. The dialogue around condom use should emphasize not only its protective properties but also its cont raceptive properties especially when used with other forms of birth control. The theme of the aesthetic feeling of c ondoms emerged as an important barrier to condom use. Male participants expressed th eir perceptions that condoms detracted from the pleasurable feeling of vaginal sexual in tercourse. Commenting on their preference to go raw, men indicated that condoms decr ease penile sensitivity during sexual intercourse. This emphasis on penile pleasure is rooted within a larger social and cultural context whereby sexual intercourse is char acterized by intense se xual pleasure for the male partner through vaginal penetration. With in the broader societal framework, female sexual pleasure is deemphasized, while male pleasure is the optimal goal of sexual intercourse. HIV prevention and education e fforts must emphasize the importance of men appreciating less intens e physical pleasure through vagina l intercourse and highlight the benefits of less penetrative sexual activities such as mutu al protected masturbation and protected oral sex. Haitian men echoed condom use concerns such as the unnatural feeling of condoms. Viewed as an artificial, forei gn object, older (45-58 years) Haitian men especially were averse to condom use. In a ddition, older Haitian me n did not advocate for condom use since their religious Catholic aff iliation does not endorse the use of condoms. These findings indicate that cu lturally tailored approaches are needed to address Haitian
219 beliefs about condoms and sexual intercourse. C onsideration must also be given to the religious beliefs among Haitians that ma y deter positive thinking about condoms. Study findings demonstrate that men s condom use behaviors are largely determined by their female pa rtners attitudes to ward condom use. An emerging theme throughout discussions of male condom use behavior was womens negative attitudes toward condom use. Men frequently reporte d that their female partners objected to condom use thus creating an a dditional barrier to protecte d sexual intercourse. According to male study participants, women fail to ne gotiate condom use and even encourage their partners not to use condoms. Men perceive that these condom use attitudes in female partners are rooted in desire s for pregnancy, an event that may create a more permanent bond with their male partners. Men also asse rted that women did not support condom use and often complained that It dont give you the same feelin . Focus groups among Haitian-born and U.S.born women confirmed mens scripts regarding womens attitudes toward condoms. Themes regarding womens negative attitudes to condom use included: 1) condoms created physiological or vaginal discomfort; 2) low self-esteem and depression resulting in womens inability to negotiate condom use; 3) desires for pregnancy and; 4) tr ust in a male partner. Findings reveal that womens attitudes toward condom use must be addressed within an ecological framework that considers the social, psychological, stru ctural and biomedical factors that might produce these negative attitudes. HIV educat ion efforts among women must highlight methods of making condom use less discomforting. Emphasis must be placed on the use of water-based lubricants to minimize vagi nal discomfort during sexual intercourse. HIV prevention models must also consider m acrosystem factors such as unemployment,
220 discrimination and other chronic stressors th at may lead to depr ession and low selfesteem among women. Interventions such as Sister to Sister and The Sista Project that teach negotiation and refusal skills, enhance self-worth, and build communication and sexual assertiveness skills among African American wome n are important to address the HIV risk behaviors practiced within black heterosexual relati onships (DiClemente & Wingood, 1995; Jemmott, Jemmott & OLeary, 2007). Adaptation and implementation of similar interventions for Haitian women are n ecessary to address attitudes to condom use that inhibit safer sex behaviors. In addition, condom negotiation and safer sex must be taught within the context of the male-female relationship dynamic. Histor ically, the onus has been placed on women to negotiate the use of a male controlled prevention method. This approach must be revisited and couples-based HIV prevention must be emphasized with men and women being held responsible for safer sex behavior s. Interventions such as RAPP (Real AIDS Prevention Project) that target heterosexual women and their partners should be adapted more broadly in black communities to increas e consistent use of condoms. Key elements of RAPP include community engagement peer outreach, one-on-one safer sex discussions, safer sex gatheri ngs, HIV prevention presentations, and role model stories (Lauby, Smith, Stark, Person, & Adams, 2000). Th ese approaches should be adopted to engage men, women and communities in taking responsibility for safer sex behaviors. The study also revealed that black wome n are threatened by the gender sex-ratio imbalance within the black population and feelings that it is necessary to trap a man or attempt to solidify a sexual relationshi p through pregnancy. Women therefore often oppose condom use because of their desire to conceive. Considering this gender
221 imbalance, women are more likely to adhere to mens sexual prefer ences and less likely to negotiate condom use fearing rejection by their male partne r. As one study participant stated, she did not want to be that girl that said no to him and then he was going to leave. Within stable or long-term relationshi ps, condoms are viewed as a symbol of infidelity or sexual activity outside the re lationship. Men who attempt to use condoms are questioned about their fidelity. Likewise, women who suggest condom use are seen as distrusting or are suspecte d of sexual promiscuity. This link between condom use and fidelity creates a major barrier to condom us e within heterosexual re lationships. Couplesbased interventions such as CONNECT, a couple-leve l intervention for heterosexual couples (El-Bassel et al., 2003) are needed to unravel the misconception that condoms equal distrust. Like CONNECT, interventions must teach couples the skills to enhance communication, condom negotiation, solve prob lems, identify risk behaviors and commit to change behaviors to enhance safer sex. HI V prevention efforts must also emphasize the need to continue to use condoms even with in perceived long-term relationships. Since men in this inquiry report partner concu rrency and low condom use, persistent condom use must be encouraged within casual as well as regular or steady se xual relationships. In addition, instead of focusing primarily on wo men, men who have sex with men, or gay populations, prevention efforts must also target heterosexual men as a group and hold them accountable for safer sex practices. Behavioral Health This study explored the influence of al cohol and substance use and abuse on HIV risk behaviors in U.S.-born and Haitian-bor n heterosexual relationships. Findings reveal
222 that younger black men especially, do not pe rceive mental or physical impairments caused by intoxication and substance use. Ma le study participants younger than 45 years of age perceived that their cognitive and behavioral skills relative to condom use are unaffected by alcohol and/or s ubstance use prior to sexual intercourse. These perceptions contradict the findings of rese arch reports and studies that have found that alcohol and drugs inhibit cognitive and beha vioral skills related to safe r sex (Cederbaum et al., 2006; Meade, 2006; National Institute on Drug A buse (NIDA), 2006; U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2008). However, more mature U.S.-born men between the ages of 45-60 years related experiences wh ereby alcohol and dr ug use significantly altered their judgment, inhibition, and behavioral skills, and in some instances resulted in negative outcomes such as HIV infection. Additionally, Haitia n-born and U.S.-born women acknowledge that alcohol and substance use impairs their own safe sex abilities and that of their male partners. Women repor ted that their partners are unable to think about condoms let alone properly use a condom while intoxicated or high. These findings reveal the need for continued and enhan ced education on the relationship between substance use and high risk sexual behavior s especially targeted to younger black heterosexual men. Cultural Norms From a cultural perspective, several themes emerged as male study participants discussed macrosystem factors that influence their sexual behaviors: 1) family attitudes toward sexual health communica tion; 2) peer norms; 3) hi p-hop culture and; 4) cultural attitudes toward homosexuality and bisexuality.
223 Family Attitudes toward Sexual Health Communication. A critical finding was the dearth of sexual health communication within the family structure. Overwhelmingly, U. S.-born and Haitian-born men and women expressed that their families failed to disc uss sexual behavior, condom use, or sexual health. For most study participants, sex e ducation was largely acquired through venues external to the family such as schools, the me dia, and peers. Any fa mily or parental sex communication centered on abstinence and wa rnings against pregnancy. Parents who participated in the study were asked to discu ss the extent to which they addressed sexual behaviors with their children. These discussi ons confirmed that ther e are several barriers to parental communication about sexual issues. Parents admitted to being embarrassed to discuss sex with their children and therefore relied on schools and teachers to teach their children about sex. In addition, highly conser vative and religious beliefs prevented parents from providing comprehensive sex education. Children ar e therefore open to receiving sex education from sources that may or may not be reliable. Interestingly however, despite religious and c onservative beliefs, this study found that family members encourage their male adolescents to be sexually experienced. This advice seems to counter conservative religious beliefs that prohibit sex outside of the marriage. These gaps and inconsistencies in family communica tion have significant implications for HIV prevention and education efforts. Approaches are needed to build parental skills and enhance their confidence and self-efficacy to discuss sexual behavior. Interventions should also teach parents the importance of communicating consistent messages to their children rather than endors ing conservative behaviors wh ile also encouraging sexual experience in male adolescents. As discussed above, interventions such as ImPACT that
224 emphasize building parental skills such as parental monitoring and effective communication can be helpful in addressing the lack of family dialogue about sexual health (Stanton, 2004). As one Haitian-born male study participant suggested, an open forum with children and parents may initiate the dialogue within families. I think some kind of forum or some kind of training that needs to really take place where parents and their kids can actually come to. I think the same thing with the health fair that takes place, so something I would say almost similar where you could have, depending on the amount of peop le who register, well you have this group, you have ten parents and yeah, with their kids in one session and so forth where they can re ally sit. 'Cause then it will make the parents who are uncom fortable to discuss it have someone else discuss it then ask some questions and then have the kids ask questions. And so it ki nda make the pathway much easier for them. The importance of family communication on se xual health is even more critical with the existence of abstin ence-only or abstinence until marriage education in schools and other entities that interf ace with children, teenagers and young adults. Abstinence is effective in preventing HIV and other STIs and should be taught as a component of comprehensive sex education. While abstinen ce is a healthy sexual option for teens and young adults, in reality, abstinence is not larg ely practiced within the American society (Santelli et al., 2006). Therefore, abstinenceonly programs are deficient because they do not offer safer sex alternatives for individuals who choose to be sexually active. In their study among 7th and 8th graders, Sather & Zinn ( 2002) found that abstinence-only education did not significantly change adoles cents values and att itudes about premarital sex or their intentions to engage in prem arital sexual activity. In its position paper on abstinence-only education polic ies and programs, the Society for Adolescent Medicine supports comprehensive sex education that in cludes abstinence, correct and consistent
225 condom use, and contraception among adolescent s who are sexually activ e (Santelli, Ott, Lyon, Rogers & Summers, 2006). Comprehensive education on sexual health should be provided within the family unit as well as in schools. P ublic health professionals must continue to work with policymakers and advocate for legislative cha nges that repeal abs tinence-only education laws and requirements. Strategic approaches and community advocacy as adopted by The California Wellness Foundation will be key to effecting policy changes. In California, the passage of the Comprehensive Sexual Heal th and HIV/AIDS Prevention Education Act was made possible by building capacity with co mmunity based organizations to advocate for effective teen pregnancy prevention polic ies (Brindis, Geierstanger & Faxio, 2009). In Florida, similar approaches are necessary to initiate long-term changes in abstinence-only education legislation. Hip-Hop Culture. Operating within the macrosystem, study findings reveal that mainstream hip-hop music negatively influences mens sexual beha viors and their percep tions of women. The study indicates that blac k masculine ideologies are direct ly influenced by the media and especially by hip-hop culture. The negative imag es and stereotypes portrayed within this musical genre often promote promiscuity, profanity, and objec tification of women. Female study participants also acknowledge d that hip-hop lyrics and graphical images affect their personal self images and c oncepts of womanhood. Often, women aspire to emulate the images of women who are portrayed within rap videos as video vixens and are seen as the ultimate woman who is able to keep and sustain relationships with men.
226 HIV education and prevention efforts must consider the strong influence of hiphop and make better attempts to collaborate with the music industr y to communicate HIV prevention messages. Efforts such as the wrap-it-up campaign on Black Entertainment Television (BET) have fueled some awarene ss, however, broader, collaborative HIV education and awareness effo rts are needed. Male and female study participants suggested that public health practitioners work directly w ith hip-hop moguls and artists such as Jay-Z, Trey Songz, and Lil Wayne to enhance HIV awareness. Since hip-hop artists are viewed as role models es pecially among the adolescent and younger populations, the public health community must engage musicians and rappers in serious dialogue about the images and lifestyles portrayed by the ly rics and music videos that influence sexual behaviors, ideologies, a nd self-concepts among black men and women. Hip-hop is an underutilized vehicle for wide spread HIV education and awareness. The public health community must take the firs t step to bridge the divide between HIV prevention messages and the negative se xual influence of the hip-hop culture. Cultural Attitudes toward Homosexuality and Bisexuality. Findings of this inquiry demonstrate that homophobic attitudes persist within the U.S.-born and Haitian-born black communities. Rooted within black culture and history are definitions of manhood that dictate heterosexuality. Findi ngs from this inquiry show that within the study population, homosexuality is stigmatized and vi ewed as sinful and unnatural. In addition, homosexuality is seen as contrary to Black masculine ideologies as homosexuals are seen as effeminate and w eak. These perceptions of homosexuality may result in fear and reluctance of Black gay or bisexual men to identify as homosexual and secretly engage in risky sexual behaviors with men.
227 As confirmed by the findings of this st udy, homosexuals and bisexuals are blamed for the HIV epidemic. Therefore, it is not surprising to learn that men expressed homophobia and a culture of violence to ward homosexual and bisexual men. These attitudes are exacerbated by high levels of religiosity within the black community whereby homosexuality and bisexuality are not tolerated and viewed as sinful. These negative and sometimes violen t attitudes deter African Am erican and Haitian men who have sex with men (MSM) and men who have sex with men and women (MSM/W) from disclosing their sexuality, enc ourage secretive same-sex en counters, and prevent them from seeking HIV prevention services and care. Although the rese archer probed male participants about their experiences with bi sexuality or the down low participants tended to share their disgust towards the beha vior but did not identify with or connect with bisexuality. This distanci ng of self from bisexuality may result from stigmatizing and negative attitudes to bisexuality and ho mosexuality within the black community. Therefore, effective HIV prevention stra tegies will require understanding the experiences of black MSM and MSM/W within the context of African American and Haitian history and culture that ascribe sp ecific definitions of manhood. Interventions need to address structural and socio-cultural factors that create barri ers to HIV prevention including an emphasis on the violent att itudes portrayed toward MSM and MSM/W. First, community-based interventions such as RAPP (Real AIDS Prevention Project) are needed on a broader level to address co mmunity attitudes to homosexuality and bisexuality (Lauby et al., 2000). A key elemen t of RAPP is community engagement to change community norms that may facilitate risky sexua l behaviors. Using similar approaches, interventions s hould target community indi viduals with educational
228 messages that discourage violent and stig matizing attitudes toward homosexual and bisexual men. Second, interventions that target heterosexual men such as Nia described above (Kalichman et al., 1999) should address their feelings toward homosexuality and bisexuality and discuss the implications of negative community attitudes for increased sexual secrecy and HIV transmission within the black community. In addition, these interventions should be adapted for the Haiti an community as Haitian men in the study portrayed feelings of violence to ward homosexuals and bisexuals. Peer Norms Peer norms also play a significant role in mens conceptualization of HIV risk and protective behaviors. Operating within the exosystem or the community/peers sphere of the socio-ecological model of STD risk and pr otective factors, peers can exert important influences on sexual behavior (DiClemente et al., 2005). Themes regarding peer norms involved risky sexual behaviors such as multip le sex partners and inconsistent condom use. These peer norms may place black men a nd women at risk for HIV/AIDS and make it challenging for them to im plement protective sexual behavi ors. Studies have found that individuals who are not constr ained by social and peers norms are likely to engage in HIV protective behaviors (Dancy & Berbaum, 2005). Therefore, HIV prevention efforts should not focus primarily on individual-level factors to promote behavior change. For optimal effectiveness, interventions must al so focus on the social and peer norms that influence sexual behaviors w ithin the black community. Gender Norms and HIV Risk Study findings indicate that gender norms shape the environment of HIV risk and protective behaviors within heterosexual relation ships. As shown in previous applications
229 of the theory of gender a nd power to safer sex behavi ors (Wingood and DiClemente, 1998), power imbalances and gender inequa lities often black womens decisions regarding condom use negotiation. As show n in this inquiry, women are largely financially independent and ar e mutual partners in making financial decisions, but take minimal control over sexual decision-m aking. While financial independence among women has been linked to increased like lihood to effectively negotiate condom use (Pulerwitz et al., 2002; Whyte, 2005; El-Bassel, Caldeira, Ruglass & Gilbert, 2009), the results of this inquiry contra dicts this link. In fact, men who reported having financially independent female partners also reported inconsistent condom use and mutual agreement against using condoms. Condom-use decisions ar e driven by male partners who may have negative attitudes to condom use. Results s uggest that gender norms such as female submissiveness and a desire to cater to their partners preferences ma y contribute to risky sexual behaviors within black heterosexual relationships. Likewise, womens hesitation to negotiate condom use may also be driven by their own negative condom use attitudes which give men even less motivation to use condoms. Womens atti tudes to condom use must be viewed within a broa der socio-cultura l and structural context that ascribe women to inferior roles and affect female self-p rotective behaviors. One such structural phenomenon is the gender ratio im balance in the black community. Sex Ratio Imbalance Among focus group discussions with U.S. -born women, themes regarding sex ratio imbalances emerged as a factor that diminishes womens power and abilities to negotiate safer sex practices. As shown in previous studies (Ferguson et al., 2006; ElBassel et al., 2009), the consequences of this sex ratio imbalance is men having
230 concurrent female sex partners and wome n adhering to mens condom use preferences. This inquiry found that women who perceived a shortage of eligible mates were more likely to tolerate male promiscuity and more likely to report attempts to conceive in order to trap their mate. In addition, women are less likely to insist on condom use fearing rejection and abandonment by a male sexual pa rtner. The sex ratio imbalance creates a complex environment within which to addr ess safer sex behaviors. HIV prevention approaches must address the link between this imbalance and womens often unspoken fear of losing their sexual partners. HIV prevention and intervention programs must incorporate counseling that discusses heal thy relationship-seeking and self-esteem building. Interventions such as The Sista Project and Siste r to Sister that emphasize pride, self-worth, negotiation sk ills and assertive communicati on skills need to be utilized on a broader level (DiClemente & Wi ngood, 1995; Jemmott et al., 2007). These interventions must also be ad apted and tested within the Haitian community. To address gender imbalances, open dialogue must also be initiated about this topic in which the community (men and women) is engaged in developing solutions to this growing problem. Childhood Sexual Abuse and Trauma Histories Sexual abuse and trauma histories emerged as primary themes in discussions of cultural and gender-related f actors that influence sexual behaviors. U.S.-born women revealed histories of childhood sexual abus e, childhood exposure to parental domestic violence, and sexual coercion. Women also noted that the absence of a positive male role model and father figure in thei r lives contributed to their li mited abilities to communicate effectively with their male partners. These experiences often diminish womens abilities
231 to negotiate safer sex because of fear of victimization and male-perpetrated abuse. These findings have significant implications for be havioral health care and mental health counseling. Health care provi ders should be aware of the prevalence of childhood sexual abuse among female patients and offer re ferrals for mental health counseling and treatment. HIV prevention programs must also consid er womens sexual abuse histories and facilitate linkages to mental health res ources. Research findi ngs indicate that intrapersonal approaches to HIV preventi on are inadequate. HIV prevention must be conducted in consideration of social ecologi cal models that incorporate structural, cultural and gender-related factors. Conceptual models such as the Sexual Health Model (Wyatt, 2009) can be used to inform the deve lopment of interventions that incorporate cultural and historic aspect s of the African American culture. As Wyatt proposes, interventions should consider key concepts such as interconnectedness, sexual ownership, and body awareness. Likewise, interventions such as the Enha nced Sexual Health Intervention (Wyatt et al, 2004) that focus on the impact of sexual histories on current cognitive and behavioral patterns within a cu lturally competent framework are necessary to address childhood sexual abuse and trauma histories in black women. Influence of Religion A significant finding is the effect of voudou on the conceptualization of HIV transmission within the Haitian community. While Haitian men portrayed relatively high levels of knowledge about HIV transm ission, Haitian women revealed that voudou continues to influence beliefs and practic es around HIV communi cation, prevention and care. According to Haitian-born female study pa rticipants, Haitians hold non-sexual, non-
232 biomedical concepts of HIV transmission that are rooted in beliefs that HIV is a product of witchcraft which is assigned as a curse on the infected indivi dual. Addressing these culturally embedded beliefs presents unique challenges to the public health community. However, efforts must be made to address mythical beliefs within the context of Haitian culture. These approaches will require the use of culturally competent models and gaining trust within the Haitian community. With younger generations that have been implanted in the United States educational efforts must be gin early in an attempt to supersede the misconceptions that may be taught within the family structure. Likewise, older Haitian men (45-58 years) described the condom inhibitive effect of their Catholic beliefs. In a 2009 speech in Cameroon, Pope Benedict XVI was quoted as saying condoms are not the answer to Af ricas fight against HIV (MSNBC, 2009). Ascribing to similar beliefs, Haitian male study participants expressed their beliefs that condoms should not be used dur ing sexual intercourse. Despit e these religious beliefs, public health educational efforts must c ontinue to target Haitian men with HIV prevention and condom use messages. Comm unity-based approaches may be most efficient in reaching this community. Collabor ation with churches, local social events, sporting events, and community venues frequented by Haitian men is key to effectively reaching this population with HIV education programs. Structural Factors Coupled with the factors discussed above ar e the structural fact ors that influence HIV transmission in the black community. Many of the factors previously discussed such as the sex ratio imbalance, se xual abuse and even the hip-hop culture are the direct result of structural factors such as the disproportionate incarcera tion of black men, residential
233 segregation, gang subculture, lack of access to adequate health care services, urban deprivation, economic disadvantage, harsh drug possession laws that target black men for imprisonment, racism and discrimination (L ane et al., 2004; Rhodes, Singer, Bourgois, Friedman & Strathdee, 2005). These risk f actors do not exist on th e intrapersonal level but rather create an environment of risk that requires structural and political interventions. State and nati onal policies such as the Affordable Car act which became law on March 23, 2010 are needed to provide better access to h ealth care services in poor, underserved communities (U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Services, 2010). In addition, the criminal justice and public health systems must work together to develop solutions to the disproportionate incarceration rates of black men and the resultant effects on the HIV epidemic. In addition to policy changes, struct ural interventions that incorporate community-based approaches to reducing HIV disparities will be necessary to curb the HIV epidemic in the black community. Inte rventions that build social capital and emphasize interconnectedness, family cohesi veness and social networks may offer a structural approach to rebuild minority co mmunities. Fullilove, Green & Fullilove (2000) propose structural interventions such as the Family to Family program that strengthen family functioning, encourage neighborhood building, and connect children to adults in their community through weekly family gatherings where family members pray, dine together, play games and focus on the child ren in the community. This approach may offer a feasible model to alter the social environment of communities that have been destroyed by epidemics of vi olence, drugs and HIV/AIDS.
234 Strengths and Limitations of the Study Study Limitations First, the findings of this inquiry are based on self-reported data from study participants. Results are based on participan ts perceptions, recall and interpretation of their lived experiences Although this is a potential wea kness of the study, qualitative methods assume subjectivity as a part of th e understanding of the human reality. Within the naturalistic paradigm, subjectivity is a major characteristic whereby meanings are constructed based on personal realities (L incoln and Guba, 1985). To minimize the limitations of self-reported data, the researcher developed rapport with each participant to enhance levels of trust. Second, nonprobability sampling techniques such as convenience and snowball sampling were utilized during the recruitm ent phase of this study. While random sampling methods are appropriate for quantita tive studies, nonrandom samples are most appropriate for qualitative inquiry as sampled cases are selected base d on their relevance to the research topic and ability to provi de rich information rather than their representativeness (Neuman, 2003). In addition, while the resear cher attempted to recruit a diverse age group of Haitian women, all female Haitian participants were between the ages of 18-27 years. As older women may have different experiences and views of male behaviors, future research studies should at tempt to include older Haitian women within the exploration of HIV risk behaviors practiced by Haitian-born men. The third limitation is social desirabili ty bias among study participants. According to Neuman (2003), social desirability bias occurs when a participant alters his/her responses to make their reports conform to social norms. Sexual behavior is a highly
235 sensitive issue that carries el ements of stigma and judgment. Interview participants may have reported socially desirable responses to prevent stigmatization or negative appraisal by the researcher. To control for this bias, th e researcher maintained a neutral posture and was careful not to appear judgmental with in interviews and focus group discussions. The gender effect is a fourth limitation of the study. As the researcher was female, male research participants may have responded in a manner they perceive to be desirable for a female listener thereby altering thei r self-presentations. For example, male participants may have over reported conservative beha viors and underreported risky sexual behaviors. To contro l for this limitation, the resear cher remained neutral and nonjudgmental during discourses with male study participants. Finally, this study is subject to research er bias. While several strategies were employed to minimize researcher bi as as detailed in chapter thr ee, it should be noted that researcher bias was of concern during th e conduct of this inquiry. Neuman (2003) outlines six categories of bias that intervie wers should be aware of: 1) errors by the respondent which involves forgetting, lying or misunderstanding because of the presence of others; 2) unintentional errors or resear cher sloppiness; 3) inte ntional subversion by the interviewer such as purposefully omitting questions or altering answers; 4) interviewers expectations ba sed on appearance or other qual ities of the participant; 5) interviewer failure to probe certain responses and; 6) influence on participants answers based on the appearance or attitude of the researcher. The researcher addressed these biases by ensuring that she wa s properly trained and possess ed appropriate skills to conduct interviews and focus groups. Chapter three further discusses in detail how researcher bias was controlled in this study.
236 Study Strengths Inherent in this study are many strength s that enhance the body of knowledge on socio-cultural, structural, and intrapersonal fact ors that interact to influence HIV risk and protective behaviors among U.S.-born and Haitian-born populations. First, the triangulation of data collection techniques adds to the strength of this inquiry by utilizing novel methodological approaches to explore HI V risk. During phase I, in-depth, semistructured interviews were a pplied to derive sexual script s of the experiences, knowledge and attitudes of heterosexual men. Because of the sensitivity of the topic and the researchers goal of eliciti ng personal sexual information fr om male participants, the interview format was most appropriate. Ph ase II incorporated focus group methods to elicit black womens perceptions of the sexua l behaviors practiced by black men. The use focus groups in the second phase of the study was intended to promote self-disclosure within a group setting that would allow gr oup discussants to influence each other by reacting to the ideas and experiences of others in the group (Krueger, 2000). Second, this study fills a si gnificant gap in the lite rature by exploring the intrapersonal, socio-cultural and structural f actors that influence se xual behavior in subgroups of black heterosexual men. There are limited research studies that focus on subgroup analyses of sexual behavior. Two recent studies have assessed ethnic differences in HIV risk behaviors. Conducte d in New York City, Hoffman and colleagues (2008) compared black West Indians and U.S.-born blacks sexual and drug use risk behaviors. They found that West Indian wo men had lower confidence levels to discuss STI testing or condom use with their sex partne rs. In this study, Haitians were not studied as a separate and distinct ethnic group. Villanueva et al. (2010) compared risk
237 perceptions and sexual experi ences between African American, Caribbean Islanders and Haitians. They found that Creole-speaking Hait ians had lower HIV risk perceptions, were less likely to use condoms, and less likely to have ever been tested for HIV. However, Villanueva et al. (2010) limited the age range of their study sample to 18-39 year olds. Therefore, this study adds to the body of knowledge relative to prevention science research by qualitatively asse ssing HIV risk perceptions a nd behaviors, including a wide range of ages, and focusing on distinct ethnic groups (Haitian a nd African American). Third, this study revealed cultural factor s related to HIV ri sk and protective behaviors that must be further explored. Relative to the Haitian community, there are unique cultural practices that must be addressed within the context of HIV prevention. One such finding is the belief that HIV inf ection is related to voudou or non-biomedical, mythical, concepts of illness. As these beli efs are embedded within the cultural fabric of the Haitian community, prevention efforts must not gloss over these beliefs but rather incorporate them within HIV edu cation and prevention efforts. Finally, this study provided a holistic approach to sexual behaviors. Both men and women were included in this exploratory st udy giving a holistic pe rspective to the study findings. Moreover, the findings derived from phase II of the st udy confirmed many of the responses from the male individual in terviews. In some instances, men and women provided divergent perceptions and experien ces: 1) men ascribed to HIV conspiracy beliefs but women did not; 2) men did not perceive impaired skills after alcohol/substance use while women did; 3) me n perceived that women hold most of the power to make sexual decisions in relations hips while women did not seem to use or perceive the same level of power. Often, st udies may not provide analyses through the
238 lens of both men and women. This study attempted to provide a comprehensive examination of the status of sexual behavi ors among U.S.-born and Haitian-born men and women. Section III: Implications for Public He alth Education, Practice, and Research Public Health Education and Practice The findings of this study have several implications for public health education. HIV prevention education should continue to focus on increasing knowledge about HIV transmission and safer sex methods. Findi ngs show that HIV education has been successful in creating high levels of HIV knowledge among the populations studied. Prevention science however has not been effect ive in motivating individuals to translate their HIV/AIDS knowledge into safer sex behaviors. HIV education models have historically emphasized indi vidual-level approaches that enhance intrapersonal knowledge and attitudes. However, this study shows the need to move beyond psychological HIV education and intervention ap proaches to ecological approaches that consider structural, socio-cu ltural and behavioral health factors that impact sexual behaviors. Critical to this inquiry is the finding that HIV conspiracy beliefs were pervasive within the male study population. As these theories may create barriers to positive reception of HIV prevention messages, treatmen t and care, HIV education must begin to address the conspiracy beliefs held by U.S.-born and Haitian-born black men. Consideration must also be gi ven to the historical and cultu ral context of discrimination, racism and distrust within which these beli efs are embedded. For optimal effectiveness, HIV prevention messages must be sensitive to th e cultural and historical intricacies that
239 dictate conspiracy beliefs. As noted above, gender-specifi c HIV programs and interventions that address c onspiracy beliefs are needed for heterosexual black men. Implementation of interventi ons such as Nia, a vide o-based, small group level intervention to educate black men about HI V/AIDS can be utilized to address HIV conspiracy beliefs (Kalichman, Cherry & Browne-Sperling, 1999). High risk sexual behaviors such as part ner concurrency and inconsistent condom use must be addressed within the context of socio-ecological factors that influence risk. Masculine ideologies and social cons tructions of manhood and woman must be considered in the assessment of high-risk behaviors such as multiple sex partners. Cultural emphasis on heterosexism and male sexual experience may endorse promiscuous sexual behavior among men and boys. HIV education efforts must address these constructions and attempt to deconstruct the concepts of black ma le sexual prowess and machismo. HIV education effort s must also address the multiple social and contextual factors that influence condom use decisi on-making. Educational approaches should include couples-based counseli ng that reinforces mutual responsibility for safer sex, condom carrying and condom use skills-building, emphasize the importance of condom use within long-term relationships, construct the link between condoms and contraception, teach women effective ways of minimizing condom use discomfort, and explore novel ways of incorporating less pene trative sexual activities within the sexual experience. Couples-based programs such as CONNECT that emphasizes personal, relational, and societal influences on behavi or can be implemented to teach couples skills to enhance sexual safety within their relationships (El-Bassel et al., 2003).
240 Study findings also have significant implicati ons for behavioral he alth particularly mental health and substance abuse couns eling and services. HIV education and prevention efforts must consider the chil dhood sexual abuse and trau ma experiences of black women as these experiences may have a detrimental effect on womens abilities to protect themselves from HIV and other STIs Study findings reveal that women with sexual abuse histories have diminished capaciti es to negotiate safer sex with male sex partners. Previous studies have found that trauma-based inte rventions are efficacious in reducing HIV risk behaviors among women wh o had experienced childhood sexual abuse and adult partner violence (Wyatt et al., 2004; Sikkema et al., 2007). The realities of trauma and abuse histories must be cons idered as HIV education and intervention programs are implemented, and mental health counseling services should be provided for women with these traumatic histories. In a ddition, based on the alc ohol and substance use and abuse behaviors reported by study part icipants, substance abuse counseling and rehabilitation should be inco rporated within HIV preventi on programs. Education efforts must also emphasize the link between substan ce abuse and high risk sexual behaviors as younger men tended to deny any cognitive of be havioral impairment as a result of intoxication or substance use. Within the context of community-based HIV education and awareness, public health practitioners and educators must a ddress the underlying i ssues of sex ratio imbalance, womens self-esteem, gender roles, and womens abilities to seek healthy sexual relationships. HIV prevention efforts mu st address black womens fear of losing a male partner and its link to the gender im balances in the black community. Likewise, traditional gender roles that hinder womens ab ilities to make condom-use decisions need
241 to be deconstructed within the minds of black women. While companionship is important, women must also consider the de trimental consequences of remaining in unhealthy relationships. The unde rlying factors such as depression, low self-esteem, and the need for male partner validation that c ontribute to womens negative attitudes to condom use must be addressed. These message s and socio-ecological influences should be incorporated in HIV prevention and interv ention approaches that target black women. Interventions referenced above such as Sister to Sister (Jemmott et al., (2007), The Sista Project (DiClemente & Wingood, 1995) and Sihle (DiClemente & Wingood, 1995 that build self-efficacy and teach women personal and cultural pride and assertiveness skills within a culturally comp etent context should be adapted in black communities and tailored for other ethnic groups such as Haitians. In addition, HIV prevention programs mu st address homophobia and the culture of violence toward homosexuals and bisexuals Effective HIV prevention strategies will require understanding the expe riences of black MSM and MS M/W within th e context of African American and Haitian history and cu lture that ascribe specific definitions of manhood. Gender-specific inte rventions that target heterosexual black men such as Nia (Kalichman et al., 1999) need to address structural and soci o-cultural factors that create barriers to HIV prevention including an emphasis on the violent attitudes portrayed toward MSM and MSM/W. Study findings reveal that parental communication about sexual behavior is virtually non-existent in the African Amer ican and Haitian communities. HIV education efforts must therefore target parents and we ll as the youth within the African American and Haitian communities. Communication skills -buildings and self-efficacy enhancing
242 techniques would be helpful in teaching pa rents effective methods of communicating sexbased information to their children. Finally, HIV education should utilize community-based approaches for the development and implementation of HIV prevention programs. Study participants indicated that HIV prevention messages are not widely disseminated within effective community-based channels. Study participants suggested that public health practitioners and educators utilize community-based venues such as sporting events, music festivals, dance and social events such as Kompa in the Haitian community, schools, and universities to disseminate HIV informati on. In addition, the media and hip-hop culture should be utilized as dissemination ve hicles for HIV prevention messages. Public Health Research Future research endeavors should continue to focus on the social and ecological determinants of sexual behavior among black heterosexual men. Much of the research literature focuses on gay-identified men, MSMs and MSM/Ws. Little research focuses on the risk behaviors practiced by men who self-identify as he terosexual or who have sex with women (Bowleg, 2004). As one study participant noted, as far as research studies and stuff like that, theres relativel y none that really fo cus directly with heterosexual black males. Thats why I was surprised when I heard about this one. I was like WHAT? This study deconstructs beliefs with in the research community that black heterosexual men are opposed to participating in research. If approached in a culturally appropriate and trusting manner, men are ope n and even eager to participate in HIV prevention research. This study suggests that more holistic approach es to assessing HIV risk behaviors are needed within the black male heterosexual population.
243 Further, additional research studies are needed to further explore subgroup differences in the HIV/AIDS knowledge, attitude s, beliefs, and risk behaviors. This study represents a formative step in the devel opment of socio-ecological subgroup analyses. Further research is needed to more fully ex plore this critical ar ea of inquiry. Additional black subgroups living in the United States su ch as Africans and i ndividuals from other Caribbean islands should be included in futu re studies. Subgroup analyses in relation ecological influences on sexual behaviors should also be conducted among Hispanic communities as subgroup differences may play a key role in the development and implementation of future HIV education and prevention programs as the U.S.-born population becomes more diverse. Future research should more fully investig ate the behavioral he alth factors that influence HIV risk. Factors not addressed in this study such as th e relationship between specific levels of alcohol and drug use, sexual risk behaviors and perceptions of impairment should be more closely studi ed. In addition, the relationship between childhood sexual abuse, trauma histories, and depressive symptoms within these subgroups should be more extensively explored. Factors related to family communication about sexual issues must be addressed within public health research. Larger impact studies are needed to more fully explore the factors that create barriers to family a nd parental communication within U.S.-born and Haitian-born black cultures. Intervention rese arch is needed to develop effective approaches to address barriers in sexual health communication. Socio-ecological influences on HIV risk is a growing ar ea of inquiry that requires additional studies that fully explore so cial and ecological factors such as:
244 black masculine ideologies and social constructions of manhood and womanhood; media influences such as hip-hop culture; sex ratio imbalances within the black community; culturally embedded social and peers norms and beliefs that influence sexual behavior; gender norms that may render women incapable of making healthy sexual decisions. Concepts and dynamics of trust and how trust influences condom use and safer sex behaviors Finally, future studies sh ould develop quantitative methods and instruments to more broadly assess socio-ecological factors such as cultural norms, media, parental communication and gender norms that influenc e sexual behavior in subgroups of black heterosexual men thus allowing fo r generalizability of findings. Dissemination of Findings Immediate next steps will include dissemin ation of research findings to academic and lay audiences. Research findings will be disseminated through manuscripts submitted to peer-reviewed journals, as well as nati onal, statewide (e.g. Fl orida Public Health Association) and local conferences. In additi on, articles will be submitted to local media outlets such as the Florida Sentinel, a local black newspaper. Fi ndings will also be shared with research participants w ho indicated an interest in r eceiving follow-up information on the study results.
245 LIST OF REFERENCES Adimora, A., Schoenbach, V., Martinson, F., Donaldson, K., Fullilove, R., & Aral, S. (2001). Social context of sexual relations hips among rural African Americans. Sexually Transmitted Diseases, 28 (2), 69-76. Adrien, A., Cayemittes, M., & Bergevin, Y. (1993). AIDS-related knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, and practices in Haiti. Bulletin of PAHO, 27 (2), 234-243. Amaro, H., Raj, A. & Reed, E. (2001). Wome n's sexual health: The need for feminist analyses in public health in the decade of behavior. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 25 324-334. Aggleton, P. & Parker, R. (2002). A conceptual framework and basis for action: HIV/AIDS stigma and discrimination Geneva, Switzerland: Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS. Associated Press (2009, March 17). Pope: Condoms not the answer in AIDS fight. MSNBC. Retrieved July 5, 2010, from http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29734328/ Bandura, A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review, 84 191-215. Bandura, A. (1994). Social cognitive theory and exercise of control over HIV infection. In R.J. DiClemente & J.L. Peterson (Eds.), Preventing AIDS: Theories and methods of behavioral interventions (pp. 25-59), New Yo rk, NY: Plenum. Basen-Enquist, K. (1992). Psychosocial pred ictors of "safer sex" behaviors in young adults. AIDS Education and Prevention, 4 120-134. Beatty, L. A., Wheeler, D., & Gaiter, J. (2004). HIV prevention re search for African Americans: Current and future directions. Journal of Black Psychology, 30 (1), 4058. Becker, M. H. (1974). The health beli ef model and sick role behavior. Health Education Monographs, 2 409-419.
246 Bedimo, A.L., Bennett, M., Ki ssinger, P., & Clark, R.A. ( 1998). Understanding barriers to condom usage among HIV-infected African American women. Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care, 9 (3), 48-58. Berg, B.L. (2004). Qualitative research methods for the social sciences (5th ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon. Bogart, L.M. & Thorburn, S. (2005). Are HIV/AI DS conspiracy belief s a barrier to HIV prevention among African Americans? J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr, 38 (2), 213218. Bowleg, L. (2004). Love, sex and masc ulinity in sociocultural context. Men and Masculinities, 7 (2), 166-186. Bowleg, L., Lucas, K.J., and Tschann, J.M. ( 2004). "The ball was always in his court": An exploratory analysis of relationship scripts, sexua l scripts, and condom use among African American women. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 28 (1), 70-82. Bowser, B.P. (1992). African-American culture and AIDS prevention: from barrier to ally. The Western Journal of Medicine, 157 (3), 286-294. Boyatzis, R.E. (1998). Transforming qualitative data: Thematic analysis and code development. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Brindis, C.D., Geierstanger, S.P., & Faxio, A. (2009). The role of policy advocacy in assuring comprehensive family life education in California. Heath Educ Behav, 36 (6), 1095-1108. Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). The ecology of human development: Experiments by nature and design Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Brooks, R.A., Etzel, M.A., Hinojos, E., Henry, C.L. & Perez, M. (2005). Preventing HIV among Latino and African American gay a nd bisexual men in a context of HIVrelated stigma, discrimination, and ho mophobia: Perspectives of providers. AIDS Patient Care and STDs, 19 (11), 737-744. Brooks, R.A., Lee, S., Newman, P.A., & Lei bowitz, A.A. (2008). Se xual risk behavior has decreased among men who have sex w ith men in Los Angeles but remains
247 greater than that among heterosexual men and women. AIDS Education and Prevention, 20 (3), 312-324. Brown, L. K., DiClemente, R. J., & Re ynolds, L. A. (1991). HIV prevention for adolescents: utility of the health belief model. AIDS Education and Prevention, 3 50-59. Buseh, A.G., Stevens, P.E., McManus, P., Addison, J., Morgan, S., & Millon-Underwood (2006). Challenges and opportunities for HI V prevention and care: Insights from focus groups of HIV-infected African American men. Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care, 17 (4), 3-15. Campbell, C. A. (1995). Male gender role s and sexuality: Implic ations for women's AIDS risk and prevention. Soc. Sci. Med., 41 (2), 197-210. Carey, M. P., Carey, K.B., & Kalichman, S.C. (1997). Risk for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection among persons with severe mental illnesses. Clinical Psychology Review., 17 (3), 271-291. Catania, J.A., Kegeles, S.M., & Coates, T.J. (1990). Towards an understanding of risk behavior: An AIDS risk reduction model (ARRM). Health Education Quarterly, 17 (1), 53-72. Cederbaum, J. A., Coleman, C. L., Goller, G. & Jemmott, L.S. (2006). Understanding the HIV risk reduction needs of heterosexua l African American substance-abusing men. Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care, 17 (6), 28-37. Center for AIDS Prevention Studies and the AIDS Research Institute. (2001). What are heterosexual men's HIV prevention needs? Retrieved February 12, 2007, from http://www.caps.ucsf.edu Centers for Disease Contro l and Prevention. (2002). Drug-associated HIV transmission continues in the United States Retrieved October 13, 2007, from http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/resources/factsheets/PDF/idu.pdf Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2006). Twenty-five years of HIV/AIDS United States, 1981-2006. MMWR, 55 (21), 585-589.
248 Centers for Disease Contro l and Prevention. (2007a). A heightened national response to the HIV/AIDS crisis among African Americans Retrieved April 4, 2007, from http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/topics/aa/resour ces/reports/pdf/heightenedresponse.pdf Centers for Disease Contro l and Prevention. (2007b). HIV/AIDS and African Americans. Retrieved May 1, 2010 from http: www.cdc.gov/hiv/topics/aa/index.htm Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2007c). Racial/ethnic disparities in diagnoses of HIV/AIDS 33 states, 2001-2005. MMWR, 56 (9), 189-193. Centers for Disease Contro l and Prevention. (2008a). HIV and AIDS in the United States: A picture of today's epidemic. Retrieved September 29, 2008 from http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/topics/s urveillance/united_states.htm Centers for Disease Contro l and Prevention. (2008b). HIV/AIDS among women Retrieved September 25, 2008, from http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/topics/wom en/resources/factsheets/women.htm Centers for Disease Contro l and Prevention. (2009a). Basic Statistics Retrieved April 30, 2010 from http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/topi cs/surveillance/basic.htm#ddaids Centers for Disease Contro l and Prevention. (2009b). HIV/AIDS among African Americans. Retrieved April 30, 2010 from http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/topics/a a/resources/factsheets/aa/htm Centers for Disease Contro l and Prevention. (2009c). U.S. Public Health Service Syphilis Study at Tuskegee. Retrieved July 8, 2010 from http://www.cdc.gov/tu skegee/timeline.htm Centers for Disease Contro l and Prevention (2010). Basic Information about HIV and AIDS Retrieved April 30, 2010, from http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/topics/basic/index.htm Chapman Walsh, D., Sorensen, G., & Leonard, L. (1995). Gender, H ealth, and Cigarette Smoking. In B.C. Amick III, S. Levine, A.R. Tarlov, & D. Chapman Walsh (Eds.), Society and Health (pp. 131-171). New York, NY: Oxford University Press. Connell, R.W. (1987). Gender and power. Stanford, CT: Stanford University Press.
249 Coreil, J., Lauzardo, M., & Heurtelou, M. (2004). Cultural feasibility assessment of tuberculosis prevention among persons of Haitian origin in South Florida. Journal of Immigrant Health, 6 (2), 63-69. Cournos, F., & Mckinnon, K. (1997). HIV Se roprevalence among people with severe mental illness in the United States. Clinical Psychology Review, 17 259-269. Crabtree, B.F., & Miller W.L. (Eds.). (1999). Doing qualitative research (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Creswell, J. W. (1998). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five traditions Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Dancy, B.L., & Berbaum, M.L. (2005). Condom use predictors for low-income African American women. West J Nurs. Res, 27 28-44. Davis, R.E., Couper, M.P., Janz, N.K., Caldwell, C.H., & Resnicow, K. (2010). Interviewer effects in public health survey. Health Education Research, 25 (1), 1426. Debus, M. (n.d.). Handbook for Excellence in Focus Group Research Retrieved June 25, 2007, from http://www.globalhealthcommunication.org/tools/60 Dickson-Swift, V., James, E.L., Kippen, S., & Liamputtong, P. (2008). Risk to researchers in qualitative research on se nsitive topics: Issues and strategies. Qualitative Health Research, 18, 133-144. DiClemente, R.J. & Wingood, G.M. (1995). A ra ndomized controlled trial of an HIV sexual risk reduction intervention for young African American women. JAMA, 274 (16), 1271-1276. DiClemente, R.J., Salazar, L.F., Crosby, R.A ., & Rosenthal, S.L. (2005). Prevention and control of sexually transmitted infections among adolescents: the importance of a socio-ecological perspective-a commentary. Journal of the Royal Institute of Public Health 119 825-836. Dolcini, M.M. & Catania, J.A. (2000). Psychos ocial profiles of wome n with risky sexual partners: The national AIDS behavioral surveys (NABS). AIDS and Behavior, 4 (3), 297-308.
250 Dworkin, S.L., Fullilove, R.E. & Peacock, D. (2009). Are HIV/AIDS Prevention interventions for heterosexually active me n in the United States gender-specific? American Journal of Public Health, 99 (6), 981-984. El-Bassel, N., Witte, S., Gilber t, L., Wu, E., Chang, M., Hill, J. (2003). The efficacy of a relationship-based HIV and STD preventi on program for heterosexual couples. American Journal of Public Health, 93 (6), 963-969. El-Bassel, N., Caldeira, N., Ruglass, L.M ., Gilbert, L. (2009). Addressing the unique needs of African American women in HIV prevention. American Journal of Public Health, 99 (6). 996-997. Essien, E. J., Meshack, A.F., Peters, R.J ., Ogungbade, G.O. & Osemene, N.I. (2005). Strategies to prevent HIV transmission among heterosexual African-American men Retrieved October 13, 2007, from http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/5/3 Exner, T. M., Gardos, P. S., Seal, D. W ., & Ehrhardt, A. A. (1999). HIV sexual risk reduction interventions with hete rosexual men: the forgotten group. AIDS and Behavior, 3 (4), 347-358. Farley, T. A. (2006). Sexually transmitted diseases in the southeastern United States: Location, race, and social context. Sexually Transmitted Diseases, 33 (7), S58S64. Farmer, P., Connors, M., & Si mmons, J. (Eds.). (1996). Women, poverty and AIDS: Sex, drugs and structural violence. Monroe, Maine: Co mmon Courage Press. Ferguson, Y.O., Quinn, S.C., Eng, E., & Sande lowski, M. (2006). The gender ratio imbalance and its relationship to risk of HIV/AIDS among African American women at historically black colleges and universities. AIDS Care, 18 (4), 323-331. Fisher, J.D. & Fisher, W.A. ( 1992). Changing AIDS-risk behavior. Psychological Bulletin 111 (3), 455-474. Fisher, J.D. & Fisher, W.A. (2002). The In formation-Motivation-Behavioral Skills Model. In R.J. DiClemente, R.A. Crosby & M.C. Kegler (Eds.), Emerging theories in health promotion practice and research: Strategies for improving public health (pp. 40-70). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
251 Flood, M. (2003). Lust, trust and latex: Why young heterosexual men do not use condoms. Culture, Health & Sexuality, 5 (4), 353-369. Florida Department of Healt h, Bureau of HIV/AIDS. (2006). Silence is death: The crisis of HIV/AIDS in Florida's Black communities Retrieved February 5, 2007, from http://www.doh.state.fl.us/D iseasectrl/aids/index.html Florida Department of Health, Bureau of HIV/AIDS (2007a). Florida HIV/AIDS Annual Report 2007. Retrieved May 1, 2010 from http://www.doh.state.fl.us/disease_ctrl/ai ds/trends/epiprof/mini_aids07c.pdf Florida Department of Health. (2007b). HIV/AIDS and Blacks: Silence is Death Retrieved September 25, 2008 from http://www.doh.state.fl.us/D isease_ctrl/aids/updates/facts/2007_B lack_Fact_Shee t.pdf. Florida Department of Health (2008a). Organizing to survive: The HIV/AIDS crisis among Florida's women Retrieved June 2008 from http://www.doh.state.fl.us/disease_ctrl/aids. Florida Department of Health. (2008b). Impact of HIV/AIDS cases among Caribbean born reported in Florida through 2008. Retrieved May 1, 2010 from http://www.doh.state.fl.us/Dis ease_ctrl/aids/tr ends/slides/2008_s lides/Caribbean0 8.pdf Florida Department of Health. (2008c). Haitians in Florida 2008. Retrieved May 1, 2010 from http://www.doh.state.fl.us/Dis ease_ctrl/aids/trends/slides/2008_slides/Haitians08. pdf Florida Department of Health. (2010). Man Up: The crisis of HIV/AIDS among Florida's men. Retrieved May 1, 2010 from http:www.floridaaids.org/Docs/Man_Up_Report.pdf Ford, C.L., Whetten, K.D., Hall, S.A., Kaufman, J.S. & Thrasher, A.D. (2007). Black sexuality, social constructi on, and research targeting 't he down low' ('the DL'). Ann Epidemiol, 17, 209-216.
252 Fullilove, R.E., Green, L., & Fullilove, M.T. (2000). The family to family program: a structural intervention with implicatio ns for the prevention of HIV/AIDS and other community epidemics. AIDS, 14 (Suppl 1), S63-S67. Gadon, M., Chierici, R.M. & Rios, P. (2001) Afro-American migr ant farmworkers: a culture in isolation. AIDS Care, 13 (6), 789-801. Gall, M.D., Gall, J.P., & Borg, W.R. (2003). Educational research: An introduction (7th ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon. Grbich, C. (1999). Qualitative research in health: An introduction Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Grzywacz, J.G. & Fuqua, J. (2000). The soci al ecology of health: Leverage points and linkages. Behavioral Medicine, 26 101-115. Hall, H.I., Song, R., Rhodes, P., Prejean, J. An Q., Lee, et al. (2008). Estimation of HIV incidence in the United States. JAMA, 300 (5):520-529. Harawa, N.T., Williams, J.K., Ramamurthi, H.C. & Bingham, T.A. (2006). Perceptions towards condom use, sexual activity, and HIV disclosure among HIV-positive African American men who have sex with men: Implications for heterosexual transmission. Journal of Urban Health, 83 (4), 682-694. Health Resources and Services Administration. (2008). African-Americans and HIV/AIDS. Retrieved April 30, 2010, from http://hab.hrsa.gov/populati on/aficanamericans.html Heise, L.L. & Elias, C. (1995). Transforming AIDS prevention to meet women's needs: A focus on developing countries. Soc. Sci. Med., 40 (7), 931-943. Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. (2008a). Black Americans and HIV/AIDS Retrieved August 15, 2008, from www.kff.org Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. (2008b). The Global HIV/AIDS Epidemic. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from www.kff.org
253 Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. (2008c). The HIV/AIDS Epidemic in the Caribbean. Retrieved August 15, 2008 from www.kff.org Hillsborough County Health Department (2006). Area 6 HIV/AIDS Statistics. Retrieved May 9, 2008, from http://www.hillscountyheal th.org/hiv_aids/newsletter/JULSEP2006.pdf Hinson, R. W., Strunin, L., Berlin, B., & Heer en, T. (1990). Beliefs about AIDS, use of alcohol and drugs, and u nprotected sex among adoles cents in Massachusetts. American Journal of Public Health, 80 295-299. Ickovics, J.R., Beren, S.E., Grigorenko, E.L., Morrill, A.C., Druley, J.A. & Rodin, J. (2002). Pathways of risk: Race, social class, stress, and coping as factors predicting heterosexual risk behaviors for HIV among women. AIDS and Behavior, 6 (4), 339-350. Janz, N. K., & Becker, M. H. (1984). The heath belief model: A decade later. Health Education Quarterly, 11 1-47. Janz, N.K., Champion, V.L. & Strecher, V.J. (2002). The health belief model. In K. Glanz, B.K. Rimer & F.M. Lewis (Eds.), Health behavior and health education: Theory, research and practice (pp. 45-66). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Jarama, S. L., Belgrave, F.Z., Bradford, J., Young, M., & Honnold, J.A. (2007). Family, cultural and gender role as pects in the context of HIV risk among African American women of unidentified HIV st atus: An explorator y qualitative study. AIDS Care, 19 (3), 307-317. Jemmott, L.S., Jemmott, J.B., & O'Leary, A. (2 007). Effects on sexual risk behavior and STD rate of brief HIV/STD prevention interventions for African American women in primary settings. American Journal of Public Health, 97 (6), 1-7. Kalichman, S., Cherry, C., & Browne-Sperling, F. (1999). effectiveness of a video-based motivational skills-building risk-reducti on intervention for inner-city African American men. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 67 (6), 959-966. Kegeles, S. S., Kirscht, J. P., Haefner, D. P., & Rosenstock, I. M. (1965). Survey of beliefs about cancer detection and taking papanicolaou tests. Public Health Reports, 80 815-823.
254 Kent, M.M. (2007) Immigration and America's Black Populatio n. (Population Bulletin Vol. 62, No. 4). Washington, DC: Population Reference Bureau. Klonoff, E.A. & Landrine, H. (1999). Do black s believe that HIV/AI DS is a government conspiracy against them? Preventive Medicine, 28, 451-457. Krueger, R. A., & Casey, M. A. (2000). Focus groups (3rd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Lane, S.D., Rubinstein, R.A., Keefe, R.H., We bster, N., Cibula, D.A., Rosenthal, A. et al., (2004). Structural vi olence and racial dispar ity in HIV transmission. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved, 15, 319-335. Lauby, J.L., Smith, P.J., Stark, M., Person, B ., & Adams, J. (2000). A community-level prevention intervention for inner city wo men: Results of the women and infants demonstration projects. American Journal of Public Health, 90 (2), 216-222. Lawless, S., Kippax, S., & Crawford, J. ( 1996). Dirty, diseased and undeserving: The positioning of HIV positive women. Soc. Sci. Med., 43 (9), 1371-1377. Lerner, M.L. (2005). Urie Bronfenbrenner: Career contributions of the consummate developmental scientist. In U. Bronfenbrenner (Ed.), Making human beings human: Bioecological perspectives on human development (pp. ix -xxvi). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Lewis, L.J. & Kertzner, R.M. (2003). To ward improved interpretation and theory building of African Amer ican male sexualities. The Journal of Sex Research, 40 (4), 383-395. Lincoln, Y.S. & Guba, E.G. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications Locke, L.F., Wyrick Spirduso, W., & Silverman, S.J. (2000). Proposals that work: A guide for planning dissertations and grant proposals (4th ed.) Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications: Logan, T.K., Cole, J., Leukefeld, C. (2002). Wo men, sex and HIV: Soci al and contextual factors, meta-analysis of published inte rventions, and implications for practice and research. Psychological Bulletin, 128 (6), 851-885.
255 Lush, T. (2002, May 6). Haitian roots deepening. St. Petersburg Times. Maes, C.A., Louis, M. (2003). Knowledge of AIDS, perceived risk of AIDS, and at-risk sexual behaviors among older adults. Journal of the Academy of Nurse Practitioners, 15 (11), 509-516. Magee, E.M., Small, M., Frederic, R., Joseph, G., & Kershaw, T. (2006). Determinants of HIV/AIDS risk behaviors in expectant fathers in Haiti. Journal of Urban Health, 83, 625-636. Maiman, L. A., & Becker, M. H. (1974). The health belief model: Origins and correlates in psychological theory. Health Education Monographs, 2 336-353. Mantell, J.E., Dworkin, S.L., Exner, T.M., Hoffman, S., Smit, & Susser, I. (2006). The promises and limitations of female-in itiated methods of HIV/STI protection. Social Science & Medicine, 63, 1998-2009. Martin, M.A., Rissmiller, P., & Beal, J.A. ( 1995). Health-illness beliefs and practices of Haitians with HIV disease living in Boston. JANAC, 6 (6), 45-53. Massey, D.S. (2004). Segregation and stra tification: A biosocial perspective. Du Bois Review, 1 (1), 7-25. Matthews, H. (2004, June). Why Study Beliefs. Guest lecture presented at Qualitative Methods in Community Health Research Class, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL. Mays, V.M., Cochran, S.D., & Zamudio, A. (2004). HIV prevention research: Are we meeting the needs of African American men who have sex with men? Journal of Black Psychology, 30 (1), 78-105. McCormack Brown, K. (1999). Health Belief Model Overview Retrieved November 14, 2003, from http://hsc.usf.edu/~kmbrown /HBMInteractiveHandout.htm McCree, D.H. (2009). A plan of action for tackling HIV/AIDS among African Americans. American Journal of Public Health, 99 (6), 972.
256 McDonnell, M., & Kessenich, C. R. (2000). HIV/AIDS and women. Lippincott's Primary Care Practice, 4 (1), 66-73. Meade, C.S. (2006). Sexual risk behavior among persons dually diagnosed with severe mental illness and substance use disorder. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 30 147-154. Medicine Net (2008). Definition of Heterosexual. Retrieved January 27, 2008, from http://www.medterms.com/script/m ain/art.asp?articlekey=3745 Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary (10th ed.). (1993). Springf ield, MA: MerriamWebster. Miller, M., Serner, M., & Wagner, M. (2005). Drug-using men who have sex with men in an inner-city community. Journal of Urban Health, 82 (1), Suppl 1, i26-i34. Millett, G., Malebranche, D ., Mason, B., & Spikes, P. (2005). Focusing "down low": Bisexual black men, HIV risk and heterosexual transmission. Journal of the National Medical Association, 97 (7), 52S-59S. Montao, D.E. & Kasprzk, D. (2002). The theo ry of reasoned action and the theory of planned behavior. In K. Glanz, B.K. Rimer & F.M. Lewis (Eds.), Health behavior and health education: Theory, research and practice (pp. 67-98). San Francisco, CA: Josey-Bass. Montgomery, S. B., Joseph, J. G., Becker, M. H., Ostrow, D. G., Kessler, R. C., & Kirscht, J. P. (1989). The health belie f model in understanding compliance with preventive recommendations for AIDS: How useful? AIDS Education and Prevention, 1 303-323. Morin S.F., Vernon, K., Harcourt, J., Steward, W.T., Volk, J., Riess, T.H. et al. (2003). Why HIV infections have increased among men who have sex with men and what to do about it: Findings fr om California focus groups. AIDS and Behavior, 7 (4), 353-362. Nachman, S.R. & Dreyfuss, G. (1986). Ha itians and AIDS in South Florida. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 17 (2), 32-33.
257 National Alliance of State & Terr itorial AIDS Directors (2005). A Turning Point: Confronting HIV/AIDS in African American Communities Retrieved January 20, 2007, from http://www.nastad.org/Docs/high light/2006113_AA_Call2Action_120905_final.p df National Cancer Institute (2007). Health Disparities Defined. Retrieved January 26, 2008, from http://crchd.cancer.gov /definitions/defined.html National Institute on Drug Abuse (2006). Research Report: HIV/AIDS Retrieved April 16, 2010, from http://www.drugabuse.gov/ ResearchReports/HV/HIV.html National Minority AIDS Council. (2006). African Americans, he alth disparities and HIV/AIDS Retrieved February 5, 2007, from http://www.nmac.org/nmac2/PDF/NMA C%20Advocacy%20Report_December% 202006.pdf Neuman, W.L. (2003). Social research methods: Qualitative and quantitative approaches (5th ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon. O'Leary, A., & Martins, P. (2000). Structural factors affecting women's HIV risk: a life course example. AIDS, 14 (S1), S68-S72. Operario, D., Smith, C. & Kegeles, S. (2008) Social and psychologi cal context for HIV risk in non-gay-identified African Am erican men who have sex with men. AIDS Education and Prevention, 20 (3), 347-359. O'Sullivan, L.F., Hoffman, S., Harrison, A. & Dolezal, C. (2006). Men, multiple sexual partners, and young adults' sexual relations hips: Understanding th e role of gender in the study of risk. Journal of Urban Health, 83 (4), 695-708. Othieno, J. (2007). Understanding how cont extual realities affect African born immigrants and refugees living with HI V in accessing care in the Twin Cities. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved, 18 170-188. Otto-Salaj, L. L., Kelly, J.A., Stevenson, L.Y., Hoffmann, R., & Kalichman, S.C. (2001). Outcomes of a randomized small-group HIV prevention intervention trial for people with serious mental illness. Community Mental Health Journal., 37 (2), 123-144.
258 Parker, R. (2001). Sexuality, culture, and power in HIV/AIDS research. Annu. Rev. Anthropol., 30, 163-179. Parker, R., Aggleton, P., Attawell, K ., Pulerwitz, J., & Brown, L. (2002). HIV/AIDSrelated stigma and discrimination: A conceptual framework and agenda for action. New York, NY: The Population Council. Parry, C. D., Blank, M.B., & Pithey, A.L. ( 2007). Responding to the threat of HIV among persons with mental illn ess and substance abuse. Current Opinion in Psychiatry, 20 235-241. Paterson, B.L., Gregory, D., & Thorne, S. ( 1999). A protocol for researcher safety. Qualitative Health Research, 9, 259-269. Patton, M.Q. (2002). Qualitative research & evaluation methods (3rd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Pinkerton, S. D., Johnson-Masotti, A.P., Otto-Salaj, L.L., Stevenson, L.Y., & Hoffmann, R.G. (2001). Cost-effectiveness of an HIV prevention interventi on for mentally ill adults. Mental Health Services Research, 3 (1), 45-55. Plowden, K. O., Fletcher, A., & Miller, J. L. (2005). Factors influencing HIV-risk behaviors among HIV-positive urban African Americans. Journal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care, 16 (1), 21-28. Potocky, M., Dodge, K., & Greene, M. (2007) Bridging the cultura l chasms between providers and HIV-positive Haitians in Palm Beach County, Florida. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved, 18, 105-117. Prochaska, J.O., Redding, C.A. & Evers, K.E. (2002). The transtheoretical model and stages of change. In K. Glanz, B.K. Rimer & F.M. Lewis (Eds.), Health behavior and health education: Theory, research and practice (pp. 99-120). San Francisco, CA: Josey-Bass. Pulerwitz, J., Amaro, H., De Jong, W., Gortmaker, S.L., Rudd, R. (2002). Relationship power, condom use and HIV risk among women in the USA. AIDS Care, 14 (6), 789-800.
259 Quinn, T.C. & Overbaugh, J. (2005). HIV/AI DS in Women: An Expanding Epidemic. Science 308, 1582-1583. Raiford, J.L., DiClemente, R.J., Wingood, G.M. (2009). Effects of fear of abuse and possible STI acquisition on the sexual behavior of young African American women. Am Journal of Public Health, 99 (6), 1067-1071. Raj, A., Silverman, J.G., Wingood, G.M., & Di Clemente, R.J. (1999). Prevalence and correlates of relationship abuse among a community-based sample of low-income African American women. Violence Against Women, 5 (3), 272-291. Read, J. G., & Emerson, M. O. (2005). Racial context, black immigration and the U.S. black/white health disparity. Social Forces, 84 (1), 181-199. Read, J. G., Emerson, M.O. & Tarlov, A. (2005). Implications of black immigrant health for U.S. racial disparities in health. Journal of Immigrant Health, 7 (3), 205-212. Reid, P.T., (2000). Women. Ethnicity, and AI DS: What's love got to do with it? Sex Roles, 42 (7/8), 709-722. Rhodes, T. (1997). Risk theory in epidemic times: sex, drugs, and the social organisation of 'risk behaviour'. Sociology of Health & Illness, 19 (2), 208-227. Rhodes, T., Singer, M., Bourgois, P., Friedma n, S.R., Strathdee, S.A. (2005). The social structural production of HIV ri sk among injecting drug users. Social Science & Medicine, 61 1026-1044. Romero-Daza, N., Weeks, M., Singer, M. (1998). Much more than HIV! The reality of life on the streets for drug-using sex workers in inner city Hartford. Int'l Quarterly of Community Health Education, 18 (1), 107-119. Rosenstock, I. M. (1966). Why people use health services. The Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly, 44 94-127. Rosenstock, I. M. (1974a). The health be lief model and preventive health behavior. Health Education Monographs, 2 354-386.
260 Rosenstock, I. M. (1974b). Historical origins of the health belief model. Health Education Monographs, 2 328-335. Rosenstock, I. M., Derryberry, M., & Carrige r, B. K. (1959). Why people fail to seek poliomyelitis vaccination. Public Health Reports, 74 98-103. Rosenstock, I. M., Strecher, V. J., & Becker, M. H. (1994). The health belief model and HIV risk behavior change. In R. J. DiClemente & J. L. Peterson (Eds.), Preventing AIDS: Theories and methods of behavioral interventions New York: Plenum Press. Santana, M., & Dancy, B.L. (2000). The s tigma of being named "AIDS carriers" on Haitian-American women. Health Care for Women International, 21 161-171. Santelli, J., Ott, M.A., Lyon, M., Rogers J., Summers, D., Schleifer, R. (2006). Abstinence and abstinence-only educatio n: A review of U.S. policies and programs. Journal of Adolescent Health, 38, 72-81. Santelli, J., Ott, M.A., Lyon, M., Rogers J., Summers, D. (2006). Abstinence-only education policies and programs: A positi on paper of the Society for Adolescent Medicine. Journal of Adolescent Health 38, 83-87. Sather, L. & Zinn, K. (2002). Effects of abs tinence-only education on adolescent attitudes and values concerning premar ital sexual intercourse. Family & Community Health, 17 (2), 1-15. Scolari, Sage Publications Software. (1997). Ethnograph Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc. Sikkema, K.J., Hansen, N.B., Kochman, A., Tarakeshwar, N., Neufeld, S., Meade, C.S., Fox, A.M. (2007). Outcomes from a group intervention for coping with HIV/AIDS and childhood sexual abuse: Reductions in traumatic stress. AIDS Behavior, 11 (1), 49-60. Stanton, B., Cole, M., Galbraith, J., Xiaomi ng, L., Pendleton, S., Co ttrel., et al. (2004). Randomized trial of a parent intervention: Parents can make a difference in longterm adolescent risk behavi ors, perceptions, and knowledge. Arch Ped Adolesc Med, 158 (10), 947-55.
261 Strecher, V. J., DeVellis, B. M., Becker, M. H., & Rosenstock, I. M. (1986). The health belief model and HIV ri sk behavior change. Health Education Quarterly, 13 7391. Strecher, V. J., & Rosenstock, I. M. (1997). The health belief model. In K. Glanz, F. M. Lewis & B. K. Rimer (Eds.), Health Behavior and Health Education San Francisco: Josses-Bass Publishers. Stokes, J.P. & Peterson, J.L. (1998). Homophobia, self-estee m, and risk for HIV among African American men who have sex with men. AIDS Educ Prev, 10, 278-292. Sumartojo, E. (2000). Structural factors in HIV prevention: concepts, examples, and implications for research. AIDS, 14 (suppl 1), S3-S10. Tallis, V. (2001). Gender dimensions of HIV/AIDS treatment programs. Canadian Woman Studies, 21 (2), 63-67. Thomas, J.C. & Thomas, K.K. (1999). Things ai n't what they ought to be: social forces underlying racial disparities in rates of sexually transmitted diseases in a rural North Carolina county. Social Science & Medicine, 49, 1075-1084. Thorne, S. (2000). Data analys is in qualitative research. Evid Based Nurs, 3, 68-70. Turmen, T. (2003). Gender and HIV/AIDS. International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics, 82 411-418. U.S. Census Bureau. (2000). County factsheet: Hillsborough County, Florida Retrieved June 25, 2007, from http://www.census.gov/ U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2000). Healthy people 2010: Understanding and improving health. 2nd ed. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2005). Substance Abuse and HIV/AIDS Retrieved April 16, 2010, from ftp://ftp.hrsa.gov/hab/su bstance.final.pdf
262 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2007). Dear colleague letter Retrieved March 9, 2007, from www.cdc.gov/hiv/topic/aa/resourc es/other/pdf_Dear_Colleague_03082007.pdf U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2010). Stages of HIV. Retrieved April 30, 2010, from http://www.aids.gov/hiv-aids -basics/diagnosed-with-hiv-aids/hivin-your-body/stages-of-hiv/ U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2010). Healthcare.gov. Retrieved July 5, 2010, from http://www.healthcare.gov/ U.S. Department of Justice. (2004). HIV in Prisons Retrieved February 16, 2008, from http://www.ncjrs.gov/App/Public ations/abstrac t.aspx?ID=235402 U.S. Department of Justice. (2007). Prison and Jail Inmates at Midyear 2006. Retrieved February 16, 2008, from http:// www.ojp.gov/bjs/pubs/ascii/pjim06.txt Ulin, P. R., Robinson, E. T., & Tolley, E. E. (2005). Qualitative methods in public health: A field guide for applied research San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Vivelo, F.R. (1978). Cultural Anthropology Handbook. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill. Vijayakumar, G., Mabude, Z., Smit, J., Beksin ska, M., Lurie, M. (2006). A review of female-condom effectivene ss: patterns of use and im pact on protected sex acts and STI incidence. International Journal of STD & AIDS, 17 (10), 552-659. Welbourn, A. (2006). Sex, life and the fema le condom: Some views of HIV positive women. Reproductive Health Matters, 14 (28), 32-40. Wheeler, D.P. (2006). Exploring HIV preven tion needs for non-gay identified black and African American men who have sex with men: A qualitative exploration. Sexually Transmitted Diseases, 33 (7), S11-S16. Whitehead, T. (1997). Urban low-income Af rican American men, HIV/AIDS, and gender identity. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 11 (4), 411-447. Whyte, J. (2005). The measurement of HIV ri sk level in African American women who dwell in the southeastern United States. JANAC, 16 (6), 48-55.
263 Wight, D. (1999). Cultural factors in young he terosexual men's perception of HIV risk. Sociology of Health & Illness, 21 (6), 735-758. Wilson, B.D.M & Miller, R.L. (2003). Examini ng strategies for culturally grounded HIV prevention: A review. AIDS Education and Prevention, 15 (2), 184-202. Wingood, G.M. & DiClemente, R.J. (1998). Partne r influences and gender-related factors associated with noncondom use amo ng young adult African American women. AIDS Care, 18 (4), 323-331. Wingood, G.M. & DiClemente, R.J. (2000). Appl ication of the theory of gender and power to examine HIV-related exposures, ri sk factors, and effective interventions for women. Health Education & Behavior, 27 (5), 539-565. Wingood, G.M. & DiClemente, R.J. (2002). The Theory of Gender and Power. In R.J. DiClemente, R.A. Crosby & M.C. Kegler (Eds.), Emerging theories in health promotion practice and research: Strate gies for improvi ng public health (pp. 313346). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Wohl, A.R., Johnson, D.F., Lu, S., Jordan, W., Beall, G., Currier, J. et al. (2002). HIV risk behaviors among African American men in Los Angeles county who selfidentify as heterosexual. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome, 31 (3), 354-360. Wolitski, R.J., Jones, K.T., Wasserman, & Sm ith, J.C. (2006). Self-identification as "down low" among men who have sex w ith men (MSM) from 12 U.S. cities. AIDS Behavior, 10 519-529. World Health Organization (2008). AIDS Epidemic Update. Retrieved April 30, 2010, from http://data.unaids.org/pub/Re port/2009/JC1700_Epi_Update_2009_en.pdf Worth, D. (1989). Sexual decision-making and AIDS: Why condom promotion among vulnerable women is likely to fail. Studies in Family Planning, 20 (6), 297-307. Wyatt, G.E., Longshore, D., Chin, D., Carmona J.V., Loeb T.B., Myers, H.F., Warda, U., Liu, H., Rivkin, I. (2004). The efficacy of an integrated risk reduction intervention for HIV-positive women with child sexual abuse histories. AIDS Behavior, 8 (4), 453-462.
264 Wyatt, G.E. (2009). Enhancing cultural and c ontextual intervention strategies to reduce HIV/AIDS among African Americans. American Journal of Public Health, 99 (11), 1941-1945. Zak-Place, J., Stern, M. (2004). Health belie f factors and dispositional optimism as predictors of STD and HIV preventive behavior. Journal of American College Health, 54 (5), 229-236.
266 Appendix A: Epidemiological Data Figure 1: Race/ethnicity of persons (including children ) with HIV/AIDS diagnosed during 2007 Note : Based on data from 34 states with l ong-term, confidential, name-based HIV reporting. Source : CDC Website. http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/topics/a a/resources/factsheets/aa.htm
267 Appendix A (continued) Figure 2. Percentage of adult AIDS cases by race/ethnicity, Florida, compared with percentage of adult HIV cases by race/ethnicity, Florida, 2007. *Other includes Asian/Pacific Islanders, Native Alaskans/American Indians and mixed races.*2007 Florida Population Estimates, Adu lts (Ages 13+), DOH, Office of Planning, Evaluation and Data Analysis. Source: Florida HIV/AIDS Annual Report 2007 (mini version). http://www.doh.state.fl.us/disease_ctrl/ aids/trends/epiprof/mini_aids07c.pdf
268 Appendix A (continued) Table 1: Cumulative HIV cases through 9/30/06 in Hillsborough County Race/Ethnicity Adult/Adolescent Pediatric Total Cases % Cases % Cases % Hispanic All races 324 15% 5 17% 329 15% NonHispanic Am. Indian/Alaska Native 5 0% 0 0% 5 0% Asian 1 0% 0 0% 1 0% Black/African American 1003 48% 21 69% 1024 49% Asian/Pacific Islander 3 0% 0 0% 3 0% White 744 35% 5 14% 749 35% Multi-race 17 1% 0 0% 17 1% Total 2097 100% 31 100% 2128 100% Source: Hillsborough County Health Department http://www.hillscountyhealth.org/hiv_aids/newsletter/JUL-SEP2006.pdf
269 Appendix A (continued) Table 2. HIV/AIDS cases among Caribbean born reported through 2008 (N=24,069) Caribbean Country of Birth F requency of HIV/AIDS Cases Aruba 9 Anguilla 1 Netherland Antilles 5 Antigua and Barbuda 25 Bahamas 589 Bermuda 9 Barbados 70 Cuba 6294 Cayman Islands 10 Dominica 15 Dominican Republic 439 Guadeloupe 2 Grenada 26 Haiti 10956 Jamaica 1427 St. Lucia 28 Montserrat 1 Martinique 2 Puerto Rico 3678 Turks and Caicos Islands 65 Trinidad and Tobago 206 St. Vincent and the Grenadines12 British Virgin Islands 15 U.S. Virgin Islands 185 Comment: Of the 24,069 HIV/AIDS cases bor n in the Caribbean, 24,047 were adults (13 years and older) and 22 were pediatric cases. Source: Florida Department of H ealth Bureau of HIV/AIDS. http://www.doh.state.fl.us/Dis ease_ctrl/aids/tr ends/slides/2008_s lides/Caribbean0 8.pdf
270 Appendix B: Population Data Table 1: U.S. foreign-born black population by country of birth Country of Birth Number living in the U.S. Africa 512,628 Caribbean 1,250,611 Central America 136,535 South America 113,347 Others 867,717 Total 2,099,865 Source: U.S. Census Bureau. www.census.gov Table 2: Estimates of U.S.-born and forei gn-born black population in Florida by selected County and region of origin Hillsborough County Black Population 147,966 U.S.-born blacks (African American) 137,925 Foreign-born blacks 10,041 Foreign-born blacks by region Barbados 167 Haiti 2,370 Jamaica 3,571 Trinidad & Tobago 1,343 Other Caribbean 1,692 East & West Africa 1,012 Source: U.S. Census Bureau. www.census.gov
271 Appendix C: Recruitment Flyers WE NEED YOUR OPINION! Nou vle f yon ti pale av-w We need your opinion on sexual health, and relationships in the Black/African American and Haitian community We are looking for men who are: Black or African American and born in the United States or Born in Haiti Are 18 years and older Live in Hillsborough County If you are selected, you will be paid for your time (Interviews will be conducted in English) If you would like to partici pate please call 813-230-xxxx UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH FLORIDA
272 Appendix C (continued) WE NEED YOUR OPINION! Nou vle f yon ti pale av-w We need your opinion on sexual health, and relationships in the Black/African American and Haitian community We are looking for women who are: Black or African American and born in the United States or Born in Haiti Are 18 years and older Live in Hillsborough County If you are selected, you will be paid for your time (Interviews will be conducted in English) If you would like to partici pate please call 813-230-xxxx UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH FLORIDA
273 Appendix D: Eligibility Checklists Eligibility Checklist: Men The criteria below will be used to determine the inclusion or exclusion of men from the study. Do you consider yourself to be black ? ________ (Yes) Were you born in the United States? ________ (Yes) OR Were you born in Haiti? ________ (Yes) Do you consider yourself to be heterosexual? ________ (Yes) How long have you lived in the U.S.? ________ (at least 3 years) How old are you? ________ (18 years or older) Do you reside in Hillsborough County? ________ (Yes) Are you able to understand/speak English? ________ (Yes) Have you ever had sexual intercourse? ________ (Yes) If respondents answer according to the re sponses indicated in brackets, they qualify for the study. If qualify, ask the person to provide a fi rst name that they would like to be referred as at the time of the interview. ______________________________ Schedule a date, time, and location for the interview. If their responses do not co rrespond to the answers in br ackets they do not qualify for the interview. Thank the caller for their ti me and inform them that they do not qualify for the study.
274 Appendix D (continued) Eligibility Checklist: Women The criteria below will be used to determine the inclusion or exclusion of women from the study. Do you consider yourself to be black ? ________ (Yes) Were you born in the United States? ________ (Yes) OR Were you born in Haiti? ________ (Yes) Do you consider yourself to be heterosexual? ________ (Yes) How long have you lived in the U.S.? ________ (at least 3 years) How old are you? ________ (18 years or older) Do you reside in Hillsborough County? ________ (Yes) Are you able to understand/speak English? ________ (Yes) Have you had at least one African American/Haitian sex partner? ________ (Yes) If respondents answer according to the re sponses indicated in brackets, they qualify for the study. If qualify, ask the person to provide a fi rst name that they would like to be referred as at the time of the interview. ______________________________ Schedule a date, time, and location for the interview. If their responses do not co rrespond to the answers in br ackets they do not qualify for the interview. Thank the caller for their ti me and inform them that they do not qualify for the study.
275 Appendix E: Demographic Survey Demographic Survey We would like to know more about you by asking you a few questions. We do not need your name and all the information you sh are with us will be kept confidential. 1. What is your age? ______________________ 2. Tell me about your marital status. Are you: 1. Married 2. Divorced 3. Widowed 4. Separated 5. Never married 6. Member of an unmarried couple 3. How would you describe your ethnicity? 1. Hispanic or Latino 2. Not Hispanic or Latino 4. How would you describe your race? 1. American Indian or Alaska Native 2. Asian 3. Black or African American 4. Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander 5. White 5. What is the highest grade or year of school you finished? 1. Never attended school or only attended kindergarten 2. 8th grade or less 3. 9th to 11th grade 4. High school graduate or GED 5. Some college or techni cal school (1-3 years) 6. College graduate or higher degree (college 4 years or more) 6. What is your household income level? 1. Under $15,000 per year 2. $15,000-$24,999 per year 3. $25,000-$34,999 per year 4. $35,000-$44,999 per year 5. $45,000-$59,999 per year 6. $60,000-$75,000 per year 7. $75,000 or more per year
276 7. Tell me about your employment status 1. Employed for wages 2. Self-employed 3. Out of work for more than 1 year 4. Out of work for less than 1 year 5. A homemaker 6. Student 7. Retired 8. Unable to work 8. How would you describe your sexual orientation?(please pick one) 1. Heterosexual 2. Bisexual 3. Homosexual or gay 4. Other (please specify) _______________________ 9. How did you find out about this study? 1. Flyer 2. Newspaper 3. Friend 4. Other (please describe) ______________________ Thank you for completing this demographic survey!
277 Appendix F: Informed C onsent for Interviews Informed Consent Information to Consider Before Taking Part in This Research Study IRB Study # 107697 I The following information is being presen ted to you to help you decide whether or not you want to be involved in this research study. Please read this carefully. If there is anything you do not understand, please ask the person in charge of the study. Title of the Study : An Exploratory Study of the Intrapersonal, Socio-Cultural, and Behavioral Factors that influence HIV Risk Behavi ors among Ethnic Subgroups of Black Heterosexual Men: The Intersection of the Beliefs and Pe rceptions of Black Women This consent is for individual in terviews with male participants. Person in charge of this research study : Shalewa Noel-Thomas. Where the study will be done: various public sites in Hillsborough County. Should you take part in this study? This form tells you about this research study. After reading through this form and having the research explained to you by someone conducting this research, you can decide if you want to take part in it. If, at any time, you ha ve any questions, feel free to ask the person explaining this study to you. This form explains: Why this study is being done. What will happen during this study and what you will need to do. Whether there is any chance you might experience potential benefits from being in this study. The risks of having problems because you are in this study. Its up to you. If you choose to be in the study, then you can sign the form. If you do not want to take part in this study, you should not sign the form.
278 Why is this research being done? You are invited to participat e in a research study about sexual health, behaviors of Black men, and HIV risk and transmission in the Black community. The purpose of the study is to learn about the HIV risk behavi ors among black men including their attitudes, values, beliefs, and experiences as well as the beliefs of Black women. What are the study procedures? If you agree to be in the study, you will si t down for an interview with a trained interviewer who will ask you questions about your life experiences, sexual experiences, beliefs, attitudes, and perceptions. The interview will be audio taped. You will also be asked to complete a short survey th at asks general questions about you. How long will you be asked to stay in the study? The interview will take 1 2 hours to co mplete. The general demographic survey will take 10 -15 minutes. Will you be paid for taking part in this study? You will be paid $25 for your participation in this study. You will also be paid for any applicable travel costs (bus fare, mileage) to the interview site. You will be paid in cash immediately after you co mplete your participation. What will it cost you to take part in this study? You will need to provide your own transportation to take part in the study. What are the potential benefits if you take part in this study? The information you provide will be used to help researchers, health professionals and other agenci es understand the knowledge, attitudes, beliefs and life experiences of blacks w ith regard to sexual behaviors and HIV transmission. Findings may be used to develop prevention messages and intervention programs with the black community. You will receive written materials on HIV prevention. What are the risks if you take part in this study? We do not anticipate any risk s to you as you participat e in this study. However, some of the interview questi ons about sexual experiences, beliefs and perceptions may make you uncomfortable. Please remember th at your participation is voluntary and you are free to decline to answer any questions or to stop your participation in the study at any time. Should you experience any mental distress during the interview, you will be referred to mental health re sources in your community. Who will see the information that you give? In our research, we use and share inform ation about people and their health. We know that this information is private. Federal law protects health information.
279 The law lets us use and share health inform ation for research if you agree to let us do this. If you let us use and share informa tion about you, we will pr otect it as required by law. If you sign this form, it means you are letti ng us use and share this information for research. Your information will be stored on a password protected computer. When we write up the study, your information will be combin ed with that of other participants and shared with research participants, other researchers, and community members. Your name or other identifying information will be kept confidential Authorized research personnel, the USF Institutional Review Board and its staff and other USF personnel may inspect the reco rds from this study. The results of this study may be published. However, the published results will not in clude your name or any other personal information th at could identify you in any way. Your Rights: You can refuse to sign this form. If you do not sign this form: You will not be able to take part in this research study You will be given a copy of this c onsent form. PARTICIPATION IN THIS STUDY IS VOLUNTARY. You may withdr aw from the study at any time. What if you join the study and d ecide you want to stop later on? You can decide after signing this info rmed consent document that you no longer want to take part in this study. If you decide you want to stop taking part in the study, tell the study staff as soon as you can. You can get the answers to your questions. If you have questions about the study, please call Shalewa NoelThomas at (813) 230-0210. If you have questions about your ri ghts as a person who is taking part in a research study, you may contact the Division of Research Compliance at the University of South Florida at (813) 974-5638. Signatures for Consent for this Research Study It is up to you to decide whether you want to take part in this study. If you want to take part, please read the statements below a nd sign the form if the statements are true. I freely give my consent to take part in this study. I understand that by signing this form I am agreeing to take part in research. I have received a copy of this form to take with me. Signature of Person Taking Part in Study Date Printed Name of Person Taking Part in Study
280 Statement of Person Obtaining Informed Consent / Research Authorization I have carefully explained to the person taki ng part in the study what he or she can expect. I hereby certify that when this person signs this form, to the best of my knowledge, he or she understands: What the study is about. What procedures/interventions/i nvestigational drugs or devices will be used. What the potential benefits might be. What the known risks might be. I also certify that he or she does not have any problems that could make it hard to understand what it means to take part in this research. This person speaks the language that was used to explain this research. This person reads well enough to understand this form or, if not, this person is able to hear and understand when th e form is read to him or her. Signature of Person Obtaining Informed Consent Date Printed Name of Person Obtaining Informed Consent
281 Appendix G: Informed Consent for Focus Groups Informed Consent Information to Consider Before Taking Part in This Research Study IRB Study # 107697 I The following information is being presen ted to you to help you decide whether or not you want to be involved in this research study. Please read this carefully. If there is anything you do not understand, please ask the person in charge of the study. Title of the Study : An Exploratory Study of the Intrapersonal, Socio-Cultural, and Behavioral Factors that influence HIV Risk Behavi ors among Ethnic Subgroups of Black Heterosexual Men: The Intersection of the Beliefs and Pe rceptions of Black Women This consent is for focus gr oups with female participants. Person in charge of this research study : Shalewa Noel-Thomas. Where the study will be done: various public sites in Hillsborough County. Should you take part in this study? This form tells you about this research study. After reading through this form and having the research explained to you by someone conducting this research, you can decide if you want to take part in it. If, at any time, you ha ve any questions, feel free to ask the person explaining this study to you. This form explains: Why this study is being done. What will happen during this study and what you will need to do. Whether there is any chance you might experience potential benefits from being in this study. The risks of having problems because you are in this study. Its up to you. If you choose to be in the study, then you can sign the form. If you do not want to take part in this study, you should not sign the form.
282 Why is this research being done? You are invited to participat e in a research study about sexual health, behaviors of Black men, and HIV risk and transmission in the Black community. The purpose of the study is to learn about the HIV risk behavi ors among black men including their attitudes, values, beliefs, and experiences as well as the beliefs of Black women. What are the study procedures? If you agree to be in the study, you will si t down for a focus group with a trained interviewer who will ask you questions about your life experiences, sexual experiences, beliefs, attitudes, and perceptions. The entire focus group discussion will be audio taped. You will also be asked to complete a short survey that asks general questions about you. How long will you be asked to stay in the study? The focus group will take 1 2 hours to complete. The general demographic survey will take 10 -15 minutes. Will you be paid for taking part in this study? You will be paid $25 for your participation in this study. You will also be paid for any applicable travel costs (bus fare, mileage) to the interview site. You will be paid in cash immediately after you co mplete your participation. What will it cost you to take part in this study? You will need to provide your own transportation to take part in the study. What are the potential benefits if you take part in this study? The information you provide will be used to help researchers, health professionals and other agenci es understand the knowledge, attitudes, beliefs and life experiences of blacks w ith regard to sexual behaviors and HIV transmission. Findings may be used to develop prevention messages and intervention programs with the black community. You will receive written materials on HIV prevention. What are the risks if you take part in this study? We do not anticipate any risk s to you as you participat e in this study. However, some of the interview questi ons about sexual experiences, beliefs and perceptions may make you uncomfortable. Please remember th at your participation is voluntary and you are free to decline to answer any questions or to stop your participation in the study at any time. Should you experience any mental distress during the interview, you will be referred to mental health re sources in your community. Who will see the information that you give? In our research, we use and share inform ation about people and their health. We know that this information is private. Federal law protects health information.
283 The law lets us use and share health inform ation for research if you agree to let us do this. If you let us use and share informa tion about you, we will pr otect it as required by law. If you sign this form, it means you are letti ng us use and share this information for research. Your information will be stored on a password protected computer. When we write up the study, your information will be combin ed with that of other participants and shared with research participants, other researchers, and community members. Your name or other identifying information will be kept confidential. Because of the group setting, absolute confidentiality cannot be guaranteed. However, we ask that you keep what is discussed during the group confiden tial and not disclosed to others outside the group. Authorized research personnel, the USF Institutional Review Board and its staff and other USF personnel may inspect the reco rds from this study. The results of this study may be published. However, the published results will not in clude your name or any other personal information th at could identify you in any way. Your Rights: You can refuse to sign this form. If you do not sign this form: You will not be able to take part in this research study You will be given a copy of this c onsent form. PARTICIPATION IN THIS STUDY IS VOLUNTARY. You may withdr aw from the study at any time. What if you join the study and d ecide you want to stop later on? You can decide after signing this info rmed consent document that you no longer want to take part in this study. If you decide you want to stop taking part in the study, tell the study staff as soon as you can. You can get the answers to your questions. If you have questions about the study, please call Shalewa NoelThomas at (813) 230-0210. If you have questions about your ri ghts as a person who is taking part in a research study, you may contact the Division of Research Compliance at the University of South Florida at (813) 974-5638. Signatures for Consent for this Research Study It is up to you to decide whether you want to take part in this study. If you want to take part, please read the statements below a nd sign the form if the statements are true. I freely give my consent to take part in this study. I understand that by signing this form I am agreeing to take part in research. I have received a copy of this form to take with me. Signature of Person Taking Part in Study Date
284 Printed Name of Person Taking Part in Study Statement of Person Obtaining Informed Consent / Research Authorization I have carefully explained to the person taki ng part in the study what he or she can expect. I hereby certify that when this person signs this form, to the best of my knowledge, he or she understands: What the study is about. What procedures/interventions/i nvestigational drugs or devices will be used. What the potential benefits might be. What the known risks might be. I also certify that he or she does not have any problems that could make it hard to understand what it means to take part in this research. This person speaks the language that was used to explain this research. This person reads well enough to understand this form or, if not, this person is able to hear and understand when th e form is read to him or her. Signature of Person Obtaining Informed Consent Date Printed Name of Person Obtaining Informed Consent
285 Appendix H: Interview Guide Interview Guide Introduction: Hello. My name is Shalewa Noel-Thomas and I am a student at USF. How are you? [Icebreaker]. I am conduc ting this study to help understand the HIV knowledge, attitudes, beliefs and behaviors of black men and women in our community. I will be asking you a series of questions about your own attitudes, beliefs and behaviors about sexual health and HIV. I appreciate your time and respect your privacy; your answers are completely confidential. More importantly, your name w ill not be used when we use the data we collect. I do want to let you know that I am recording our conversation so that I dont miss any of your responses, is this okay with you? The first thing I would like to do is get your consent for participating in this study. I will read the consent form to you and then ask you to sign it. CONSENT SHOULD BE TAKEN HERE! ASSIGN ID #, ID should consist of the first 3 digits if their ZI P CODE and first 2 letters of their LAST NAME. Example: Tony Thompson at (33515): ID = 335TT. ID: ____________________________ Interviewer Name: Date: Location: Coder: Gender: M F Consent Signed Incentive Given ID: Haitian African American Age:
286 Appendix H (continued) Interview Guide Knowledge, Attitudes, Beliefs: 5. When you think about HIV & AIDS, what comes to your mind? 6. What can increase a persons risk of getting HIV/AIDS? 7. What can a person do to protect themselves from HIV? 8. Where do you believe HIV originated or how do you believe it first started? Probes: a. Do you think HIV is a real disease? b. Do you think HIV may have been invented or created by someone? [The next set of questions will ask about your sexual relationships. Please be assured that all your responses and any identifying information will be kept confidential. One of the aims of the survey is to use this information to develop better HIV prevention programs in the community] HIV Risk Behaviors: 1. Tell me about the nature of your sexual relationship/s with your partner/s. Probes: a. Have you been sexually active in the past 12 months? b. Do you have a steady/regular sexual part ner? If yes, describe your level of commitment to your steady sexual partner. c. Do you have sexual partners other y our steady/regular sexual partner? If yes, how many? If yes, tell me about your decision to have multiple sex partners. 2. Do you think [African American/Haitian] men you associate with tend to have one steady/regular sex partner or do yo u think they tend to have multiple partners at the same time? [Feel free to be honest and open you will not be judged because of your answer] Probe: a. [If the response is multiple partners ], Tell me why you think black men you associate with may have multiple sex partners? b. [If the response is one partner ], Tell me why you think black men you associate with may have one steady sex partner? Condom Use 1. Tell me what you think about male condoms and condom use during sexual intercourse? Probes: 1. Do you always use condoms during sexual intercourse? If no, why not? 2. Describe the reasons for using a condom during sex? 3. When you use condoms, what type do you use, latex or lambskin? 4. Do you think condoms are easy to use? 5. Do you feel comfortable going to the store to buy condoms? 6. Is it difficult to afford condoms? 2. Tell me about your condom use with your steady/regular sexual partner. Probes: a. In the past 12 months, have you always used condoms during vaginal sex
287 with your steady sex partner? If no, why not? b. In the past 12 months, have you always used condoms with your steady sex partner during anal sex? If no, why not? c. Describe a situation when you had sexual intercourse in the past 12 months and did not use a condom. d. Why did you decide not to use a condom? e. Describe a situation in the past 12 months in which you did use a condom. f. Why did you decide to use a condom? g. What factors do you think about when you are deciding whether or not to use a condom during sex? Cultural Norms: 1. How do your friends and family members influence your sexual relationships? Probes: a. What do your friends and family members say about condom use? b. What do your friends and family members say about HIV and AIDS? 2. How do you think the media/hip-hop culture affect sexual behavior among black men? 3. Tell me some other factors/things in black culture that influence sexual behavior (i.e. number of sex partne rs, condom use) in black men. 4. What does the term heterosexual mean to you? 5. What does to term bisexual mean to you? 6. What does homosexuality mean to you? 7. Do you know anyone who is homosexual? What do you think of when you think about this person? 8. What does the term down low mean to you? [Explain if the interviewee is not familiar] 9. Do you know of anyone who is on the down low? If so, what comes to mind of when you think about this person? 10. How do you feel about the whole down low behavior? 11. How do you think the down low affects HIV transmission in the black community? 12. Do you know anyone who has HIV or AIDS? If so, what comes to mind when you think about this person? 13. If you were going to educate black men about HIV prevention: what would you say to them? Where would be the best places to go to reach them? How would you get the word out to men (radio, TV, DVD. CD, iPod)? Gender Norms: 1. Tell me about decision-making between you and your sexual partner/s in your relationship/s. Probes: a. How does your female partner make decisions about condom use in your relationship? b. Is your female partner dependent on you financially? If so, how does that make you feel? 2. What role do you think women play in HIV transmission in the black community? [The next set of questions will ask ab out your use of alcohol and recreational drugs. Please be assured that all your resp onses and identifying information will be confidential. One of the aims of the survey is to use this information to develop better
288 HIV prevention programs in the community] Behavioral Health: a. Tell me whether or not alcohol or recreational drugs play a role in your sexual relationships. Probes : a. Do you or your sexual partners u se recreational drugs or alcohol? b. Have you ever felt high or drunk befo re or during sexual intercourse? Has your partner been high or drunk befo re or during sexual intercourse? c. If so, how do you think recreational drugs or alcohol affected your judgment prior to and during sex? d. Are you able to think about using a condom after using alcohol or recreational drugs? This is the end of the interview. Do you have any other thoughts/comments/questions? ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________ GIVE EACH PARTICIPANT HIV EDUCATIONAL/RESOURCE MATERIALS HERE!!! Thank you so very much for your time. Have a wonderful day!
289 Appendix I: Focus Group Guide Focus Group Guide Hello. I am Shalewa Noel-Thomas from USF and I would like to welcome you here this afternoon/morning. We appreciate you taking time out of your busy schedules to participate in this discussion. The information you offer about your thoughts will help to provide a better understanding of HIV health is sues in the black community. This is a USF research project. I want to assure you that nothing you say will be identified with you. The final report will say things like m ost people said or a few women said, but no names or identifying information will be given. We will take notes and if everyone is in agreement we will also audiotape this discussion and will not ask any of you for your names. It is important that we tape the discussion so that we are able to capture all the information you share to accurately analyze the data. We have a lot of ground to cover in a shor t period of time. Please turn off all cell phones, pagers, beepers etc. I want to be sure I honor the timeframe I promised for this focus group. For this reason I may cut you off if I need to move to the next question. However, I will remain after the session if there are any questions that we did not cover during the focus group. Does everyone know what a focus group is and how it works? For this particular group we want to know what you think about HIV in the black community. There are no wrong or right answers this is not a test We just want to know what you think. Are there any questions at this time? We want you to feel comfortable to say what you think without your real name attached to it. For this reason, we invite you to create a name tag w ith whatever name you wish to be called. You may use your real name if you want to but you dont have to. Please write down a name for us to refer to you for the purposes of the tape recording. Please remember that what is discussed in this room stays in this room. You are free to talk about your opinions and thoughts to anyone you choose, but please do not share what you have heard others say. Before we begin I want to mention a few house rules: 1) The session is being taped, please limit any extra noise such as tapping the table, pe n clicking, etc. 2) Please refrain from talking when someone else is talking or having side conversations, these make it difficult to get a good tape. You ma y hear me remind you only one person can talk at a time. 3) Please do not make nega tive comments about a nother persons opinion or feelings. We want to know what everyone thinks and your opini on or experience may be different than the next pe rson. 4) Please respect the opinio ns of everyone in the group, by allowing them to finish thei r thought and not interrupting. Ice-breaker What was the last mo vie you saw? Recommend it or not?
290 Now we are going to switch gears and I am going to ask you your beliefs and thoughts about sexual practices, condom use, and HIV/AIDS. OK, lets begin: 1. Sometimes we may hear that black men do not like to use condoms? Tell me your thoughts about this? Probes: a. We sometimes hear men say that using condoms removes the spontaneity from sex. Tell me what you think about this belief. b. Some men may say that their female partners do not want to use condoms. What do you think about this? 2. How would you say black men respond when they are asked to use a condom by their female partners? 3. Sometimes you may hear/read that black men tend to have multiple sex partners? What do you think about this? 4. What do you think happens when black men use drugs or alcohol before having sex? 5. We have talked about black mens beliefs and sexual behaviors such as condom use and sex partners. From your experience, how do you think black mens sexual behavior s affect your own health? 6. What can we do as a community to help men to protect themselves and their partners against HIV? 7. Tell me your thoughts about black men and the hip-hop culture. 8. Tell me what you think black men believe about HIV and gay men. 9. Some men may say they never discussed sex or condom use with a parent, guardian or family member while growing up. What do you think about this? 10. Is there anything else you would like to share? Thank you very much for your time a nd I appreciate you r participation. End of Focus Group Guide
291 Appendix J: Itemization of Coding by Independent Coders Secondary Coder: Male In terviews (U.S.-born) File Name AA336JA25 AA336DM19 AA336JJ26 Overall Themes Monogamy/Trust determines condom use Spiritual beliefs and homosexuality Spiritual beliefs and condom use Interpersonal communication and beliefs about condom use Familial communications about sexual behavior Conflicting media messages and the application of preventive behaviors Non-condom use and gender roles (mutual decision)/Condom use and decision making HIV/AIDS risk and decision making among women (victim blaming) Condom use is crucial but not a perpetual act Stigma and HIV/AIDS risks Promiscuity Knowledge, Attitudes, & Beliefs -Fear & worry Want to learn more, undetectable -Thought it was curable -Risky behaviors, promiscuity What increases risk? -Unprotected sex -Unprotected sex, needles, etc. Promiscuity How can you protect yourself? -Abstinence -Protective intercourse -Condoms -Universal precautions: condoms, having one mate, no drug usage Origination of disease -Experiment on Africans by Whites -Something from the White man -Originated from Africa; a disease to punish mankind for being promiscuous -Wasnt invented or created; its by chance HIV Risk Behaviors -One sex partner-have mutual understanding -Believe black men more likely to have multiple sex partners -Reasons: not satisfied trying something new -Multiple sex partners -Women dishonest about partners -Monogamous -Black men tend to hae multiple partners. -Reason: want to fit in or its just something to do Risk Behaviors -Condoms always necessary -Prevent disease and death, safety -Had engaged in unprotected sex -Reason: Partner was a virgin; trust and care for partner -Dont always use condoms -Didnt have one and it felt good without it -Acknowledges and states that he needs to use condoms -Reasons for needing to use them: dont -Its good to protect yourself -Reasons: to prevent unplanned pregnancies and STDs -Inconsistent condom use
292 want anything to fall off, AIDS, pregnancy, catching something, regrets -Reasons for not using them: spur of the moment, condom unavailable, does not perceive need to use condoms at moment of intercourse -Reason: trusts partner; heat of the moment Cultural Norms -Mother discussed safe sex Pushed having safe sex -Little dialogues with father stay out of trouble -Stigma associated with HIV/AIDS -Impacted his interaction with such individuals -Equated homosexuality to being fruity or a punk. -The media has a strong influence on black mens sexual behavior -what they converse about and believe, the type of women they express interest in or attract -Bisexual women more acceptable. -Spirituality introduced when speaking about homosexuality. -Down low men are freaks and basically gay. -Friends encourage condom use -Family encouragement to carry condoms -The media stimulates the excitement to have sex (i.e. women shaking their booties and pornography). -Doesnt want to be affiliated with a homosexual individual. -Down low was equated to going through a phase; unable to define the term. -Use scare tactics to educate black men about HIV; outcomes driven education -No condom usage in his family; parents taught him to have one partner and abstain until marriage. -Discussions about settling down and the risks associated with doing otherwise but no real discussions about sex; his parents are oldfashioned. -Believes the media has a severely negative impact on sexual behavior among black men. Scantily clad women Sex sells and always talked about -Bisexuality and homosexuality is more accepted in the black culture if its women. -Reasons: guys fantasy (i.e. threesome) -Doesnt condone homosexuality -Feels guys are confused when they are on the down low; they
293 go through spurt when they want women and men. -Feels the message about HIV/AIDS is out there but black men have heard it so much it doesnt affect them anymore. Gender Norms -Believe women play a role in unprotected sex; he made the decision to use a condom or no sex. -Equated women having unprotected sex to looking for someone to be withrelationship, a marriage. -Condom used if female requests -Women not financially dependent -Women dishonest about disease status -Both he and the female mutually decided not to use a condom. -Partner was somewhat dependent upon him financially. -Women need to initiate more precautions. Behavioral Health -Has been drunk during sex -Using recreational drugs will impair your judgment and you are more likely not to protect yourself. -Never used them during sex -Never used recreational drugs before or during sex. Additional Comments -Changing sexual behavior in black community can be impacted by rappers (positive messages), some women need to reconsider what they are attracting or are attracted to (i.e. thugs), & parents have to be mindful of their involvement. -Provide pamphlets with images and little paragraphs about the disease -Feels more visual aids should be used in terms of messages for prevention. -Ensure that HIV/AIDS medication developments are not desensitizing people are sending conflicting messages to teens and others.
294 Appendix J (continued) Primary Coder: Male In terviews (U.S.-born) File Name AA336JA25 AA336DM19 AA336JJ26 Overall Themes High knowledge levels Importance of condom use Conspiracy beliefs Inconsistent/non-condom use Trust in partner Sexual spontaneity Long term relationships Multiple sex partners Lack of family communications about sexual behavior Negative media influence Gender roles mutual decision-making about condom use Homophobia Alcohol use prior to sexual activity Knowledge, Attitudes, & Beliefs -Fear, worry HIV curable -White man has cure; conspiracy beliefs. -Risky behaviors, promiscuity. What increases risk? -Unprotected sex -High knowledge levels (Unprotected sex, needles). Promiscuity, multiple sex partners, IDU. How can you protect yourself? -Abstinence; protective measures -Condoms -Abstinence -Universal precautions: condoms, monogamy, no drug use. Origination of disease -Experimentation by white doctors; created to destroy blacks; conspiracy beliefs -Originated from the white man. -Originated from Africa; religiosity (HIV is punishment from God) Risk Behaviors -Inconsistent condom use -Determined by level of trust; length of time in relationship; virginity of partner; immediate availability of condoms; female partner not wanting to use condoms. -Inconsistent condom use -Better feeling; caught in the moment; immediate availability of condoms -Recognize need for condom use -Previous STI experience -Inconsistent condom use -Trusts partner, unplanned sexual encounters, long term relationship
295 Cultural Norms -Dialogue with mother about safe sex -Lack of safe sex dialogue with father -Lack of safe sex dialogue with peers -Strong media influence -Homosexuality viewed as lack of masculinity ( fruity) -Homophobia -Disapproval of down low sexual behavior. -Lack of family dialogue -Family encourages condom use since contraction of STI -Media stimulates sexual urges. -Homophobia. -Unfamiliarity with Down Low terminology. -Religiosity within family; family values centered on abstinence until marriage. -Little discussion about sexual health with peers. -Severe negative impact of hiphop on sexual behaviors. -Male bisexuality and homosexuality not accepted in black culture. -Men on the down low perceived to be confused. Gender Norms -Women play key role. -Women seek permanent relationships and do not insist on condom use. -Lack of genuine care for female partners. -Women dishonest about sexual history -Female partner financially independent. -Mutual decision with partner to stop condom use -Role of women: women to know their sex partners better Behavioral Health -Drug use; alcohol use; perception that alcohol is noninhibitive -No condom use if high or drunk prior to sexual activity. -Never used recreational drugs before or during sex. Additional Comments -No access to health care -Show the community the outcomes of HIV/AIDS -Utilize schools, churches for HIV education.
296 Appendix J (continued) Secondary Coder :Male Interviews (Haitian-born) File Name HA336KS20 AA336WN36 AA336BL50 Overall Themes Importance of protection Personal responsibility High knowledge of HIV risk factors Resentment of Haitian origin of AIDS argument Multiple partners Lack of family discussion about sexual activity Homosexuality unacceptable Negative effect of hip-hop and societal portrayal of sex Unequal gender roles pertaining to condom use decisions Knowledge, Attitudes, & Beliefs -Perceived seriousness -Abstinence -Importance of testing -Personal responsibility Protection important -Unclear about transmission -Personal responsibility -Not caused by God -Homosexual causality -Caused by promiscuity -AIDs selfinflicted What increases risk? -Needles -Oral sex with cuts -Blood transfusions -Accurate knowledge -Unprotected sex Homosexuality, promiscuity, anal sex How can you protect yourself? -Male condoms -Condoms -Monogamy, heterosexuality, condoms Origination of disease -Green monkey origin -Offended by accusation of Haitian origin of AIDS. -Did not originate in Haitian as often argued Risk Behaviors -Multiple sex partners -Misogyny; multiple chicks -Men vs. girl dynamic -Uses condoms consistently Prevent STDs and pregnancy -Weigh decision of risks vs. benefits -Multiple partners -Desire for monogamy -Inconsistent condom use -Condoms sometimes used for STD protection and unwanted pregnancy prevention. -Regret after noncondom use -Self responsibility -Monogamy -Long-term marriage
297 Cultural Norms -No open discussion with family and sexual behavior -Personally touched by HIV family member died of AIDS. -Sex education obtained in schools, friends -Heterosexuality is normative -Homosexuality acceptable in women but not in men. -Disagrees with homosexuality -Down low behavior perceived to be misleading. -Hip-Hop and media affects sexual behavior -Lack of parental discussion about sexual behavior -Tolerant of homosexuals -Unfamiliar with down low term. -HIV a sensitive issue -Embarrassed to discuss sex with children -Teen pregnancy an issue -Talk to friends about sex but not to children -Society gives too much sexual information encourages sexual behavior -Homosexuals mentally ill -Homosexuality is wrong religiosity -No fear of people with AIDS Gender Norms -Condom negotiation is male role -Women should use the female condom -Women should negotiate condom use -Women may not be heard -Gender roles not equal -More worried about daughters than sons -Young people lack knowledge of sex partners history -Discourages birth control -Male controls household and sexual decisions -Role of women: abstinence before marriage; use protection; get to know sex partners; HIV testing important; use protection even with negative status Behavioral Health -No drug or alcohol use -Frequent sex with alcohol use -Denial of impairment while tipsy or drunk -No drug or alcohol use Additional Comments -Need more HIV awareness -Utilize sports venues, message bulletins -Educate within social venues -Need for abstinence education -Teen pregnancy an issue in U.S.
298 -Less teen pregnancy among Haitians
299 Appendix J (continued) Primary Coder : Male Interviews (Haitian-born) File Name HA336KS20 AA336WN36 AA336BL50 Overall Themes Religiosity Personal responsibility Angered by accusation that AIDS originated among Haitians Multiple sex partners Inconsistent condom use Lack of family communication Negative effect of pop culture Male condom-use decision making Male dominance Knowledge, Attitudes, & Beliefs -High knowledge levels about HIV risk and protective behaviors Unsure about HIV transmission -Lack of education -Personal responsibility -Religiosity God protects married individuals What increases risk? -Needles -Blood transfusions -Accurate knowledge -Unprotected sex Multiple sex partners How can you protect yourself? -HIV Testing -Protection -Abstinence -Condoms use -Monogamy Origination of disease -Green monkey theory -Resents accusation of Haitians being carriers of HIV -United States -Homosexuals -Multiple partners Risk Behaviors -Multiple sex partners -STD and pregnancy prevention -Multiple partners -Inconsistent condom use prevention. -Regret unprotected sexual behaviors -Desire for spontaneity -Married longterm -Faithful -Non-condom use
300 Cultural Norms -Lack of family communication -Lack of HIV/AIDS discussion among peers -Hip-hop negatively affects others -Personal detachment from hip-hop effect -Haitian men promiscuous -Homophobia -Cultural violence towards homosexuals -Little family communication about sexual behavior. -Pop culture has tremendous effect on sexual behavior. -Aversion to those who choose to be homosexual. -No family dialogue about HIV/AIDS -Does not speak to children about sex -Embarrassment -Media overly informative about sex which causes pregnancy and AIDS -Homosexuality brings sickness and AIDS -Anal sex causes disease -No fear of people with AIDS Gender Norms -Male decides on condom use -Female condoms an option for women -Women to insist on condom use -Male makes condom use decisions -Womens voices not heard during sexual activity -Women should protect themselves -Women to more closely assess male partners -HIV testing important Behavioral Health -No drug or alcohol use -Commonly uses alcohol as sexual enhancement -Perceive alcohol does not affect judgment -No drug or alcohol use Additional Comments -Need more HIV awareness -Utilize sports venues, message bulletins -Other factors that influence HIV transmission: -income, education, welfare system, need for parental guidance.
301 Appendix J (continued) Focus Group Coding File Name: U.S.-born Women (18-30 years) Coder 1 Primary Coder Coder 2 Secondary Coder Themes Negative male attitudes to condom use Female aversion to condom use Low self-esteem Need to trap a partner Perceived trust Late realization of consequences among women Lack of parental dialogue about sexual behavior Fear of discussing sex with parents Male partners have multiple sex partners Better sex while intoxicated Alcohol impairs thinking Lack of condom use while under the influence of alcohol Little sexual dialogue with partner Negative hip-hop lyrics Lack of HIV testing in black community Non-confirmation of conspiracy beliefs Need for community education Women may not like to use condoms. Barriers among women: Depression Desire for pregnancy Strategies to keep male partner Lack sex education within the family unit Family emphasizes pregnancy prevention Perceptions of male infidelity Male machismo multiple partners proves manhood Intoxication inhibits clear thinking in men and women Some men intentionally transmit disease to women Women do not insist on condom use Lack of female empowerment to discuss sexual history with male partner HIV not perceived to be a problem in the black community Negative hip-hop role models Women also influenced by pop culture Blacks afraid to get tested for HIV
302 History of mistrust in the black community Fear of AIDS inhibits testing More education needed in black community
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Shalewa Noel-Thomas completed her Bach elors degree in Biology with a minor in Chemistry at Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University in 1999. She then received her Masters in Public Health from the University of South Florida in 2002. In 2003 she began her doctoral studies in Public He alth with a specialization in Behavioral Health. Ms. Noel-Thomas is currently the Program Manager for the Tampa Bay Community Cancer Network (TBCCN), an NCI-funded Community Network Program. She has over 7 years of experience in program management, implementation and evaluation in public health programs. She ha s worked with public health providers, physicians, and community partners to a ddress health disparities in cancer and HIV/AIDS. Her areas of expertise in clude program management, program implementation, community academic partnershi ps and health education. Her research interests include health disparities, HIV pr evention, womens healt h, behavioral health, and psychosocial and ecological determinants of health. Ms. Noel-Thomas has also served as the program coordinator for a perinatal HIV prevention program at the University of South Florida where she coordinated HIV educational programs for health care providers. Her ultimate goa l is to make an impact on health disparities and contribute to e fforts to decrease inequities in health.